English Reading Comprehension in Relation To Academic Performance of Grade 5 Pupils, Pilar Central Elementary School, Bohol
English Reading Comprehension in Relation To Academic Performance of Grade 5 Pupils, Pilar Central Elementary School, Bohol
RESEARCHERS:
Joevarie I. Junio
Darlyn V. Olmillo
Lorelyn G. Caluyo
Introduction
successful in all other areas of education. Children must attain this skill at an early age
because acquiring literacy becomes more difficult as they grow older. That is, if strong
foundation skills are not acquired early on, gaps in learning outcomes grow larger over
time (Gove, 2011). Studies suggest that without quality instruction, a child who reads
poorly in the early grades will continue to read poorly in the upper grades and will
require more and more instructional intervention in order to catch up (Juel, 1988).
nurture a culture of reading which considered a requisite skill in all content areas,
DepEd announced the “Hamon: Bawa’t Bata Bumasa” (3Bs) initiative. Education
Secretary Leonor Briones, in DepEd memorandum no. 173 s. of 2019, said that the 3Bs
initiative will help strengthen the Every Child a Reader Program (ECRAP) which
primarily aims to “equip learners with reading skills to make them proficient and
independent readers in their grade level and all offices at the Central, Regional and
Schools Division Offices as well as in school levels to respond to the 3Bs initiatives by
“intensifying their advocacy for reading” and by “pledging their commitment to make
every learner a reader at his or her grade level.” Moreover, also directed all DepEd
offices and school levels to “align their priorities towards the promotion of culture of
reading as a key step in closing achievement gaps.” on the recent results of national
assessments for student learning, learners were struggling to meet learning standards
in early language, literacy and numeracy, there are also “low achievement levels” in
English, Math and Science which “appear to be caused by gaps in learners reading
According to Jaum (2004), it has been reported by EDCOM in 1991 that the
typical elementary school graduate had a competency level equivalent only to what is
expected at the third grade level. This dismal situation long time ago is exactly the same
situation happened in Pilar Central Elementary School. Last March 2019 Oral Reading
Verification Test (ORVT) in English were conducted to all grades four to six pupils in the
school. Sixty percent of the grade five learners did not pass the test. When ORVT Oral
Reading Verification Test was conducted to this pupils, most of them are frustration
reader. And more disappointingly there exist a non-reader in that class. Even in the
previous school years there have been non-readers in grade five class. This perennial
problem in this institution could be possible hindered if strong foundational skills are
This yearly problem on pupils’ academic performance of the school made the
researcher decide to undertake this study and exerted an effort to gather data on
reading competencies in grade five through Oral Reading Verification Test. These Oral
Reading Assessment aim to identify the state of learning outcomes for this grade five
Thus, result of the study is our key purpose, for us to find out The English
achievement and to determine whether the modular teaching is more effective than
school year due to the Covid-19 pandemic which affects the education system. Schools
are adapting this new normal set-up for pupils to still get quality education. The system
of taking in modules has turned into a piece of all level of instructions in all subjects
managing one particular topic. It could be utilized within any setting which is helpful to
the learner and may be finished at the learner’s own particular pace. The gathered data
from these assessments will be used as ground for appropriate intervention for the
continuous improvement of both the teachers and learners, hoping that the perennial
dilemma in the higher grades will be prevented and remediated as early as possible.
THEORITICAL BACKGROUND
“Learn to read” before “read to learn”. This notion implies that basic literacy is the
English. Jaum (2004) expressed in her study that one of the most crucial skills that have
nature of present day life of a person can hardly exist without being able to read.
Belisario (1993) (as cited in Jaum, 2004) stated that reading is the magic key to the
world of enlightenment an enjoyment. It is the basic tool for learning in the other subject
areas.
Tovani, who also worked with Keene and Zimmermann, is a teacher and
literacy coach in Denver. In this book, she discusses why many children who have
learned how to recite the words on the page still struggle with comprehension. She
believes struggling readers need to see how good readers think as they read. To
promote thinking, Tovani asks children to write down what’s on their minds as they
read. Tovani says writing makes readers pay attention to their “thinking voice,” the
thoughts they have as they try to understand the text. By recording their thinking in the
attempts to understand the text. Readers can return to their thinking, revise their ideas
There are three types of theories of reading comprehension. They are mental
Education ISSN 2162-6952 2016, Vol. 6, No. 2 233 www.macrothink.org/jse 5.1 Mental
Representations Van Oostendorp and Goldman (1998) expressed that when a reader is
reading a text, he can create a mental representation of the text that explains how the
According to Kintsch (1998), when a reader is reading a text, three various levels
of mental representation are created. They are the surface component, the text-base,
and the situation model. Kintsch (1998) continued that when the words and phrases and
not the meaning of the words and phrases, are encoded in the mental representation,
indicates the meaning of the text and is composed of those parts and connections that
are arose from the text itself without increasing anything that is not clearly identified in
the text. A text-base can be made without any memory of the accurate words or
phrases from the text. In a pure text-base, the reader applies previous knowledge to
(1998), the situation model is a structure that combines the text-base and the related
knowledge is required but this knowledge is a more general one that is necessary for
decoding texts in general, while the previous knowledge in the formation of a situation
model is more specific regarding the content of the text. 5.2 Content Literacy Content
literacy is the ability to read, understand, and learn from texts from a particular matter.
