Paper ANITOLAARMANDVOKSHI
Paper ANITOLAARMANDVOKSHI
Paper ANITOLAARMANDVOKSHI
net/publication/298748789
Santiago Calatrava, City of Arts and Science: The Similarity of the Elements
CITATIONS READS
4 21,710
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Ani Tola on 17 March 2016.
1
Polytechnic University of Tirana
Faculty of Architecture and Urbanism
Tirana, Albania
Abstract. This paper presents a description of the buildings of the City of Arts
and Science and defines the key elements that Calatrava uses in the designing of
this complex.
In the beginning is presented a general description of the City of Arts and
Science. A further analysis is been done for each building, which is based in the
context of the concept that Calatrava uses. Also is done an analysis in the
context of shape, structure and materials, which are very connected with the
concept of the architect. In the end, are analyzed also the elements that are
similar with his prior projects and how they have been developed. These
elements also have been served for his recent work.
The paper concludes that the key elements that Calatrava uses in this complex
are almost the key element that Calatrava has been used in the other prior
projects. These key elements which are also present in its recent works, creates
the design vocabulary that Calatrava uses in his projects.
1 Introduction
This paper introduces a description of the buildings of the City of Arts and Science
and defines the key elements that Calatrava uses in the designing of this complex.
The opening provides a general description of the City of Arts and Science. The
city of Arts and Sciences is an urban recreation center of culture and science that was
completely developed by Santiago Calatrava. It also incorporates L‟Oceanogràfic, an
underwater city designed by the late Felix Candela. This complex is made up by
seven building such as, L'Hemisfèric, The Science Museum Principe Felipe,
L‟Umbracle, El Palau de les Arts Reina, L'Oceanogràfic, the bridge El Pont de l'Assut
de l'Or and the last but not least, L'Àgora.
After that, it describes each of the composing buildings. It contains general
information for each building and describes the architectural and engineering
concepts and elements.
A further analysis has been done for each of the composed buildings. This analysis
is based in the context of the concept that Calatrava uses, such as the human being
and nature. It also gives an analysis in the context of shape, structure and materials,
which are connected to each other and the concept of the architect.
In the end, it also analyses the elements that are similar to each other and his prior
projects and how they have been developed. These elements have also been compared
to his recent work.
“As the site is close to the sea, and Valencia is so dry, I decided to make water a
major element for the whole site using it as a mirror for the architecture.” 1
1 Santiago Calatrava
2 Alexander Tzonis; Santiago Calatrava - The complete works (2007); pp.216;
3 Joseph M.Valerio; Valerio Dewalt Train : Architecture (1999); Barcelona, pp. 150-160
3 Architect’s Biography
“Santiago Calatrava Valls was born on the 28th of July 1951 in Benimàmet, an old
municipality now integrated as an urban part of Valencia, Spain. He is a Spanish
architect, sculptor and structural engineer whose principal office is in Zürich,
Switzerland.
In Valenzia, he pursued his undergraduate architecture degree at the Polytechnic
University of Valencia along with a post-graduate course in urbanism. During his
schooldays, he also undertook independent projects with a group of fellow students,
bringing out two books on the vernacular architecture of Valencia and Ibiza.
Following graduation in 1975, he enrolled in the Swiss Federal Institute of
Technology in Zürich, Switzerland, for graduate work in civil engineering. In 1981,
after completing his doctoral thesis on “The Foldability of Space Frames", he started
his architecture and engineering practice.
Calatrava's early career was mainly dedicated to bridges and train stations, with
designs that elevated the status of civil engineering projects to new heights. His
Montjuic Communications Tower in Barcelona, Spain (1991) in the heart of the 1992
Olympics site, as well as the Allen Lambert Galleria in Toronto, Canada (1992), were
important works and turning points in his career, leading to a wide range of
commissions. The Quadracci Pavilion (2001) of the Milwaukee Art Museum was his
first building in the United States. Calatrava's entry into high-rise design began with
an innovative 54-story-high twisting tower called Turning Torso (2005), located in
Malmö, Sweden. Calatrava has also designed a futuristic train station, the World
Trade Center Transportation Hub, at the rebuilt World Trade Center in New York
City.
His style has been heralded as bridging the division between structural engineering
and architecture. In his projects, he continues a tradition of Spanish modernist
engineering that included Félix Candela, Antonio Gaudí, and Rafael Guastavino.
Nonetheless, his style is also very personal and derives from numerous studies of the
human body and the natural world.4
Completely designed by Santiago Calatrava, this building was the first one that
was opened to the public in April 1998. L‟Hemisferic is the centerpiece of this
complex, with a surface of 13,000 m2. Its position in the site is very well thought by
the architect, as it is set in a slightly below grade to avoid the conflict of the view with
the two others buildings, “Science Museum” and “Palacio de las Artes”.
