Resource Optimization Techniques, Risk, and Quality
Resource Optimization Techniques, Risk, and Quality
OR
ER OU
RI
PE
Y
CT EL
LE ADE
Resource Person:
Ayesha Zahid
Adeel YounisUR
Learning
Objectives By the end of this lesson, you will be able to understand
SU NIS
1. Schedule Optimization Tools
OR
2. Resource Optimization Techniques
ER OU
RI
3. How to deal with over constrained budget
PE
Y
4. Documenting Baseline
CT EL
5. Scope Creep
UR
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
Resource • Resource optimization is the set of processes and
methods to match the
Optimization available resources (human, machinery, financial)
SU NIS
with the needs of the organization in order to
OR
achieve established goals.
ER OU
RI
Resource Optimization Techniques are
PE
Y
• * Resource smoothing is "a resource
CT EL
optimization technique in which free and total
float are used without affecting the critical path."
LE ADE • * Resource leveling is "a resource optimization
UR
technique in which adjustments are made to the
project schedule to optimize the allocation of
resources and which may affect the critical path."
Optimization
Resource
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
Schedule Schedule optimization is the process of making
sure each individual task or action in a schedule is
Optimization aligned with your ultimate goal. ... Delivery
SU NIS
companies often use schedule optimization to
OR
make sure a delivery route is laid out with the least
ER OU
RI
possible mileage (and thus lowest fuel cost).
PE
Y
CT EL
Schedule Optimization Tools:
UR
• Scope Reduction
Fast Tracking
Fast-tracking is a technique where activities that
would have been performed sequentially using the
SU NIS
OR
original schedule are performed in parallel.
In other words, fast tracking a project means the
ER OU
RI
activities are worked on simultaneously instead of
PE
Y
waiting for each piece to be completed separately.
CT EL
Fast Tracking is not always an option. If Activity B
UR
Fast Tracking can not be used as we cannot both
pack and drive in parallel, not even partially.
Crashing Project crashing is the method for shortening
the project duration by reducing the time of one or more
critical activities to less than their normal time.
Crashing is achieved by devoting more resources. Thus
SU NIS
OR
the cost associated with the project is increased.
ER OU
RI
PE
Y
CT EL
LE ADE
UR
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
Scope • If Crashing or Fast Tracking are not options for
compressing the project schedule, then the Project
Reduction Manager has one more option they can explore with
SU NIS
the Sponsor and management. They can recommend
OR
that the scope of work be reduced.
ER OU
RI
• By reducing the scope of work, there is a likely impact
PE
Y
on the reduction of time needed to complete the
project.
CT EL
• This of course means that the original set of
LE ADE deliverables agreed to can't be delivered.
UR
• If management agrees to the reduction in scope, this
must be captured and documented in the list of
activities, the WBS, the Scope Statement, the
Requirements documentation, and the Project Charter.
Over • None of the Triple Constraints can be traded off for
the other.
Constrained • This is a high-risk situation for a Project Manager
SU NIS
Projects
OR
who will need to use their interpersonal relationship
skills and negotiation skills to demonstrate to
ER OU
RI
management that the project is over constrained
PE
Y
and will not have a likelihood of success.
CT EL
• Project Manager needs to ask the Sponsor and other
Stakeholders to assist with understanding which two
LE ADE constraints are the most important.
UR
• Constraint can be manipulated by the Project
Manager, then the project has the opportunity to
succeed.
Documenting • Once the scope, schedule, and budget have been
completed and approved by the key project
Baseline Stakeholders, it must be baselined.
SU NIS
OR
• The baseline represents the agreed-to schedule,
scope, and budget.
ER OU
RI
• It is baselined at the end of the Planning Phase once
PE
Y
the entire Project Plan is complete.
CT EL
• It is then used as the basis for monitoring and
UR
are: the Scope Statement, the Requirements
document, the WBS, the schedule, and the time-
phased budget.
Scope Creep • Scope Creep is "the uncontrolled expansion to
product or project scope without adjustments to
time, cost, and resources."
SU NIS
OR
• Scope Creep occurs when the project takes on
additional work that was not in the originally
ER OU
RI
defined scope of work (Requirements, Scope
PE
Y
Statement or WBS).
CT EL
• The difference between Scope Creep and Scope
Change is that Scope Change initiates and
LE ADE approves changes through the defined change
control process. A Scope Change was the "give
SU NIS
OR
• Simply put, it means that no changes to the
ER OU
RI
approved Project Plan are made unless there is
written notice and approval.
PE
Y
• The written notice is called a Change Order (or
CT EL
Change Request).
SU NIS
OR
1. How to Identify Risks
ER OU
RI
2. How to Perform Risk Analysis
PE
Y
3. How to Deal with Qualitative Risk
CT EL
4. How to Manage Quantitative Risk
LE ADE 5.