There are three types of content literacy: general literacy abilities, content-specific
literacy abilities, and previous knowledge of content. The general and the content-
specific literacy abilities indicate some more general type of knowledge that does not
hinge on the detailed content of a particular text. This knowledge is applied to make a
knowledge of content is the knowledge that is related to the content of a particular text
and is applied to make a situation model in the mental representation. For example, it is
not obvious that mathematics makes a necessity for content-specific literacy abilities
and the reading comprehension in mathematics hinges on more general literacy abilities
and previous knowledge. It can be stated that the symbolic language in mathematics is
the main cause for the need of content-specific literacy skills (McKenna & Robinson,
1990). 5.3 Cognitive Processes The application of syntactic and semantic rules together
with the activation of more particular previous knowledge occurs automatically and
defined as the highly automatic and unconscious processes. For instance, when we see
a dog and directly know it as a dog; we are conscious of the outcome of the process but
there isn’t any active and conscious thought processes for this identification (Kintsch,
1992). Problem solving deals with active thinking when we want to remember the name
of a person we see and know. Accordingly, when we read a text without Journal of
Legal Basis
which ensures inclusive and equitable quality education and promote lifelong learning
opportunities for all. Targets would be, by 2030 eliminate gender disparities in education
and ensure equal access to all levels of education and vocational training for the
vulnerable situations. And by 2030, ensures that all youth and a substantial proportion
basic mathematics and literacy skills and some 750 million adults remain illiterate in
2016 half of the global illiterate population lives in South Asia and a quarter lives in sub-
Saharan Africa.
poverty. Over the past decade, major progress was made towards increasing access to
girls. Nevertheless, about 260 million children were still out of school in 2018 — nearly
one fifth of the global population in that age group. And more than half of all children
and mathematics.
countries announced the temporary closure of schools, impacting more than 91 per cent
jeopardize hard won gains made in improving global education. In an effort to foster
International Collaboration and ensure that education never stops UNESCO is mounting
a response with a set of initiatives that includes the global monitoring of national and
localized school closures. To protect the well-being of children and ensure they have
access to continued learning UNESCO in March 2020 launch the COVID-19 Global
Education Coalition, a multi sector partnership between the UN family, civil society
organizations, media and IT partners to design and deploy innovative solutions together
they help countries tackle content and connectivity gaps and facilitates inclusive
learning opportunities for children and youth during this period of sudden and
As stated in the Philippine Constitution Article XIV, Section 1; the state shall
protect and promote the right of citizens to quality education at all levels and shall take
appropriate steps to make such education accessible to all. In addition to this Republic
Act of the Philippines No. 7743 was enacted to promote the moral and intellectual well-
being of the Filipino by increasing the literacy rate and emphasizing the significant role
of education in nation building through the establishment of public libraries and reading
Republic Act No. 10556, an act declaring every 27 th day of November as “Araw
ng Pagbasa” a regular working holiday. This Republic act recognizes and supports
endeavors that promote reading and literacy, motivate awareness and uphold our
said that the 3Bs initiative will help strengthen the Every Child a Reader Program
(ECRAP) which primarily aims to “equip learners with reading skills to make them
proficient and independent readers in their grade level and all offices at the Central,
Regional and Schools Division Offices as well as in school levels to respond to the 3Bs
initiatives by “intensifying their advocacy for reading” and by “pledging their commitment
to make every learner a reader at his or her grade level.” Moreover, also directed all
DepEd offices and school levels to “align their priorities towards the promotion of culture
of reading as a key step in closing achievement gaps.” on the recent results of national
assessments for student learning, learners were struggling to meet learning standards
in early language, literacy and numeracy, there are also “low achievement levels” in
English, Math and Science which “appear to be caused by gaps in learners reading
DepEd Memo No. 362 s.2017 on Guidelines on the conduct of ORVT form Grades 1 to
As stated on the book published by Tovani, she believes that in order to build
comprehension the reader that has a difficulty reading needs to learn how good readers
think as they read and that readers be able to convey, revise their ideas and gather
information needed.
