Chapter 1 3 Zonal Reading (1) Daan
Chapter 1 3 Zonal Reading (1) Daan
Chapter 1 3 Zonal Reading (1) Daan
THE PROBLEM
Introduction
The COVID-19 pandemic is the first and foremost a health crisis. Many countries
have decided to close schools, colleges, and universities. This problem clarifies the
issues policy makers are facing between closing schools which includes reducing
communication and keeping lives and allowing employees to work and maintain the
economy. Temporary severe disruption is felt in many families around the world: home
education is not only the most frightening thing in parent’s productivity, but also in
children's social and educational well-being. In addition, this rapid change in home
schooling during the epidemic has brought back attention to the importance of sharing
the responsibility for student’s learning. As more and more people become accustomed
to life in the world of long-distance learning, parents and teachers continue to improve
their home learning routines — especially for students who struggle with reading
deeper meaning. Therefore, in order to develop and strengthen the programs that
DEPED already has, it is also important to know good examples of how to strengthen
Accordingly, the nation was thrown into an uproar by the release of the 2018
Program for International Student Assessment (PISA) Report which stated that students
in the Philippines got lower scores in reading comprehension than most of those
surveyed in other nations. In fact, the country’s overall score in reading was a
measly 340 points. Based on the findings, over 80 percent of Filipino students around
the age of fifteen did not reach the minimum level of proficiency in reading. In addition,
the oral reading fluency for students in early grades is estimated to be about 30 percent
lower than in typical years, and students from lower achieving schools may be falling
even farther behind according to Newsroom press release in the year 2021.
The research brief urges policymakers and educators to pay close attention to
the impact of the pandemic on the student’s reading skills especially in reading
173 series of 2019, Hamon: Bawat Bata Bumabasa ( 3 B’s Initiative) intensifying the
advocacy for reading and by pledging commitment to make every learner a reader at
In the context, reading comprehension skills among junior high students have
implemented and some learners had difficulty comprehending through self-study. Based
on various related studies, reading comprehension is a critical learning skill for all
students (Clarke, Truelove, Hulme, & Snowling, 2013; Wong, 2011). Students need
expectations, which are required in the classroom settings. The importance of being
students move from one grade to another (Clarke, Truelove, Hulme, & Snowling, 2013;
Wong, 2011). In contrast, not being able to successfully comprehend can prevent
students from learning, retaining information that they read, and graduating from school,
which will negatively impact different aspects of their lives later on (Hoeh, 2015; Mason,
2004). Not only is reading comprehension a valuable skill for learning in school, but in
order to successfully interact in everyday life, individuals need reading skills in order to
be able to have and maintain a job and successfully engage in different daily activities
(Hoeh, 2015; Mahdavi, & Tensfeldt, 2013), and live independently (Hoeh, 2015). The
need for reading comprehension becomes very critical when thinking about the negative
consequences of not being able to read in critical situations. Thus, addressing the gap
encourage the researcher to develop one good example to strengthen the home- school
applied according to schedule and list of students. The level of comprehension per
students will be determined through the aide of Deped PHIL-IRI questionnaire based
from the Philippine Informal Reading Inventory Manual 2018. According to Philippine IRI
Manual 2018, the questionnaire can either be used for 1.) Student’s individual reading
level which determine student’s independent, instructional, and frustration levels for
three types of literacy tasks: oral reading, silent reading, and listening comprehension;
and can be used to, 2.) Monitor growth and response to intervention which is
determined by obtaining the comparison of the pre- test and post test results of Phil- IRI,
as well as determine the efficacy of program or reading interventions conducted by the
Theoretical Framework
context.
other words, the learning is contextualized to provide students with realistic roles that
problem solving in integrated learning contexts. Integrated learning contexts take on the
form of drawing realistic connections, making learning meaningful for students, and
activity supports learning opportunities that relate to and extend thinking to other
content areas. It involves the utilization of anchored material or media, the most
among students and a beginning point for further learning on a subject. When the
the teacher then builds upon it through additional lessons. During the discussions and
activities, the teacher and students can see the material or the intervention anchored to
add on the learning of the students for better and effective understanding, and any
questions that arise during the activity will be answered and understood more by the
students themselves.
Further, the anchor is the scenario or situation given to learners that sets the
stage or provides the context for use of learners’ knowledge or skills. The anchored
activity not only promotes connections between the content and real-life but also
between subject areas. Students can reflect on how other domains related to the
learning is meaningful.
