A Project On Analysis of Ulips in India
A Project On Analysis of Ulips in India
A Project On Analysis of Ulips in India
CHAPTER-1
INTRODUCTION
In the commercial arena, the choice of an effective strategy is perhaps the most
important and the toughest decision to take. The decision to select among the grand
strategies and deciding upon which strategy will best meet the enterprise’s
objectives is rendered complex by multiple considerations.
The same is also true with the insurance companies in India who are constantly
revamping their strategies and coming out with innovative options to stay in the
competition. There were days when Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) was
the only insurance company available to people in India and where people
synonymised Insurance to LIC. Also since it was a Public Sector Undertaking
(PSU) it has a great support from people. But now times have changed a lot of
private players have entered into the fray. There have been a lot of Indian
companies collaborating with foreign insurance giants like ICICI Prudential, Bajaj
Allianz etc who have already made their presence felt in the Indian Insurance
industry.
Even though LIC is still the market leader with more than over 60% of the market
share, the private players are giving it a tough time. Since the last decade the
market share of LIC had fallen down by about more than 20%.
The new private players have started offering a variety of unlimited schemes right
from insurance plans for a 30 day old baby to that of a 70 year old senior citizen.
Also the private companies have started creating the importance and need of
1
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
insurance in today’s life. They have started positioning their brands and are
marketing their products in such a way the people have started feeling the need of
security in their lives.
Taking into account the huge population and growing per capita income besides
several other driving factors, a huge opportunity is in store for the insurance
companies in India. According to the latest research findings, nearly 80% of Indian
population are without life insurance cover while health insurance and non-life
insurance continues to be below international standards. And this part of the
population is also subjected to weak social security and pension systems with
hardly any old age income security. As per our findings, insurance in India is
primarily used
as a means to improve personal finances and for income tax planning; Indians have
a tendency to invest in properties and gold followed by bank deposits. They
selectively invest in shares also but the percentage is very small (4-5%). This in
itself is an indicator that growth potential for the insurance sector is immense. It's a
business growing at the rate of 15-20% per annum and presently is of the order of
around more than $55 billion.
India is a vast market for life insurance that is directly proportional to the growth in
premiums and an increase in life density. With the entry of private sector players
backed by foreign expertise, Indian insurance market has become more vibrant.
2
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
heavy hand of government still dominates the market, with price controls, limits on
ownership, and other restraints. They private players are still in their initial days
and would take some more time to capture a good market share. At present they
are coming up with new and innovative ideas.
Since the last decade the life insurance industry in India has been growing very fast
and many new companies have entered this business insurance. The Indian life
insurance industry has recorded a robust growth of more than 16 % for the nine-
month period which ended on December 31, 2009.It is expected to grow at an
amazing rate of 20 per cent this year Also in the present scenario the most sought
after insurance plans are the Unit Linked insurance Plans (ULIPs).
Unit-linked insurance plans, ULIPs, are distinct from the more familiar ‘with
profits’ policies sold for decades by the Life Insurance Corporation. ‘With profits’
policies are called so because investment gains (profits) are distributed to
policyholders in the form of a bonus announced every year.
3
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
ULIPs also serve the same function of providing insurance protection against death
and provision of long-term savings, but they are structured differently. In ‘with
profits’ policies, the insurance company credits the premium to a common pool
called the ‘life fund,’ after setting aside funds for the risk premium on life
insurance and management expenses.
Every year, the insurer calculates how much has to be paid to settle death and
maturity claims. The surplus in the life fund left after meeting these liabilities is
credited to policyholders’ accounts in the form of a bonus. In a ULIP too, the
insurer deducts charges towards life insurance (mortality charges), administration
charges and fund management charges.
The rest of the premium is used to invest in a fund that invests money in stocks or
bonds. The policyholder’s share in the fund is represented by the number of units.
The value of the unit is determined by the total value of all the investments made
by the fund divided by the number of units. If the insurance company offers a
range of funds, the insured can direct the company to invest in the fund of his
choice. Insurers usually offer three
choices — an equity (growth) fund, balanced fund and a fund which invests in
bonds. In both ‘with profits’ policies as well as unit-linked policies, a large part of
the first year premium goes towards paying the agents’ commissions.
ULIPs offer the kind of flexibility that no insurance product can. ULIPs essentially
combine the benefits of an insurance policy and a market-linked investment.
Investors can select a ULIP with an equity-debt combination that is in line with
their risk profile. A risk-taking investor would typically select one with a high
equity component, while a risk-averse investor would opt for a debt-heavy one.
