Train Control Systems in A Metro Railway 17.1 Role of Signalling in A Railway System
Train Control Systems in A Metro Railway 17.1 Role of Signalling in A Railway System
Role of Signalling in any kind of Railway System be it a Main Line System or a Suburban
System or a Metro System, is to enable Safe & Speedy Movements of Trains.
This would mean that each and every Apparatus, Component, Circuit and
Sub-system employed in the Signalling System shall be so designed that
a Failure occurring in any of its Component or Sub-system shall result in
a Safe side Failure of the System, as a whole.
(iv) Seamless Integration with all other associated Systems e.g. Integration of
Station Signalling with Block Signalling & Telecommunication Systems
and with Passenger Information Display Systems (PIDS) provided for the
Benefits of Travelling Public.
Principle listed at (i) above (No Compromise on Safety) is Sacrosanct in the Design of
any Signalling System. However, the way this Fail-safe Feature is incorporated, differ on
the type and quantum of Traffic to be dealt with.
Table 11.1 provides for the distinct Features of the two types of Rail Traffic obtainable
on Main Lines and Suburban / Metro Rails. These Features shall be the additional
governing Factors for the type of Signalling System to be provided on Metro Railway or
for that matter on a Main Line Railway.
Table 11.1
As seen from the above Comparison, the Headway Requirement in a Metro System is
significantly smaller as compared to that required on a Main Line Railway or even on a
conventional Suburban Railway Section and hence Aids to be provided to Drivers shall
play an important Role in deciding the kind of Signalling and type of Train Control
System to be provided on a Metro. While Automatic Train Protection (ATP) System,
preferably with Cab Signalling, and ATS (Automatic Train Supervision) shall be the
prime Requirements for a Metro System, the Safety Objectives could, perhaps, be met
with simple Provision of Spot based Train Protection & Warning System (TPWS) or
Automatic Warning System (AWS) on a Main Line Railway. If the Headway
Requirements for the Metro are envisaged as 90 seconds or so then the Provision of
Automatic Train Operation (ATO) System and Cab Signalling shall become inescapable.
In a Metro System, the Requirements of Headway to meet the Traffic Demands being
too stringent, Automation of the Signalling System to provide Continuous Automatic
Train Control (CATC) shall be the prime need.
Design Headway shall be of the order of 90 to 120 Seconds, as required, to meet the
Traffic Demands.
The Train Control & Signalling System for the Metro System shall comprise of following
Sub-subsystems:
(i) Automatic Train Protection (ATP) System with Cab Signalling. The
Track to Train communication shall be through Joint less Coded Audio
Frequency Track circuits (AFTCs).
While Automatic Train Protection (ATP) Sub-System & Automatic Train Supervision
(ATS) Sub-system shall be the essential for the Metro Signalling System, ATO may be
Optional. Provision of ATO shall, however, be inescapable if Headway Requirement of
90 Seconds or so is contemplated.
Train Control & Signalling Systems shall permit Manual Mode of Working viz. ‘Run on
Site (ROS)’ & ‘Cut-out’ Modes, to cater for the failure situations of CATC System. Line
side fixed Signals shall be provided for this purpose, in addition to Cab Signalling. Speed
in these Modes shall, however, be limited to 25 Kmph.
Mobile Train Radio Communication (MTRC) System shall be provided to enable the
Train Driver to contact Operations Control Centre (OCC) / Station Control Room (SCR)
in case of Emergency. The Train Radio System shall also interface with Train Control
and Signalling System to enable it to report the Alarm and Status of the Train-borne
Signalling Equipment to the OCC and for dynamic Registration of Train Identification
Number (TID) with the System.
The ATP Sub-system shall be the Hub to ensure Safety of Train Operations. This
System shall perform the following Functions:
(ii) Transfer the Information from the Track to Train about the position
of the Train ahead.
(iii) Measure the Speed of the Train and Control its Speed in
accordance with the position of the Train ahead.
(v) Cause Brake Application, if the Train Speed exceeds the Safe
Speed.
(vi) Detect ‘Roll Back’ of the Train and cause Brake Application in
such a contingency.
(vii) Ensure that the Train Deceleration Rate used for Braking is
reached within specified time of Service Brake Application otherwise
Application of Emergency Brakes should take place.
(viii) Provide Cab Signals and needed Displays for the Driver.
(x) Enable Train Doors Opening on Platform side when the Train is
Docked.
(xi) Prevent the Train from Starting if the Doors are detected ‘Not
Closed’.
The Main Function of Interlocking System shall be to provide the requisite Interlocking,
Control and Indication Functions as also support all the feasible Train Movements in the
Yard. The CBI shall be based on Entry-Exit System and shall have separate Controls,
upon Operation of which the Trains will be allowed to operate in Reverse Direction
except at Terminals and Turn-back Stations. The System shall interface with CATC
System.
(ii) Points are only moved, when all the Safety Conditions are met.
(iii) Signals only clear to a Proceed Aspect, when all the Safety Conditions
are fulfilled.
(iv) The System is Fail-safe and Failures shall not provoke an Unsafe
situation. Under Failure conditions, Signals shall display a Stop Aspect
and Points shall not be moved and shall remain in their last operated
position.
The Routes may be set in either Normal Mode or Automatic (Fleet) Mode. Fleet Mode
shall be applicable to Routes with Points setting restricted to Normal (Straight) position
only.
In Normal Operation, the Route shall be released by the Train movement, if the Route is
not set in the Fleet Mode. However, it shall be possible for an Operator to release the
Route with a specific Local / Remote Control, as per the Requirements of Operations as
also to meet the Emergent situations.
The Interlocking System, on receipt of a Route Remote Control from the Local ATS (the
Command either originated from the Central ATS (CATS) or the Local ATS itself (LATS),
shall permit to:
(i) Control and Lock the Points to the position required by the Route.
The Interlocking System on Stations of Metro Railway shall essentially be of Solid State
type and Computer based. Besides the usual Interlocking Functions of Route Setting,
Route Locking, Clearance of Signals and Automatic Sequential Release of Route after
the passage of Train on the envisaged Route, the Interlockings to be provided at Metro
Stations shall have to be equipped with following additional Features:
(i) The System shall interface with Continuous Automatic Train Control
(CATC) System.
ATS shall have two Components Local ATS (LATS) and Centralized ATS
(CATS).
When the links with the LATS are lost, an Emergency Switch on the
Control cum Indication Panel (CCIP) and / or a Control Terminal with
VDU Display shall transfer the Control of the Panel to CATS.
Train Operated Route Release (TORR) does not cause the Route to be
Reset in this Mode of Route Control.
A ‘Cycle Setting Control’ received from the ATS or the Control cum
Indication Panel / Control Terminal shall set a pre-determined Cycle of
Operations in the Interlocking. The Cycle can be simple (Control of two
Routes) or combined (Control of Multiple Routes alternately with a
preferential first Route).
When the Interlocking receives such a Control, the Cycle will be set in the
Interlocking, if the following conditions are satisfied:
(c) The Maintenance Block for the Cycle Routes is not Set.
(c) The Berthing Track circuit (s) of this Route are occupied.
Cycle Un-setting:
If the Controller controls the Cancellation of a Route that is Set and that
belongs to a particular Cycle then the latter shall be Un-set immediately.
(b) Any given Traffic Direction Variable that is Set shall Un-set
when the associated Route Locking section releases.
The Release of the Set Traffic Direction shall be made possible if a Route
Control Command in the opposite Direction is received from the ATS or
from the Interlocking itself when a Cycle is Set in the Interlocking.
One Timer shall be used for each Turn-back Track. The Time-out for the
Timer shall be 45 - 60 sec. This Value shall be programmable.
For reversing the Traffic Direction, the Interlocking shall carry out the
following processing:
(a) If the Interlocking has received a Command from the LATS
to set the succeeding Route in the currently established
Direction of Traffic or if such a setting has been
automatically controlled in the Interlocking by specifying
the relevant Cycle in the Interlocking then if all the
conditions for Route Locking are satisfied then the
succeeding Route shall be set.
(c) If all the above conditions are met then the Interlocking
shall Release the current Traffic Direction, Reset and Stop
the Timer and Set the Reverse Traffic Direction.
The Train Control & Signalling System shall be based on Fail-safe Computers and
Safety-critical Software. The System shall be configured with Fibre Optic Transmission
System (FOTS) based WAN as the backbone of transmission of both vital and non-vital
information between CBIs and Trackside ATP equipments. The Track side Systems
shall be connected to the Central ATS (CATS) System at the Operation Control Centre
(OCC) again through the FOTS for performing the function of Supervision and
Regulation of Traffic on the line.
ATP is a Vital Safety System of Safety Integrity Level (SIL) ‘4’ and is made up of a
number of Sub-systems which maintain the Safety of Train Operation including the
Separation of Trains, Enforcement of Speed Restrictions, and Safe Operation through
Interlockings.
The Interlocking and associated Sub-systems cater for the Route Protection Functions.
Track circuits are used by the Interlocking for the Track Vacancy Detection and in a
specific Variant of ATP System for the Data Transmission from Track to Train as well.
ATP System has two main Components – the Train-borne & Trackside. Important
Functions performed by these two Components in case of a typical variant of the ATP
System, the ‘Distance-to-Go’ type, are as under:
(i) Reception of Signal and Line Information from the Wayside Units (ATP
Wayside equipments, Beacons and Loops).
Based on the Dynamic Track related Speed Profiles, the ATP System
monitors and enforces the changes in the Target Distance / Target
Speed, thus maintaining a safe Distance between Trains.
Releasing Doors on the correct side at Stations when the Train has come
to a Stop within the Stopping Window (- 0.7 m to + 1.0 m).
The System ensures that no movement of Train is possible until all Train
Doors are detected Closed & Locked. Loss of Door Closed Signal causes
the ATP System to initiate a Brake Application.
The System ensures that the Train observes the permitted speed within
the Speed Restriction Section until the Tail end of the Train has passed
the end Point of the Section.
(i) Storage of Line Parameters like Line Gradient, Curve, Track section
length, Civil Speed Restriction Sections, Temporary Speed Restriction
Sections, and Station Stopping Points etc.
Following are the three different Implementations of Automatic Train Protection (ATP)
System:
Block Schematic of a Fixed Block ATP System is shown in Figure 17.9. As seen from
the Figure in this version of ATP, there shall be two Red Signals protecting a Train and
an unoccupied Overlap Block between the two Trains – Train ‘1’ & Train ‘2’ to provide for
the full Safe Braking Distance. Though the Figure 17.9 shows the Block Signals on the
Line side, many ATP equipped Systems may not have Visible Line side Signals as in
those Systems, the Signal Indications are transmitted directly to the Driver’s Cab
Console.
Each Block carries a Speed Code. Speed Code corresponds to the Speed permitted in
that Block. If the Train tries to enter a Zero Speed Block or if it enters a section at a
Speed higher than that authorised by the Speed Code, the On-board Computer shall
cause an Emergency Brake Application. Victoria Line of the London Underground
System is equipped with the Fixed Block ATP System. The System provided is a simple
System with only three Speed Codes - Normal, Caution and Stop (Figure 17.10).
A modern version of Fixed Block ATP provides for two pieces of Information for the On-
board Computer, about the State of the Line ahead – (a) What Speed can it do in this
Block ? and (b) What Speed must it be doing by the time it enters the next Block? This
Speed Data is picked up by Antenna on the Train. The Data is coded by the Track side
electronic equipment and transmitted from the Rails to the Train. The Code Data
consists of two parts, the authorised Speed Code for this Block and the Target Speed
Code for the next Block. The Figure 17.11 shows how this works.
A Train (Train ‘2’) in Block A5 approaching Signal A4 will receive a 40 over 40 Code
(40/40) to indicate a Permitted Speed of 40 Kmph in this Block and a Target Speed of 40
Kmph for the next. However, when it enters Block A4, the Code will change to 40/25
because the Target Speed must be 25 Kmph when the Train enters the next Block A3.
When the Train enters Block A3, the Code changes again to 25/0 because the next
Block (A2) is the Overlap Block and is the Forbidden Territory. Speed, therefore, must
be zero by the time Train reaches the end of Block A3. If the Train attempts to enter
Block A2, the On-board Computer will detect the Zero Speed Code (0/0) and will cause
an Emergency Brake Application. As mentioned above, Block A2 is acting as the
Overlap or Safe Braking Distance behind the Train (Train ‘1’) occupying the Block A1.
Fixed Block ATP System is suitable for handling Traffic Density Levels ‘Medium to Low’.
Trains operating over a line equipped with ATP can be manually or automatically driven.
To allow manual driving, the ATP Codes are displayed to the Driver on a Panel in his
Cab. In the Example shown in Figure 17.12, Driver would begin Braking somewhere
around the Brake Point (‘#’) because he would see the 40/25 Code on his Display and
would know, from his knowledge of the Line, where he will have to stop. If Signals are
not provided, the Signal Positions may be indicated by Trackside Block Marker Boards
to show the Drivers the entrances to Blocks.
If the Train is installed with Automatic Driving (ATO - Automatic Train Operation), Brake
Initiation for the reduced Target Speed can be by either a Track mounted Electronic
‘Patch’ or ‘Beacon’ placed at the Brake Initiation Point or, more simply, by the change in
the Coded Track circuit. Both Systems are used by different Manufacturers but, in both,
the Train passes through a series of ‘Speed Steps’ to the Signalled Stop.
Drawback in the Fixed Block ATP System is the space lost by the Empty Overlap Block
behind each Train. If this could be eliminated, the Line Capacity could be significantly
increased, depending on the Block Lengths and Line Speed. In the Figure 17.13, the
Train in Block A1 causes a series of Speed Reduction Steps behind it so that, if a
following Train enters Block A6, it will get a reduced Target Speed. As it continues
towards the Zero Speed Block A2, it gets a further Target Speed Reduction at each new
Block until it stops at the end of Block A3. It will stop before entering Block A2, the
Overlap Block. This Braking Curve is shown as the Braking Curve ‘1’.
To remove the Overlap section, it is simply a question of moving the above Braking
Curve forward by one Block. The Train will now be able to proceed at Normal Speed a
Block closer (A5 instead of A6) to the Occupied Block, before it gets a Target Speed
Reduction. However, to get this close to the Occupied Block requires accurate and
constant checking of the Braking by the Train. The On-board Computer calculates the
Braking Curve required, based on the ‘Distance to Go’ to the Stopping Point and using a
Line Map contained in the On-board Computer’s Memory. The New Curve is shown as
‘Distance to Go’ Braking Curve. A Safety Margin of 25 m or so is allowed for error so
that the Train will always stop before it reaches the critical boundary between Blocks A2
and A1. Note that the Braking Curve should reduce (or flare out’) at the final Stopping
Point in order to give the Passengers a comfortable stop.
Speed Monitoring:
Both the older, ‘Speed Step’ Method and ‘Distance-to-Go’ Method require the Train
speed to be monitored. In Figure 17.13, we can see the Braking Curve ‘1’ of the Speed
Step System always remains inside the Profile of the Speed Steps. The Train’s ATP
equipment only monitors the Train’s Speed against the Permitted Speed limit within that
Block. If the Train goes above that Speed, an Emergency Brake Application will be
invoked. The Braking Curve ‘1’, as such, is not monitored.
In the ‘Distance-to-Go’ System, the Braking Curve is monitored continuously so that the
Speed Steps become unnecessary. When it enters the first Block with a Speed
Restriction in the Code, the Train is also told how far ahead the Stopping Point is. The
On-board Computer knows where the Train is now, using the Line Map embedded in its
Memory, and it calculates the required Braking Curve accordingly. As the Train brakes,
the Computer checks the progress down the Curve to check the Train never goes
outside it. To ensure that the Wheel Revolutions used to count the Train’s progression
along the Line have not drifted due to wear, skidding or sliding, the On-board Map of the
Line is updated regularly during the trip by fixed, Track-mounted Beacons (called
Location Beacons) laid between the Rails.
Distance-to-Go ATP System is suitable for handling High Traffic Density Level.
‘Distance-to-Go’ ATP System has a number of advantages over the Speed Step
System. It can increase the Line Capacity and can also reduce the number of Track
circuits required, since frequent changes of steps to keep adjusting the Braking Distance
are not needed. The Blocks are now just the spaces to be occupied by Trains and are
not used as Overlaps as well. ‘Distance-to-Go’ can be used for Manual Driving as well
as for Automatic Operation.
Systems may vary in configuration but usually, several Curves are provided for the Train
Braking Profile. Figure 17.14 shows three: One is the Normal Braking Curve within
which the Train should brake, the second is a Warning Braking Curve, which provides a
Warning to the Driver (a Service Brake Application Alarm) and the third is the
Emergency Braking Curve which will force an Emergency Brake if the Driver does not
reduce Speed to within the Normal Braking Curve.
As the Signalling Technology has developed, there have been many Refinements to the
Block System but, in recent years, the Emphasis has been on attempts to get rid of
Fixed Blocks altogether. Getting rid of Fixed Blocks has the advantage that we can vary
the distances between Trains according to their Actual Speeds and according to their
Speeds in relation to each other. It’s rather like applying the Freeway (Highway) Rules
for Speed Separation. One does not need to be a Full Speed Braking Distance from the
Car in front because that Car won’t stop dead. If the following Car is moving at the same
Speed as the Car ahead, the second Car, in theory, can travel immediately behind the
first Car and, when the first Car brakes, the second Car also does the Braking. If a few
metres are allowed for Reaction Time to the Brake Lights and Variations in Braking
Performance of the First Car, the System should work well.
In the Figure 17.15, as long as each Train is travelling at the same Speed as the one in
front and they all have the same Braking Capabilities, they can, in theory, run as close
together as a few metres. Allowing some room for Reaction Time and small errors and
Trains could run as close together, say as 50 m or so. In practical Implementation,
however, it is essential to maintain a Safe Braking Distance between Trains at all times.
The System so implemented is termed as Moving Block ATP System. The Block
Locations and Lengths in this System are in consonance with Train Locations and
Speeds, i.e. the Blocks are Movable rather than Fixed. This flexibility usually requires
Radio Transmission, sometimes called Communications Based Train Control (CBTC) or
Transmission Based Signalling (TBS) rather than Track circuit Transmission, to detect
the Location, Speed and Direction of Trains and to tell the Trains their Permitted
Operating Speed.
On a Moving Block equipped ATP, the Line is usually divided into Areas or Regions,
each Area under the control of a Computer and each with its own Radio Transmission
System. Each Train transmits its Identity, Location, Direction and Speed to the Area
Computer which makes the necessary calculations for Safe Train Separation and
transmits this to the following Train (Figure 17.16).
The Radio Link between each Train and the Area Computer is continuous so the
Computer knows the Location of all the Trains in its Area all the time. It transmits to
each Train the location of the Train in front and gives it a Braking Curve to enable it to
stop before it reaches that Train. In effect, it is a dynamic ‘Distance-to-Go’ System.
One Fixed Block Feature has been retained - the requirement for a Full Speed Braking
Distance between Trains. This ensures that, if the Radio Link is lost, the latest Data
retained On-board will cause the following Train to stop before it reaches the preceding
Train.
In a Moving Block System, each Train also confirms its own position on the Ground from
Beacons, located at Intervals along the Track, which recalibrate the Train’s position
compared with the On-board Computerised Line Map (Figure 17.16).
Transferring a Train from one Area to another is also carried out by using the Radio
Links and, additionally by a Link between the two adjacent Area Computers. The Areas
overlap each other so, when a Train first reaches the boundary of a new Area, the
Computer of the first Area contacts the Computer of the second Area and alerts it to
listen for the new Train’s Signal. It also tells the Train to change its Radio Codes to
match the new Area. When the new Area picks up the ID of the Train it acknowledges
the handover from the first Area and the Transfer is complete.
Another version of the Moving Block System has the Location Computers on the Trains.
Each Train knows where it is in relation to all the other Trains and sets its Safe Speeds
using this Data. It has the advantage that there is less wayside equipment required than
with the Area Computer System but the amount of Transmissions is much greater.
Moving Block ATP System is used for handling Very High Level of Traffic Density.
Moving Block System, besides catering for Very High Levels of Traffic Density offers
following distinct advantages in comparison over other two Systems:
(i) Moving Block System with Radio Transmission requires less Wayside
Equipment than the Fixed Block & Distance-to-Go Systems. Reduced
Wayside Equipment leads to reduced Installation & Maintenance Costs.
(ii) Better Reliability and quicker Fault Location is possible with the Moving
Block Technology.
Comparative Analysis:
Comparative Analysis of the three Variants of ATP Systems viz. Fixed Block, Distance-
to-Go & Moving Block in respect of the built-in Protective Features and Capacity for
handling Low / Medium / High Traffic Density Levels is given in following Table:
Table 17.4
Data Transmission between Track side & On-board Equipment of an Automatic Train
Protection (ATP) System can be handled in two ways:
The System using Coded Track circuits is known as the ‘Continuous’ Transmission
System because Data is passing to the Train all the time. However, it does have its
limitations. There are Transmission Losses over longer Blocks and this reduces the
effective length of a Track circuit to about 350 m. The Equipment is also expensive and
vulnerable to bad weather, electronic interference, damage, vandalism and theft. To
overcome some of these drawbacks, a solution using Intermittent Transmission of Data
is employed. It uses Electronic Beacons placed at Intervals along the Track.
In a typical System employing Beacons for Data Transmission (Figure 17.21), there are
two Beacons, a Location Beacon to tell the Train where it is and a Signalling Beacon to
give the Status of the Sections ahead. The Beacons are sometimes referred to as
‘Balises’. Data Processing and the other ATP Functions are similar to the Continuous
Transmission System.
In Figure 17.22, the Beacon for Red Signal A2 is located before Signal A1 to give the
Approaching Train ‘2’ room to stop. Train ‘2’ will get its Stopping Command here so that
it stops before it reaches the Beacon for Signal A3.
In Figure 17.23, the Train has stopped in front of Signal A2 and will wait until Train ‘1’
clears Block A2 and the Signal changes to Green.
A disadvantage of the above variant of Beacon System is that once a Train has received
a Message indicating a Reduced Speed or Stop, it will retain that Message until it has
passed another Beacon or has stopped. This means that if the Block ahead is cleared
before Train ‘2’ reaches its Stopping Point and the Signal changes to Green, the Train
will still have the Stop Message and will stop, even though it doesn't have to. To avoid
the situation of an unnecessary stop, an Intermediate Beacon is provided (Figure
17.24). This updates the Train as it approaches the Stopping Point and will revoke the
Stop Command if the Signal has cleared. More than one Intermediate Beacon can be
provided, if required.
(ii) The Wayside ATP equipment and On-board ATP equipment shall have a
Fault-Tolerant equipment Design using Redundancies or other Design
Features to ensure that a High Level of Train Service is maintained in the
presence of Single Point Failure and also ensure achievement of the
Availability, as specified. Availability is enhanced by employing
Redundant Systems.
(iii) The wayside ATP equipment and On-board ATP equipment are
configured in a Fail-Safe arrangement with suitable Redundancies
conforming to Safety Integrity Level ‘4’ (SIL - 4), as defined in CENELEC
Standard EN50129.
Figures 17.3 & 17.4 provide the Block Schematics for ‘2-out-of-2’ and ‘2-
out-of-3’ Configurations.
In a typical ‘2-out-of-2’ Configuration (Figure 17.3), two independent,
Instruction-synchronised and Identically Programmed Microcomputers
with the same Structure are used. The Process Data is read into each
Channel in Parallel and processed synchronously. The Statuses after
sequences of Process Steps and the Test and Output Data generated
during the Process Steps are checked to ensure that they are the same.
Two Comparators, which are independent of each other and of the
Microcomputers, permit the Output to the Process if the Information from
two Computers tallies. If the Comparators detect an error, either one can
initiate a safety Shut down of the System. The Design of the System
ensures that a Shut down always blocks the Process and a Fail-safe
State is reached.
(v) Redundancy for the On-board ATP Equipment is catered for to provide
for Enhanced Availability. It can be done in either the same Cab or
between the Front and Rear Cabs so that the failure of one On-board
ATP equipment does not prevent the Train from being run in Revenue
Service. There will be Dynamic Data Exchange between the two Units
either in the same Cab or in the Front and Rear Cabs, with Automatic
Changeover without Driver’s Intervention in the event of failure of one
Unit with an Indication in the Cab.
(vi) Software:
The Software of the On-board and Track side ATP equipment comprises
of:
(a) System Programs for the internal working of the
Microcomputers and the Communication between them,
providing Fail-safe processing of all Data.
(b) Application Programs, which implement the Functions
of the ATP System. Application Programs have to be
Modular in Structure and required to be approved for Fail-
safe Operation by an Independent Authority. The
associated Compiler is also needed to be checked to
ensure its error-free Operation and Validated by an
Independent Authority.
Principle of Operation:
Refer to Figure 17.5 for the Block Schematic of the ATP System, which illustrates the
constituting Components / Sub-systems and their inter-relationship.
The ATP Trackside Units extract Driving Instructions from the Data of the Interlocking &
Track Vacancy Detection System and from the Planning Data and transmit it to the ATP
On-board Unit. Driving Instructions in the Distance-to-Go ATP System consist of Target
Coordinates – the Target Distance & Target Speed, the Maximum permitted Line Speed
and the Line Gradient.
The On-board ATP System has the Information of the Train Data (Characteristics of the
Rolling Stock) & Route Map in the form of Invariants, stored in its Memory. Armed with
the State of Route and Movement Authority in the form of Variants (Status of Track
circuits, Route Set, Points etc) as received from Trackside Units, the On-board ATP
calculates the Speed-Distance Profile with Supervision to a fixed Target Point.
The Actual Speed of the Train and Distance covered are continuously measured with the
aid of Odometer Pulse Generators (OPG).
If the Train exceeds the permitted Speed at the current position, the ATP On-borne Unit
initiates irrevocable application of Emergency Brakes, after issuing a Warning, which
brings the Train to a Stop before the Emergency Brakes are released and Service can
be continued ahead.
Track-to-Train Transmission:
ATO (Automatic Train Operation) is the non-vital part of Train Operation, related to
Station Stops, Starts and running from Station to Station.
(i) Automatic Control of Train running from Station to Station (without the
Intervention of Train Driver), while remaining within the Safety Envelope
calculated by the ATP. The ATO System generates the Speed Control to
the Traction and Braking System of the Train with respect to the
computed Speed Profile. The System ensures that the Train achieves
timely, accurate and smooth Station Stops or stops ahead of a Restrictive
Point.
(ii) Automatic Opening of Train Doors during Station Stops under the
Supervision of the ATP System, without the Intervention of Train Driver.
(iii) Automatic Closing of Train Doors after the lapse of Station Dwell Time
under the Supervision of the ATS System, again without the Intervention
of Train Driver.
ATO System tells the Train approaching a Station where to stop so that the complete
Train is in the Platform. This is assuming that the ATP has confirmed that the Line is
Clear. The Sequence of Station Stopping operates as shown in Figure 17.25.
The Train approaches the Station under Clear Signals to do a normal run in. When it
reaches the first Beacon - either a Looped Cable or a fixed Transponder, a Station Brake
Command is received by the Train. The On-board Computer calculates the Braking
Curve to enable it to stop at the correct point and, as the Train runs in towards the
Platform, the Curve is updated a number of times (it varies from System to System) to
ensure Accuracy of Stop.
London’s Victoria Line, has up to 13 points checking for the Train Speed as it brakes into
a Station. This high number of Checks is needed because the On-board Braking Control
gives only three fixed Rates of Deceleration. Even then, Stopping Accuracy obtainable
is ± 2 m. Modern Metro Systems require less wayside Checking because of the
Dynamic and more accurate On-board Braking Curve calculations. Modern Installations
can achieve ± 0.15 m Stopping Accuracy, which is 14 times better than achievable on
London’s Victoria Line.
The ATO caters for correct Docking of the Train at Platform as explained above.
When the Train has stopped, it verifies that its Brakes are applied and checks that it has
stopped within the Door Enabling Loops (Figure 17.26). These Loops verify the position
of the Train relative to the Platform and which side the Doors should open. Once all this
is complete, the ATO will open the Doors.
After a set time, predetermined or varied by the Control Centre as required, the ATO will
close the Doors and automatically restart the Train if the Door Closed Proving Circuit is
complete. ATO will then accelerate the Train to its Cruising Speed, allow it to coast to
the next Station Brake Command Beacon and then brake into the next Station,
assuming no Intervention by the ATP System.
In some Systems like that in Delhi Metro, the Job of Opening and Closing the Train
Doors at a Station and restarting the Train when all Doors are detected Closed is
entrusted to the Driver. Such Systems are, however, designed to prevent Doors being
opened until the Train is ‘Docked’ in the right place.
Following are the possible Operational Modes of Trains on a Metro Railway, equipped
with Automatic Train Control (ATC) System, encompassing Automatic Train Protection
(ATP) System, Automatic Train Supervision (ATS) System and Automatic Train
Operation (ATO) System:
This Mode is the usual Mode where ATO is not provided. This Mode is
also used when ATO fails in case the ATO has been provided on the
section.
In this Mode, the Train Driver shall operate the Train manually.
Indications shall be provided in the Cab of the Train with On-board
Displays for Maximum Safe Speed (MSS), Current Speed, Target
Distance / Speed as deduced from the most restricting ATP condition and
the Signalling Mode etc. Interlockings shall establish and protect the Set
Route. The Braking Curve shall be computed continuously along the Line
and acted upon so as to enable a minimum Safety Distance (Safety
Margin in Figure 17.6) to be maintained.
ATP Mode is only possible when the Mode Selector is in the ATP
Position.
The Cut-out Mode shall be used when the On-board ATP Equipment or
both the On-board ATO & On-board ATP equipment fail.
In the Cut-out Mode, Line side Signals are used to provide Information to
the Train Driver that the Route is Clear to the next Interlocking.
Accordingly, the Train Driver shall operate from Interlocking to
Interlocking following the Aspects of the Line side Signals. In this Mode,
the Train Driver shall operate the Train at a maximum of 25 Kmph and
this Speed Enforcement shall be ensured by On-board Rolling Stock
Equipment.
(a) Immediately after unlocking the Cab and pressing the ROS
Button inside the Depot Area (ATP Supervision not
possible).
(b) To drive the Train within the Depot (No Trackside ATP
Equipment).
Immediately after unlocking the Cab and pressing the ROS Button, the
Train can be run under RM Mode. In case of Emergency Brake because
of the Speed Limit, the driver can release the Emergency Brake by
pressing the ROS Button.
ROS Mode allows running a Train under the sole Responsibility of the
Driver. It is used:
(a) Immediately after unlocking the Cab and pressing the ROS
Button outside the Depot Area (ATP Supervision not yet
possible).
Mode Selector:
Following are the Positions of the Mode Selector on Sections equipped with ATP
system:
After ‘Switch On’ of the Cab, the ATP starts up and waits in Readiness
Mode until the Driver presses the ROS Button. After pressing the ROS
Button the ATP changes the Mode to RM / ROS depending upon the
Location of Train (Depot / Main Line).
In ATP Position of the Mode Selector, RM & ROS Modes are also
possible.
A change of the Mode Selector Position is allowed only in Standstill. The Train shall
initiate a Brake when the Driver uses the Mode Selector during the Run.
ROS Button:
(i) After ‘Switching On’ the Cab to allow a change from Readiness to one of
other Modes including ATP, depending upon the conditions.
(iii) To change from ATP Mode into ROS Mode, for example to drive over a
Stopping Point in front of a failed Track circuit.
Figure 17.27 provides for the different Positions of the Mode Selector and ensuing
changes to the Operational Modes for the Train.
Degradation of Operating Mode:
In the event of failure of ATO, there shall be Automatic graceful Degradation of Mode
from ATO to ATP in a Safe manner such that speed of the Train is brought below the
Maximum Safe Speed of the ATP Mode. In case of failure of ATP, the Degradation to
Rolling Stock Mode (Cut-out Mode) shall not be Automatic. The Train will automatically
come to a Stop and the Driver shall change over to Cut-out Mode by operating a Manual
sealed Switch.
The Train Driver shall also have the facility to place the Train into Manual ATP
Operation, at any time. In this Operation, the Driver shall operate the Train manually with
ATP Enforcement of Speed Restrictions. The ATP System shall also prevent the Train
Driver from opening the Doors unless the Train is properly berthed (within the Stopping
Window) and there is a Platform on the side, he wants to open. In case of emergencies,
however, the Train Driver shall be able to open the Doors at other locations than the
Platforms.
Transfer from ATP to ATO back shall only be possible at Standstill, usually at a Station
Stopping Point.
Figure 17.28 details all the Transactions between various Operational Modes of the ATP
System as also the circumstances under which these Transitions are affected from one
Mode to the other.
ATS is that Subsystem within the Automatic Train Control System, which monitors the
System Status continuously and provides the appropriate Controls to direct the
Operation of Trains in order to maintain intended Traffic Patterns and minimise the effect
of Train Delays on the Operating Schedule. The System also has the capability to
organize the Train Movements in an optimum manner in case of Abnormalities.
Using Networked Computers and Automated Functions, ATS ensures efficient Rail
Operation, Automatic Monitoring and Control of Interlockings through Automatic Train
Tracking to Automatic Route Setting.
ATS assigns Identification Numbers to Trains and provides all necessary Real Time
Train Information to the Operator.
ATS also caters for Tools for Time Table Generation & Modification as also for the
Management of Signalling Equipment.
(vi) Driving of the Passenger Information System (i.e. PIDS & PAS).
In Execution of its functions, ATS interfaces with external Sub-systems such as CBI,
ATC, Master Clock, PIDS / PAS, Train Radio and NP-SCADA etc.
ATS System is divided in a Central and a Local Part, called CATS & LATS. Both are
independent and use Redundant Systems. All ATS Functions are available in both the
Systems. Servers for CATS are located at the Operations Control Centre (OCC) and for
LATS at a number of Strategic Locations on the Section, one LATS Server controlling a
number of contiguous Stations.
In case that both CATS & LATS are not available, VDU provided at the Station provides
for Off-line Operations.
MMIs of the Stations are connected to the COM server of the concerned LATS System.
COM Server runs the specific ATS Functions such as Automatic Route Setting (ARS),
Automatic Train Regulation (ATR) and Train Monitoring & Tracking etc. They provide the
incoming Information and the result of the Automatic Functions to the MMIs.
Interlockings (CBIs) of the Stations are connected to the Central Ethernet LAN via
Redundant FEP Units. Ethernet can be based on the Standard Twisted Pair Cable or
OFC.
Interlockings work in two Modes – Remote Mode through ATS and in Local Mode
through the VDU, the MMI. A Service & Diagnostic (S&D) Computer is provided at all
Interlockings and in the OCC.
A Central Interface Computer connects the ATS with External Systems, such as PIDS,
PAS, NPSCADA and Train Radio.
A Back-up Depot Control System is provided at the Control Centre within the Depot.
Depot ATS need not be equipped with Automatic Train Describer Sub-system for Trains
coming from Main Line.
Depot Controller and Crew Controller Workstations connected to CATS System are
available in the Depot Station.
Crew Controller Work Stations are also provided at each Terminal Station.
Training & Simulation System is located in the OCC as well as in the Depot Station.
Block Schematics of Network Structure in OCC and that of LATS at the Station are
shown in Figures 17.29 & 17.30.
The ergonomically designed Train Control Workstation with GUI (Graphical User
Interface) is provided for easy Operation. All Dialogues are pre-programmed and can be
minimized to an Icon for fast Access.
(vii) Messages for the System are passed to all Workstations, which are
responsible for their Evaluation.
The Train Supervision gets the ‘Track Occupied’ Messages from the Interlockings, which
enable the Section-wise stepping of the Train Identification Number on the Display and
its Indication in the Display Sections.
Train Identification Information is used to update and control the Internal Database.
The Automatic Setting of Train Routes releases the Line Controller of regular
Operations. Its Function is to generate Interlocking Commands in order to set Train
Routes based on current Train Locations and issue those Route Commands to the
Interlocking System.
ARS can also provide for Functions of Automatic Train Reversing (Terminal Mode of
Operation) as well as other Operating Modes for each Route such as Fleet Mode,
Manual Mode and Sequence Mode (Applicable at Terminal Stations only).
ATR performs the Regulation of Train Trips, according to Delays calculated from the
given Time Table.
(i) To provide the PIDS in the Stations, with the Expected Arrival Times.
(ii) To supply other Systems, for example the Automatic Route Setting
System, with the relevant Data.
(iii) To check the Stopping Points set by ATP and ordering their Cancellation,
if necessary.
In Default Mode, ATR shall change the Dwell Time at the current Station
or the Traveling Time to the next Station and send this Data to the Train,
if a Deviation has been detected. With the received Dwell Time, the Train
MMI shall inform the Driver to close the Train Doors and to depart the
Station in time.
After transmitting the Dwell Time to the Train, ATR starts to decrement
the Dwell Time and send it to the MMIs. If the Dwell Time reaches zero,
the ATR releases the Halt Point. Besides this, a Stopping Point is
released when an Empty Train is approaching a Station or when a Skip
Command is active for a Station.
With the received Traveling Time, the Train MMI shall inform the Driver to
accelerate or slow down the Train.
Here each Train shall be dispatched from the Platform by the Manual
Interference of the Controller.
ATR can also provide for pre-programmed Application / Removal of Temporary Speed
Restrictions (TSRs). Here it shall be possible to specify Days & Times during which the
Speed Restrictions are to be applied / removed.
When the ATR is inactive, the Dwell Times & Traveling Times read from the Timetable
shall not be adjusted based on the Timetable Deviations. The Operator has to enter
Dwell Times & Traveling Times manually, and these values shall be used instead.
In both cases, when the ATR is active or inactive, the Estimated Arrival Times in the
successive Stations are transmitted to the PIDS Process according to the current
Timetable Deviation.
Timetable Compiler:
(i) The resulting behaviour of the Railway System due to the Constructed
Timetable can be imitated realistically.
(ii) The Operability of the Regular or Alternative Timetables with respect to all
important Technical & Operational Constraints can be verified.
Timetables can be visualised by Time Distance Graphs, where the Position of a Train,
as a function of Time, is displayed as a continuous Curve.
After Evaluation & Verification, the created Timetables can be exported to the Internal
Database of the ATS System.
Once a Timetable is created and exported to the Running System, an On-line Program
can be used, to modify a Train Schedule, if required. Modifications could be applied
temporarily and when no more needed, the originally imported Timetable can be loaded
again.
Timetable Management:
An Operation Day is assigned to every Calendar Day in the Traffic Period. The valid
Daily Timetable for a Calendar Day is determined from the Operation Day assigned to it.
The Calendar File (describing the Traffic Period) and the Daily Timetable are stored in
the External Timetable System and on the COM Server. Figure 17.31 shows the
Overview of the Database of Time Table Management (TTM) System.
Using pre-formatted Dialogues, the Operator at the OCC can perform the following
Tasks related to Timetable Management:
(i) Activate a Daily Timetable as Operational Timetable on the COM
Server in OCC for a Day.
Timetable Comparison:
(i) The Timetable Comparison for Trains on the basis of Messages giving
their current Locations.
Train Graphs:
The Train Graphs are displayed in Route vs Time Co-ordinate System. The Route Axis
is Horizontal and the Time Axis is Vertical.
Also different points of Interest on the Graphs can be marked with Overlay Icons. For
Example, in a Train Graph, all the points where the Deviation exceeds certain Limits can
be indicated with a special Icon.
A Mimic Overview Display Panel is provided in the OCC to display the following:
(v) Alarms:
The Mimic Display is positioned and so sized such that it presents an unobstructed view
to all Control Room Staff, when seated at their Consoles.
On the Mimic Display, Train Progression is displayed by Train ID in the Train ID Box.
Train ID Box shall be provided at all Platform lines, Sidings and in section between any
two Stations for each line.
Report Server:
A separate Report Server is usually catered for to log all relevant Timetable Data - the
Planned & Actual Arrival Times, Reporting Data – Train Report & Trip Report (Train
Movements & related Events), System Commands, Alarms & Acknowledgements and
Failure Data etc. in a Structured Database.
The Data Logs can be Retrieved, Filtered, Viewed and Managed for On-line and Off-line
Analysis and for Incident investigation at both OCC as well as Local Station. For this
purpose, Database Specific Structured Query Language (SQL) is used.
Facility of Train-borne Log is also provided to record & retrieve all Train-borne Train
Control and Signalling System Faults.
(i) Movements within the Depots beyond the entrance Interlockings, shall be
controlled by Line side Shunt Signals and Stop Signals.
(ii) Stop Signals shall be provided at the Entry to and Exit from the Depot.
(iii) Position Light type Shunt Signals shall be provided for every Route
leaving the Stabling Lines.
(iv) Signals shall also be provided for movement of Rakes for various
Maintenance facilities within the Depot and also between Non-interlocked
Area and Interlocked Area within the Depot.
(vi) The Track circuits shall be of Remote-fed AFTC type. For any Stabling
Track that can hold more than one 8-Car Rake, The Track circuits shall
be provided in such a way so as to detect the presence of Rakes
individually.
(viii) The relevant Track circuit, Signal and Point Indications of the concerned
Main line Station Interlocking shall be made available at the Depot
Interlocking and the relevant Track circuit, Signal and Point Indications of
the Depot Interlocking shall be made available at the concerned Main line
Station Interlocking.
(ix) The Interlocking at the concerned Main line Station shall not allow any
Signal to display ‘Proceed’ Aspect in to the Depot unless the Interlocking
in the Depot has been lined up with a Route. Similarly, the Interlocking at
the Depot shall not allow any Signal to display ‘Proceed’ Aspect in to the
Main line Track, unless the Interlocking at the Main line Station has been
lined up with a Route for exit of a Rake from the Depot.
(x) Change Operating Mode Marker Board shall be provided at the Transfer
Berth from the Running line to the Depots. This is to facilitate the Train
Driver to change to Restricted Manual Mode, prior to entry to the Depot.
(xi) Buffer Stop Signals shall be provided at the ends of the Stabling lines &
Sidings in the Depots. Buffer Stop Signals shall also be provided at both
ends of the Test Track in the Depots.
(xii) The Train Control and Signalling System shall be designed to allow for
the extension of the Depot in future. This shall include consideration of
the Interfaces required for the extension.
(i) At Depot Control Centre ATS link having a separate duplicated ATS
Server System with a Master Slave configuration shall be provided with
Automatic & Manual switchover of Control. Failure of this ATS Monitoring
& Recording System shall not affect the operation of ATS Monitoring and
Recording System at OCC and vice - versa.
(ii) Time displayed on various Depot ATS Display and Reporting equipment
shall be synchronised with the Master Clock.
(iii) The System shall be protected from unauthorised access by using User
Name & Password protection.
(iv) The System shall comprise a Depot Controller’s Workstation and Crew
Controller’s Workstation, a Dual Server Data Processing System and
Communication link with the OCC ATS System for Control, Indication and
Train Information transfer.
(v) The ATS System at Depot shall continuously present dynamic and static
overview of Train movement & Signalling Information within the Depot
Control Area and for the connecting Tracks to Main line.
(vi) It shall display current status of Track side Signalling equipment,
Signalling Controls, Train description at Arrival and Departure Tracks.
Rake ID, Crew ID and Radio ID of static as well as moving Trains and
Real Time Train movement using Track circuit status etc.
(vii) Track circuit failure or Track circuit ‘Put out of Service’ shall allow the
progression of Train movement to be followed on the Line Overview
Diagram on the Workstation (s) without the loss of Train description using
Train Trekking Algorithm.
(viii) The Depot ATS System shall provide interfacing with the Main line
Signalling Control System for Trains entering and leaving Mainline
Service.
(ix) Rake Number, and Train Consists etc. for each Train / Vehicles leaving
the Depot for Main line Service shall be automatically generated by ATS
System, and the same shall be available in both OCC and Depot ATS
System. The Depot Controller / Crew Controller at the Control screen
shall have the facility of entering the Crew Number for each Train and
Rake ID & Train Consists etc., where required. The System shall permit
at least 10 entries to be kept in advance of Train dispatching.
(x) Train Identification and Train Consists, Crew Number and other Train
details shall be automatically transferred (through Cut-in Track TWC) to
the OCC ATS System for display on the Signalling Control Screen and
the Signalling Line Overview Screen after the Train has entered into the
Main line. When a train is returning to the Depot, a Train Approaching
Alarm shall be raised on the Depot Controller’s Signalling Control Panel.
Train Identification shall be transferred (through Cut-out Track TWC) to
OCC & Depot ATS System for display.
(xii) The Depot ATS System shall initiate a Message for the Depot Controller
and sound an Audible Alarm at OCC & Depot each time a Train leaves
the Main line for the Depot or vice-versa. The Audible Alarm shall cease,
when acknowledged.
(i) The Test Track shall be equipped with full Trackside ATP / ATO Systems
for Train Tests to be conducted within the limitations of the Test Track
length. Test Track Tests shall be essentially required, whenever certain
modifications - Hardware or Software, are done in the Train-borne
equipment.
(ii) The Depot Test Track shall provide the ability to dynamically Test the
Train-borne System.
(iii) It shall be possible to simulate two Stations, one at each end of the Test
Track.
(iv) The Test Track shall be connected to the Interlocking of the Depot.
*******