McNamara and Magliano (2009) emphasized that this approach is a task of both
reader and text factors that happen within a larger social context. Duke (2003) stated
text through metacognition, information in the text, and the views of readers related to
the text. Kintsch (1998) and van Dijk and Kintsch (1983) defined reading
comprehension as the process of producing meaning from the text in order to obtain
meaningful learning rather than to acquire meaning from individual words or sentences.
The results of reading comprehension is the cognitive representation of a text
meaning that is combined with the readers’ previous knowledge. This is called a mental
model (Johnson-Laird, 1983) or a situation model (Kintsch, 1998). This model defines
what has been learned (RAND Reading and Study Group, 2002). Keenan, Betjemann,
and Olson (2008) states that reading comprehension requires the attainable expansion
there are many sources for possible comprehension break and these sources are
According to Jaum (2004), it has been reported by EDCOM in 1991 that the
typical elementary school graduate had a proficiency level equivalent only to what a
(Juel, 1988). This Study suggest that without quality instruction, a learner who
reads poorly in the early grades will continue to read poorly in the next higher levels that
Refined reading comprehension skills are vital not only to academic and
the increasing demand for well- educated workers in today's information- and service-
related economies, it is reported that the proportion of American adults are classified as
“instructional readers’’ remained consistent between 1992 and 2003. This guide,
teachers and other educators can use to successfully teach reading comprehension to
young readers. The panel believes that students who read with wide range at an early
age gain approach to a broader range of texts, cognition, and educational chance
level and word-level, readers have to be able to study precisely and fluently.
textual content is all about, relates facts in the text to prior knowledge, asks
questions while reading the grasp of the text, and summarizes what is being
read.
read. A literature review from Laurice M. Joseph, the capacity to display one's own
comprehension is an integral skill for deriving which means from text. Self-questioning
at some point of studying is an approach that allows readers to screen their reading
comprehension and increases their potential to study independently. We assess the
conceptual and empirical literature on the relation between oral reading rate and
relation: (a) application of simple behavior analytic standards suggests that fluent
decoding need to produce better studying comprehension thru direct and oblique
relations, (b) behavior analytic grasp of the significance of the rate of conduct as
developed through Skinner, Lindsley and Haughton implies that greater reading chance
explicitly states that excessive rate analyzing sets the stage for high quality
Chawwang, (2008) investigated English analyzing issues amongst Thai EFL learners.
The learn about determined that most of the students face difficulties in analyzing
containing technical expressions (Carlisle, 2000; Qian, 2002). This is due to the fact
language enables them to have extra in-depth appreciation of text. Hence, oral capacity
is distinguished when it comes to apprehend how professional a reader can be for the
reason that readers gather new vocabulary through listening. Having adequate
In the past decade, there has been accelerated hobby in tutorial vocabulary and
and use of tutorial language to support analyzing comprehension (Nagy & Townsend,
2012). Specifically, data has shown that understanding of academic words predicts a
(Townsend et al., 2012). In one such study (Townsend et al., 2012), academic word
which, in refers to literacy, activating reading strategies (Braga & Busnardo, 2017). In
cognizance is additionally defined as the focus of individuals in the use of their cognitive
procedure which allows them to be more knowledgeable readers (Girli & Öztürk, 2017)
Aarnoutes & Van der Boss, 1998:65) state that ‘reading comprehension is a notably
Besides this, quite a number other cognitive and meta-cognitive tactics additionally play
a principal function in the studying comprehension system (Hugo, 1993; Swanson & De
La Paz, 1998; Chan, 1991; Cross & Paris, 1988; Bos & Vaughn, 1994; Mastropieri,
Scruggs, Bakken & Whedon, 1996). Which means that comprehension is a method
(Grade V)
Independent Reader
Instructional Reader
Frustration Reader
Non Reader
Continuous Improvement Plan
THE PROBLEM
1.1 age;
1.2 sex?
dimensions:
2.4 Non-Reader?
comprehension when categorized according to their gender and age from previous
school year to the recent school year utilizing modular distance learning.
The researcher believes that this study can greatly improve the educational
system in the country. This research will find out the effectiveness of modular approach
in teaching in order to assess the student learning, performance and achievement and
to determine whether the modular teaching is more effective than traditional methods.
