Newtons Laws
Newtons Laws
1.
between them is F. When the gravitational force between them is F/4, the distance between the
surfaces of the spheres is
A R
B 2R
C 4R
D 6R
(Total 1 mark)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(3)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(1)
g = 9.8 N kg–1
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(b) The figure below shows a satellite in a geostationary orbit around the Earth.
______________________________________________________________
(1)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
radius ______________________ m
(1)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(1)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(1)
(Total 14 marks)
___________________________________________________________________
(1)
Configuration A
Configuration B
Figure 1
Consider a 1 kg mass of sea water at position P. This mass experiences forces FE, FM and
FS due to its position in the gravitational fields of the Earth, the Moon and the Sun
respectively.
(i) Draw labelled arrows on both diagrams in Figure 1 to indicate the three forces
experienced by the mass of sea water at P.
(3)
(ii) State and explain which configuration, A or B, of the Sun, the Moon and the Earth will
produce the higher tide at position P.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
Haberdashers Monmouth School For Girls Page 4 of 68
(c) Calculate the magnitude of the gravitational force experienced by 1 kg of sea water on the
Earth’s surface at P, due to the Sun’s gravitational field.
(3)
(Total 9 marks)
(a) State the law that governs the magnitude of the force between two point masses.
4.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
16 –8.3
35 –3.8
(i) Show that the data suggest that the potential is inversely proportional to the distance
from the centre of the Sun.
(2)
(ii) Use the data to determine the gravitational field strength near the surface of the Sun.
(3)
(3)
(iv) Calculate the kinetic energy of the Earth due to its orbital speed around the Sun and
hence find the minimum energy that would be needed for the Earth to escape from its
orbit. Assume that the Earth moves in a circular orbit.
(3)
(Total 13 marks)
D
(Total 1 mark)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(b) Some of the earliest attempts to determine the gravitational constant, G, were regarded as
experiments to “weigh” the Earth. By considering the gravitational force acting on a mass at
the surface of the Earth, regarded as a sphere of radius R, show that the mass of the Earth
is given by
where g is the value of the gravitational field strength at the Earth’s surface.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
Calculate the mass of the Moon and express its mass as a percentage of the mass of the
Earth.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
(Total 7 marks)
Which one of the following graphs correctly shows the relationship between the gravitational
7.
force, F, between two masses and the distance, r, between them?
A B
C D
(Total 1 mark)
(Total 1 mark)
The Global Positioning System (GPS) is a system of satellites that transmit radio signals which
9. can be used to locate the position of a receiver anywhere on Earth.
(a) A receiver at sea level detects a signal from a satellite in a circular orbit when it is passing
directly overhead as shown in the diagram above.
(i) The microwave signal is received 68 ms after it was transmitted from the satellite.
Calculate the height of the satellite.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(4)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(5)
(Total 9 marks)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
(b) By considering the centripetal force which acts on a planet in a circular orbit,
show that T2 3
R , where T is the time taken for one orbit around the Sun and R is the
radius of the orbit.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
(c) The Earth’s orbit is of mean radius 1.50 × 10 11 m and the Earth’s year is 365 days long.
(i) The mean radius of the orbit of Mercury is 5.79 × 1010 m. Calculate the length of
Mercury’s year.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(4)
(Total 10 marks)
A projectile moves in a gravitational field. Which one of the following is a correct statement for
11. the gravitational force acting on the projectile?
(Total 1 mark)
(a) Give two examples of the techniques used by geologists to obtain values of the strength of
13. the local gravitational field of the Earth.
In each of your quoted examples, describe the information that the geologists can derive
from their measurements.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(4)
Figure 1 shows two positions of a pendulum hung near to, but on opposite sides of, the
mountain. The centre of mass of the mountain is at the same height as the pendulum.
Figure 1
(b) (i) Explain why the pendulums do not point towards the centre of the Earth.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
(ii) Suggest why Maskelyne carried out the experiment on both sides of the mountain.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(1)
(c) Figure 2 shows measurements made with the left-hand pendulum in Figure 1.
Figure 2
(3)
(ii) Figure 2 shows the left-hand pendulum bob lying on a horizontal line that also
passes through the centre of mass of the mountain. The bob is 1.4 km from the
centre of the mountain and it hangs at an angle of 0.0011° to the vertical.
(3)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(1)
(Total 14 marks)
Two identical spheres exert a gravitational force F on each other. What is the gravitational force
14. between two spheres, each twice the mass of one of the original spheres, when the separation of
their centres is twice the original separation?