Conceptual Framework
Below is the schematic diagram of the study which outlined the input, process,
as the participants of study are studied before and after the intervention.
questionnaires
during this time of
2. What is the
respondents’ level of Statistical blended learning.
comprehension in
terms of: Treatment
a. Literal
b. Inferential through pre-
c. Critical
test and post
test
3. Is there significant
difference between Interpretation
Aside from Covid 19 pandemic affects nearly 1.6 billion learners in more than
long-term planning have long been the collective problem of public schools in the
Philippines. According to the PISA report, expenditure per student in the country is 90
percent lower than the global average and the ability of each student to learn and
teaching materials and an environment that is not very conducive to classroom learning
due to Covid 19 cases. Hence, this study aims to determine the effectiveness of zonal
a. Age
b. Gender
a. Literal
b. Inferential
c. Critical
Statement of Hypothesis
comprehension among grade 9 students before and after the zonal reading
intervention.
comprehension among grade 9 students before and after the zonal reading
intervention.
profile.
Students. The result of this study would try to shed lights among students in
developing their knowledge, skills and experiences that they must have to be able to
understand both the main idea and the details of any given texts, and to be able to
English teachers. This study can give teachers the information on how effective
the zonal reading is for the students to develop their reading skills in terms of
improve student performance in English by the use zonal reading as an alternative way
trainings and programs for the development of students reading skills, and for the
teachers who function as the guide for student’s zonal learning. It will also be useful in
providing evidence- based feedback that that will enlighten the importance and
Future Researchers. This study can serve as a basis and benchmark for further
similar studies to be undertaken along in the line of zonal reading. Besides, b eing able
to encounter future complications in relation to the study, this study will provide
an alternative tool for students learning in terms of their reading skills despite the
presence of Covid- 19 pandemic. The participants of the study will be limited only to
secondary schools in the Division of El Salvador City. The conduct of the study will be
done through determining the reading comprehension score among grade 9 student’s
pre-test and post-test experiment. This indicates that students will take an assessment
The study will also cover in determining the relationship between student’s socio
Definition of Terms
To further understand the concept of the study, the following terms were defined
operationally.
Literal - questions in which the answers are explicitly stated in the text
Inferential - questions in which the answers are not explicitly stated in the text. These
questions require the reader to establish relationships between what he/she knows and
what is stated in the text. Questions regarding vocabulary words used in the text may
also be considered inferential when they require the reader to use context clues in order
CHAPTER 2
This section showcases the literature reviews dealing with the importance and
studies and some important ideas in relation to zonal reading will also be discussed.
Reading Comprehension
life. Reading keeps people informed, up-to-date, and thinking. It is both an acceptable
and effective process. It is a powerful process where the reader seeks to communicate
concept of understanding that can be most important. Self-study alone is not enough: in
addition, each person needs to be able to distort, analyze, and rearrange ideas and
information. One needs the ability to understand what the author is trying to say (Mckee,
2012).
Reading problems that adversely affect students' understanding may include one
or more of the following: improper use of prior knowledge, vocabulary, difficulty reading
fluently, limited knowledge of common text structures (Gersten, Fuchs, Williams, &
Baker, 2001; Graham & Bellert, 2005), difficulty of imaginative practice (Hall, Barnes,
appropriate strategy needed to find meaning in the text (Woolley, 2008). Having one or
more of these problems can prevent students with 3 learning disabilities from
understanding what they are learning and succeeding in school. It is very important to
help students with reading difficulties to overcome learning difficulties that can prevent
them from achieving literacy success before they reach higher grade. This is because,
in the lower grades, students are more focused on learning to read, while more than a
third grader is learning to read (Sloat, Beswick, & Williams, 2007; Clarke, Truelove,
Hulme, Snowling, 2013). Failure to solve learning difficulties during elementary school
greatly increases the likelihood that learning difficulties will follow in their later years
(Ford & Opitz, 2008; Samuelsson, Lundberg, & Herkner, 2004). Sloat, Beswick, and
Willms (2007) state that most students who do not know the basics of reading skills by
the end of the third grade will never learn to read well, have more difficulty with the
grade level curriculum, need more continued support, and do less than their classmates
in reading success. Therefore, the critical role played by students in tertiary education
emphasizes the importance of identifying struggling students in their first grades and
providing them with the most appropriate learning strategies (Antoniou & Souvignier,
reading difficulties and the urgent need to teach children to read during the first few
years of school so that they can" learn to read "in grades 3 and above" (Sloat, Beswick,
and Willms, 2007, p. 524). To avoid the long-term negative effects, teachers need to
apply and integrate reading comprehension strategies into their daily teaching practices
Taylor, Pearson, Clark, and Warpole (2000) have found that traditional classroom
teaching in reading generally does not include many commands or activities that are
reading comprehension can help teachers to develop new subjects that can be added to
teaching them how to communicate effectively with written texts, using interactive
techniques, allows them to easily remember what they are reading and to find meaning
in the passage (Ruiz, 2015). Improving all students' reading skills to reduce the learning
gap is one of the key objectives of the No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) and the Every
Student Succeed Act (ESSA). Closing the gap can be done by requiring and
how to use specific strategies to improve their reading comprehension skills (Stetter &
Hughes, 2010).
