CHAPTER IV

PRESENTATION ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION

INTRODUCTION

This chapter contains detailed presentation and discussion of data analysis

and the cumulative results of the online survey that was conducted to the BSN

students of Pilar College of Zamboanga City Inc. This study aims to determine the

perceptions of the Nursing students towards their virtual learning experience. The

findings are presented using a tabular form and are segregated according to the

Statement of the Problem which are the following: A. Learning Modules, B. Delivery

of Instructions, C. Virtual Environment, and D. Class Discussions. The analytical

procedures are arranged according to the sequence of specific questions.

INTERPRETATION

The researchers used the four-point Likert Scale which is composed of

(4- Strongly Agree; 3- Agree; 2- Disagree; 1- Strongly Disagree) as choices.

Four-Point Likert Scale

Scale/Frequency Range Verbal Interpretation

1 1.00 - 1.50 Strongly Disagree

2 1.51 - 2.50 Disagree

3 2.51 - 3.50 Agree

4 3.51 - 4.00 Strongly Agree

40
Table 1: Interpretation of responses according to the Learning

Modules

Questions : Learning SA A D SD Weighted Verbal

Modules 4 3 2 1 Mean Interpretation
Frequency
The modules contain 14 53 9 2 3.01 Agree
relevant topics and has
enough number of activities
to answer by the students
The Nursing Students 44 26 5 3 3.42 Agree
consider the use of modules
as an advantage because
they can read it during their
free time or anytime they
want.
The use of colored pictures 50 19 5 4 3.47 Agree
and figures in the modules
of each course provides
good visual perception and
it enhances the learning of
the nursing students.
Overall Weighted Mean 3.3 Agree
Key: Strongly Disagree (R= 1.00-1.50), Disagree (R= 1.51-2.50), Agree (R=

2.51-3.50), Strongly Agree (R= 3.51-4.00)

Table 2: Interpretation of responses according to the Delivery of

Instructions

Questions : Delivery of SA A D SD Weighted Verbal

Instructions 4 3 2 1 Mean Interpretation
Frequency
The instructors are audible 22 40 12 4 3.02 Agree
during online classes and
the lessons are explained
and delivered clearly.
The instructors update the 23 43 10 2 3.12 Agree
nursing students about their
requirements regularly.
The unstable internet 66 9 0 3 3.77 Strongly
connectivity often causes Agree
the nursing students to

41
 misunderstand or mishear
what their instructor said
during online discussions.
Overall Weighted Mean 3.30 Agree
Key: Strongly Disagree (R= 1.00-1.50), Disagree (R= 1.51-2.50), Agree (R=

2.51-3.50), Strongly Agree (R= 3.51-4.00)

Table 3: Interpretation of responses according to the Virtual

Environment

Questions :Virtual SA A D SD Weighted Verbal

Environment 4 3 2 1 Mean Interpretation
Frequency
The instructors give 24 44 5 5 3.12 Agree
compliment to those
students who are able to
share their thoughts and
insights about the topics
that are being discussed.
The level of anxiety that the 33 33 8 4 3.22 Agree
students felt during the face
to face recitations and
reporting is at par with the
level of anxiety that they
also feel during virtual
recitations and reporting.
The Student nurses find the 5 36 28 9 2.47 Disagree
virtual environment
convenient and efficient
when it comes to lectures
and discussions.
Overall Weighted Mean 2.94 Agree
Key: Strongly Disagree (R= 1.00-1.50), Disagree (R= 1.51-2.50), Agree (R=

2.51-3.50), Strongly Agree (R= 3.51-4.00)

Table 4: Interpretation of responses according to the Class

Discussions

42
 Questions : Class SA A D SD Weighted Verbal
Discussions 4 3 2 1 Mean Interpretation
Frequency
The instructors give equal 15 53 8 2 3.04 Agree
opportunity to every student
to recite and answer the
questions during online
discussions.
The communication 42 32 4 0 3.49 Agree
problems due to poor
internet connectivity which
are commonly encountered
during virtual classes
usually arise from the
students than the
instructors.
The virtual class discussions 16 48 9 5 2.96 Agree
in the new normal allows
sufficient time for nursing
students to formulate their
thoughts/answers before
sharing them to the class.
Overall Weighted Mean 3.16 Agree
Key: Strongly Disagree (R= 1.00-1.50), Disagree (R= 1.51-2.50), Agree (R=
2.51-3.50), Strongly Agree (R= 3.51-4.00)