The building is meant to resemble a giant eye, is also known as the “Eye of
knowledge”. Taking a look to Calatrava‟s sketches, we can easily read that his
inspiration for the concept of this building was the eye.
The whole shape of the eye will be drawn by a mirror plan, which will be the
surface of the water. The building is surrounded in all of its parts by a water pool, and
the bottom of the pool is made of glass. The accessibility from the building to the pool
is made up of two sides that are the curved axes of the “eye”. These two sides are
designed as the eyelid, which opens and closes to create this access with the water
pool and they also serve as a shade-shutter. The structure of the “eyelid”, the shutter,
is built by aluminum awnings alongside the perimeter that fold upward collectively or
as individual units. This structure of the shutter forms the brise-soleil roof that opens
alongside the elliptical axis of the eye. The brise-soleil is moved hydraulically up the
outside of the structure by telescoping cylinders. When this brise-soleil is opened, we
can see the dome that is conceived as the pupil of the eye.
In “The Dome” part of the Hemisferic are designed the IMAX Cinema,
Planetarium and a Laserium. This planetarium is a half-sphere composed of concrete
110 meters long and 55.5 meters wide. The IMAX Theater‟s spherical exterior is
vestured in fragments of shattered tiles. The structural concrete and steel shell creates
a vault above the planetarium. The concrete encasement is extended upwards to the
other parts of the “eye”, in which are the entrances for the building. In those parts, the
brise-soleils of the “eyelid” shutter are narrowed and replaced by a slat structure in
the both sides of pivoting point of the concrete shell. They imitate the structure of a
feather.
There are three main elements which Calatrava used in the L‟Hemispheric; the
Eye, the Brise-Soleil and the Swooping Anchor.
Through the metaphor of an eye, the architect‟s eye is frequently present in the
work of Calatrava. The planetarium is the most explicit reference to the human eye,
and his sketches for the project make this link clear. He always expresses the relation
between human body and architecture. The eye shape element was present in the
other prior projects that Calatravas uses before designing the L‟Hemisferic. The half
sphere necessary for the projection of IMAX movies is the kind of geometric form
that stimulates the imagination of Calatrava. It also represents the human eye, and
also the sphere of the cosmos.
The movement of the structural elements that Calatrava uses is present in this
project in the Brise Soleil, which serves as a sunshade for the building. Also this
element further heightens the expression of his fascination with vision.
The second principal building is The Science Museum Principe Felipe, which is
also completely designed by Santiago Calatrava. It is designed in 1991-1995 and
constructed 1996-2001. Its surface occupies around 40,000 m² on three floors. The
building is made up of three floors of which 26,000 square meters are used for
exhibitions, which is currently the largest in Spain. The first floor has a beautiful view
of the Turia Garden that surrounds it; which is over 13,500 square meters of water. In
the second floor is “The Legacy of Science”, an exhibition by the researchers;
Santiago Ramón y Cajal, Severo Ochoa y Jean Dausset. The third floor is known as
the “Chromosome Forest”, which shows the sequencing of human DNA.
Also on this floor are the “Zero Gravity,” the “Space Academy,” and “Marvel
Superheroes” exhibitions. This magnificent building stands 220 meters long, 80
meters wide and 55 meters high10. It looks just like a brilliant idea, from a very
innovative mind of Calatrava. The sunken garden extends beneath the walkway to
optically connect the museum to the administrative buildings. The shape of the
building resembles the skeleton of a whale. The structure of the building demonstrates
the skeleton and is the only architectural element. This prehistoric skeleton is
designed by the repetition of the one element, which is like the bone of the skeleton.
This element serves as a modular that is repeated in constant distance from each other
in the direction of the longitude of the building. They are the primitives of the shape
for this building. The symmetrical ends of the building are braced firmly by
triangulated structures which also mark the entrances.
Calatrava uses only three materials: white concrete that is the skeleton, the glass
that gives transparence all the building, and the steel, which is the structure of the
glass. The building‟s architecture is known for its geometry, structure, use of
materials, and its design around nature 11. The white supporting concrete framework of
the south-facing facade is filled with glass. The north facade is a glass and steel
screen that forms a continuous curtain along the full length of the building. This is a
modular development of 104 meters width and 241 meters in length.
There are three main elements which Calatrava used in Museum Principe Felipe;
the Eye, the Tree structure and the Bones and Skeleton.
The eye shape always remains a key element in Santiago Calatrava‟s work. He also
uses the shape of the eye, in a smaller scale in the Science Museum Principe Felipe
than the base shape of L‟Hemisferic. This building is just like a miniature of the
Hemisferic. Also in the center of it are designed even the brise-soleil, which are the
eyelid of Hemisferic, as the pupil of the eye in this building.
L‟Umbracle (Promenade and Car Park), which is located on the Southern facade of
the complex, is the latest contribution of Santiago Calatrava‟s to the unique and
comprehensive complex of the City of Arts and Sciences. The L‟Umbracle was
designed during 1995-1997 and constructed from 1997 until 2001, when it was
opened to the public. The 320 meter long and 60 meter wide structure houses parking
spaces for 900 cars and 20 busses. The promenade that is in the upper level has a
surface of 50,860 m2. The Umbracle is a space that is a home to numerous sculptures
surrounded by nature. It harbors in its interior The Walk of the Sculptures, an outdoor
art gallery with sculptures from contemporary artists. It was designed as an entrance
12 Cathedral of St. John the Devine, New York City, USA; By Santiago Calatrava; 1991.
13 Brookfield Place (BCE Place), Toronto, Canada; By Santiago Calatrava; 1987-92
14 Spandau Station, Berlin, Germany; By Santiago Calatrava; 1991
15 Oriente Station, Lisbon, Portugal; By Santiago Calatrava; 1993-98
16 Kuwait Pavilion, Seville, Spain; by Santiago Calatrava; 1991-92
17 Shadow Machine, New York, USA; By Santiago Calatrava; 1992
to the City of Arts and Sciences. The upper part comprises a long panoramic
promenade, with a tree-lined garden, from where there is a superb view of the
Complex as a whole. Its 55 fixed arches and 54 floating arches that stand 18 meters
high make the “umbrella” of the garden. The plants in the garden were carefully
picked to change color with the seasons18. L‟Umbracle is intended as “a contemporary
reinvention of the winter garden”. The arches structure is made by steel construction,
and they are identical from the beginning to the end. Also in this building we have an
element that repeats in the longitude direction, with a constant distance. The material
that Calatrava uses in this project is the steel structure and it is white colored. This is a
very transparent structure because it lacks solid surfaces as well as the use of glass.
Which are the Key Elements that Calatrava uses in the design of The L’umbracle?
The tree elements that he uses in this building are; the steel arches, the tree pillars,
the mosaic tiles.
The concept of the Tree Pillars that Calatrava had been designed in the BCE
Place19 and the Steel Arch which joints the pillars, have been used and in the
construction of the L‟Umbracle‟s Promenade. With the same logic Calatrava has
designed his next project which is Olympic Game‟s Promenade 20.
18 http://www.arcspace.com/architects/calatrava/camino_moreras/index.html
19 Brookfield Place (BCE Place), Toronto, Canada; By Santiago Calatrava; 1987-92
20 Master Plan for the 2004 Olympic and Paraolympic Games, Athens, Greece; By S. Calatrava; 2001-4.
Fig. 11. The steel arches
In the parking level, Calatrava is using his tree pillars and they seem that they are
not only as o constructive solution, but they also stand in harmony with the function
of the upper level. The way how they are positioned in the tree pillars, is based on the
earlier studies that Calatrava has done for the Oriente Station21 in which the architect
sketches the trees of a dense forest.
For the aspiration of the parking level and for daylight Calatrava is using the conic
volumes, which are intersected by spherical volumes. In the circular open surface of
the conic surface, the architect uses blue mosaic tiles. We can see the influence of the
Gaudi‟s style.
The Palacio de las Artes Reine Sofia is an opera house and performing arts center.
Its surface is around 44,000 m2, and is 75 meter tall. The building is designed
completely by Santiago Calatrava during 1995-1997, and is constructed during 1997-
2005. In April of 2005 it was opened to the public. It contains four large rooms: a
Main Room, Magisterial Classroom, Amphitheater and Theater of Camera. It is
dedicated to music and the scenic arts. The Palau de Les Arts has four sections; the
main hall, the master hall, the auditorium, and the Martin y Soler theatre. It holds
many events such as opera, theatre and music in its auditoriums. The building has a
metallic feather outer roof that rests on two supports and is 230 meters long and 70
meters high. One of the supports allows for part of the building to overhang. The
building is supported by white concrete. Two laminated steel shells cover the building
weighing over 3,000 tons. These shells are 163 meters wide and 163 meters long22.
The Palacio de las Artes Reine Sofia was conceived as a series of casual volumes
which have been unified through their enclosure within two symmetrical shells. The
shells are made by concrete and are cut-away, to be crowned by a sweeping steel
sheath that project axially from the entrance concourse out over the uppermost
contours of the curvilinear envelope. This genius structure defines the identity of the
Palacio de las Artes Reine Sofia. The symbolic of the seashell that Calatrava
resembles, presents a dynamic effect as a signal in the landscape. While walking in
the promenade by outside, the different volumes looks like they are stacked between
the horizontal decks off the side of the structure. The nucleus part of the building is
occupied by the technical facilities, such as the scenery module and lifting
mechanisms for the stage and orchestra‟s pit of the opera house, and its fully air-
conditioned auditorium, which seats 1300, is set within an acoustically shaped shell
embedded within the cluster. In these different services, there is also a smaller
auditorium, which is conceived mainly for chamber music concerts, seats 400, and a
large auditorium to the east, which is partially protected beneath the open shell and
can seat around 2000 people.
Which are the Key Elements that Calatrava uses in the design of The Palacio De
Las Artes Reine Sofia?
22 http://www.arcspace.com/architects/calatrava/camino_moreras/index.html
Though in some views of this project may bring to mind Calatrava‟s Tenerife
Concert Hall23, he ventures here into different territory, approaching an almost
Surrealist range of shapes. The similar element might be the helmet that looks like a
head‟s snake. Also the types of the materials that are used in those two buildings are
the same, as always white concrete, steel and glass. Both of the buildings are seen as a
“monumental sculpture”.
Calatrava also uses a broken tile surface, which also shows the influence of Antonio
Gaudi, a figure Calatrava clearly admires. Also the Blue Mosaic Tiles are used in the
interior and the exterior of the Opera House.
El Pont de l'Assut de l'Or is a suspension bridge that connects the south side with
Minorca Street, whose 125 meters high pillar is the highest point in the city. It crosses
the Turia Gardes, the former riverbed of Turia River. The design of the bridge is made
by Santiago Calatrava, as a common design with the other bridges that has been done
before. The total length of the bridge is 180 meters, and the height is 125 meters,
which makes it the highest point of the city. The bridge was opened to the public in
2008.
Calatrava has used the white concrete and the steel for the construction. In this
structure there are 19 spans that are connected in two points, by the diagonal position
between the vertical wing and the horizontal path of the bridge 24.
23 Tenerife Concert Hall, Tenerife, Canary Island, Spain; By Santiago Calatrava; 1991-2003
24 http://www.arcspace.com/architects/calatrava/camino_moreras/index.html
Fig. 16. El Pont de l'Assut de l'Or bridge
Which are the key elements that Calatrava uses in the design of the El Pont De
L'assut De L'or?
This bridge brings in mind his famous bridge Alamillo Bridge 25 , which is one of
his earliest works. The El Pont de l'Assut de l'Or bridge, comes as a miniature of the
Alamillo Bridge. Almost every element is the same. The only differences between
them are the dimension and the proportion between the two edges of the triangle
shape of the bridge.
The structure of El Pont de l'Assut de l'Or bridge is based in the same concepts that
was designed the Alamillo Bridge. The Steel Cables are connected with the concrete
construction in the same method. They are lying in diagonal position, or better to say
as the hypotenuse of the triangle. Is very understandable the engineering skills that
Calatrava owns.Also the horizontal plan of the bridge serves as a path for vehicles and
pedestrians.
25 Alamillo Bridge and La Cartuja Viaduct, Seville, Spain; By Santiago Calatrava; 1987-92
5 Conclusions
Analyzing the above buildings of the City of Arts and Science, I can conclude that
the key elements that Calatrava uses in this complex are almost the key elements that
Calatrava has been using in the other prior projects. These elements that are present in
its recent works are the key elements that create the Calatrava‟s vocabulary design.
Calatrava in the complex presents some similarities in:
The concept that Calatrava uses in this Complex is always based in the human
being. The most common element is the shape of the eye, as the architect always says
that is the “eye of knowledge”. In addition to the human being, is presented and the
symbol of the nature forms such as the tree, the seashells, and the whale skeleton. In
his projects in the center of his concept is the relation of the forms in the nature and in
the human being. Studying the structure of this relation is the basement and for his
structural designs.
The shape, is not casual in Calatrava‟s designs, and also isn‟t as a resultant of the
site limits. Calatrava‟s shapes are drawn as an analysis of the rapports between
elements of a conceptual natural and human being. The architect brings in sketches,
not a copied shape but he carefully studies not only the geometrical element but also
the function that will be happening there and the sustainability in every aspect.
Studying in engineering school, Calatrava is not only an architect, but he is also an
engineer. His works are not only based in the principles of architecture but also they
are well thought in the principles from the mind of an engineer. Calatrava skills are
not only in imagination, but also he has strength skills in realizing his works. He uses
concrete and steel, as the important element. The structure elements, such as the
pillars, arches are based in the concept of nature, such as tree, human body, the
skeleton, etc.
Calatrava always uses three main materials such as, the white concrete, steel
structures, and glass. He is able to bring monumental volumes even with these
materials. Calatrava mostly presents vernacular architecture, and is influenced by the
Spanish architects. He develops the structural concept and he uses the characteristic of
the materials.
While some contemporary architects, who shall remain unnamed, seek innovation
in extravagant but often unusable forms, the vocabulary of Calatrava is rooted in a
sense of design and engineering which precedes more from within than from an
imposed and dysfunctional artistic ambition.
References