Villamor Group, Final Copy, Chapter 1-5

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 35

Republic of the Philippines

Carlos Hilado Memorial State College


Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

JACKFRUIT (Artocarpus heterophyllus Lam) SEEDS


FLOUR FOR CUPCAKES

A Research Paper
Presented to
Research I
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Binalbagan, Negros Occidental

In Partial Fulfillment
Of the Requirements for the Degree
Bachelor of Secondary Education
Major in Technology and Livelihood Education

By
NICO PAOLO N. ARBOLEDA
BEA V. CATALUÑA
JOHN FRANCIS D. PRECIOSO
JOHN PAUL B. TUA
JETHRO B. VILLAMOR

March 2017
Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

INTRODUCTION

Jackfruit is a huge tree that grows to as high as 30 meters,

larger than mango, breadfruit etc. It is believed to be

indigenous to the South-western rain forests of India. Today, it

is widely cultivated in the tropical regions of Indian

subcontinent, Thailand, Malaysia, Indonesia and Brazil for its

fruit, seeds, and wood. The tree grows best under tropical humid

and rainy climates but rarely survives cold and frosty

conditions. (http://www.nutrition-and-you.com/jackfruit.html)

Botanically, this popular Asian tropical fruit belongs to

the family of moraceae, genus: Artocarpus and is closely related

to figs, mulberry, and breadfruit. Scientific name: Artocarpus

heterophyllus. (http://www.nutrition-and-you.com/jackfruit.html)

The jackfruit seeds are a good source of starch (22%) and

dietary fibre. The meal is categorized as a low GI meal. The low

GI could be due to the collective contributions from dietary

fibre, slowly available glucose and un-gelatinised (intact)

starch granules in the seeds.

(https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21789865)

In the Philippines, Jackfruit is locally known as langka,

nangka.
Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

This study was conducted to utilize the jackfruit

(Autocarpus heterophyllus Lam) seed into flour for cupcakes. It

aims to determine the acceptability of cupcakes made of jackfruit

seed flour of 3 different ratios in terms of flavor, odor,

texture, color and general appearance when they are taken as a

whole and also to determine the significant difference among the

three taste tests namely: Test 1 (4:4), Test 2 (5:3) and Test 3

(6:2) ratios of Jackfruit seeds flour to commercial flour in

making cupcakes.

Objectives of the Study

Generally, this study aims to utilize the jackfruit seed

(Autocarpus heterophyllus) into flour for cupcakes.

Specifically, this study aims to determine the following:

1. The acceptability of cupcakes made of jackfruit seed flour

of 3 different ratios in terms of flavor, odor, texture,

color and general appearance when they are taken as a whole.

2. Is there a significant difference among the three taste

tests namely: Test 1 (4:4), Test 2 (5:3) and Test 3 (6:2)

ratios of Jackfruit seeds flour to commercial flour in

making cupcakes?
Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

Statement of the Hypothesis

1. There is no significant difference among the three taste

tests namely: Test 1 (4:4), Test 2 (5:3) and Test 3 (6:2)

ratios of Jackfruit seeds flour to commercial flour in

making cupcakes in terms of flavor, odor, texture, color and

general appearance.

Definition of Terms

The following terms are defined conceptually and operationally in

order to provide clearness and accuracy to the researchers and

readers.

Acceptability. It is conditions considered to be

satisfactory or a condition that would likely gain somebody’s

approval (Microsoft Encarta Dictionary, 2009).

In this study, the term refers to a condition that is

considered good enough to meet the requirements of the

respondents for the Jackfruit seeds flour for cupcakes.

Appearance. It is the way somebody or something looks or

seems to other. It is an outward aspect of somebody or something

that creates a particular impression (Microsoft Encarta

Dictionary, 2009).
Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

In this study, the term refers to the judgment of the

respondents using the sense of sight towards the Jackfruit seeds

flour for cupcakes.

Color. A quality such as red, blue, green, yellow, etc.,

that you see when you look at something (Merriam-Webster

Dictionary, 2017).

In this study, the term refers to the color of the

cupcakes.

Cupcake. A very small cake that is baked in a pan shaped

like a cup (Merriam-Webster Dictionary, 2017).

In this study, cupcake refers to the sweet dessert that is

made of Jackfruit seeds flour and commercial flour mixture.

Flavor. It is the quality of something that you can taste

(Merriam-Webster Dictionary, 2017|).

In this study, flavor refers to the quality of taste of the

cupcakes.

Flour. A powder made from grain that is used in cooking for

making bread, cakes, etc. (Merriam-Webster Dictionary, 2017).


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

In this study, four refers to the powdery substance made

from Jackfruit seeds.

Hedonic Scale. It is any scale or test which seeks to

measure on the same continuum (Jones, Peryam and Thurstone,

1955).

In this study, the term refers to the 9-Point Hedonic Scale

originally developed by Peryam in 1955. The 9-Point Hedonic Scale

was used in this study to determine the sensory attributes of

Jackfruit seeds flour for cupcakes in terms of flavor, odor,

texture, color and general appearance.

Hedonic Testing. It is a process that involves having

potential consumers of the product to evaluate various product

and a small number of items on a ballot (Wikipedia, 2009).

In this study, the term refers to the taste test process

conducted to the respondents using the 9-Point Hedonic Scale.

Jackfruit. It is a huge tree that grows to as high as 30

meters, larger than mango, breadfruit etc. It is believed to be

indigenous to the South-western rain forests of India. Today, it

is widely cultivated in the tropical regions of Indian

subcontinent, Thailand, Malaysia, Indonesia and Brazil for its


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

fruit, seeds, and wood. The tree grows best under tropical humid

and rainy climates but rarely survives cold and frosty conditions

(http://www.nutrition-and-you.com/jackfruit.html).

In this study, the term refers to the fruit in which the

seeds came from.

Jackfruit Seeds. Jackfruit seed encased inside a thin,

transparent outer cover. It largely composes of starch and

protein. Each seed measures about 2 to 4 cm in length, and 1 to 3

cm in thickness (http://www.nutrition-and-

you.com/jackfruit.html).

In this study, the term refers to the seeds that are made

into flour for cupcakes.

Jackfruit Seeds Flour. Jackfruit seeds flour is the product

of the processes made to the jackfruit seeds

(http://www.nutrition-and-you.com/jackfruit.html).

In this study, the term refers to the result of processing

the Jackfruit seeds. It is the product obtained by grinding the

sun-dried seeds. The main variable in this study.

Odor. It is a smell whether pleasant or unpleasant. It is

further defined as a quality or attribute that suggests or


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

resembles a particular thing (Microsoft Encarta Dictionary,

2009).

In this study, the term refers to the smell of the cupcakes.

Seed. A small object produced by a plant form which a new

plant can grow (Merriam-Webster Dictionary, 2017).

In this study, the term refers to the Jackfruit seeds that

are made into flour for cupcakes.

Taste Test. A taste test is a tool used to gather

information about the flavor of a food or product

(http://www.wisegeek.com/what-is-a-taste-test).

In this study, the term refers to the test given to the

respondents using the 9-Point Hedonic Scale.

Texture. The term refers to the appearance of a surface

especially how rough or smooth it is. It is the structure of a

substance or material such as soil, or food, especially how it

feels when touched or chewed (Microsoft Encarta Dictionary,

2009).

In this study, the term refers to the appearance of the body

of the cupcakes as judged by the respondents.


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

Scope and Limitations of the Study

This study aims to determine the level of acceptability of

jackfruit seed flour of 3 different ratios for cupcakes among 15

faculty members of CHMSC-Binalbagan Campus in the A.Y. 2016-2017

in terms of flavor, odor, texture, color and general appearance.

Significance of the Study

This study is envisioned to utilize the seeds of jackfruit

as flour for cupcakes. This will primarily be of great help to

small scale entrepreneurs, future researchers, researcher, CHMSC

Community, future teachers, TLE students, TLE teachers, schools,

and parents.

CHMSC Community. This study can help the school community by

making the product of this study as a subject for income

generation.

Future Researchers. This study will encourage future

researchers to undertake related studies and cover a larger

scope.
Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

Future Teachers. This study will help future teachers as

basis for related studies. Specifically, studies related to

product development and the like.

Parents. This study will help every household to utilize the

jackfruit seeds into flour for cupcakes, or for other related

desserts.

Researcher. This study will benefit every researcher to

undertake similar studies and make this research paper as basis

for such research.

Schools. This study can help schools to generate income

through production.

Small Scale Entrepreneurs. This study will support small

scale entrepreneurs to produce products which requires affordable

substitutes for commercial flours, such as the jackfruit seeds

flour.

TLE Students. This study will help TLE students to come up

with related researches that can be beneficial to their studies.

Furthermore, this study can be their basis for research

improvement.
Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

TLE Teachers. This study can help the TLE teachers to

conceptualize related researches that can help themselves, their

students, and their school.


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

Chapter II

Review of Related Literature

George and Boskou (1975) analyzed the chemical composition

of tomato seeds. The seeds contained 24.5 per cent protein, 28.1

per cent fat, 2.9 per cent of total sugars (as glucose), 5.4 and

19.1 percentage of ash and crude fiber, respectively. Higher

mineral contents (mg/100 g) for potassium (780), phosphorus

(690), magnesium (300), Calcium (160), sodium (110) and ferrous

(17) were reported. In the year 1975, Oyenuga and Fetuga

evaluated the nutritive value of two local varieties of

watermelon seed flour. Bara and Serewe, the two local varieties

documented good amount of protein ( 35.70 and 30.60 % ), crude

fiber (2.40 and 3.10%), ether extract (54.20 and 56.90%), total

ash (4.20 and 3.40 %) and carbohydrates (3.50 and 6.00 %),

respectively.

Fleming et al. (1976) determined the composition of

sunflower seed flour. The defatted flour contained protein

(53.00%), crude fat (1.80%), higher levels of crude fiber (3.60%)

and ash (8.20%).

Bobbio et al. (1978) reported the proximate composition of

jack seeds. Jack seeds contained 61.50 per cent moisture, 12.30
Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

per cent protein, 25.10 per cent carbohydrates and 0.50 per cent

crude lipids.

Carlson et al. (1981) investigated the nutritional

composition of tomato seed. The mean values of moisture (9.60%),

crude fat (22.20%), crude fiber(18.30%) and crude protein

(33.90%) were documented.

A study was conducted by Akobundu et al. (1982) to analyze

the chemical compositions of egusi (cucurbitaceae) seed kernels.

Study revealed that, hull-free kernels contained protein

(28.40%), lipid (52.00%), crude fiber (2.70%), ash (3.68%) and

carbohydrate (8.21%). Egusi seed flour had good quantities of

minerals (mg/100g) viz., sulphur (580), calcium (354), potassium

(1442) and phosphorus (1950). Besides, seed flour also recorded

significant amounts of vitamins, especially thiamine (4.16 µg/g)

and niacin (35.40 µg/g)

Dingra and Kapoor (1984) documented the composition of mango

seed kernel. The seed kernels constituted 5 per cent protein (g),

67 per cent crude fat (g), tannins (0.19 -0.44%), oleic acid

(42.00%) and stearic acid (39.00%).

Nutritional and fatty acid contents of pumpkin and melon

seed flour was documented by Lazos (1986). The data obtained for
Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

pumpkin and melon seeds on a dry basis were, crude oil (45.40 and

37.80%), crude protein (32.30 and 25.20g%), crude fiber (12.10

and 15.40g%) and ash (4.65 and 3.85g%), respectively. The major

fatty acid of both oils was linoleic acid (18:2), in

concentrations of 43.10 and 64.60 per cent, respectively followed

by oleic acid (18:1), 37.8 and 20.10 per cent, respectively.

Mineral content (mg) indicated rich sources of K (1111.00 and

1288.00%), P (852.00 and 557.00%) and Mg (205.50 and 256.00%),

respectively.

Yanez et al. (1986) analyzed the chemical composition of

amaranth seed flour. The mean values (g) for moisture (9.67%),

protein (2.69%), ash (2.80%), fat (7.15%) fiber (3.34%), and

carbohydrates (62.30%) were documented.

Hemavathy et al. (1987) studied the polar lipids of Alphonso

mango kernel. Total lipid (g) in the kernel of alphonso mango

extracted, amounted to 11.60 per cent of the dry kernel. Total

lipid consisted of 96.10 per cent of neutral and 3.90 per cent of

polar lipids which comprised 2.90 per cent glycolipids and 1.00

per cent of phospholipids.

A study was conducted by Kumar et al. (1988) on the

proximate composition of jackfruit seed flour. The seeds of


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

Kathari and Bharat Baramasi varieties of jackfruit were found

good sources of carbohydrates (28.01 and 26.83g %), protein

(6.75 and 6.25g %), fat (0.78 and .89g %) and ash (1.27 and 1.16g

%), respectively. The calorific value of both Kathari and

Bharat Baramasi were found as 146.06 and 140.33 KCal/100g,

respectively. Kathari variety was observed to be nutritionally

excelling, compared to the Bharat Baramasi variety on the basis

of most of the constituents analyzed.

In a review, Singhal and Kulkarni (1988) reported the

compositions of amaranthus seed flour. The seeds contained

moisture, protein, fat, crude fiber, and ash with the mean values

(g), 6.20, 13.20, 6.30, 3.60 and 2.80 percentages, respectively.

Giami and Bekebian (1992) investigated the nutritional

properties of pumpkin seed flour. The mean values (g %) were

4.20, 28.10, 47.00, 3.10 and 12.90 for moisture, crude protein,

ether extract, total ash, crude fiber and carbohydrates,

respectively. Iron and total phosphorus contents recorded were

4.50 and 140.00 mg/100g, respectively.

Rajarajeshwari and Jamuna (1999) studied the nutritional

profile of the jack seed flour. The flour contained the moisture
Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

(4.43 %), protein (21.30g %), fat (2.73g %), total ash (2.00g %),

crude fiber (5.69g %) and carbohydrates (63.85g %).

Vishwanathan et al. (1999) analyzed the compositions of

Teramnuslabialisspreng. seeds flour documented (g) crude protein,

crude fat, ash and nitrogen free extracts constituted 22.86,

6.10, 4.62 and 58.15 per cent, respectively. The calorific value

of 100grams dry matter of seed material was 379 K.calories.

In the year 2001, Nagaraj evaluated the nutritional value of

defatted cashew kernel flour. The mean values (%) were 63.50,

20.30 and 12.90 for protein, carbohydrate and sugars,

respectively.

Tananuwong et al. (2002) reported the chemical compositions

of jackfruit seed flour. The major components of the flour were

carbohydrates (82.25%), protein (11.17%), lipid (0.99%) and crude

fiber (1.67%). The total starch and amylose contents were

analyzed and the values recorded as 77.76 and 32.05 g/100g,

respectively.

In the year 2004, Akubor conducted a study to investigate

the compositions of melon seeds. The seeds documented 6.00 g per

cent moisture, 29.30g per cent protein, 54.90g per cent crude fat

and 3.00, 2.80 and 4.00g percentages of ash, crude fiber and
Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

carbohydrates, respectively. Further Akubor (2005), evaluated the

chemical composition of breadfruit seed flour. The flour

documented the proximate compositions (g) such as moisture

(8.60%), protein (17.30%), crude fiber (2.50%), ash (2.80%), fat

(11.00%) and carbohydrates (62.80%). The calorific value was

noted as 419.40 K.calories per 100grams of seed flour.

A study by Amoo (2005) was conducted on the proximate

compositions (g) of cashew kernel flour. The kernel flour

contained 20.90 per cent protein, 42.80 per cent fat, 8.00 per

cent moisture, total ash and crude fiber contents were 2.80 and

1.40 per cent, respectively. The carbohydrate content was noted

as 24.10 per cent.

Aremu et al. (2006) assessed the compositional

characteristics of cashew nut flour. The mean values of proximate

compositions (g %) were moisture (5.70), ash (4.40), ether

extract (36.70), crude protein (25.30), crude fiber (1.20), and

carbohydrate (26.80). The calorific value was 2243 KJ/100g and

fatty acid content was noted as 29.40 per cent. Abundant minerals

(mg/100g) constituted were K, Mg, Na and Ca while least were Cu,

Zn, and Fe. Amino acid analysis revealed that cashew nut flour
Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

contained nutritionally useful quantities of most of the

essential amino acids.

There have been few studies on jackfruit seeds. Bobbio et al

(1978) reported some physicochemical properties, such as pasting

characteristics of jackfruit seed starch. Kumar et al (1988)

studied the proximate compositions of two varieties of jackfruit

seeds and reported considerable biochemical difference between

the two varieties. The starch content of the seed increases with

maturity (Rahman et al 1999). Different locations give different

seed contents. Some functional properties of jackfruit seed

flour and its protein digestibility was reported by Singh et al

(1991).

Jackfruit

Description

Fruit of the langka is green, oblong, fleshy, twenty-five to

sixty centimeters long, edible and covered with pyramidal

projections. It grows on the trunk and on the main branches of


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

the tree. The flesh is yellow, sweet, and very aromatic. The

leaves are alternate, leathery, broadest near the tip and pointed

at the base, entirely or sometimes three lobbed. Disregarding

exaggerated reports of enthusiastic travelers, the jackfruit is

doubtless the largest of fruits and that such heavy bodies are

borne in the main trunk or main branches of the tree.

Nutritive value

The high carbohydrate contents of langka indicates that it

is nutritious. It is however deficient in calcium and iron. The

seeds are very rich in starch. They have a good flavor but are

poor sources of calcium and iron (Pascuala, De Jesus, 1969, Know

Your Plant Foods).

Uses

The pulp of the green lanka fruit is usually cooked with

fish and coconut milk, while that of the ripe fruit is eaten

uncooked or made into preserve or sweet. The seeds of the ripe

fruit are roasted or boiled before they are eaten or may be added

to the preserved meat, may be ground after boiling and made into

dessert such as jam or pastillas (Pascuala, De Jesus, 1969, Know

Your Plant Foods).


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

Chapter III

METHODOLOGY

This chapter discusses the method of research used, the

steps in making jackfruit seeds flour, the procedures and

ingredients in baking cupcakes, and the method of data gathering.

Research Design

The experimental research design was used in this study. The

primary concern of this design is to measure progress by noting

the degree of change between what was and what is (Leuterio,

2006).

Respondents of the Study

The researchers purposively picked fifteen (15) faculty

members of CHMSC-Binalbagan Campus for the A.Y. 2016-2017 to be

the respondents of the study. A 9-Point Hedonic Scale Survey

Sheet was used to rate the product in terms of flavor, odor,

texture, color and general appearance.

Research Instrument

Following the method of Kroll (1998), Peryam and Girardot

(1952), Peryam and Pilgrim (1957), a 9-Point Hedonic Scale will


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

be used to describe the likings of the respondents to Jackfruit

Seeds Flour for Cupcakes. The 9-Point Hedonic Scale Survey Sheet

asked the respondents to rate on a scale of 1-9 their answers

using the psychological judgment as 1 which indicates “extremely

dislike” and 9 as “liked extremely”.

The respondents will be asked to eat, evaluate and rate the

first sample with 4:4 ratios of jackfruit seeds flour to

commercial flour according to flavor, odor, texture, color and

general appearance allowing their personal relative desirability.

The same process will be administered to the second and third

tests respectively. The respondents will be guided accordingly

until the completion of the survey. The 9-Point Hedonic Scale and

the categorical interpretations were presented below in Table

3.1.

Table 3.1 The 9-Point Hedonic Scale


9-Point Hedonic Categorical
Scale Interpretations
1 Dislike extremely
Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

2 Dislike very much


3 Dislike moderately
4 Dislike slightly
5 Neither like nor dislike
6 Like slightly
7 Like moderately
8 Like very much
9 Like extremely

Data Gathering Procedure

A letter of permission was given to the Executive Director

to conduct the study to 15 faculty members of CHMSC-Binalbagan

Campus in the A.Y. 2016-2017. When permission was granted, the

researchers administered the questionnaire at the available time

of the respondents.

During the administration of the questionnaire, the

researchers gave instructions to the respondents. The respondents

were asked to eat the cupcakes and evaluate the three tests based

on its flavor, texture, odor, color, and general appearance.

Steps in Making Jackfruit Seed Flour

The researchers collected fresh jackfruit seeds on market

places, houses, and fruit stands. After collecting the jackfruit

seeds, it was washed twice using running water and strained

afterwards. The washed seeds were weighed using a weighing scale.


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

Weighed seeds were then lye peeled between the hands while

washing it thoroughly under running water.

The seeds were sliced crosswise and placed over wire trays

and sun-dried for 3-5 days. After 3-5 days, the researchers

gathered the sun-dried seeds and grinded it using an electric

grinding machine.

Baking Cupcakes

In baking cupcakes, the researchers started by gathering all

the needed materials, tools, equipment and the ingredients which

are listed on the tables below.

Table 3.2 List of Ingredients


1 cup butter 2 tsp. salt
¾ cup sugar 3 tbsp baking powder
8 pcs eggs 2 can evaporated milk
1 cup cake flour 2 can condensed milk
3 cup Jackfruit Seed Flour 1 bar cheese grated
2 tbs vanilla 2 tsp cream of tartar

The ingredients stated above are doubled in order to make a

two-recipe batter mixture.

Table 3.3 Materials, Tools and


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

Equipment
Paper cupcake holder Electric mixer
Spatula Cheese grater
Basins Strainer
Spoons Cupcake trays
Measuring cups
Measuring spoons

In baking cupcakes, the researchers strained the baking

powder, salt, sugar, commercial flour and Jackfruit seeds flour.

Next, the egg white were separated from the yolk and set aside.

Creaming the butter while adding the egg yolks one at a time is

the next step. Then they stirred in half of the grated cheese,

evaporated milk and condensed milk. The sifted dry ingredients

were added then to make the batter mixture and mixed well.

The oven was the preheated to 375º F for 20-30 minutes. Next

the egg whites were mixed together with the cream of tartar until

stiff. The batter mixture was then added to the mixed egg whites.

Afterwards, the researchers lined the paper cupcake holder into

the baking pans, and spooned in with ¾ cup mixture and sprinkled

with grated cheese. The researchers then baked the cupcakes for

45 minutes.
Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

Chapter IV

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Based on the evaluation of the 9-Point Hedonic Scale Sheets

regarding the level of acceptability of jackfruit seeds flour of

3 different ratios for cupcakes, the table below (Table 4.1)

shows the results.

Table 4.1 Level of Acceptability of Jackfruit Seeds Flour of 3


Different Ratios for Cupcakes
GENERAL
APPEARANC
LEVEL FLAVOR ODOR TEXTURE COLOR E
MEA MEA MEA MEA IN
  N INT N INT N INT N T MEAN INT
TEST 1 7.1 7.4 7.4 7.9 LV
(4:4) 3 LM 0 LVM 0 LVM 3 M 7.67 LVM
TEST 2 7.8 7.6 7.6 8.2
(5:3) 0 LVM 0 LVM 0 LVM 0 LE 8.20 LE
TEST 3 8.0 7.8 7.9 8.2
(6:2) 0 LVM 0 LVM 3 LVM 7 LE 8.40 LE
Origin: LM – Like Moderately, LVM – Like Very Much, LE – Like
Extremely, INT – Interpretation
Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

Table 4.2 Range and Interpretation of Data


Range Interpretation
8.20 – 9.00 Like Extremely
7.40 – 8.19 Like Very Much
6.60 – 7.39 Like Moderately
5.80 – 6.59 Like Slightly
5.00 – 5.79 Like
4.20 – 4.99 Dislike
3.40 – 4.19 Dislike Slightly
2.60 – 3.39 Dislike Moderately
1.80 – 2.59 Dislike Very Much
1.00 – 1.79 Dislike Extremely

On test 1, with 4:4 ratios of jackfruit seeds flour to

commercial flour, in terms of flavor the respondents mean is 7.13

with an interpretation of like moderately. Among the three tests

the Test 1 (4:4) has the lowest mean. Test 3 (6:2) has the

highest mean of 8.00 and is interpreted as like very much when it

comes to flavor. The results implies that the mixture with higher

Jackfruit seed flour content is more flavorful than of those

which has lesser contents.

In terms of odor, Test 1 (4:4) has the lowest mean of 7.40

and is interpreted as and Test 3 (6:2) has the highest mean of

7.80. Both tests got the categorical interpretation of like very

much. The results suggests that the higher the ratio of Jackfruit

seeds flour, the more it affects the odor of the product.


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

In its texture, Test 1 (4:4) got the least value of 7.40 and

Test 3 (6:2) has the highest value of 7.93. Both tests got the

categorical interpretation of like very much. The results imply

that the cupcake made of higher Jackfruit seeds flour has a finer

and/or intact texture than of the one which has less Jackfruit

seeds flour content.

In terms of color, Test 1 (4:4) has the lowest mean of 7.93

with an interpretation of like very much. Test 3 (6:2) has the

highest mean of 8.27 among the three tests. The results infers

that the higher the Jackfruit seeds flour content, the higher the

possibility that the color will be affected and vice versa.

In its general appearance, the test that got the lowest mean

is Test 1 with a mean of 7.67 and a categorical interpretation of

like very much. Test 3 got the highest mean of 8.40 among the

three tests with a categorical interpretation of like extremely.

The results implies that Test 3 (6:2) is more attractive/eye

catching than the Test 1 (4:4).

The second objective of the study was to determine the

significant difference among the three tests namely: Test 1

(4:4), Test 2 (5:3) and Test 3 (6:2) ratios of Jackfruit seeds


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

flour to commercial flours in making cupcakes. Table 4.3 shows

the results of the objectives.

Table 4.3 significant difference of the variables and their

interpretations.

  F P - INTERPRETAT
VALU ION
E
FLAVOR 3.40 .043 SIGNIFICANT
2
ODOR .488 .617 NOT
SIGNIFICANT
TEXTURE 1.19 .312 NOT
9 SIGNIFICANT
COLOR .880 .422 NOT
SIGNIFICANT
GENERAL 5.22 .009 SIGNIFICANT
APPEARAN 3
CE

Table 4.3 shows the results of the significant differences

among variables of Jackfruit seeds flour for cupcakes. In terms

of flavor, the computed P-Value is .043 below the level of

significance which is 0.05. This means that there is a

significant difference among the three tests namely: Test 1

(4:4), Test 2 (5:3) and Test 3 (6:2) ratios of Jackfruit seeds

flour to commercial flours in making cupcakes. The table 4.4

below shows that the dependent variable which is the flavor is

more prevalent on Test 3.


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

Table 4.4 Post Hoc Test on Flavor

95%
Confide
nce
Interva
l
Depend Mean Uppe
ent (I) (J) Differe Std. r
Variab LEV LEV nce (I- Erro Sig Lower Boun
le EL EL J) r . Bound d
.
. .
2 -.66667 3479 -1.5496
172 2163
3
1
.
. .
3 -.86667 3479 -1.7496
055 0163
3
.
. 1.54
1 .66667 3479 -.2163
172 96
3
FLAVOR 2
.
. .
3 -.20000 3479 -1.0830
848 6830
3
.
. 1.74
1 .86667 3479 -.0163
055 96
3
3
.
. 1.08
2 .20000 3479 -.6830
848 30
3

In terms of odor, the computed P-Value is .617, which is

higher than the level of significance which is 0.05. This means


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

that there is no significant difference among the three tests

namely: Test 1 (4:4), Test 2 (5:3) and Test 3 (6:2) ratios of

Jackfruit seeds flour to commercial flours in making cupcakes.

In terms of texture, the computed P-Value as shown in Figure

4.3 is .422, which is higher than the level of significance which

is 0.05. This means that there is no significant difference among

the three tests namely: Test 1 (4:4), Test 2 (5:3) and Test 3

(6:2) ratios of Jackfruit seeds flour to commercial flours in

making cupcakes.

In terms of color, the computed P-Value is .422 which is

higher than the level of significance which is 0.05. This means

that there is no significant difference among the three tests

namely: Test 1 (4:4), Test 2 (5:3) and Test 3 (6:2) ratios of

Jackfruit seeds flour to commercial flours in making cupcakes.

In terms of its general appearance, the computed P-Value

is .009, which is below the 0.05 level of significance. This

means that there is a significant difference among the three

tests namely: Test 1 (4:4), Test 2 (5:3) and Test 3 (6:2) ratios

of Jackfruit seeds flour to commercial flours in making cupcakes.

Table 4.5 below shows that the dependent variable which is the

general appearance is more prevalent on Test 3.


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

Table 4.5 Post Hoc Test of General Appearance

95%
Confidence
Interval
Depende Mean Lowe Uppe
nt (I) (J) Differe Std. r r
Variabl LEV LEV nce (I- Erro Sig Boun Boun
e EL EL J) r . d d
. -
. .
2 -.53333 2345 1.12
087 0620
8 86
1
. -
. -.13
3 -.73333* 2345 1.32
012 80
8 86
.
. -.06 1.12
1 .53333 2345
General 087 20 86
8
Appeara 2
.
nce . -.79 .
3 -.20000 2345
697 53 3953
8
.
. . 1.32
1 .73333* 2345
012 1380 86
8
3
.
. -.39 .
2 .20000 2345
697 53 7953
8
Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

Findings of the Study

As reflected in the tables above, there is a significant

difference in terms of flavor and general appearance among three

tests namely: Test 1 (4:4), Test 2 (5:3) and Test 3 (6:2) ratios

of Jackfruit seeds flour to Commercial Flour. Both differences

are highly attributed to Test 3 (6:2) ratios of Jackfruit seeds

flour to commercial flour.

As shown above, there is no significant difference in terms

of texture, color and odor among three tests namely: Test 1

(4:4), Test 2 (5:3) and Test 3 (6:2) ratios of Jackfruit seeds

flour to Commercial Flour. Differences in ratios of Jackfruit

seeds flour to commercial flour never influenced the respondents’

personal relative desirability.


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

Chapter V

RECOMMENDATIONS

Based on the results of the study the following are being

recommended by the researchers:

1. New flavors should be applied to the recipe.

2. Future researchers may decorate the cupcakes to make it more

attractive and pleasing to the eyes.

3. Future researches should experiment on different ratios to

enhance the product.


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

4. Future researchers should experiment or research more on the

variables which results showed no significant differences.

References

Book References

Md. Shariful Islam, Rokeya Begum, Morshada Khatun, Kamalesh

Chandra Dey, A Study on Nutritional and Functional Properties

Analysis of Jackfruit Seed Flour and Value Addition to Biscuits,

Vol. 4 Issue 12, December-2015.

Dr. Edgar Chambers, IV, The 9-Point Hedonic Scale, Peryam & Kroll

Research Corporation, May 1998.

Vanna Tulyathan, Kanitha Tananuwong, Prapa Songjinda, Nongnuj

Jaiboon, Some Physicochemical Properties of Jackfruit


Republic of the Philippines
Carlos Hilado Memorial State College
Binalbagan Campus
Enclaro, Binalbagan, Negros Island Region

(Artocarpus heterophyllus Lam.) Seed Flour and Starch, Department

of Food Technology, Faculty of Science, Chulalongkorn University,

Thailand, August 2001.

Electronic References

http://paperheart1993.blogspot.com/2008/03/feasibility-of-grind-

jackfruit-seeds-as.html

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/286965912_Functional_pro

perties_of_jack_fruit_seed_flour

http://www.primaryinfo.com/scope/jackfruit-seed.html

APPENDICES

You might also like

pFad - Phonifier reborn

Pfad - The Proxy pFad of © 2024 Garber Painting. All rights reserved.

Note: This service is not intended for secure transactions such as banking, social media, email, or purchasing. Use at your own risk. We assume no liability whatsoever for broken pages.


Alternative Proxies:

Alternative Proxy

pFad Proxy

pFad v3 Proxy

pFad v4 Proxy