10 .

Reviewers comment
Reviewing place: Seminar room
Date of review: 24/07/2021GC.
Reviewer 1:
Name: Dr Tefera Terefe
Academic Rank: Assistant Professor
Field/ Specialization: Power and Control Engineering
Faculty: Electrical Power and Control Engineering Department
Address: Adama, Ethiopia
Institution: Adama Science and Technology University
E-Mail: tefera06@gmail.com
Phone. No: +251 912 305301

Comments:
 Instead of Advanced Electrical Machine Design-EEng 6021, recommend Design and
Modelling of Electrical Machines.
 Instead of Advanced Research methods- EEng 7061, recommend Scientific Research
Methods
 Trying to make advancements in Advanced Power System Analysis and Simulation
with inclusion Computer-Aided Power Flow Analysis, contingency analysis, network
matrix is good one.
 Instead of Advanced Power System Protection, Advanced Power System Protection
and Switch Gear is recommend.
 Instead of Renewable Energy and Micro Grid Technologies, it is better to make
Micro Grid Technologies and Distributed Generation.
 Only two courses in Elective II- in Energy Informatics is less. Pls try to incorporate
more
 Assigning 2 Cr. Hr. on Linear and Non-Linear Systems Theory- EEng 6031seems not
sufficient. In addition, 14 Crs.(5 courses) On 1st sem.,and 16 Cr.Hr (6 courses) in 2nd
sem.is that possible beyond 12 Cr.Hr.? Max Cr.Hr/semester?
 Advanced Power System Protection to be elective rather than being main one.
 Increase the no.of elective course so that students can have more freedom. In your
case, only one in each semester.
 Course coding is not explained or known. What does 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th letter indicate?
 Only 1 course in Module 03: Linear and Non-linear Systems Theory doesn’t look
appropriate. May be include with others or add more. Stochastic and Random
Processes.
 Recommend the naming of Artificial Intelligence and its Applications in power
system.
 Recommend to include Switchgears as one chapter (6) in course Advanced Power
System Protection and also include zones of protection in one of the chapters (3)
  Recommend Seminar and Thesis to be after main modules like module 02 or 03 not
in module 6 w/c is just after elective modules.

Reviewer 2:
Name: Dr.Teshome Goa
Academic Rank: Assistant Professor
Faculty: Electrical and Computer Engineering
Field/ Specialization: Power Engineering
Address: Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
Institution: Addis Ababa Science and Technology University
E-Mail: tesh.goa95@gmail.com/, teshome.goa@aastu.edu.et
Phone. No: +251922682169

Comments:
I.Advanced Electrical Machine Design, needs discussion and amendment
recommended to merge the electrical machine drive with this course if possible.
II. High Voltage Engineering, recommended to be replaced by Advanced power
system operation and control then HV engineering can be moved to the elective
courses
III. Advanced Power System Protection recommended to be replaced by advanced
power system planning and reliability and this course can be given as an elective
course.
 Advanced Power System Analysis and Simulation, the course content:
A. chapter one Computer aided power flow analysis it’s recommended to add the
Comparison of the Gauss–Seidel, Newton–Raphson and Fast Decoupled Methods of
Load Flow Stud
B. chapter two: considering the advance course, the content regarding the solution of
OPF needs revision and given by; OPF Formulation: Economic Load Dispatch,
Optimal Reactive Power Dispatch (ORPD) , Economic Emission Dispatch (EED)
Security Constrained OPF (SCOPF) OPF Solution Technique: Lagrange Multiplier
Method ; Linear Programming OPF (LPOPF), Interior Point Method
Reviewer 3:.
Name: Dr.Milkias Berhanu
Academic Rank: Assistant Professor
Field/ Specialization: Power and Control Engineering
Faculty: Electrical Power and Control Engineering Department
Address: Adama, Ethiopia
Institution: Adama Science and Technology University
E-Mail: milkiasber@gmail.com
Phone. No: +251912122945

Comments:
  Smart Grid Technology and Communication Technology in Smart Grid have
to be merged because Smart grid technology is all about efficient extraction
and control of energy sources, smart metering, and more communication
activities with different network protocol from the existing internet protocol.
Recommend to remove the course “Communication Technology in Smart
Grid” and enrich the contents of smart grid technology.
 Distributed Generation and Micro grids Control this subject important for
energy informatics graduates because the success of smart grid technology
depends also on the efficient extraction, control and integration of micro grids.
 Renewable Energy and Micro Grid Technologies: The contents for the
renewable energy part are covered at UG level in most of the universities in
the country. It may sound good if the modelling and control techniques for the
corresponding energy sources are incorporated apart from sizing and selection
activities. Other renewable energy sources utilization, extraction, sizing,
modelling activities are missing like “Biomass Energy, Geothermal Energy,
Nuclear Energy,. And one important element missing is Energy Storage
Technologies”. The contents about DG seem good and in enriched it will be
more nice. Recommend to rename the course as “DG and Microgrids Control”
.
Curriculum Workshop Chairperson:
Name: Getnet Tadesse Ayele (PhD)
Academic Rank: Assistant Professor
Faculty: Faculty of Electrical and Computer Engineering
Field/ Specialization: Power system Engineering
Address: BahirDar, Ethiopia
Institution: BahirDar Institute of Technology
E-Mail: aytadget@gmail.com
Phone. No: +251948438338

Curriculum Workshop Reporter: