Chapter 3

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 81

Republic of the Philippines

Polytechnic University of the Philippines


COLLEGE OF ARCHITECTURE, DESIGN AND
THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT
Department of Architecture

ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER


Stimulating Mindanawons Cultural Diversity in the Capital Region
Through Phenomenological Architecture

CHAPTER 3

In Partial fulfilment of the course requirements in


Architectural Design 9

Bachelor of Science in Architecture

Submitted by:
Soriano, Emerson John M.
2016-00197-MN-0

Submitted to:
Arch. Melodia Sampan
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

CHAPTER 3

TERM OF REFERENCES

3.1 REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE

3.1.1 LITERATURE REVIEW 1

Purpose: The Literature review define the importance of the Cross-cultural

Communication to stimulate cultural diversity as one reason of the proposed

research project.

CROSS-CULTURAL COMMUNICATION IN CULTURAL DIVERSITY

As community builders, understanding culture is our business. No matter

where you live, you are working with and establishing relationship with people.

Culture refers to a group or community which shares common experiences that

shape the way its members understand the world. It includes groups that we are

born into, such as race, national origin, gender, class or religion. Culture is a strong

part of people’s lives. It influences their views, their values, their hopes, their

loyalties and their worries and fears.

Why is understanding culture important if we are community builders?

The world is becoming increasingly diverse and include peoples of many

religions, languages, economic groups and other cultural groups .It is becoming

clear that in order to build communities that are successful at improving conditions

and resolving problems, we need to understand and appreciate many cultures,

establish relationships with people from cultures other than our own, and building

a strong alliances with different cultural groups14.

▪ In order to build communities that are powerful enough to attain significant

change we need large numbers of people working together.

▪ Each cultural group has unique strengths and perspectives that the larger

community can benefit from.

▪ Understanding cultures will help us overcome and prevent racial and ethnic

divisions.

SORIANO, E.J.M 2
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

▪ An appreciation of cultural diversity goes hand in hand with a just and

equitable society.

▪ If we do not learn about the influences that cultural groups have had on our

mainstream history and culture, we are all missing out on a accurate view

of our society and our communities.

Establish relationships with other people culture through cross cultural

communication or exchange that can establish relationship with people as an act

against racism and other forms of discrimination, overcome internalized

oppression and building strong and diverse nation.15

Cross-Cultural strengthen Intercultural Communication

Equality, diversity and inclusion are everyone’s business. According to

Bloomfield and Wood (2011), interculturality cannot be expected to occur by

accident alone- there need to be tools, agents, spaces and places of

interculturality. They also defined intercultural centers as any spaces where there

is an underlying philosophy that cultural mixing is more desirable than separation.

Bloomfield and wood (2011) determine the elements or the shared principles from

different intercultural centers.

▪ Intergenerational nature of intercuturality - requiring focus with children in

and outside the school.

▪ Insistence on high quality and artistic excellence- bringing the best out of

people by transferring skills, and putting cultural and social differences to

work creatively to produce new outcomes.

▪ Creating a reflective/ spiritual space- which makes people feel safe and

allows them to shift to more open and tolerant positions at their own pace,

by getting to know and respect others.

Understanding Cross-cultural Communication and its connection with

interculturalism is a must in building a good relationship with others. Establishing

relationship with other people culture can make a difference and will able to unhype

the stereotyping in a certain culture. This will also bring the spirit of unity in diversity

in the community.
SORIANO, E.J.M 3
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

3.1.2 LITERATURE REVIEW 2

Purpose: The Literature Review provides the importance of design and weaving

traditions of Mindanawons and the symbolic patterns that will incorporate to its

building design.

WEAVING A STRONGER FABRIC OF MINDANAWONS IDENTITY THROUGH

TRADITIONAL TEXTILES

Philippines has a rich textile tradition with no less than 26 areas identified

as principal active- practitioners of the tradition. Each area corresponds to a

province with a community engaged in the production. It is entirely, the 26 textiles

areas are those of e 23 Ethno linguistics communities roughly representing ½ of

the major ethno-linguistic groups in the Philippines.12 out of 23 ethno linguistic

communities that practice textile weaving is came from Mindanao. South’s colorful

fabrics serve as an image of the different cultural groups thriving together in the

region—Muslims, Christians and Lumads.

Cultural Factors that Influence and Ornamentation of Textiles

According to Norma Absing Respicio on her book From the Journey of a

Thousand Shuttles: The Philippine Weave that the Philippine belief system is non-

Christian in terms of textile patterns. It is a world where mortals and spirits, nature

and ancestral, intermingle as dramatized in the rituals of appeasement and

propitiation, and in the belief of life after death.

The most significant factors in the manufacture of textile is the fact that they

play a dominant role in the religious life of Mindanawons. Textiles are rich with

religious connotations- from their manufacture to their use in rituals. The religious

character is implied in the sacred origin of the ikat

technique and in the motifs that adorns the traditional

and clothing forms.


Figure 6: Human Pattern
The weaving and ornamentation of textiles using
Source: Respicio,N.A

figures representing human, animals and plants have an aura of sanctity and often

involve a spiritual guardian. Beautifully adorned textiles are created for use in a

SORIANO, E.J.M 4
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

ritual that is meant to invoke deities for the assurance of well-being of the weaver

herself, the wearer and the entire community.

Buaya represents to scare the buso " buso

referred to all demons, spirits of diseases, evil

supernatural beings of whatever form.8


Figure 7: Crocodile Pattern
Source: Respicio,N.A

Overall the textiles of each region are resulting art forms that originate from

the minds and hands of native artists who live within a social group 9. The artists

expressions are often group expressions that point to the values and styles of the

cultures from which they came from. The personal, socio-political, and religious

aspirations of the community inspires the creation of finely woven and decorated

textiles and sustain the textile tradition10.

Clothing are considered communal properties and thus worn by several

individuals with varied measurements. (Reyes p.153) Hence, if each shirt, trousers

or skirt is tailored in the body of the wearer. The use and ownership of the piece is

limited to just one individual, thus discouraging social exchange which is essential

in unifying members of the community and their diverse culture.

Based on the research it can be concluded that the weaving textile has a

big factor in stimulating cultural diversity in Mindanao. The textiles designs

mentioned showcase symbolism which are conceptual and abstract. It exemplify

how to achieve a timeless status for trade and cultural center. The symbolism,

imagery and aesthetics of culture from textile design in architecture, can invite the

people not only to learn but also to think, speak, feel and behave new.

The literature reviewed identifies that through the appropriation of symbols,

meaning and intention, a wide array of knowledge of culture can be embedded

simultaneously within a trade and cultural center. It is important to the study

because it discussed the critical questions that concern the design of trade and

cultural center. Furthermore, having knowledge in rich history of the textile in

Mindanao can help the researcher in planning and designing the weaving and

design center as part of Mindanao Trade and Cultural Center

SORIANO, E.J.M 5
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

3.1.3 LITERATURE REVIEW 3

Purpose: The Literature Review provides the derivation of the design guidelines in

using the Phenomenological approach in Architecture.

PHENOMENOLOGICAL CONCEPT IN ARCHITECTURE

Designing an experience is a unique responsibility of an architect.

Phenomenology demonstrated in architecture is the manipulation of space,

material, and light and shadow to create a memorable encounter through an

impact on the human senses. This theory promotes the integration of sensory

perception as a function of a built form. This creates an experience that is beyond

tangible, but rather abstract, observed and perceived.

Architecture influences the community through incorporating human activity

with adapted site context, organized programmatic and interstitial space, and

exploration of material. Phenomenological concept strategies in architectural

design intend to develop a unique experience of the phenomena of space, light

and form. This theory contrasts rationalism by analysing quality based on its effect

on the sensitivity of human perception, rather than developing a mechanical sense

of reason and tectonics. As defined by theorist Vernon Bourke, rationalism is a

theory "in which the criterion of the truth is not sensory but intellectual and

deductive" (Bourke p.263). Rationalism produces a layered system of scientific

reduction, whereas phenomenology delivers layers of sensory details such as

emotion informed by design features of light and shadow, material and spatial

perception. A new interpretation of functionality within design exists in the

phenomenological construct.

The dynamics of human perception, of the individual and the community,

should influence design form and function, in terms of circulation and organization

of an elastic, sinuous program to produce sensory architecture. Architecture is

designed to serve the needs of human activity; therefore, creates a relationship

between human senses and the building to transform emotion and perception.

Throughout history admiration for the human body in architecture resonates,

specifically in its relationship to human perception. Christian Norberg- Schulz

SORIANO, E.J.M 6
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

stresses that “the environment influences human beings, and this implies that the

purpose of architecture transcends the definition given by early functionalism”

(Norberg-Schulz). Phenomenology is the function of quality. Design should

foremost consider sensory details when integrating a collaborative program.

Intimate memories of place are often derived from intricate forms of detail allowing

a bond, beyond physical use of a building, an experience, to become ingrained in

memory.

The Senses

The senses play a vital role in Phenomenology. The very subject of

phenomenology is everything that can apprehended through our senses and its

main axis is the belief that we should turn towards the experiences themselves, as

they enter our body and mind through the senses or are within us. Sokolowski’s

separation of sense in the classical distinction between the five ‘external’ sense

(vision, hearing, touch, taste and smell) and the four ‘internal’ ones (common

sense, memory, imagination and estimation, the sense for what is harmful or

helpful) can help us understand the different levels of experience 17. As he

suggests,” vision presents color, light and shadow; hearing presents sound and its

loudness and softness; touch presents surface and texture and so forth”.

When a stimulus goes through our sensory system in order to perceive it, it

has to relate to something. When it comes to simple stimuli that address the five

essential senses, things can be more straightforward. However, still the relation to

something that is already there is essential. We need our memory, our common

sense, our experiences, our subconscious mechanism and our momentary

dispositions.

The architect must act as a composer that orchestrates space into

synchronization for function and beauty through the senses – and how the human

body engages space is of prime importance. As the human body moves, sees,

smells, touches, hears and even tastes within a space – the architecture comes to

life. The rhythm of architecture can be felt by occupants as a result of the

architect’s composition – or arrangement of all the sensorial qualities of space. By

arranging spatial sensorial features, an architect can lead occupants through the

SORIANO, E.J.M 7
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

functional and aesthetic rhythms of a created place. Architectural building for all

the senses can serve to move occupants – elevating their experience.

Experiential Approach

There are three closely inter-rellated concepts namely experience,

interaction and engagement (Dalsgaard 2008). He cited Dewey in his clear

distinction between experience, which is the constant stream of experience of

being in the world, and an experience, a discrete event that stands out on the

background of the continuous experience. Interaction can be defined as a person

acting in a situation in order to effect certain changes while drawing upon personal

and external resources. Based in a Deweyan understanding of experience and

interaction in which the user enters into a reciprocal relationship which potentially

effects changes in both the user and the situation. Engagement relies on a certain

mode of experiencing the world, namely inquiry Inquiry is the controlled or directed

transformation of an indeterminate situation into one that in its constituents

distinctions and relations as to convert the elements of the original situation into a

unified whole (Dalsgaard 2008).

A key interaction concern when designing engaging interactive

environments is to simultaneously frame a situation that invites or provokes a user

to interact and to scaffold the interaction by offering access to certain resources.

(Dalsgaard,2008).

Figure 8: The Interactive Experience Model


Source:www.museumexperiencedesign.wordpress

SORIANO, E.J.M 8
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Architecture has the power to transform human behaviour and experience

(Ahlawat, 2015).Juhani Pallasma said in his book, “ The Geometry of Feeling” that

the style of modern architecture suggest that it is lacking in experiential and

sensorial aspects. Besides the functional and aesthetic demand the question for

the design should include how the people will feel inside the building and how are

they going to experience the space. Architectural Phenomenology can be used as

a tool for creating experience in space. The experience in architecture is the result

of individual perception and quality of spaces created by the architect. Experience

is created when the space is designed for creating a sense of place keeping in

mind the user requirements and how the user will perceive that space as depicted

in the figure. Human experience space in perspective not in plan and elevation so

the design should support the perspective need of human psychology

(Ahlawat,2015)

Emotion Based Approach

The process of how emotions are triggered is universal (Desmet 2002). A

basic model of emotions compromises of three underlying key variables; appraisal,

concerns and stimulus. Appraisal is the direct, immediate sense judgemental of

weal or woe and as being at the heart of every emotion. It is a non-intellectual,

automatic evaluation of the significance of a stimulus foer ones personal well-

being. Concern is always present in every emotion. An environment will only evoke

an emotion if it either matches or mismatches a concern. Stimulus can be some

event, someone saying something to us encountering something in a spce

(Desmet, 2002).

As architectural feature or built environment (stimulus) evokes an emotion

when it is appraised as either inspiring or indifferent to one’s concern. The basic

model of emotions applies to all human emotions. Thus emotions can only predict

or manipulate emotional impact of their designs when they are aware of the

concerns of those for whom they design (Fadzil 2015)

There are three environmental stimuli; the morphological factor, sensory

factor and perceptual factor (Cho & Kim, 2017). The morphological factors reflect

SORIANO, E.J.M 9
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

the idea of order and variables, such as volume façade, complexity, variety,

proportion, order and rhythm which fall under the visual composition of the

buildings. The consideration of the pleasurableness of the sensation received from

the buildings can be identified through the sensory factors which includes material,

color, texture, light and object. And the perceptual factors include context-

awareness, real-time feedback, social integration and immersive experience (Cho

& Kim 2017)

The study suggest that the sensory features are strong stimuli for users

emotions in spaces compared to the morphological features. The study also found

out that perceptual factors influence emotion more than the space evaluation

space which includes memory, attraction, pleasure, stimulation, contents and

satisfaction. Thus, designers need to design buildings in more diverse ways.

Emphasizing sensory factors and perceptual factors, not just focusing on

morphological factors for design.

3.1.4 LITERATURE REVIEW 4

Purpose: The Literature Review provides Steven Holl’s interpretation and

application of the manipulation of space and the human body as one of the pioneer

criteria in Phenomenological Architecture that will help in designing and planning

the research project.