A F
B 2F
C 4F
D 8F
(Total 1 mark)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(b) In 1798 Cavendish investigated Newton’s law by measuring the gravitational force between
two unequal uniform lead spheres. The radius of the larger sphere was 100 mm and that
of the smaller sphere was 25 mm.
(i) The mass of the smaller sphere was 0.74 kg. Show that the mass of the larger sphere
was about 47 kg.
(2)
answer = ______________________ N
(2)
(c) Modifications, such as increasing the size of each sphere to produce a greater force
between them, were considered in order to improve the accuracy of Cavendish’s
experiment. Describe and explain the effect on the calculations in part (b) of doubling the
radius of both spheres.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(4)
(Total 10 marks)
C W
D 2W
(Total 1 mark)
A 1023
B 1030
C 1036
D 1042
(Total 1 mark)
A projectile moves in a gravitational field. Which one of the following is a correct statement about
18. the gravitational force acting on the projectile?
The gravitational force between two uniform spheres is 3.1 × 10–9 N when the distance between
19.
their centres is 150 mm. If the mass of one sphere is 2.5 kg, what is the mass of the other?
A 0.043 kg
B 0.42 kg
C 2.8 kg
D 4.1 kg
(Total 1 mark)
Masses of M and 2M exert a gravitational force F on each other when the distance between their
20. centres is r. What is the gravitational force between masses of 2M and 4M when the distance
between their centres is 4r?
A 0.25 F
B 0.50 F
C 0.75 F
D 1.00 F
(Total 1 mark)
gravitational
weight
potential
(Total 1 mark)
If an electron and proton are separated by a distance of 5 × 10–11 m, what is the approximate
22.
gravitational force of attraction between them?
A 2 × 10–57 N
B 3 × 10–47 N
C 4 × 10–47 N
D 5 × 10–37 N
(Total 1 mark)
Which one of the following statements about Newton’s law of gravitation is correct?
23.
Newton’s law of gravitation explains
D how various factors affect the gravitational force between two particles.
(Total 1 mark)
___________________________________________________________________
2 _________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
The figure below shows how the gravitational force acting on the space probe varies with height
above the Earth’s surface.
(b) State the physical significance of the shaded area in the figure above.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(1)
= ____________________
(2)
(d) Explain why gS is more important than gE in predicting the motion of the space probe as it
escapes from the Solar System.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(1)
(e) The space probe eventually reaches a point where the gravitational influence of the Solar
System is negligible.
The probe is unpowered as it approaches an isolated interstellar body X.
The gravitational field of X changes the kinetic energy of the space probe.
The table below shows the distance of the space probe from the centre of mass of X and
the speed for two positions A and B of the space probe.
A 6.0 1.1
B 0.17 1.3
mass of X = ____________________ kg
(4)
(Total 10 marks)
25.
Which one of the following gives a correct unit for ?
A N m−2
B N kg−1
C Nm
D N
(Total 1 mark)
Figure 1 Figure 2
(a) (i) Use Newton’s gravitational law to calculate the gravitational force exerted by the Earth
on a student.
force ____________________ N
(3)
(3)
(ii) Calculate the magnitude of the centripetal force required so that student B moves
with the Earth at the rotational speed of 460 m s–1.
(iii) Show, on Figure 1, an arrow showing the direction of the centripetal force acting on
student C.
(1)
(c) Student B stands on a bathroom scale calibrated to measure weight in newton (N). If the
Earth were not rotating, the weight recorded would be equal to the force calculated in part
(a)(i).
State and explain how the rotation of the Earth affects the reading on the bathroom scale
for student B.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
(Total 14 marks)
A FE > FS > FM
B FS > FE > FM
C FE > FM > FS
D FM > FE > FS
(Total 1 mark)
(a) (i) Define gravitational field strength and state whether it is a scalar or vector quantity.
28.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
(ii) A mass m is at a height h above the surface of a planet of mass M and radius R.
The gravitational field strength at height h is g. By considering the gravitational force
acting on mass m, derive an equation from Newton’s law of gravitation to express g
in terms of M, R, h and the gravitational constant G.
(2)
(b) (i) A satellite of mass 2520 kg is at a height of 1.39 × 107 m above the surface of the
Earth. Calculate the gravitational force of the Earth attracting the satellite.
Give your answer to an appropriate number of significant figures.
(5)
(c) State and explain one possible use for the satellite travelling in the orbit in part (ii).
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(Total 14 marks)
The Rosetta space mission placed a robotic probe on Comet 67P in 2014.
29.
(a) The total mass of the Rosetta spacecraft was 3050 kg. This included the robotic probe of
mass 108 kg and 1720 kg of propellant. The propellant was used for changing velocity
while travelling in deep space where the gravitational field strength is negligible.
Calculate the change in gravitational potential energy of the Rosetta spacecraft from launch
until it was in deep space.
Give your answer to an appropriate number of significant figures.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
Calculate the deceleration of the Rosetta spacecraft produced by the four thrusters when
its mass was 1400 kg.
(d) Calculate the maximum change in speed that could be produced using the 1720 kg of
propellants.
Assume that the speed of the exhaust gases produced by the propellant was 1200 m s–1
(i) Calculate the gravitational force acting on the robotic probe when at a distance of 2.0
km from the centre of mass of the comet.
(ii) Calculate the escape velocity for an object 2.0 km from the centre of mass of the
comet.
(iii) A scientist suggests using a drill to make a vertical hole in a rock on the surface of
the comet. The anchoring would be removed from the robotic probe before the drill
was used. The drill would exert a force of 25 N for 4.8 s.
Explain, with the aid of a calculation, whether this process would cause the robotic
probe to escape from the comet.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(3)
(Total 20 marks)
D
(Total 1 mark)
When comparing the electrostatic force acting on a pair of charged particles to the gravitational
force between them, the product ε0G can appear in the calculation.
A C2 kg–2
B C2 m–2
C F kg2 N–1 m–2
D it has no unit
(Total 1 mark)
The gravitational force between X and Y is F when angle SXY is 90°, as shown in the diagram.
What is the gravitational force between X and Y when they are nearest to each other?
A 2F
B 3F
C 4F
D 5F
(Total 1 mark)
(Total 1 mark)
The distance between the centre of Pluto and the centre of Charon is d.
X is the point at which the resultant gravitational field due to Pluto and Charon is zero.
(Total 1 mark)
The distance between the centres of the Earth and the Moon is 3.8 × 108 m. The mass of the
35.
Earth is 6.0 × 1024 kg and the mass of the Moon is 7.4 × 1022 kg.
At what distance from the centre of the Earth would the spacecraft experience no resultant force
due to the Earth and the Moon?
A 3.8 × 107 m
B 4.8 × 107 m
C 3.4 × 108 m
D 3.8 × 108 m
(Total 1 mark)
A 3.5 × 1022 N
B 1.7 × 1026 N
C 5.3 × 1033 N
D 8.9 × 1050 N
(Total 1 mark)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(b) Figure 1 shows a point charge of +46 μC placed 120 mm from a point charge Q.
Figure 1
Q = ____________________ C
(3)
(c) Explain, without calculation, whether net work must be done in moving a proton from infinity
to position P in Figure 1.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
Figure 2
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(Total 9 marks)
Each sphere is charged by connecting it briefly to the positive terminal of a high-voltage supply,
the other terminal of which is at 0 V.
After this has been done the charge on each sphere is 52 nC.
potential = ____________________ V
(3)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(d) Show that the magnitude of the electrostatic force on each sphere is about 4 × 10–3 N.
(3)
(e) A student measures the angle θ when the apparatus in the diagram above is at equilibrium.
The student records θ as 7°.
Discuss whether this measurement is consistent with the other data in this investigation.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(Total 14 marks)
A 1018
B 1028
C 1036
D 1045
(Total 1 mark)
A1
A1
3
B1
1
B1
C1
A1
3
B1
1
B1
1
C1
C1
3.08 (cao)
A1
3
B1
1
B1
1
[14]
3.
(a) force acting per unit mass or g = F / m or g = with terms defined
(1)
(ii) sun and moon pulling in same direction / resultant of FM and FS is greatest /
clear response including summation of FM and FS
M1
configuration A
A1
(2)
correct substitution
C1
B1
2
C1
A1
2
B1
B1
B1
3
C1
C1
A1
3
or KE=
B1
B1
B1
3
[13]
C
5.
[1]
(a) attractive force between two particles (or point masses) (1)
6. proportional to product of masses and inversely proportional to
square of separation [or distance] (1)
2
(c) (1)
(= 0.0123) ∴ 1.23%
3
[7]
D
7.
[1]
D
8.
[1]
[or v2 = = (1)
v= (1)
(i) (1)
(ii) (1)
4
[10]
A
11.
[1]
D
12.
[1]
or mean density of the Earth is higher than that of the mountain (1)
7
[14]
A
14.
[1]
Haberdashers Monmouth School For Girls Page 45 of 68
(a) force of attraction between two point masses (or particles) (1)
15.
proportional to product of masses (1)
[alternatively
(b) (i) mass of larger sphere ML (= πr3ρ) = π × (0.100)3 × 11.3 × 103 (1)
[alternatively
(c) for the spheres, mass µ volume (or µ r3, or M = πr3ρ) (1)
mass of either sphere would be 8 × greater (378 kg, 5.91 kg) (1)
B
16.
[1]
C
17.
[1]
B
19.
[1]
A
20.
[1]
A
21.
[1]
C
22.
[1]
D
23.
[1]
the (minimum) energy needed/work done to launch the space probe to a height
of 8 × 106 m
OR
the change in GPE of the probe when moved from Earth’s surface to a height of
8 × 106 m ✔
1
✔1 g S =
✔1 ALTERNATIVE
The Universal gravitational equation for both bodies may be used:
(d) The force from Earth because of its smaller mass, is less than the force from
the Sun at a similar distance.
OR
The total work done in moving a long way from the Sun is much greater than that in moving
a long way from the Earth because mE ≪ mS .
Condone reference to “edge of Solar System” as “a similar
distance”.
1
OR m × 2.40 × 105 J
✔2 ∆E p =
OR
Loss and gain may be replaced with change or Δ’s for this mark.
✔3 and
A
25.
[1]
M1
-missing m in substitution
491 (490)N
A1
-substutution with incorrect powers of 10
Condone 492 N,
B1
allow W, mg (not gravity); R
allow if slightly out of line / two vectors
shown at feet
B1
condone if colinear but not shown acting on body
In relation to surface W ≤ R (by eye) to allow for weight vector
starting in middle of the body
Must be colinear unless two arrows shown in which case R vectors
½ W vector(by eye)
B1
Max 2 if not easy to follow
B1
463 m s−1
B1
Must be 3sf or more
C1
Allow 1 for use of F = mrω2 with ω= 460
A1
B1
C1
A1
B1
or R = mg – mv2/r
[14]
A
27.
[1]
(b) (i) ✓
[or F = gives v2 ✓
[or T2 = ✓
= ✓
= = 7.97 (hours) ✓
Allow ECF from wrong F value in (i) but mark to max 4 (because
final answer won’t agree with value to be shown).
First 3 marks are for determining time period (or frequency). Last 2
marks are for relating this to the number of transits.
Determination of f = 3.46 × 10–5 (s–1) is equivalent to finding T by
any of the methods.
5
1.9 × 1011(J)
2 sf
condone errors in powers of 10 and incorrect mass for payload
Allow if some sensible working
4
0.0198 N
Allow incorrect powers of 10 and mass
3
(ii) Use of v =
Correct substitution v =
0.86 (m s-1)
Recognisable mass – condone incorrect power of 10
3
Clear conclusion
C
30.
[1]
A
31.
[1]
B
32.
[1]
D
33.
[1]
C
34.
[1]
35. C
[1]
A
36.
[1]
(a) (The electric field strength at a point) is the force per unit charge ✔
37.
On a (small) positive charge (at that point) ✔
(only given if an attempt is made at the first mark)
An equation is not sufficient unless the symbols are defined. Unit
charge can be replaced by coulomb.
(Reference to a point is not needed as it is in the question but a
reference to moving between points or other points can cancel a
mark.)
If “mass” appears in the answer, it must be a synonym for “object”.
2
=) 1.4 × 108.
3
(c) Work must be done on the positive proton because P is at a positive potential
OR
Work must be done (on the positive proton) due to the repulsive forces / because like
charges repel OWTTE ✔
(d) (As the ball falls) it experiences both vertical and horizontal forces/accelerations ✔
OR
In this 2nd mark a wrong answer will gain zero marks even if accompanied by a correct
answer
‘Horizontal’ needs to be accompanied by some implication that it is
away from the wall. This may be by some reference to repulsion
from the wall.
Moves diagonally can imply straight.
“Moving away and downwards” does not imply straight.
Do not credit “horizontal straight line” or “vertical straight line.”
‘Gravity ‘ on its own is not a force whereas weight is.
2
[9]
✔2
(e) (As each sphere is in equilibrium then tan θ = a mark is given for a
reference and substitution into this equation in any configuration. The second mark is
for an evaluation that is said to be consistent. Use of 4 × 10–3 N given in part (d)
gains full credit.)
or
or
Alternatively
T= = 0.032 ✔1Alt
Alternative
(find the ratio between the forces)
✔1b
OR
C
39.
1036
[1]
Few candidates did not equate the two equations in part (a) (ii), cancel m and rearrange into the
form shown.
The vast majority of candidate performed the calculation in part (a) (iii) correctly, but a significant
number quoted the final answer to either one or three significant figures (instead of the correct
two). A small minority of candidates forgot to square the radius of the Earth.
In part (b) (i), most candidates recognised that the period would be 24 hours.
Difficulty was had by some candidates in part (b) (ii) who struggled to add the quantities written in
different forms.
Part (b) (iii) was done well either by candidates dividing the circumference of the obit by the
period in seconds or else using the mass of the Earth calculated in part (a) (iii).
Most candidates gave an appropriate use for geostationary satellites in part (b) (iv), however
GPS and ‘mobile phones’ were not accepted.
In part (b) (v) few candidates were able to discuss the avoidance of dishes tracking by having
geostationary satellites.
(a) Most candidates managed to give an acceptable definition of gravitational field strength.
3. Those who did not usually failed because they omitted to mention unit mass or because
they confused field strength with potential or potential energy.
(b) (i) This part was also well done. Some candidates gave confused labelling, showed their
forces in the wrong direction, or omitted to show the forces on both of the diagrams.
(ii) Explanations were often not clear: some candidates created a difficulty by referring to
the resultant force when they probably were thinking of the resultant force of only FM
and FS. A few candidates sought to give explanations relating to the distances
between the Earth and the Sun or Moon, highlighting the need to advise candidates
not to rely on judgements of distance from diagrams which are not to scale.
(c) This calculation was done well by most of the candidates. A few tried to use an equation for
potential rather than force and some made processing errors, often forgetting to square the
orbital radius even though they had shown it as being squared in their equation.
(a) This was done well by the majority of candidates. A common error was to state that the
4. force is inversely proportional to the square of the radius.
(b) (i) Most candidates knew a method of showing the inverse proportionality. However,
many used only two of the sets of data or provided only a series of numbers without
any explanation of what they were doing or providing any conclusion. In the worst
cases, answers were set out poorly and any reasoning was hard to follow.
(iii) There were relatively few correct answers to this part. Many candidates could not
identify an appropriate equation to use or did not realise that they had the value for
GM from earlier parts. Some determined the energy needed for the Earth to move
from the surface of the Sun to the position of the Earth’s orbit. Those who recalled G,
having no value for the mass of the Sun, determined the energy required for the
Earth to escape from the Earth.
(iv) Most were able to gain some credit for this part, gaining marks for calculating the
speed of the Earth in its orbit and/or for use of the KE formula. Many either ignored
the last part or added the KE in orbit to their answer to part (iii).
Missing from most attempted statements in part (a) were the expected references to point
6. masses and to an attractive force. Many candidates simply tried to put the well-known formula
into words, whilst others referred to the sum of the masses rather than the product of them.
Answers to part (c) were frequently completely successful, making an interesting contrast with
the earlier parts of this question. The main problems here were omission of kg after the mass of
the moon, significant figure penalties, and arithmetical slips – typically forgetting to square the
denominator.
This question raised similar demands to the previous question, in that they required more than
8. one concept to be combined to give an algebraic result. In this question, electrostatic and
gravitational forces had to be considered together. The facility was 64%, and this question was
the best discriminator in the test. Over one-fifth of the responses were for distractor A, which has
(4π ) in the numerator instead of the denominator of the required expression.
Most candidates scored the mark in part (a) (i) and went to use their answer correctly in part (ii).
9. A small number of candidates however, failed to add the height calculated in part (i) to the Earth’s
radius or added the radius in km to the height in m. They were usually able to gain some credit
for knowing the correct equation to use.
In part (b) (i), many candidates gave a clear and correct expression, using either the expressions
for centripetal acceleration or the speed in terms of the mass of the Earth. Weaker candidates
confused the symbols for speed and gravitational potential on the data sheet and attempted to
calculate the speed using the expression for gravitational potential. Most candidates who
completed part (i) went on to complete part (ii) successfully, although some lost the final mark as
a result of giving the answer to too many significant figures. Some candidates in part (ii)
successfully related the time period to the radius of orbit and thus gained full credit. A small
minority of candidates gained no credit as a result of misreading part (b), attempting to provide
answers based on a time period of 24 hours.
Both halves of part (c) followed directly from the T2 R3 result in part (b), and the candidates
who realised this usually made excellent progress. Unfortunately, a large proportion tried to go
back to first principles and tied themselves in knots with the algebra and/or arithmetic, often
getting nowhere. Confusion over which unit of time to employ in the different parts caused much
difficulty, especially for candidates who had calculated a constant of proportionality in part (i).
Some very elegant solutions to part (ii) were seen, where the result emerged swiftly from
(165)2/3. The most absurd efforts came from candidates who made the implicit assumption that
the Earth, Mercury and Neptune all travel at the same speed in their orbits, leading to wrong
answers of 141 days and 165 respectively.
The direction of forces in gravitational, electric and magnetic fields continues to be an area of
11. misunderstanding, as illustrated by the responses in this question, which had a facility of 55%.
Despite the fact that this question was about gravitational fields, just over a quarter of the
candidates selected distractor C, where the force is supposed to be at right angles to the field.
This confusion with a magnetic field is no more understandable than that of the 11% who chose
distractor B, where the force would be in the opposite direction to the field. Perhaps this latter
group were thinking of electrons in an electric field. Such incorrect responses suggest that
candidates were not always reading the questions with sufficient care.
This question was a graphical test of inverse proportionality, as represented by the universal law
12. of gravitation. The facility of the question was 65%, but one quarter of the candidates were
tempted into choosing distractor C.
This question was about gravitational forces. Application of the inverse square law was
14. completed successfully by 70% of the candidates in the former question.
Many correct statements of Newton’s law of gravitation were seen in part (a). Some candidates
15.
referred to just one aspect of the law ( M1M2, or 1/r2, not both together) and only received
one mark. A reference to point masses – which helps when explaining the meaning of r – was not
common. In fact a clear understanding of the meaning of r was expected in satisfactory answers.
The common inadequate responses, when neither was more fully explained, were ‘radius’ and
‘distance’ Candidates who tried to rely simply on quoting F = GM1M2/r2 were awarded a mark
only when the terms in the equation were correctly identified; a further mark was available to
them if they gave a clear definition of r or referred to the nature of the force as attractive.
Part (b) (i) could be approached using either ‘mass = volume × density’ or ‘mass r3’. The first
method was far more common, and most answers were satisfactory. On this paper, this was the
first example of a question requiring candidates to ‘show that…’ Convincing answers to this type
of question should include the fullest possible working, in which the final answer is quoted to one
more significant figure than the value given in the question. Here, for example, a value of 47.3 kg
was convincing. Part (b) (ii) also proved to be very rewarding for most candidates.
Common errors here were failing to square the denominator, or to assume that surfaces in
contact meant that r = 0 (whilst still arriving at a finite numerical answer!).
This question which had a facility of 70%, was an algebraic test of the relationship between the
16. weight of an object at the surface of a planet and the mass and radius of that planet. This
question discriminated well and had no particularly strong distractor.
Another reused question combined Coulomb’s law with Newton’s law of gravitation and needed
17. candidates to take data from the Data and Formulae Booklet. The incorrect responses were
distributed fairly evenly across the three remaining distractors.
The candidates in 2010 found this question to be slightly easier than their predecessors, with the
18. facility advancing from 55% to 59%. One in four candidates demonstrated their confusion with
magnetic fields by opting for distractor C, where the force was perpendicular to the field.
This question, involving a rearrangement of the force equation from Newton’s law, had a facility
19. of 77%.
This was a fairly demanding calculation on the inverse square law of gravitation, in which
20. candidates had to consider the effect of changing both the size of the attracting masses and their
separation. Just over half reached the correct conclusion. No doubt it was errors in rearranging
the arithmetic and/or algebra that caused 34% of candidates to opt for distractor B, where the
new force was double what it ought to be.
This question continued the theme of gravitation. At first sight, it should be easy. In fact it was the
21. most demanding question in the test, with a facility of only 33%. Marginally more candidates
chose the incorrect distractor D than the correct answer. This was a fairly simple test of inverse
square proportion for force and inverse proportion for potential. Candidates made matters difficult
by confusing the distance from an external point to the centre of the Earth with the distance to the
surface of the Earth.
Data for the gravitational constant and the masses of the electron and proton had to be extracted
22. from the Data Sheet (see Reference Material) for use in this question where the topic was the
gravitational force between two particles. Over four-fifths of the students succeeded with this.
This question involving statements about Newton’s law of gravitation, had a facility of 85%. When
23. pre-tested, this question had been found appreciably harder but was more discriminating than on
this occasion.
(a) Most of the answers seen lacked detail. For example, instead of referring to the inverse-
24. square relationship of gravitational field with distance, students often wrote that the field
strength decreases with distance. The “field lines spread out” was written instead of
referring to the centre of mass being the location at which field lines point or the directional
gravitational force acts. Finally, equipotential lines were described as being “curved” rather
than being concentric about the centre of mass.
(c) It was most common for students to determine gS and gE individually rather than going
straight to the ratio (as in the alternative on the mark scheme). The major problems for
most students were the choice of correct distances to substitute into their working
equations or failing to square the chosen distance in their calculations. Adding the Sun’s
radius to the distance or just using the Sun’s radius in the calculation of g S was a common
error.
(d) Most students did not produce an answer of the standard that is expected at A-level. Many
stated the Sun has a larger effect because its is “bigger” or “more massive” than the Earth.
They ignored the fact that distance has a bearing on the gravitational force on the probe.
Very few took the trouble to state anything about the probe–Earth distance and probe–Sun
distance being comparable.
(e) Most students simply looked for an equation that involved mass, speed and distance, then
simply ‘played’ with numbers. Inappropriate force and circular-motion equations were
commonly seen. The third marking point was also lost by many who missed any reference
to the changes in kinetic and potential energies. The most frequently gained mark was the
calculation of change in kinetic energy. However, there were many who failed to gain this
mark by using the square of the difference in speed in their calculation. The determination
of change in potential energy had a common error too; this was the substitution of the
difference in distance for separation into the potential-energy equation.
This question was on gravitational effects. Rearrangement of possible units to obtain the ratio of
25.
the quantities g2 / G was required; almost 70% of the candidates could do this correctly but 20%
chose distractor B (N kg-1 instead of N m-2).
(ii) Many attempts were unconvincing and frequently carelessly drawn. Weight and
reaction forces were often shown as not being collinear. Some showed a reaction
force at one of the feet but not the other. That the length of a vector should represent
magnitude was not realised by many candidates.
(b) (i) A good proportion of correct approaches were seen but many candidates seemed
unsure what equation to use so quoted some that were not relevant. Good structure
in a mathematical argument is an important skill in all problems but even more so in
‘show that’ type questions were marks are awarded for each step.
(ii) Again there was a good proportion of correct response. Some candidates used F =
mrω2; and 460 m s-1 for ω.
(iii) Misunderstanding about centripetal force was common here and there were relatively
few correct answers. The majority showed the force acting toward the centre of the
Earth. Whilst a component of this force provides the centripetal force, the direction of
the centripetal force is toward the centre of rotation which in the diagram is
perpendicular and toward the axis of rotation of the Earth.
(c) There were very good answers from candidates who understood that the scales read the
reaction force.There were many who knew the formula mg – R = mv2 / r but thought that
the scales would record mg and assumed R to remain constant so that the centripetal force
increased the scale reading.
In this question the candidates had to decide about the relative magnitudes of the forces from the
27. Earth, the Moon and the Sun acting on a spacecraft when close to the Earth. Values for the
relevant masses and distances were provided in case candidates needed to perform a
calculation, or to carry out a check on their intuition. Obviously the spacecraft would not be in
orbit around Earth if FE was smaller than either of the other two forces. Hence FE must be the
largest of the three forces. The relative sizes of FM and FS then comes down to the ratio M / R2,
because the local gravitational field strength caused by each of the masses is GM / R2. The
facility of the question was 56%. 29% of the candidates chose distractor C; they appreciated that
FE is largest but thought that FM would be greater than FS.
Part (b)(i) caused few problems and marks were generally high. Sometimes incorrect values had
been extracted from the data booklet for the mass and radius of the Earth. Three significant
figures were expected in the answer; therefore a minimum of three significant figures should also
have been used in the substitution and working. When h = 1.39 × 107 was used as the radius of
the orbit one mark was lost and the value of the force thus obtained was carried forward to make
most marks available in part (b)(ii). Part (b)(ii) offered a very wide range of approaches to enable
students to show that the satellite would make three transits of Earth in every 24 hours. Apart
from the three alternatives given in the mark scheme (all of which were frequently seen) a very
concise calculation showed that a satellite with an angular speed of 2.19 × 10−4 rad s−1 would
move through an angle of 18.9 rad in one day, equating to (18.9 / 2π =) 3.01 transits.
Use of polar orbiting satellites for monitoring the Earth (weather forecasting, spying, surveying,
etc.) were well known in part (c), although some students confused the application with an
equatorial geosynchronous satellite. Explanations of the application were often less satisfactory:
reference to the rotation of Earth beneath the orbit, allowing the whole surface to be scanned,
was the key here. The ability to provide regular updates of the information obtained was also an
acceptable explanation. Students who mentioned the use of the polar satellite for
communications gained the first mark but were usually unable to point out its limitations, caused
by intermittent contact.
(b) Many stated that the propellant/fuel was ejected through the nozzle. The statements about
the momentum of the exhaust gases were often confused. The most popular way of
deriving thrust was by attempting to use Newton’s 3 rd law but the statements were often
incomplete.
(d) Although some students attempted to use conservation of momentum, most realised that
the rocket equations was needed. There is the same confusion over the meaning of the
symbols vf and mf. Some used mf = 1720 kg instead of 1330 kg, and others, after correctly
calculating vf = 996 m s−1, went on to subtract this from the exhaust gas speed, thus
sacrificing a mark.
(e) (i) Most students chose the correct formula, but many forgot to square the radius, and
others chose the wrong mass. The original mass of the spacecraft (3050 kg) was the
most popular erroneous value, although even the mass of the Earth was seen
occasionally.
(ii) Nearly everyone started with the correct formula but two common errors ensued.
Some forgot to take the square root and others did not convert 2.0 km to meters. Also
some gave the answer to 1 sf (0.9 m s−1) thus losing a mark.
(iii) Those who calculated that the velocity change of the probe was 1.1 m s−1 followed
with the right conclusion. Some students used the wrong mass but could still gain the
third mark with a correct comparison.
Direct application of Newton’s law of gravitation easily gave the answer in this question, which
30. had a facility of 78%. A very small number of incorrect responses came from assuming that the
law gives F ∝ (1 / r) – represented by distractors A and D. Rather more (14%) chose distractor B;
these students probably added the two component forces acting on the spacecraft instead of
subtracting them.
This was an unusual question on combinations of electrical units. 54% of the responses were
31. correct, whilst 18% selected distractor C and 20% distractor D (no unit). The latter must have
been tempting because both ε0 and G are constants.
This question tested the gravitational inverse square law in the context of two planets orbiting a
32.
star. Application of Pythagoras’ theorem shows that (XY) 2 = 3R2. When the planets are closest,
their separation is reduced to R; thus the force increases from F to 3F. The facility of the question
was 58%, with one in five of the responses being for distractor C (4F).
81.4% correct
36.
(a) As was the case in 2017, many students had not learnt definitions thoroughly. So, the
37. actual unit of charge was absent from many scripts as was a reference to a positive
charge. Weaker students mixed the definition of electric field strength with electric potential.
44.4% of students did not gain any credit here.
(c) Most students showed a weakness in their understanding in this topic. The fact that the
resultant electric field was zero at P, and they rightly concluded that the field was zero at
infinity, made it too tempting to conclude the line between P and infinity must be an
equipotential, which was obviously wrong. Only about a third of the students thought about
the work that must be done in moving a proton to a region close to two positive charges.
Also very few referred to the potential being zero at infinity. 60.7% of students scored zero.
(d) This was another question done badly, with 61.1% failing to score. The common answers
fell into two groups. The first just regarded the ball being released as if it were thrown and
therefore following a parabolic path. The second group ignored gravity all together and
wrote about the ball travelling away horizontally. Very few students analysed the situation
by considering the forces and then the resulting accelerations in the horizontal and vertical
directions. In fact, many students did not mention force or acceleration but kept to
generalities such as “it moves away from the wall and falls”.
(a) Many students found this to be a relatively straightforward calculation and 60% gained full
38. marks. For others, the main difficulty was in choosing the correct radius to substitute into
the equation. Some who performed the calculation in a single step made a slip and
squared the radius.
(b) On this relatively simple question only a quarter of the students scored both marks. Even
more able students did not seem to know that the foot of an arrow represents the position
where the force is applied. The weight arrow, for example, was more frequently seen
starting at the base of the sphere B rather than starting at the centre of mass. Also, many
students did not try to represent all three forces.
(c) Very few students scored both marks. Even the most able students either presented a
problem but then did not suggest how it could be overcome, or told the examiner how to
measure d without stating a problem. Most students did not express clearly how d should
be measured. There was often a reference to a tool such as a vernier calliper or set square
but no indication of how it should be used. A very common statement that does not answer
the question was that ‘d is not measured in the correct place. It should be measured from
the centres of the spheres’ .
(d) Most students scored some marks on this question and over 60% gained full marks. The
minority that failed to gain marks either did not square the distance between the centres of
charge or did not use the centre-to-centre distance.
(e) Less than half showed that the figures were self-consistent. Some students attempted to
show consistent values but used an incorrect trigonometrical function. Others gave a
general answer such as ‘the angle is small which fits the data’ . Some did not appreciate the
problem and dealt only with the lengths of the triangle made with the two spheres and the
support.
(f) The calculation of the gravitational force was done well by most students. Unfortunately,
many students then failed to compare this to the electrostatic force. Many simply said the
gravitational force was negligible without saying compared to what.