GWEC 2023 Interactive
GWEC 2023 Interactive
Supporting Sponsor
Associate Sponsors
4/02/11 15:40:22
GWEC.NET
Table of contents
Foreword 3
Executive summary 7
Wind energy: The coming renewables acceleration 13
Part One: A new energy market 17
Part Two: Challenges in the supply chain 23
Part Three: The risks and opportunities of regionalisation 33
Part Four: The IRA is set to turbocharge the US wind sector 41
Part Five: How Europe plans to rise to the challenge 47
Part Six: Will China continue to be the market leader? 51
Part Seven: How to achieve a just transition 57
Case studies 63
Focus on offshore wind 69
Markets to watch 83
Market Status 2022 91
Market Outlook 2023–2027 103
Appendix 111
Global Wind Energy Council Muchiri, Thoa Nguyen, Liming Qiao, Marcela Ruas, Association, Renewable Energy Institute – Japan, We received valuable review and commentary
Rue de Commerce 31 Martand Shardul, Thang Vinh Bui, Nadia Weekes, Korea Wind Energy Industry Association, China for this report from
1000 Brussels, Belgium Rebecca Williams Wind Energy Association, Developers of Renewable •Rina Bohle Zeller (Vestas)
info@gwec.net Energy for AdvanceMent (DREAM) – Philippines, •Dan Wetzel (IEA)
www.gwec.net
Additional contributions Thailand Wind Energy Association, Mongolian
Asociación Mexicana de Energía Eólica, Asociación Renewable Energy Association, Indonesian Front cover image courtesy of Vestas
Costarricense de Productores de Energía, SER Renewable Energy Society (METI), Iran Renewable
Lead Authors
Colombia – Asociación Energías Renovables, Energy Association – IRWEA, Electricity Sector Published
Mark Hutchinson, Feng Zhao
Associação Brasileira de Energia Eólica e Novas Association of Kenya, South African Wind Energy 27 March 2023
Contributors and editing Tecnologias (ABEEólica), Camara Eólica Argentina, Association – SAWEA, Clean Energy Council
Ben Backwell, Emerson Clarke, Esther Fang, Ramón Asociación Peruana de Energías Renovables – SPR, (Australia), American Clean Power, Canadian Design
Fiestas, Jeanette Gitobu, Navneet Khinda, Reshmi Asociación Chilena de Energías Renovables y Renewable Energy Association − CanREA, lemonbox
Ladwa, Anjali Lathigara, Wanliang Liang, Wangari Almacenamiento – ACERA, Japan Wind Power WindEurope. www.lemonbox.co.uk
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 1
Foreword
2 GWEC.NET
Foreword
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 3
Foreword
investment in their wind sectors: inputs for the energy transition, facilities, from South Korea to the
who gets the investment will fosters innovation and keeps costs US to Poland.
depend on who has the most from rising unnecessarily.
attractive market conditions and Much more is needed, and fast.
the most efficient regulators. For In order to ensure that the wind The wind industry will need to
power equipment – and this industry is able to meet the forge new partnerships with
includes key commodities such as expectations of policymakers and governments, cities, communities,
copper and rare earth elements society at large, it is essential that we investors and customers in order to
(REEs), power transmission start investing in new capacity and enable the next era of growth.
equipment, wind turbines and
offshore installation vessels –
market dynamics are likely to The wind industry will need to forge new
change from buyers’ to sellers’
markets as supply chains struggle
partnerships with governments, cities, communities,
to keep up with demand. investors and customers in order to enable the
According to the data in this Global next era of growth
Wind Report 2023, spare capacity
in the wind energy manufacturing
industry is likely to disappear by plant, and in training and skills, right Working together, we can put into
2026. For some inputs and in some now. Otherwise, we run the risk that place the right policies, which will
regions, the squeeze will be felt we will not be able to deliver our allow trillions of dollars in
before then. Both Europe and the promises, policymakers will turn to investments to flow and the
US are facing the risk of supply other, less efficient alternatives, and creation of millions of jobs.
chain shortfalls, and these could society will fail in its climate goals.
be worsened by policies aimed at As a starting point, we need to
reshoring manufacturing away This may sound counterintuitive in leave the hesitancy of the past
from China and protecting local an environment where companies behind and adopt a new mindset in
industry and jobs. have found it difficult to keep their our industry. The wind industry is
businesses viable, but it is a no longer the hobby sector of forty
As this report shows, while creating challenge we cannot ignore. years ago. Our technology is
more diversity and resilience in the Thankfully, the sector’s leaders resilient and mature, and is poised
supply chain is an important and can see the opportunity ahead, to play a unique role in the energy
necessary objective, decision and companies are already transition. Now, in order to deliver
makers will have to design policy investing – despite the highly on the promises we have made, we
very carefully to make sure that it unfavourable conditions of the last need a confident wind industry that
allows the fair exchange of essential few years – in new manufacturing is capable of moving boldly ahead.
4 GWEC.NET
Foreword
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 5
Sponsor
transition is already well under way, required for the global industry to hit industry. Additionally, the
supported by record new installed capacity targets. continuous development of a highly and development. Together, these
investment commitments. skilled workforce will be critical, as critical initiatives will advance the
The supply chain of the future well as the implementation of growing global needs for a highly
needs rapid expansion – in line higher levels of automation skilled workforce that can support
The supply chain needs rapid with the ambitions of its main solutions, which can reduce project the ambitions of industry and
expansion – in line with the stakeholders. This is why GWEC’s hours and overall costs. countries around the world.
Global Wind Report 2023 is even
ambitions of stakeholders more crucial, highlighting a Today’s industry leaders know that Building on earlier success in
number of key actions necessary new technologies for steel offshore wind across Europe – and
From new steel plant capacity, in both the short and long term. transformation will play a critical now the rapid expansion in Asia
planned or already online, to pipe role in profitability, particularly in and the Americas – the future of
mills, shipyards and regional While there are many pieces of welding and cutting, which the wind industry depends on the
fabricators around the world, these encouraging news across the continues to be at the core of the combined efforts of many. The
new industry investments are global supply chain, there are also expanding global wind industry. industry needs continued support
driving one of the most rapid several practical challenges to Lincoln Electric and other critical from governments and private
global industrialisation periods we overcome if we are to accelerate supply chain businesses are investment around the world for
have seen. The outcome of this capacity to meet the installed leveraging decades of industry further acceleration and
process will enable the world to targets forecast around the world. expertise and experience to expansion of the supply chain. By
build and install turbines, towers innovate and solve these critical aligning these resources with a
and foundations (fixed-bottom and As a key global supplier who challenges through two key growing role for wind as a key
floating) of immense size, never supports the entire fabrication drivers: technology and higher part of the energy transition, the
before realised. supply chain of assets and involvement in workforce training industry will thrive.
6 GWEC.NET
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Wind in 2022
8 GWEC.NET
Wind in 2022
floating wind. Norway l A strong uplift for renewable The global offshore wind market is
commissioned 60 MW of floating energy in the US over the next expected to grow from 8.8 GW in
wind capacity last year, bringing ten years, primarily driven by the 2022 to 35.5 GW in 2027, bringing
the region’s total installations to 171 Inflation Reduction Act (IRA). its share of total new global
MW, equal to 91% of global installations from today’s 11% to
installations. l hina’s commitment to further
C 23% by 2027. In total, 130 GW of
expanding the role of offshore wind is expected to be
Market outlook renewables in its energy mix, added worldwide in 2023-2027,
The unprecedented twin aiming for renewable energy to with expected average annual
challenges of ensuring secure and contribute more than 80% of total installations of nearly 26 GW.
affordable energy supplies and new electricity consumption by
meeting climate targets have the end of the 14th Five-Year Beyond 2027, we expect the growth
propelled wind power Plan (2021-2025). momentum to continue as global
development into an extraordinary commitments to net zero, coupled
new phase of ever faster growth. l overnments fully waking up to
G
After a challenging year, the global the opportunities that offshore
wind market is ready to bounce wind can provide, making The twin challenges of secure energy supplies and
back in 2023, exceeding 100 GW offshore wind truly global and
for the first time. increasing ambition in mature climate targets will propel wind power into a new
and developing markets. phase of extraordinary growth
With a double-digit growth rate of
15%, the mid-term outlook for wind l Strong growth in large emerging
energy looks very positive. GWEC markets both onshore and offshore
Market Intelligence expects that from the middle of this decade. with growing energy security capacity required by 2030 to stay
680 GW of new capacity will be concerns, have already brought the on track for a net zero/1.5C
added in the next five years. This The CAGR for onshore wind in the urgency of deploying renewables pathway. Nevertheless, GWEC
equals more than 136 GW of new next five years is 12%. Expected to the top of the political agenda. believes that the milestone of a
installations per year until 2027. We average annual installations are second TW is likely to be passed
believe there are five pillars that 110 GW, with a total of 550 GW Compared with the 2030 global before the end of 2030 – provided
will underpin this level of success likely to be built in 2023–2027. outlook released alongside last governments implement new
in the next five years: Growth in China, Europe and the year’s Global Wind Report, GWEC policy solutions to ensure that the
US will be the backbone of global Market Intelligence has increased global supply chain can meet
l urope’s renewed urgency to
E onshore wind development in the its forecast for total wind power increasing demand from both
replace fossil fuels with next five years. Altogether, they are capacity additions for 2023–2030 established and emerging markets
renewables to achieve energy expected to make up more than by 143 GW (YoY growth of 13%). – in addition to addressing
security in the aftermath of the 80% of total additional capacity in The revised growth rate will only challenges such as permitting and
Russian invasion of Ukraine. 2023–2027. achieve 68% of the wind power market design.
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 9
Policy summary
10 GWEC.NET
Policy summary
As our heat map (see page 82) already mobilising massive economic development and job demand up to 2027. But the picture
shows, there are still tens of investment in renewable creation over a narrow focus on is less rosy for offshore wind.
countries where wind power generation, decarbonised achieving the lowest possible Starting in 2026, Europe’s existing
development is being held back transport, energy storage and price. offshore turbine nacelle assembly
by regressive policies or improved grid connections. In capacity will no longer be able to
ineffective processes. Increasingly, Europe, the REPowerEU By adopting this high-level support growth outside of Europe,
however, governments are eyeing programme seeks to wean the mindset, governments will allow and by 2030 it will have to double
up the vast opportunities that continent off Russian gas while wind power original equipment from current levels to meet
facilitating this sector opens up in removing obstacles to green manufacturers (OEMs), developers, European demand alone.
terms of industrial development, energy deployment. And approval shipping companies and other Elsewhere, nacelle bottlenecks look
skilled jobs and socioeconomic of China’s 14th Five-Year Plan , actors in the supply chain to invest, likely in Asia (excluding China) and
returns, as well as environmental covering the 2021–2025 period, ensuring an optimal balance in the Americas, especially once the
benefits. turbocharges innovation-driven between supply and demand, and pipeline of Brazilian projects starts
low-carbon development, with delivering benefits for all. being rolled out.
Investing to boost wind GWEC estimating annual wind
development installations of 60–65 GW per year Facing up to the size of the
Wind energy has established its for onshore and 15 GW for challenge
credentials as one of the most offshore in the second half of this Gearing up to deploy huge Spare capacity is limited and will
efficient tools for decarbonising
power systems. Failing to deploy
decade. volumes of wind power capacity is
a far from straightforward task.
likely disappear by 2026 unless
wind fast enough risks increasing While these policies are providing Adding 1 TW in seven years, when urgent investment is made in the
costs through greater exposure to a welcome boost to local industry it took around 40 years to install the
fossil fuel volatility, geopolitical and promising long-overdue action first TW, is no mean feat.
supply chain
pressure and higher carbon to reduce some of the complex
emissions. Socially, wind power has rules associated with wind energy Following a difficult patch of
the potential to benefit development, they could also retrenchment, the wind energy Shortages are expected to emerge
communities by creating millions threaten the sector’s ability to rise manufacturing industry is now in the second half of this decade for
of skilled jobs around the world. to the acceleration challenge. facing the prospect of a rapid key components such as blades and
Economically, it can act as a upturn. Spare capacity is very generators. Gearbox manufacturing
catalyst for trillions of dollars of Growing demand for equipment limited, and likely to disappear by capacity is well positioned to
investment. and the key commodities that are 2026 unless urgent action is taken support growth up to 2027, but a
required to produce it will place to invest in the supply chain. concentrated supply chain and
Heavyweights such as the US and significant pressure on supply regionalised sourcing strategies
the EU have ramped up chains. It is essential that Our analysis in Part 2 shows that 163 look certain to create bottlenecks.
government support for wind policymakers approach GW of nacelle production capacity
energy. The Biden administration’s procurement with a more holistic is available worldwide, which is China dominates the global supply
Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) is perspective that prioritises likely to meet projected global chain for other crucial components
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 11
Policy summary
In sum, both Europe and the US local supply of critical inputs for collaboration and the scaling up of
are facing the risk of supply chain their industries, including steel investment everywhere.
shortfalls as soon as 2026, products and raw materials such Policymakers must come together
particularly if they follow through as rare earth elements (REEs). This to design mechanisms that make
with some of the ‘reshoring’ has the potential to severely limit the relevant inputs for the energy
policies that several countries and the industry’s capability to upscale. transition freely available around
regions are rolling out to the world.
strengthen energy resilience and When considering the localisation
boost local industry. or reshoring of their energy sector, Policymakers have the power to
governments have choices: they avoid the crippling bottlenecks that
Supply chain pressures will alter can use incentives or preferential are likely to arise if supply chains
market dynamics treatment for domestic suppliers or do not rise to the challenge of the
Paradoxically, just as renewable reserve the procurement of certain growing demand for equipment.
energy proves itself as the most goods or services for them. But they must ensure they engage
cost-effective form of energy and in early and open dialogue with
the one best insulated from the GWEC advises against industry to ensure that policy goals
vagaries of geopolitical pressures, prescriptive localisation and industry action are aligned. If
wind energy runs the risk of seeing requirements or restrictive trade designed properly and
its progress thwarted by the practices, which could lead to comprehensively, policies
practical implications of untapping price increases and disruption. It designed to enable the scaling up
its immense growth potential. argues instead for flexibility that of the supply chain and its
such as castings, forgings, slewing can build on national and diversification represent a huge
bearings, towers and flanges, with As countries and regions compete regional competitive advantages, opportunity for the world.
a market share of more than 70%. for investment, the winners will be giving OEMs and the supply
those with the most attractive market chain more flexibility in For the wind industry to meet the
Vessels used in offshore conditions and the most effective optimising their production. An expectations of policymakers and
installations are expected to be in regulation. Policymakers must tread incentive-based approach will society at large, it is essential that
sufficient supply in China, but the narrow path that enables an also give the wind industry the investment starts right now in new
Europe could see shortages adequate level of trade to ensure the confidence to overcome recent industrial capacity, and in training
towards the end of the decade, energy transition is not delayed challenges and begin to scale up and skills. In the absence of such
unless investments are made while boosting opportunities for for the next phase of global impetus, the industry runs the risk
before 2027. And the US, with its their domestic supply chains. growth. of falling short of what is required
Jones Act restrictions, will certainly to deliver the necessary capacity,
struggle to meet the Biden Efforts to boost energy security The scale of the investment and leading policymakers to turn to
Administration’s target of 30 GW of and strengthen the local economy production needed to achieve the less efficient alternatives, and
offshore wind by 2030 unless it have led some countries to reach energy transition will require ultimately causing society to miss
acts to build new vessels. beyond manufacturing to achieve continued global and regional its climate targets.
12 GWEC.NET
WIND ENERGY: THE COMING ACCELERATION
The coming renewables acceleration
14 GWEC.NET
The coming renewables acceleration
UK
5%
rhetoric under the Trump
administration – albeit with continued
EU Offshore wind targets of 10 GW
Kazakhstan 10 GW
Mongolia by 2030 and 30–45GW by 2040
Uzbekistan
United States
Algeria
Costa Rica
Senegal
Thailand
Vietnam
Philippines through restating the USA’s climate
Colombia
Ghana
Nigeria
Ethiopia
India
Indonesia and through the Inflation Reduction
Brazil
Act (IRA). This landmark piece of
100% ● Annual target of 8 GW onshore wind
Tanzania
Peru Brazil ● Cross-party support for wind tender every year between 2023 and
100% energy as a driver of economic Renewable 2030 based on a single-stage
power by
Chile
Uruguay
wind energy development
South Africa accelerating the transition to a clean
Argentina
energy economy across multiple
Victoria - offshore
Australia
● New national government supportive of onshore
and offshore wind development
sectors. The prospects for offshore
wind, in particular, are very exciting.
9 GW wind by 2040 ● Offshore Electricity Infrastructure Regulations
No federal targets
released
● Announced areas for offshore wind in
Gippsland (Victoria)
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 15
The coming renewables acceleration
companies from outside the scarred by years of financial losses challenges while looking to deploy
energy industry are increasingly may retreat into caution and massive amounts of additional
keen to invest in wind protectionism. This would be the capacity in an ever-growing number
development. worst possible scenario both for of countries. Such a huge rise in
the wind industry and the energy wind power development can only
BloombergNEF estimates that transition – as global supply materialise if governments play their
offshore wind financing activity diversification has supported the part, through supportive and stable
will hit new records in 20233, with reduction of wind’s LCOE. market conditions, in allowing the
more than 30 GW of new projects wind industry to scale up to the
getting the go-ahead, over half of As gigawatt-level projects kick off ambitious targets it is expected to
which will be outside China. in new and traditional wind deliver.
Floating offshore technology is markets across the globe, GWEC
making steady progress and will anticipates a flurry of orders for In an increasingly interconnected
open up previously untapped turbine manufacturers everywhere, world, the wind sector must prove
markets. and pressure on all elements of the that it can continue to innovate,
supply chain as a result. It is collaborate and integrate. From
However, the promise of massive essential that the industry gears up the role of women and minorities
expansion risks colliding with the to respond to this challenge by in the industry to the wide-
Additionally, the EU is looking to reality of delivering turbines on thinking strategically about the ranging challenge of
introduce legislation that would land and in the water. The industry road ahead and setting itself up to sustainability, GWEC is
simplify and fast-track permitting is emerging from several difficult deliver on its ambition, supported determined to facilitate
procedures for climate-neutral years, during which turbine by adequate policies. connections between the many
industrial infrastructure, with the manufacturers have suffered stakeholders the sector affects.
goal of boosting Europe’s key financial losses and policymakers A turning point for wind
green industries and their full have often failed to provide the Having achieved impressive Having long established its
value chains. Efforts are also being optimal conditions for fast and learnings and economies of scale credentials as a reliable, effective,
made to reduce dependence on efficient market development and over the past two decades, wind is efficient and cost-competitive
non-EU sources of raw materials the necessary grid buildout. now a mature sector which, like technology, the wind industry
and rare earth elements (REEs). more traditional energy sources, now needs the right conditions to
While technological advances are reacts to external factors such as step up to the level that is
Responding to burgeoning happening across the sector – from commodity prices, interest rates required of it to fully deliver on its
demand China’s continued lead in upsizing and political support – rather than promise of cleaner and cheaper
Demand for wind energy continues turbine components, to global its own internal dynamics. energy for all.
to grow and expand. The trend efforts to improve the circularity of
towards corporate power purchase traditionally difficult-to-recycle No longer the new kid on the energy 3. https://about.bnef.com/new-energy-outlook/
4. https://www.vestas.com/en/media/company-news/2023/
agreements shows no sign of epoxy-based turbine blades4 – block, the wind sector is at a turning vestas-unveils-circularity-solution-to-end-landfill-
slowing down, and large there is a danger that an industry point – facing up to a host of new for-c3710818
16 GWEC.NET
PART 1: A NEW ENERGY MARKET
Part 1: A new energy market
A new energy market Projected changes in global electricity generation (TWh) by source
31,500
In 2022, the world saw many of its for gas-importing countries, causing
long-established paradigms surges in the prices of everything – 31,000
shattered by a number of deeply from fertilisers to heating and power
transformative events. Inflation – and causing low-income countries 30,500
reached levels not seen since the to suffer the most. 30,000
massive disruptions of the 1970s –
driven at both times in large part by The global response has been to 29,500
commodity price increases. The focus on energy security and
29,000
unprovoked attack on Ukraine by resilience. Governments
Russia laid bare the world’s introduced measures to make 28,500
dependence on fossil fuels – and the energy affordable by utilising all
energy insecurity that comes with it. available energy sources, 28,000
including coal, gas and nuclear, 2021 2022 Coal Oil Gas Nuclear Renewables 2025
As Russia is the world’s second and by committing to developing
largest gas producer, this more renewables in the latter part Source: IEA, 2023
18 GWEC.NET
Part 1: A new energy market
Commodity Price Index Significantly more wind will be as companies globally commit to
required to achieve those goals. environmental, social and
governance (ESG) goals that
300 Substantiating this trend, the require them and their suppliers to
International Energy Agency decarbonise.
250
(IEA)’s Electricity Market Report
2023 sees renewable energy This is a mega-trend to watch as
200
sources supplying pretty much the GWEC believes the demand side
totality of the additional electricity will become much more vocal in
2016 = 100
150
generated between 2022 and its desire to see more renewables
100 2025.6 come online to help them and their
suppliers meet their
50 In its Renewables 2022 report – the decarbonisation targets. An
agency’s primary analysis of the example of this is the Asia Clean
0
renewable energy sector – the IEA Energy Coalition8 – launched by
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
forecasts capacity additions GWEC, the World Resources
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
reaching record highs through Institute and The Climate Group
Source: IMF, 2023
20277, led by solar and wind. It and including Google, Apple,
expects annual additions to range Samsung, Nike and many other
Historical London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR, %) from 350 GW in the main scenario large corporates with significant
to 400 GW in the accelerated case. commitments to decarbonise.
6. https://www.iea.org/reports/electricity-market-report-2023
7. https://www.iea.org/reports/renewables-2022
Source: IMF, 2023 8. https://gwec.net/acec-launches-to-rapidly-drive-corporate-clean-energy-procurement-in-asia/
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 19
Part 1: A new energy market
LNG spot prices in Asia (USD/mmbtu) GWEC Market Intelligence production capacity will be
database of global wind supply needed to meet fast-growing
side, the industry had a potential demand.
60 turbine production capability of
120 GW in 2020. Since 105 GW All energy costs are on the up
50 of turbines were delivered in Following the massive disruptions to
2021, that leaves approximately supply chains caused by the
40
10% of spare capacity. However, COVID-19 pandemic, energy
because of low profitability in demand bounced back as
30
2021 and 2022, many turbine economies reopened. Stretched
20 manufacturers have cut back on supply chains tried to balance
staff and closed some production supply with demand, while shipping
10 facilities. and logistics bottlenecks added to
the strain. Prices for a range of
0 As the industry starts to grow goods, from cars and wind turbines
again, will turbine manufacturers to washing machines and food, rose
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
have enough visibility on turbine dramatically.
Source: Federal Reserve, 2023
demand to rapidly ramp up
production capacity? Meanwhile, as inflation soared,
Average quarterly wholesale electricity prices
central banks became concerned
Another significant recent trend is about its impacts on the economy
1200
the growing China–US/EU tension and embarked on a series of
on trade and other policies, interest rate rises, leading the
Indexed electricty price (Q1 2019 -=100)
1000
possibly marking a move away cost of capital to also increase.
from globalisation in an attempt to Higher cost of capital leads to
800
shore up regional economies and increased costs for all
security of supply. What are the investments.
600
implications for wind energy,
400
especially with China being such a The historically high commodity
dominant producer across the prices seen in the last two years, and
200 renewables supply chain? the upturn in the cost of capital seen
in 2022 as central banks tightened
0 These are some of the questions monetary policy, has impacted all
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
we will look to address in detail in energy sources worldwide.
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024
Germany France United Kingdom Spain United States
later chapters of this report. At the
Japan Australia Nordics India European index high level, it seems inevitable that From 2010 to 2020, Newcastle coal
Source: IEA, 2023 a significant, global ramping up of futures, the benchmark for the top
20 GWEC.NET
Part 1: A new energy market
coal-consuming region of Asia, Equipment manufacturing for Historical LCOE by technology (USD/MWh)
ranged between $50/tonne and gas-fired and coal-fired generation 250
$120/tonne9. After sharp increases – as for wind and solar generation
in 2021, they averaged $350/tonne – has benefited from the efficiency 200
in 2022, making the cost of coal- improvements achieved over the
fired power generation decades. But with high inflation 150
substantially higher than the cost and massive disruptions to global
of wind in almost every country. supply chains, coupled with higher 100
And that is before the cost of expenditure in shipping and
carbon or its abatement is even logistics, the capital cost (CAPEX) 50
taken into account. of electricity generation for all
technologies has risen. 0
Over the past two years, prices 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022
for Asian liquified natural gas Wind has achieved significant
Wind onshore US Wind onshore UK Wind offshore UK Japan coal
(LNG) have spiked against 2020 cost reductions over the last 20 CCGT Japan CCGT UK Coal US Philippines coal
levels. While most LNG-importing years and the wind industry is Source: BNEF, 2023
countries have long-term now considered fairly mature,
contracts in place, they are especially onshore wind. 20 years (+/-30%) with the
unlikely to cover 100% of Offshore wind is newer but, variation caused by the usual
demand, leaving countries having been commercial for at movements in supply and demand,
exposed to importing spot least 15 years, it is also reaching and particularly by the cost of
cargoes. This has come at a very maturity. This means that the materials such as steel and
high financial cost, particularly in dramatic price reductions that we copper.10 There is no reason to
the past year. And because LNG have seen historically are likely think that wind, as it matures, will
markets are global the price to slow and future cost act differently.
impacts are felt globally. fluctuations in the cost of wind
are likely to reflect the underlying Relative costs of wind power
These trends contributed to a cost of capital, commodity costs remain low
historic increase in wholesale (steel, copper), and logistics The cost profile of electricity
electricity prices. Average costs, as noted above. generated from wind and solar
quarterly wholesale electricity energy versus electricity
prices spiked in much of the world For example, the cost per kilowatt generation powered by traditional
through the end of last year, and (kW) for a gas-fired turbine, a fossil fuels appears very favourable
while the IEA projects prices to mature technology, has been – it has been for some time and
drop in 2023, the projections are roughly 1,000 USD/kW for the last will continue to be.
not close to where they have been 9. https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/coal
in previous years. 10. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1364032117305531?via%3Dihub
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 21
Part 1: A new energy market
From cost to value While the focus over the last two possible, to one around how they
At the same time, to achieve their decades or more has been on can achieve the maximum amount
ambitions, countries will also have achieving cost reductions, with of economic development and job
to move decisively to fix current procurement arrangements largely creation, while moving rapidly to
market and regulatory imbalances, led by concerns from treasury fulfil their emission reduction
which have seen leading departments, policymaking now targets.
companies in the wind industry needs to focus on the societal and
supply chain declare losses over a economic value of wind energy. GWEC and its member
period of several years while fossil Wind energy is already highly companies, alongside sister
fuel-producing companies make competitive compared with fossil organisations and partners like
record profits. fuels and nuclear, but its wider social IRENA and the IEA, are working
value needs to be recognised in hard to achieve the necessary
This situation, referred to by market and procurement change in focus and create
leading commentators in the frameworks. improved market and regulatory
energy sector as a ‘bizarre conditions for a rapid and
paradox’, has been ‘a colossal Wind energy, in combination with confident transition.
Wind power still maintains price market failure’, according to other renewable energy
advantages in most countries, even GWEC CEO Ben Backwell.11 Poor technologies, is the most efficient This will allow wind original
without considering the impacts or market design and procurement way of decarbonising power equipment manufacturers (OEMs),
future carbon pricing schemes. have led to a ‘race to the bottom’ on systems. The evidence shows that developers, shipping companies
There is no reason why wind power wind pricing, while inflationary a failure to deploy wind rapidly and other actors in the supply
should lose its price advantage pressures combined with enough carries with it far higher chain to invest, ensuring an optimal
over LNG and coal in most markets government price caps have costs in terms of exposure to fossil balance between supply and
globally. exacerbated the squeeze on fuel volatility, geo political pressure demand, and delivering benefits
profitability. As we shall see, this in and higher carbon emissions for all.
To make wind power as cost- turn has led to underinvestment in leading to damage from climate
efficient as possible going forward, it manufacturing and has created the change. In later sections of this report, we
is essential that governments likelihood of supply chain look at how policy discussion is
continue to provide visibility on bottlenecks in the years to come. Wind energy has the potential to shifting in key markets for the
future demand through ambitious create tens of millions of new renewables transition. But first we
nationally determined contributions In order to enable the huge amounts skilled jobs around the world and examine the current state of the
and sectoral targets while of supply chain investment needed act as a catalyst for trillions of global wind supply chain and
introducing enabling regulations and to meet increased demand, dollars of investment. It is essential discuss the potential impact of
removing bottlenecks in permitting governments and regulators will that policymakers move the policies aimed at achieving a
and other phases of development. need to act smartly to fix current discussion around procurement larger share of national and
market imbalances and set the stage away from a narrow focus on regional content in wind turbine
11.Wind Power’s ‘Colossal Market Failure’ Threatens
Climate Fight for growth. achieving the lowest price manufacturing.
22 GWEC.NET
PART 2: CHALLENGES IN THE SUPPLY CHAIN
Part 2: Challenges in the supply chain
driven by expected explosive installation uplift in the US, driven 300 2,400
year’s Global Wind Report, GWEC What is the state of the global IRENA World Energy Transitions Outlook: 1.5°C Pathway (2021). This data represents new and cumulative capacity and
does not account for decommissioned projects.
Market Intelligence has increased wind supply chain?
its forecast for total wind power As the birthplace of the wind World’s top five wind turbine and component production hubs by annual output
capacity additions for 2023–2030 industry, Europe enjoys a mature
by 143 GW (13% YoY). The main supply chain spanning from
reasons behind this upgrade turbine nacelles through to key
2
include: components and raw materials. 4
1
However, since establishing a local 3
l nergy system reform in
E wind supply chain in 2008–2010,
Europe, replacing fossil fuels China has not only become the 5
with renewables to achieve world’s leading wind turbine
energy security in the manufacturing base, but also the
aftermath of Russia’s invasion of largest production hub for key
Ukraine; components and raw materials. Source: GWEC Market Intelligence, February 2023
24 GWEC.NET
Part 2: Challenges in the supply chain
European and American turbine Overview of global wind turbine nacelle facilities
OEMs decided to diversify their
China Europe India USA LATAM Asia Africa Total
supply chain to ensure security of
Pacific & ME
supply, in the aftermath of the
COVID-19 pandemic. India, the Total number of nacelle assembly 77 (4)* 16 13 4 6 3 1 123
second-largest Asia-Pacific (APAC) facilities (onshore)
hub for turbine assembly and key Total number of nacelle assembly 20 (1)* 5 0 0 0 4 0 30
components production, has since facilities (offshore)
gained an increasingly prominent
role in the global wind supply Number of announced nacelle 17 0 2 0 0 0 0 19
chain. assembly facilities (onshore)
Number of announced nacelle 47 1 0 3 0 4 0 55
While most of the suppliers to the assembly facilities (offshore)
wind industry are still based in * facilities owned by western turbine OEMs
APAC, Europe and the Americas,
new entrants have also emerged in
the Middle East and North Africa
(MENA) region. Europe is the world’s second- Global wind turbine manufacturing capacity in 2023
largest turbine nacelle production
Other (APAC excl. China and India) 1%
Will there be enough supply base, with assembly facilities
chain capacity to feed growth? mainly located in Germany, LATAM 4%
Denmark, Spain, France, Portugal India 7%
Turbine nacelles and Turkey. The US is the world’s
Globally, there are 153 turbine third-largest wind nacelle
US 9%
assembly plants currently in manufacturing hub, followed by
operation, with another 74 facilities India and LATAM – primarily Brazil.
either under construction or in the 163 GW
planning stage. China has more Globally, 163 GW of nacelle
than 100 nacelle assembly production capacity is available in Europe 19%
facilities in operation and another 2023. At first glance, the wind
64 under construction. With a industry appears to have enough
turbine nacelle production nacelle assembly capacity to meet
capacity of 98 GW per year, the the projected global demand up
country accounts for 60% of the to 2027. However, the picture is China (incl. capacity from three western turbine OEMs) 60%
global market share, making it by different if separate benchmarks Note: Wind turbine manufacturing capacity refers to wind turbine nacelle assembly capability and doesn’t represent
actual nacelle production in 2023.
far the world’s dominant turbine are applied for onshore and
nacelle manufacturing hub. offshore wind, especially at a Source: GWEC Market Intelligence, February 2023
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 25
Part 2: Challenges in the supply chain
Onshore turbine nacelle capacity Onshore turbine nacelle capacity Onshore turbine nacelle capacity
excl. China & India, 2023 in China, 2023 in India, 2023
Western turbine OEMs 15% (12,000) Chinese turbine OEMs 11% (1,200)
RoW 1% (350)
LATAM 15% (6,150)
regional level. Out of this total, 12 GW is from the turbine nacelle production base, for this decade, we conclude that
three western OEMs: Vestas, SGRE followed by the US (13.6 GW), India the supply chain in China, India
Challenges in the supply chain for and GE Renewable Energy. (11.5 GW) and LATAM (6.2 GW). and LATAM will have enough
onshore wind nacelles nacelle production capacity to
China dominates global onshore With 21.6 GW of annual assembly When we compare these accommodate demand, while the
wind turbine nacelle assembly with capacity per annum, Europe is the production capacities with the rest of world, in a business as
82 GW of identified annual capacity. world’s second largest onshore onshore wind demand projected usual scenario, will continue to
26 GWEC.NET
Part 2: Challenges in the supply chain
Offshore turbine nacelle capacity Expected offshore turbine nacelle capacity Offshore turbine nacelle capacity
excl. China, 2023 excl. China, 2024 in China, 2023
North America 0% North America 0% China (non CN OEMs)
APAC excl. China 6% (1,000)
17% (1,900)
rely on imported wind turbines supply chain is interrupted by Europe and the US can be fully Challenges in the supply chain for
to cope with the anticipated proposed regional initiatives such as utilised – an unlikely occurrence as offshore wind nacelles
growth. ‘Made in Europe’ and ‘Made in the buffer room is normally required to Compared with onshore wind,
USA’ – and no new nacelle assembly ensure suffcient supply and the supply chain for offshore
For Europe and the US, we expect capacity is built at the same time – production capacity will be wind turbines is more
sufficient supply throughout this we expect to see supply chain impacted by the introduction of new concentrated, due to the fact that
decade if western turbine OEMs can constraints in both regions by the onshore turbines with greater power more than 99% of total global
smoothly mobilise the capacity they middle of this decade. Even rating – we foresee a bottleneck offshore wind installation is
own in China and India. However, if assuming that all of the existing occurring from 2026. presently located in Europe and
the free flow of the global wind nacelle production capacity in the APAC region.
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 27
Part 2: Challenges in the supply chain
China is the world’s number-one GWEC Market Intelligence does plans announced by western OEMs
offshore turbine nacelle not see any problems arising in in partnership with Japanese and
production centre with annual the near term, given that Korean firms materialise in time.
assembly capacity of up to 16 GW, European OEMs are able to share
of which 1 GW is owned by one spare offshore nacelle assembly In the US, considering local
western turbine OEM. Excluding capacity with emerging markets content requirements (LCRs)
China, the APAC region has an in APAC and North America in associated tax credits and
offshore turbine nacelle capacity 2023–2024. incentives under the IRA and the
of 1.9 GW, mainly located in two-year lead time needed to
Taiwan and South Korea. However, the situation is going to build a new offshore wind nacelle
change. Starting in 2026, we production facility from scratch, it
In Europe, current nacelle assembly expect Europe’s existing offshore is of the utmost urgency that GE
capacity for offshore wind is about turbine nacelle assembly capacity Renewable Energy, SGRE and
9.5 GW, which we anticipate to no longer be able to support Vestas turn their investment plans
reaching 11.5 GW next year when a growth outside of Europe. into concrete action.
new nacelle facility comes into
operation in Eastern Europe. In fact, we expect that from 2027 There are no plans for offshore
Europe’s offshore wind turbine wind projects to be built in LATAM
No offshore turbine nacelle nacelle assembly capacity will until the latter part of this decade.
assembly facility is currently in struggle to cope with the growth However, early investment is
operation in North America, expected in Europe alone. Existing needed to avoid bottlenecks. This
although GE Renewable Energy, capacity needs to double in order is especially true of Brazil, where
SGRE and Vestas have announced to meet the projected demand for 71 offshore wind projects, totalling
nacelle investment plans for New this region in 2030. more than 170 GW, had filed
York and New Jersey in Q1 2023. environmental investigation
Similar to North America, LATAM Looking at APAC (excluding licences by the end of 2022,
has no offshore nacelle assembly China), although offshore turbine according to the country’s
facilities despite Chinese turbine nacelle capacity is likely to Ministry of Mines and Energy.
OEM Mingyang looking for increase to 3.7 GW after expansion
offshore wind investment work is completed at one of the Key components
opportunities in Brazil since 2020. existing facilities in 2024, it will still GWEC Market Intelligence has
be insufficient to meet demand in been monitoring the supply chain
Looking at the demand and this region from 2027. Taking into for key wind turbine components
supply situation for this decade, account estimates that demand for since 2019. Based on our latest
our benchmark results show offshore wind turbines in this supply chain update, no
more challenges for offshore region will reach 7.9 GW in 2030, it bottlenecks are expected in 2023–
wind than for onshore wind. is imperative that the investment 2024 for key components such as
28 GWEC.NET
Part 2: Challenges in the supply chain
Global WTG blade manufacturing Global WTG generator manufacturing Global wind gearbox manufacturing
capacity in 2022 capacity in 2022 capacity in 2022
Other APAC 1% Other APAC 3% Other APAC 1%
LATAM 7% LATAM 3%
India 12%
India 7%
US 7%
India 11%
130GW 125GW 160GW
Europe 14%
blades and generators, but further is well positioned to support It is also important to note that bearings, towers and flanges with
investment in both components is the expected growth up the supply chain for key more than 70% global market
needed to accommodate growth to 2027. A concentrated supply components is highly dependent share. How other regions enact
after 2024. chain and regionalised on China. In addition to policies designed to reshore
sourcing strategies, however, gearboxes and generators, China production or restrict trade will
Following recent investment, look certain to create controls the global supply chain have a strong impact on the
gearbox manufacturing capacity bottlenecks. for castings, forgings, slewing supply picture and on cost.
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 29
Part 2: Challenges in the supply chain
Case study: Sourcing rare earth materials for wind energy from local supply chains
The increasingly ambitious wind – and following a toughening of
energy targets being set to reduce China’s export restrictions of rare China dominated REE mining and processing in Q4 2022
reliance on traditional energy earth-related technologies – there is
sources – both in terms of growing policy and industrial concern Other 32% Other 6%
geographical and material in Europe, North America, Australia
dependence – present a challenge and elsewhere.
from a supply chain perspective. This
While sourcing enough REPMs for
is particularly true for rare earth
wind energy generation can be Mining Processing
elements (REEs), with top
difficult, the greatest challenge for the
policymakers increasingly calling for
industry is being able to source them
de-risked supply chains.
domestically or from a de-risked
Wind energy uses large amounts of supply chain. In major markets such
rare earth permanent magnets as Europe, the US and Australia,
(REPMs), contributing significantly demand for REPMs in wind energy is China 68% China 94%
to global demand. Wind energy substantially larger than local supply.
OEMs have faced challenges in Source: Benchmark Mineral Intelligence
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
principally in Malaysia and Estonia. producers in the US to help them High-speed drive Medium-speed drive Direct drive REPM consumption, tonnes
Because the wind industry is exposed compete with their Chinese Source: GWEC, Benchmark Mineral Intelligence
Note: This chart displays direct REPM use (magnet volumes) in DD and medium-speed drivetrains per annum. It is not
to the impacts of geopolitical tensions counterparts. Benchmark forecasts normalised to final raw materials demand.
30 GWEC.NET
Part 2: Challenges in the supply chain
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 31
Part 2: Challenges in the supply chain
Wind turbine installation In Europe, the current WTIV supply foresees a likely shortage in All of this has brought the urgency
vessels (WTIVs) chain can cope with demand, given Europe towards the end of this of building supply chain security
According to GWEC Market that annual offshore wind installations decade, unless investment in new for renewables to the top of the
Intelligence’s Global WTIVs are relatively flat and unlikely to WTIVs is made before 2027 political agenda and created a
database 2022, China and reach the 10 GW milestone until (assuming a lead time of three global green investment race.
Europe operate the majority of 2026 – which also explains why years for delivering a new WTIV
jack-up and heavy-lift vessels European vessel operators are able vessel). The Inflation Reduction Act (IRA),
used for offshore wind turbine to release their jack-up and heavy- signed into law by the Biden
installation. No global shortage lift vessels over the next two years to In the US, where only two tailor- Administration in August 2022,
of WTIVs is expected up until support the demand from emerging made Jones Act compliant WTIVs promises to move the US closer to
2026. markets in Asia, mainly Taiwan and are currently under construction, its climate goal. Its provisions on ax
Japan, and the US. plans for new WTIVs will have to be credits and LCRs associated
Following an offshore wind executed in the next two or three incentives have generated concern
installation rush in 2021, new Looking at the supply chain years to avoid bottlenecks, if the in the EU and other countries about
installations in China slowed down situation for the 2027–2030 period, Biden Administration’s target of 30 the IRA’s potential negative impact
in 2022, and we do not expect to however, while GWEC Market GW of offshore wind by 2030 is to on their domestic manufacturing
see 2021-level installations again Intelligence does not expect WTIV be met. industries. In response, the EU
until 2026. supply chain constraints in China, it unveiled its Green Deal Industrial
Restrictive trade policies could Plan, which aims to boost Europe’s
Number of wind turbine installation vessels in 2022 delay the energy transition cleantech competitiveness and to
The past three years have shown keep green investments at home.
80
the exposure and vulnerability of
In operation renewable industries to geopolitical What we are witnessing now is a
70 Under construction/planned
dependencies, commodity price clear misalignment between
60 cycles, logistics bottlenecks and government, industrial, trade and
50
12 19 trade barriers. The sudden post- financial policies. It must be
lockdown recovery of industrial understood that without well-
40
4
production in 2021 led to fierce functioning and competitive
4 competition for raw materials, as global wind supply chains –
30
well as ongoing bottlenecks in alongside equal access to raw
20 manufacturing capacity. materials and components – the
energy transition will not
10 4
Russia’s invasion of Ukraine also materialise. There is a danger
0
48 31 47 37 10 8 4 2 deepened geopolitical concerns that the restrictive trade policies
Jack-up Heavy lift Jack-up Heavy lift Jack-up Heavy lift Jack-up Heavy lift and intensified the existing trade proposed by the EU and the US
(Europe) (Europe) (China) (China) (Asia ex.China) (Asia ex.China) (North America) (North America) tensions between China and other may risk delaying the global
Source: GWEC Market Intelligence Global Offshore Wind Turbine Installation Vessel Database, October 2022 markets, such as Europe and the US. energy transition.
32 GWEC.NET
PART 3: THE RISKS AND OPPORTUNITIES
OF REGIONALISATION
Regionalisation and decoupling supply chains
– risks and opportunities
As a result of the combined effects assembly plants in operation The Inflation Reduction Act (IRA)
of geopolitical threats, climate today, with another 74 facilities provides significant incentives for
imperatives and energy security either under construction or in US-based manufacturing, which
challenges, the deployment of the planning stage. These could render uncompetitive any
renewable energy capacity is assembly plants will need projects that do not use the levels
expected to accelerate components from across the of local content required to qualify
substantially over the coming global supply chain, requiring for the extra tax incentives
years (see Part 1). This substantial investment to meet stipulated in the law. The EU has
acceleration comes as countries demand. expressed ‘serious concerns’
and regions move to implement about the IRA, alleging it may
their ambitious energy and Our analysis in Part 2 also reveals breach WTO international trade
climate targets and is driven by that shortages for both nacelles rules, and has responded with its
continued cost advantages and key components may Green Deal Industrial Plan. Within
compared with fossil fuels. develop in the US and Europe this plan is the Net Zero Industry
mid-decade if the free flow of the Act (NZIA), which requires national
GWEC Market Intelligence has global wind supply chain is governments to apply non-price
increased its forecast for additional impacted by regional initiatives criteria – defined as environmental
wind power installations in the aimed at achieving ‘Made in sustainability, energy system
2023–2030 period by 143 GW Europe’ and ‘Made in the USA’ integration, and contribution to the
(+13% YoY). We now expect the supply chains. resilience of cleantech supply
first TW of wind power to be chains – to procurement
installed by mid-2023 and the GWEC is concerned that mechanisms. These measures
second TW to be reached at the governments around the world do would allow governments to award
end of this decade. not understand the potential higher prices in procurement
impacts of their poorly mechanisms to enable companies
This massive increase in coordinated actions, which is why to invest in EU-based supply
installations will create a need for the availability of key data on chains, and make production more
significant additional capacity supply chain development is sustainable through circular
across the entire wind supply critical, and why continuous economy and other practices.
chain (see Part 2). For example, dialogue with industry must be However, policymakers should
there are 153 turbine nacelle undertaken. beware of introducing more
34 GWEC.NET
Part 3: The risks and opportunities of regionalisation
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 35
requirements and restrictions on Range of options for localisation
industry that do not result in better
rates of return for companies.
Prescriptive
Highly prescriptive taxes
The NZIA also sets an annual Component-specific requirements
wind-turbine manufacturing
capacity target of 36 GW for EU
member states, which is more than
double the 16 GW of wind turbines
installed in Europe in 2022.
However, unlike the clarity and
Incentive based
long-term visibility provided in the Income or production tax credits
IRA, the NZIA does not directly More collaborative approach
address the poor market
conditions that caused the
profitability of European wind measures to ensure high levels of have created a greater
turbine manufacturers to fall. Nor local content in their wind energy understanding of the need to
does it establish new EU funding sectors. The table below create a more diversified and
or financing mechanisms to scale summarises some of the measures resilient supply chain. However,
supply chains to the level required. being introduced by major actors. global trade flows continue to be
critical to global economic
Another key pillar of the EU’s plan, Some countries are reaching well manufacturing. Additionally, actions
the Critical Raw Materials Act, beyond manufacturing, going attempting to decouple from
states that by 2030 10% of raw ‘upstream’ to achieve local supply China and to reshore or localise
materials should be extracted and of critical inputs for their industries, manufacturing capabilities are
at least 40% of them processed in including specific steel products likely to create unintended
the EU. However, what’s not yet used in the wind industry and raw consequences in terms of
clear is how the potentially higher materials such as rare earth bottlenecks and higher costs.
costs of those materials will be elements. In some cases, this These in turn, could have the
distributed fairly among western includes inputs that are currently potential to slow, delay or even
supply chain companies. not produced locally, or are derail the global energy transition.
produced in small quantities.
Many other major economies, It is of critical importance that, as
including Japan, Korea, the UK, The COVID-19 crisis and its they are urged to act on the energy
Poland, India, Taiwan, Saudi Arabia aftermath (including widespread crises, governments around the
and Brazil already have – or are in disruption of logistics and world do not underestimate the
the process of designing – increased geopolitical tensions) potential impacts of poorly
36 GWEC.NET
Part 3: The risks and opportunities of regionalisation
coordinated interventions. This is localisation requirements and generator), slewing bearings, l the availability of critical
why GWEC advocates urgent and argued instead for flexibility in towers, flanges, castings and components and materials
continued dialogue with the wind order to build on national and forgings. By comparison, according l the existence of a skilled
and renewables industry – along regional competitive advantages. to consultancy Wood Mackenzie, no workforce
with the wider network of key As a rule, GWEC is more powertrains or castings were made l the need to create or maintain
components and commodities supportive of incentive-based in the US in 2021. Even in some political support for continued
suppliers – to ensure that policies rather than prescriptive policies as countries where sophisticated market growth.
achieve the intended goals of the former tend to give more manufacturing supply chains exist,
supporting cost-effective and flexibility to both OEMs and the for example India, China is the For the offshore wind sector, a
faster deployment of larger supply chain in optimising their primary supplier of castings. strong degree of localisation is
quantities of renewables while production. imperative, since producing and
boosting local economies and How politicians, policymakers and assembling very large
employment. Measuring the impacts of regulators globally try to address components is best done portside,
reshoring this concentration in the supply facilitating installation in nearby
Governments have several choices As more reshoring policies are chain will have a critical impact on waters. Transporting fully
when they look to localise or being proposed and introduced the wind industry and its ability to assembled nacelles plus blades
reshore their energy sectors. They globally, it is important to reflect on deliver the capacity necessary for and towers from remote locations
can encourage the use of locally the potential impacts on costs and carrying out the energy transition and installing them in limited
produced content either through timing of wind installations. Any in the timelines outlined in the numbers would likely make
incentives and/or preferential time policies require local content, Paris Agreement. projects uneconomical.
treatment, such as tax incentives or either through restrictions or
favourable customs duties. incentives, there is a risk of Industry approaches to There is no exact formula for
Alternatively, they can specify increasing the overall costs of the localisation managing the trade-offs between
which goods or services must be wind power produced. Another As we have noted, wind project localisation and affordability.
provided by domestic suppliers. significant unintended operators and OEMs must take into Achieving the right balance can be
Or they can use a combination of consequence is the creation of consideration a series of complex, particularly challenging in new
both of these approaches. supply chain bottlenecks. interconnected factors when they markets that have yet to deploy wind
decide where to locate projects – and as such do not have
For GWEC members, localising Currently the wind supply chain is manufacturing facilities. These fully developed and/or competitive
production is a desirable approach highly globalised but with China as include: wind supply chains.
that can lead to significant the principal supplier at a
efficiencies and logistical savings. component level. GWEC Market l the size of local wind markets From a purely cost-driven point of
However, achieving necessary Intelligence’s global wind supply l logistical factors view, it makes more sense for
scale to amortise investments in chain analysis shows that China l the existence of national and countries to take a phased
industrial plants is a key concern. controls more than 70% of the regional incentives approach that allows imports of
The industry has advised global supply chain for powertrains l the existence of specific rules key components and aims to
governments against prescriptive (main shaft and gearbox plus around local manufacturing increase localisation as scale
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 37
Part 3: The risks and opportunities of regionalisation
to their own advantages. For regulatory support the wind sector been adopted in the US through
example, for offshore wind, the needs to take off. This is particularly the IRA and would suggest that this
countries around the North Sea have true given the predominance of approach be adopted – and
built an array of interlinked industrial government-run auctions as the adapted, of course, to local
capabilities, a skilled workforce, port main procurement mechanism for circumstances – in other major
facilities and logistics around wind energy and the strong political energy markets such as the EU, the
installation and operations and levers that these create. UK, Japan and elsewhere.
maintenance. It would be desirable
for a similar cooperative ecosystem In the long run, as markets develop, As the world enters a phase of
to evolve to address APAC’s strong the growth of the wind energy significant acceleration of
demand for offshore wind, rather manufacturing sector and related renewable energy deployment,
than every country trying to quickly service sectors can play a key role with governments and the
evolve its own complete offshore in maintaining social and political private sector seeking to realise
wind manufacturing and installation support for the industry. As we heightened ambition, GWEC
supply chains. have seen in places as diverse as believes that the incentive
the UK, the US, Brazil and Denmark, approach will be a key
local manufacturing and differentiator for countries and
The incentive approach will be a key differentiator employment eventually translates
into long-term, bipartisan support
regions wishing to attract the
huge amounts of investment that
for countries and regions in attracting the huge for the wind industry, and creates a the energy transition will
virtuous circle of growth, require. Although the panorama
investments that the energy transition will require investment and higher political is evolving rapidly, it seems
ambition for the sector. clear that other countries and
regions are now scrambling to
increases. It is also important for However, as we have seen, cost In short, industry is usually willing to match the ambitious approach
countries to carefully consider considerations often take second accept some increase in costs in the US has taken and will risk
their specific advantages in terms place to concerns such as local order to achieve political and losing out if they don’t.
of access to materials and investment and job creation; the regulatory support and wider social
components at competitive prices, position of local industrial licence. But some ways of achieving GWEC also believes that the
existing industrial footprints and conglomerates; and political this are better than others. incentive-based approach will
availability of skilled labour. considerations around national play a key role in enabling the
control and rivalries with other The debate around the proposed wind industry to push beyond
Countries with relatively small actors. In many cases, strong approaches for achieving more the challenging period it has
domestic markets need to look to political factors make commitments local content is developing rapidly. faced over the last few years and
regional markets and plan how their to creating a local wind energy GWEC, as already noted, is begin to scale up for the next
industries can make the most of manufacturing industry a strongly supportive of the phase of global growth with
regional supply chains while playing prerequisite for achieving the incentive-led approach that has confidence.
38 GWEC.NET
Part 3: The risks and opportunities of regionalisation
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 39
In order to meet the ambitions of policymakers intervene, and over globalisation. GWEC has
governments, energy consumers which time period. advocated a cautious approach
and wider society, the wind from policymakers involving full
industry needs to invest strongly in If poorly conceived or executed, consultation with relevant actors
increasing the capacity of the actions to impose rapid reshoring in order to fully understand
supply chain while simultaneously could lead to supply chain impacts from trade restrictions.
building resilience and bottlenecks (particularly in the EU
diversification. and the US, but also in other large The scale of the investment and
economies), potentially leading to production needed to carry out the
GWEC believes that material delays in the transition. energy transition will require
policymakers’ approach to this We have already seen the impact continued global and regional
task in the present period could of such bottlenecks on a more collaboration and the scaling up of
greatly impact the success of the localised scale in the past – the widespread investment. We believe
energy transition. Supply chain current situation could see far that it is imperative for policymakers
diversification and reshoring will more significant impacts. to come together to collaboratively
undoubtedly affect the costs of the design mechanisms that facilitate a
transition, but to what extent will GWEC recommends that streamlined, incentivised and
depend on how decisively policymakers, international accelerated energy transition.
institutions, the private sector and
civil society engage in a If designed properly and
comprehensive dialogue to build comprehensively, policies created
Trends in globalisation – here to stay?
supply chains that can meet the to enable the scaling up of the
Global trade is highly complex, and no l ver the past five years, the
O requirements of the Just Energy supply chain and its diversification
region is close to being self-sufficient, largest economies have not Transition while ensuring that represent a huge opportunity for
a McKinsey Global Institute report systematically diversified the necessary inputs are available at the world. We will see in
points out. It makes a few key points: origins of imports. the right pace and without the risk subsequent sections how different
of sharply higher costs and countries and regions are
l No region is close to being self- l Alleconomies have vulnerabilities, bottlenecks. approaching the task.
sufficient. Every region relies on trade some more than others.
with others for more than 25% of at Similarly, the intensification of GWEC and the wind industry will
least one important type of good. l I nformed reimagination of global more restrictive trade practices be engaging in intensive dialogue
trade requires a granular approach and trade disputes could also with all stakeholders in the
l About 40% of global trade is both in mapping concentrated trade lead to price increases and coming months and years to
‘concentrated’, with importing relationships and in deciding on disruption – although the ensure we are playing our role in
economies relying on three or fewer action – whether to double down, evidence suggests that, despite achieving the scaled-up,
nations for this share of global trade. decouple or diversify. increasingly loud debate, we are confident and diverse supply
a long way from an end to chain the world needs.
40 GWEC.NET
PART 4: THE IRA IS SET TO TURBOCHARGE
THE US WIND SECTOR
Part 4: The IRA is set to turbocharge the US wind sector
42 GWEC.NET
Part 4: The IRA is set to turbocharge the US wind sector
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 43
Part 4: The IRA is set to turbocharge the US wind sector
Projected annual clean power capacity installations under the IRA supply chain. New manufacturing growth. China produces nearly
facilities, processing plants and 70% of all powertrains and 65% of
120 raw material production will castings, while the US produced
further catalyse economic growth none of either in 20211. While the
100 97GW
and job creation, with the intention US has enough manufacturing
85GW of insulating the US from capacity to supply most domestic
80
13% CAGR
75GW
geopolitical supply chain risks. demand for onshore turbine
68GW
equipment to 2031,the story is
58GW
60 53GW Protecting against those risks has different for offshore, where the US
44GW engendered criticism that the act is at a standing start. Whether
38GW
40
28GW 28GW
disadvantages foreign companies, enough capacity will come online
but the IRA has also set in motion a to supply all US offshore wind
20 new wave of climate and clean developments planned for
energy ambition. The EU has installation by 2027 remains a key
0
responded with its Green Deal issue.
e
e
21
22
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
are exploring their own responses. Beyond wind power, energy
Source: ACP, 2022 However, uncoordinated storage is eligible to qualify for the
government activity leading to an investment tax credit for the first
entrenchment of national and time, and green hydrogen can
US new wind power installations forecast (MW) regional supply chains risks access a production tax credit
20000 stalling the global wind industry’s rationed depending on the
growth. A coordinated and lifecycle emissions profile of the
balanced expansionist approach fuel’s production.
15000 from governments is necessary for
domestic markets to grow while With clear incentives and stable
ensuring a healthy global supply policies for the renewables
10000
chain that can deliver cost-effective industry in place, the ACP expects
clean energy. annual wind, solar and energy
5000 storage capacity installations to
Uncertainty remains on how grow to over 90 GW by the end of
quickly the global and American the decade, more than tripling the
0 supply chain can adapt to the new 28 GW installed in 2021. This
conditions created by the IRA, to growth will require unprecedented
22
e
23
24
25
26
27
20
20
20
20
20
Onshore Offshore
Source: ACP, 2023
1. https://www.woodmac.com/horizons/boom-time-what-the-inflation-reduction-act-means-for-us-renewables-manufacturers/
44 GWEC.NET
Part 4: The IRA is set to turbocharge the US wind sector
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 45
Part 4: The IRA is set to turbocharge the US wind sector
46 GWEC.NET
PART 5: HOW EUROPE PLANS TO
RISE TO THE CHALLENGE
Part 5: How Europe plans to rise to the challenge
20
reforms last summer to speed up developers on the interpretation of
the permitting of renewables. EU rules across the EU-27 national,
15 These now need to be negotiated regional and local jurisdictions.
10 and enshrined in EU legislation in
a revised EU Renewable Energy The revised EU renewables law will
5 Directive. also ensure that wind energy
0 development goes hand in hand
First is the proposal to consider the with biodiversity protection. The
12
13
14
15
26
17
8
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
21
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
New capacity financed 2022 decrease Investments needed for 2030 of ‘overriding public interest’, strengthen the population-based
Source:WindEurope, 2023 enabling the EU to reach climate approach to species protection,
48 GWEC.NET
which is already part of EU them to existing ones should they Europe clean and digital transition.
environmental law. Doing so will wish to do so. Keeping and expanding a European
ensure a good working balance wind supply chain will reduce costs
between the parallel sets of public Some EU countries are already and energy bills for end consumers
policy interest that are renewables making use of the emergency rules while creating jobs and growth.
and biodiversity while contributing and are taking ambitious steps
to Europe meeting both its climate nationally to improve permitting. In response to the US IRA, the EU
objectives and its energy security Germany’s cabinet has already presented its Green Deal Industrial
goals. In addition, the revision approved and enacted most of the Plan in March 2023 to strengthen
envisages even faster permitting emergency measures. It is applying Europe’s clean energy industries.
deadlines in selected ‘go-to’ areas the concept of ‘overriding public The plan contains two important
where biodiversity risks are minimal. interest’ in court cases. France has pieces of legislation for the
voted on legislation that will speed European wind industry which
The final revision of the EU up the expansion of renewables, could allow it to deploy the right
Renewable Energy Directive is due and Spain is making an effort to investments and volumes going
to be completed in mid-2023. In fast-track the approval of wind and forward.
the meantime, EU governments solar projects stuck in a large
can apply the EU emergency backlog of environmental permit First is the Net-Zero Industry Act,
permitting framework adopted in applications. which targets the industrial
December 2022, which confirmed manufacturing of key technologies
renewables as projects of Industrial policy and equipment that are central to
‘overriding public interest’ so long Europe is also fast-forwarding its the European energy transition. For
as site location is correctly green industrial policy. 2022 was a wind, it sets an annual
selected and mitigation measures difficult year for the wind energy manufacturing capacity target of 36
are in place to protect biodiversity. supply chain, with Europe’s turbine GW. The act focuses on simplifying
It also clarified the permits that manufacturers and suppliers hit hard the permitting processes for new
need to be delivered within the by inflation, dysfunctional trade factories. It also identifies strategic
mandatory permitting deadlines flows, bottlenecks in the sourcing of dependencies across supply chains
for new and repowered projects, materials and poor auction designs and proposes actions to remove
advanced grid connections in some EU countries. existing bottlenecks and increase
approvals, and allowed simplified supply chain resilience.
EIAs for repowering – covering The EU agrees that it needs a
only the additional impacts linked reliable and cost-competitive wind Second is the Critical Raw Materials
to wind farm expansion. The supply chain to achieve its energy Act, which plays a key role in
measures are mandatory for new security goals. And that it must improving the sourcing of materials
projects and new permits, but continue investing in its wind for clean energy that Europe needs.
governments could also apply industrial base to deliver a made in The act explores opportunities for
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 49
mining and processing more raw that alleviates the energy crisis potential of Contracts for
materials in Europe while forging burden for end-consumers while Difference (CfDs) and Power
new trade deals with partners that avoiding a reversal of 20 years of Purchase Agreements (PPAs). It
can diversify supply routes. It also European energy market should also leave space for
emphasises the importance of integration. The EU cannot afford to investors to access some market
recycling and reusing key materials get this wrong. revenue so they can meet their PPA
to help increase the resilience of obligations. This will be key for
Europe’s supply chains. The central response to the current companies managing large
crisis remains more energy supply, portfolios of energy investments
All of this will be underpinned by in particular with more homegrown across different markets, and for
some degree of EU public financial renewable electricity generation. building sound financing strategies
support, including, for instance, Europe’s EMD must therefore send for renewables.
channelling existing resources from the right investment signals to
the EU and national Recovery Plans deploy wind energy at scale and Equally importantly, the new rules
towards critical supply chains. The ensure that the EU’s investment must cement investment certainty.
European Commission and environment for future wind farms Market scale is achieved in
member states are discussing in remains attractive. countries where governments
parallel a more flexible framework respect the stability of existing and
for the allocation of state aid that can Therefore, the existing revenue caps awarded support schemes and
support industrial competitiveness. on inframarginal generators must be market-based arrangements, and
The EU is also considering setting removed and cannot serve as a where governments plan ahead
up a new EU Sovereignty Fund to starting point for EMD reform. In and provide regulatory visibility
finance investments in the strategic 2022, the EU adopted a temporary for the wind industry and its supply
sectors charged with delivering the emergency framework that allowed chain with concrete wind
EU Green Deal. governments to intervene deployment objectives. The EU
exceptionally on power markets to Renewable Energy Directive
Electricity Market Design control prices. Many EU prohibits retroactive changes to
Crucially, Europe is reforming its governments scrambled to existing support mechanisms and
Electricity Market Design (EMD) introduce revenue caps for requires governments to outline
this year. The current market inframarginal power generation in an forward-looking auction schedules
design has been beneficial by uncoordinated fashion – some even (timeline, budget, capacity) and
facilitating the integration of large taxed unrealised revenues. This has technology-specific auctions to
amounts of cost-effective undermined investor confidence attract investments. None of this
renewables. and halted investment in renewables. should be put into question as
Europe reforms its EMD.
EU policymakers are under The new EMD should allow
pressure to deliver a quick reform developers to leverage the Co-authored with WindEurope
50 GWEC.NET
PART 6: WILL CHINA CONTINUE TO BE THE
MARKET LEADER?
Will China continue to be the market leader?
China is the world’s largest wind country’s newly installed power with wind and solar power
market. The country achieved generation capacity. China’s generation, at more than 1,000
record additions of 68.6 GW of renewable energy capacity will TWh, providing 13.8% of China’s
grid-connected onshore wind in continue to grow as the country electricity consumption.
2020 and 16.9 GW of offshore strives to meet at least half of its
installations in 2021 – a miracle incremental power demand growth Although renewable energy is
driven primarily by the complete with renewables under the 14th growing fast, coal power
phaseout of renewables subsidies. Five-Year-Plan. generation will still play a crucial
role this decade. A severe drought
Shifting from a subsidy-driven Political commitment paves the last summer saw Sichuan province
market to a pro-renewables way for long-term development suffer electricity shortages due to
market Since China’s President Xi Jinping its reliance on hydropower. New
Since 2022, China’s renewable announced the ‘30-60’ target in coal-fired power projects in
energy market has entered a new 2020 – to achieve peak emissions Sichuan were approved late last
stage. The support for renewables by 2030 and carbon neutrality by year to prevent a recurrence of this
has switched from a feed-in tariff 2060 – China has started working situation but will be built next to
(FiT) model to a ‘grid parity’ on the long-term goal of creating a large-scale renewable energy
model, whereby electricity new type of power system with facilities so that the flexibility
generated from renewables will renewables at its core. Speaking at offered by thermal power plants
receive the same remuneration as the 20th Party Congress Report in can support renewable energy
that from coal-fired power plants. 2022, the President said that the integration.
planning and construction of the
Nevertheless, the phaseout of new energy system should be How the 14th Five-Year Plan will
subsidies has not slowed the pace accelerated, providing a blueprint support renewables
of renewable energy development for energy security and low- From the Gobi Desert to the sea,
in China. Although new grid- carbon, green development. and from the Tibetan Plateau to
connected wind capacity in 2022 the vast plains, several 10 GW-
was only 37.6 GW – a 21% drop By the end of 2022, standing at level wind and solar farms have
from the previous year, mainly 1,213 GW, China’s installed been completed and put into
driven by COVID-19 restrictions – renewable energy capacity operation, such as Jiuquan in
installations of all renewables surpassed coal power for the first Gansu, Hami in Xinjiang, and
including hydropower, wind, solar time. Renewable energy now Zhangjiakou in Hebei. Gobi and
and biomass recorded a stellar accounts for 47.3% of the country’s other desert areas, including the
year, accounting for 76% of the total power generation capacity, upper reaches of the Yellow River,
52 GWEC.NET
Part 6: Will China continue to be the market leader
China’s 14th Five-Year Period renewable energy development plan energy. Data centres are being
located in the vicinity of huge wind
farms in northern China to use
green electricity locally.
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 53
Part 6: Will China continue to be the market leader
Average tender prices of wind turbines in China (CNY/kW) historic leap – from ‘following’ to
‘running alongside’ and now
‘leading’ – in wind technology
8000 development.
7000
Ambitious targets will boost
6000 offshore wind development
5000 Construction of several 10 GW
offshore wind bases is anticipated
4000
off the eastern coast, while a
3000 number of provincial and
2000
municipal governments have been
working on offshore wind
1000 development plans since 2020.
0
The market potential for offshore
20
20
20
20
21
21
21
21
22
22
22
22
23
wind is growing and the local
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
industry is ready to support annual
1
1
Q
Q
Onshore Offshore installations of approximately 15
GW. Last November, at the Global
Note: Prices are based on date of tender and include wind tower
Source: China Bidding Centre, February 2023
Offshore Wind Summit-China 2022
co-organised by GWEC in Haikou,
Hainan, the Chinese wind industry
More than 15 wind turbine in the long term as the large two-to-three years Chinese released an initiative that calls for
manufacturers are active in China. Chinese EPC contractors will likely turbine OEMs like Mingyang, 100 GW of offshore wind in China
Although the domestic market is shift their investment from thermal Goldwind and Haizhuang have by 2025, 200 GW by 2030 and
large, competition has become power plants to renewable released offshore turbines in the 1,000 GW by 2050. If this happens,
increasingly fierce, with record-low projects. 16–18 MW range. In February China will make up 50% of the
prices being reported in the past 2023, Envision launched the Global Offshore Wind Alliance’s
two years. To survive the domestic Leading wind turbine technology EN-220/10 MW model and two global offshore wind target for
price war, Chinese OEMs started Price pressure has acted as a weeks later SANY rolled out the 2050.
exploring opportunities overseas. driver of technology innovation, 230/8-11MW prototype in Beijing
Additionally, as the Chinese as Chinese wind turbine OEMs – the largest onshore wind China’s first floating offshore wind
government announced in have continued to launch new turbine in the world. turbine, the Three Gorges Pioneer,
September 2021 that it would stop turbines with greater power was installed in July 2021 in
funding new coal projects abroad, rating and bigger rotors to remain The Chinese wind power Yangjiang, Guangdong. Two demo
this will drive wind turbine exports competitive. Over the past equipment industry has achieved a platforms have been installed
54 GWEC.NET
Part 6: Will China continue to be the market leader
since, and a couple of projects Floating offshore wind projects in Southern China Sea
have been announced. China’s first
floating wind platform with a water
Guangzhou
depth of more than 100 metres and
further than 100 kilometres from Shenzhen
shore, the ‘CNOOC Guanlan’ – will
be operational in June 2023. It will Hong Kong
provide electricity for the China’s first floating wind turbine
Wenchang offshore oilfield in China’s first floating wind platform with a water depth
Hainan. of more than 100 metres and an offshore
distance of more than 100 kilometres
22
e
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
predicted that generation from wind Onshore Offshore
and solar power will double by 2025 Source: GWEC Market Intelligence, March 2023
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 55
Part 6: Will China continue to be the market leader
56 GWEC.NET
PART 7: HOW TO ACHIEVE A JUST TRANSITION
Part 7: How to achieve a just transition
58 GWEC.NET
Part 7: How to achieve a just transition
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 59
Part 7: How to achieve a just transition
Mineral intensity for wind power by turbine type so far failed to sufficiently engage
with the communities that are most
Overall mineral intensity (kg/MW) Use of rare earth elements (kg/MW) affected – the highly coal-
dependent regions.
DFIG
The Planning for Climate
Gearbox
Commission (PCC) has made
significant progress in accelerating
PMSG a JET dialogue through a series of
multi-stakeholder consultations.
The PCC developed a just
transition framework that seeks to
PMSG engage in tackling various aspects
Direct drive
60 GWEC.NET
Part 7: How to achieve a just transition
support a JET in African and Asian also their supply to the grid. This States in the US have typically taken Policy recommendations
countries such as Indonesia, India, will underpin the case for a coal a localised approach to assessing 1. Commit to a diverse, equitable
Senegal and Vietnam.13 At the Bali phaseout driven by the credible the impacts of the energy transition and inclusive workforce
G20 summit, held in November prospect of a sufficient volume of on their workforce. The growth of through outreach.
2022, Indonesia launched its JETP clean energy to replace it. the offshore wind sector is opening Mainstreaming diversity, equity
supported by the International up opportunities for workers in and inclusion in the workforce
Partners Group (IPG), which The South Africa initiative has the other industries to pursue a career requires commitment and action
includes the US, Canada, Japan, the potential to pave the way for in the green economy – facilitated across company segments, from
EU, the UK, Norway, Germany, longer-term climate action through by reskilling and training human resources to marketing
France, Italy and Denmark. Over a policy instruments like the JETP. investment, alongside stakeholder to senior leadership. The wind
period of three to five years, the Other coal-dependent countries engagement. sector should be seen as an
Indonesian JETP promises to can look to South Africa to see the attractive and welcoming place
mobilise 20 billion USD worth of links between a just transition, Examples of this include:
investment.14 achieving national decarbonation
goals, and meeting NDCs . l OEM Carolina Long Bay
B Diversity should encompass
Increased investment will only offshore wind auction: bidders
drive a JET if the funding is actually United States and the Inflation are awarded a 20% monetary gender, ethnicity and
fed into localities to accelerate Reduction Act: investment in credit to support workforce
physical ability
renewables projects. One training and local supply chains training programmes to develop
challenge the wind sector and The Biden Administration’s the local supply chain. The total
16
other renewables are facing is a Inflation Reduction Act (IRA)15 is a credit awarded is around 42
lack of agency, with funding being national policy framework that million USD. to work at different career
set out but not fed into the project promises to further the just stages. Youth outreach and
pipeline. This must be actively transition by enabling local l The North America Building education can ensure that the
challenged: if local projects and production and job creation Trade Union (NABTU) and industry’s diversified job
infrastructure are not implemented, through an unprecedented array Ørsted: a Project Labour opportunities are understood,
the JETP risks losing credibility. of measures facilitating investment Agreement (PLA) brings particularly in early-stage wind
into good jobs and mitigation together the private sector and countries. Diversity should
If coal is to be phased out in measures that protect impacted the unions to help the US encompass gender, ethnicity
coal-dependent areas, the supply workers and communities. workforce meet the and physical ability. A cultural
of renewables needs to grow requirements of the offshore change in companies will enable
significantly. To achieve this, By specifying the workforce and wind farm supply chain.17 them to leverage the talent of
countries need to create enabling communities as key stakeholders
13. https://www.g7germany.de/resource/blob/974430/2057928/1315842ed9de069fa1be82dab18dabb2/2022-06-28-leaders-communique-
regulatory and economic that should benefit from this executive-summ-data.pdf?
conditions that support and investment, it sends a clear signal to 14. https://www.gov.uk/government/news/indonesia-just-energy-transition-partnership-launched-at-g20
15. https://www.epa.gov/green-power-markets/inflation-reduction-act
facilitate not only the deployment investors and civil society that a 16. https://www.doi.gov/pressreleases/biden-harris-administration-announces-winners-carolina-long-bay-offshore-wind-energy
of renewable energy assets but green economy can provide stability. 17. https://nabtu.org/press_releases/nabtu-orsted-sign-landmark-mou/
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 61
Part 7: How to achieve a just transition
women and people from more sustainable local supply 5. Investment to facilitate
minorities. chains and jobs. Governments retraining, reskilling and
and the wind industry should sustainable job creation.
2. Drive social dialogue and collaborate to review local Governments and the private
increased stakeholder industrial supply chains and sector should provide funding
engagement both nationally foster the creation of decent towards training and reskilling
and locally. Creating space for jobs. Schemes to incubate programmes that can benefit
social dialogue and increasing businesses and capabilities for them both. Investing into the
stakeholder engagement the wind sector, such as workforce will benefit the
supports social cohesion and a favourable loans and the economy at large while
common understanding of the promotion of industrial enabling the private sector to
challenges and opportunities clusters, will support the tailor skills to its project
ahead. Stakeholders include creation of viable local supply requirements. The investment
displaced workers, residents of chains. will pay off in multiple ways and
communities hosting projects boost the green economy.
and members of affected 4. Tailored reskilling/
communities such as the fishing retraining pathways to 6. R
egulations in mining and
industry for offshore wind. The transfer from carbon- extractive communities to
need to discuss a JET is well intensive industries to wind ensure an ethical work
understood but the dialogue industry jobs. Acknowledging environment. National policies
needs to translate into national varying skill sets and must ensure that working
ambition, alongside transparent providing tailored training conditions do not allow the
local engagement, for programmes will reduce the exploitation of workers, and that
communities to understand and barriers to entry into the wind mining communities for REE
feed into the actions that will workforce. Having identified and other critical materials are
affect them. viable projects, the public sustainable. Because these
sector and the wind industry materials come from a limited
3. Promote public-private should work together to number of countries, targeted
collaboration to create value identify communities of need regulation is needed to protect
locally. Regions that depend and match them with the workforce and promote
on the production of fossil fuels anticipated workforce gaps. growth in the wind energy
for revenue may face By supporting career sector. Standards must be set to
economic displacement in a progression pathways for avoid greater demand leading
rapid phaseout. On the path to fossil-fuel workers into to more exploitation, and strictly
decarbonising their energy renewable energy, the public enforced to protect the rights of
systems, they must be sector will encourage labour workers and provide them with
encouraged to transition to mobility and upskilling. decent working conditions.
62 GWEC.NET
CASE STUDIES
Case Study: Global Alliance for Sustainable Energy
64 GWEC.NET
of sustainability standards and the produced/acquired with Certified common understanding between
adoption of best practices. EPD/LCA with explicit bill of utilities and suppliers on
materials by the end of 2024. climate-compatible buying
The following are examples of strategies.
elements put forward by the l Traceability and auditing for at
alliance for integrating into tender least two key raw materials used The Global Alliance for
processes between suppliers and in one main component by the Sustainable Energy was initially
clients: end of 2024. convened by the Enel Foundation.
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 65
Case Study: Women in Wind
Women in Wind
The wind energy industry is still Women in Wind (WiW) was formed
heavily male-dominated, with only in 2019 to address this gap in the
21% of the global wind energy wind industry. It aims to support
workforce being women – lower and encourage the advancement of
than the renewables sector overall women in the wind energy sector
and lower than the oil & gas by providing them with the
industry – according to the necessary skills and opportunities
landmark Wind Energy: A Gender to become leaders in their field.
Perspective report, published in
2020 by the Women in Wind Looking ahead, WiW aims to lead
Global Leadership Program (WiW) by example and to work with
in partnership with IRENA.1 companies within the wind sector
66 GWEC.NET
Case Study: Women in Wind
Programme methodology
Currently recruiting its fifth cohort,
WiW is an intensive 12-month
programme covering a range of
learning and development
activities including online courses,
workshops, mentoring and
networking events.
Key outcomes
Increased representation in
leadership positions
As a result of the programme,
several participants have been
promoted to leadership positions
within their organisations, and
many others have taken on
additional responsibilities and
expanded their professional
networks.
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 67
Case Study: Women in Wind
with many citing increased Profiled participants from the 2022 cohort
visibility, better communication
skills, and a more positive outlook
as key benefits of the
programme.
68 GWEC.NET
FOCUS ON OFFSHORE WIND
Focus on offshore wind
70 GWEC.NET
Focus on offshore wind
Progress has been less marked lifted restrictions on foreign predictable project pipelines and (EIA) timelines, largely stemming
elsewhere. Vietnam, with 599 GW ownership in renewable energy the policy infrastructure for from local fishing community
of offshore wind potential, faces and awarded more than 50 wind massive scale-up. resistance.4 GWEC welcomes the
major policy uncertainty as the energy service contracts for more government’s intention to move to
Power Development Plan 8 (PDP8) than 40 GW of offshore wind There were high hopes for Japan a central system of allocation and
targeting 7 GW of offshore wind by capacity. However, the government following the launch of its First stands ready to support these
2030 remains in draft form since its has yet to draft the rules and Vision for the Offshore Wind Power efforts.
release in March 20213. Vietnam’s regulations governing the activities Industry in 2020. It has since
Ministry of Industry and Trade of offshore wind farms, from started drawing out designated Taiwan’s Round 3.1 was highly
(MOIT) is seeking to develop an pre-development to operation. sea areas that will be dedicated for contested with seven offshore wind
auction framework for offshore general auction. However, projects being awarded to nine
wind but regulations on site More mature markets like Japan, concerns have been raised about developers. However, concerns
surveying and marine spatial Taiwan and South Korea have basic the transparency of the selection persist about auction design,
planning are unclear. policy frameworks that enable the criteria for the offshore tender,
initial deployment of offshore wind compounded by lengthy 3. Global Wind Report (GWEC, 2022)
4. Japan’s Offshore Wind Faces High Risks on the High
In the past year, the Philippines projects but lack robust policy, Environmental Impact Assessment Seas (BNEF, 2019)
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 71
Focus on offshore wind
including an unrealistically low more and more areas look to build transformation programme that
price cap and poor flexibility in their offshore wind capacity. This promotes collaboration across the
terms of the localisation calls for initiatives that facilitate supply chain to improve
requirement. skills and knowledge transfer, and productivity and facilitates shared
for national governments to move growth opportunities between
Vestas recently invested 300 away from ‘business as usual’ developers and the supply chain.
million USD in South Korea5, approaches. Strengthening
confirming the country’s collaboration through public- The Global Offshore Wind Alliance
increasing attractiveness as the private partnerships is the key to (GOWA)8, a global diplomatic
next high-potential offshore wind closing the gap between reality initiative launched at COP27 by
market. Despite a relatively mature and ambition by building on Denmark, IRENA and GWEC, aims
supply chain, South Korea has yet existing industry strength to unlock to create a multi-stakeholder
to finalise a one-stop-shop (OSS) the world’s offshore wind potential community to achieve 380 GW by
bill that would truly kickstart and enable global scale-up. 2030 and beyond (see page 79).
offshore wind development.
Public private partnerships will Industry and governments can work together
accelerate deployment
Accelerating offshore wind to accelerate deployment through existing
globally at the scale required to technologies and robust policy frameworks
deliver on the energy transition will
require unprecedented efforts
from both governments and the
private sector, working together in The UK’s Offshore Wind Sector Conditions for accelerating
partnership. Deal6 is an attractive model that offshore wind development
brings the government and Industry and governments can
As the test bed of large-scale, industry together, each with clear work together to unblock
commercial offshore wind roles and responsibilities, to bottlenecks and accelerate
deployment, Europe has enabled overcome challenges to offshore offshore wind deployment through
the industry to acquire wind development. The sector deal existing technologies and robust
considerable knowledge and sets out collaboration across areas policy frameworks.
expertise. The cumulative offshore such as supply chain growth,
wind experience will advance system integration, skills and future 5. https://www.koreaherald.com/view.
php?ud=20230119000218
across a variety of structures workforce. The Offshore Wind 6. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/
including regions, states and Growth Partnership7 sits alongside offshore-wind-sector-deal
7. https://owgp.org.uk/
countries with different demand the sector deal as an industry- 8. https://www.irena.org/Energy-Transition/Partnerships/
profiles and growth aspirations as funded long-term business GOWA
72 GWEC.NET
Focus on offshore wind
GWEC has identified some urgent can also help capture benefits and
next steps that we recommend opportunities related to
governments take if they are to biodiversity and nature
take full advantage of the energy conservation, ensuring the wind
independence and socioeconomic industry continues to be a leader
benefits that offshore wind can in delivering positive
bring. socioeconomic outcomes for all
communities. Effective permitting
Permitting relies on streamlined regulatory
Globally, offshore wind projects frameworks and a coordinated
typically take up to nine years to approach within a country,
move from early development including models like a an OSS
stage to full commissioning9. The approach, the open-door scheme,
bulk of this time is spent in the and fast-track procedures.
permitting and consenting stage,
with timelines stretching even Establishing a single contact point
further when there are barriers or will ensure a smooth and
delays in the permitting process10. administratively lean process from
Generally, once permitted, large- consenting through to
scale offshore wind projects can decommissioning. The concept of
be constructed very quickly – an OSS has long been used in
typically in two years, depending mature European markets like the
on project size.11 UK and the Netherlands. Learning
from European best practices,
Done right, effective permitting other countries are now starting to
regimes can unlock significant adopt this approach. In 2022, Brazil
amounts of offshore wind capacity, introduced an OSS system through
enabling it to contribute to an information portal that manages
economic growth, as well as to the offshore areas used for power.12
provision of large-scale, South Korea’s National Assembly
homegrown clean electricity. has been discussing a proposed
Holistic approaches to permitting OSS Bill13 to make progress on the
9. GWEC, Five Point Plan (2022)
10. GWEC’s Statement on Implementing Vietnam’s PDP 8 Target and Net Zero Commitment (2022)
11. Joint Statement by GWEC and the Global Solar Council at the G20 Investment Forum on Energy Transition (2022)
12. Ordinance N.3 of 19 October 2022, https://www.in.gov.br/en/web/dou/-/portaria-interministerial-mme/mma-n-3-de-
19-de-outubro-de-2022-437756126
13. Special Act on Offshore Wind Power Development (SAOWPD)
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 73
Focus on offshore wind
74 GWEC.NET
Focus on offshore wind
be delayed, creating bottlenecks to Development Statement to drive While the commercialisation of this Floatgen, installed at the offshore
growth and to the achievement of longer-term supply chain technology is still in its early test site in 2018.
climate targets. investment. stages, to date 35 countries have a
hydrogen plan and 17 are Auction design
GWEC would urge governments Deploying offshore wind at the preparing one, according to BNEF. (non-price criteria)
looking to establish their first speed and scale required for the IRENA identifies China, the EU, After a decade of cost reductions,
leasing process to consider the energy transition will necessitate India, Japan, South Korea and the offshore wind is at an inflection
short- and long-term trade-offs new approaches to leasing that US as early adopters. point with a highly competitive
when it comes to leasing fees and prioritise volume. An intriguing LCOE that is now 3 USD/MWh
allocation. Uncapped competitive new model has emerged from In Australia, green hydrogen is at below that of coal and 18 USD/MWh
allocation of leases, for example, Denmark, where the Open Door the centre of global below that of gas.18 While achieving
may result in higher short-term policy would allow developers to decarbonisation strategies. In
revenues for leasing authorities, identify potential sites, undertake preparation for Australia to
but to the longer-term detriment of preliminary investigations and become a major hydrogen Deploying offshore wind at
electricity consumers. Uncapped secure grid connections. At the exporter, the government the speed and scale required
competitive allocation may also not time of writing, the scheme had published in early 2022 a National
contribute to more holistic supply regrettably been suspended. The Hydrogen Strategy. With a vision to necessitates new approaches to
chain growth outcomes. industry hopes that the Danish
government reconsiders.
be at the forefront of renewable
hydrogen production and export,
leasing that prioritise volume
In the UK, The Crown Estate, the Queensland State Government
which owns the territorial seabed Hydrogen launched the Hydrogen Industry affordable electricity remains the
out to 12 nautical miles off Green hydrogen and power-to-X Workforce Development Roadmap key priority, it is also important for
England, Wales and Northern can drive the transition in transport 2022-2032 at the Australian Clean the industry to scale up while
Ireland, is legally required to and the hard-to-abate sectors. Energy Summit in July 2022. maximising the overall industrial
achieve ‘best consideration’ for its Green hydrogen solutions could and system value for offshore wind.
dealings. The competitive bidding decarbonise iron and steel, Offshore wind has a central role
approach, however, raises the long-haul aviation and shipping. to play in green hydrogen The introduction of the IRA in the
concern that additional costs will As renewable electrification and production. In 2022, the world’s US to drive domestic
find their way into prices paid by storage technologies continue to first offshore green hydrogen manufacturing capability, regional
consumers. GWEC would instead advance, green hydrogen has the production platform was transmission and investment is
encourage emerging markets to potential to be employed across inaugurated in France. The heralding a new era in the
look towards Scotland’s ScotWind all sectors. With accelerated electrolyser, supplied by Plug international race for offshore
leasing model, where bidding deployment, its costs can be Power and developed with Lhyfe, wind. The beneficial changes to
fees were capped to 100,000 GBP competitive with blue hydrogen is the first capable of operating on the tax credit available, when
per square kilometre. The by the early 2030s. Green a floating platform.17 It will use
ScotWind process includes a hydrogen also has great export electricity supplied by BW Ideol’s 17. Lhyfe (2022) inaugurates world’s first offshore
renewable hydrogen production pilot site
mandatory Supply Chain potential. floating offshore wind turbine 18. 2H 2022 Levelized Cost of Electricity Update (BNEF)
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 75
Focus on offshore wind
76 GWEC.NET
Focus on offshore wind
available in the project feasibility sustainability and biodiversity; Hollandse Kust West (HKW) tender
evaluation for their first offshore system integration and innovation; placed a high priority on non-price
tender round in 2020. One of the supply chain development and criteria as the tender focused on
requirements was a track record of benefits to communities. how well the wind farm can be
engagement with key stakeholders integrated into the Dutch energy
and impact on local and national Selected criteria should be: system. Site VI of HKW, on the other
employment and manufacturing. l Clear and objective to identify hand, focused on biodiversity.23
the right project without being
In Taiwan, stringent LCRs required discriminatory against any group Ultimately, non-price criteria in
developers to locally procure 26 ‘key of stakeholders. auction design should encourage
development items’ for at least 60% l Transparent and measurable to healthy competition and innovation
of a project’s proposed capacity. avoid introducing additional while enabling rapid scale-up of
Without a clear implementation administrative processes and offshore wind development and the
pathway and sufficient support complex bidding activities. recovery of costs.
mechanisms from governments, l Reasonable and practical to
LCRs can be counterproductive by build on current industry Floating offshore wind
driving up prices while hampering capabilities without further With 80% of the world’s offshore
competition and innovation. Local inflating the cost or delaying wind resource potential in areas
value is best created through project development. with a water depth of more than 60
naturally local jobs, particularly in metres, from 2030 we expect to
transport, construction and O&M In 2022, the German Parliament see a rapid acceleration of floating
– as the servicing of wind farms adopted a new offshore wind law offshore wind.24 Many of the Non-price criteria in auction design
creates jobs over the full project (WindSeeG) establishing two emerging offshore markets, such
lifetime of 20+ years while job types of auctions, one of which as Vietnam and the Philippines, are should encourage innovation while
creation in manufacturing requires a involves negative bidding with no predominantly floating markets. enabling rapid development
market with long-term stability. caps on the amounts developers Mature markets are increasingly
bid. The industry sees this change looking at floating offshore as they
Including non-price criteria should as doing more harm than good, as run out of seabed areas suitable
enable a shift from focusing on uncapped negative bidding means for fixed-bottom offshore projects.
lowest-price projects to rewarding additional costs for electricity
project delivery with highest consumers and the supply chain.22 20. https://www.weforum.org/projects/system-value
21. https://windeurope.org/policy/position-papers/
value.20 The use of these criteria windeurope-position-on-non-price-criteria-in-auctions/
recognises the wider societal Non-price criteria are increasingly 22. https://windeurope.org/newsroom/press-releases/
negative-bidding-in-german-offshore-wind-law-threatens-
value that wind energy brings. accepted in Europe, with all supply-chain/
successful offshore wind auctions in 23. https://windeurope.org/newsroom/press-releases/
europes-latest-offshore-auction-mainly-using-non-price-
Non-price criteria can be prioritised 2022 including non-price criteria as criteria-is-a-success/
if they fall under three categories21: part of the evaluation. Site VII of the 24. Floating Offshore Wind - A Global Opportunity (GWEC)
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 77
Focus on offshore wind
78 GWEC.NET
Focus on offshore wind: GOWA
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 79
Focus on offshore wind: OEP
80 GWEC.NET
Focus on offshore wind: OEP
Accelerating ocean-based The OEP knows that while there The OEP will create a network of
renewable energy requires new are common elements to regional experts that can work with
approaches to deployment, building a successful offshore governments and stakeholders to
including a sustainable approach wind sector, it is essential to build knowledge on offshore wind.
to ocean stewardship, to avoid the work within the unique economic Serving as a catalyst for longer-
industry being caught in the and political contexts of each term systematic change, the OEP
crossfire of wider conversations country. For this reason, it intends to provide experts who
around ocean management. focuses on a number of actions can sit alongside officials in
that are crucial to successful governments, rather than work
In new markets especially, the project delivery. remotely from within large
offshore wind industry needs to consultancies. This will allow us to
establish early partnerships with Expertise and networking support learning inside new
conservation groups and local Because the wind industry has so country markets and accelerate
communities to shape emerging far deployed and invested in the growth in expertise.
regulations and political vast majority of offshore wind
narratives. projects, the OEP occupies a The OEP will also make an
ongoing effort to create and/or
invest in local networks to facilitate
While there are common elements to a successful dialogue and shared working
between ocean and nature NGOs,
offshore wind sector, it is essential to work with the community groups, industry
unique context of each country groups and government
stakeholders.
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 81
Policy heat map
Renewable energy by 2030
Egypt China
45%
● 42% renewable energy by 2035 with ● 50 GW of planned installations during the
support of Green Corridor Initiative 14th Five-Year Period (2021–2025)
● Installations projected to rise from 1.7 GW ● Projected annual installations of
60 GW Offshore wind by 2030 to 8 GW by 2030 70–80 GW until 2030
● Multi-GW scale projects in early stages of ● Local industry ready to support annual
development installations of approximately 15 GW South Korea
300 GW Offshore wind by 2050 ● Wind energy target increase from 2 to 34%, as
part of a 30% renewables target by 2036
● Projected 34 GW of installed wind energy
by 2036
● New government implementing a 'One Stop
Shop Bill' to fast-track project development
Uzbekistan
South
United States Korea
Japan
30 GW Offshore wind by 2030
Tunisia China
Morocco
Algeria
Egypt
Mexico Saudi India Taiwan
Arabia 15 GW Offshore wind over
2026–2035 (1.5 GW/yr)
Mauritania
Thailand
Senegal Vietnam
Philippines
Costa Rica
Nigeria
Ethiopia
Ghana
17 GW Wind energy by 2030
Colombia
Kenya
Indonesia
India
Brazil Tanzania
100% ● Annual target of 8 GW onshore wind
Peru Brazil ● Cross-party support for wind tender every year between 2023 and
100% energy as a driver of economic Renewable 2030 based on a single-stage
power by
growth and job creation 2030 two-envelope bid system. 28 GW Wind energy by 2030
● ABEEólica expects annual additions ● MNRE published a strategy paper
Renewable
power by in the region of 3 GW for onshore Mozambique outlining a tender trajectory of 37 GW of
2030
wind over the next decade Nambia offshore wind by 2030
● Offshore wind and green hydrogen ● Indian government and industry seizing
Australia
expected as additional drivers for supply chain opportunities
wind energy development
South Africa
Uruguay
Chile
Argentina
Australia
● New national government supportive of onshore
Victoria - offshore and offshore wind development
9 GW wind by 2040 ● Offshore Electricity Infrastructure Regulations
No federal targets
released
● Announced areas for offshore wind in
Gippsland (Victoria)
Strong installed capacity increase, new ambitious targets and/or policy improvement
Adequate targets and policies, but not matched by expected progress
Lack of progress or regression
82 GWEC.NET
MARKETS TO WATCH
Markets to watch: Brazil
84 GWEC.NET
Markets to watch: Brazil
in wind farms, there is a 2.9 BRL With around 8,000 kilometres of The bill was drafted by former Rio
uplift on GDP.4 coastline blessed with strong Grande do Norte Senator Jean Paul
oceanic winds, Brazil has the Prates – now the newly appointed
The wind energy sector in Brazil is potential to install more than 1,200 CEO of state energy incumbent
consolidating its growth under the GW of offshore wind, according to Petrobras. An offshore wind
free electricity market environment a study by the World Bank.6 This enthusiast, he has raised
and saw a further shift away from dwarfs the already impressive 500 expectations that the company will
regulated auctions towards GW that ABBéolica estimates could review its strategic plan for 2023-27
corporate PPAs in 2022, giving it be installed onshore. to boost investment in renewable
added resilience. energy, and offshore wind
The past year saw a flurry of specifically. A significant shift may
ABEEólica expects annual additions regulatory activity around offshore take time, but with its strong wind
in the region of 3 GW for onshore wind power generation. Since supply chain and well-established
wind over the next decade – but Federal Decree 10,946/2022 – offshore engineering expertise,
hopes this will prove to be a
conservative estimate. It is
particularly optimistic about the With its strong wind supply chain and well-
prospects for a new and very
promising offshore wind energy established offshore engineering expertise, Brazil
market as the regulatory foundations could position itself as a regional leader
for its success are being laid.
Offshore wind:
great expectations setting guidelines on the use of Brazil could position itself as a
Even before the cabinet of President maritime space and the regional leader in an area with
Lula took office on 1 January 2023, exploitation of natural resources several countries poised to invest
the Director of Energy Development – came into force in June 2022, a heavily in offshore wind energy.
at the Ministry of Mines and Energy draft bill on offshore energy
(MME), Marina Rossi, had been regulation (PL 576/2021) started For 2023, ABEEólica plans to
talking up the role of offshore wind making its way through parliament continue to work towards the
in the country’s economic and two ordinances provided establishment of a sound and
development, emphasising the guidelines on the use of maritime consistent regulatory framework for
importance of streamlined rules to areas and the creation of a one- offshore wind, with the support of
facilitate deployment.5 stop-shop for project licensing. GWEC and an industry keen to
invest in the country. Another major
4. https://ABEEólica.org.br/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/Estudo-Braulio_final.pdf
5. https://www.folhape.com.br/economia/ventos-fortes-nas-usinas-eolicas-contra-o-aquecimento-global/250189/
boost for the sector could come from
6. https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2020/05/27/energia-eolica-offshore-brasil-esmap green hydrogen, which has the
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 85
Strap to watch: Brazil
Markets
86 GWEC.NET
Markets to watch: India
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 GWEC.NET 87
Strap to watch: India
Markets
Energy Agency, it also published a India’s domestic annual high-impact opportunities for
conceptual plan with a pipeline of 15 manufacturing capacity stands at catalysing wind power generation
offshore wind projects. Additionally, 10-12 GW for wind turbine and manufacturing in the state of
the Center of Excellence on generators. India is also the world’s Tamil Nadu. GWEC also
Offshore Wind and Renewable second-largest market for gearbox presented a similar scenario to
Energy, jointly set up by the Danish manufacturing and the second- the government of Gujarat,
government and the MNRE, largest supplier of blades and alongside recommendations on
published reports on maritime generators in the APAC region. repowering, offshore wind, robust
spatial planning that build on earlier monitoring of utility-scale wind
FOWIND4 and FOWPI5 projects. To further strengthen its leadership farms and transmission projects
in the wind manufacturing sector, to various central government
Creating a market for offshore India must put in place a roadmap agencies.
wind in India demands a strong for a resilient supply chain of raw
partnership between the materials – including rare earth India is in a unique position to
government, development finance metals and non-standard steel – and leverage growing export and
institutions, commercial banks, the for specific jobs such as casting and international service opportunities
offshore wind industry, and local forging. Existing import duty relief in the APAC and European regions.
communities. Developing India as on equipment and components A strategic supply chain impetus is
an attractive offshore wind market such as balsa wood and pultruded pivotal to scaling up India’s wind
further requires the introduction of carbon fibre, which cannot be manufacturing sector.
appropriate standards, such as produced or manufactured in India,
environmental impact assessment must continue. Prime Minister Narendra Modi
(EIA) guidelines, and support for has called for India to become a
energy offtake while ensuring the Micro, small and medium developed economy by 2047.6 In
competitiveness of offshore wind. enterprises (MSMEs) play a pivotal the so-called Amrit Kaal – the
role in the Indian wind 25-year period between the 75th
Seizing supply chain manufacturing sector. Going and 100th anniversaries of India’s
opportunities forward, the government should independence, which was gained
Recent increases in commodity consider targeted production-linked in 1947 – India must leverage all
prices, coupled with the emerging incentives for companies currently channels, including Vision for
impacts of shrinking supply chains engaged in the onshore wind sector, 2047 and the Sovereign Green
in Europe, are pointing to a huge and for those wishing to get involved Bonds (SGrB) framework, to
opportunity for India in the global in offshore wind manufacturing. support its wind sector, thus
wind energy supply chain. achieving the government’s
In 2022, GWEC India convened a vision of green growth and a
4. https://gwec.net/members-area-market-intelligence/fowind/
5. https://www.fowpi.in/
supply chain stakeholder renewable energy-led future for
6. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/93574111 roundtable, which outlined the country.
88 GWEC.NET
Markets to watch: Egypt
e
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
worldwide.
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
Cumulative installations (2022-2030)
Key to unlocking this ambition is the
Egyptian government
announcement of the Green
Corridor Initiative, a separate Source: GWEC, 2023
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 89
Markets to watch: Egypt
90 GWEC.NET
MARKET STATUS
92 GWEC.NET
Market Status 2022
The status of onshore wind in 2022 New onshore wind power capacity in 2022 and
market share by country (%)
New grid-connected onshore wind installations in 2022. The 50.6 GW Despite finishing the year with a Top 5*
capacity in 2022 amounted to 68.8 of new onshore wind capacity strong final quarter, the US wind Other
GW, bringing cumulative global approved under the ‘grid parity’ industry commissioned only 8.6
onshore capacity to 842 GW, with scheme in 2021 shows that the GW of onshore wind capacity in 28%
YoY growth of 8.8%. country is on track to reach its 2022, the slowest year since 2018,
ambitious renewable energy according to American Clean
Thanks to record installations in targets included in the 14th Power (ACP). Due to supply chain
68.8 GW 72%
Sweden, Finland and Poland, and Five-Year Plan (2021-2025). The constraints and grid
recovering installations in Chinese Wind Energy Association interconnection issues, more than
Germany, Europe performed well (CWEA) reported that 44.7 GW of 10 GW of onshore wind capacity
in a volatile 2022, adding a record onshore wind capacity was has had delays, slowing the rate of
16.7 GW of onshore wind capacity. installed in 2022, but the latest installations. GWEC expects the US
statistics released by the National market to accelerate sharply now
Global additions in 2022 were 5% Energy Administration (NEA) show that the IRA is in place and is fully *China, US, Brazil, Sweden and Finland
lower than in the previous year. that only 32.6 GW of new onshore understood by investors.
The slowdown in LATAM, Africa & wind capacity was grid-connected
ME is partly responsible for the last year. In addition to China and the US, the New onshore wind power capacity in 2022 by
decline, but the primary reason is other onshore wind markets in the market support mechanism (%)
the slowdown of onshore In the US, our Q1 2022 Outlook top five in 2022 were Brazil (4.1
installations in the US. forecast relatively stable onshore GW), Sweden (2.4 GW) and
wind growth for 2022. The Internal Finland (2.4 GW). China (grid parity)
China’s onshore wind installations Revenue Service (IRS) in June 2021 2.5% Auction/tenders
3.2% US (PTC)
plunged in 2021 when the world’s provided a further one-year ‘Grid parity’, auction/tenders and FiT
largest onshore wind market extension for projects that started the PTC remained the top three 0.6% Green certificate
entered the era of ‘grid parity’, construction in 2016 or 2017, market support mechanisms Other
meaning that electricity generated allowing project developers to behind onshore wind capacity 8.6
by onshore wind would be qualify for the full Production Tax added in 2022. Collectively, they
remunerated with the same Credit (PTC) rate if their projects account for a combined 91% 68.8 GW
32.6%
regulated price as coal power in can meet a commercial operation market share, the same as the 21.3%
every province. GWEC Market date (COD) of end-2022. However, previous year.
Intelligence forecast, in its Q1 2022 many projects were delayed by
Outlook, that Chinese onshore developers as they awaited full Excluding China, 13.7 GW of
installations would bounce back, clarity on the rules of the Inflation onshore wind capacity was
reaching 46 GW of new Reduction Act (IRA). awarded worldwide last year
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 93
Market Status 2022
94 GWEC.NET
Market Status 2022
8.8 GW of new offshore wind was Europe more than three l I taly also commissioned its first
fed into the grid last year, bringing decades to achieve. commercial offshore wind
total global offshore wind capacity project last year. The 30 MW
to 64.3 GW by the end of 2022. l With 2.5 GW offshore wind Beleolico offshore wind farm, 21,106
The new additions are 58% lower capacity across six countries which features 10 MySE3.0-135
than the bumper year of 2021 but connected to the grid in 2022, wind turbines from Mingyang, CAGR +19.2% 2,317
still make 2022 the second highest Europe accounted for the not only represents the first
year in offshore wind history. majority of the remaining new installation of Chinese wind 1,001
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 95
Market Status 2022
96 GWEC.NET
Market Status 2022
New installations decline in all regions, The annual wind market (onshore
and offshore combined) declined
in all regions except Europe in
except Europe 2022, with a YoY fall of 17.1%.
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 97
Market Status 2022
00
46 79
COD by end of 2022. Although only 4.1 GW of onshore wind had been commissioned by the third quarter of 2022, a big
,0
,5
32
installation push was still expected for Q4 2022. ACP statistics show that Q4 was the strongest quarter of the year, but due to
supply chain constraints and grid interconnections, quarterly installations were still down 35% compared with 2021.
India onshore
India commissioned 1.58 GW of wind power in the first three quarters of 2022, continuing the trend of recovering installation
rates. However, total additions in 2022 were still lower than our Q3 2022 projection, which is primarily driven by the
cancellation of projects rendered unviable by high inflation and delays on account of grid unavailability and timeline
extensions in their Scheduled Commissioning Date (SCD).
Germany onshore
To reduce reliance on fossil fuels imported from Russia, Germany’s new federal government increased its 2030 renewables
target while introducing a new ‘Onshore Wind Law’ (WindLandG) in July 2022 to accelerate installations as part of its ‘Easter
Package’. Actual onshore wind installations in 2022 were slightly lower than expected, but still made Germany Europe’s
largest wind market for additions in 2022.
Brazil onshore
Wind power development in Brazil has demonstrated the industry’s resilience over the past three years, especially during the
COVID-19 pandemic and the country’s political turbulence. 2022 was a record year, with more than 4 GW of onshore wind
installations. The strong growth is linked to projects being developed through both the regulated scheme of public auctions
and the free market of private PPAs.
Vietnam onshore
Since more than 1 GW of registered onshore wind projects missed their COD deadline in 2021, we expected some of them to
start commercial operation in 2022, provided offtake agreements could be made. However, no onshore wind projects
achieved commercial operation last year due to the ceiling price used by EVN as the cap to negotiate PPAs with investors for
renewable projects not being in place until January 2023.
UK offshore
0
In 2022, GWEC Market Intelligence expected the remaining offshore turbines (totalling 924 MW) at the 1.4 GW Hornsea
61
50
8,
9,
Project 2 to reach commercial operation, and half of the turbines at the 1,075 MW Seagreen Project (114 wind turbines) in
Scotland to come into operation. Although all the turbines were fully commissioned at the Hornsea Project 2, only 27 wind
turbines (255 MW) were grid-connected at the Scottish project.
0
00
2
5
05
06
6,
Germany offshore
90
5,
4,
3
3,
0
40
The 342 MW Kaskasi offshore wind farm reached commercial operation in the German North Sea in 2022, in line with our
70
7
40
2,
2
84
1, 9
2,
projection. New offshore wind installations have been low since 2020, primarily due to unfavourable offshore wind policies
46
17
2,
1,
1,
and a small short-term offshore wind project pipeline.
2
2
0
34
34
0
30
China offshore
After a record year in 2021, with nearly 17 GW of offshore wind grid-connected, new installations were predicted to drop China US India Germany Brazil Vietnam UK Germany China
dramatically following the introduction of ‘grid parity’ in the Chinese offshore wind market from 2022. GWEC Market offshore offshore offshore offshore
Intelligence predicted 6 GW of offshore wind to be commissioned in 2022, which was primarily based on the fact that more
than 7 GW of offshore wind projects had started construction by Q1 2022.
98 GWEC.NET
Market Status 2022
Sweden 4%
UK 13%
Brazil 6%
US 13%
India 5%
Germany 7% UK 22%
US 17%
Detailed data sheet available in GWEC’s member-only area. For definition of region see Appendix - Methodology and Terminology
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 99
Market Status 2022
CAGR 95.3
+3% 93.6
6.9
21.1
Onshore
Offshore CAGR
+10% 77.6
8.8
63.8
CAGR 3.4 60.8
+22% 6.2
54.9
2.2
53.5
51.7 4.5 50.7
1.5 4.4
45.0
1.2
38.5 39.1 40.6
0.9 0.9 36.0
0.6
1.6
26.9
0.4
20.3
0.3
14.7
11.5 0.1
8.1 8.2 0.1
6.5 7.3 0.1
0.2 0.3
0.1
6.4 7.1 7.9 8.1 11.4 14.6 20.0 26.5 37.9 38.2 39.8 43.9 34.5 50.2 60.4 52.7 49.0 46.3 54.6 88.4 72.5 68.8
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022
Share of offshore ~1% ~3% 5-23% 11%
100 GWEC.NET
Market Status 2022
906
64
830
56
CAGR
+11% 745
36
650
29
591
Onshore 23
Offshore 540
19
CAGR 488
+17% 14
433
12
CAGR
370
+26% 8
319
7
283
238 5
198 4
3
159
94 121 2
1
74 1
48 59
24 31 39 -1
-1 -1
0 -1
0
31 39 47 58 73 93 119 157 195 234 278 312 362 421 473 522 568 621 709 774 842
24
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022
GWEC adjusted 2021 total installations compared with the Global Wind Report 2022 based on the latest available statistics. For details see Appendix – Methodology and Terminology
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 101
Market Status 2022
MW, offshore New installations 2021 Total installations 2021 New installations 2022 Total installations 2022
Total offshore 21106 55549 8771 64320
Americas 0 42 0 42
USA 0 42 0 42
Asia-Pacific 17788 27695 6311 34006
China 16900 26390 5052 31442
Japan 0 52 84 136
South Korea 0 142 0 142
Vietnam 779 874 0 874
Taiwan 109 237 1175 1412
Europe 3317 27812 2460 30272
United Kingdom 2317 12739 1179 13918
Germany 0 7713 342 8055
France 0 2 480 482
Netherlands 392 2460 369 2829
Denmark 605 2308 0 2308
Belgium 0 2262 0 2262
Other Europe 4 328 90 418
GWEC adjusted 2021 new and total installations compared with the Global Wind Report 2022 based on the latest available statistics.
102 GWEC.NET
MARKET OUTLOOK
are five pillars that will underpin wind can provide, making
this level of success in the next five offshore wind truly global and primarily on three market auctions (Europe, LATAM, Africa
years: increasing ambition in mature support mechanisms: & ME and South East Asia).
and developing markets.
l urope’s renewed urgency to
E l ‘Grid parity’ (China) In addition to addressing
replace fossil fuels with l trong growth in large emerging
S challenges such as permitting
renewables to achieve energy markets both onshore and l Tax credit (PTC, ITC and and market design, governments
security in the aftermath of the offshore from the middle of this technology-neutral tax credits will have to implement new policy
Russian invasion of Ukraine. decade. in the US) solutions to ensure that the global
supply chain can meet increasing
l strong uplift for renewable
A Global wind power growth in l Wind-specific, technology- demand from both established
energy in the US over the next 2023–2027 will continue to rely neutral, renewable and hybrid and emerging markets.
104 GWEC.NET
Market Outlook 2023–2027
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 105
Market Outlook 2023–2027
106 GWEC.NET
Market Outlook 2023–2027
be added to the grid in China in the Thailand and Sri Lanka) and Central
next five years. Asia (primarily Kazakhstan and
Uzbekistan) are likely to make up
Asia excl. China 22% and 12%, respectively, of the
Excluding China, India is the largest new capacity expected for this
wind market in Asia. We expect the region in 2023–2027.
country’s onshore wind market to
continue to recover, with new Pacific
additions peaking in 2025–2026 No projects were commissioned in
given the expiry of the 100% New Zealand in 2022, although two
interstate transmission charge waiver projects totalling 260 MW were
(ISTS) in June 2025. Towards 2030, under construction last year. With
annual growth has the potential to construction work ongoing at
reach 5-6 GW under the new another two projects expected to be
8 GW/year tender trajectory. online by December, 2023 will be a
However, the tapering down from record year for this market. However,
50% to zero of ISTS charge waive- growth in New Zealand is likely to
offs between 2026 and 2028 is likely stop if no project is added to the
to limit installations to 4.5–5.0 GW. In pipeline in the next two years. In
total, 21 GW of onshore wind Australia, the total capacity of
capacity is likely to be added in India shovel-ready onshore wind projects
in 2023–2027, accounting for half of at the start of 2023 was close to 4
the predicted additions for the GW. Although the installation rate in
region. No onshore wind projects 2023 is predicted to be the lowest
achieved commercial operation in since 2019 – based on announced
Vietnam last year, but we expect new project CODs – annual installations
capacity to be commissioned in will surge again from 2024 and more
2023 and 2024 now that a ceiling than 3 GW of onshore wind is
price used by EVN to negotiate PPAs expected to be connected before
with investors for their renewable 2026. Growth momentum is likely to
projects has been set by the Ministry continue beyond 2025 because:
of Industry and Trade. Elsewhere in
the region, growth is expected to l ore states have rolled out
M
come from Japan, Pakistan and renewable tenders and renewable
emerging markets of southeast Asia, energy zones as more renewables
as well as in Central Asia. Southeast and storage are urgently needed
Asia (mainly the Philippines, Laos, to replace coal plants due to retire.
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 107
Market Outlook 2023–2027
across the country. In total, 60 GW of region in the next five years with
onshore wind capacity is expected Brazil, Chile and Colombia
to be added in the next five years in contributing 78% of the additions.
North America, of which 92% will be
built in the US and the rest in Africa/Middle East
Canada. Growth momentum is After a record year in new
unlikely to stop in this region beyond installations in 2021, Africa & ME
2027, as more capacity is predicted connected 453 MW of wind power
to be added in the US in 2028–2032, last year, the lowest since 2013.
primarily driven by technology- Compared with GWEC Market
neutral tax credits. Intelligence’s Q3 2022 Outlook, new
onshore wind additions for this
Latin America region in the next five years have
Growth in LATAM remained stable been downgraded by 16% (2.6
in 2022 with new installations GW). This is the result of most of the
reaching 5.2 GW, the second highest awarded onshore wind projects
in history. The growth was primarily from the REIPPP Bid Window 5
driven by Brazil, which had a record auction being delayed in South
year and made up nearly 80% of the Africa and no wind capacity being
region’s additional capacity. Brazil awarded from the REIPPP Bid
performed well in the past two years: Window 6 auction, launched in
its strong growth was linked to 2022, due to the unavailability of
projects being developed through grid capacity in the provinces of
both the regulated scheme of public Eastern Cape and Western Cape.
auctions and the free market of With GW-level projects expected to
private PPAs. Despite pipeline be built in North Africa and Saudi
growth having been interrupted by Arabia – and projects from the
an unhelpful policy environment in REIPPP Bid Window 5 auction
Mexico and economic instability in coming online – annual growth is
Argentina, new LATAM installations likely to bounce back in this region
of 5 GW are likely in 2023–2027, reaching 5 GW in 2026–2027. In
primarily driven by ongoing growth total, 17 GW of new capacity is
in Brazil and Chile, as well as the expected to be added in the next
completion of long-awaited projects five years (2023–2027), of which 5.3
in Colombia. GWEC Market GW will come from South Africa, 3.6
Intelligence expects 26.5 GW of GW from Egypt, 2.4 GW from Saudi
onshore wind to be added in this Arabia and 2.2 GW from Morocco.
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 109
Market Outlook 2023–2027
Regional onshore and offshore wind outlook for new installations (GW)
4.9
23.3 4.7
21.0 21
0.9 1
19.1 18.9
5 17.8 3.4
16.2 16.7
14.8 14.9 15.4 5.1 14.5 3.1
0.9
5.2 0.8
5.9 5.4
5.2
3.9
3.8
0.5 1.2 2.5
9.6 9 10 11 14 16
0.3 2.3
0.3
0.9
0.3
2022 2023e 2024e 2025e 2026e 2027e 2022 2023e 2024e 2025e 2026e 2027e 2022 2023e 2024e 2025e 2026e 2027e
North America onshore Latin America onshore Europe onshore Africa onshore Middle East onshore
2022 2023e 2024e 2025e 2026e 2027e 2022 2023e 2024e 2025e 2026e 2027e
China onshore India onshore Other Asia-Pacific onshore Asia-Pacific offshore Europe offshore North America offshore
110 GWEC.NET
APPENDIX
Appendix
112 GWEC.NET
Appendix
Market Intelligence
GWEC Market Intelligence provides a Market Insights
Policy and Regulations Asset Owners
series of insights and data-based analysis Market statistics,
Country profiles, policy Database of asset owners
on the development of the global wind market outlook,
industry. This includes a market outlook,
updates, offshore updates in key markets
auction/tender updates
country profiles, policy updates, deep-
dives on the offshore market among many
other exclusive insights.
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 113
Appendix
3. Market Outlook
Global Wind Market Outlook 2023-2027 (Q1 and Q3) Database + Report Semi-Annual
India Market Outlook Report 2023-2027 Annual
Global Wind Workforce Outlook 2023-2027 Annual
5. Auctions/Tenders
Global Wind Auction Database Annual/Auction Trends and Learnings Quarterly
7. Components Assessment
Blade (Q4 2023), Generator (Q4 2021), Gearbox (Q4 2022), followed by other components Special Report
9. O&M
O&M Service Provider Database (ISP - OEM - Self-perform) Annual
O&M Service Provider Status Report (including regional trends) Annual
114 GWEC.NET
Global Leaders
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 GWEC.NET 115
Global Leaders
116 GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 GWEC.NET
Appendix
Leading Sponsor
Supporting Sponsor
Associate Sponsors
4/02/11 15:40:22
Lincoln Electric Bryan O’Neil (Bryan_ONeil@lincolnelectric.com) Harting Electric Guanghai Jin (Guanghai.Jin@harting.com)
Hamburg Messe info@windenergyhamburg.com Techstorm Martijn van Breugel (martijn@techstorm.com)
(WindEnergy Hamburg) Bureau Veritas Paul Trevillyan (paul.trevillyan@bureauveritas.com)
GWEC | GLOBAL WIND REPORT 2023 117
Global Wind Energy Council
Rue de Commerce 31
1000 Brussels, Belgium
T. +32 490 56 81 39
info@gwec.net
@GWECGlobalWind
@Global Wind Energy Council (GWEC)
@Global Wind Energy Council