This will inform the government and donors regarding system needs for improving
School Administrators. This study would made them aware of the pupil’s
reading status in Grade V. This would enlighten them on what proper solutions to be
Teachers. It provides them the basis on their choice of techniques and strategies
that are suitable to the different needs of the learners which are applicable in this new
Pupils. The results of this study help the pupils realize that they need to exert
more effort in improving their reading skills by studying harder to improve their
Parents. The findings on this study is a good feedback for them on their child’s
level of reading comprehension skills. Having been informed, they can make a thorough
follow-up on their child’s reading skills inorder to improve the academic performance on
Future Researchers. This study would serve as basis for future researchers to
conduct a similar study in other factors and other areas of concern related to learners’
Grade Five pupils enrolled during the school year 2020-2021 in Pilar Central
Elementary School. The result of this study is true only to the Grade Five pupils of the
said school.
The Oral Reading Verification Test (ORVT) are conducted consecutively for the
Grade Five pupils in their respective advisers. The results in ORVT are used to
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Research Design
This study focuses on the correlational analysis between pupil’s level of reading
The process involve in the study include the gathering of ORVT results from
respective advisers in Grade Five. Presentation, analysis and interpretation of the data
was made and finally, the coming up with the findings and conclusions.
Research Environment
Poblacion Pilar, Bohol along the town proper. It is a complete elementary having two
section per grade level. It has 22 classroom teachers and 1 principal. The school’s total
population at present 490 pupils. Every grade in this school has struggling readers who
Research Respondents
The subjects of the study are the 63 Grade Five pupils of the said school for the
school year 2020-2021. Grade five section 1, 31 pupils and Grade Five section 2, 32
Table 1 shows the specific breakdown of the number of respondents per section.
Table 1
Research Instrument
Oral Reading Verification Test (ORVT) tool was utilized to assess level of reading
comprehension in English of Grade Five pupils whether they are independent readers
non-reader.
Tool 1
Oral Reading Verification Test (ORV)
Grade V
No. of Words: 73
Questions:
1. What are included in the solar system in the story? Name at least two.
Answers: * the sun, the moon and all planets
(any of the three answers)
3. What is a chromosphere?
Answer: colored ring of the sun
4. Why do we need the sun?
Possible Answer:
* It keeps animals, plants and people warm
* It gives us light
* It helps plants grow
5. What would happen if the sun does not have gases?
Possible Answers:
* We will not have heat or light energy
* Earth will be cold
* We will die
6. What would be the effect of too much exposure to sunlight to one’s health?
Possible Answers:
* I might have skin cancer.
* If I look at it directly, it might blind me
* I will feel thirsty
* I will faint
* Sunburn
7. If you were a scientist, what possible inventions could you do that will use
the sun’s energy?
Possible Answers:
* Batteries that will absorb the sun’s energy
* Things that will move using heat and light energy.
* Solar lights
Tool 2
1. The ORV shall be administered every one week after the written
2. Examiners for a certain grade level are the teacher of the next grade
assigned writers which was validated during the division write shop and
5. The ORV test shall include three to five questions for Grade 1 & 2 , five
to seven questions for Grade 3-6 and 8-11 questions for Grade 7-10.
6. Questions from Grade 1-7 will be answered orally by the learners, while
choice answers.
their visit.
their visit.
11. The school principals are required to advice their teachers to create a
as he / she improves his reading level, and so on. This technique will
Tool 3
Tool 4
Tool 5
S
co
SAMPLE QUADRANT
re
5 4 3 s2 1 0
60
55 A B
50
45
No. of Words Read
40
35
30
25 C D
20
15
10
5
A – Reads fast and Comprehends well
B – Reads slow but Comprehends well
C – Reads fast but poor Comprehension
D – Reads slow and comprehends poorly
The researcher will use of the Oral reading Verification Test (ORVT) as tool and
conduct assessment to a grade five pupils as our respondents and we’re randomly
selected through a piece of paper place it in empty box and the leader will randomly
pick 13 ( 6 Males and 7 Females) respondents and the members will randomly pick 12
respondents ( 6 Males and 6 Females) with the permission of the school Principal and
Parents of Pilar Central Elementary School through signing the letter consent provided
by the researchers.
DEFINITION OF TERMS
Academic performance - is the knowledge and skills that students have mastered in a
subject or a course. It’s basically a measure of how well students have performed or
understand in the various assessment items such as essays, tests, reading, and examinations
Oral Reading Verification Test (ORVT)
Oral Reading test is individually administered oral test that will help determine a
Independent Reader
Can read independently with ease without the help and guidance of the teacher.
Instructional Reader
Frustration Reader
Non-reader
Cannot read. The pupils is unable to recognize and sound out letter connections