Case Study: Effect of Non-Linear Load On Distribution System
Case Study: Effect of Non-Linear Load On Distribution System
Case Study: Effect of Non-Linear Load On Distribution System
Distribution System
Prepared by:
Tana Taher Azeez
(MSc Student)
Supervised by:
Hilmi Padhil
(Assistant Professor)
Erbil-Kurdistan
December, 2017
ABSTRACT
A load will be linear when it takes out a current from the source which is related
to the voltage (linear). And in the case of “non-linear” load, impedance changes
with applied voltage. The current drawn from such non-linear load is also non-
linear i.e. non-sinusoidal even when it is connected to a sinusoidal voltage source.
Harmonic currents contents which are present in non-sinusoidal currents
intermingle with the impedance of the power distribution system to create voltage
distortion which affects the distribution system and the loads connected to it. The
serious power-line pollution is a result of increasing use of power electronic
systems and time-variant nonlinear loads in industry. Hence, power supply quality
is degraded. It results in the reduction of system efficiency, apparatus overheating,
and increase power. As the utilization of the number of harmonics-producing
loads has increased over the years.
Keywords
1 INTRODUCTION
Because of the constantly expanding number of nonlinear loads on distribution
systems, the existence of harmonics, nowadays, is inevitable. It has caused the
increase of waveform voltage and current supply distortions with the consequent
loss in the power quality and as a result voltage and current waveforms are rarely
sinusoidal. Also damage of the components of the networks has been produced
such as in user’s equipment. In addition, distribution systems are quite often
unbalanced in nature. This necessitates the study of the combined effect of
unbalance and nonlinearity on power system voltages and currents. The increase
in recent decades of electrical equipment that produce harmonics has posed severe
problems for electrical networks and power quality. Sinusoidal voltages or
currents, the frequency of which are a multiple of the fundamental frequency (50
Hz) of the power system are called harmonics. Effect of harmonic presence is
considerable in all sections of power systems such as distribution, transmission
and generation.
High harmonic voltage levels and harmonic load currents, regardless of the
source, will lead to operating problems on the electric power distribution system.
These problems, which include equipment heating, overvoltage, and load
disruption, have been discussed in (Key and Lai 1993) (IEEE Standard 519-1992,
1993).
This standard provides recommended practices for the harmonic evaluation of
electrical power systems, which is widely accepted by the industries and utilities.
European standard EN 50160 is set the boundaries for harmonic voltages. In
addition there are recommendations for harmonic current, mainly following
IEEE519(Key and Lai 1993).
2 LITERATURE REVIEW
Tremendous work has been done for harmonics, their analysis and various
mitigation techniques of harmonics. For the reliable and efficient operation of any
system a properly designed electrical system is necessary. And the system should
be harmonic free. For this purpose, capacitors in harmonic environment are
applied. They are beneficial because they result in minimized THD, improved
power factor and elimination of power factor penalties(Andrews, Bishop et al.
1996) [3]. Lucian Asiminoae, Sergej Kalaschnikow and Steffan Hansen have
discussed two harmonic detection methods. The methods are selective harmonic
compensation and overall harmonic compensation (Durdhavale and Ahire 2016)
[4].
3 LOAD CHARACTERISTICS
The voltage waveforms generated at centralized power plants and then stepped up
to a transmission voltage level generally are very close to ideal (i.e.
sinusoidal)and have negligible distortion. The nature of major transmission
devices such as transmission lines, cables, and transformers are quite linear, thus
they cause little distortion to voltage or current waveforms. However, variable
frequency drives and uninterruptible power supplies which use electronic devices
to rectify ac to dc and then invert back to ac are nonlinear devices. Several loads
are nonlinear such as switch mode power supplies and fluorescent light ballasts
and, of course, frequency converters of motor drives used in different applications
both in industry and dwelling. Generated nonlinear currents result in distorted
voltages and currents that can adversely impact the system performance in
different ways. Since the number of harmonic producing loads has increased over
the years, it has become increasingly necessary to address their influence when
making any additions or changes to an installation. To adequate appreciate the
impact of this phenomenon there are two important concepts to keep in mind with
regard to power system harmonics. The first is the nature of harmonic-current
producing loads (non-linear loads) and the second is the way in which harmonic
currents flow and how the resulting harmonic voltages develop.
The objective of the electric utility is to supply their consumers with sinusoidal
voltage at fairly constant magnitude. This objective is complicated by the fact that
non-linear currents exist. Nonlinear currents can originate from any of three
causes:
Reactive Linear loads are Loads which contain Inductive and capacitive
components .if the Load is Capacitive , the current wave form will shift to the left
of the voltage wave form , so the current ‘leads’ the voltage as shown in figure 2 .
If the load is Inductive, the current waveform will shift to the right of the voltage
wave form so the current ‘lags’ voltage as shown in figure 3
Figure 3Inductive Loads
For Non-linear loads change the shape of the current waveform from a sine wave
to some other form .The nature of non-linear loads is to generate harmonics in the
current waveform. This distortion of the current waveform eventually leads to
distortion of the voltage waveform, especially if the feeding grid is weak (large
impedance) and proportion of non-sinusoidal currents is high enough. Under these
conditions, the voltage waveform is no longer proportional to the current. Typical
examples of non-linear loads include: rectifiers (power supplies, discharge
lighting, UPS units), adjustable speed motor drives, ferromagnetic devices, DC
motor drives and arcing equipment (arc furnaces).
In Typical electronic power unit, a capacitor charges for a short period of the peak
of the voltage waveform via diodes, for the rest of the supply half cycle, the
diodes are reverse biased and no current flow from the supply. The current
waveform thus consist of short pulses forward of the voltage peaks in figure 4.
The current drawn by non-linear loads is not sinusoidal but still it is periodic,
meaning that the current wave remains the same from cycle to cycle.
Mathematically, periodic waveforms can be
described as a series of sinusoidal waveforms
that have been summed together
4 HARMONICS
The load is said to be nonlinear when the current it draws does not have the same
waveform as the supply voltage. Mostly, this load is represented by the device
comprising power electronics circuits such as
In the case of a motor drive, the AC current at the input to the rectifier looks more
like square wave than a sine wave. The rectifier can be thought of as a harmonic
current source and produces roughly the same amount of harmonic current over a
wide range of power system impedances. The characteristic current harmonics
that are produced by a rectifier are determined by the pulse number. The
following equation allows determination of the characteristic harmonics for a
given pulse number [4]:
𝑛 = 𝑘𝑞 ± 1
Where: n is the harmonic number (integer multiple of the fundamental), k is any
This means that a 6-pulse (or 3-phase) rectifier will exhibit harmonics at the 5th,
7th, 11th, 13th, 17th, 19th, 23rd, 25th, etc. multiples of the fundamental. The
magnitudes of the harmonic currents will be the fundamental current divided by
the harmonic number (e.g. the magnitude of the 5th harmonic would be about
1/5th of the fundamental current). A 12-pulse (or 6-phaserectifier) will, in theory,
produce harmonic currents at the 11th, 13th, 23rd, 25th, etc. multiples. In reality,
a small amount of the 5th, 7th, 17th and 19th harmonics will be present with a 12-
pulsesystem (typically the magnitudes will be on the order of about 10 percent of
those for a 6-pulsedrive).
Figure 7Resultant waveform of system having 3rd, 5th and 7th harmonics
Variable frequency drives also produce harmonic currents at the output of the
inverter which are seen by the motor. Most of these harmonics are integer
multiples of the inverter operating frequency and not the power supply frequency,
but little generalization can be made about their magnitude since this varies
greatly with the type of drive and the switching algorithm for the inverter
semiconductors. Some "inter-harmonic" currents may also be present at the input
or the output of the drive. Inter-harmonics do not fit the classical definition of
harmonics since they do not necessarily occur at integer multiples of the power
supply or inverter fundamental frequency. Harmonics can occur on the input at
the power system frequency plus or minus the inverter operating frequency [3]
[4].
Harmonics creates a big challenge for engineers because they poses more
distortion in voltage. The effect of triplex harmonics come with overheating in
wires, overheating in transformer units and also may become the cause of end
user equipment failure. Triplex harmonics overheat the neutral conductor of 4
wire system. the neutral have generally no fundamental frequency or even
harmonics but there may be existence of odd harmonics in system neutral
conductor and when there is system consist of triplex harmonics it is become
additive. These triplex frequency impact on the system can be understand by this
way that even under balanced load condition on the account of triplex frequency
neutral current magnitude reaches up to 1.75 times of average phase current [6].
Under above discussed case if the load of system increase may become cause of
failure of insulation of neutral conductor which further result in the breakdown of
transformers winding. The important and major effect of Harmonics is further
discussed as:
Harmonics effect transformer losses and eddy current loss density [7]. Actually,
the harmonic effects on transformer will not be notice until actual failure occurs.
It will occurs when there has been changes that been made to the system like
additional or replacement of new loads. Overheating of transformer is always
been related with harmonics effects.
Because of harmonics, the losses in conductor will increase. The resultant current
will increase the distortion and is given by equation 1
I rms=√ 1+(THD )2
1
In industrial load where a lot of motors are used, we need to improve power
factor. For this purpose we are connected capacitor banks near to the loads to
improve it. Since harmonics create reactance as for capacitor reactance will
increase as the frequency decrease. Therefore, the linear loads served from a
common feeder, which also serves nonlinear loads of some other consumers, may
become susceptible to harmonic distortion. Moreover, a consumer’s system which
does not have harmonics can be subjected to harmonic pollution due to of other
consumers in the system. The capacitors can be severely overloaded due to
harmonics and can be damaged [7].
There are many harmonics sources are present but out of them few are listed here
which play a role as the major sources of harmonics [14],[16].
If the power source is fluctuating, static compensators are used at the ends of
transmission lines or near sources of fluctuating power, static compensators
manage the voltage. Reactors which are controlled by Thyristor will produce near
about 1% of the 11th harmonic current.
Rectifiers give higher inductance on the dc side compared to the ac side. Hence
the dc current is almost constant and then converter starts acting as a harmonic
voltage source on the dc side where as the harmonics current source on the ac
side.
4.3.3 Transformers
Latest electronic devices contain switched mode power supplies. SMPS regulates
AC or DC input voltage. SMPS unit draws current pulses contain large amount of
harmonics of third and above higher order harmonics.
Basically, harmonics are difficult to reduce. But the power quality gets reduced
because of harmonics. They show economic impacts such as earlier failure of
equipment’s, losses in distribution systems. So, they should be detected at early
stage.
The cutoff frequencies of the filters are directly dependent on this constant. A
simple equation to represent the cutoff frequencies for both the basic high and low
pass RC filters is shown in Equation (2.7) [13].
1 1 1
ƒс = 2 πCR , RC = , τ= 2 πfc
2 πfc
The characteristic of cutoff frequency of both low and high pass filter is shown in
figure 9
There are various issues in the design of a passive filter for its proper functioning
in harmonic reduction. The key issues are mentioned here:
a) Minimizing harmonic source current: The prime objective of the filter design is
to minimize the harmonic current in ac mains. This is ensured by minimizing the
filter impedance at the harmonic frequencies so that the harmonic filter acts as a
sink for the harmonic currents.
For voltage source type of harmonic loads (such as diode rectifier with R-L load
filter), passive series filter is considered as a potential remedy for harmonic
mitigation [16]. Here, the different tuned branches of passive filters are connected
in series with the supply and the diode rectifier. Figure 11 shows the schematic
diagram of a passive series filter connected at input ac mains. It consists of a set
of low block tuned shunt filter tuned at 5th and 7th harmonic frequencies and high
block tuned filter for 11th harmonic frequency. These passive filters blocks most
dominant 5th, 7th and other higher order harmonics and thus prevents them from
flowing into ac mains. Here, the performance of the series filter is not much
dependent on the source impedance. However, it results in reduction in dc bus
voltage due to voltage drop across filter components
Figure 11Schematic diagram of passive series filter
Passive Shunt Filter
It is the most common method for the cancellation of harmonic current in the
distribution system. Passive harmonic filter are basically designed on principle of
either single tuned or band pass filter technology. As the name suggests shunt
type filter are connected in system parallel with load. Passive filter offer a very
low impedance in the network at the tuned frequency to divert all the related
current and at given tuned frequency. Because of passive filter always have
tendency of offering some reactive power in the circuit so the design of passive
shunt filter take place for the two purpose one is the filtering purpose and another
one is to provide reactive compensation purpose of correcting power factor in the
circuit at desired level. The advantage with the passive shunt type filter is that it
only carry fraction of current so the whole system AC power losses are reduced
compare to series type filter. Figure 12 shows the schematic diagram of 6 pulse
converter system connected with shunt passive type filter which are simply
employed ever connection in distribution system have R-L load in system [16].
Figure 12Schematic diagram of passive shunt filter
There are several type of passive filters, the most commonly filter types as shown
in figure 13 [7].
Conclusion
Andrews, D., M. T. Bishop and J. F. Witte (1996). "Harmonic measurements,
analysis, and power factor correction in a modern steel manufacturing facility."
IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications 32(3): 617-624.
Chang, G. W. and C.-I. Chen (2010). Measurement techniques for stationary and
time-varying harmonics. Power and Energy Society General Meeting, 2010 IEEE,
IEEE.
Guihong, F., Z. Jing, Z. Yisong, Y. Yong and Z. Bingyi (2005). Harmonic power
detection and measurement device based on harmonic power flow analysis.
Electrical Machines and Systems, 2005. ICEMS 2005. Proceedings of the Eighth
International Conference on, IEEE.