4
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
Simply put, ULIPs are structured in such a way that the protection element and the
savings element are distinguishable, and hence managed according to your specific
needs. In this way, the ULIP plan offers unprecedented flexibility and
transparency.
So with many players around for a company to really be successful it has to really
be very efficient on all fronts. It has to constantly adapt to the changing consumer
preferences with a lot of new innovations and implementing new technology try
to different from the lot. Especially if it is a new player in the market the company
has to really work very hard to get into the completion and stay afloat.
The investment is denoted as unit and is represented by the value that it has
attained called as Net Asset Value (NAV). ULIP came into play in 1960s and
became very popular in Western Europe and America. The reason that is attributed
to the wide spread popularity of ULIP is because of the transparency and the
flexibility which it offers to the clients.
As time progressed the plans were also successfully mapped along with life
insurance needs to retirement planning. In today’s times ULIP provides solution
for all the needs of a client like insurance planning, financial needs, financial
planning for children’s future and retirement planning.
5
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
ULIPS as the name suggests are directly linked with the investments made by the
insured. Though he does not have a direct say in this but he does offer his choice in
the form of investment. With stock markets soaring high a few months back,
ULIPs were offering a good rate of return, but now with a sudden downfall of the
stocks, ULIPs are bound to become negative investments.
6
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
CHAPTER-2
TOPIC ANALYSIS
INSURANCE
Insurance may be described as a social device to reduce or eliminate risk of loss to
life and property. Under the plan of insurance, a large number of people associate
themselves by sharing risks attached to individuals. The risks which can be insured
against include fire, the perils of sea, death and accidents and burglary. Any risk
contingent upon these, may be insured against at a premium commensurate with
the risk involved. Thus collective bearing of risk is insurance.
CHARACTERISTICS OF INSURANCE
1. Sharing of risks
2. Cooperative device
3. Evaluation of risk
4. Payment on happening of a special event
5. The amount of payment depends on the nature of losses incurred.
7
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
8
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
We envisage that life premiums in 2011 will be $65.96 billion, a growth larger
than they were in 2007. The performance of the market is forecast to accelerate,
with an anticipated CAGR of 9.78% for the four-year period 2007-2011 expected
to drive the market to a value of $65.96 billion by the end of 2011. There would be
a growth of $24.6 billion i.e. 59.48% in the next 4 years.
Non-life premiums in India were $6.53 billion in 2007. Gross written premium
(GWP) in the Indian non-life insurance market reached a value of $5.75 billion in
2006, this representing an annual growth of 13.55% for the period spanning 2006-
2007. Estimated non-life premiums rose from INR230 billion ($5.75 billion) in
2006 to INR261 billion
($6.53 billion) in 2007. We anticipate that non-life premiums will grow by a
CAGR of 9.40% between 2007-2011. We are looking for non-life premiums to
rise by $405 million over the five years to the end of 2011 with a growth rate of
62.02%. (Source: http://www.scribd.com/doc/4996143/OVERVIEW-OF-
INSURANCE-SECTOR )With a huge population base and large untapped market,
insurance industry is a big opportunity area in India for national as well as foreign
9
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
investors. India is the fifth largest life insurance market in the emerging insurance
economies globally and is growing at 32-34% annually. This impressive growth in
the market has been driven by liberalization, with new players significantly
enhancing product awareness and promoting consumer education
and information. The strong growth potential of the country has also made
international players to look at the Indian insurance market. Moreover, saturation
of insurance markets in many developed economies has made the Indian market
more attractive for international insurance players, according to "Booming
Insurance Market in India (2008-2011)”.
With the entry of several low-cost airlines, along with fleet expansion by
existing ones and increasing corporate aircraft ownership, the Indian
aviation insurance market is all set to boom in a big way in coming years.
Health insurance is poised to become the second largest business for non-
life insurers after motor insurance in next three years.
10
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
A booming life insurance market has propelled the Indian life insurance
agents into the ‘top 10 country list’ in terms of membership to the Million
Dollar Round Table (MDRT) — an exclusive club for the highest
performing life insurance agents.
(Source:http://www.marketsmonitor.com/Report/IM588_related.htm)
LIFE INSURANCE
As is evident from its very name, it deals with insurance of human life. “Life
insurance corporation of India”- a public sector undertaking has the monopoly in
this sector since its nationalization.
All life insurance companies in India have to comply with the strict regulations laid
out by Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDA).
Therefore there is no risk in going in for private insurance players.