INTERPRETATION

In table 1, majority of the respondents agreed that learning modules

have appropriate contents and it contains sufficient number of activities

answerable by the nursing students. The table also implies that the

respondents also agreed that modules serves as an advantage for them as they

can read their lessons anytime they want. Lastly, the respondents evaluated

and they agreed that incorporating colored pictures and figures in the

modules provides them a clear visual perception and it enhances their

learning.

43
 In the study of Reyes and De Guia (2017), they concluded that tough

modules may be a great tool for learning it must obtain high acceptability,

validity and relevance. Hence, the lessons must be reliable, clear, appealing,

and original. . However, Cheating, plagiarism, and integrity in taking test

remains to be one of the biggest issues in ensuring quality online instruction

(Simonson et al, 2003). Similarly, in the study entitled ‘'Modern Based

Approach and Student's Achievement Literature,' by Ambayon (2020), he

stated that Learning Modules is more operative in teaching learning method

compared to usual teaching approaches because in this modular approach the

students learn at their own stride. It is unrestricted and self-learning. There is

instantaneous reinforcement, this allows stimulation to the students and it

can build curiosity in them. Similarly, Tohidi et. al (2019) also underscored

that incorporating anatomical parts and images of conditions in the modules

could help the students enhance their memory and understanding towards the

lesson.

In the table 2, majority of the respondents agreed that the instructors

are audible during online classes with lessons explained and delivered clearly.

Respondents evaluated and they agreed that instructors update the nursing

students about their requirements regularly. Finally, the respondents

evaluated and they strongly agreed that unstable internet connectivity can

alter the delivery of instructions during online discussions.

Similarly, in the study entitled ‘A comparative Analysis of the Student

Performance in an online vs. face-to-face environmental science course from

2009 to 2016’ by Paul and Jefferson (2019), It has been shown that during

virtual classes, the student needs uninterrupted internet connection. With

44
slow internet connectivity, students are unable to communicate, send

assignments, or access study materials if technical difficulties arise. As a result

of this problem, the student can become frustrated, perform poorly, and lose

interest in learning.

In table 3, the respondents agreed that Instructors give compliments to

students who are able to share their thoughts and insights about the topics

that are being discussed. Respondents also agreed that the level of anxiety that

students felt during the face to face recitations is the same as the level of

anxiety that they also feel during virtual recitations and reporting. Lastly, the

respondents evaluated and they disagreed that virtual environment is

convenient for lectures and discussions.

In a similar study conducted by Ajmal & Ahmad (2019), they revealed

that most of the students engaging in the virtual learning classes are still

capable of experiencing anxiety and nervousness during active discussions.

They underscored that students who often manifest anxiety during

discussions leave the meeting intentionally and exhibit speech difficulties. The

third statement in table 3 is further supported by a qualitative research

conducted by Gedera (2014), who underscored one of the main reasons why

students are attracted to virtual learning is for its flexibility, as it was fully

online and it enabled them to have flexibility in terms of time and place.

However, on a particular day when the internet connection is not stable, or in

the presence of any technical difficulties the student may not be able to

participate in serious lectures and class discussions.

In table 4, the respondents agreed that the instructors give them equal

opportunity to recite and express their thoughts during online discussions. It

45
can be inferred and the respondents agreed that the internet connectivity

issues usually arise from their connection and it has less incidence on the

instructors. Lastly, the result indicated that respondents agreed that virtual

class discussions allow ample time for nursing students to think about their

answers before sharing it to the class. Virtual class discussions permits them

to organize their thoughts before expressing it during the discussion.

Similarly, Gedera (2014) underscored that another advantage of virtual

classroom that supported students’ active participation was the ability to have

an oral discussion in real time right after each presentation. Having a

discussion after each presentation allowed the students to clarify issues

related to the topic immediately, as well as provide some peer feedback. The

third statement has similar findings to Yilmaz (2015), the study concluded

that virtual classroom provide a two-way interaction between the students and

the instructors. Though virtual classes are spontaneous, participants are able

to search for the terms on the internet while the other participants are still

answering compared to face-to-face classes (F2F).

46
 Chapter V

SUMMARY

Virtual learning is a learning experience that is enhanced through

utilizing computers and/or the internet both outside and inside the facilities of

the educational organization. The instruction most commonly takes place in

an online environment. The teaching activities are carried out online while the

educator and learners are physically separated. Due to the ongoing COVID-19

pandemic, the Commission on Higher Education along with the Department

of Education has prompted educational safety measures resulting in

formalized teaching and learning systems specifically designed to be carried

out remotely by using electronic communication.

The intention of the school is to increase the number of students

(reaching those that are far away), and its goal is to give quality education

despite of the ongoing pandemic. The Nursing Program of Pilar College of

Zamboanga City Inc. also utilized blended learning modality in the teaching-

learning process. To deliver quality education, the program opted for modular

learning and virtual meeting. The main focus of this research study was to find

out the perceptions of the student nurses of Pilar College of Zamboanga City,

Inc. towards Virtual Learning Experience. The study focused on the

perceptions of nursing students towards Virtual learning experience as to the:

• Learning Modules

• Delivery of Instructions

• Virtual Environment

• Class Discussion
47
 The respondents of the study were the nursing students of Pilar College

of Zamboanga City, Inc. who are officially enrolled in the academic year 2020-

2021. The number of the respondents was 78 which is roughly 22% of the total

population of nursing students, derived using the Slovin’s formula with 10% as

the margin of error. The respondents are from the level one, level two, level

three, and level four. The researchers used the quantitative research method

in interpreting the results of the study. The research instrument used in

gathering the necessary data was a 12-item survey form that was created using

Google Forms. The researchers used a non-probability sampling, specifically,

the convenience sampling method in collecting data from the respondents as

this allowed a fast collection of comprehensive data.

CONCLUSION

Based from the findings of the study, the researchers hereby offer the

following conclusions:

The learning modules provided by the instructors offer abundant help

to nursing students as they contain useful, relevant and credible topics

incorporated with sufficient number of activities that can be answered by the

students at the back of each learning modules. Based on the perceptions of the

respondents, learning modules are a great advantage because this can be used

along with other nursing related books and it already contains summarized

lessons that may not be well understood by the students if they read it on the

actual book. In addition, they can read the modules in the most convenient

time possible which is also considered to be an advantage for their continuous

learning despite of the current shift of nursing education in the country. The

learning modules can be a good temporary substitute of other nursing books

48
for students who cannot purchase or avail the actual book and since most of

the contents are all based on the textbooks and other credible websites as per

instructor’s choice, the students may still use them after graduation in

preparation for the Nursing Licensure Examination. Furthermore, the

students can write side notes on the learning modules which they perceive to

be a useful information. The visual perceptions of the nursing students are

stimulated by the integration of colored images, tables and figures in the

learning modules of individual courses. It helps them to understand the

concept and it provides a mental image of what a certain condition looks like.

Tables and figures are proven to be useful for quick memorization of terms

and values that are needed to be mastered by the students.

The delivery of Instructions are perceived by the students to be audibly

clear during online classes. The instructors discuss the lessons clearly most of

the time and the students encounter minimal inconvenience on the

instructor’s connection. However, there were several instances in which the

entire city has experienced a city-wide internet curtailment which halted some

online classes and this can no longer be controlled by the students, instructors

and the institution. There are also occasions where instructors result in

sending their announcements and instructions via phone calls and text

messages to compensate for the unstable internet connectivity or if power

interruption has occurred before the class or in the middle of the discussion.

The students are receiving constant reminders from their instructors

regarding their requirements and consideration for late submissions are often

applied by the instructors more often compared to the traditional face to face

classes. Unstable internet connectivity disrupts the communication between

49
the students and their instructors. The respondents perceived that slow

internet signals prevent them from understanding the concept of the lesson

that is being discussed by the instructor during that particular time.

Therefore, delivery of instructions is highly dependent upon the strength of

individual’s internet connectivity. This also involves the compensatory

measures that both instructors and nursing students take in order for them to

somehow maintain communication with each other.

The virtual interactions during online classes creates an environment

where student nurses still receive compliments from their instructors similar

to the traditional F2F classes. The student nurses are able to share their

thoughts and insights in an environment where there is less judgment and

fear of embarrassment. However, the anxiety that is inflicted by the virtual

recitations and reporting is still the same as the traditional F2F classes.

Therefore, anxiety levels remain unaffected and the same to students who are

being called for virtual recitations and reporting. The respondents perceived

the virtual environment to be less convenient for presentation of lectures and

discussions. Therefore, despite the good feedbacks on how the virtual

environment is during virtual classes the respondents still prefer the F2F

interaction for presentation of lectures and discussions.

The class discussions, given the advantages and resources of this rich

learning environment; it still allowed nursing students to exchange ideas and

information through virtual discussions which are typically followed by

recitations, the students were given equal opportunity by their instructors to

recite and to answer based on their capacity. Since the start of the school year,

embarrassment from recitation which commonly occurs during F2F classes

50
were lessened and students are now determined to recite because they are not

prohibited to search for answers on the internet during recitations and most of

the answers are found in the learning modules. The institution still maintains

its ability to provide fast internet connectivity to the instructors as most of the

connectivity problems encountered during online classes arise from the

students.

Lastly, discussions which are held virtually provided the students

ample time to formulate their answers before even sharing them to the class.

Virtual class software like Google Meet which is mainly used by the BSN

program offers a ‘Raise Hand’ feature which helps the instructor call the

names of those who are ready to recite. Those who are still formulating their

answers may raise their hand later on; thus, virtual class discussions

diminishes the instances of biased selection of students during discussions

and recitations.

RECOMMENDATIONS

Based on the results of this study the following recommendations were

provided:

Learning Modules

• Learning Modules must contain less printing errors and should contain

consistent numbers of activities to answer by the students. The modules must

also be distributed to the students following the regular schedule of returning

the activities that were answered by the students.

51
• Students should create a daily schedule in reading and answering the

activities in the modules in the most convenient time possible to avoid

conflicts with their daily tasks.

• The utilization of colored images and figures on the modules in each courses

must be consistently maintained all throughout the school year to ensure good

visual perception and understanding to the students.

Delivery of Instructions

• The administration should provide the instructors proper teaching materials

which they can use in schools or when working at home. The instructors

should only use high quality headphones to deliver the best audio quality to

the students during discussions.

• The instructors must consistently remind the students by posting detailed

information of various instructions in the Google Classroom. The post must

contain the activity number and the due date of the task to remind the

students of their responsibilities and the last date of submission.

• The students in the succeeding school year should already have a stable

internet connectivity at all times if possible to be able to understand the

discussions and catch up with the requirements. Their gadgets should

preferably support 4G or 5G connectivity to allow fast transmission of data

connection during virtual classes.

Virtual Environment

• The instructors should not be bias when choosing students to answer during

recitations. They must continue to give compliments to the students who are

52
speaking up to uplift their morale and encourage them to listen all throughout

the class.

• The instructors should provide enough time for students to familiarize the

lessons in recitations and reporting. To the students, they must prepare ahead

of time by doing advanced reading sessions to be familiar with the next lesson.

• For the nursing students, to be able to succeed in online class, they should be

given enough time to fully adapt in the virtual environment until the time

comes when they can no longer discriminate the difference between virtual

presentation and F2F presentation. Instructors should keep in mind that

online learners need program orientation and course orientation before

getting started.

Class Discussions

• The instructors should be consistent in giving fair chances to every student

to speak and deliver their answers during the virtual discussions. They are

encouraged to make the discussions interactive, spontaneous but in a less

stress-provoking way.

• The students should also do their part in ensuring a constant and strong

internet connection to promote a good communication between their

instructors and to avoid frequent disconnection during class discussions.

• To the instructors, avoid discouraging students when they cannot express

their thoughts accurately during class discussions. They are encouraged not to

compare students instead, instructors must commend those students who

tried their best in answering and explaining their thoughts during the

discussions.

53
Appendices

PILAR COLLEGE OF ZAMBOANGA CITY, INC

R.T. Lim Boulevard, Zamboanga City
Tertiary Education Department
Nursing Program

January 4, 2021

S. Ma. DivinaConsejo E. Billanes, RVM

BSN, Program Head
Pilar College of Zamboanga City, Inc.
Dear Sister Divine,
Praised be Jesus and Mary!
The undersigned are the 3 rd year BSN students of Pilar College of Zamboanga
City, Inc. undertaking a research entitled “NURSING STUDENTS’
PERCEPTION TOWARDS VIRTUAL LEARNING” In Partial Fulfilment of the
Requirements for Nursing Research I.
The researchers are humbly asking your permission to validate the attached
self-made questionnaire/survey statements for the study. Attached on the
second page is the Statement of the Problem of this research. With your
expertise, the undersigned are requesting for you to review if the statements in
the questionnaire would fit to the statement of the problem. The researchers
are looking forward to your positive response.
Thank you and more power!
Respectfully yours,
Members:
VHINCE NORBEN C. PISCO
DAISY WALDA J. ABDURAJAN
RYAN BOY V. DEL PRADO
JOHAR S. KALBI
MARVIE THERESE E. PORTUITO
KRYSTAL JANE B. SALINAS

54
Noted:
S. Ma. DivinaConsejo E. Billanes, RVM
BSN, Program Head

Pilar College of Zamboanga City, Inc.

R.T Lim Boulevard Zamboanga City
Tertiary Education Department

January 4, 2021
Mr. Edmund V. Enopia, MIT
Bachelor of Science in Information Technology Program Dean
Pilar College of Zamboanga City, Inc.
Dear Mr. Enopia,
Praised be Jesus and Mary!
The undersigned are the 3 rd year BSN students of Pilar College of Zamboanga
City, Inc. undertaking a research entitled “NURSING STUDENTS’
PERCEPTION TOWARDS VIRTUAL LEARNING” In Partial Fulfilment
of the Requirements for Nursing Research I.
The researchers are humbly asking your permission to validate the attached
self-made questionnaire/survey statements for the study. Attached on the
second page is the Statement of the Problem of this research. With your
expertise, the undersigned are requesting for you to review if the statements in
the questionnaire would fit to the statement of the problem. The researchers
are looking forward to your positive response.
Thank you and more power!
Respectfully yours,
Members:
VHINCE NORBEN C. PISCO
DAISY WALDA J. ABDURAJAN
RYAN BOY V. DEL PRADO
JOHAR S. KALBI
MARVIE THERESE E. PORTUITO
KRYSTAL JANE B. SALINAS

55
Noted:
Mr. Edmund V. Enopia
Bachelor of Science in Information Technology Program Dean

Pilar College of Zamboanga City, Inc.

R.T Lim Boulevard Zamboanga City
Tertiary Education Department

January 4, 2021
Mrs. Nerissa M. Manalo, MAED
Bachelor of Elementary Education Program Dean
Pilar College of Zamboanga City, Inc.

Dear Mrs. Manalo,

Praised be Jesus and Mary!
The undersigned are the 3 rd year BSN students of Pilar College of Zamboanga
City, Inc. undertaking a research entitled “NURSING STUDENTS’
PERCEPTION TOWARDS VIRTUAL LEARNING” In Partial Fulfilment
of the Requirements for Nursing Research I.
The researchers are humbly asking your permission to validate the attached
self-made questionnaire/survey statements for the study. Attached on the
second page is the Statement of the Problem of this research. With your
expertise, the undersigned are requesting for you to review if the statements in
the questionnaire would fit to the statement of the problem. The researchers
are looking forward to your positive response.
Thank you and more power!
Respectfully yours,
Members:
VHINCE NORBEN C. PISCO
DAISY WALDA J. ABDURAJAN
RYAN BOY V. DEL PRADO
JOHAR S. KALBI
MARVIE THERESE E. PORTUITO
KRYSTAL JANE B. SALINAS

56
Noted:
Mrs. Nerissa M. Manalo
Bachelor of Elementary Education Program Dean
Pilar College of Zamboanga City, Inc.
R.T Lim Boulevard Zamboanga City
Tertiary Education Department

Dear Respondent/s

Praised be Jesus and Mary!

The ongoing pandemic has affected the delivery of education world-

wide. It altered the educational system and institutions have to quickly adapt
to the changes imposed by the Commission on Higher Education (CHED).
Pilar College of Zamboanga City, Inc. has implemented blended learning to
ensure the continuity of education of the students. In partial-fulfilment of the
requirements in Nursing Research I, the researchers conducted a study
entitled “NURSING STUDENTS’ PERCEPTION TOWARDS VIRTUAL
LEARNING EXPERIENCE.”

In line with this, the researchers would like to ask for your participation
in answering the online survey. The researchers will treat your response with
utmost confidentiality and you have the right not to provide your name. Your
participation is highly appreciated.

Please select your response before proceeding to the survey form.

I allow myself to voluntarily fill-up and answer this survey as honest as I can.

I do not want to participate in this online survey.

Noted:

57
Mrs. Josefina B. Malindog
Nursing Research I Professor

Pilar College of Zamboanga City, Inc.

R.T Lim Boulevard Zamboanga City
Tertiary Education Department

Instructions: Read each statement carefully and select the answer that best
suits your opinion. Only one answer is accepted.

Question Strongly Agre Disagre Strongly

Agree e e Disagree
MODULES

1. The modules contain relevant topics

and has enough number of activities to
answer by the students.
2. The nursing students consider the
use of modules as an advantage
because they can read it during their
free time or anytime they want.
3. The use of colored pictures and
figures in the modules of each course
provide good visual perception and it
enhances the learning of the nursing
students.
DELIVERY OF INSTRUCTIONS

4. The instructors are audible during

online classes and the lessons are
explained and delivered clearly.
5. The instructors update the nursing
students about their requirements
regularly.
6. The unstable internet connectivity
often cause the nursing students to
misunderstand or mishear what their
instructor said during online

58
discussions.
VIRTUAL ENVIRONMENT

7. The instructors give compliment to

those students who are able to share
their thoughts and insights about the
topics that are being discussed.
8. The level of anxiety that the
students felt during the face to face
recitations and reporting is at par with
the level of anxiety that they also feel
during virtual recitations and
reporting.
9. The Student nurses find the virtual
environment to be convenient and
efficient when it comes to lectures and
discussions.
CLASS DISCUSSION

10. The instructors give equal

opportunity to every student to recite
and answer the questions during
online discussions.
11. The communication problem due
to poor internet connectivity which are
commonly encountered during virtual
classes usually arise from the students
than the instructors.
12. The virtual class discussions in the
new normal allows sufficient time for
nursing students to formulate their
thoughts/answers before sharing them
to the class.

59
References:

Ali, W. G. (2016). Nursing Students’ Readiness for e-Learning Experience.

GynecolObstet (Sunnyvale) 6: 388.

Allen, I. E., & Seaman, J. (2003). Sizing the opportunity: The quality and

extent of online

EducationintheUnitedstates.http://sloanconsortium.org/publications/surve

y/sizing_the_opportunity2003

Al-Shuaibi, A. (2014). The Importance of Education

https://www.researchgate.net/-

publication/260075970_The_Importance_of_Education

Arkorful, V., &Abaidoo, N. (2015). The role of E-learning, advantages and

disadvantages of its adoption in higher education. International Journal of

Instructional Technology and Distance Learning, 12(1), 29-42.

https://www.itdl.org/Journal/Jan_15/Jan15.pdf

Baticulon, R, Alberto, N. R., Baron, M. R., Mabulay, R. E., Rizada, L. G., Sy,

J. J., Tiu, C. J. S., Clarion, C., (2020). Barriers to Online Learning in the

Time of Covid-19: A National Survey of Medical Students in the Philippines.

Bakerson, M., Trottier, T., & Mansfield, M. (2015). Assessment in Online and

Blended Learning Environments (S. Koc, X. Liu, & P. Wachira, (eds.)).

Information Age Publishing Inc. https://mafiadoc.com/assessment-in-

online-and-blended-learning _597c735917

60
Banna, J., Lin, M. F. G., Stewart, M., &Fialkowski, M. K. (2015). Interaction

matters: Strategies to promote engaged learning in an online introductory

nutrition course. Journal of Online Learning and Teaching, 11(2), 249.

Bettinger, E., & Susanna, L. (2017). Promises and pitfalls of online education.

Evidence Speaks

Reports,2(15),24.http://www.k12accountability.org/resources/OnlineEduca

tion/Promises_and_Pitfalls_of_Online_Ed.pdf

Bower, M., Dalgarno, B., Kennedy, G. E., Lee, M. J., & Kenney, J. (2015).

Design and Implementation Factors in Blended Synchronous Learning

Environments: Outcomes

fromCrosscaseAnalysis.Computers&Education,86,117.https://doi.org/https:

//doi.org/10.1016/j.compedu.2015.03.00623ddb28e0735fb.html

Britt, M., Goon, D., & Timmerman, M. (2015). How to better engage online

students with online strategies. College Student Journal, 49(3), 399–404.

Chua, R, E., Sibbaluca, B.G., Miranda, R.D., Palmario, G.B., Moreno, R.P., &

Solon, J. P.T., (2020). The Status of the Implementation of the E-Learning

Classroom in Selected Higher Education Institutions in Region IV-A Amidst

the COVID-19 Crisis. Journal of Critical Reviews, 7(11).

Dabbagh, N., &Bannan-Ritland, B. (2005). Online learning: Concepts,

strategies and

applications.Peason/Merill/PrenticeHall.http://schoolar.google.com/schola

r?

hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=online+learning+strategies&oq=#d=gs_qabs&u=

%23p%DEmzTLyJQBToJ

61
Dennon, A. (2020). Coronavirus Impacts on Students and Online Learning.

Best Colleges.

Dhawan, S. (2020). Online Learning: A Panacea in the time of COVID-19

Crisis. Journal of Education Technology System, 49(1), 5-22.

El-Sofany, H. F., & El-Haggar, N. (2020). The Effectiveness of Using Mobile

Learning Techniques to Improve Learning Outcomes in Higher Education.

International Journal of Interactive Mobile Technologies, 5.

Gagnon, M. (2019). Effects of E-learning in a continuing Education Context

on Nursing Education: Systematic Review of Systematic Qualitative,

Quantitative, and Mixed studies Reviews.

https://www.jmir.org/2019/10/e15118/

Garrison, D. R. (2017). E-Learning in the 21st Century: A Community of

Inquiry Framework for Research and Practice (3rd Edition). London:

Routledge/Taylor and Francis

Giarla, A. (2017). The benefits of blended learning. teachthought. Available:

http://www.teachthought.com/learning/blended-flipped-learning/the-

benefits-of-blended-learning/

KANEMATSU, D. M. (2020). Teaching During the COVID-19 Pandemic. 2.

Kentnor, H. E. (2015). Distance Education and the Evolution of Online

Learning in the United States. In H. E. Kentnor. Denver,USA: Information

Age Publishing.

62
Landrum, B., Bannister, J., Garza, G., &Rhame, S. (2020). A Class of One:

Students’ Satisfaction with Online Learning. Journal of Education for

Business, 0(0), 1–7. https://doi.org/10.1080/08832323.2020.1757592

Martin, F. &Bolliger, D.U. (2018). Engagement matters: Student perceptions

on the importance of engagement strategies in the online learning

environment. Online Learning, 22(1), 205- 222. doi:10.24059/olj.v22i1.1092

https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1179659.pdf

McKenzie, K & Murray, A (2010) How e-learning can enhance learning

opportunities in nurse education. Nursing Times; 106: 5, Early Online

Publication

Means, B., Yukie, T., Murphy, R., Bakia, M., & Jones, K. (2016). Evaluation

of Evidence-Based Practices in Online Learning: A Meta-Analysis and

Review of Online Studies. Washington, D.C.

Mobo, F. D, &Sabado, G. (2019). An assessment of the Effectiveness of E-

Learning in AMA Olongapo Campus. Oriental Journal of Computer Science

and Technology, 12.

Morcillio et al., (2020).Experiences of Nursing Students during the Abrupt

Change from Face-to-Face to e-Learning Education during the First Month

of Confinement Due to COVID-19 in Spain. International journal of

Environmental research and public health. p.15

Munalim, L. (2020). Column: COVID19, online classes, & Transactional

Distance

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/339899810_Column_COVID19

_online_classes_transactional_distance
63
Nambiar, D. (2020). The impact of online learning during COVID-19:

students’ and teachers’ perspective. The International Journal of Indian

Psychology, 8(2), 784-793. 10.25215/0802.094

Nguyen, T. (2015). The Effectiveness of Online Learning: Beyond no

Significant Difference and Future Horizons. MERLOT Journal of Online

Learning and Teaching, 11(2), 309–329.

https://jolt.merlot.org/Vol11no2/Nguyen_0615.pdf

Peter et al.(2006). E-Learning in nursing education-Challenges and

opportunities. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17102285/

Popa, D., Repanovici, A., Lupu, D., Norel, M., &Coman, C. (2020). Using

Mixed Methods to Understand Teaching and Learning in COVID 19 Times.

Sustainability, 12(20), 1-20. https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/12/20/8726

Reynato, A. D., Kim, S., Song, J.-G., & So, W. (2007, November). A Study on

E-Learning for Philippines. International Journal of Multimedia and

Ubiquitous

Engineering.November14,2020,from=https://www.researchgate.net/public

ation/229052306_A_Study_on_e-Learning_for_Philippines

Richardson, J. C., Arbaugh, J. B., Cleveland-Innes, M., Ice, P., Swan, K. P., &

Garrison, D. R. (2012). Using the Community of Inquiry framework to

inform effective instructional design. In L. Moller & J. B. Huett (Eds), The

next generation of distance education: Unconstrained learning (pp. 95-125).

Boston, MA: Springer.

64
Rios, T. (2019). THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN STUDENTS’

PERSONALITIES AND THEIR PERCEPTION OF ONLINE. Journal of

Educators Online, 1.

Stern, J. (2015). What is Online Learning? Introduction to Online Teaching

and Learning, 1-2.

Smith, C., Hoderi, M., &Mcdermott, W. (2019). A Preliminary Study of

Students Perception and Learning from Different Delivery Methods.

Academy of Educational Leadership Journal, 23(2), 1C

Thomson, L. D. (2010). Beyond the Classroom Walls: Teachers’ and Students’

Perspectives on How Online Learning Can Meet the Needs of Gifted

Students. Journal ofAdvancedAcademics, 21(4),

662712.http://joa.sagepub.com.pluma.sjfc.edu/content/21/4/662.full.pdf+ht

ml

Thongsri, N., Shen, L., &Yukun, B. (2019). Investigating factors affecting

learner’s perception toward online learning: evidence from ClassStart

application in Thailand. Behavior and Infromation Technology, 8.

Tria, J.Z. (2020). The COVID-19 Pandemic through the Lens of Education in

the Philippines: The New Normal. International Journal of Pedagogical

Development and Lifelong Learning, 1(1), ep2001.

You, J. W. & Kang, M. (2014) The role of academic emotions in the

relationship between perceived academic control and self-regulated learning

in online learning. Computers & Education, 77,

65
Zacharis, N. (2015). A multivariate approach to predicting student outcomes

in web-enabled blended learning courses. Internet High Educ, 27, 44–53.

Article. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.iheduc.2015.05.002ng outcomes.

Zayapragassarazan, Z. (2020). COVID-19 : Strategies for Online

Engagement of Remote Learners. Jawaharlal Institute of Postgraduate

Medical Education and Research (JIPMER), 9(246), 1–11.

https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.7490/f1000research.1117835.1

66