Critical Jurnal Review

DosenPengampu :

Sabda Dian Nurani Siahaan.S.Pd.,M.B.A

DisusunOleh:

Andika Christoper Siringoringo

NIM : 7213560015

Class B

PROGRAM STUDI KEWIRAUSAHAAN

FAKULTAS EKONOMI
UNIVERSITAS NEGERI MEDAN
TA. 2021
 INTRODUCTION
Praise and gratitude I pray to the presence of God Almighty, for His blessings and grace,
the author can complete preparation of this task well and timely collection of his duties.
This task is made with the intent to fulfill one of the six tasks required in the college
contract, namely the critical journal review the courses of English Business Communication.
The author would like to thanks for our lecturer Dr. M. Ihksan and Choms Gary GT Sibarani,
M.Si, Ak, Ca has given the author the opportunity to complete this task.
The author realizes that in making this critical journal review there are errors, both in
language usage errors and typing errors. For that criticism and constructive suggestions are in
need of authors for improvement in writing the next paper.

Medan, 2021

Author
 Daftar Isi

KATA PENGANTAR.............................................................................................................................2

Daftar Isi ..................................................................................................................................................3

BAB I PENDAHULUAN.......................................................................................................................4

A. Latar Belakang.............................................................................................................................4

B. Tujuan CJR..................................................................................................................................4

C. Manfaat CJR................................................................................................................................5

BAB II IDENTITAS JURNAL ...............................................................................................................6

A. Identitas Jurnal Utama .................................................................................................................6

B. Identitas Jurnal Pembanding........................................................................................................6

BAB III RINGKASAN JURNAL ...........................................................................................................7

A. Jurnal Utama................................................................................................................................7

B. Jurnal Pembanding.......................................................................................................................8

BAB IV Kelebihan dan Kekurangan Jurnal ..........................................................................................12

A. Kelebihan Jurnal........................................................................................................................12

B. Kekurangan Jurnal.....................................................................................................................12

BAB V PENUTUP ................................................................................................................................13

A. Kesimpulan................................................................................................................................13

B. Saran ..........................................................................................................................................13
 PENDAHULUAN

A. Latar Belakang

The development of science is minimal due to the low interest in reading students at this time. Criticizing
journals is one way that can be done to increase the relevance of reading interest. Criticizing Journals (Critical
Journal Review) is an activity to review a journal in order to know and understand what is presented in a
journal. Basically, a journal review focuses on evaluation (explanation, interpretation and analysis) of the
strengths and weaknesses, what is interesting, and how the journal can change perceptions and ways of
thinking as well as a consideration of whether the knowledge gained in a particular field of study. In addition,
criticizing journals can also train our ability to analyze and discuss the discussion presented by the author. So
that it becomes a valuable input for other writing creative processes. Criticizing a journal cannot be done if the
critic does not read the entire journal. By doing this review, readers can find out the quality of the journal with
the work of the same author or other authors and can provide input to journal writers in the form of criticism
and suggestions on the systematics of writing, content, and substance of the journal.

B.Tujuan Penulisan CJR

The objectives in making a Critical Journal Review, namely:

1. Fulfill one of the mandatory tasks given by the lecturer in the Entrepreneurship course

2. Provide an overview to the reader regarding the identity of the journal, the summary of the journal, the
advantages and disadvantages of the journal, both in terms of systematic writing, as well as the overall
cohesiveness of the journal content and its implications from various aspects.

3. Adding insight to the critics because in the journal presented problems and solutions that will increase our
knowledge.

B. Manfaat CJR

The benefits of making a Critical Journal Review, namely: I. As a student engaged in the world of Education.
These journals need to be criticized because they can improve students' skills in making good and correct
research reports.

II. Increase students' knowledge of the theory and application of the results of researchers' ideas so that this
knowledge can be a new inspiration for students as prospective teachers in compiling or designing effective
learning. Improve the results of the analysis in each journal that will be criticized.

IdentitasJurnal
Journal 1

Culture Identity in Intercultural Business Communications

Original Title

Journal

Volume -

Years 2017

ISSN 2306-8401

Journal Homepage

Author Bao Juyuan

Reviewer Septi Anggi Piona

Date 11 march 2019

Journal 2

Business Communication between People with Different

Original Title
Cultural Backgrounds

Journal Conference of the International Journal of Arts and Sciences

Volume -

Years 2009

ISSN 1943-6114

Journal Homepage

Author Livia Ablonczy-Mihályka

Reviewer Septi Anggi Piona

 Date 11 march 2019

Review Journal

2.1 Top Journal

Jounal 1
Background Business communication is a core step when doing
businesses. As economy is globalized today, business
communications often meet with culture identity.
Wherever you are doing businesses, people there have
their own culture identity which affects the business
communications a lot. This paper will explain the role
culture identity plays in intercultural business
communications in four major points. Firstly, the meanings
of culture identity will be introduced by two aspects. They
are distinction and respect. Secondly, the reasons why
culture identity is so important in intercultural business
communications will be discussed. Next thepaper will talk
about how to use language and behavior to develop culture
identity in intercultural business communications. And the
last part will be how culture identity promotes intercultural
business communications by understanding and
multicultural individuals. Business communications in an
intercultural environment should consider culture identity
seriously, because cultureidentity plays a big part when
communicating with business people in other cultures and
 influence the outcomes. Peopleinvolved in intercultural
business communications can also use culture identity to
improve the communications and develop their own
culture identity
Conclusion According to the development of globalization, especially
in economy area, culture identity plays an important role in
intercultural business communications. Business people
should consider carefully the effects culture identity will
makeduring intercultural business communications in
order to produce effective and satisfied business
communications.

Journal 2

Background Internationalization, trans-border trade and cross cultural business

are all terms that have been coined over the past decade(s) to reflect
the reality of the world economy. Growth and success in today’s
global economy depend on being able to work internationally.
The business environment has inreasingly expanded outside single
nations or regions of the world to encompass many differing
countries (Sims 2007). Understanding the globalisation of business
practices is an important area and researchers and academics have
been studying the subject of business in multicultural settings for
decades. Researchers in applied linguistics, in cultural
anthropology and/or sociology, therefore professionals working in
multicultural environment have emphasised the importance of
knowledge of different cultures and they agree that globalisation
has brought about the growing trend to communicate with people
from different cultural backgrounds (Borgulya 2007, Bakacsi and
Takács 2002). A greater understanding of differing nations and
cultures leads to more positive interactions (Lin, 1999) and more
successful business relationships (Palazzo, 2002).
It is important to work out what words mean in a particular and
cultural context (Katan 1999). Different cultures have differing
values, perceptions and philosophies. As a result, certain ideas may
have very different connotations for people having different
cultural backgrounds. Different cultures may have different rules
and norms and favour different means of business communication.
Cultural differences cause communication problems in every
business interaction.
The purpose of the present paper is to investigate business
communication features of people with different cultural
backgrounds. At the root of the argument is the hypothesis that
there is an altering in communication rules and norms between
these people. We communicate the way we do because we are
 raised in a particular culture and learn its language, rules, and
norms.
Research purposes The purpose of the present paper is to present the results of
a survey conducted with professionals who communicate
with foreign business partners. The data were gathered by
means of a questionnaire. At the root of the argument is the
hypothesis that communication rules and norms between
people with different cultural background have altered and
different cultures have differing values, perceptions and
philosophies.
Research methodology Current research is based on a survey conducted in 2008 at
several multinational companies. Data were gathered by a
questionnaire entitled 'Business communication between
people with different cultural backgrounds’ (questionnaires
have been supposed to be rather efficient for gathering data
in the first part of research but in the second section of the
research interviews will be conducted with individuals to
be able to explore which questions, views or issues are
worthy of later follow-up study).
Analytical technique Kualitatif
Discussion The analysis of the survey revealed several
misunderstandings regarding the notion of culture.
However, even though we all know to which culture
belong, definition of the word has been difficult (Katan
1999:16). ‘Definition of the culture usually turn on
postulations of structures of contents and values of groups,
generally nation-sized’ (Menezes de Souza 2006: 107). For
instance, Geertz (1973) takes a semiotic approach that
defines culture as having to do with creating meaning
through communication.
Culture is understood, in this context, as collectively held
set of attributes, which is dynamic and changing over time.
Cultural awareness or cultural intelligence is increasingly
 being viewed as a critical skill in securing success in
multicultural environment. With more people from
culturally diverse backgrounds meeting within the business
environment, clear and effective communication is
necessary between them. Although in many cases a
common language may exist, usually English, culture can
and does still cause problems.
Conclusion The interest in the study of business communication has
grown tremendously during the past several years. The
present paper is only the first step of an ongoing research
comprising linguists, economists and experts in
communication who would like to study several aspects of
the recent phenomenon known as ‘intercultural approach
to business communication’ from a multi-disciplinary
point of view. It is true that the rich heritage of diverse
cultures is a valuable resource to be protected, and that a
major educational effort is needed to convert the diversity
from a barrier to communication into a source of mutual
enrichment and understanding (Clyne 1992). In order to
communicate in business, to obtain knowledge of practice
of the strategies, it is not enough to learn the words and the
grammar; it also involves being able to handle the
language as the vehicle or the medium of a culture.
Intercultural and linguacultural competencies (FitzGerald
2003: 170-203) should be developed in order to
communicate very effectively in multicultural
environment.
Communicative behaviour is believed to be strongly
influenced by cultural value systems (FitzGerald 2003:
21). Samovar and Porter (1991:108) claim that ‘in the
study of human interaction, it is important to look at
 cultural values, but in the study of intercultural
communication it is crucial’.In their comments the
respondents highlighted that in the 21st century globally
employable graduates are needed who do possess
intercultural empathy. This is already an urgent need in the
business world where multicultural encounters have
become a common practice.
Advantages the results of this study are clearly explained
shortcomings in this study the steps in the study are not
Weakness presented so that the reader is confused where the journal
research steps

PENUTUP

A. Kesimpulan

Each written work certainly has characteristics that are different from one another, both in terms of
language, advantages, and disadvantages. Every journal must contain information that has been clearly
explained by the author regardless of the shortcomings contained in each journal, but it is certain that
each journal will bring benefits to readers in terms of getting more information.

This journal contains abundant information that can make readers interested in reading and analyzing
this journal. Above has been presented a summary and also the advantages and disadvantages of each
journal which is expected to be a comparison between the opinions of readers of the journal.

B. Suggestion The advantages of the journal are to be further maintained and strengthened, and the
shortcomings of the journal are to be further researched to achieve maximum results.