In terms of being rated for financial strength like international players, only ICICI
Prudential is rated by Fitch India at National Insurer Financial Strength Rating of
AAA (Ind) with stable outlook indicating the highest claims paying ability rating.
11
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
Life insurance.
Table-1: Trend of the Indian insurance industry ($Bn) 2000-2011
Non-Life Life
0.00 2000
10.00 2001
20.00 2002
30.00 2003
40.00 2004
50.00 2005
60.00 2006
70.00 2007
80.00 2008
90.00 2009
100.00 2010
110.00 2011
12
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC), the state owned behemoth, remains by
far the largest player in the market. Among the private sector players, ICICI
Prudential Life Insurance(JV between ICICI Bank and Prudential PLC)is the
largest followed by Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance Company Limited (JV between
Bajaj Group and Allianz).
The private companies are coming out with better products which are more
beneficial to the customer. Among such products are the ULIPs or the Unit Linked
Insurance Plans which offer both life cover as well as scope for savings or
investment options as the customer desires. Further, these types of plans are
subject to a minimum lock-in period of three years to prevent misuse of the
significant tax benefits offered to such plans under the Income Tax Act.
Unlike the mutual fund product that has a very simple cost structure, ULIPs carry
a greater number of costs (administration and mortality), in addition to the others.
So comparing ULIPs with mutual funds is erroneous. Right now there are a total
twenty two life insurance companies operating in India, of which one (Life
Insurance Corporation)
is a Public Sector Undertaking and the remaining twenty are all private sector
enterprises.
13
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
1. AEGON RELIGARE
2. AVIVA
3. BAJAJ ALLIAZ
4. BHARATHI AXA
5. BIRLA SUN LIFE
6. FUTURE GENERALI
7. HDFC STANDARD LIFE
8. HSBC
9. ICICI PRUDENTIAL
10. IDBI FORTIS
11. ING VYSYA
12. KOTAK LIFE INSURANCE
13. LIC
14. MAX NEWYORK LIFE
15. MET LIFE
16. RELIANCE LIFE
17. SAHARA INDIA
18. SBI LIFE
19. SHRIRAM LIFE
20. TATA AIG LIFE
21. DLF PRAMERICA
22. CANARA HSBC OBC
14
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
Table-2: Market share of the Indian Life Insurance industry (figures are
approximate)
Companies Percentage
LIC 64%
ICICI 9%
Bajaj 7%
SBI Life 3%
Reliance 3%
HDFC 3%
Birla 2%
Max Newyork 2%
Kotak Mahindra 1%
Others 6%
15
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
STUDY OF ULIPs
India, ULIP insurance policies are on the top in the popularity chart because it
offers more benefits than traditional life insurance plans. There are many benefits
are available such as higher returns on investment, partial withdrawal, flexibility to
choose life cover, wider fund options, top up facility, free switches, tax benefits,
etc.
If you are looking for long term investment and better returns, ULIP is a right
option to achieve your goal. But, you may find difficulties while purchasing the
ULIP, because there are single and regular premium option. You have to choose
the right option for you. In single premium ULIP, you need to pay a single
payment and you will enjoy the benefits throughout the policy term. In case of
regular premium, you need to pay premium on regular basis, it can be paid by
annual, half annual, quarterly and monthly mode.
16
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
In terms of investment, both products offers similar options like equity, debt and
liquid. Under regular premium option you may ask for commitment to pay more.
But, under single premium product nobody will ask you to pay more as a matter of
commitment. In the initial years of ULIP, single premium product offer better
returns than regular premium product. But, it's balance power shifts down latter.
But this is not in effect, the product is sold very aggressively due to IRDA norms.
Regular premium ULIP products are also good in various factors such as
affordability, tax benefit and large return.
There are also ULIP charges to consider than single and regular premium. It is also
important to take a overview of different charges are under ULIP plans. It includes
premium allocation charge, risk cover charges, policy administration charges, fund
management charges, service tax charge, miscellaneous charge, etc.
At the end, ULIP is a good mixture of life cover and investment. But don't buy it
for investment purpose only, there are another good options available for the
investment. Unit linked insurance plan (ULIP) is a life insurance solution that
provides the client with the benefits of protection and flexibility in investment. It is
a solution which provides for life
insurance where the policy value at any time varies according to the value of the
underlying assets at the time .
STRUCTURE OF ULIPs
ULIPs offered by different insurers have varying charge structures. Broadly the
different types of fees and charges are given below. However the insurers have the
right to revise or cancel the fees and charges over a period of time
( Source: http://www.scribd.com/doc/7044410/ULIPs)
17
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
Administrative Charges:
These are charges that are levied for the administration of the policy and the
related cost of administration of the insurance company,itself. They are more
related to the cost like IT , operational, etc cost of continuing the policy.
Mortality Charges:
This covers the cost of providing life protection for the insured and may be paid
once at the start of the policy for a recurrent manner for example this charges
levied to provide the insurance cover under the plan . Normally these charges are
one year charges as per the age of the holder.
18
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
Premium
Less charges
Rider charges
19
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
Rider charges are similar in nature to the mortality charges as they are levied to
pay for the other protection benefits that the policy holder has choosen for- like the
critical illness benefit or the accident benefit,etc.
Surrender Charges
When the policy holder decides to surrender the policy or partially withdraw some
of the units for cash , a surrender charge may be apply.
Surrender charges are used to cover initial expenses that have been incurred by the
company but not yet recovered from the policyholder yet.
20
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
Flexibility Transparency
21
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
TAX IMPLICATIONS
• ULIPs: Very flexible in moving between equity and debt funds(not tax
implications until maturity of the policy).
22
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
Do as much homework as possible before investing in an ULIP. This way you will
be fully aware of what you are getting into and make an informed decision.
More importantly, it will ensure that you are not faced with any unpleasant
surprises at a later stage. Our experience suggests that investors on most occasions
fail to realise what they are getting into and unscrupulous agents should get a lot of
'credit' for the same. Gather information on ULIPs, the various options available
and understand their working. Read ULIP-related information available on
financial Web sites, newspapers and sales literature circulated by insurance
companies.
23
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
performing; also study the portfolios of various plans. Expenses are a significant
factor in ULIPs hence an assessment on this parameter is warranted as well.
Enquire about the top-up facility offered by ULIPs i.e. additional lump sum
investments which can be made to enhance the policy's savings portion. This
option enables policyholders to increase the premium amounts, thereby providing
presenting an opportunity to gainfully invest any surplus funds available. Find out
about the number of times you can make free switches (i.e. change the asset
allocation of your ULIP account)
from one investment plan to another. Some insurance companies offer multiple
free switches every year while others do so only after the completion of a
stipulated period.
When your agent recommends a ULIP from a given company, put forth some
product-related questions to test him and also ask him why the products from other
insurers should not be considered. Insurance advice at all times must be unbiased
and independent; also your agent must be willing to inform you about the pros and
cons of buying a particular plan. His job should not be restricted to doing paper
work like filling forms and delivering receipts; instead he should keep track of
your plan and offer you advice on a regular basis.
24
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
ADVANTAGES OF ULIPs
Can easily rebalance your risk between equity and debt without any tax
implications.
Best suited for medium risk taking individuals who wish to invest in equity
and debt funds (at least 40% or higher exposure to debt). No additional tax
burden for those investing mainly in debt unlike in MFs.
The accretion to the fund invested can be checked on daily basis unlike the
traditional policies.
Charges are transparent in nature, with the latest AML guidelines insisting
on common nomenclature of charges for all insurance companies
The customer can time the market by exercising switch options and make
the most when markets are zooming or choose to be conservative when
markets are falling..its thus win-win situation
25
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
Stages in one life like education of children, marriage, and retirement needs
can be soundly planned by the help of ULIPs.
Disadvantages
ULIPS are attractive for risk taking people and less attractive for risk
adverse people.
26
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
The complicated design of the polices make them less aware of the product
planned out more evenly. Mutual fund managers cannot take a similar long-term
view because they have bulk investors who can move money in and out of schemes
at short notice.
Unit Linked Insurance Plan, popularly called ULIP, it is to be borne in mind that
ULIP’s being a market linked instrument will fetch good returns on a long term
basis. The basic advantage of a ULIP over other investment instruments is that it
offers the twin benefits of life insurance as well as an investment. Apart from that,
there are a number of ways in which ULIP’s can prove to be advantageous over
Mutual Funds, Regular Insurance Policies and Fixed Deposits. Let’s analyze:
27
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
Maxi miser: If high growth is your priority, this is the plan for you. You can
enjoy long-term capital appreciation from a portfolio that is invested primarily in
equity and equity-related securities
Protector: If on the other hand, your priority is steady returns, you can opt for the
protector Plan. Plan, you can accumulate a steady income at a low risk across a
medium to long-term period from a portfolio, which is primarily invested in fixed
income securities.