BODY,MOVEMENT AND THE ARCHITECTURAL SPACE

Phenomenology of perception can be considered as bringing human

perception as the manifestation of consciousness in one‟s daily bodily engagement

with the world. In this connection, the world is not separable from our experience of

the world, it is our experienced world. ―We are caught up in the world and we do not

succeed in extricating ourselves from it in order to achieve consciousness of the world‖

(Merleau-Ponty, 1962, p.5). However, the experienced world is fundamentally related

to our body; the body as an incarnate „lived body‟, not as an object

Holl’s denoting of the three main principles as the relation of body to space, the

spatiality of perception and finally the notion of lived space, designates, indeed, his

emphasis on the phenomenology of space he puts emphasis in architecture. Through

his use of materials, color, light, and his focus on detail a phenomenological

SORIANO, E.J.M 10
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

understanding of architecture and an awareness of its experiential potential is made

manifest. He explains the importance of bodily presence that of experiences the

architectural work, by saying: “The body is the very essence of our being and our

spatial perceptions.”

Holl considers the body as an essential feature of the architect’s conception of

space. Approaching, to Merleau-Ponty’s phenomenological philosophy, for the

architect the body is not only the way we exist in the world, but also the subject of

architectural perception. The body experiences the space. It is through the body that

one is able to connect himself/herself to the space. As Holl mentions “…space is only

perceived when a subject describes it.”Presupposing the primacy of body in

architectural conception, perception is interpreted as the means by which the space

can be comprehended. As Holl mentions, “spatial definition is ordered by perception.”

Within this framework, it can be stated that he brings forth a body-dependent approach

to architectural space. Perception should not be disregarded in conceptualizing

architectural space.

Holl’s emphasis on body’s spatial experiences can be related to the primacy of

perception in providing the ground for body’s “being-in-the-world.” Perception enables

the body to acquire a lively communication with others, things and the entire world;

being experientially connected to space, the subject perceives architectural space.

3.1.5 LITERATURE REVIEW 5

Purpose: The Literature Review provides Steven Holl’s interpretation and

application of the manipulation of materials as one of the pioneer criteria in

Phenomenological Architecture and its effect to human senses that will help in

designing and planning the research project.

THE HAPTIC FIELD

Phenomenology emphasis on the making of architecture resides in ultimate

aim of connecting the intellect with senses, idea with phenomena and body with

environment. In order to do this, putting forward the haptic sensibility must practice

in architecture.

In view of his emphasis on the phenomenal experiences offered through

architecture, Holl mainly focuses on the feeling of material texture, the details, and

SORIANO, E.J.M 11
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

the spatial effects of light reflections, through which architecture’s phenomenal

potential is made manifest. What Holl calls the “haptic realm” is this multi-sensory

experiential phenomenon, through which architecture speaks without words. The

architect is concerned with the unpredictability of spatial and material experiences

of a building and its tectonic impression. Therefore, as he states, “the play of light

and shadow, the music echoes and textures and smells, the aura and presence of

real materials” become the means through which architectural meaning is

conveyed.

Accordingly, Holl focuses on the experiential and emotional attributes of

materiality and the spatial sense. How people receive the experiential depth of his

architecture is his main concern. For him, the spatial, material, and light

experiences of built form conduct the perceivers’ understanding of architecture

independently of architect’s implications. .

For the architect, a phenomenal field is presented through the physicality of

the built form. In this phenomenal field there exist visual, tactile, aural qualities,

even sense of odor. The use of material, the design of details, color, light and

shadow effects establish a phenomenal realm, which is distinctive to architecture.

Steven Holl uses the term “haptic realm,” which for him best manifests the multi-

sensory phenomenological qualities of architecture

3.1.6 LITERATURE REVIEW 6

Purpose: The Literature Review provides Steven Holl’s interpretation and

application of the Light and shadow as one of the pioneer criteria of

Phenomenological Architecture and its effect to human sense that will help in

designing and planning the research project.

LIGHT AS STRUCTURE MATERIAL

Steven Holl concentrates on light as an architectural element, or a

structuring material. He experiments with the ever-changing qualities of natural

light and their spatial effects. It can be stated that Holl uses light poetically. In his

buildings, natural light is transmitted into interior spaces, usually not directly, but

through uniquely designed architectural elements, in order to control and structure

SORIANO, E.J.M 12
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

light reflections. His use of light creates plastic and artistic effects where light

becomes a space-defining factor through which a sense of spatial depth is brought

into presence.

Another fundamental property of light can be mentioned as its potential to

conduct the way the texture of surface can be perceived. Depending on the way it

is used, light effects cause to strengthen or diminish material texture. The shadows

and shades create varying material and spatial senses in the perception of a

building. Thus, due to varying textural effects, the use of light becomes an act

intensifying the depth of architectural forms and spaces. Holl points out the

emotional and psychological dimensions in the experience of architecture. While

perceiving a building the body enters into an intimate experiential realm, which is

related to the psychological insights of the subject. Light has an influential role in

the perception of architecture. In his book Anchoring Holl states as follows:

“Space remains oblivion without light. Light’s shadow and shade, its

different sources, its opacity, transparency, translucency, and conditions of

reflection and refraction intertwine to define or redefine space. Light subjects space

to uncertainty, forming a kind of tentative bridge through fields of experience. What

a pool of yellow light does to a simple bare volume or what a paraboloid of shadow

does to a bone white wall presents us with a psychological and transcendent realm

of the phenomena of architecture.”

As he emphasizes above, Steven Holl’s focus on can be related with the

psychic implications of light in architecture. The perception of varying qualities of

light is influenced by the psychological and emotional states of the viewers.

Color, which Holl defines as “the absent referent to an experience,” is an

important quality in the phenomena of architecture.In his buildings, he works with

color reflections and projections, experimenting the spatial and surface effects of

color. Color indicates the supposed character of architectural space. It intensifies

the architectural expression. It is influential in the perception of surface and form.

SORIANO, E.J.M 13
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

3.1.7 LITERATURE REVIEW 7

Purpose: The Literature Review provides Steven Holl’s basic phenomenological

concerns and application that will help in designing and planning the research

project.

PHENOMENAL ZONES

In ‘Phenomenal Zones’ (1994), Steven Holl intends to describe basic

phenomenological concerns and the way he utilizes them in his projects and

designs. These themes play an important role during the first stages of drawing,

and mostly are the departure point in finding and developing a concept and idea.

Of color

Holl talks about the phenomenology of color which is rooted in the variety

of the reflections in various surfaces and materials. Moreover, the situation,

climate, and culture are very vital in the perception of color. Different people have

different feelings about the different conditions of light reflected in different climates

on different surfaces and textures.

Of light and shadow

“My favorite material is light. Without light, space remains in oblivion. Light‟s

myriad sources, its conditions of shadow and shade, and its opacity, transparency,

translucency, reflection, and refraction intertwine to define or redefine space. Light

makes space uncertain. What a pool of yellow light does to a simple volume, or

what a paraboloid of shadow does to a bone-white wall – these comprise the

transcendental realm of the phenomena of architecture” (Holl, 2003, p.27).

Holl takes a very delicate attitude towards the presence and absence of the

light in architectural space, and it plays a vital role in his architectural investigations

and studies, so that in different projects, light is the inspiration source. He intends

to catch the ‘thingness’ of the light, the essence of the light, as a very phenomenal

entity. “There is a „thingness‟ to light that one cannot form with one‟s hands. Light

is not verbal; we need images, we need spaces. A new field of vision is opening to

the pressure of light, the speed of shadow”

SORIANO, E.J.M 14
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

On the other hand, light is perceived in contrast to darkness, so that to

capture the light we need first understand the darkness. “With as much attention

to darkness and to the contrasting secrets of light and dark, we engage in a

metaphysics of light. Night‟s darkness evokes a connection to Dionysian

archetypes and mysteries, while the bright light of day is Apollonian, exuberant,

and unconcealed” (Holl, 1996, p.11).

Spatiality of night
Using a chemical term, Holl talks about the viscosity of the spaces. For

instance, the viscosity of night space has a density which is unique to every city.

Therefore, we can talk about the Tokyo night, Manhattan night and Amsterdam

night. The viscosity of spaces determines the fluidity of spaces and not only leads

to visual fluidity, but also has psychological implications. Thus, “Architecture can

define fluid movement by determining daytime and nighttime viscosities of light and

shadow”(Ibid., p.13). In this connection, Holl states that the sudden change of the

quantity of night light in the twentieth century altered our perception of the

cityscape deeply. For example, Holl argues that approaching the cities at night by

air provides a completely different and new sensation of the city space. “To shape

this light is to give new dimensions to the urban experience” (Holl, 1994b, p.69).

This fact is more important in the cities where the night time is longer than the day

time.

Water: a phenomenal lens


Holl considers water as a ‘phenomenal lens’ with the power of reflection,

spatial reversal, refraction, and the transformation of rays of light. The power of

water is mostly forgotten because of the current urban constructions which do not

allow us to be in touch with the natural phenomena. In ‘Fukuoka Housing’ by Holl

the ‘void space’ as the water garden is the scene of the presence of the dancing

liquid sunlight, by which the patterns of the moving water are projected on the

undersides of ceilings and soffits. Thus, the void spaces become a ‘phenomenal

lens’ in which “a fresh rain is immediately evident in ripples on the void space water

courts. The wind changes the pattern of the reflections depending on its intensity.

Clouds pass overhead and likewise pass through the mirror bottom voids”.

SORIANO, E.J.M 15
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Therefore, the water court brings the sky, the clouds, and the rain into the heart of

the building, and plays a ‘gathering’ role by which various surrounding phenomena

come together.

Of sound
Holl argues that in the perception of space we should not rely simply on the

visual, but shift our attention to how it is shaped by resonant sounds, vibrations of

materials, and texture. Every city, for instance, has it own ‘sound space’, derived

from its activities and spatial map of the city’s geometry.

Detail and touch


According to Holl, the haptic realm in architecture is related to the sense of

touch. This realm is closely linked to the details and materiality of the work: “When

the materiality of the details forming an architectural space become evident, the

haptic realm is opened up. Sensory experience is intensified; psychological

dimensions are engaged” (Ibid., p.91).

Lived time
Holl talks about the ‘lived time’ in contrast to the modern linear concept of

time which is the result of the temporal fragmentation of modern life. He refers to

the idea of ‘duration’ introduced by Henri Bergson as ‘multiplicity of secession,

fusion, and organization’ and asserts that “an architectural space forms the frame

of measure for „lived time‟” (Garofalo, 2003, p.74).

On the other hand, Holl argues that the current attitudes towards

conservation of the past through stimulating it are very superficial and avoids the

existential burden of time. He says that “We are not merely of our time, we are our

time” and states that architects should not ignore the implications of time which are

the result of new conditions and developments. However, there should be a

resistance against the current commercial attitudes in making a similar

monotonous world. Though a global movement tends to connect all the places and

cultures in a continuous time-place fusion, the opposite one focuses on the local

cultures and places. Thus, “a new architecture must be formed that is

simultaneously aligned with transcultural continuity and with a poetic expression

of individual situation and community”


SORIANO, E.J.M 16
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

3.1.8 LITERATURE REVIEW 8

Purpose: The Literature Review provides the concept, spatial programming,

design guidelines and standards that will help in designing and planning of

Museum, as one of the physical scope of the research project.

CONCEPT OF MUSEULOGY AND SPATIAL REQUIREMENTS

From the first established concept of museum as historical center, idea

changed in reason and work on as indicated by various societal setting. Afterward,

when International Council of Museum (ICOM) was set up in 1946, individuals who

were exhibition hall laborers at long last embraced the meaning of historical center

as non-benefit, perpetual foundation, in the administration of society and of its

improvement and open to the general population.

Museum architecture as defined as the art designing and installing or

building a space that will be used to house a specific museum functions, more

particularly the functions of exhibition and display, and remedial active

conservation, study, management and receiving visitors (Desvallees, 2010)

In the Philippines, museum design is guided by Guidelines for Museums by

Dr.Jesus T. Peralta for the National Commission for Culture and the Arts (NCCA).

Also there are international guidelines for museum design by the International

Commission of Museums. (ICOM).

Guidelines for Museum

Physical Facilities

The facilities a museum requires correspond basically to the various steps

in the processing of specimens or collection items. The ideal certainly is to have

adequate space in the museum premises to carry out all the functions. Where the

ideal does not exist, provisions should be made for vital functions to be carried out.

1. Fumigation/ Cleaning

A collection item that has just come in and is newly registered ordinarily

undergoes treatment. The final phase of treatment is cleaning of the item or object

SORIANO, E.J.M 17
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

just before it is placed with the rest of the collection. The reason is that it might be

infected with fungus, wood borers,etc., which may contaminate other items in the

collection. Fumigation is imperative. In the absence of fumigation chambers, other

means can be resorted to.

2. Storage

Most small museums do not have provisions for storage. Storage space is

imperative not only as the usual little closets and rooms reserved for office

equipage and facilities but also and more so for collection items. A museum

continually collects even though exhibition space is usually limited. Rotation of

exhibitions require space for keeping items not on display.

Storage System

Collection items should be classified while in storage. The items may be

grouped according to type of items. For conservation purposes, storing by material

is recommendable since it is easier to treat, for instance, textiles as a group instead

of individual pieces scattered all over the collection.

Exhibition

Curators should take a keen interest in visitor profiles in order to make the

museum effective in a community. The population of museum visitors shares

general characteristics. Among these are:


The art audience is from a narrow segment of the population, generally white collar
and well-educated.
The sexes are just about evenly represented.
Museum visitors at least have some college education.
People tend to go to museums with others.
Many are repeat visitors.
Museum attendance vary seasonally with the least during the summer months.
The museum visitor spends an average of five minutes in an exhibition, and less in an
art display.
The average visitor’s attention span is about thirty seconds per exhibit in a science
museum.
“The majority of the public appears to be gaining little or nothing other than trivial
impression of the exhibits”
(Zyskowksi, 1968).
Only a small percentage of visitors make use of printed guides.
Education and place of residence are important determinants of museum attendance.
Museums actualize the experiences of the visitors.
While adding to knowledge, museum exhibits tend to amplify feelings.
Some form of visitor participation is advantageous in maximizing the effects of
museum visit.
There are beliefs, however, that visitors expect to remain passive, preferring to be
left on their own.
SORIANO, E.J.M 18
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Education is the best predictor of museum attendance.