6.
Plan & Implement Risk Responses
How to Develop Risk Register
UR
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
• Risks are uncertainties or events that planning can not
completely overcome or control.
• Project Managers must analyze and work to identify
SU NIS
OR
ways to control the impact of the most significant
risks, proactively.
ER OU
RI
• Activities to control the impact of potential risks
PE
Y
become part of the project scope, the project budget,
CT EL
and the project schedule.
A risk is "an uncertain event
LE ADE
or condition that, if it occurs,
has a positive or negative
Sometimes issues are confused with risks.
• A key distinction is that an issue is a problem that has
UR
effect on one or more project occurred and must be addressed. A risk is something
objectives." that may occur in the future - an uncertain event.
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
Impact of Risk on Project
vs
Risk
Amount
at Stake
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
Risk Identification
• Risk planning begins by identifying possible risks that could impact the project.
SU NIS
• The Project Manager, Project team, and Stakeholders should all participate in identifying
OR
possible risks for a project.
ER OU
RI
• Risks can include technological, economic, cultural, environmental, organizational, external,
internal, business, resources, schedule, budget, profit, quality of deliverables, etc.
PE
Y
Some additional techniques to help identify risks are:
CT EL
• Review historical records of similar projects
LE ADE
• Use a checklist of common risks that can occur
• Brainstorm with the team what possible risks might occur
UR
• Review the Project Scope (WBS and activities), schedule, and budget for any assumptions that
could manifest themselves into risks or any risks you identified outright when creating these
documents
Risk Identification Example
Let's look at an example. If our project is to build a house, what possible uncertainties can there be?
Are there environmental risks? Yes!
SU NIS
OR
Bad weather can cause a delay in the project schedule
Bad weather can damage exposed building materials on the site, causing project delays
ER OU
RI
Poor soil conditions can cause a delay in excavation
PE
Y
Exceptionally good weather could allow the project to finish ahead of schedule
CT EL
Are there possible scope risks? Yes!
Client can change the design, causing a schedule delay and possible cost increase
LE ADE
Are there possible economic or financial risks? Yes!
Material costs could be higher than anticipated, causing a reduction in profit
UR
Material costs could be lower than anticipated, causing an increase in profit
Client may not make payments on time, causing a delay in the schedule and possible profit loss
Are there quality risks? Yes!
Building materials from suppliers could be defective causing poor quality construction or collapse
• The challenge for most Project Managers is that
Risk Analysis there are many more risks identified than can
possibly be addressed or responded to.
SU NIS
OR
• Therefore, it is important in the Planning Phase to
prioritize risks so that the greatest risks can be
ER OU
RI
addressed.
PE
Y
• Not all risks have the same impact on the project
CT EL
nor do they have the same probability of
occurrence.
LE ADE • We use risk analysis to help prioritize the most
UR
detrimental risks that require attention by the
project.
• There are two types of risk analysis:
Qualitative and Quantitative.
Qualitative • Qualitative risk analysis allows us to prioritize risks
based on their probability of occurring and their
Risk Analysis impact, and sometimes also how easy it is to
SU NIS
Strategies detect a possible risk.
OR
• Typically this information is collected from
ER OU
RI
Stakeholders and the project team with each risk
PE
Y
being assessed against a scale for probability of
occurring, impact, and ease of detection.
CT EL
Qualitative Risk Analysis has two strategies
LE ADE 1. Probability and Impact Matrix
UR
2. Risk Priority Number (RPN).
Qualitative Risk Analysis with Probability of Occurrence
SU NIS
OR
ER OU
RI
PE
Y
CT EL
LE ADE
UR
Probability
Matrix
and Impact
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
Risk Priority • Formula: The Risk Priority Number, or RPN, is a
numeric assessment of risk assigned to a process,
Number or steps in a process, as part of Failure Modes and
SU NIS
(RPN) Effects Analysis (FMEA), in which a team assigns
OR
each failure mode numeric values that quantify
ER OU
RI
likelihood of occurrence, likelihood of detection,
and severity of impact.
PE
Y
CT EL
LE ADE
UR
Risk Priority Impact:
Number 1 - No impact
2 - Not significant impact
SU NIS
(RPN)
OR
3 - May or may not be significant impact
4 - Significant impact
ER OU
RI
5 - Severe impact Ease of Detection:
PE
1 - Definite detection
Y
Probability: 2 - Easy to detect
CT EL
1 - Won't happen 3 - May or may not detect
UR
4 - Likely to occur
5 - Definitely will occur
Risk Priority
Number
(RPN)
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
Risk Priority Risk 1: Guest list may not be complete, accurate, and
available on time, causing the party objectives to not be
Number achieved.
SU NIS
(RPN)
OR
Risk 2: Material costs could be higher than planned,
causing a budget overrun.
ER OU
RI
Risk 3: If there is insufficient interest from the guests in any
PE
Y
prospective business ventures, the project may not achieve
For each of the Four risks,
CT EL
5 prospective sales orders.
use the scale to select the
LE ADE
probability, impact, and
detection rating. Then
Risk 4: If party equipment or supplies fail to operate as
expected or operate with defects, the project objective for
UR
calculate the RPN. party guests to remain for at least 2 hours will be in
jeopardy.
Risk Priority Risk Probability Impact Detection RPN
Number Risk 1 3 4 2 24
(RPN)
SU NIS
OR
Risk 2 3 4 3 36
Risk 3 3 3 4 36
ER OU
RI
Risk 4 3 4 4 48
PE
Y
CT EL
Risk Probability Impact Detection RPN
LE ADERisk 4
Risk 2
3
3
4
4
4
3
48
36
URRisk 3
Risk 1
3
3
3
4
4
2
36
24
Risk Now that we have identified, analyzed, and prioritized
our risks, we can begin to build risk response plans.
Response A risk response is a proactive action that we will take to
SU NIS
Plan &
OR
address the risk in advance with the intent to avoid it
outright, to mitigate or lessen its impact and/or
Contingency
ER OU
RI
probability, or to transfer the risk to a third party.
Budget
PE
Y
There may also be risks we choose to accept because
CT EL
they have a low RPN or low probability and impact, or
there is no feasible way to mitigate, avoid, or transfer
LE ADE the risk.
UR
All risks identified should have a strategy for handling
them, but not all strategies require a preventative
action plan be defined (i.e. the "accepting" strategy
purposefully has no preventative action taken).
Risks With For risks with possible negative impacts to the project, we
have four choices as to a strategy for handling them.
Negative • Accept - Accept that the risk may occur and decide not
SU NIS
Impact
to take any preventative action (no response plan will
OR
be provided). We will monitor the risk in our regular
ER OU
RI
status meetings for any possible changes. Note that
there is a difference between actively choosing to
PE
Y
accept a risk and ignoring a possible risk.
CT EL
• Mitigate - Take preventative action to reduce the
impact and/or probability of the risk occurring. Mitigate is
LE ADE the most commonly used risk response strategy. Some
examples include changing the project to implement
UR
additional processes for testing or prototyping, providing
additional training, choosing higher quality materials or
resources, or reducing complexity of the project product
or processes.
Risks With • Avoid - Take preventative action to completely avoid
the chance that the risk can occur. Some examples
Negative include changing the project objectives, project result,
or the project scope to remove the threat.
SU NIS
Impact
OR
• Transfer - Take preventative action to transfer the risk
ER OU
RI
to a third party. This option doesn't eliminate or
reduce the risk, it just transfers it to someone who may
PE
Y
be better equipped to deal with it. Usually this requires
CT EL
extra budget to be put in place. Some examples would
be having the client be responsible for the work
LE ADE (instead of the project), purchasing insurance,
purchasing a warranty, or contracting with a supplier
UR
on a fixed price basis.
Risks With Sometimes risks can represent opportunities to the project. In
such cases we also have four choices for how we may choose
Positive to deal with the possible upside of a risk.
SU NIS
Impact
• Accept - Accept that the risk may occur and decide not to
OR
take any action. We will monitor the risk in our regular
ER OU
RI
status meetings for any possible changes. This means that if
the opportunity presents itself we be pleasantly surprised,
PE
Y
but no proactive response plan will be put in place.
CT EL
• Enhance - Be proactive to improve the chances of the
impact and/or probability of the risk occurring.
LE ADE • Exploit - Be proactive to attempt to ensure that the risk
UR
does occur.
• Share - Be proactive to transfer the risk to a third party or
share the risk with a third party in an attempt to realize the
opportunity.
Response
Plan Example
Risk
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
Reusing Risk • Risk strategies could be reused on future similar
projects and become part of the standard project
Response approach for this company.
SU NIS
Strategies
OR
• In other words, identify the strategy as a best
practice and update their standard contract to
ER OU
RI
always include a payment schedule and
PE
Y
penalization clause. (For the example discussed)
CT EL
• In this way, the learning from past projects can
enhance the performance of future similar
LE ADE projects by embedding in risk prevention
strategies from the start.
UR
Quantitative • By performing quantitative risk analysis we must quantify
the risks to determine contingency funds for risks that may
Analysis & occur in the project.
SU NIS
Contingency
• Once our risks are identified, analyzed, and strategized for
OR
responses, we can determine how much contingency to
ER OU
RI
place in the project budget.
• Projects that are using known technologies with highly
PE
Y
experienced project personnel will have less risk than a
CT EL
project implementing a new product or using new
The Expected Monetary
technologies with inexperienced personnel.
LE ADE
Value (EMV) is how much
money you can expect to • As such, the contingency budget should be determined
UR
make from a certain based on the risk associated with each specific project and
the risk tolerance of the organization.
decision.
• In order to determine a contingency budget, an approach
called Expected Monetary Value (EMV) can be used.
Monetary
Value (EMV)
Expected
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
Risk • It is important to note that risks change over the
life of a project.
Monitoring • The ability of the Project Manager and project
SU NIS
and Control
OR
team to prepare a comprehensive list of risks is
critical.
ER OU
RI
• If the risks identified are weak or incomplete, then
PE
Y
the risk plan will also be weak and incomplete.
CT EL
• Therefore, it is critical in the Planning Phase to
UR
strategy for risks and their responses.
Risk Register • The Risk Register (or Risk Log) is key to the
identification, monitoring, and control of the risks
over the life of the project and must be considered
SU NIS
a living document.
OR
• * A Risk Register is "a repository in which outputs
ER OU
RI
of risk management processes are recorded."
PE
Y
• Risks should be reviewed on a regular basis during
CT EL
Project Execution when the project status is
reviewed in order to determine what risks should
LE ADE be closed, what new risks may need to be opened,
and how to respond to those risks.
SU NIS
OR
ER OU
RI
PE
Y
CT EL
LE ADE
UR
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
Basic Quality Tool Descriptions
Cause and Effect Diagram: "a decomposition technique that helps trace an undesirable
effect back to its root cause."
SU NIS
OR
Flowchart: "the depiction in a diagram format of the inputs, process actions, and outputs
ER OU
of one or more processes within a system."
RI
Checksheet: "a tally sheet that can be used as a checklist when gathering data."
PE
Y
Pareto Diagram: "a histogram, ordered by frequency of occurrence, that shows how many
CT EL
results were generated by each identified cause."
LE ADE
Histogram: "A bar chart that shows the graphical representation of numerical data."
Control Chart: "a graphic display of process data over time and against established control
Scatter Diagram: "a correlation chart that uses a regression line to explain or to predict
how the change in an independent variable will change a dependent variable."
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
Basic Quality
Tools
Project 1. Management Reviews: these are typically summary level
reviews of the quality metrics, the projects major
Reviews & accomplishments, and status. The frequency of these reviews
SU NIS
depends on the guidelines used within an organization. A
Types
OR
monthly frequency is common. Management reviews can also
include phase gate reviews. * A phase gate review is "a review
ER OU
RI
at the end of a phase in which a decision is made to continue to
PE
Project reviews conducted
Y
the next phase, to continue with modification, or to end a
to monitor and control the project."
CT EL
quality performance and 2. Team Reviews: these are typically more detail-level reviews of
LE ADE
expectations of the project
and the product (result or
the quality metrics, project accomplishments, progress, and
performance, with an emphasis on how efficient the processes
UR
service) being produced. are for managing the project. Issues and risks are also reviewed
in these meetings in detail to ensure an acceptable closure rate
and resolution as well as review corrective actions needed for
metrics outside their variance limit. These reviews could be held
as often as daily, however weekly is common.
Project 3. Customer Reviews: these are typically summary
level reviews with a focus on the production and
Reviews & acceptance of the deliverables of the project. These
reviews discuss any quality concerns related to the
SU NIS
Types
OR
deliverables as well as provide a general review of project
status. These reviews could happen monthly or timed
ER OU
RI
with the production of key deliverables over the life of the
The reviews are intended to
PE
Y
project.
provide a mechanism to review
CT EL
4. Post Project Reviews: this is a specialized review
the quality metrics as well as to
held during the Project Closing Phase. This review is used
review discussions around
LE ADE
risks, issues, and changes as
they relate to project
to collect feedback from Stakeholders as to what went
well on the project and what could be improved for future
UR
projects. A key outcome of this review is the collection of
performance and to control lessons learned and best practices that can be used in
overall quality. future projects.
Quality A quality audit "is a structured, independent process to
determine if project activities comply with organizational
Audits and project policies, processes, and procedures.“
SU NIS
OR
The purpose of the quality audit is to review the
efficiency of the project and the processes used on the
ER OU
RI
project.
PE
Y
Audits should not be used to resolve project conflicts or
CT EL
issues, as those should be addressed immediately by the
Project Manager as part of the management of the
LE ADE project and leading the team through the project.
UR
Audits are conducted by someone outside of the project,
but typically from within the organization - such as a
member of the Project Management Office.
Plan
Management
Communication
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR
LE ADE
CT EL
UR
ER OUY
SU NIS
PE
RI
OR