Balancer: If you prefer a balance of growth and steady returns, choose our
balancer plan. This would ensure that your portfolio is invested in equity-linked
securities, as well as in fixed income securities.
28
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
29
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
Although this is how the ULIP options are generally designed, the exact
debt/equity allocations may vary across insurance companies. A ULIP
policyholder has the option to invest in a variety of funds, depending on his risk
profile. If one does not have the appetite to invest in equity, they can choose a debt
or balanced fund.
Flexibility
Individuals can switch between the ULIP variants outlined above to capitalise on
investment opportunities across the equity and debt markets. Some insurance
companies allow a certain number of free' switches. This is an important feature
that allows the informed individual/investor to benefit from the vagaries of
stock/debt markets. For instance, when stock markets were on the brink of 7,000
points (Sensex), the informed investor could have shifted his assets from an
Aggressive ULIP to a low-risk Conservative ULIP.
Switching also helps individuals on another front. They can shift from an
Aggressive to a Balanced or a Conservative ULIP as they approach retirement.
This is a reflection of the change in their risk appetite, as they grow older.
30
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
realise that ULIPs also tend to do the same, albeit on a quarterly/half-yearly basis.
As a matter of fact, even the annual premium in a ULIP works on the rupee cost-
averaging principle. An added benefit with ULIPs is that individuals can also
invest a one-time amount in the ULIP either to benefit from opportunities in the
stock markets or if they have an investible surplus in a particular year that they
wish to put aside for the future. When you're buying a ULIP, make sure you select
one that works well for you. The important thing is to look for and understand the
nuances, which can considerably alter the way the product works for you. Take the
following into consideration:
Charges : Understand all the charges levied on the product over its tenure, not just
the initial charges. A complete charge structure would include the initial charges,
the fixed administrative charges, the fund management charges, mortality charges
and spreads, and that too, not only in the first year but also through the term of the
policy
Fund Options and Management : Understand the various fund options available
to you and the fund management philosophy and objectives of each of them.
Examine the track record of the funds and how they are performing in comparison
to benchmarks. Who manages the funds and what experience do they have? Are
there adequate controls?
Importantly, look at how easily you can access information about your fund's
performance when you need it -- are their daily NAVs? Is the portfolio disclosed
regularly?
Features : Most ULIPs are rich in features such as allowing one to top-up or
switch between funds, increase or decrease the protection level, or premium
31
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
holidays. Carefully understand the conditions and charges associated with each of
these. For instance, is there a minimum amount that must be switched? Is there a
charge on the same? Must you go through medical underwriting if you want to
increase the sum assured?
Company : Last but not least, insure with a brand you can trust to honour its
commitment and service you according to your requirements
First and foremost, investors need to understand that a ULIP is a bundled product
of their investments and their insurance proceeds. Since privatization in 2000 and
the introduction of ULIPs as a life insurance product category, the overall
insurance penetration in the country has grown from around 2% to 4%. Today,
more than 70 per cent of the new business premium for life insurers comes from
Ulips.
All Ulips have several funds in which your money can be put to work, much like a
mutual fund. Assuming that you choose the growth or the equity plan, ask for the
NAV performance for the last two years at least. Choose three with the highest
performance track record vis-a-vis the benchmark. Now choose the best
performing policy in terms of returns with the lowest cost. Here's a 5-step
investment strategy that will guide investors in the selection process and enable
them to choose the right unit-linked insurance plans (ULIPs).
But before we get there, let's understand what ULIPs are all about?
For the generation of insurance seekers who thrived on insurance policies with
assured returns issued by a single public sector enterprise, unit-linked insurance
plans are a revelation. Traditionally insurance products have been associated with
attractive returns coupled with tax benefits. The returns part was often so
32
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
compelling that insurance products competed with investment products for a place
in the investor's portfolio.
Perhaps insurance policies then were symbolic of the times when high interest
rates and the absence of a rational risk-return trade-off were the norms. The
subsequent softening of interest rates introduced a degree a much-needed
rationality to insurance products like endowment plans; attractive returns at low
risk became a thing of the past. The same period also coincided with an upturn in
equity markets and the emergence of a new breed of market-linked insurance
products like ULIPs.
Investors have the choice of enhancing their insurance cover, modifying premium
payments and even opting for a distinct asset allocation than the one they originally
opted for. Also if an unforeseen eventuality were to occur, in case of traditional
products, the sum assured is paid along with accumulated bonuses; conversely in
33
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
ULIPs, the insured is paid either the sum assured or corpus amount whichever is
higher.
Insurance seekers have never been exposed to this kind of flexibility in traditional
insurance products and it would be fair to say that ULIPs represent the new face of
insurance.
While few would dispute the value-add that ULIPs can provide to one's insurance
portfolio and financial planning; the same is not without its flipside. For the
uninitiated,
As is the case with most evolved investment avenues, making informed decisions
is the key if investors in ULIPs wish to truly gain from their investments. The
various aspects of ULIPs dealt with in this publication will certainly further the
ULIP investor's cause.
34
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
CHAPTER-3
RESEARCH DESIGN
Problem Statement
Investors are being confused because many insurance companies approach and
explain that their product is better than other companies’ product. They have been
explained only about the NAV returns and not the actual returns what they
(investors) will receive after amortizing the charges.
• To compare the Unit Linked Insurance Plans (ULIPs) with some selected
companies.
35
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
METHODOLOGY
The techniques used for data collection are:
A. Internet surveys and
B. Questionnaire method
The following methodology has been followed to achieve the objectives of the
project.
SOURCES OF DATA
In the data collection method, we have collected both primary and secondary data
to meet our objectives
Primary Data
The primary data was collected by a survey based on the questionnaire. It was
formulated on the basis of information carefully gathered by me about the various
mindsets of the people. This questionnaire was mainly formulated to target the
common man to see his perception and awareness of various investment options
available.
Secondary Data
36
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
The secondary data was collected directly from the companies and their websites
and internet surveys. Also a lot of similar research studies and journals have been
referred .
1. Life protection
2. Investment and Savings
➢Market linked fund based on risk profile
➢Switch option
➢Premium redirection
➢Automatic transfer plan(ATP)
3. Flexibility of cover continuance
4. Transparency
5. Extra protection with riders
➢Death due to accident
➢Disability
➢Critical illness
6. Liquidity
➢During the term partial withdrawals
➢ At Maturity
7. Tax planning
37
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
Limitations:
I. Only five Life Insurance companies have been considered for the study.
III. The scope of the project is limited to conceptual and marketing aspects of
Life Insurance Companies and doesn’t include Claim Settlement and the
under writing part of the operations which are equally important aspect of
learning.
38
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
CHAPTER-4
COMPARITIVE SECONDARY DATA ANALYISIS
39
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
No of funds 5
Riders ADBR,CIBR
No of funds 7
Riders ADBR,CIBR
INVEST ASSURE II
Min entry age 15,20,30 yrs
40
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
No of funds 5
Riders ADBR,CIBR,WOP
Min premium payment term NM
INVEST ASSURE EXTRA
Min entry age 15,20,30 yrs
No of funds 4
Riders ADBR,CIBR
41
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
INVEST ASSURE:
III. Customer can keep his money invested till the age of 75 years and take
benefit of the market performance whereas here the plan matures at the
age of 60.
43
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
No of funds 6
No of funds 3
Riders NM
CENTURY PLUS
Min entry age 8 yrs
No of funds 7
Riders ADBR
No of funds 7
PENSION GUARANTEE
Min entry age 45yrs
No of funds NM
Riders NM
46
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
COMPARITIVE ANALYSIS
of this product.
♦ Max entry age in wealthsurence is 65 as against this product which has a cut of 60
years.
CENTURY PLUS:
47
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
of this product.
♦ In wealthsurence there is a choice of 5 riders where as in this product only 1 rider is
available.
PENSION GUARANTEE:
♦ Wealthsurance can be customised for retirement planning.
♦ Customer can opposite for a partial withdrawal without any changes post 3 years
from his fund value and use the money as pension. There is no tax charges on the
money withdrawn or taken as pension.
48
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
a. MARKET PLUS
b. PROFIT PLUS (RP & SP)
c. FORTUNE PLUS
MARKET PLUS
Min entry age 18 yrs
No of funds 4
Riders ADBR
No of funds 4
Riders ADBR,CIBR
FORTUNE PLUS
Min entry age 12 yrs
No of funds 4
Riders ADBR
COMPARITIVE ANALYSIS
MARKET PLUS:
PROFIT PLUS(RP&SP):
♦ Premium allocation charge is 15% min in this product where as wealthsurance has a
change of max 4%.
♦ In wealthsurance there is unlimited switching redirection and partial withdrawal
FORTUNE PLUS:
51
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA.
52
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT COLLEGE.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
ENDOWMENT PLUS II b.
ENHANCED LIFE PROTECTION II c.