improve students' understanding of the written material. These strategies include, but
are not limited to, for image editors (DiCecco & Gleason, 2002), co-learning strategies
(Vaughn et al., 2011), peer support strategy (Rafdal et al., 2011), storytelling (Zahoor &
Janjua, 2013), and questioning (Rouse, Alber-Morgan, Cullen, & Sawyer, 2014). Also,
of a particular teaching method or teaching strategy. The data collected from the 5-
grade tests gives teachers the opportunity to (a) develop the most appropriate
instruction for students, (b) make a better decision on which subject will best teach, (c)
block what support should be used during their studies, and (d) and what challenges
students may face. Close Process (Ahangari, Ghorbani, and Hassanzadeh, 2015),
informal learning inventory (Burns and Roe, 2011), rewriting process (Hagtvet, 2003) ,
think aloud (Spinelli, 2012) are some examples of these classroom-based
comprehension tests.
Conversely, being able to successfully acquire reading ability in the early grades
can greatly enhance learners' achievement in their higher grades. Therefore, it is very
important to address problems in reading comprehension in early grades (Ford & Opitz,
2008; Swanson, 2000; Goo et al., 2013; Corcoran, 2005) through reading
comprehension skills in their early years (Spencer, Goldstein, Sherman, Noe, Tabbah,
Ziolkowski, & Schneider, 2012; Slavin, Lake, Chambers, Cheung, & Davis, 2009).
learning disabilities. Taylor, Alber, and Walker (2002) examined the effectiveness of
income students with learning disabilities. The research was conducted in a specialized
educational resources room. Findings showed that both self-questioning and news
understanding. Also, Stagliano and Boon (2009) examined the impact of using a media
descriptive text. The findings of this study revealed that storytelling is a practical
strategy that has helped to improve students' understanding of descriptive text. Other
noting that using technology improves students' reading comprehension (e.g., Lenhard,
Baier, Endlich, Schneider, and Hoffman, 2013; Delancruz, 2014). For example, Redcay
and Preston (2016) examined the impact of the use of iPad app-guided instructions on
teachers' fluency and comprehension skills for second graders. The results of that
quasiexperimental study showed that students who were taught using the teacher-
directed iPad app instructions showed higher scores on reading comprehension and
fluency compared to students who did not receive the teacher-directed iPad app. Some
studies focus on the relationship between students' attitudes towards learning and the
levels of application of the cognitive strategy (e.g., Sallabas, 2008; Kırmızı, 2011). The
results of these studies have shown that there is a positive relationship between
In other words, students with a good reading environment often use a reading
strategy as an aid to helping build a sense of the text. However, few studies have
disabilities in grades two and three (Gooden, 2012; Williams, 2005). Also, a small
Gersten et al., 2001; Reid & Lienemann, 2006; Swanson, 2000). While previous quality
research has explored reading comprehension strategies for special education teachers
using in inclusive environments and classrooms with second- and third-grade students
understanding their students with disabilities in the resource area. Therefore, the
shortcoming as observed in relation to this non-researched issue is that the topic has
comprehension strategies for third grade with learning disabilities in the class room
environment.
According to the World Literacy Foundation, the beginning of the year 2020 has
seen the lives of millions of people ruined by the outbreak of COVID-19. Educational
institutions in 192 countries have temporarily closed their doors, and the closure has
As more and more children are forced to stay home and not go to school, the risk
The brain is a muscle that needs to be strengthened to improve its growth. Learning is
an easy way to help keep students' minds refreshed and focused during the global
turmoil that has created many barriers to education. Not only does reading that instill in
students' understanding and curiosity, but it also helps in developing important skills
such as critical thinking, reasoning, and comprehension. These are important factors in
helping students stay in touch with their learning until formal education programs are
fully recovered. Reading promotes literacy, and reading and writing change lives.
minutes of study can help lower heart rate and blood pressure, as well as reduce
psychological stress.
(GSE) provides new evidence about the impact of epidemics on student learning in the
early grades, showing different changes in the development of basic reading skills at
different times over the past year. The results from the reading tests given to first to
fourth graders across the country show that the growth of learners' fluency in oral
reading - the ability to read aloud and audibly - was largely halted in the spring of 2020
following the sudden closure of the school by COVID-19. Gaining these skills was
strong in the fall of 2020, but it was not enough to recoup the losses students
Education plays a vital role in the financial and social development of any
critical to developing a solid foundation for the country's progress (Epstein, 2018).
Achieving lessons defines children's status in the classroom and gives young people
opportunities to develop their skills and improve their grades and prepare for future
The home is the student's main focus, and the home has a profound impact on
student achievement and is a major factor in a child's education (Marcon, 1999). The
way in which a student lives, his/her sustenance, and his/her way of life are affected by
the home (Trumbull, et al. 2017). The types of family structure contribute to a student's
achievement in school.
Applessed (2020), starting a home visit program and closing the home school gap takes
a lot of planning, training and support to make it work. Initially, teachers often expressed
concern about the safety of visiting homes they did not know, what to do during 30 to 90
minutes, and how to draw proper boundaries during visits. Many other teachers who
have never visited homes have had concerns about language barriers, parental
reactions to visits, and appropriate visits to their full schedules. However, after training
for the visits and participating in the home visit programs, the majority of teachers found
evidence that home visits can increase student performance, over-parental involvement,
reduce behavioral problems, and foster positive attitudes toward school. Properly done,
a home visit can provide teachers, parents and students with a better opportunity for
connection, communication and collaboration.
CHAPTER 3
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
respondents of the study, research instrument, validity and reliability of the research
instrument, data gathering procedure, scoring procedure, and statistical treatments that
Research Design
`This study will use quasi experimental research which aim to evaluate
interventions with the aide of pre-test and post-test design in which comprehension
score of the students will be compared to determine the effectiveness of such
intervention. In addition, this study will employ correlational research design which
investigates relationship between the socio demographic profile of the students and
Research Locale
The study will be conducted at El Salvador City, Misamis Oriental, in one of its
urban public secondary schools in the city at DepEd Division of El Salvador City during
individuals as catalysts of change that could contribute to the world. It was established
in 1980 with the joint efforts of the barangay official and local municipal officials in their
desire to cater graduates of elementary grades from hinterland nearby barangays and
of the place too. The first operation of the school started with four teachers (1 male and
3 females) who took charge of the 180 enrollees for first year and second year levels.
Third year and fourth year levels were offered the following year.
Figure 3.1. Locale of the Study
Sampling Design
data collection from population members who are conveniently available to participate in
which researcher relies on his or her own judgment when choosing members of
Barangay Cogon, El salvador. Each section contains 45 students. All of four sections
the intervention is applied, then followed by the post- test after the intervention is
applied to determine the effectiveness of the intervention which is the zonal reading.
Research Instrument
The researcher will be using a questionnaire based from the Philippine Informal
components for 20 items based the level of comprehension: literal, inferential, and
critical. Comprehension score will be measured and will be used to compare in pre-test
For the reliability test, a pilot test will be conducted considering at least 20
students to participate in the test. Reliability test will be measured by determining the
Cronbach alpha such that the value must not be less than 0.700.
study. On the first meeting (week 1) the respondents will be oriented regarding the
conduct of the research study, and the pretest will be administered. Then, the
cooperating teacher in both the control group and the experimental group will process
the class discussion on writing essays, and descriptive text. The teacher will be
supervised and monitored by the researcher. In the control group only pure lecture or
the traditional way of teaching shall be employed, while on the experimental group the
researcher will provide to the teacher the necessary procedure for the zonal reading.
Same process will be will conducted on the 2 nd week up to the last week of the month.
The conduct of the study is expected to finish within two months. The post-test will then
Scoring Procedure
Statistical treatment
Data collected from the questionnaire will be tallied, analyzed, interpreted and
the individual values. This was used to determine average mean score of students in
between two variables and is denoted by r .This was used to determine the relationship
the pretest and post test score of Grade 9 student before and after the zonal reading
intervention.