The museum visitor has a wide variety of interests and backgrounds.
The museum visitor has limited time.
The museum visitor is physically exhausted after a visit and often overwhelmed by too
much sensory inputs.
The average museum visitor is not anxious for more information or educational
materials on museum collections. Most people do not read display labels. Keep
children in mind with respect to labels.
In sum, museums provide different services for different people. Visitors

have different personal interests, thus a museum visit cannot be structured. A

museum should therefore aim to provide a wide range of opportunities for their

visitors to choose from, making the museum experience unique for each individual.

The primary concern of many museums is display of the collection items.

Limitations of space call for well-organized exhibits and periodic rotation. Most

museums tend to display everything at once.

The exhibition gallery should be:


Well-ventilated
Dust-free with some means to control light, temperature and humidity.
This would mean that the gallery be an enclosed hall with no windows through which
direct sunlight could enter. Windows, too, can get in the way of the placement of
exhibition facilities and visitors traffic flow.
No general lighting for the hall is needed but a large number of outlets should be well
and conveniently distributed throughout the room; on the base of the wall, the flooring,
or the ceiling, would be recommendable.

It is advisable for small museums to opt for display structures that are

generalized, that is, designed to accommodate different kinds of objects with

varying sizes. There are three types of display structural facilities needed:

Display facilities should be highly adaptive to various needs. In case of


shadow boxes, the glassed portion should be deep and high, which could
accommodate a number of related objects rather than just one. Some means of
providing adequate ventilation for the displayed object must be made, especially
if high-intensity lighting is to be used which will increase temperature inside the
showcase. Of course, especially valuable objects warrant a special case.
Where storage space is a problem, the bottom part of display cases can be
utilized for storage if constructed as such and provided with access.
Pedestals, to save on space, can be made into sizes that can nest inside
one another. There must be some means to lock the glass tops to the bases. It
is better to have a large pedestal holding a small object than vice versa, so large
sizes are better. Large ones also are more stable.

SORIANO, E.J.M 19
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Sufficient number of assorted sizes of small boxes to be used as individual


pedestals of smaller objects inside a display case should be available.
Display panels should be dismountable so that these can be stored in as
small a space as possible. To last longer, perforated panels are recommended
because things can be laid out on them without the continual use of nails. It is
preferable that the panels are double-faced.

Design Considerations in Museum

Conservation

All materials change through time. Conservation merely retards the rate of

changes to perpetuate the condition of an object. In general, rapid and frequent

changes in the physical environment of an object will lead to its earlier

deterioration. A relatively stable environment without the extremes is therefore

ideal for conservation of museum objects. The Philippines is fortunate in being in

the tropics where the fluctuation of climate is not to the extremes. The difference

in annual temperature is not that pronounced. In fact, the difference in temperature

between day and night is greater. The problem is more with respect humidity for

our environment has plenty of this. Countries in temperate regions have greater

museological problems due to the fluctuation of environmental conditions to the

extremes.To avoid the growth of fungi, extreme temperature changes and

dampness should be avoided. Thymol crystals can be used to inhibit the growth of

moulds. This must be used with care. It should not be used near oil paintings,

painted woodwork, etc. because it can soften many paints and lacquers.

Pollutants

Even clean air contributes to the decay of specimens due to its oxygen

content. Atmospheric pollution aggravates the situation for museums particularly

with respect to carbon monoxide, sulphur dioxide, hydrogen sulfide, and the soot

from insufficiently burned fuel from motor vehicles. Dust is dangerous for this

provides the nuclei for water condensation and the start of chemical and physical

reactions. Nearness to sea poses dangers of the corrosive effects of salt. The only

SORIANO, E.J.M 20
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

effective control of air pollution is air conditioning. Where this is not possible free

air ventilation with filtration may be used.

Temperature

If the temperature range can be managed then this should be kept within

the range of 20ºC ± 2ºC as most collection items will not deteriorate as quickly at

these temperatures. A simple room thermometer will do to measure the

temperature. In the absence of air conditioners, electric fans or other forms of

ventilation will suffice.

Humidity

A relative humidity of 50-55% is recommended. If the relative humidity

goes above 65% and the temperature is also high, moulds will develop and

destroy many objects such as textiles, pigments and paper. Hygrometers are

used to measure relative humidity. In the absence of these, one can more or less

feel increased humidity by a feeling of heat, oppressiveness and stickiness of the

skin.

Light

Light has a deleterious effect on certain materials like pigments, inks, dyes,

paper, textile and the like. It should therefore be controlled. Natural light has both

ultra-violet and infra-red rays. Ultra violet rays can cause chemical changes on

some objects while infra-red light or heat can effect physical changes.Ultra-violet

filtering plexiglass can be used in frames and cases instead of glass. Fluorescent

lights can also be covered by these filters. There are lighting facilities like Philips

TL-37 which have ultra-violet filtering components.

To control infra-red rays the amount of light falling upon an object should be

limited. Spotlights give off excessive heat. The amount of light that falls upon an

object should receive serious consideration.

SORIANO, E.J.M 21
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Defining Organization of Space in Museum

The functions inherent in a museum all revolve around the notion of

relationship. The relationship is between a cultural object and a person: on the one

hand, between the object and the curator, and on the other, between the object

and the public. These relationships determine the essential aim of the museum,

and hence the nature of the functions to be fulfilled if that aim is to be achieved.

The functions will be more or less numerous and complex according to the type,

kind and size of the museum. They may, however, be divided into four classes:

Basic activities

Composed of the functions relating to the permanent exhibition rooms, the

study rooms, the temporary exhibition rooms, and where applicable, the areas

used for Presentation or exhibitions.

Reception activities

They usually cover reception areas proper, together with information,

orientation, sales, cloakrooms and toilets, issuing of tickets, meeting points,

cafeteria and/or restaurant, reading-room, play room, rest-rooms, children's

workshops, etc.

Logistic activities

These are parallel reception activities, but are concerned with products and

exhibits. They include the safety and surveillance of both people and exhibits, the

transit and storage of consumer goods, the transit and storage of exhibits

(reserves), workshops in which presentations and displays are prepared,

workshops which make various articles needed for exhibitions, etc., laboratories

and so on.

Coordination activities

Coordination activities are the ‘intellectual’ support of the three preceding

forms of activity. They are concerned chiefly with office and study areas, such as

the director’s or curator’s office, offices of staff responsible for conservation,

administration and management, and study and assembly rooms.

SORIANO, E.J.M 22
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Organization of Space in Museum


LIBRARY

PUBLIC AREAS
DISPLAY RELATED
EVENTS

General reception
EXHIBITION LECTURE RM

Key Role:
RECEPTION
FOR CHILDREN RESTAURANT
o rest and relaxation
o smoking area
RECEPTION
o meeting point
Figure 9: Bubble Diagram
o assembly point Source: Programming for Museums
Planning and Designing Consideratons:
Other facilities located in The reception of the public should be at street level,
on the same level as access to gardens and car
General Reception parks he sexes are just about evenly represented.
Ideally, for reasons of security, the general reception
o information centre area should be the only one opening directly on the
outside.
o cloakrooms and toilets
The general reception area should be free of all
o telephones security checks, except in special circumstances.
o sale of products Entry should be free and unimpeded, and the general
appearance should be such as to attract people into
o sale of tickets, etc. the museum.

Reception of Staff and of visiting experts

Key Role:
o When the general reception is shut, the staff entrance is the only possible
mode of entry into the museum. It therefore has to be under strict and
permanent surveillance.
Location: Separated from the general reception area
Considerations: Strict and Permanent surveillance
Reception of Children

Key Role:
o Reception of children is an autonomous activity and should be adapted to
the problems of young visitors either alone or in groups.
Location: It is independent of the general reception area, but is directly connected
both with it.
Considerations: Strict and Permanent surveillance and free-expression workshops
provided especially for children.
Permanent and Temporary Exhibition.

Key Role:
o The function of presentation or exhibition covers all the activities facilitating
a direct relationship between object and public at the cultural, scientific,
recreational or aesthetic level. The areas in which this relationship occurs
form the most important nerve centre of the museum.

SORIANO, E.J.M 23
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Planning and Designing Consideratons:


Must be ready access to these areas from the general reception area (or their own
special reception area if they have one).
In close functional relationship with the reserve (storage) areas and museological
workshops, though they are strictly isolated from them.
Public means of access to the exhibition areas should be easily visible. Access may
be from the outside provided it is through an enclosed space (e.g. an inner courtyard)
within the general area of the museum.
Exhibition areas should in most cases have a supply of natural light sources that can
be controlled. Artificial light should never be such as to create problems. The best
natural lighting is often zenithal, though lateral lighting may be more suited to some
museums.
As they are meant to hold large numbers of the public strolling about freely, exhibition
areas need to be spacious and allow plenty of room to move around. The flow of
movement should be fluid and easy.
Strict surveillance from the point of view of security and fire and theft prevention, and
it must be possible to isolate them completely from the rest of the museum’s
activities.
Never open directly on to an outside area connected to the street. They should
include enclosed and isolated service areas where objects can be changed or
exhibitions prepared.

Reading and reference rooms

Reading and reference areas usually fall into two main parts: (a) reference

areas proper; and (b) storage areas containing reference documents. When there

is free access to open shelves, the two areas are usually partly or wholly combined.

Key Role:
o The function of reading and reference may concern public and staff alike,
and the areas involved may be shared or separate. The modes of
operation are the same whether it is the public or the staff that is
concerned.

Planning and Designing Consideratons:


These areas need to be specially placed, away from the main flows of movement
(risk of noises), and sound-proofed.
In the case of the staff, the areas should be in close functional relationship to the offices
of the conservation staff. In the case of the public, they should be close to the general
reception.
Provided the standard approximates to daylight, it is not usually essential to have
good natural lighting,except for consulting drawings, prints, photographs, etc., in
which case the same conditions should apply as for exhibition areas.
In either case, they should never open directly on to an outside area directly linked to
the street. Storage areas must be screened from daylight.

Other events related to exhibits.

Areas set aside for other events related to exhibits often need to be ‘open’

spaces, very flexible and without heavy equipment. Without aspiring to provide

stage facilities, they accommodate a variety of activities supplementary to those of

the exhibition proper, and therefore need to be able to cater for various practical

SORIANO, E.J.M 24
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

and technical requirements as regards acoustics, lighting, access, etc. They are

strictly isolated from other museum activities and may sometimes continue into the

open.

Projection and lecture rooms.


Planning and Designing Consideratons:
They should open directly on to the general reception area, their only connection with
the outside being via the prescribed safety exits.
They should have their own special security checks.
They should be completely sound-proofed, and situated preferably on ground level or
in the basement; contain a public auditorium, a projection-cum-control room, a
service area with office and ante-room, and toilets. It should be possible to use them
outside normal museum hours.

Rest and recreation areas.

Cover many kinds of activity and may include play, physical relaxation,

conversation, strolling about, and so on. Rest areas should be placed within areas

devoted to other activities, to which they should form the antithesis.The rest areas

will thus be isolated both visually and acoustically from the context of the activity

to which they belong. They may include service areas and such facilities as

telephones, water fountains, tea- and coffee-dispensers, etc.

Assembly and lecture rooms.

The areas concerned should open on to a reception area (general or

special); be isolated visually and acoustically, and relatively independent. They

may be grouped together or separate as appropriate, but are situated on a major

axis of movement through the museum, and may include service areas (anteroom,

offices, projection and simultaneous- interpretation rooms). They may be used by

either public or staff.

Cafeteria and/or restaurant.

This covers all catering, and the areas concerned are specialized

according to their particular function: bar/refreshment room, cafeteria, restaurant,

etc. They are usually completely isolated from the museum’s other activities, for

reasons both of comfort (smell, noise, etc.) and of security (long opening hours),

as well as for functional reasons.

SORIANO, E.J.M 25
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

They may open on to both the main reception area and the outside (street

and/or private space such as garden or terraces), and they can be divided into

three parts.

(a) Public refreshment area (cafeteria-restaurant);


(b) Preparation area (kitchen); and,
(c) Private service area (store-rooms).

These three types of area may open on to the outside so long as security

for the rest of the museum is properly safeguarded. The public cafeteria and/or

restaurant may sometimes be open to the museum staff.

OFFICE AREAS

Administration and management offices.

The director’s office or the curator’s office is therefore located in the middle

of the office areas, and, for convenience, close to the reception area for visiting

specialists.

Administration covers everything involved in administrative service, and is

chiefly made up of: personnel management, welfare services, budgetary

management, general services, etc. The areas used for this function may be of

three types: partitioned off (individual offices) semi-open plan, and open plan.

Management covers all the practical and technical tasks involves in the

proper functioning of the museum: i.e. archives, security, cleaning, telephones,

mail ser- vices, rest and relaxation, information and orientation, sales. The areas

concerned (apart from offices, which may be grouped together) are usually

scattered throughout the museum.

Archives.

The area set aside for archives may be outside the general office area, but

should preferably be in direct and easy relation to it.

It needs surveillance, and calls for installation of a special automatic fire

detection and sprinkler system.

SORIANO, E.J.M 26
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Security.

The central security office may include a centre for checking equipment

and premises for the security staff (these two areas being adjoining). It is set

apart from public areas and accesses to it call for strict surveillance. Its location

should take into account:

(a) the need for swift intervention on the part of staff (central position);

(b) the dangers of too easy public access; and

(c) the network of automatic control and surveillance systems.

These areas should provide reasonable comfort for the staff concerned,

but should not open on to the outside unless there is no possibility of unlawful

entry and/or obstruction. ,

Conservation and museology.

The function of conservation covers all the scientific and technical tasks

necessary for the proper functioning of the museum and the conservation and

study of its contents. It includes: conservation proper, documentation, teaching

and group work, drawing office, etc.


Planning and Designing Consideratons:
As regards conservation proper, the areas concerned should be linked to the exhibit
reserves, the exhibition rooms and the reference areas (library and docu- mentation).
A special strong-room should be provided for works in transit.
Spacious and quiet general work areas facilitate the preparation of exhibitions and
new displays.
Documentation requires large work areas and good sound-proofing.
The drawing office is comparable to the architectural office.
Daylight is indispensable for all areas devoted to conservation.

SERVICE AREAS

Technical and waste disposal installations.

These areas include all central plants of this kind, i.e. heating and cooling

plant, air-conditioning and heat conservation plant, electricity-supply plant and

security and emergency systems, centre for storing and distributing sprinkler

fluid, plant for collection and treatment of refuse, telephone systems, etc., and

plumbing.

SORIANO, E.J.M 27
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Planning and Designing Consideratons:


This heavy equipment can be a source of noise and vibration, so the technical
installations are isolated from the museum’s other activities. Floors, ceilings and walls
are treated accordingly (floating floors, double partitions, etc.).
For security reasons, access to the tehical installations is subject to strict supervision.
They should be rationally situated in relation to the power and water mains
They mostly contain heavy machines and equipment, often bulky, and there should
be easy and adequate access from outside for the purpose of repairs and alterations.

Staff premises.

Staff areas may include the following units: cloakrooms, toilets, showers,

rest-rooms and recreation rooms, staff rooms, infirmary, union premises, assembly

room. They may also include a cafeteria where the staff does not use the public

cafeteria/restaurant area.

The infirmary should be placed so that stretchers can easily be carried out

to an ambulance, and the possible presence of members of the public should be

taken into account (in the case of accidents or sudden illness).

Staff premises should have a high standard of comfort as regards both

installation and equipment (for example, daylight in staff room, rest-room and

recreation room).

Stores and reserves.

Although their function is the same, it is necessary to distinguish between

goods storage and art reserves. Stores serve for stocking ordinary consumer

goods necessary for the proper functioning of the museum, together with

equipment necessary for the maintenance of the building. The, reserves are

devoted chiefly to the storing of exhibits.

Both stores and reserves should be located between the areas of the

activities they serve and the delivery areas. They may be underground and require

no natural light. They should be completely isolated, have access that can be

strictly checked (one entrance, without direct connection with outside), and be

especially well protected against fire and theft. The reserves also have study areas

in which specialists may study individual objects. Storage and reserve areas may

be broken down functionally as follows: stores proper, transit, packing and

SORIANO, E.J.M 28
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

unpacking, and reception and distribution.Handling areas should be included

under this heading (storage of trolleys, etc.).

Work-shops.

This term covers all areas in which production functions are carried out, i.e.

building maintenance workshop, museology workshop, workshop for maintenance

and restoration of exhibits, photographic laboratories, photographic studio,

equipment simulation workshop, duplication and photocopying workshop, and

vehicle maintenance workshop.

These units as a whole may be grouped together or divided into two parts,

according to size : (a) Workshops relating to the exhibits (b) Workshops relating to

the building or administration.

Workshops may open directly on to the outside, but it is preferable to have

an intermediate buffer area which can be subject to supervision (usually loading

and unloading bays).

FINDING AND ANALYSIS

Theres a lot that needed to be considered when designing Museums. Although

Museums are being often being designed in an open-plan layout, the critical things

that needed to be address is the safety and conservation of the materials that were

being exhibited. The guidelines provide a comprehensive requirements and

guidelines in planning such development from the need space and facility up to the

favourable mechanical and electrical systems to be installed.

RELEVANCE TO THE STUDY

The guidelines will be beneficial to the users because it provided the space

requirements need in developing museums in the Philippines. It enlisted the

spaces defined each of them and suggested some alternatives if such space can

be provided. Also provide where would be the best location for a certain facilities

to be able to maximize its usefulness.It also formulated the required utilities that

would greatly affect the display in the Museum.

SORIANO, E.J.M 29
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

3.1.9 LITERATURE REVIEW 9

Purpose: The Literature Review provides the concept, spatial programming,

design guidelines and standards that will help in designing and planning of Library,

as one of the physical scope of the research project.

CONCEPT OF LIBRARY AND SPATIAL RQUIREMENTS

Library play an important role as a cultural center . In addition to providing

books,it can provide record and tape lending, music listening facilities, visual-aid

facilities, and lecture series as well as act as a general information center. With

such an expanded role, the library or cultural center will be an important element

in the neighborhood .

Regardless of the size of the community, its library should provide access

to enough books to cover the interests of the wholepopulation .

1. Libraries serving populations from 5,000 to 50,000 require a minimum of 2 books

per capita .

2. Communities up to 5,000 persons need access to a minimum of 10,000

volumes, or 3 books per capita, whichever is greater. The library building should

provide space for the full range of library services All libraries should have

designated areas for children's, young adult, and adult materials.

Multipurpose rooms should be provided for meeting, viewing, and listening

by cultural, educational, and civic groups unless such facilities are readily available

elsewhere in the community. They should be located for easy supervision so that

they may be used for quiet reading and study when not needed by groups . No

single type of building is satisfactory for all public libraries. Each building is likely

to be different, and its differences should be directly related to its service program.

Library Space requirements

Generally speaking, the total need may be divided into five categories:

space for (1)books, (2) readers, (3) staff, (4) group meetings, and (5) mechanical

operations and all other (stairways, elevators, toilets, etc .) .Actual space

SORIANO, E.J.M 30
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

allocations will tend to vary in accordance with the library service program in

relationship to community needs.

Space for Books

To a large extent the amount of book shelving required will depend on the

size of the library service area and whether the library is a member of a library

system . Most library planners, when estimating the size of the book collection,

apply a standard which ranges from three books per capita (smallest communities)

to one and one-half books per capita (largest cities).

Figure 10: Optimum Shelving Conditions for Adult


Source: Time Saver Standards for Building Type p.344

Figure 11: Optimum Shelving Conditions for Teen agers


Source: Time Saver Standards for Building Type p.344

Figure 12: Optimum Shelving Conditions for Children


Source: Time Saver Standards for Building Type p.344

SORIANO, E.J.M 31
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Space for Readers

Reader seating requirements should be determined for at least 20 years

ahead. Two principal sources of information which library building planners will

find equally useful, a careful analysis of purely local needs, and second, existing,

time- proven formulas applied as a basic guide.

Figure 13: Minimum clearance for people in Reading Room


Source: Time Saver Standards for Building Type p.348
Space for Staff

Staff space requirements should be calculated on the basis of 100 sq ft per

staff member. It is important that this standard be met for there is ample evidence

that space for staff has been outgrown more rapidly than any other type of space

in most library buildings .The unit of measurement of 100 sq ft per staff member

includes space for desk, chair, books, and equipment. A checklist of staff work

areas should include(1) administrative offices, (2) workrooms, and (3) staff lunch

and lounge rooms .

Administrative offices should include a combination librarian's office-trustee

room;spaces for the assistant librarian and a secretary-receptionist ; business

office ; and other related offices . Work room areas should be provided for technical

processing; reference, circulation, extension, and other departments subject

specialists ; and supply storage. Comfort facilities for the staff should include

cooking and lunchroom areas as well as appropriate locker, lounge, and toilet

facilities for both men and women. Comfortable working conditions contribute to

effective personnel administration as well as to efficient library service.

SORIANO, E.J.M 32
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Space for Mechanical Operations


Included within this category are halls, stairways, toilets, elevators and lifts,

air ducts, heating and air conditioning equipment, closets, and shops. Because it

is exceedingly easy to underestimate the amount of space required for mechanical

operations, it is recommended that the best available technical advice be secured

to assure inclusion of an accurate estimate within the program statement.

Fortunately, with the development of new construction materials and techniques

combined with new concepts in planning, much less space is needed for these

purposes than was formerly the case. It is suggested that an allowance of 20

percent be made for mechanical operations. In comparison, some planners

allowed twice as much space not too many years ago. It is of utmost importance

that this space requirement not be overlooked. After the amount of space needed

has been estimated, it should be added to the total required for the other activities

to be provided in the building.

FINDING AND ANALYSIS

There’s a lot that needed to be considered when designing Library.

Although Library has a minimum requirements since limited activities happened

there though the safety and conservation of the books must be addressed. The

guidelines provide a comprehensive requirements and guidelines in planning such

development from the need space and facility up to the Mechanical operations.

RELEVANCE TO THE STUDY

The guidelines will be beneficial to the readers and staff because it provided

the space requirements need in developing Library in the Philippines. It enlisted

the spaces defined each of them.Also provide anthropometrics and ergonomic that

focused on the circulation, flow and interconnection of the spaces to the users that

varies according to age e.g adult, teenager or children.

SORIANO, E.J.M 33
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

3.1.10 LITERATURE REVIEW 10

Purpose: The Literature Review provides the concept, spatial programming,

design guidelines and standards that will help in designing and planning of

Theater, as one of the physical scope of the research project.

CONCEPT OF THEATER AND ITS SPATIAL REQUIREMENTS

Theaters as a Building Type

The heterotopic quality is one of the ways in which theater buildings are a

distinct building type. In fact, theaters possess multiple characteristics that make

them an extraordinary building type. And these characteristics are additional

reasons for the fascination they hold for both architects and the public.

Theater buildings exist for the preparation and presentation of live

performing arts. A theater can also be used as a lecture hall, cinema, or meeting

place, but its range of uses is limited. This lack of versatility reinforces the

perception of the theater as a separate space with a quality of “otherness.”

Theaters Are Complicated Buildings

Theaters bring with them a complicated set of requirements, as or more

intricate than hospitals, although this is not widely recognized in the design and

construction professions. In fact, theater buildings are not well understood by the

architects and contractors who design and build them, and this only adds to the

complexity of creating them.

Design Consideration for Theaters

Population

Theaters house a large number of people (up to tens of thousands) in one

room. The need for the audience to see and hear the performance defines

particular three-dimensional room geometries.Protecting the life safety of large

numbers of patrons is a further complication.

Program

SORIANO, E.J.M 34
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Program here means the architectural program and includes all the

functions that must be accommodated within the building. The front face of the

building invites the public into exciting, elegant, or monumental front-of-house

spaces. Around the back of the building is a loading dock leading to utilitarian,

often factory-like back-of house spaces. In between are many individual rooms

with unique requirements. A classroom or office building may have many identical

rooms, but a theater does not. And each individual room in a theatre has critical

relationships to other unique rooms. Accommodating the optimal locations and

adjacencies of these rooms is a challenging task.

Structure

The auditorium requires long structural spans and often multiple

cantilevered balconies. In addition, the structural system of a theater must

accommodate rigging and other equipment loads. Unlike downward gravity loads,

rigging loads point in all directions, including up! The structural design may be

complicated by acoustic requirements for massive walls, ceilings, and roofs—for

sound reflection and/or noise isolation. Sometimes critical rooms have

independent and isolated structural systems (called box-in-box construction) to

prevent intrusion of exterior noise.

Services

The heating and cooling system must be quiet, so as not to disturb the

performance. Usually this means a high volume, low velocity system where a large

quantity of slow-moving air is delivered via huge ducts snaking through the

building. Similarly, thousands of electrical conduits for power, lighting, sound,

projection, and broadcast equipment must find their way from control and

equipment rooms to distribution points throughout the building.

Different types of theatre building

1. Opera house:

This belongs to the tradition of 18-19th century Italian opera buildings. It is

characterised by a clear spatial and architectural separation between auditorium

SORIANO, E.J.M 35
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

and stage, by high numbers of seats (1 000 to nearly 4000) and the corresponding

system of boxes or tiers, which is necessary for so many theatre goers.

2. Playhouse:

This is in the tradition of the German reform theatre of the 19th century. It is

characterised by the stalls layout (that is, the audience sit on a large, rising and

curved floor) and by a pronounced apron stage (area in front of the proscenium),

which can be used for the play as well. The playhouse also, however, follows the

tradition of the English theatre in the round. The open and variable layout became

more intensive with the spatial experimentation of theatres in the 1970s.

3. Multi-purpose theatre:

This mixed form of opera, theatre and ballet is a speciality in German-

speaking regions. The space is mostly characterised by the predominant influence

of the opera. The frequent changes of scenery are enabled by the appropriate

subsidiary rooms (store, scenery store, workshops).

4. Musical theatre:

Actually no separate type of building, but rather a theatre built, usually, for

a particular musical by an impresario. A specific challenge for the designer is the

adaptation of the building to the concept of the musical without neglecting the

needs of later uses for other productions.

Space Planning of Theaters

STAGE

Proscenium Stages

The defining features of a proscenium theater are the wall separating the

auditorium and stagehouse and the opening in this wall that gives the audience a

view into the stagehouse.

Types of Performance

SORIANO, E.J.M 36
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

The stage opening width is primarily determined by the types of

performances that will take place on the stage. Both repertoire and production

practices come into play.

Proscenium Opening

The proscenium opening is often made adjustable to better suit different types of

performances, or to allow more flexibility within a performance type. The adjustable

elements could also be architecturally finished panels that track in and out, or even

framed scenery or stage drapery that’s not part of the architecture at all. When a

proscenium opening is adjustable or has a decorative frame, a distinction is made

between the hard and soft openings.


The soft opening is the decorative or trimmed (adjustable) opening—the These
areas need to be specially placed, away from the main flows of movement (risk of
noises), and sound-proofed.
The hard opening matters for building code purposes. This is the opening
defined by fire-resistant construction and usually protected by a fire curtain.

Stage Footprint

We turn now to the dimensions of the stage behind the proscenium. Usable Area
Stage dimensions are given as the clear depth (D) and width (W), as these

dimensions define the usable floor area.

Figure 14: Stage Plan and Transverse Section


Source: Theater Planning p.154

Wings

The stage areas to each side of the proscenium opening are called wings, or off

right and off left. The wings need not be symmetrical.

SORIANO, E.J.M 37
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Plaster Line

The line on the stage side of the proscenium wall from which the clear depth

of the stage can be measured is called the plaster line. No fixed obstructions exist

between the plaster line and the rear wall of the stage, so it’s the theoretical line

on the stage floor from which the director and production designers are unfettered

by architecture. The plaster line is an important datum, and all dimensions on stage

are taken either from the stage centerline or “from plaster.”

Figure 15: Acting Area Figure 16: Scenery Area Figure 17: Circulation & Work Area
Source: Theater Planning p.155 Source: Theater Planning p.155 Source: Theater Planning p.155

Stage Height

The volume above the stage floor is called the fly loft, rigging loft, or the fly

or flies. The term stagehouse tends to encompass both the stage floor and fly

loft, while the terms fly tower and stage tower connote the appearance of the

stagehouse from the exterior.

A useful starting point for a full fly is to apply a longstanding rule of thumb:

the preferred grid height (G) is three times the proscenium height (h) and should

be no less than 2.5 times the proscenium height (h). That is,

Fly Loft

Extended over the entire stage footprint or just over the central portion,

leaving one or both wings at a lower height. Scenery, lighting, drapery, and other

production elements and equipment are suspended within the fly loft on rigging

and lowered (flown in) or raised (flown out) as needed. One or more galleries may

be provided at the side walls of the fly loft for operating and maintaining the rigging

SORIANO, E.J.M 38
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

and other stage equipment. Usually, a gridiron extends over the entire upper

portion of the fly loft.

Gridiron

Is a structural steel frame that supports the rigging equipment and provides

personnel access for operations and maintenance. The walking surface is bar

grating or toe-down channels spaced to provide open slots between channels.

Typically, seven feet of clear height is provided between the top of the grid

channels and the underside of the roof steel. While it is a walking surface, the

gridiron is not a floor for building code purposes.

Fire Safety Curtain

Automatically descends to close off the proscenium opening in the event of

a fire. The bottom of the curtain must be out of the audiences view when stored,

and when deployed the top of the curtain overlaps the top of the stage opening by

two feet. Add two feet for grid structure and sprinkler piping (as above) and two

feet for extra hardware at the top of the fire curtain. The minimum grid height to

accommodate a fire curtain is:

If the proscenium opening is 16 feet high (h = 16) then this formula results in the

same grid height as the minimum formula G = 2.5 × h.

50-Foot Dimension

Another benchmark for grid height is a maximum 50-foot dimension from

the stage floor to the ceiling or the underside of the roof deck overhead. The

International Building Code requires stages with heights greater than 50 feet to

have walls with a minimum 2-hour fire resistance rating and a fire safety curtain

protecting the proscenium opening. Stages that are 50 feet or lower in height must

have walls with a minimum 1-hour fire resistance rating, and no fire safety curtain

is required. Therefore, dropping the height of the stage tower for a small stage to

50 feet or lower can result in significantly lower construction costs.

SORIANO, E.J.M 39
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Stage Circulation

Entrances

Performers and technicians should be able to access the stage at each of the
four corners. If this is not possible, access to at least three corners is the
minimum requirement.
Each entrance should be as close to the actual corner as possible, and should
be provided with a vestibule (sound and light lock) to prevent the intrusion of
unwanted light and noise onto the stage.

Loading
A stage needs a loading door in addition to the above personnel doors
The preferred location is on the side wall opposite the rigging. If the door must
be on the rear wall, it should be as far offstage as possible, so that it’s not
blocked by a backdrop or other scenery.
A loading door may be provided with a sound and light lock, depending on the
uses of the adjoining spaces. As is obvious, the loading door must
accommodate the largest object the users might want to move onto the stage—
the trick is guessing the size of that object. If the theater is only for touring
shows, a door somewhat larger than the cross-section of a semitrailer will do.

Corridors
A corridor that wraps around the side and rear walls of the stage and connects
our four corner entrances is the ideal.
This corridor should be wide enough for easy movement of people, musical
instruments, costume racks, and road cases.
At minimum, a crossover corridor connecting the two rear stage entrances
should be provided, so that performers and others can quickly get from one wing
to the other outside of the audience’s view..
If no crossover corridor is provided, the rear of the stage must be dedicated to
this purpose, limiting the effective depth of the stage.

Vertical Circulation
Convenient vertical circulation is also needed. The preferred solution is a stair
at each side of the stage that provides ready access to the traproom below the
stage and to all raised galleries and the gridiron above the stage. These same
stairs should provide access to the technical levels above the auditorium. If
the grid is especially high, or the project especially well-funded, then an
elevator serving these levels should be provided.

Traprooms
A traproom is the area below the stage into which openings can be created

for staircases, trap doors, or other scenic effects. Both the opening in the stage

floor and the cover for that opening is called a trap. A traproom extends the vertical

dimensionality of the stage and provides greater artistic flexibility. Not all stages

require traprooms.

SORIANO, E.J.M 40
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Table 10: Stage Dimensions Ratio


Source:Theater Planning p.167
Forestage Zone

The forestage is the three-dimensional zone where a proscenium stage and

auditorium meet. The forestage geometry may be static or flexible, but it is always

a transition zone between performance space and audience space. Very often the

forestage has movable parts to create an extension of the stage apron, additional

audience seating, or orchestra pits of differing sizes. It may be heavily equipped

with rigging, lighting, and audio technology to allow the extension of the production

design into the auditorium.

Apron

The apron is the area

of the stage between the

house curtain and the stage

riser or orchestra pit. It should

be deep enough for the

performance of entractes—

short scenes performed in

front of the closed curtain—

but not deeper than


Figure 18: Forestage Zone
necessary. Our objective always is Source: Theater Planning p.173

to keep the first row as close as possible to the plaster or setting line, where the

full production capacity of the stagehouse is available.

SORIANO, E.J.M 41
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Orchestra Pit

Orchestra pits must be usable by musicians in wheelchairs. Some older

theaters have shallow pits accessed via steps from the auditorium, but it takes

great finesse to make this arrangement both attractive and code-compliant. The

preferred point of entry and exit is below the apron. Here, if a platform lift is needed,

it can be outside of the auditorium and stage. Pits with an occupancy of 50 or more

require two exits, and these are usually located at the two ends of the pit below the

apron. One of these doors might be double-leafed, to facilitate movement of large

instruments.

The pit should extend at least five feet upstage of the apron edge, to

accommodate the exit doors and provide maneuvering room for wheelchair users.

Figure 19: Orchestra Pit Geometry and Sightlines


Source: Theater Planning p.177

SORIANO, E.J.M 42
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Audience Seating

Most patrons in most auditoriums sit in chairs fastened to the building. A

few patrons will use wheelchairs or other mobility devices, and a few may sit in

loose armchairs in the boxes. In flexible or informal spaces, the audience may sit

on movable chairs that are ganged into rows. And there are many other seating

variations including benches, banquettes, sofas, and stools of varying heights.

We’ll look in detail at the two most common types of seating, fixed auditorium

chairs and wheelchair spaces.

Figure 20: Elevation of Seating (gradient)


Source: Neuferts-4th Edition p.212

Fixed Auditorium Chairs


Auditorium chairs are field assembled from component parts, usually standard

cataloged parts. Even with no customization, the available parts, colors, and

fabrics present a wide range of options.

Figure 21: Fixed Auditorium Chairs and Figure 22: Fixed Auditorium Chairs on
Wheelchairs Spaces (a) Steep Slope(b) Shallow Slope
Source: Theater Planning p.228 Source: Theater Planning p.230

SORIANO, E.J.M 43
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Chair Width

Chair backs and seats are manufactured in a range of widths used to create

horizontal stagger between successive chair rows. Width is measured as the

centerline-to centreline dimension between adjacent standards, so the actual width

of the back or seat part is a few inches less than the nominal width. If the row is

curved, the standards will be splayed, and chair width is measured along a

theoretical arc called the “chair size line” or “setting out line.”

Chair widths grew gradually through most of the twentieth century: the

current range is 20 to 24 inches.

Back Pitch

Back pitch is the angle of the chair back, which is set when the back is

fastened to the standards. Back pitch ranges from 12 degrees (which provides an

upright posture for balcony seating with downward viewing angles) to 22 degrees

(which provides a relaxed posture for orchestra seating where sightlines are closer

to horizontal). Theater chairs almost always promote a more upright posture and

have firmer padding than cinema chairs, which are heavily padded and sometimes

recline.

Chair Envelope

Chair envelope is simply the front-to-back dimension of the chair, measured

plumb line to plumb line. Chair envelope may be measured with the seat down or

with the seat up. If the seat is self-rising, the“seat up” dimension is used for code

calculations. This dimension, labeled b in Figure 22, is usually between 18 and 22

inches.

Back Overhang

The back overhang is the distance between the chair size line and a plumb

line at the rear of the chair back. This is dimension d in Figure 22. Again, this

dimension varies with back pitch—so its larger for chairs at the orchestra level and

smaller for balcony seating. Because the chair back overhangs the riser face, up

to 12 inches of extra depth must be allowed at the last row.

SORIANO, E.J.M 44
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Wheelchair Spaces

Number

The required number of wheelchair spaces varies, with proportionately

more spaces required in smaller auditoriums. Table 13.1 indicates the minimum

requirements according to the 2010 ADA Standards for Accessible Design.

Table 11: Required Number of Wheelchair Spaces


Source:Theater Planning p.231, 2010 ADA standards foe accessible

Means of Egress (MOE) Components

In technical terms, a means of egress is a continuous path of travel from

any point in a building to a public way. It consists of three parts—the exit access,

the exit, and the exit discharge. In code terms, an exit is just one part of a means

of egress system.

Exit Access
An exit access is a path from anywhere in a building that leads to an exit. In an
auditorium, its the travel route from each chair or wheelchair space to one or
more exits. It is a concept very relevant to the design of seating layouts, since
the spaces between the rows of chairs, the aisles, and most open floor areas
within the auditorium are all part of the exit access.
Exits
Conceptually, the simplest exit is a door that leads directly to the exterior.
Enclosed interior stairs, ramps, and corridors can also be exits, as can exterior
stairs and ramps. Perhaps the most arcane of exits is the horizontal exit. This is
a passage that brings you “horizontally” across a fire barrier into a “safe
area.Horizontally meaning without a significant change in level, and safe
meaning protected from fire and smoke spreading from the area .
Accessible Routes and Egress

Not all means of egress components are usable by persons with impaired
mobility. As defined by the ADA and the building code, the term “accessible
route” refers to a circulation path usable to persons with impaired mobility,
including persons in wheelchairs. The building code goes on to define
requirements for accessible means of egress.

SORIANO, E.J.M 45
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Catchment Areas
The required capacity of an aisle depends on the number of seats it
serves. To determine this, each level of the auditorium is divided into
catchment areas that assume proportionate use of the means of egress
capacity. Figure 13.3 shows a simple example—a single level auditorium with
500 seats is served by four doors of equal width. We assume one quarter of
the audience will exit through each of the four doors, so the portion of aisle
leading to each door must have a capacity of 125 people. If the aisles have a
slope greater than 1:12, the width required is 125 times 0.22 or 27.5 inches.

Figure 23: Catchment Area Example


Source: Theater Planning p.236
Minimum Width

The actual width of aisles is often determined not by the capacity

calculation, but by a separate code requirement for minimum width. Table 13.2

lists minimum aisle widths according to the 2015 edition of the IBC.

The aisles in our example from Figure 13.3 are sloped aisles with seats on

only one side, serving more than five rows. According to Table 13.2, their

minimum required width is 36 inches.

Table 12: Minimum Aisle Widths per 2015 IBC in inches


Source:Theater Planning p.237

SORIANO, E.J.M 46
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

WORKSHOPS AND STAFF ROOMS

Figure 24: Catchment Area Example


Source: Theater Planning p.236
Workshops for production of scenery

The area required for scenery workshops is 4-5 times the main stage area

for medium-sized theatres (theatres and multi-purpose theatres); in large opera

houses or double theatres (opera and theatre), 1 0 times. Workshops, in or outside

the building, should always be accommodated on one level. The Workplace

Regulations and their technical rules and the work protection and accident

prevention rules of insurers have to be taken into account in the design. In some

cases, the company and collective agreements with the employees can also have

an effect.

Scenery workshops are categorised as follows:

a) Painting room:

The floor area must be designed to accommodate two large backdrops or

'cycloramas' (Rundhorizonte - curved backdrops) rolled out on the floor for

painting. The average size of a cyclorama is 10 x36 m.lt must be possible to sub

divide the room with a thick curtain for spraying work. Also required are underfloor

heating to dry the painted backdrops; wooden floors for spreading out the

canvases; a gallery from which to check the work lying on the floor. The painting

SORIANO, E.J.M 47
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

room is located next to the sewing room (with a size about 14 of the painting room)

joining the pieces of material.

b) Carpenter's shop:Divided into bench and machine rooms, it has wooden floors

and an adjoining timber store for 3-10 productions.

c) Upholstery: approx. 1/10 area of painting room.

d) Metalwork: as carpenter's shop, screeded floor.

e) Sculpture workshop.

f) Workshops should be grouped round an assembly room, which serves to test-

assemble the scenery and has the same floor area as the stage. The height should

be proscenium plus 2 m, diameter 9-10m.

g) Changing, washing, and rest (canteen) rooms are to be provided for technical

staff, and offices for the technical management.

Further workshops for sound, lighting, props and costumes, size as required

(production intensity, personal equipment).

Personnel rooms

Artistic staff, stage manager, administration. Historically, personnel rooms

were situated on both sides of the stage: left, ladies, right, gentlemen, although

this was operationally impractical. Today, these rooms are located on one side,

opposite the technical side on several floors. This includes make-up, frequently

also the costume workshop, administration and stage manager.

REHEARSAL AND PUBLIC ROOMS

Rehearsal rooms

Every theatre needs at least one rehearsal stage to back up the main stage.

For example, a small theatre: the main stage has the scenery of the current play

and the rehearsals take place on the rehearsal stage. The dimensions should

correspond to the main stage. Typical floor plan of the rehearsal stage of a

SORIANO, E.J.M 48
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

traditional theatre. Multipurpose theatres and opera houses also require: orchestra

rehearsal room, chorus rehearsal room, soloist rehearsal room and ballet room.

Experimental theatres

These also require, in

reduced form, staff and rehearsal

rooms,workshops and stores, if in

continual operation.

Technical rooms

Rooms for transformer,

medium- and low-voltage

switchgear, emergency power


Figure 25: Large Rehearsal Room , Typical Plan
supply batteries, air conditioning
Source: Neuferts- 4th Edition p.217

and ventilation plant, water supply (rainwater system), according to local conditions

and specialist design work.

Lobby

The area in which the audience gathers and socializes before the

performance and during intermissions. It provides access to the auditorium and to

patron amenities. The lobby may provide queuing space at the ticket office

windows, coat check, and concessions. It’s often used for the sale of programs

and other show merchandise.

Ticket Office

. Ticket office designs range from the highly secure, with bulletproof sales

windows, to open counters similar to a hotel registration counter. The trend is

perhaps toward open counters, as the exchange of cash at ticket windows

declines and many arts organizations attempt to improve the experience of their

customers.The ticket office is usually located near the public entry to allow

convenient access for daytime visitors. The location must allow space for patrons

to queue at the sales stations without disrupting the flow of other patrons in and

out of the building.

SORIANO, E.J.M 49
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

FINDING AND ANALYSIS

Designing and Planning theatre required a lot of knowledge and

analyzation. There’s a lot that needed to be considered in planning the Theater.

From the stage, backdrop wall, curtain, audience seating and the egress. The

guidelines provide a comprehensive requirements and guidelines in planning such

development from the need space and facility up to the Structural and Mechanical

operations.

RELEVANCE TO THE STUDY

The task of theater design is first to determine the size and shape of the

audience chamber, and to develop seating layouts, access, circulation, and egress

to ensure the safety of the audience and the quality of their experience. It also

includes the layout of the stage or performance area, with circulation and technical

elements such as traps, grids, and galleries.

The guidelines will be beneficial to the performer, staff and audience

because it provided the space requirements need in developing Theater in the

Philippines. It enlisted the spaces defined each of them. Also provide

anthropometrics and ergonomic that focused on the circulation, flow and

interconnection of the spaces to the users.

3.1.11 LITERATURE REVIEW 11

Purpose: The Literature Review provides the spatial programming, design

guidelines and standards that will help in designing and planning Auditorium, as

one of the physical scope of the research project.

AUDITORIUM DESIGN

Auditorium and stage/acting area

Size of auditorium: the number of people in the audience gives the required

floor area. For seated spectators, assume >0.5 m2/spectator. This number results

from: seat width x row spacing

SORIANO, E.J.M 50
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Exits, escape routes 1.2 m wide per 200 people. 1% of the seats (at least two)

must be accessible for wheelchair users, if possible in connection with a seat for

an accompanying person.

Proportions of the auditorium

These are derived from the psychological awareness and angle of view of

the spectator, or the requirement for a good view from all seats. Options are:

1. Good view, without moving head, but light eye movements of approx. 30°.

2. Good view with slight head movements and light eye movements of approx. 60°.

3. Max. awareness angle without head movement approx. 110°, i.e. all actions in
the field are 'in view'. Outside this field, there is uncertainty, because 'something'
is out of view.

4. Full head and shoulder movement allows an angle of view of360°.

Four Qualities in designing Auditorium

Proximity
The first quality is proximity. The design of the auditorium must place the

members of the audience in close proximity to the performance and to each other.

According to tht Nineteenth century European theater architects Fellner and

Helmer described this quality succinctly and somewhat humorously in their “rules”

for theater design:

1. The aim is to get the audience as close as possible to the stage.

2. It is important for the art of theatre to see the actor’s eyes and mouth.

3. Create an auditorium as small as possible, leave out any unnecessary spaces.


The audience is happiest in an intimate space, even at the cost of the architect’s
feelings.

Cluster

The quality of cluster is harder to measure, but it has observable features.

One is encirclement, or the enveloping of the performance area by the audience

seating. Cluster is also developed by placing spectators where they have a close

connection to the performance, and placing spectators where other audience

members can see them. These design features enhance the intangible

SORIANO, E.J.M 51
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

phenomenon often described as the “exchange of energy” between the performers

and audience.

Scale

Scale is a quality of all architecture. In its simplest form, scale simply means

size, but scale is also developed through the use of proportion, repetition, order,

light, and shadow. Scale can be used to minimize the stature of the individual.

Medieval cathedrals (which exalt God over humanity) and communist party plenary

auditoriums (which exalt the party over the individual) are clear examples of this

use of scale. Theater designers work in the opposite direction, using scale to

support the performer and enhance the performance. On a movie screen the

performers’ bodies can be magnified many times. In real life and in live

performance, the performers’ bodies are only so big. Therefore, the theater

architecture must assumea human scale.

Place

The quality of “place” describes architecture that is stimulating, pleasant, and

meaningful to its inhabitants. In Towards a New Architecture, Le Corbusier put it

this way—“You employ stone, wood, and concrete, and with these materials you

build houses and palaces. That is construction. Ingenuity is at work

o Vivid and varied colors


o Articulated side walls and finished ceiling
o Multiple and distinct seating areas and levels
o Seating served by aisles and crossaisles to provide some measure of
mobility
o Lighting on the room surfaces and faces of spectators
o Multiple, close focal points and sources of sound

RELEVANCE TO STUDY

Designing and Planning Auditorium required a lot of knowledge and

analyzation. Applying the four qualities in designing Auditorium will provide

comfortability, interconnection of the spaces and innovate the theatre design to the

users.

SORIANO, E.J.M 52
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

3.1.12 LITERATURE REVIEW 12

Purpose: The Literature Review provides the concept, spatial programming,

design guidelines and standards that will help in designing and planning of Trade

Hals, as one of the physical scope of the research project.

PLANNING AND DESIGNING SOCIAL SPACES WITHIN TRADE HALLS

Commercial exhibitions and trade shows are one of the significant powerful

tools for community to introduce and sell their own products and services. The

trade halls purpose is to attract, hold, persuade and inform visitors. In trade shows,

a well organized and designed social space can allow exhibitors and visitors to

communicate and interact each other in effective way.

Design Strategies

Distance Control

In terms of human senses and communication, the study of social

dimensions is related to the the most comprehensive social activities, such as

walking, resting, seeing and hearing in both public and private spaces. To

familiarize and control those dimensions in trade show planning is a necessary

prerequisite leading to the success of exhibition layout.

Interior Streetscape

When the massive exhibition venue is treated in a context of urban space,

interior streetscape is a useful tactic to form a powerfully structured, vividly

identified and highly imageable environment within trade shows.

Figure Ground
The contrast of an object to the ground. The suspending banner,standing
banner, standing signage or other vertical elements can stand out as figures in
contrast to exhibiting booths and build mental identity.
Continuity.
Series of coherent parts related by keeping a common scale, form, texture, or
color for a space or area (Ibid).Using the same material on booth board of a

SORIANO, E.J.M 53
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

particular color along the pathway will give continuity and orientate visitors to
the destination.
In streetscape design, Rubestein (1992) gives the following characteristics

that should be considered in design or aesthetic quality associated with trade show

design and considered to be applied to social space design

particular color along the pathway will give continuity and orientate visitors to
the destination.
Sequence
Continuity in the perception of space that may create motion or mood, or give
direction (Ibid). Any repetition and similarity of shape,color or texture can
contribute to this characteristic.
Rhythm
Is a break interrupting the sequence of repetitive elements at specific intervals
(Ibid). It can be incorporate into a flooring pattern by creating a design.
Sensory Quality
Sensory qualities is a further dimension to the sense of a place, the visual
impression and appeal to senses of hearing , smell and touch (Ibid). Features
that cn please human senses can give the social space an atmosphere that
attracts people like well-designed banners, soft illumination, comfortable sitting
area and appealing activities.
Motion
A process of temporal alternation or geographical position changing.It reinforces
direction or distance and gives a sense of form in motion (Ibid).

Figure 26: Trade Halls Bubble Diagram


Source: www.google.com

Spatial Requirements
Information hub
▪ Information display
▪ Self service catering for café, drinks or snacks
▪ Desk for customer service or administration staff
▪ Sitting area for relaxing
Exhibition Booths

SORIANO, E.J.M 54
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Forum Stage
▪ Sitting Area for audience
▪ Stage for presenting a speech
Lounge
▪ Intimate seating for relaxing
▪ Open seating for conversations
▪ Self service catering for café, drinks or snacks

Figure 27: Minimum Width of a Shop


Source: Neufert-4th Edition p.270
Circulation

Circulation is devoted to the movement of the trade halls attendees. In the

same way as exhibition booths, the social space must also be easily accessible

and the circulation adequate for the activities. The pathway or aisle should be wide

enough for people to pass through, stand, look or bend to look. There is also room

for people to stop to talk or to exchange information without disturbing the solidarity

viewer (Velarde,2001)

FINDING AND ANALYSIS

Trade shows is a powerful tool to introduce and sell products and services

need to attract, hold, persuade and inform visitors. In trade shows, well-designed

social spaces cn facilitate active communications and interactions between

exhibitors and visitors.

RELEVANCE TO THE STUDY

Besides introducing amenities to and design strategies to retain visitors,

social spaces can balance or re-stimulate visitors emotions. Based on

SORIANO, E.J.M 55
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

environmental psychlogy and exhibition design, it provides a new strategy of

organization for exhibition layout, structured by social spaces and various scale

and levels. The understanding of human behaviour and activities determines an

appropriate configuration of social spaces,

3.2 CASE STUDY

LOCAL CASE STUDY

3.2.1 LOCAL CASE STUDY 1

Purpose: The case study is focused in designing the first ever experiential museum

in the Philippines on how they exhibit the material heritage and showcase it

wherein the visitors engage in more interactive ways.

QUEZON CITY
EXPERIENCE
(QCX MUSEUM)

Quezon, Memorial Circle,


Diliman, Quezon City

3.2.1.1 SUMMARY: Figure 28:QCX Museum


Source: www.google.com

The Quezon City Experience Museum or better known as QCX museum, is

a 6 229.21 square meters interactive and socio-cultural/ historical museum which

primarily exhibits the history of Quezon City. It is situated inside the premises of

Quezon City Memorial Circle facing the eastern side of the Elliptical Road.

3.2.1.2 ARCHITECTURAL ANALYSIS:

SPACE CONFIGURATION

The QCX complex is composed of a 5-pod museum has its own coffee

shop, a small cafeteria and memorabilia store at the lobby, where visitors can

spend time, dine or buys souvenir items. It also consist of a small theatre with 80-

90 seating capacity that can be rented out for group film screening and other

SORIANO, E.J.M 56
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

events. Its lecture room, which has 60 seats, can also be rented, as venue for

important meetings and other activities.

Each pods are interconnected with covered path walks and are arranged in

radial manner forming a circular courtyard right in the center of the development.

The layout also created more open space in the middle where sculptures, planters

and free-flowing benches are placed which also provides an experience to the

outdoor space.

LAYOUT OF GALLERY

The museum is compromising of an overall 16 interactive galleries namely;

Pylon,Quezon on a Hill, Malacañang, War Gallery, Monument, Housing , Jeepney,

Education, Street Scenes, Business, Entertainment, Issues and Barangay. Each

galleries displays the humble beginnings of the city of Quezon, the issues and

tragedies it encountered and the envisioned future. The gallery promotes users

experience by arranging each gallery in a manner that would create more

movements and integration of interactive and innovative materials such as digital

arts and learning sources. Another experiential approach that can be seen inside

the museum is the recreation of particular place of event such as the horrifying

views of the Balete Drive and Wars that conveys dark and intense emotion to the

users with the help of manipulation of lights, materials and space.

3.2.1.3 FINDING/SYNTHESIS:

The QCX Museum creates a breakthrough design in historical and socio-

cultural museums. Unlike any other similar established development, this facility

creates a learning environment far from the traditional way of displaying artifacts

that only serves the visual satisfaction but it also considered other senses such as

touch, hear and smell.

3.2.1.4 APPLICATION IN RELATION TO PRESENT STUDY:

The museum is an effective model of experiential design.It also provides

different strategies integrated inside the building the purpose of providing sensual

and perceptual experience to the users. The QCX Museum especially the

SORIANO, E.J.M 57
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

recreation of particular place or events can incorporate to the proposed research

project especially the dark and intense emotion that provide to the users because

of manipulation of space, materials and light and shadow.In addition, the

arrangement of galleries in the QCX museum inspired the proponents to integrate

it to the proposed Mindanao Trade and Cultural Center in the NCR.

3.2.2 LOCAL CASE STUDY 2

Purpose: The case study is focused in planning the first Cultural Center in the

Philippines specifically the different theaters and exhibitions gallery in the center.

CULTURAL
CENTER OF
THE
PHILIPPINES

CCP
Complex,
Roxas Blvd,
Pasay City

Ar. Leandro
Locsin
Figure 29:Cultural Center of the Philippines
Source: www. culturalcenter.gov.ph
3.2.2.1 SUMMARY:

The Cultural Center of the Philippines (CCP), located in Pasay City, is the

premiere showcase of the arts in the Philippines. It has been producing and

presenting music, dance, theatre, visual arts, literary, cinematic and design events

fro the Philippines and all over the world for fifty four years. It was established in

1966 during Ferdinand Marcos Regime, to promote and preserve the Filipino arts

and culture. The CCP provides different venues for performances and exhibition

for local and international productions. The center was design by Filipino National

Artist Leandro Locsin who was known for the use of concrete, floating volume, and

simplistic design in his projects.

3.2.2.2 ARCHITECTURAL ANALYSIS:

EXTRERIOR

SORIANO, E.J.M 58
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

The characteristics of the center is International style buildings are rectilinear

forms; light, rigid plane surfaces that have completely exposed; open interior

spaces by the use of glasses in general and an illustrational weightless quality

produced by the use of cantilever construction.

The great structure was designed by Ar. Leandro V. Locsin to promote and

preserve Filipino arts and culture. The rest of the structure is clad in concrete,

textured by crushed seashells, the parts of the shell itself within the concrete that

was used mainly in street and amazingly in structure itself.

SPACE CONFIGURATION:

The center as designed is contemporary and functional in structure; simple

and elegant in tone. The architectural concept will consist of: (1) a theatre of

performing arts, (2) a museum and an art gallery which shall serve as the treasure

house of cultural artifacts and works of art (3) an art and music library (4) an open

amphitheatre for outdoor concerts, and other artistic performances.

Tanghalang Nicanor Abelardo


(Main Theater)
The theatre has four levels

Orchestra, Boxes, Balcony 1 and

Balcony 2 and is able to accommodate

a total of 1 821 guests. The theatre has


Figure 30:Interior of the Main Theater
Source: www. culturalcenter.gov.ph a split orchestra pit floor and is

equipped to meet the requirements of large theatrical production such as ballets,

operas, symphonic concerts and other musicals.

Tanghalang Aurelio Tolentino


(Little Theater)
The Little Theater is a

Figure 31 : Interior of the Little Theater


Source: www. culturalcenter.gov.ph

conventional proscenium stage,

designed for drama, chamber music,

SORIANO, E.J.M 59
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

solo recitals, lectures and film screenings, with a capacity of 421 guests. The stage

curtain is a tapestry made in Kyoto, Japan based on the painting of Roberto

Chabet, former director of the CCP museum.

Tanghalang Huseng Batute


(Studio Theater)
Designed for experimental production and has two level as a studio which

features a variable stage.

Tanghalang Francisco Balagtas


(Folk Arts Theater)
Figure 32: Interior of the Studio Theater This covered proscenium
Source: www. culturalcenter.gov.ph
amphitheatre as where popular concerts

are usually staged it has a seating capacity of

Figure 33: Exterior of Folk Arts Theater 8,458 with ten sections.
Source: www. culturalcenter.gov.ph

Tanghalang Manuel Conde


(Dream Theater)
The CCP Dream Theater is the first

direct-

to- home satellite venue for art and culture films

and videos on the arts of the Philippines.


Figure 34: Interior of the Dream Theater
Source: www. culturalcenter.gov.ph

Exhibition Halls/ Galleries


o Bulwagang Juan Luna (Main Gallery)
The Bulwagang Juan Luna on the third floor offers a year round program of

large survey and retrospective exhibition. The gallery is a rectangular space, has

white walls and floors area of 440 sq. meters.

o Bulwagang Fernando Amorsolo (Small Gallery)


The Bulwagang Fernando Amorsolo on the fourth floor is an intimate space

for individual exhibitions and installations.

o Pasilyo Vicente Manansala (Second Floor Hallway)


A gallery that can feature diverse visual exhibits, installations, and collections

of artworks. This gallery is named after the National Artist for Painting, famous for

his unique style in depicting Filipino culture found in his works.

o Pasilyo Guillermo Tolentino (Third Floor Hallway)

SORIANO, E.J.M 60
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Located along Balcony 1 on the \third Floor. The gallery is used for regional art

works or for exhibits in line with cultural agreements. Named after the National

Artist for Sculpture, whose work have remained Iconic in modern Philippine art

history.

o Pasilyo Victorio Edades (Fourth Floor Hallway)

Situated at the east end of the Fourth Floor where the works of new talents are

usually displayed. It is often used for exhibits of panoramic works, photographs,

drawings, prints and works on paper. The gallery is named after the National artist

for painting who has made Philippine modern art stand out.

STRATEGIC SITE LOCATION

. The Cultural Center of the Philippines is also accessible to the great

population of Manila area and surrounding cities and districts. Manila is a perfect

location since it is the center of government and of commercial and cultural

activities that attracts the greatest number of foreign and provincial visitors

3.2.2.3 FINDING/SYNTHESIS:

The Cultural Center of the Philippines exemplifies an international style

architecture that flourished during its time. The building might be massive but it

was complemented by its floating and weightless effect which is an exquisite

example of cantilever construction.

3.2.2.4 APPLICATION IN RELATION TO PRESENT STUDY:

The Cultural Center of the Philippines is the first ever cultural center in the

country. The Center offer various venues for performances and varies its sizes

depending to the users. After the proponents conduct research to the Center. The

proponent will use as an inspiration as one of the physical scope of the research

project is the Tanghalang Aurelio Tolentino or also known as the Little Theater.

The project’s theater will use conventional proscenium stage which is commonly

used by the other theater as well. The proponent can also incorporate to the

research project on how the center locate, plan and named the exhibition hall/

galleries that can be seen in all open spaces that can create interaction to the

SORIANO, E.J.M 61
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

visitors. The way they honor the artist by naming the exhibition halls / galleries

according to the artist forte.

In addition, the Center offer different venues for showcasing the arts of

Filipino that promotes the culture and its traditions..In terms of exhibition the center

highlights the artist’s masterpiece by complementing the choice of lighting, the

color of the walls or partitions that will add another drama of the atmosphere.

3.2.3 LOCAL CASE STUDY 3

Purpose: The case study focused on how Nayong Pilipino incorporate the

different historical place in the amusement park that provides a sensory,

emotional and experiential approach in architecture.

NAYONG PILIPINO

Centennial Road,
Clark Field,
Mabalacat,
Pampanga

Figure 35:Nayong Pilipino


Source: www.visitpilipinas.com

3.2.3.1 SUMMARY:

Nayong Pilipino is a one stop place to know about the Phillippies. It is a 5

acre amusement/ theme park type environment. This park essentially a

representation in a miniature version of the diverse Philippine and its culture, all in

one place. This recreational/ leisure/ history-learning facility is divided into

numerous geographically-sectionalized display areas.

3.2.3.2 ARCHITECTURAL ANALYSIS:

SORIANO, E.J.M 62
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Nayong Pilipino directly translates to Philippine

Village, and that is essentially what the park is

about.Instead of Human replicas, Nayong Pilipino is

composed of imitations of both natural and man-made

wonders that can be seen in the Philippines. These

include small versions of RiceTerraces in Banaue, Mt.

Figure 36: Replica of Ifugao Tabon in Palawan, the National Hero Jose Rizal’s
Rice Terraces
Source: house and the Barasoian Church in Malolos, Bulacan.
www.visitpilipinas.com

Aside from the infrastructures, there are

also native villages within the Nayong

Pilipino namely the Kalinga, Ifugao and

Aeta with natives who can explain their

way of life.

Figure 37:Replica of Mt. Tabon


Source: www.visitpilipinas.com

Moreover, the Nayong Pilipino

has daily cultural shows, the Teatro, the

Heroes Plaza, and around the Lagoon.

Nayong Pilipno also has two museums

that feature cultural artifacts.


Figure38:Replica of Rizal’s House
Source: www.visitpilipinas.com
3.2.3.3 FINDING/SYNTHESIS:

Nayong Pilipino is a great place to explore the diverse culture of the

Philippines. Some regions of the Philippines area represented through the replicas

of their traditional house, landmark or structure. In this park, the visitors can feel

they’re exploring the culture of the country without travelling. There are different

stalls where local products and crafts of different regions are being sold. The

cultural shows that will be additional learning spaces for the visitors where they

can actually see their traditional dances, rituals and acts.

3.2.3.4 APPLICATION IN RELATION TO PRESENT STUDY:

SORIANO, E.J.M 63
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

The replication of historical/ tourist landmarks came from different places in

the country provides the spirit of a place that Nayong Pilipino features. The

proponent inspired to adopt the replicas that promote sensory, emotion and

experiential approach that will help to stimulate the cultural diversity of the

Mindanawons. Manipulation of space by adopting the historical landmarks original

location, manipulation of materials by using different materials that provide intricate

design for replication and the manipulation of light and shadow that creates a

memorable and learning impact to the visitors.

FOREIGN CASE STUDIES


3.2.4 FOREIGN CASE STUDY 1
Purpose: The case study focused on the conceptualization and the spatial

programming of the King Abdulaziz Center that promotes the culture and history

of Saudi Arabia.

KING ABDULAZIZ

CENTER

Dharan,Dharan,
Saudi Arabia

Snohetta
Architectural Firm

Figure 39::King Abdulaziz Center


3.2.4.1 SUMMARY: Source: www.snohetta.com

The King Abdulaziz center for World Culture is a bold initiative on the part

of the Saudi Aramco Oil Company to promote cultural development within the

kingdom. The project contains diverse cultural diversities, including auditorium,

cinema, library, exhibition hall, museum and archive that serve the local population

and becoming a cultural landmark on both a regional, national and global horizon.

3.2.4.2 ARCHITECTURAL ANALYSIS:

SORIANO, E.J.M 64
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

FORM CONCEPT

The design focuses on the

geological nature of the area, using

an assortment of different sized rock

which symbolize diversity. These

rocks lean on one another to

Figure 40: Form Conceptualization illustrate solidarity, and show that the
Source: www. snohetta.com
various disciplines explored in the

building all depend on one another. The design even extends to the layout of the

content housed within, placing inspiration from past in the rocks underground, the

present at ground level and the future soaring up into the sky.

SPACE CONFIGURATION

Library
The library in this center is not

the typical type, rather than just a

varied series of book shelves, the

library is an interactive experience,

with an emphasis on active learning.


Figure 41: Interior of the Library
The library consist of books, Source: www. snohetta.com

periodicals and reports in digital

archives, to encourage a new culture

of reading in the Kingdom.

Knowledge Tower
This tower consist of 18

floors of learning facilities that host

2000 workshops annually in STEM

subjects, as well as the arts,

Figure 42: Interior of the Knowledge Tower multimedia and skill building
Source: www. snohetta.com
program.

Children Museum

SORIANO, E.J.M 65
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

The first museum intended for the children aged twelve and under, this aims

to develop cognitive and personality skills during the formative years, through

exhibitions and entertaining, interactive activities.

Museum
It provides a panoramic view of

the best of Saudi and global cultures in

four galleries. Each focuses on a

specific topic, opening minds to new

ideas, forms of cultural expression, and


Figure 43: Interior of the Museum
Source: www. snohetta.com understanding. The discovery begins

with Contemporary Saudi art, followed by Saudi Identity and heritage, Islamic art

and legacy and the natural history of the Arabian Peninsula.

The Great Hall


The Great Hall is the window

to the world, housing international

touring exhibitions, festivals,

conferences and event. By offering

visitors chance to see what other


Figure 44: Interior of the Great Hall
societies have to offer, this space act
Source: www. snohetta.com

as a bridge connecting cultures.

Multimedia Theater
A 3000 seat auditorium offers

lectures or film. Its primary purpose

I to screen original works from the

emerging Saudi Film industry, as

Figure 45: Interior of the Multimedia Theater


well as educational and culturally
Source: www. snohetta.com
insightful documentaries from

across the globe.

SORIANO, E.J.M 66
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Performing Arts Theater


The 900 seat theatre will feature

live local and international productions.

The shows will reinforce Saudi social

and cultural values and provide training

to local talent in the fields of cinematic,

production, script writing and the Figure 46: Lobby of Performing Arts
Source: www. snohetta.com
supporting arts.

Archives Library
The Archives Library is the place for Kingdom’s heritage. The rare, vital

documents, record and elements of their history are managed, catalogue and

preserved.

Energy Exhibit
The Energy Exhibit provides a hands on, immersive experience of the world

of petroleum, its sciences, energy and technology.

3.2.4.4 FINDING/SYNTHESIS:

The center is the world cultural center for its innovativeness when it comes

to materials used, the programs and the spaces. Each spaces that they planned

promotes their culture and learning for future generations.

3.2.4.5 APPLICATION IN RELATION TO PRESENT STUDY:

The King Abdulaziz Center is a structure that is an innovation of architecture

and engineering. Its innovativeness of the materials where in it can manipulate its

spaces, and light and shadow attained by this project is substance of the

phenomenological approach.

The proponent will use as an inspiration are the spaces that the Cultural

Center provides.

▪ The Museum that focuses on a specific topic, opening minds to new

ideas, forms of cultural expression, and understanding. The

discovery begins with Contemporary Saudi art, followed by Saudi

SORIANO, E.J.M 67
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Identity and heritage, Islamic art and legacy and the natural history

of the Arabian Peninsula.

▪ The Great Hall that is the window to the world, housing international

touring exhibitions, festivals, conferences and event. By offering

visitors chance to see what other societies have to offer.

▪ Promoting and teaching its legacy by providing a center that is very

well known product by its country like the Energy Exhibit. The exhibit

provides a hands on, immersive experience of the world of

petroleum, its sciences, energy and technology.

In addition,the proponent will use as an inspiration are the manipulation of

the spaces, materials and light and shadow that the center apply to the following

spaces: (1) its great hall; the interplay of the light and shadow in its ceiling, multi

meida theatre; the application of materials and the effect of the light, the lobby;

natural light that creates spaciousness and its being abstract to the form

conceptualization of the center.

3.2.5 FOREIGN CASE STUDY 2

Purpose: The case study is focused on the innovative material used in the façade

and the connectivity used in the interior spaces.

RAIF DINCKOK

YALOVA

CULTURAL

CENTER

Yalova, Turkey

Emre Arolat
Architects

Figure 47: Raif Yalova Cultural Center


Source: www. archdaily.com
3.2.5.1 SUMMARY:

The Raif Dinckok Yalova Cultural Center located in Yalova, a tourist town

on the Sea of Marmara, has adual nature:on the one hand it stands out for its

charming landscape, full of colors and vegetation; on the other it is an industrial

SORIANO, E.J.M 68
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

and manufacturing center.The main objective of the project was to relate

architecture, which has a cultural function, to the city and to the inhabitants of the

city, attempting to reconcile the conflicting aspects of the place and of the

landscape.

3.2.5.2 ARCHITECTURAL ANALYSIS:

SPACE CONFIGURATION

The Cutural Center translates into an extremely flexible distribution of

internal spaces, because it is completely independent from the outer envelope: the

visitor experiences the feeling of being in a large open space, despite the many

activities that take place there, conferences, research and entertainment.

Figure 48: Ground Floor Plan Figure 49: Second Floor Plan
Source: www. archdaily.com Source: www. archdaily.com

EXTERIOR

Figure 50: Raif Yalova Cultural Center during night


Source: www. archdaily.com

The façade is perforated provide the surface to dissolve at the night time

like a tulle curtain and the inner would to be perceived easily. The users enters the

building from its mouth. There is not a door or a barrier. The metal tulle now

transform into a protector it leaves the negative impacts of rain, sun and wind but

SORIANO, E.J.M 69
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

it does not transform into an interior space because of it semi- transparent nature.

The air ventilates freely in the area.

The façade is made of material

called Corten steel, which is constanly

enriched with new shades due to

oxidation and the formation of the typical

protective layer of a purple color, caused

by its exposure to air.

The building façade also enriched

with a spectacular feature, as the design

of metal mesh represents a homage to

traditional Arab architecture, which is

Figure 51: Skin of the Exterior


characterised by the conspicuous
Source: www. archdaily.com
presence of decorative grilles.

The cultural center is sub divided into two layers the outer enveloped which

is made up of corten steel and the inner enveloped that is composed of the spaces

like conferences, exhibitions and many more. This contextual layers symbolizes

the distinction of the two existing faces of the site.

CONNECTIVITY

Figure 52: Sections


Source: www. archdaily.com

SORIANO, E.J.M 70
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

The spaces in the building are shaped specifically to their different functions

and necessary dimensions areas like 600 people capacity multi-purpose room, 150

people capacity workshop room, nuptial and exhibit rooms, library, office and

cafeteria are related to each other from different elevations. These spaces that are

disconnected from the building façade and from each other exit inside the building

with their unique geometries. This surfaces emphasize Yalova’s colorful and

overgrown natural texture. It is aimed that the joyful image that various plants

generate will appear beneath the surface of the façade as a second layer of

exterior perception of the building just like it is on digital publication close

perception.

The ramps that connects these spaces to each other by creating a sheltered

inner street, try to enrich lives of the visitors. That open spaces that are in between

the ramps are mostly recreational activity functions and service spaces. This

spaces use lighting (natural or artificial) to give a vibrant color to the visitor that

lead to a social developmental of an individual.


Figure 53: Ramp 1 Figure 54: Ramp 2 Figure 55: Ramp 3
Source: www. archdaily.com Source: www. archdaily.com Source: www. archdaily.com

STRATEGIC SITE

LOCATION

One face of Yalova is its natural side. The endemic plants, areas where

these plants are grown, exhibited and evaluated commercially, and even most

developed arboretums of the near geography are facts that determine the current

existing state of the city.

SORIANO, E.J.M 71
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

The other face of Yalova is an industrial city. This is the existing area without

trees. It is not vibrant compared to the other side this is the place where labor and

sweat come out.The architects reconcile the two existing states that are totally

opposites to each other. And this creates the unique soul of the city.

3.2.5.3 FINDING/SYNTHESIS:

The DMK Cultural Center proves the relationship of the built environment

which is the cultural center, the city and the people of the city is the primary vessel

of the design. In this sense, the center fulfilled to connect the opposite layers of

the city through culture.The center has many spaces like multi-purpose room,

workshop room, nuptial and exhibit rooms, library, office and cafeteria are related

to each other from different elevations. The exterior is very andapply the abtract

representation of the traditional Arab architecture.

3.2.5.4 APPLICATION IN RELATION TO PRESENT STUDY:

The proponent will use as an inspiration are the following:

▪ The DMK Cultural Center building façade that is enriched with a spectacular

feature, as the design of metal mesh represents a homage to traditional

Arab architecture, which is characterised by the conspicuous presence of

decorative grilles

▪ The connection in that connects the spaces provides the ability of the light

and shadow to interplay,the ability in social interaction and location of

galleries in the center.

▪ The open spaces below the ramps can create a social interaction spaces

for the visitors.

3.2.6 FOREIGN CASE STUDY 3

SORIANO, E.J.M 72
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Purpose: The case study is focused on the spaces of the weaving center .

GAGYEL LHUNDRUP

WEAVING CENTER

Thimpu, Bhutan

Figure 56: Gagyel Lhundrup Weaving Center


Source: www. google.com
3.2.6.1 SUMMARY:

Located on the south end of Thimpu in Changzamtog, the Gagyel Lhundrup

Weaing center provides Bhutan’s finest fabrics.

3.2.6.2 ARCHITECTURAL ANALYSIS:

THE CENTER

It is a simple building with neutral facade, and used the Bhutanese

architecture. Their most refined and complex traditional arts is the art of weaving.

Weaving from them also brings luck and Bhutanese take superstitions very

seriously, one can use to keep evil spirits by painting giant ejaculating phalluses

on the walls. It has two storey building were divided in retailing, workshops and

showcasing their products. The retail and showcase area is in the ground floor

while the workshop, where you can see the actual weaving and hand looming is

located in second floor.

3.2.6.3 FINDING/SYNTHESIS:

The center preserve their richest traditional art by having a workshop and

retail at the same time.

3.2.7.4 APPLICATION IN RELATION TO PRESENT STUDY:

The proponent will use as an inspiration are the spaces that the Weaving

Center provides. Design and Weaving center is one of the physical scope of the

proposed project.

3.2.7 FOREIGN CASE STUDY 4

SORIANO, E.J.M 73
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

Purpose: The case study focused on how the Museum used phenomenological

approach in creating a memorable impact to the society.

JEWISH MUSEUM

Berlin, Germany
Ar. Daniel Libeskind

Figure 57: Jewish Museum


Source: www.archdaily.com

3.2.7.1 SUMMARY:

The current Jewish Museum Berlin was opened in 2001 and is the largest

Jewish museum in Europe. It consist of three buildings, two of which are new

additions specifically built for the museum by architect Daniel Libeskind. German-

Jewish history is documented in the collections, the library and the archive, and is

reflected in the museum’s program of events.

3.2.7.2 ARCHITECTURAL ANALYSIS:

THE CONCEPT

The building’s overall composition is the distorted Star of David, with a

straight “void “running through the length of the building. Heavy with symbolism

and metaphor, the building uses fragmentation, void and disorientation to reflect

the three aforementioned aspects of Jewish history.

EXTERIOR

The most obvious element of the building’s exterior is the fragmented Star

of David from which the plan is derived. This is combined with the contrast of the

straight line of the void, which can be seen from the above in the form of roof

elements. Libeskind states, “One is a straight line, but broken into many fragments,

the other is tortuous line, but continuing indefinitely.”

SORIANO, E.J.M 74
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

VOID

Figure 58: Jewish Museum Conceptual Plan


Source: www.archdaily.com
The theme of fragmentation can be seen in th overall “ tortuous” line of the

plan, but also in the window placement. Libeskind plotted the addresses of Jewish

citizens on a pre-war map of Berlin and used the matrices to determine the form

of the windows- a less obvious but no less powerful metaphor. The theme can also

be seen in the lack of right angles or symmetry in almost any part of the building.

INTERIOR
The main metaphor of the interior of the museum

is the void metaphor. Libeskind states that the straight

line void cutting through the museum “is the space of

Berlin, because it refers to that which can never be

exhibited when it comes to Jewish Berlin history.

Humanity reduced to ashes “( Libeskind 1999). The


Figure 59: The Void
Source: www.archdaily.com space is organized in such an unavoidable way that

“visitors must cross one of the 60 bridges that open this void”

The other main metaphor of the building’s interior is the split entry route,

where visitors are faced with choices mirroring the choices of Jews during the

holocaust. “The descent leads to three underground axial routes, each of which

tells a different story. The first and longest, traces a path leading to the stair of

continuity, then up to and through the exhibition spaces of the museum,

emphasizing the continuous of history. The second leads out of the building and

into the Garden of Exile and Emigration, remembering those who were forced to

leave Berlin. The third leads to a dead end, the Holocaust Void.

SORIANO, E.J.M 75
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

GARDEN OF EXILE

First and foremost, the garden,

which visitors move through as they exit

the museum,” represents an attempt to

completely disorient the visitor. It


Figure 60: The Garden of Exile
represents a shipwreck of history” Source: www.archdaily.com

(Libeskind 1999). Libeskind achieves this disorientation by tilting the floor. This is

especially effective considering the garden appears to be the only structure in the

museum to be composed on a grid systemof right angles.

3.2.7.3 FINDING/SYNTHESIS:

The Jewish Museum utilizes symbolism and metaphor, including

fragmentation, void and disorientation, in order to create a more substantial

museum experience for the visitor. Rather than presenting information as museum

traditionally do. Jewish Museum use these effects to communicate the aspects of

Jewish history, especially the Holocaust, which cannot be expressed in only words.

3.2.7.4 APPLICATION IN RELATION TO PRESENT STUDY:

Libeskind’s design significant to its complexity, artistic beauty and

downright audacity. The form concept has aura of mystery and symbolism that

pervades the entire building. On its own, the Jewish Museum Berlin is a

manifestation of the repeated phrase “Let us not forget,” but it is also a part of the

greater experience of Berlin.

The proponent will use as an inspiration are the following:

▪ The researcher inspired by the sculpture and work of art that has a deep

meaning that surely tangled in the memory of the visitors and will be

timeless masterpiece.

▪ The garden of exile that can incorporate to Steven Holl’s as water as

phenomenal lens.

▪ The manipulation of materials that provides sensory, emotional and

experiential experience to the visitors.

SORIANO, E.J.M 76
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

3.2.8 FOREIGN CASE STUDY 5

Purpose:The case study focused on Steven Holl’s application of

Phenomenological Architecture.

BLOCH GALLERY
OF ART
‘The Feather’

Kansas City, Missouri


Ar. Steven Holl

Figure 61: Bloch Gallery of art during night


Source: www.bnim.com

3.2.8.1 SUMMARY:

The Henry W. and Marion H. Bloch Gallery of Art, an expansion to the

Nelson-Atkins Museum of Arts, fuses architecture with landscape and features five

striking “ lenses” rising from the rolling terrain on the east side of the Museum. The

new addition contais galleries and public facilities including an entry lobby, an art

library, a café and a sculpture court devoted to the works of Isamu Naguchi.

3.2.8.2 ARCHITECTURAL ANALYSIS:

THE FIVE LENSES

1
23
4 5

Figure 62: Bloch Gallery of art spaces


Source: www.bnim.com

SORIANO, E.J.M 77
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

• The first of the five lenses

forms a bright and

transparent lobby, with café,

art library and bookstore,

inviting the public into the

Museum and encouraging Figure 63: First lenses of Bloch Gallery


Source: www.bnim.com
movement via ramps towards

the galleries as they progress

downward into the garden.

• From the lobby a new cross

axis connect through to the

original Figure 64: Landscape beside Bloch Gallery


Source: www.bnim.com
Building’s grand spaces.

The second lenses is where the events and activities room located

and on its ground floor is the contemporary arts area 1.

• From its third to fifth lenses is where located the contemporary arts

area 2 and spaces for featured exhibitions.

The design for each lenses has a sustainable building concepts; the

sculpture garden continues up and over the gallery roofs, creating sculpture

courts between the lenses, while also providing green roofs to achieve high

insulation and control storm water.

CONNECTIVITY

The galleries, organized in sequence to

support the progression of the collections, gradually

step down with the use of ramps and stairs down into

the Park, and are punctuate by views into the

landscape. The bloch building will provide

experience to the visitors the flow between light, art,


Figure 65: Ramps and Stairs architecture and landscape.
Source: www.bnim.com

SORIANO, E.J.M 78
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

THE BUILDING AND SITE

According to Steven Holl, the idea of complimentary contrast, the stone

and the feather, drive the design for the addition to the classical stone temple

and surrounding landscape. The addition envisioned a new paradigm fusing

landscape and

architecture. In contrast

to the stone building,

the new lightweight

architecture of glass

lenses is scattered

about the landscape


Figure 66: Actual site of the Gallery
Source: www. bnim.com
framing sculpture

gardens.

3.2.8.3 FINDING/ SYNTHESIS:

The Bloch Addition, often described as “the Feather”, is an exploration of

space through the effect of light. A unique juxtaposition to the static existing Nelson

Art Gallery building, the light-gathering lenses strung down the hillside integrate a

sensitive, experiential journey into the site’s fabric. Holl’s flowing program

circulation and structural design allows infused day lighting opportunity throughout

the galleries. The envelope of channel glass glows in the night and a permits

ambient light during the day and its language is extended throughout the building.

Figure 67: Light and Shadow


Source: www. bnim.com

Figure 69: Light and


Figure 68: Natural Light Materials
Source: www. bnim.com Source: www. bnim.com

SORIANO, E.J.M 79
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

3.2.8.4 APPLICATION IN RELATION TO PRESENT STUDY:

The Bloch Gallery design by Steven Holls is the application of his

Phenomenal Zone; Color,Light and shadow, Spatiality of night, Water: a

phenomenal lens,sound, Detail and touch and Lived time.

The proponent will use as an inspiration are the following:

▪ The movement between the light gathering lenses of the new addition

weaves the new building with the landscape in a fluid dynamism based on

a sensitive relationship to its context.

▪ Rather than an addition of a mass the new elements exist in complementary

contrast with the original classical temple. It is a dynamic relationship

between art, landscape, light and architecture that can be adopted to the

project.

▪ Phenomenological experience of space and material seem to be highlighted

with cooperation of light and shadow. Holl suggests, “the perceptual spirit

and metaphysical strength of architecture are driven by the quality of light

and shadow shaped by solids and voids, by opacities, transparencies and

translucencies.

▪ The design for each lenses has a sustainable building concepts; the

sculpture garden continues up and over the gallery roofs, creating

sculpture courts between the lenses, while also providing green roofs to

achieve high insulation and control storm water.

▪ The connection that connects the spaces provides the ability of the light and

shadow to interplay,the ability in social interaction and location of galleries

in the center.

▪ The open spaces below the ramps can create a social interaction spaces

for the visitors.

SORIANO, E.J.M 80
ESPASYO: MINDANAO TRADE AND CULTURAL CENTER
Stimulating Minadanawons Cultural Diversity in the National Capital Region
through Phenomenological Architecture

SORIANO, E.J.M 81

You might also like

pFad - Phonifier reborn

Pfad - The Proxy pFad of © 2024 Garber Painting. All rights reserved.

Note: This service is not intended for secure transactions such as banking, social media, email, or purchasing. Use at your own risk. We assume no liability whatsoever for broken pages.


Alternative Proxies:

Alternative Proxy

pFad Proxy

pFad v3 Proxy

pFad v4 Proxy