UNIT LINKED PENSION RP d.
UNIT LINKED PENSION SP
ENDOWMENT PLUS II
Min entry age 18
No of funds 7
Riders ADBR,CIBR
53
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
No of funds 7
Riders NO
No of funds 7
Riders NO
Min premium payment term TERM
54
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
Min premium NM
No of funds 7
Riders NO
COMPARITIVE ANALYSIS
ENDOWMENT PLUS:
♦ Min entry age in wealthsurance is0 years as against in this product it is 18
years.
♦ Premium allocation charge is 40% in this product where as wealthsurance
55
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
where as in this product the customer need to wait till the 5th year.
56
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
57
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
b.LIFE LINKSUPER
e. LIFE STAGE
i. LIFE STAGE RP
58
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
No of funds 7
Riders ADBR,CIBR,WOP
No of funds 7
Riders NO
Min premium payment term SP
59
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
No of funds 7
Riders ADBR,CIBRWORP
No of funds 7
Riders ADBR,CIBR
Min premium payment term 3 yrs
60
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
LIFE STAGE
No of funds 7
ADB
Riders R,CIBR
COMPARITIVE ANALYSIS
is 20000
♦ In Wealthsurance there is unlimited switching redirection and partial
61
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
LI FE LINK SUPER:
♦ Premium allocation charge is 20% in this product where as
Wealthsurancehas a charge of max 4%.
♦ Min premium in Wealthsurance is only Rs.10000 as against in this product it
is 20000
♦ In Wealthsurance there is unlimited switching redirection and partial
withdrawal allowed absolutely free of charge.
is 20000
♦ In Wealthsurance there is unlimited switching redirection and partial
withdrawal allowed absolutely free of charge.
62
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
LIFE STAGE:
♦ Premium allocation charge is 25% in this product where as
Wealthsurancehas a charge of max 4%.
♦ Min premium in Wealthsurance is only Rs.10000 as against in this
product it is 20000
♦ In Wealthsurance there is unlimited switching redirection and partial
withdrawal allowed absolutely free of charge.
♦ There are only 2 riders available in this product as against Wealthsurance
has a host of riders to choose from.
63
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
CHAPTER-5
PERFORMANCE OF ULIPs IN THE SELECTED COMPANIES
Here in order to compare the performances of the ULIPs in the selected five
companies with that of IDBI FORTIS we have selected a particular type of fund
called equity growth funds. The reason for selecting equity growth fund is that we
would be very clearly able to understand the effect of market slowdown on these
companies. Here we have considered the Net asset Values (NAV) of the equity
growth funds from April 1st 2008 to April 30th2009.We have then compared the
maximum and minimum NAVs during the period and found out the percentage
change for the NAVs observed for the equity funds of the respective selected
companies selected companies.
We have calculated the average NAV for every month (from April 1st 2008 to
April 30th2009) for all the companies and then plotted them on graphs. We have
then found out the extent to which each company was affected due to the market
slowdown. We have also taken into consideration the latest NAVs of these
companies to see the pattern of growth of these funds post recession. The
percentage change (negative) in the Net Asset value for all the companies has been
calculated below and we observe growth as we can see from its present NAV. that
LIC was the least affected among the selected companies with only a percentage
change of only -23.38% which is quite low compared to -43.84% of that of Bajaj
Allianz.
IDBI Fortis has shown a percentage change of -38.95%.But since IDBI Fortis is a
new company which was started just a year back we can say that it has managed
quite well and right now it is showing a quite good and positive .
64
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
Month NAV
Apr-08 8.4099
May-08 7.7124
Jun-08 7.5374
Jul-08 8.1797
Aug-08 7.9632
Sep-08 5.5974
Oct-08 5.7968
Nov-08 5.6706
Dec-08 5.5100
Jan-09 5.4479
Feb-09 5.1516
Mar-09 6.1597
Apr-09 6.4646
65
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
Aug-08 7.9632
Sep-08 5.9740
Oct-08 5.7968
Nov-08 5.6706
Dec-08 5.5100
Jan-09 5.4479
Feb-09 5.1516
Mar-09 6.1597
Apr-09 6.4646
66
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
Jan-09 34.8450
Feb-09 34.2650
Mr-09 33.4050
Apr-09 39.9150
Month NAV
Apr-08 12.2400
May-08 12.1735
Jun-08 11.6585
Jul-08 11.0290
Aug-08 11.4950
Sep-08 11.1155
Oct-08 9.5505
Nov-08 9.3775
Dec-08 9.6165
Jan-09 9.6130
Feb-09 9.5395
Mar-09 9.4765
Apr-09 10.5715
67
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
Month NAV
Apr-08 13.4790
May-08 13.3460
Jun-08 11.9805
Jul-08 11.9125
Aug-08 12.3240
Sep-08 11.7975
Oct-08 10.1290
Nov-08 9.8400
Dec-08 9.9140
Jan-09 9.8000
Feb-09 9.6675
Mar-09 9.4175
Apr-09 10.7340
68
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
CHAPTER-6
FINDINGS:
There is a great future of the life insurance sector in India as 80% of the Indian
population is still without life cover and people are just now coming in response to
the awareness campaigns being carried out by almost all the insurance companies.
We have found out that age plays a major role in deciding the investment
patterns of people as generally the younger class of people tend to take more risk
and invest in various instruments more frequently in a year( 2.10 times a year)
when compared with the older class of people(1.46 times a year).
69
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
Life Insurance Corporation (LIC) of India is still the undisputed market leader
as 63% of the respondents surveyed owned a policy in it and it has also got a
tremendous rating of 4.2 out of 5 in the survey conducted.
All the products of LIC &ICICI under Wealthsurance are really very good and
have an edge over most of the products of other major life insurance companies as
the plans offered by the company are really very flexible.
SUGGESTIONS:
Bajaj allianz has to improve its distribution network as its reach to a common
man is very limited .Also the number of agents working for the company is very
less right now when compared to the other companies
The company should constantly come out with innovative products as the
competition is very tough with around 22 companies fighting hard for the market
share. Some new innovative ideas have been suggested below.
♦ There should be various benefits under this plan for the customers like in
case of a premature or a complicated birth the company would bear the
expenses till the baby is healthy again through the insurance policy. Also
there could be death benefits in case of the death of the baby inside the
womb or at the time of delivery. This plan could really be successful as in
India there are lot of premature child deaths and if the company comes out
70
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
with a plan like this very tactfully with some implied conditions it would be
the first Indian company to offer insurance to unborn babies.
♦ The company could also come out with a plan for both the husband and wife
where automatically the wife gets insured along with her husband when her
husband purchases the policy. This could also be the other way round.
♦ This could be called the combo family plan. In simple words it means buy
one policy and get another free. No other company has done something like
this till now.
As the company is a new company it has to really work hard to get itself
promoted. The company could start sponsoring major events and conduct talk
shows and seminars to get noticed. It could also take the help of NGOs. There are
many people in India who still do not know about the concept of insurance.The
company could take this as an opportunity by trying to create awareness.
The company could start using star personalities for their endorsements
especially cricket stars and film stars as India is a nation of crazy cricket and film
followers and there is nothing better than reaching to the hearts of people through
cricket.
71
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
The company should come out with some really outstanding and out of the
world advertisements like the ones Vodafone has released recently which people
find it hard to forget soon.
CONCLUSION:
As we have all know today’s scenario, awareness of Life Insurance is
being created among the people, standard of life is increasing day-by-day; many
people tend to cover their risk associated with their life by taking Insurance for
their life.
People are expecting high returns from ULIPs. Since ULIPs are hot
selling product in Life Insurance Industry Contributing more than 70 % of the
premium collected by each company per year.
Investors need the clarity about the products of different life insurance
companies particularly ULIP’s. Hence we have tried to give our best to the
investors by comparing the ULIP’s of 5 leading insurance companies.
72
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
ANNEXURE - I (QUESTIONNAIRE)
QUESTIONNAIRE
(This questionnaire is only of the sake of some research work being done on
insurance companies. Confidentiality would be maintained.)
Name :__________________________________________________
Qualification:
73
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
Occupation:
74
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
75
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
Do you agree that Insurance products are susceptible to very low risk when
compared to the other options for investment?
1. ___________________________________
2. ___________________________________
3.___________________________________
Yes No
76
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
According to you what is the amount of risk involved in (ULIPs) Unit Linked
Investment Plans?
BIBLIOGRAPHY
www.hdfcstandardlife.com
www.licindia.com
www.bajajallianz.com
www.iciciprulife.com
www.tata-aig-life.com
http://www.scribd.com/doc/4996143/OVERVIEW-OF-INSURANCE-SECTOR
http://www.marketsmonitor.com/Report/IM588_related.htm
77
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.
ANALYSIS OF ULIPS IN INDIA
78
REGIONAL INSTITUTE OF COOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT.