BANE 154 (English)
BANE 154 (English)
BANE 154 (English)
DISSERTATION
Indira Gandhi National Open University
School of Social Sciences
DISSERTATION
(BANE-154)
MANUAL
General Editor
Dr. Rukshana Zaman, SOSS, IGNOU, New Delhi
Cover Design
Design: Tamal Basu, Graphic Designer, New Delhi.
Concept: Dr. Rukshana Zaman, SOSS, IGNOU, New Delhi
Photographs contributed by
Dr. Gaurav Saxena, Director, Directorate of Resettlement East Zone, Ministry of Defence, HQ Sub
Area, Kolkata (Conducting Focus Group Discussion)
Dr. Naga Raju Chikkala, Associate Professor, Tribal Cultural Research and Training Mission
(TCR&TM), Department of Tribal Welfare, Government of Andhra Pradesh, Andhra. (Pictures
clicked during rapport building)
Dr. Ubaid Dhar, Research Scholar, Discipline of Anthropology, School of Social Sciences, IGNOU,
New Delhi. (Pictures of tools used in fieldwork camera and measuring tapes)
Mr. Hashmat Habib. Research Scholar, Discipline of Anthropology, School of Social Sciences,
IGNOU, New Delhi. (Participant Observation: Casting the net)
Ms. Monika Shah, Research Scholar, Discipline of Anthropology, School of Social Sciences,
IGNOU, New Delhi (Using the anthropometer to take measurements).
Consultants
Dr. Smarika Awasthi & Dr. Pankaj Upadhyay
PRINT PRODUCTION
Mr. Rajiv Girdhar Mr. Hemant Kumar Parida
Assistant Registrar, Section Officer,
MPDD, IGNOU, New Delhi MPDD, IGNOU, New Delhi
July, 2022
Indira Gandhi National Open University, 2022
ISBN :
All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form, by mimeograph or any other means,
without permission in writing from the Indira Gandhi National Open University.
Further information about the School of Social Sciences and the Indira Gandhi National Open University
courses may be obtained from the University’s office at Maidan Garhi, New Delhi-110 068.
Printed and published on behalf of the Indira Gandhi National Open University, New Delhi by Director,
School of Social Sciences.
Laser Typesetting : Akashdeep Printers, 20-Ansari Road, Daryaganj, New Delhi-110002
Printed at :
FIELD WORK MANUAL
Contents
Pages
1.1 Introduction 9
1.1.1 What is Field work? 10
1.1.2 Dissertation Work 13
1.1.3 You and Your Supervisor 14
1.2 Writing a Synopsis 18
1.3 Field Work and Data Collection Procedure 34
1.4 Guidelines for Dissertation Submission 85
1.4.1 Structure of the Dissertation 85
1.4.2 Format of the Dissertation and Submission 85
1.4.3 Criteria for Assessment of Dissertation 87
Appendix 90
Field Work Manual
6
Introduction
COURSE INTRODUCTION
The Bachelor of Sciences (Honours) in Anthropology (BSCANH) Programme
comprises of fourteen compulsory courses and four discipline-specific courses out of
a choice of six. BANE 154 Dissertation is an optional course in the sixth semester. It is
a six-credit course that comprises compulsory fieldwork. For every student of
anthropology, fieldwork is an integral component of initiation into the discipline. Fieldwork
is an essential and important part of the study and fulfils the concept that anthropology
is a field science.
This manual would guide, help and walk you through the process of initiating the learner
into the realm of fieldwork. The course begins with the identification of a topic and
ends with the submission of a well-structured dissertation of about twenty thousand
words (excluding bibliographic references).
Course Outcome
The learner would be able to:
select a research topic
review relevant literature
write a synopsis
understand the nuances of submitting the synopsis to the Course Coordinator
conduct fieldwork and collect data once the synopsis is approved by the Course
Coordinator
analyse and interpret the data with reference to the aims and objectives of the
study
present the work in an extended and coherent manner via the dissertation.
In the BSCANH Programme, through various courses both compulsory and optional,
we have tried to provide you with adequate knowledge and information about the
discipline of anthropology. Learning theory alone is not enough to understand the subject
concern of Anthropology, thus, for every theory course, we have provided you with a
practical component. Through these practical components, you have learned to prepare
a synopsis, how to use theory in your fieldwork, which method, tools, and techniques
you can use for your work, and how to analyse your data. In this course on dissertation,
you would get the opportunity to use all the skills that you have been honing through
your courses. It is essential that learners pursuing study in anthropology visit different
communities, institutions and organisations and interact with people. The learners are
thus, encouraged through the course on (BANE 154) to visit field in a variety of socio-
cultural contexts to gain firsthand knowledge about the situation and environment and
make an in-depth study on any one of the areas or issues associated with the lives of
people. In order to make your task of conducting an empirical study an easy one, we
have prepared this fieldwork manual which will assist you in various stages of your
research.
The fieldwork dissertation should be planned and carried out independently by the
learner, (data collection like blood sample or any other anthropometric measurements,
interview, case studies, life histories, etc.,) are the sole responsibility of the researcher. 7
Field Work Manual The learner with the help of a supervisor and guidelines specified in the fieldwork
manual are to prepare for the data collection. The learner is not to engage any other
professional/research assistant in the field for data collection. Based on the fieldwork,
the learner is expected to submit a dissertation for evaluation. We are categorically
sure that you would enjoy doing the fieldwork and realise the nuances of the subject.
Fieldwork can take place in a variety of socio-cultural contexts but must be relevant to
the subject matter of the anthropology discipline. What is expected of you is to decide
on any anthropological issue you would like to undertake, review the related literature
in detail and understand and analyse it. Learner can freely choose the location and
specific theme for their fieldwork but their choice must be approved by one of the
teachers and academic counselor. The learner is however, cautioned to work on a
simple topic, as it is a learning phase and pay more attention as to how the
anthropological tools and techniques can be utilised in the field. The basic idea is that
the learner is able to comprehend what a field is and how a field is to be approached,
armed with anthropological methods, tools and techniques. You should be able to
prepare your own interview schedules, prepare notes for case studies or life histories.
Apart from this, the choice of topic is only limited by research-ethical and safety
conditions. Fieldwork dissertation would help you to apply your understanding of what
is anthropology that you have learnt in the earlier courses. This would help you to
develop your research expertise in anthropology and give you an insight as to how you
can approach the issues that you are concerned and curious about. Through this manual
we will guide you as to how you can go about completing a dissertation. The supervisor
will not only acquaint you with the procedures and rules to be followed for completion
of the project but also provide you with an understanding on how to go about it.
In this manual we have provided some guidelines which will enable you to conduct
your fieldwork and prepare the dissertation. Your dissertation supervisor will provide
you with further necessary guidance. There are five parts in this manual wherein we
have compiled the practical components of the core courses from BANC 101 to
BANC 110 to help you recapitulate and work on your synopsis and dissertation.
I am sure with the help of this manual along with the guidance of your supervisor you
will be able to carry out your dissertation work systematically and to the full satisfaction
of all concerned. In order to motivate you, for the cover design, we have used pictures
that are from actual field work conducted by our research scholars. Hope it inspires
you to conduct fieldwork on your own. Wish you all the best.
8
Introduction
1.1 INTRODUCTION
Contents
1.1.1 What is Field Work?
1.1.2 Dissertation Work
1.1.3 You and Your Supervisor
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
The general objective of the fieldwork and dissertation (BANE 154) is to help the
learner:
to develop research skills;
acquaint with the problems of humans of different cultures to conduct ethnographic
fieldwork;
to gain empirical knowledge required for preparing a research proposal;
to practice what you have learnt in the core courses;
to develop the ability to apply multi disciplinary concepts, tools and techniques to
solve research problems through ‘scientific method’ of investigation; and
to develop writing, presentation, communication and analytical skills.
Having studied the basic concepts, methods and theories of anthropology, it is
appropriate that you get familiarised with conducting your own field research. The field
work and preparation of the dissertation is going to be a new experience for most of
you. What you have learnt in the basics of anthropology may help you, to a large
extent, in understanding the social situation of our people and the need and importance
of anthropological intervention. Surely you have chosen Anthropology with a purpose.
Therefore, you must be eager to acquire some specialised knowledge on the subject.
Most people learn by doing fieldwork and facing field situations. That is how exactly
we are trying to help the learners of BSCANH. Although as a distance learner, you
may face various limitations during the learning process, still we shall help you to acquire
not only information and knowledge, but also skills in analysing humans’ situations,
their problems and the impact of various programmes being implemented. The students
require both academic and mental preparedness to successfully and satisfactorily
complete the fieldwork dissertation. We shall also try to equip you with skills for
developing dissertation proposals for research, tools for data collection, report writing
and making suggestions or recommendations.
The main purpose of this course is to sensitise you to the realities of social and human
life. This dissertation provides an opportunity to the learners to apply the knowledge
they have acquired in course of their study and to develop skills in the areas of various
courses of this programme. Therefore, you will be choosing a topic of your interest for
specialisation. This may be pertaining to the area in which you are already working or
you may like to work on a different topic. You have grasped, we are sure, from the
basics of anthropology that the areas and issues pertaining to the subject are very vast.
Here we would like to concentrate on a particular theme or topic to specialise. For
9
Field Work Manual those who want to pursue further higher qualifications, this may be their specialised
research area and is of future career interest.
Within this framework, the specific objectives of BANE 154 are to enable a learner:
to select a suitable research topic/title for the dissertation;
to write research proposal pertaining to your own research interests;
to identify and formulate research problems;
to develop the research design for conducting empirical study;
to identify the objectives of the study;
to select the fieldwork area of the study;
to develop the sampling framework;
to identify and use appropriate research methodology
establish rapport in field area;
to collect primary and secondary data;
to scrutinise the collected data;
to train in the actual entry of data (manual or computer);
tabulate data and to do statistical calculation;
develop draft chapters;
to scrutinise qualitative and quantitative analysis and interpretation of data of your
study;
to analyse the data by using classification and tabulation, following standard method
and then using appropriate statistical technique;
to finalise various chapters with the guidance of the supervisor;
to write a good dissertation;
to develop skills like proof reading, data articulation, and presentation of data;
to successfully complete the submission of the dissertation.
face to face experience with its subjects. It is the fieldwork that distinguishes
anthropology from other social sciences. In fact for many anthropologists fieldwork is
almost synonymous with ethnography.
Anthropologists also distinguish between fieldwork, which is a method of conducting
qualitative research, initially in the discipline of anthropology, and ethnography, which
is the writing up of that research. Ethnography is a systematic/scientific study of a
particular cultural group or phenomenon, based upon extensive fieldwork in one or
more selected locales. The aim of ethnography is to study societies in a holistic manner.
Ethnography brings complex, personal, and thoughtful insights and meaning to the inner
workings of social settings. Traditionally in anthropology ethnographies resulted in
ethnographic monographs on cultures and communities.
Anthropologists gather data by doing fieldwork, going to the field. Wolcott (1995)
defines fieldwork as a form of inquiry that requires a researcher to be engrossed
personally in the ongoing social activities of some individual or group carrying out the
research. Fieldwork involves living with the people they study, learning their language,
asking them questions, surveying their environments and material possessions, and
spending long periods of time observing their everyday behaviours and interactions in
their natural settings. Fieldwork involves spending a lengthy period of time participating
and observing another culture in order to generate anthropological knowledge. Spending
long period of time in the field is considered the crucial aspect, because fieldwork
allows the researcher to observe and examine all aspects of a cultural system, especially
those that could not be addressed through laboratory or survey research alone. While
conducting fieldwork they use a variety of specialised research methods, tools and
techniques to increase the validity and trustworthiness of the findings. They gather
information by watching and talking with people, and by reading available reports and
records. Observation is a main tool in an ethnographer’s toolbox, and ethnographers
spend a good deal of their time in the field observing, either as nonparticipant or
participant observers. In Participant observation anthropologists collect their firsthand
data by involving themselves into the cultures to better understand the insider, or emic
experience. In this way the fieldworker/ ethnographer not only becomes familiar with
the spatial dimensions of the research setting, and its socio-cultural dynamics, but also
how those dynamics may change at certain times of the day, week or year.
In the courses BANC-102 Block-4 and BANC-110 Block-2 we have discribed the
technique for gathering empirical data on human societies/cultures through observation,
interviews, schedules and questionnaires, etc. The techniques, methods and
methodology emphasises on the significance of field work in anthropology. In fact,
anthropology is referred to as a field science. It gives awareness on the differences and
relationship between technique, method and methodology which are the backbone of
research. Research design is essential before proceeding towards any research project.
These blocks give an idea about significance of literature in any research pursuit. It
gives the knowledge about the achievement of similar studies thereby helping the
researcher to limit the scope of their inquiry providing them the structure of their topic
along with cautioning to go beyond the scope of their quest. It is a continuous process
and efforts should be made not to repeat the study already undertaken. Literature
survey also helps to learn from the studies of predecessors who worked on related
11
Field Work Manual topics and to improvise over them. This is one of the major benefits of literature review.
You must have noticed that research design follows certain steps. Selection of the
research problem has three main components: determining the core area of research,
identifying the range of alternatives from which choices are made, and the context in
which these choices are made, i.e., the factors that can influence the choices. I am sure
after you have read through this unit on research design theory you can comprehend
how in anthropology, facts, hypotheses, theory, and science are interrelated. Do you
remember you were exposed to the idea of theory as basic building block of science?
Read BANC-108 about how hypotheses are built up from theories and how the
parameters that would reveal information form the integral part of research? Research
design as the name indicates means designing a strategy of conducting the research
satisfying what, how, where, why and all the queries pertaining to the field chosen. A
well conceived research design makes the job of the researcher an easy one. It gives a
clear picture of the research process facilitating repeatability of the study by others to
validate the results obtained. This is only possible if the research design is planned well,
keeping all the aspects into consideration. While doing so one must be very clear of the
objective of the research and then choosing the right methods and techniques not only
for collecting but also for analysing the data to achieve the objectives. A research
design also helps to manage the time and cost budgeting which is important considering
the time constraints and limited financial resources.
Tools and techniques of primary data collection and sources of collecting the same
hold a pivotal position in anthropology and that’s what you learnt in the tools and
techniques of data collection. In both direct and indirect observation and participant
and non-participant observation for primary data collection were emphasised.
Observation is one of the oldest and most commonly used methods for data collection.
Secondary data refers to already existing data which has been collected and analysed
by somebody else. The unit on secondary data reflects that the most important problem
that the social scientists of the day face concerns the collection of relevant and reliable
data. The scholars belonging to various social sciences have developed their own technique
of data collection, depending upon the nature of their discipline. Such data holds extreme
importance as secondary data which could be in the form of census, gazetteers etc.
Apart from collecting data using various tools and techniques, the fieldworker should
maintain a field dairy which will be quite useful at the time of analysing data.
The section 1.3.1 (pg. 37) on biological methods elucidates that the importance and
selection of the biological method is dependent on the objective of study. The
significance of anthropometry, pedigree analysis, serogenetics and somatometry are
well dealt with. Archaeology is one of the important branches of anthropology which
unearths the human past with the evidences from material and culture. It is not an easy
task to unravel the bygone era therefore scientific techniques are employed to reach
the conclusions. It involves everything, from locating the archaeological site, then collecting
the relic of that time, organising it to specific cultural periods by choosing from different
methods, conserving and preserving them and finally interpreting them.
The analysis and interpretation of data is the key to good research work. In BANC-
110, Block 3 the unit on statistical analysis exhibited the application of statistical
techniques in research to appreciate the need of statistical techniques and which technique
to employ best for any particular problem. It is not just deciding upon the accurate
technique but equal emphasis has to be given to interpreting the data and its result.
12 Statistical techniques play a very important role in every step. The statistical techniques
can be used to help in collecting, processing and interpreting quantitative data. The General Guidelines
fieldwork and dissertation is essential and mandatory in the study of anthropology.
Now when you will work on the dissertation remember and implement what you have
learnt in course on Anthropology and Methods of Research.
Once a supervisor has been appointed, you should follow a series of stages in the
supervision process as you proceed from refining your proposed research to the
presentation of your finished dissertation. It is important that you take responsibility for
14
maintaining the momentum throughout your candidature, and that you are well prepared General Guidelines
for your consultation with your supervisor at each stage. You should discuss with your
supervisor pre-determined deadlines for the completion of your project work. We
strongly advise that you map out, from the start, a schedule of meetings or consultations
with your supervisor at various stages of dissertation work. This will provide you with
a series of deadlines to work to and goals to achieve, and will make clear the expectations
that you and your supervisor have of one another.
It is expected to have at least four meetings with the allocated supervisor. Although
individual instances will vary, however it is expected to have minimum of four substantive
consultations of approximately 30 minutes with the supervisor. It is the responsibility of
the researcher to arrange these before the supervision period ends. It is advisable to
make arrangements for subsequent contact at the end of each meeting. Distance learning
students, on the other hand, may never meet their dissertation supervisor face-to-face
and, therefore, need to establish an alternative pattern of communication. Options
include you can telephone, email or fax, etc.
The Learner’s Role
The learners must ensure that dissertation supervisors are kept fully informed on progress
and difficulties, and are ‘interviewed’ with prepared questions at supervisory meetings.
The chapter drafts should be submitted in advance of meetings giving sufficient time to
allow for comment and discussion before proceeding to the next stage. The responsibility
is on the researcher to make sure that the meetings with the supervisor are arranged
and that learner; attend at the times agreed upon with mutual consultation. The learners
will not be ‘chased’ by supervisors. The responsibilities of the learner include:
Discuss with the supervisor the type of guidance and comments that they find
helpful.
Taking the initiative in arranging consultations, raising questions on problems or
difficulties encountered.
Delivering type-written drafts several days before a discussion.
Keeping appointments (or informing the supervisor where this is not possible).
Maintaining a schedule of work as agreed to with the supervisor. The supervisor will
almost certainly be supervising a variety of other projects; therefore, the researcher
should not assume that he/ she can immediately recall the last discussion he/she had
about a particular topic. Whenever you meet the supervisor and discuss with him, take
notes and these will help you in your work. Such record on previous meetings will also
help the supervisor to recapitulate earlier discussion and suggestions to proceed further.
Meeting with supervisors always need to be prearranged. Never expect on-the-spot
supervisions. There will also be periods when the supervisor is not available, either
because he/she is heavily committed with the duties such as examining, or on leave for
work or holiday reasons. It has to be ensured by the students that they should keep
their supervisor updated of their progrress. Supervisors cannot judge how your work
is going if the researcher just hands over a sub-section that he/she has written up. A
draft of the contents has to be annexed so that it is quite clear what follows on from
what. A note to show if and how the section in question is incomplete needs to be
15
Field Work Manual added, to clarify. It may not be possible for the supervisor to read entire dissertation as
soon as it is prepared. It would be a good idea, therefore, to discuss this and establish
which sections he/she wishes to see. Also, supervisors are not to be expected to proof
read or to correct spelling/grammer. Learners are advised to arrange for such services
themselves if needed.
Even after the supervisor has read the entire dissertation and the suggested changes
have been carried, this is no guarantee that it is of a pass standard; after all, the work
is of the researcher and its quality is dependent on his/her output. To a large extent,
then, the dissertation has to be a self- managed process. The role of the researcher is
to organise the research program as a whole, taking advice from the supervisor and
taking the initiative in discussing problems/difficulties. The supervisor’s role is to give
advice and help about the nature and standard of the work, and direct the student to
useful literature and appropriate methodology. But remember, the ultimate responsibility
lies with the researcher. Do not expect the supervisor to read drafts and re-drafts of
every piece of work, and above all, do not embarrass him/her in the latter stages by
asking whether you will be successful, not the least because he/she cannot tell you, or
do not know (if you are border line). When submitted, the dissertation is referred to,
external examiner who will make an independent judgment of your work in its entirety.
It is important that you submit whole chapters for feedback in good time for meetings
with the supervisor, accompanied each time by an updated outline, a running bibliography
and any necessary appendices. Because you have revised your chapter do not discard
your earlier draft immediately. You should keep all your data, field dairy, rough drafts,
notes taken during discussions with supervisor, etc. till the end of the dissertation. The
supervisor cannot deal with smaller sections since it is impossible to see how these
relate to the whole. You should take whole chapter if not all the chapters to him for
advice.
The role of the supervisor is to:
Give guidance about the nature of the research and dissertation/research project
report.
Give guidance on the standard of work expected, and on how to plan and manage
your time and the program of research involved.
Advice about review of relevant literature.
Give guidance on research techniques and on necessary reading.
Advice about study design, methods and developing the research question.
Oversee the writing of an outline and the selection and submission of a title.
Give guidance on the planning of empirical work and about how to collect data in
the field.
Give letters of introduction/authorisation to enable you to make enquiry and
investigations at different sources (offices, libraries, etc.).
Giving practical advice to help in the implementation of your research proposal.
Respond to first drafts of chapters.
16
Agree completion dates for successive stages of the work, requesting draft chapters General Guidelines
as appropriate and returning written material with constructive criticism on the
broad shape and structure of the work (but not on its detailed content).
Provide advice and guidance to help improve the quality of the work. Please remember
though, that dissertation preparation for a higher degree is under taken within the general
principle that the dissertation must be the learner’s own work. To reiterate, it is not
your supervisor’s job to write it for you!
In sum, the supervisor will guide the researcher towards the production of the dissertation
by discussing each part of the process. He/she may advise on relevant areas of literature,
help to develop thoughts on the topic, give guidance on the development of chapters
and on the conventions of dissertation writing. The supervisor will not act as a proof-
reader. They are obliged to read the whole of the final draft submission. In addition, he/
she will approve and recommend the proposal to the Faculty Committee as well as
certify and recommend the dissertation for evaluation.
The supervisor will be paid a token remuneration of (Rs. 500/-) only for each project.
He/she can claim project guidance fee using a proforma as (enclosed), after the
submission of the dissertation of the learners.
17
Field Work Manual
1.2 WRITING A SYNOPSIS
Contents
1.2.0 Introduction
1.2.1 Writing a Synopsis
1.2.2 Summary
1.2.3 References
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
After reading this manual the learner would be able to comprehend:
how to prepare a synopsis; and
the elements that have to be taken into account while writing a synopsis.
1.2.0 INTRODUCTION
Fieldwork is the hallmark of anthropology. It can be said to have formed the
foundation of the discipline. Famous anthropologist, Margaret Mead notes:
“We still have no way to make an anthropologist except by sending him into
the field: this contact with living material is our distinguishing mark” (Mead
1964: 5).
The first step towards fieldwork is having the intent to conduct research. This intent
gets manifested in the research synopsis. In the next section let’s discuss how to
prepare a research synopsis.
18
Preparing a Synopsis
1.2.1 WRITING A SYNOPSIS
A synopsis may be defined as a brief outline or the framework that describes the
research to be undertaken. In the synopsis one needs to discuss the topic that has
been selected for the fieldwork from the following viewpoints:
a. Introduction
b. Selection criteria of the topic: Universe and unit of study
c. Relevance of the topic
d. Literature review
e. Aims and objectives
f. Hypothesis (if any) needs to be explained with justification
g. Pilot study
h. Methods, tools and techniques
i. Data compilation, analysis and writing a report
j. References
k. Appendix
a. Introduction
The first step in writing a synopsis is giving an introduction of the work that is to
be undertaken. Like we have stated in the theory section, one cannot just barge
into a space like an institution, village, corporate organisation, etc., and conduct a
fieldwork or research. First, we need to have a detailed plan and understanding of
every step of doing the fieldwork and that begins with the identification of a problem
for research which needs to be discussed in the introduction section. In each of
the units the learner must have realised how the topic is being introduced to the
learner. Likewise, while writing a synopsis the first step is to introduce the type of
work that the researcher intends to pursue.
b. Selection criteria of the topic: Universe and unit of study
Identifying a Research Problem
For doing fieldwork the first requirement is identifying a research problem or question.
What is a research question? How do we identify a research question? What are
the criteria or benchmarks that one needs to keep in mind while formulating a research
question? These queries will be discussed in this section. Research question can
be on any topic that is relevant, can be justified and related to human beings. For
example, we can choose a research question like migration patterns of daily wage
labourers to big cities. One must be able to define and conceptualise each item of
the research problem. For example, we must first define the term daily wage
labourers, in terms of the kind of work they do, the nature of their livelihood and
also what is meant by migration. What we have read will be very helpful in this
regard. In this research question, we first need to understand why we want to study
the migration pattern, and why we are using the term pattern? Migration, as we
19
Field Work Manual know, is a phenomena and it is happening since time immemorial. People have been
moving from one place to another in search of new land, food and work. However,
when we say migration pattern we would basically be looking at the migration trends-
like long term migration or short term migration or seasonal migration, etc. Once a
research problem is identified the next step for the researcher would be to look up
at the work that has already been done in this field by other scholars. The identification
of the research problem is closely associated with the interests of the researcher;
whether he/she wants to do exploratory research, action research or a purely an
analytical theoretical research.
Reflection
The choice of topic should preferably be based on a theme or problem
associated with the subject of research. There are various sources for selection
of topic but the most common, which may lead to an interest in the topic
are:
personal experience,
something someone has said,
something you have read,
something you have studied,
something you have not studied,
your career aspirations.
Important events and trends often inspire a research topic.
want to study the migration pattern of contract labourers so here the unit of study
would be contract labourers and to make it more precise we would add the place
also, for example from which part of the country the labourers are migrating and
where they are going as contract labourers. Such detailed information makes up
the unit of study. One also needs to take into account the type of study one is planning
whether it would be qualitative or quantitative based on which the sample size in
terms of the population that would be studied would be decided, like age group of
the migrants to be studied, gender, etc.
c. Relevance of the topic
If we look into literatures, we will find that almost every topic one can think of has
been explored and researched. Going back to our example of migration, we would
find an endless amount of material on the topic. So, what do we research on? What
remains for a researcher is to find the gaps and work on them. That would lead to
looking at the problem from a different perspective. In relevance of selecting a topic
a researcher has to detail the reasons why the topic is of importance and how it
can lead to new avenues of research. This can only be achieved if one does literature
review. In the next section we will discuss literature review.
d. Literature review
Once we select and identify a research problem for our study we need to do a
background search in terms of what other research has been done in the same field
this is known as a literature review. Literature review helps in understanding how
the research problem has been looked at by other researchers and what are the
gaps that are there. It basically strengthens our research work and facilitates in doing
away with repetitions. In this section the researcher has to outline the different types
of literature that would be consulted during the course of the research. Let’s go
back to our example of migration patterns of daily wage labourers to big cities.
With this as our topic let’s see what kind of literature we would need to review.
First, we have to list out works on migration, herein we can look at different disciplines
and see how migration has been perceived by them like the economist, sociologist,
etc. Even the reports of the international organisations like International Labour
Organisation, UN reports, etc. to see the issues and problems of migration and
how migration is being perceived in the present times. Second, the anthropological
works on migration would be the next stop for literature review. One also needs
to carefully search if any of the anthropologists have worked on the universe that
you have selected. This will help in not replicating someone else’s work which is
equivalent to reinventing the wheel again. We would also have to look at the patterns
of migration, the reasons behind seasonal migration, etc. So, literature review underlines
the work that has already been done and helps one to formulate questions from
the gaps of other studies. As in the present world, everything and anything has been
explored and the challenge of a researcher is to find gaps and explore those areas
that need more attention and can be looked at from a different perspective. It also
helps us in identifying a theoretical approach that we may use and also guide us in
defining and understanding concepts.
e. Aims and objectives
In a synopsis one needs to define the aims and objectives of the research activities
21
Field Work Manual that are to be done. The aims define why a research is being undertaken. The aims
present the thematic and theoretical perspectives, objectives define those concepts
and theories in a detailed manner. While deciding on a topic it generally begins with
an area of interest that a researcher wants to focus upon, one tends to look for a
problem or unexplored issue in that area or gaps in an already researched area,
usually from a particular perspective or approach.
Aims
Aims in a research proposal broadly describe the desired outcomes from the research.
They focus on long-term intended outcomes or the researcher’s aspirations in reference
to the research. Aims are not numbered in a research proposal.
Objectives
Objectives are basically defined to understand how the aims would be accomplished.
While aims define the nature of the research in a broader sense, objectives are more
focused and define how it can be done practically. Objectives are generally numbered
in roman alphabets, so each one stands alone. Each objective must have a concrete
method defined.
Both aims and objectives should be short and precise. While defining the aims one
must have one or more objectives describing how that aim should be met. They
must be interrelated, with realistic goals keeping in view the methods that would
be employed in order to reach the scope of research. One must avoid something
too broad and it should be to the point. Now try to think what could be the probable
aims and objectives for the topic migration.
f. Hypothesis
g. Pilot study
A researcher may undertake a pilot study to test the interview schedule for fieldwork.
During the pilot study based on the actual ground reality the researcher finds ample
scope to rework on the interview schedule and refine it.
h. Fieldwork methodology
In this section the tools and techniques that are to be used in the field needs to be
described. As we have learnt in our theory section there are many tools and based
on the topic the researcher needs to select the tools and techniques that best suits
the research. One needs to note here that all the tools and techniques need not be
used. One needs to detail here how interviews are to be conducted like using an
interview schedule (structured or unstructured) or an interview guide or if it is a
22
virtual project types of questionnaires, etc. The tools and techniques stated below Preparing a Synopsis
(ii) Interview: There are many ways of conducting an interview and also there
are many types of interviews, a. direct interview and b. indirect interview
are two of the basic interview techniques. In direct interview, the researcher
meets the informant and conducts a face to face interview. While in an indirect
interview the researcher can either send the interview questions to the informant
via mail/post, email or conduct a video, web or telephonic interview. During
fieldwork as the researcher is present in the field, direct interview is the norm.
Life history, case study and focus group discussions are the different types
of interviews that a researcher uses based on the requirement of the problem
identified.
23
Field Work Manual Designing the tools for interview: In order to conduct an interview we need to
have a systematic approach. Questions need to be formulated so that the researcher
is able to acquire relevant information from the informants during an interview. Different
types of interview schedule and guides are prepared as per the requirement of the
research work.
a) Interview Guide
To assess the reliability of answers to vital questions, one may have to frame multiple
questions to get at the same information. For a questionnaire to be administered
the group has to be literate enough to fill up the forms, a drawback that is not there
while administering an interview schedule.
SAMPLE QUESTIONNAIRE
TOPIC NAME
Place: Date:
General Information:
7. Educational Qualification:
8. Family details:
Information on Migration:
10. For how many years have you been living in this town?
......................................................................................................
11. Please share the reasons for leaving your home town.
......................................................................................................
13. Tell us about some of the issues that you faced when you first came
to this town.
......................................................................................................
14. Are you the only one who came here from your home town?
......................................................................................................
19. Suggest what would motivate you to go back to your home town?
......................................................................................................
Reflection
Key Informant: Key informant can be a person either female or male who
has knowledge about the topic of research and can provide insider view. A
key informant is generally selected by a researcher during the time of rapport
building when the researcher goes around the field space trying to know the
community and adjust to the surroundings.
A life history allows an in-depth study. The rationale behind the collection of life-
histories is that people do not live in vacuum. They live in society and according to
society, guided by its norms and values. Unlike historians and biographers who look
for the life history of the unique or powerful persons, anthropologists collect the
life histories of ordinary persons, in their ordinary day-to-day existence; so that
they can learn about the general culture and the way of life in a time period. Life
histories often reflect changes and the impact of social and cultural events and
transitions on the life of a person. One of the most celebrated life histories in
anthropology is of Pedro Martinez, written by Oscar Lewis, which describes the
life of an ordinary Mexican person and his family in great detail.
The individual life history method was developed in American cultural anthropology,
as it faced the distressing situation of vanishing tribes. Quite often, they could locate
only a single or very few members of a tribe and collection of detailed life history
of a single person was the only way in which something about this vanished tribe
could be reconstructed.
(iv) Case Study
Herbert Spencer was the first sociologist to use case material in his ethnographic
work. A case study involves an in-depth research of a particular event, incident or
phenomena where a community or a group of people are directly involved or affected.
Herein, we can take the example of the Bhopal Gas Tragedy which happened in
Bhopal on December 3, 1984. One can study the after effects of the tragedy in
28 terms of physical or biological issues, psychological issues or medico-legal issues,
etc. In such a study, the homogeneity of the group is described in terms of its Preparing a Synopsis
association with the tragedy and how the individuals relate to the tragedy. Human
mind has a way of remembering incidents and occurrences that are relevant to their
own selves. Thus, case studies of different people relate directly or indirectly to
the incident when taken can provide information on the same context, but from
different perspectives or levels of memories and understanding of the event.
A case study is a holistic method that enables us to get an all-round perspective on
a single incidence or event. Some anthropologists, like Max Gluckman and Van
Velson, had also devised what was known as the extended case method. This was
often used for analysis of conflicts and legal disputes and cases and basically consisted
of following a case or an event over a long period of time, so that one could get an
insight not only into structures and norms, but also into processes of social life.
(v) Genealogy
Genealogy helps in tracing the line of descent. It forms an integral part of
anthropological fieldwork as it connects the past to the present. Genealogical studies
have also unveiled the myths and beliefs associated with ancestors and ancestor
worship. For example, during a genealogical study in a Karbi village, it was seen
that many people in the family shared the same names. The genealogy revealed
that newborn in a family could be named only after those ancestors for whom the
chomangkan (ritual related to ancestor worship) ceremony had been performed.
As the chomangkan ceremony required a huge amount of funds and finances, the
Karbis have almost stopped performing this ritual and in the village the last
chomangkan had taken place some twenty years ago, when the study was being
conducted in the late nineties.
(vi) Focus Group Discussions
Till now we have been discussing one-to-one interaction via direct or face-to-face
interview of the researcher, with the individuals in the community. Focus group
discussion is a way of interviewing a group of people within the community who
can contribute to the topic of study. The researcher at times might feel the need to
have interaction with more than one person on the same topic or the opinion of
many people on the topic might prove beneficial to the research. In such a case
Focus Group Discussions (or FGDs) are conducted. While conducting a FGD, the
group comprises of 8-10 people. A small group is manageable and the moderator
can keep the conversation going. If the group is large, some might not feel comfortable
to speak, while others might dominate the flow of conversation. In a FGD, normally
a heterogeneous group or different stakeholders are selected so that their views
and opinions on the same topic can be understood. While conducting an FGD the
researcher does not participate in it but observes and records the entire session.
This technique is more suitable for goal-oriented and action research, where one is
focusing only on one aspect, like say introduction of polio vaccine in a village or
assessing people’s attitudes to the introduction of a new welfare scheme. It is rarely
used for quantitative research.
i. Data compilation, analysis and writing a report
In this part of the synopsis the researcher needs to define how the data collected
in the field during fieldwork would be compiled, analysed and the report would be 29
Field Work Manual written. The researcher has to define in detail the methods, tools and techniques
that would be used like SPSS software or any other methods to compile and analyse
the data. See Unit 13, BANC-102 for more information on data compilation.
j. References
In this section let’s start with an understanding of the difference between bibliography
and reference. Bibliography pertains to writing down of all the books that the researcher
has read during the course of the project work. References on the other hand includes
only those works that the researcher has cited in the text or in the project report.
For example, a reference would include the work of Hugo (an author) if the researcher
had cited his work in the introduction section of migration. However, if the researcher
has read Hugo’s annual report on Migration and not quoted him in the text than
Hugo’s work would not be included in the references but if the researcher prepares
a bibliography than Hugo’s work would be cited in it. Before we move on to the
style of presentation of different types of references one pointer for the presentation
of references is that it has to be in an alphabetical order where the surname of the
author comes first. Now let us take a look at how to present references from various
sources like from a book, edited book, journal, chapter from a book or from some
website or online journal.
How to use quotes in the text like in the introduction section of your work.
In this section we will be presenting an example as how do we quote from a text.
Let’s take Hugo’s work for migration and see how we will quote it and also how
the reference has to be done.
Quotations in the text of our writeup.
“Undocumented migration is increasingly an issue within the region. It is estimated
that some of Asia’s largest undocumented migration flows may be among the largest
overall contemporary flow with Bangladesh-India alone involving up to 17 million
people”. (Hugo 2010:7).
In this quotation we have added inverted coma “…..” to the text that was directly
taken from the author Hugo’s work and written the author’s name in bracket (Hugo….)
with the year of publication that is 2010 and the page number from which the quote
was taken that is 7.
Below are a few examples of how reference has to be done if there are more
than one author or more than one book in the text.
When in the text you are referring to one author
… Hugo (1994) discussed… or …
When the same author has more than one work referred in a single year
… Hugo and (1994a; 1994b)… for a single authored piece-use a, b, etc.
When the work is done by two people
… Hugo and Crews (1993) discussed … or
When the work is by three or more people use et al.
For Book
Example 1
Hugo, G. 2010. “The future of migration policies in the Asia Pacific region”. http://
publications.iom.int/system/files/pdf/wmr2010_migration_policies_asia-pacific.pdf
accessed on 31.12.2018.
The author’s surname comes first, followed by the initials of the name, year of
publication, the article or book name (as it is from a website the name of the article
is in inverted comma) followed by the link of the website, we also need to give the
date when the website was accessed.
Example 2
In this reference the author’s work is in italics as the work was published in a book,
the details of the place where the publication was done along with the publisher
details also needs to be mentioned.
Example 3
Channa, S.M. 2015. Getting the writer’s cramps! Making the transition from
modernism to post-modernism in writing anthropology. In V.K., Srivastava (Ed.).
Experiences of fieldwork and writing (221-237). New Delhi: Serials Publication.
In this reference the author is S. M. Channa whose work we have quoted from
the edited book by V. K. Srivastava. The book is in italics, along with the place of
publication and the publisher details. In such references the page number of the
work also needs to be mentioned. Here the page numbers are (221-237).
In this case the work of the author that has been used as a reference is from a
journal. Here the volume number of the journal is included (Vol 95: No-1). In case
of journals, it is important to cite the volume number, as in a year there can be
more than one publication, as journals are published either quarterly, biannually or
annually.
31
Field Work Manual Some more examples
Austin- Broos, D. 1991. “Aesthetics or politics: A choice for anthropology”. Social
Analysis, 29:116-129,
Bindon, J.R. 1994. “Some implications of the diet of children in American Samoa”.
Collegium Anthropologicum, 18:7-15.
Bindon, J.R. and Crews, D.E. 1993. “Changes in some health status characteristics
of American Samoan men: A 12 year follow up study”. American Journal of Human
Biology, 5:31-38.
Bindon, J.R, Crews, D.E., and Dressler, W.W. 1991. “Life style, modernization,
and adaptation among Samoans”. Collegium Anthropologicum,15:101-110.
(REMEMBER THAT et al. IS STRICTLY NOT ALLOWED IN LIST OF
REFERENCES)
When the citation of an author is both in a journal and a book
Barth, F. 1987. Cosmologies in the making: A generative approach to cultural
variation in inner New Guinea. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
1989. ‘The analysis of culture in complex societies’. Ethnas 54(3-4):120 142.
When we use references of the same author we do not repeat the name of the
author in the reference. We just put the year of publication for the next book or
journal that we have used as reference.
Some more examples.
Schefold, R. 1972-73 “Religious involution: Internal change, and its consequences,
in the taboo system of the Mentawaians”. Tropical Man. 5:46-81.
1973 “Religious conceptions on Siberut, Mentawai”. Sumatra Research
Bulletin. 2:120-24.
1980 “The sacrifices of the Sakuddei (Mentawai Archipelago, Western
Indonesia): An attempt at classification”. In R. Schefold, W. Schoorl, & J. Tennekes.
(Eds.) Man, meanings, and history: Essays in honour of H.G. Schulte Nordholt.
The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff.
1982a “The efficacious symbol”. In E. Schwimmer and P.E. de jong.
(Eds.) Symbolic Anthropology in the Netherlands. The Hague: MartinusNijhoff.
In this section we have put an (a) after the year while mentioning the author’s work
that was published in 1982a. As a mark of identification if the author has published
more than one work in the same year, it is noted for example as 1972a., 1972b.
etc.
Website
For a web site, the first element would be the individual or registered name (give
as much information as possible), Year last updated, group responsible for the site
with their address (if available/applicable), the date site was last updated, the date
of access, and the URL address. The in-text citation would be (WHO, 1999).
32
WHO Country Health Information Profile: Samoa. U.N. W.H.O., Manila, Philippines. Preparing a Synopsis
(updated July 1, 1999; accessed February 23, 2007).
http://www.who.org.ph/chip/ctry.cfm?ctrycode=sma&body=sma.htm&flag=
sma.gif&ctry=SAMOA.
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/rapport accessed in 2017.
https://msu.edu/user/mkennedy/digitaladvisor/Research/interviewing.htm
k. Appendix
This section in a synopsis, report or book presents additional information like one
includes the structure of the interview guide or schedule. Any other supplementary
information that would help in enhancing and detailing the research work.
1.2.2 SUMMARY
Now let us quickly summarise what we have been reading in this manual. In this
manual we have tried to guide the learners as to how to prepare a synopsis for a
research proposal. This manual is basically a compilation of the two units 12 and
13 in your course work BANC-102 with additional inputs to allow the learners an
insight on the various steps involved in writing a synopsis. The manual explained in
detail the various criteria’s and elements that one needs to keep in mind while
preparing a synopsis like the research design, identifying a research problem and
how to approach the problem. The relevance of literature review has also been
taken up. We have tried to guide you as to how as a researcher you can plan and
conduct a research. Three basic question a researcher must always focus on at
every stage of the synopsis and research work are (a) Why am I doing the research?
(b) How will I conduct the research? (c) What would be the outcome of the research?
WHERE TO SUBMIT
Once the synopsis has been written and discussed with your supervisor, you
need to fill the forms attached herewith from your supervisor. Scan the forms
with the signature of your supervisor and along with the synopsis and email it
to bscanh@ignou.ac.in.
WHEN TO SUBMIT
Research Proposal/Synopsis of Projectwork (BANE 154)
For January Session submit latest by 15th of May
For July Session submit latest by 15th of November
1.2.3 REFERENCES
Boyce, C., & Neale, P. 2006. Conducting in-depth interviews: A guide for designing
and conducting in-depth interviews for evaluation input. MA, USA: Pathfinder
International.
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/rapport accessed in 2017.
https://msu.edu/user/mkennedy/digitaladvisor/Research/interviewing.htm 33
Field Work Manual
1.3 FIELDWORK AND DATA COLLECTION
PROCEDURE
Contents
1.3.0 Fieldwork Preparation, Research Methods, Tools and Techniques
1.3.1 Methods, Tools and Techniques in Physical/Biological Anthropology
1.3.2 Data Analysis, Interpretation and Report Writing
1.3.3 Presentation of Reference Cited
1.3.4 Summary
1.3.5 References
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
After reading this manual you will know:
how socio-cultural anthropologists conduct research;
what does fieldwork involve; and
the steps involved in a research project.
Problems encountered.
Interesting observations,
Personal feelings.
Generally students of anthropology leaving for fieldwork carry the following with
them:
Research proposal
Checklist of items to be collected
Adequate number of questionnaires, interview guides etc.
Notebooks for writing field dairy
Cameras with accessories
Audio recording devices
Appropriate instruments in biological research
Census particulars and study area maps
Identity card
Letters of introduction
Site Selection
A research site is the place where the research takes place, and sometimes a research
involves more than one site. The research site depends upon the problem selected
for study. The chosen problem may be concerned with a particular aspect of a tribal
community, a peasant community, a rural society or a modern society. Therefore
the site would be located in the habitat of the relevant society. Ethnographers have
also studied a range of social settings, such as organisations, institutions, meetings,
and just about any setting in which humans are interacting. Following are some different
settings that have been studied by ethnographers:
sacred places of tribals,
tribal weekly markets,
food gathering activities,
religious festivals,
social movements,
shopping malls,
jails/prisons,
family settings,
industry or work settings,
slaughter houses,
hospitals, city halls, and agencies.
The ethnographic study of various types of social settings is based on various attributes
of human interaction.
35
Field Work Manual In the field a researcher may experience culture shock. Culture shock is the feeling
of uneasiness, loneliness, and anxiety that occurs when a person shifts from one
culture to a different one. The more different the two cultures are, the more severe
the shock is likely to be. Culture shock happens to many cultural anthropologists,
no matter how much they have tried to prepare themselves for fieldwork. Culture
shock can range from problems with food to language barriers and loneliness. Food
differences were a major problem in adjustment for many anthropologists during
fieldwork.
Building Rapport
After selecting a site, a researcher starts his fieldwork. In the early stages of fieldwork,
the primary goal of the researcher is to establish rapport with the key leaders or
decision makers in the study village who may serve as gatekeepers (people who
formally or informally control access to the group or community). Establishing rapport
involves gaining trust of the study population, and that trust depends on how the
researcher presents herself or himself. In many cultures, people have difficulty
understanding why a person would come to study them because they do not know
about universities and research and anthropology. Also they find it difficult to understand
the purpose of all sorts of questions being asked by the anthropologist. They may
have their own explanations based on previous experience with outsiders whose
goals differed from those of cultural anthropologists, such as tax collectors,
businessmen, family planning promoters, and law-enforcement officials. As
anthropologists do not have any authority or official position, it is very important
for them to establish rapport with the people and approach them as humble learners
(Barbara D. Miller 2012).
Data Collection Methods, Tools and Techniques
Once the researcher builds rapport in the field, the next step is collection of primary
data. This is a very important part of the fieldwork as this is the base of the whole
project work or dissertation. In the field, the researcher can collect data using
anthropological methods, tools and techniques (see block 4 course BANC102).
The goal of the researcher is to collect information or data about the research topic.
In socio-cultural anthropology, variations exist about what kinds of data to emphasise
and the best ways to collect data.
A deductive approach is a form of research that starts with a research
question or hypothesis, and then involves collecting relevant data through
observation, interviews, and other methods.
An inductive approach is a form of research that proceeds without a
hypothesis and involves gathering data through unstructured, informal
observation, conversation, and other methods.
Data can be of two types:
Quantitative data or numeric information, such as the extent of land in
relation to the population or the number of people with particular health
problems. Deductive methods are more likely to collect quantitative data.
Qualitative data or non-numeric information, such as recordings of myths,
conversations and filming of events. Inductive methods are more likely to
collect qualitative data.
36
Most anthropologists, to varying degrees, combine deductive and inductive approaches Fieldwork
and quantitative and qualitative data. Anthropologists have labels for data collected
in each approach.
Etic approach refers to data collected according to the researcher’s questions
and categories, with the goal of being able to test a hypothesis.
Emic approach refers to data collected that reflects what insiders say and
understand about their culture, and insiders’ categories of thinking.
Cultural materialists are more likely to collect etic data, whereas interpretivists are
more likely to collect emic data.
Again, however, most cultural anthropologists collect both types of data (Miller 2012).
In anthropology there are several types of fieldwork methods, tools and techniques
that are used while conducting research. Below we will discuss a few fieldwork
methods that are used. A combination of observation of what people actually do
with verbal data about what people say they do and think is essential for a well-
rounded view of a culture (Sanjek 2000).
People may say that they do something or believe something, but their behaviour
may differ from what they say. All observations are not scientific. An observation
becomes scientific only if it is planned and executed systematically. It may take place
in a real life setting or in a laboratory. An anthropologist as an ethnographer observes
individual and collective behaviour in real-life settings.
For collecting data in the field, researchers use schedule and questionnaire.
A schedule is a structured set of questions on a given topic which are asked
by the interviewer or investigator personally. The order of questions, the
language of the questions and the arrangement of parts of the schedule are
not changed. However, the investigator can explain the questions if the
respondent faces any difficulty.
A questionnaire refers to a device for securing answers to questions by
using a form which the respondent fills in by himself. It consists of some
questions printed or typed in a definite order.
Participant observation method is the hallmark of anthropology. This method was
discovered by Bronislaw Malinowski. Using this method, the researcher or
ethnographer not only observes but participates in the activities of the culture. In
this manner, anthropologists attempt to record the emic (insider’s view of the behaviour)
as opposed to the etic (outsider’s view of the behaviour). This does not mean that
the emic and etic are mutually exclusive; they can complement one another by giving
both subjective and objective interpretations.
In addition to using participant-observation, cultural anthropologists in the field rely
heavily on ethnographic interviewing. An interview is a technique for gathering verbal
data through questions or guided conversation. This technique is used for obtaining
information on what people think or feel (attitudinal data) as well as on what they
do (behavioural data). It is more purposeful than a casual conversation.
Depending on the level of control retained by the interviewer, ethnographic interviews
are of two types:
37
Field Work Manual Unstructured interviews: The interviewer asks open-ended questions on
a general topic and allows interviewees to respond at their own pace using
their own words. The interviewer exercises minimum control in these
interviews.
Structured interviews (close ended): The interviewer asks all informants
exactly the same set of questions, in the same sequence, and preferably
under the same set of conditions.
If we can draw an analogy between interviews and school examinations, structured
interviews would be comparable to short-answer tests whereas unstructured interviews
would be more like open-ended essay tests.
An interview may involve only two people, the interviewer and the interviewee, or
several people in what are called group interviews or focus groups. Focus groups
are small groups (composed of six to ten people) convened by an anthropologist
to discuss a particular topic. Although focus groups are popular for conducting public
opinion polls and commercial product marketing, applied anthropologists use them
to both save time and generate insights not always possible by merely interviewing
individuals.
Other techniques used to collect data are the following:
The genealogical method: By this method a researcher can collect data on
kinship, family, and marriage patterns of a group. It is a basic method used
to help anthropologists understand social relationships and history.
The case study method: In this method an intensive study of a case is
done. Case is a social unit with a deviant behaviour. It is a method of
qualitative analysis. In anthropological research, this method is used
extensively to obtain a complete and detailed account of a social
phenomenon or a social unit, which may be a person, family, community,
institution or an event.
The life history method: By this method a researcher gets the personal history
of an individual. This way anthropologists gain insights into a culture. It
can help the researcher understand the emic perspective.
Anthropologists face many ethical problems while conducting research. In the field
a researcher must observe the following rules:
Obtain informed consent before the study or the interview begins.
Safeguard the informants’ rights, interests and sensitivities.
Communicate the aims of the interview to the informant.
The informants should have the right to remain anonymous and speak “off
record”.
There should be no exploitation of informants for personal gain.
Do not explore any sensitive issues.
Ensure confidentiality of data obtained.
Learn enough about the culture of informants to ensure it is respected during
38 the data collection process.
Fieldwork
1.3.1 METHODS TOOLS AND TECHNIQUES IN
PHYSICAL/BIOLOGICAL ANTHROPOLOGY
1.3.1.1 SOMATOMETRY
INTRODUCTION
Somatometry is the metric study of living human body. This science of measurement
of human body also holds immense significance in racial classification, evolutionary
studies and in designing of clothes and equipment. This section will facilitate you with
concise description of standard techniques, positions and methods for taking
somatometric measurements. Somatometric measurements are defined on the basis
of various anatomical landmarks and are useful in describing the morphology of man.
Somatometry (measurement of the dimensions of body) involve different types
of instruments for taking measurement, as you learnt in your course Introduction
to Biological Anthropology depending upon its nature. Anthropometric
measurements use growth references and standards for determining the growth,
nutritional status and welfare of children and adolescents. The anthropometric
measures such as Z-score and percentiles have been widely used to assess the
nutritional status of an individual and his/her growth. In this section, we have
also covered nutritional status assessment through anthropometric indices and
dietary practices. Nutritional status is the total of the anthropometric indices of
an individual which are influenced by consumption of nutrients. All this information
is obtained by physical, biochemical and dietary practices which depends on
the quality and the quantity of food consumed and the individual’s physical health.
The nutritional status of an adolescent has an important implication on his/her
health, in developing of chronic diseases and holds importance in breaking the
sequence of malnutrition. Dietary pattern that is a crucial factor to determine
the nutritional factor, is the general outline of the food and nutrient intake and
utilisation which is characterised on the basis of common eating habits. And,
the analysis of dietary patterns provides a more all-inclusive imprint of the food
intake habits or practices within a population.
GROWTH STATUS: SOMATOMETRY
Somatometry is made of two words ‘somato’ which means living and ‘metric’ which
refers to measurement, so in simple terms it means measurement of living beings.
Therefore, somatometry a division of anthropometry is defined as a systematic
technique to measure living body including head and face. Anthropologists have
formulated number of measurements for describing the morphology of man. These
measurements are not arbitrary and are based on anatomical landmarks and have
been in use for hundreds of years. They are useful in comparing various kinds of
people living in different geographical regions, i.e., for racial comparisons or to study
variations in body types. Physical growth of children is studied on the basis of their
body measurements. The nutritional status of young and adults is also assessed with
the help of these measurements. It also facilitates in the determination of certain
physiological functions like vital capacity, basal metabolic rate, etc. Data generated
on the basis of anthropometry surveys of populations has been an asset for designing
proper equipment for use in industry and defence purposes, spaceships, garments,
etc. The anthropometric surveys also provide norms of the physique of any population
and trends of changes in morphological traits. Let us learn how we take body weight
or weight, stature commonly called as height, and mid upper arm circumference.
You are familiar with landmarks and procedure of some measurements, nevertheless
lets go through it again. 39
Field Work Manual Body weight
Weight should be taken by means of standard weighing machine without any zero
error with fine accuracy. Body weight is measured in kilograms, which gives an
idea of body mass. The weight should be taken with minimum clothes and barefoot.
Instrument used: Weighing machine
Method: The needle of the weighing scale is adjusted to remove the zero error.
The subject stands with equal weight on both the feet. The head of the subject
should be forward. The reading on the weighing scale is noted when the needle is
stationary.
Precautions
Take care that the subject is wearing minimum clothes.
Weight should not be taken right after taking meals.
Make proper adjustment for clothes worn by the subject at the time of taking
weight. It is recommended that at the time of recording weight of the clothes
should also be adjusted.
Stature
Stature (floor-v): It measures the vertical distance from the standing floor to the
vertex.
Vertex (v): It is the highest point on the head when the head is in the Frankfurt-
Horizontal (FH) plane, also known as eye-ear plane. Vertex is not an anatomically
fixed point and is dependent on the orientation of the head.
Fig. 1 : Stature
Source : www.ovit.nist.gov
40
Instrument used: Anthropometer Somatometry
Method: The subject should stand erect, barefoot on a level floor against the
wall with her/his back and buttocks touching the wall. The heels should touch
the wall and toes are at an angle of 45° to each other. The shoulders should not
be raised upwards. The arms should be in standard arm hanging position and
the palms of the hands should touch the thighs. The anthropometer is placed on
the back of the subject if the vertical wall is not available. The head of the subject
must rest without any strain in the eye-ear plane or FH plane, i.e., tragion and
the right orbitale must lie in the same horizontal plane (Refer to the BANC 101
Manual). Now with the position of the subject set, standing on the right side of
the subject with anthropometer in the median sagittal plane of the subject and
allow moving cross-bar to touch the vertex lightly. Note that the anthropometer
is in vertical position.
Precautions
The subject is barefoot.
The heels, back and buttocks of the subject should touch the wall.
The toes are at an angle of 45°.
The arms should be in standard arm hanging position.
The head of the subject should be in eye-ear plane
In case of adults or child the height is measured up to the nearest millimeter using
anthropometer. And, a sliding board made of wood is used for measuring the length
of children. Infantometer is used for the measurement of recumbent length in case
of children who are less than 2 years of age.
Mid Upper Arm Circumference (MUAC)
The accurate and a reliable way to measure fat-free mass, is the upper arm
circumference at the midway between the tip of shoulder and the tip of elbow on
the left side of arm. The mid arm point is assessed by measuring the distance from
the tip of the shoulder to the elbow and then dividing it by 2.
Instrument used: Flexible steel tape
Method: The subject is asked to hang the hand freely in standard arm hanging
position. The tape is placed horizontally around middle of the upper arm where
generally the bicep muscles are most developed and reading is recorded.
Precaution
The arms should be hanging freely.
The tape should neither be tightly nor loosely held.
Note that the low reading of MUAC represents the loss of muscle mass. For
determining the risk of mortality (in children) and individuals having HIV/AIDS,
MUAC is the best assessing and screening tool. It is the only anthropometric tool
for evaluating the nutritional status in case of pregnant women as well.
41
Field Work Manual Activity
Take weight and mid upper arm circumference of five subjects
S.No Name of the Subject Weight of the Subject Mid Upper Arm
(kg) Circumference (cms)
1
2
3
4
5
The anthropometric measures such as Z-score and percentiles have been widely
used to assess the nutritional status of an individual and his/her growth. The parameters
of growth are
Z-scores (-2 and +2) and Percentiles (5 th, 85th, 95th, 97th, 99th percentiles) are
used to categorise various health conditions. Moreover, sex-age specific
anthropometric measures cut points are also evaluated using these factors.
As per WHO, use of growth chart i.e., growth reference on the basis of Z-scores
assesses the nutritional status and growth of a children and growth charts are prepared
on the basis of data generated.
42
Percentiles Somatometry
The percentile of populations falls below the variable’s value. Rank scale is used
and it is more understandable. It also indicates the expected prevalence.
Limitations:
Values are lumped to the lowest or highest percentiles
This factor does not suit, in case of assessing longitudinal growth status and
It is not comparable across different anthropometries.
The following table represents the percentile-Z-score conversion values
Additionally, percentile also defines the population’s expected percentage that should
be above or below the table. Different age-sex specific percentiles are also used
to evaluate the growth of children and their nutritional status on the basis of
anthropometric measures and other health conditions as well such as low or high
blood pressure.
An interesting information, Z-score and percentiles are convertible to each other.
For e.g. Z-scores of 2 and -2 matches to the 97.7th and 2.3rd percentiles while the
85th and 5th percentile correspond to Z-scores of 1.04 and -1.65 respectively (Wang
and Chen 2012).
PERCENTILES Z-SCORE
0.2nd -3
2.3rd -2
2.5th -1.96
5th -1.64
15th -1.04
16th -1
50th (median) 0
84th +1
85th +1.04
95th +1.64
97.5 th +1.96
97.7 th +2
99.8 th +3
Source - Wang and Chen 2012
Z-Scores
It is defined as the number of standard deviations away from the mean, when the
distribution is in a normal process. The scale is continuous from “-” to “+”. The
main advantage of this factor is that it
43
Field Work Manual allows comparison between sexes and ages;
also helps in quantifying the extreme values; and
is good for evaluating the growth status in longitudinal changes.
One of the major drawbacks of this factor is that it is difficult to perceive than
percentiles, especially for the public.
Z-scores are calculated on the basis of distribution of reference population; thus, it
reflects as the reference distribution. The reference population can be taken by mean
and the standard deviation (SD). Z-scores are also comparable across age, sex
and also is a measure of dimensionless quantity. Z-score group can be subjected
to a summary of statistics such mean and SD, and both can be studied as continuous
variable. As discussed above, the main limitation of this process that they are easy
to explain to the public eye and also limited in clinical settings.
They are also called as standard scores, where the z-score transformation is
considered to be useful when comparing the relative values of different measures
such as height vs. BMI from distribution of different standard deviations or means.
The following graph illustrates Z-score and the corresponding cumulative probability
and percentile
Fig. 2 : Z score
Source: Wang and Chen 2012
The transformed values of Z-score distribution will have a zero mean value or a
standard deviation value of 1. This conversion process is called as normalising or
standardising.
Height-for-age
This is the index that is used for evaluating stunting that is the presence of chronic
malnutrition in children. Children who are stunted have poor physical and intellectual
performance, thus the less work output leads to less productivity at the individual
level and poor socio-economic status at the community/society level. If there is a
44
presence of stunting in a child for provided population, shows that the children are Somatometry
suffering from the chronic malnutrition, thus affecting their linear growth.
Stunting is a child’s low height-for-age when compared to the standard child having
from the same age group or same age. Child who is suffering from stunting is found
to have the lower mental and the physical productivity capacity.
Weight-for-age
Weight-for-age is an index that is used for monitoring the growth for the purpose
of assessing and evaluating the status of underweight children. By carrying out the
community-based nutrition (CBN) activities every year, an analyst can assess the
weight-for-age of all children who are less than 2 years of age. This index determines
the body size and also reflects the levels of food intake and it is also used for assessing
the acute and short-term under-nutrition.
Did you realise how important these concepts in the study of human growth and
development are? Let’s learn about others to have more insight about it.
Body Mass Index (BMI) – This is measured when the weight of an individual
(in kg) is divided by the height of same individual in meters squared.
Weight (Kg)
BMI =
Height (meters) 2
45
Field Work Manual Activity
Take stature and weight of five subjects and calculate their BMI.
OBESITY ASSESSMENT
Overweight and obesity have reached a level of epidemic in various countries and
possess number of serious health and socio-economic consequences. Moreover,
obesity has negative consequences related to psychological, medical and quality of
life, it has drained all the health resources and also decreases the life expectancy.
In various developing countries, there are different type of weight associated diseases
such as obesity, overweight and underweight coexists simultaneously in different
components of their populations (Uzogara 2016) (Fontela, et al. 2017).
There are various methods which helps determine obesity such as body mass index
(BMI), skinfold caliper which are used to evaluate the body fat percentage. All
these methods are simple and effective.
As mentioned above, BMI is measured when the weight of an individual (in kg) is
divided by the height of same individual in meters squared. In case of adults, BMI
estimates the clinical diseases such as type 2 diabetes, however, its prediction for
children and adolescents is not that much. BMI is a global index that measures the
nutritional status of an individual and is used to categorize individuals both on the
basis of overweight/obesity and eating disorders in combination with the psychological
standards. The drawback of BMI is that it does not differentiate the fat and lean
masses.
Weight (Kg)
BMI =
Height (meters)2
BMI kg/m2 > 30 indicates obesity and BMI kg/m2 > 40 indicates morbid obesity,
hence we need to be very careful. High value of BMI is indicative of high potential
risk of getting diabetes, heart diseases and premature death.
B. Body Fat %
Body Fat % is the total mass of fat of human or other living divided by total body
mass and then multiplied by 100.
46
C. Conicity Index Somatometry
It is the simple anthropometric measure that is used to determine the central obesity
(Shenoy & Jagadamba 2017)
Let’s have a look at commonly used Body Adiposity Indices. We have learnt about
BMI that is used quite commonly.
Waist Circumference –Waist circumference measures the minimum circumference
of the torso which is the level of normal waist. This central fatness is of great
importance in assessing deep adipose tissue.
Instrument: Flexible Steel Tape
Method: The subject stands erect with the weight uniformly balanced on both the
feet that are placed about 25-30 cms apart from each other. While measuring,
mark the level of the lowest rib (margin) and the iliac crest in the mid axillary
line. Pass the measuring tape on the waist in the horizontal direction in midway
between the margins of lowest rib and iliac crest. Measure the circumference in
cm up to the nearest cm, ideally the investigator cm should sit on a stool in front of
the participant.
Precautions:
The tape should neither be tightly nor loosely held
Subject should stand straight with body relaxed
Feet should be together
Waist-Hip-Ratio(WHR)
Waist-Hip Ratio (WHR) is defined as the ratio of the circumference of the waist
to the circumference of hip. It is commonly used technique for defining body fat
distribution. In other words it is a useful measure for assessing the abdominal obesity
and has very limited accuracy.
Waist-Hip ratio is found to be a good indicator of stroke and ischemic heart disease.
WHR value > 0.90 in males, WHR value > 0.80 in females are considered to high
risk of diseases such as diabetes.
In adults, the ratio of waist hip is independently related with the risk of morbidity
after performing adjustments for relative weight, such that the use of body shape
and relative weight at the same time provides a good prediction about the morbidity
risk.
Instrument: Flexible Steel Tape
47
Field Work Manual Hip Circumference (HC) - This is the distance round the hip measured through
the largest part of the buttock’s region using a tape.
Method: The subject stands straight and breathes out. The tape is placed horizontally
over the buttock’s region. The circumference is measured at the point for obtaining
the maximum circumference.
Precautions
Waist-Hip-Ratio(WHR)
It is measured when WC divided by Ht i.e., height. All are measured in same units.
48
This is a simpler method than BMI (Fontela, 2017, Uzogara, 2016). We have learnt Somatometry
in the earlier section about waist circumference and stature/Height.
Reference to understand is
WHtR> 0.5 for men or women indicates Obesity
WHtR< 0.5 for men or women indicates healthy weight
Activity
Calculate WC of five subjects and identify their adiposity status.
Body composition is the percentage of fat and non-fat mass present in your body.
Body that has a desirable lower percentage of body fat is referred as healthy body
composition and a higher percentage of non-fat mass includes organs, muscles and
bones. There are many approaches to assess body composition like densitometry,
ultrasound, bioelectric impedance, anthropometry, CAT scanning, etc. As the name
suggests some of the methods are invasive, expensive and time consuming, whereas
anthropometry is non-invasive, affordable and subject friendly.
Anthropometric measurements and indices are also used such as weight, height,
skinfold thickness, diameter, length and circumference that involves mathematical
components. All these indices are the main components in estimating body segments
(Lee et al. 2015).
Body composition and growth are the key aspects of health in populations. These
factors can be assessed by measuring the fat percentage and the muscle mass. Skin
fold thickness methods have been used to determine the subcutaneous fat. As
mentioned briefly earlier, our body is mainly composed of two types of fat: Body
fat, and Non-fat mass.
Body fat is found in muscle tissue, under the subcutaneous fat deposit or skin, and
are also present around the visceral fat i.e., organs. These are the essential fats
that helps protect body’s internal organs, stores energy that act as fuel and also
normalizes body hormones which are important for our body. Whereas, Non-fat
mass areas (also called as lean tissues) include muscle, organs, tissues, water and
49
Field Work Manual bone. These tissues are metabolically active as they help burn calories while body
fat cannot do that.
Body fat percentage is used to estimate the total body fat on the basis of specific
measurements and there are several ways to estimate it such as bio-electric impedance
and Skinfold measurements. A skinfold caliper is used for the determination of skinfold
thickness through which a prediction can be made of total body fat mass.
Four skinfolds are generally used for determining total body fat:
Biceps Skinfold- It measures the maximum circumference of the upper arm when
the biceps muscle is fully contracted with elbow flexed.
Instrument: Flexible Steel Tape
Method: The subject is asked to position the hand as shown in picture. The tape
is wrapped around the contracted upper arm taking care that it remains at right
angles to the long axis of the upper arm. The tape should be wrapped horizontally
around middle of the upper arm where the bicep muscles are most developed, and
reading is recorded.
Precautions
The arms should be hanging loosely and freely at the side of the subject.
The caliper should be placed parallel to the mid-circumference line.
While taking the measurement the pressure of the caliper should be released
slowly.
The reading should be taken in 4 seconds and the reading recorded to the
nearest 4> millimeter
Subscapular skinfold – It is measured as the fold inferior to the inferior angle of
scapula, at natural cleavage. The subscapular skinfold is lifted at 45 degrees to the
horizontal plane.
Instrument: Skinfold caliper
51
Field Work Manual Method: The subject stands erect with shoulders relaxed so that the upper extremity
is hanging loosely. Standing behind the subject, palpate the vertebral border of the
scapula with fingertip running down laterally until the inferior angle is identified. If
the subject is obese, the subject is asked to fold her hand at the back, this way it
it is easier to pick the fold. The subscapular skinfold thickness is measured below
the inferior angle of the scapula. Using thumb and index finger, skin fold lightly
below the most inferior angle of the right scapula is picked. The skinfold usually is
slightly inclined’ pointing downward and laterally in the natural cleavage of the skin.
The jaws of the calipers are held at the marked level and note the reading.
There are some specific cut-off values which are used for the screening purposes
in the community-based interventions for SAM and MAM using MUAC
Bioelectric Impedance
This approach is used in the measurement of body composition and in the assessments
of healthcare system. The fundamental principles and the wide variety of methods
in case of bioelectric impedance are used to interpret the obtained information. A
large spectrum of utilisation of bio-impedance is in healthcare system and facilities
such as prediction of disease and the monitoring and keeping the status of all your
body vitals. Biological tissues possess electrical properties which are categorised
on the basis of electricity source which are:
Active response - In case of bio-electricity, active response occurs when
the biological tissue aggravates the electricity from ionic activities inside 53
Field Work Manual the cells in the form of ECG i.e., electrocardiograph signal from the heart
and EEG i.e.; Electroencephalograph signals from the brain.
Passive response - It arises when the simulation of biological tissues starts
through an external source of electric current.
The biological impedance and the bioimpedance is the ability of a biological tissue
to obstruct the electric current. Number of studies have been conducted on the
analysis of bio impedance and related to its applications in assessing the composition
of body and estimating the clinical conditions. This is due to its intrusiveness, the
low cost and portability of bioimpedance analysis. The bioimpedance is measured
from the entire body and its segments individually through the use of single and
multiple frequencies, and analysis of bioimpedance spectrograph.
Application of Bioimpedance Analysis
Let’s have a look at significance of bioimpedance analysis. In healthcare facilities,
bioimpedance helps in estimating the body sections to evaluate and monitor the
consistent changes in nutritional status in in-patients and also observing the risk related
to their nutritional status in out-patients. Various techniques such as BMI, skin fold
and weight measurement in water are used for assessing the body composition. All
these methods are used to estimate the fat mass and fat free mass, thus bioimpedance
analysis can predict the total number of body fluids that is considered very useful
for the prognosis of diseases/illnesses (Khalil et al. 2014).
NUTRITIONAL ASSESSMENT
In the above section, you learned majorly about nutritional assessment using the
somatometry approach. This section discusses about the different methods of
evaluating the nutritional status using dietary patterns and anthropometric indices.
Nutrition is considered as an important concept for preventive healthcare. An ideal
nutrition level is the amount of food intake that promotes a good health. The
nutritional level of individuals is interrelated to the status of diseases/illnesses and
health. However, the calorie intake in excess amount leads to obesity whereas a
small intake of calories results in the decrease of essential nutrients. All these changes
results in biochemical alterations and eventually to clinical signs and symptoms. The
requirements of nutritional intake are influenced by number of factors such as age,
gender, physical activity, drugs, physiological status and alcohol consumption.
Nutritional status is considered as the main and important health indicator to determine
individual’s health.
The main and the direct causes of malnutrition are:
poor consumption of food and
regular attack of diseases and infections, thus low defense system.
There are various indirect causes of malnutrition as well, they are:
Low production
Lack of awareness
Less power of purchasing
54
Poor sanitation and personal hygiene Somatometry
Anthropometric Indices
Anthropometry that we discussed earlier, originates from two words: Anthropo means
human and metry means measurement. Anthropometric measurements are used to
assess the nutritional status in community by recording growth or changes in the
composition of body. All methods are useful, however, no single method provides
a comprehensive view about the nutritional status of the population and thus, it
sometimes becomes important to use a mixture of methods. At the time of using
combination of approaches, one should always keep in mind the objectives and
accessibility of resources (Omage and Omeuemu, 1890-1897).
Anthropometry is an effective, non-invasive and quite inexpensive method that is
available to determine the body size, proportions and human body composition.
The most important and utilised measurements are:
Height/Weight
55
Field Work Manual Weight
Mid Upper Arm Circumference (MUAC)
Head Circumference
Chest Circumference
Waist circumference
Most of the measurements have been discussed in the above section. Go through
the section carefully for Height/stature, weight, circumferences at mid upper arm
and waist. In this section we will learn about Head and Chest circumference.
Head Circumference – It is the maximum circumference of the head taken just
above brow ridges. It is the measurement of head along with the supra orbital ridges
i.e., the forehead anteriorly and occipital prominence posteriorly. Occipital prominence
is the bulging and protruding part on the back part of the human head that you
must have noticed.
Instrument used: Flexible steel tape
Method: The subject sits down and the tape is placed around the head above
brow ridges and adjusted on the back of the head such that maximum circumference
is recorded.
In case of assessing the chronic problems related to nutritional status in children
below than 2 years of age, head circumference measurement is helpful because brain
grows faster during the initial 2 years of life. But after completing 2 years, the brain’s
growth becomes more inactive and at that time Head Circumference is not found
to be useful.
Precautions
Measurement tape should not be too loose or too tight
Keep the head straight.
Tape should be kept horizontal
Chest Circumference (CC) – It is the circumference of the chest measured at
the level of union of third and fourth sternebrae. The measurement should be taken
at the end of normal expiration
Instrument used: Flexible steel tape
Method: The subject should stand erect with tape running around the landmark
mentioned above. Care is taken to keep the tape horizontal.
Measuring chest circumference is of great value for determining growth in the 2nd
and 3rd years of life.
Precautions
Measurement tape should not be too loose or too tight
Tape should be kept horizontal
This table represents whether the child is undernourished or malnourished. All these
anthropometric indicators are used for the assessment of nutritional status, to
determine the involvement or to enroll children to an involvement program i.e., the
treatment package and then to discharge them from a program. If you got to know
the trick to use all the indicators then, planning an effective intervention will be easy.
Similarly, table below illustrates the use of indicators for individuals and children
who are underweight, or suffering from wasting and malnutrition on the basis of
weight and height of children relative to their age.
If an adult is having BMI < 16 Kg/m2, then he/she cannot perform a vigorous physical
activity or exercise because of their low energy storage. Moreover, they will be
more prone or susceptible to infections/diseases due to their low immunity.
Dietary Methods
It is important to identify the energy and nutrient requirement by studying the changes
in body growth and maturation. Nutrition and the dietary practices pose a major
influence on the development of an individual from infancy to old age. As we all
know, a sufficient amount of food intake and nutrient (i.e., the basic nutrients such
as proteins, fats, vitamins, carbohydrates, and minerals) is important for a normal
growth (American Dietetic Association 2005). Taking inadequate and improper
nutrition at any phase of life affects the body adversely. Because of not having sufficient
57
Field Work Manual diet, various communities are suffering from several diseases – over nutrition in adults
(majorly in old aged individuals), and under-nutrition in infants, children, and in women.
Anthropometric assessment is one of the most common approach to determine the
nutritional status of a population because of its ease in comparison to other methods,
reproducibility, and obtainability of standards on the basis of normal population for
the purpose of comparison and forming association between clinical illnesses and
abnormal measurements.
Genetic and environmental factors involving the dietary intake influences the height.
Stunting reflects the cumulative impact of under nutrition in the past.
To assess the dietary methods for determining the nutritional status, one should always
include the analysis of past or current food intakes, or the nutrient consumption by
an individual or a group of population. A questionnaire is prepared in which you
can ask about the family, (mother or the child) members dietary history like what
have eaten over the past 24 hours. Then, after recording all the data, calculate the
dietary diversity score (Kapoor et al. 2012; Popkin 2002; WHO 1966).
Dietary Diversity- It is measured by the number of food groups which are
consumed over a period of 24 hours i.e., reference period. Usually, there are six
type of food groups which are required by our body on a daily basis.
Requirement of Nutrients at Different Stages of Life
It is very important to consume healthy food at every stage of life. Most importantly,
a pregnant woman should have a good nutritional intake that helps both: the mother
and the fetus. The adequate supply of nutrients ensure that the baby grow well in
infancy time and after that as well. At the time of pregnancy, a women’s requirements
for certain nutrients increases in comparison to other and lack of those nutrients in
her diet results in the low body weight. In the 2nd and 3rd trimester, pregnant ladies
must have a good intake of calories and nutrients (WHO 2010).
Dietary History
The data about the history of dietary practices can be collected from individual/or
families depending on their requirements. This method is of prime importance as
nutritionists have reported that nutrition plays a vital role in the incidence of obesity,
heart diseases and diabetes. Dietary surveys, are used in estimating the population
and assessments of an individual, which is defined as the planned and a systematic
study of the dietary consumption of individuals/population or communities. The methods
can be both quantitative and qualitative.
The qualitative method includes the use of the food pyramid as discussed above to
predict the requirements of food and its serving and intake, whereas the quantitative
method evaluates the amount of energy and particular nutrients required for each
food by using the tables of food consumptions. These kinds of surveys are increasing
in the nutritional epidemiology areas, clinical assessment, and population surveillance.
Surveys are quite advantageous such as they are not that expensive, comparatively
easy and objective.
Types of dietary surveys
Twenty-four-hour recall
Weight intake
58
Food frequency questionnaire Somatometry
Food diary
Dietary history
Twenty-Four-Hour Recall: In this method, all the food articles are recorded which
are consumed during the 24 hours and is used in wide scale nutritional surveys.
This method involves the interview or questionnaire where the participant is asked
to recall and is required to describe his/her food consumption in detail during the
last twenty-four hours.
One of the most widely preferred participant for this method is housewife because
she generally knows everything about the dietary practices of her family members.
The investigator questions her to remember the type and amount of food intake,
how the food is prepared and in what proportion the food is getting distributed to
family members. Some of the measuring cylinders in the kitchen such as glasses,
cups, spoons and bowls are used to help the participants in recalling the details.
This method has various advantages which are:
Inexpensive
Quick and easy
Depends on short-term memory
The 24-hour recall method should be repeated two to three times where the individual
who is being interviewed may be telling the truth is definite or not.
Weighed Intake Method: This method requires the involvement of investigator,
when the subject is consuming food and the amounts of food are weighed before,
during and after serving. The amount of food is also measured that is not eaten by
the subject i.e., left-over food. Then the difference is calculated between the amounts
of food that is served and not consumed that gives the amount of food that is actually
consumed by the individual. One of the advantages of this method is its intensiveness
whereas the disadvantage is that it is time consuming.
Food Frequency Questionnaire: This method is used to collect information about
the long-term dietary practices. Individual is allowed to complete the questionnaire
by themselves and then the filled form is sent to the investigator. In India, it is generally
advisable to fill all the questions by the investigator by interviewing the subjects
where the subject is asked about how often he/she consumes special food items.
The responses are standardized so that the subject is only required to tick mark
the correct answer. The frequency of eating food items is generally calculated as
week/fortnight/month. The list of food should not exceed 150 items. The main merit
of this approach is that this method is quick and inexpensive and also involves the
coverage of more respondents.
Food Diary : Food diary is required to keep the records in a documented form
about the dietary practices such as what all food and beverages are being consumed
by the subject over a certain period of time. A time period of about 1 week can
be used in the diary to predict the dietary intake. The method is reliable as sufficient
number of days is covered by each subject. The subjects also take interest in filling
up the diary.
59
Field Work Manual The main disadvantage is that individuals are sometimes not able to estimate the
quantity of food consumed accurately. The subject concerned can also be illiterate.
Moreover, diary making can be a cumbersome process.
Dietary History : In this, the dietary practices are recorded of the participants over
a longer period of time. The investigator obtains a retrospective estimate of the food
intake using this method. The time duration covered is 3 months to one year. The
information is recorded either through interviews and/or questionnaires addressed to
the subject. This method is not used in large scale epidemiological surveys.
Separation of Plasma
Material Required: Micropipette (1ml and 100 microliter), micropipette tips (1ml
and 100 microliter)
Plasma is a cell free supernatant formed after the centrifugation of anticoagulated
blood (anticoagulant is a substance that prevent the clotting of the blood). The blood
sample collected is centrifuged in centrifuge at 1000 revolutions per minute (rpm)
at room temperature. The supernatants formed in the 10 tubes are removed with a
micropipette tip and dispensed into the labelled 5 ml falcon tube for usage in reverse
blood grouping.
62
Non-agricultural
Production
Details A1 A2 B O D1 D2 C c E e M N S s
Antisera 100µl 100µl 100µl 100µl 100µl 100µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl
3%RBC 100µl 100µl 100µl 100µl 100µl 100µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl
Rh(D)+
Antigens Fisher Weiner &
& Race Wexler
D C c E e Results
+ + 0 0 + DCe/DCe R1R1
+ 0 + + 0 DcE/DcE R2R2
+ 0 + 0 + Dce/dce R0r
+ + 0 + 0 DCE/DCE RzRz
+ + + 0 + DCe/dce R1r
+ 0 + + + DcE/dce R2r
+ + 0 + + DCe/DCE R1Rz
+ + + + 0 DcE/DCE R2Rz
+ + + + + DCe/DcE R1R2
Rh(D)-
0 + 0 0 + dCe/dCe r’r’
0 0 + + 0 dcE/dcE r” r”
0 0 + 0 + dcc/dce rr
0 + 0 + 0 dCE/dCE ryry
0 + + 0 + dCe/dce r’r
0 0 + + + dcE/dce r”r
0 + 0 + + dCe/dCE r’ry
0 + + + 0 dcE/dCE r”ry
0 + + + + dCe/dcE r’ r”
65
Production and
Commercial Practices Table 2c: Interpretation of MNSs blood group results following NIJ, USA
manual
+ + + + MNSs
+ + + ------- MNS
+ - + - MS
+ - + + MSs
+ - - + Ms
+ + - + MNs
- + + - NS
- + + + NSs
- + - + Ns
Details A1 A2 B O D1 D2 C c E E M N S s
Serum 100µl 100µl 100µl 100µl 100µl 100µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl
Reagent 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl 50µl
cells
66
Non-agricultural
Production
Fig. 13 : Grading of agglutination in A1, A2, B & O blood group as per NIB manual
Grades in agglutination: 4+: 1 big clump; 3+: 1 or 2 clumps; 2+: small clumps with
clear supernatant;1+: small clumps with turbid supernatant; 0: smooth suspension
and H: haemolysis (NIB, Guidance manual, 2013)
1.3.1.3 DERMATOGLYPHICS
INTRODUCTION
Dermatoglyphics is the study of the epidermal ridge patterns of the skin of the fingers,
palms, toes and soles. Dermatoglyphics is derived from two Greek words (‘Derma’
means skin and ‘Glyphe’ means carve). The term Dermatoglyphics was first coined
by Cummins and Midlo in the year 1926. Dermatoglyphics is considered to be one
of the important as well as interesting branches of highly developed science and
technology. Every individual possesses distinct features of ridges and their pattern
in fingers, palms and soles.
The ridge patterns are stable throughout life and are not modified by environmental
factors. The patterns are unique to each individual. Because of these qualities it
plays a very important role in the personal identification, crime detection, twin
diagnosis, racial variation and have applied values in various diseases and syndromes.
Further these features are not affected by any kind of diet or infection and thus
free from any external influences because their formation is determined not only by
genetics but also by environmental factors. They are of considerable interest as a
means of identification. The ridge configuration present on the palm is called Palmar
Dermatoglyphics and the ridge configuration present on the fingers is called Finger
Dermatoglyphics. The epidermal ridges form definite local design on the terminal
segment (phalanges) of digits and also on the palm and toes.
67
Field Work Manual FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES OF FINGERPRINTS
Primarily, it involves the study of patterns present on different region of the fingers,
palms, soles and toes but it has traditionally been the most important aspect of
dermatoglyphics analyses. The primary features of classification system are worked
out during late 19th century but were integrated into unified systems by Cummins
and Midol from different pioneering work done in the field which has come to know
the following fundamental biological principles of finger prints.
1. Epidermal ridges are very highly variable in all the individuals that this
characteristic even in small region of palm, finger or sole are not duplicated
either in another region or in different persons.
3. The several configuration types among the individuals are within limits, which
follows for systematic characters.
4. Fingerprints are impression of frictional ridge present and the actual phalanges
of finger and thumb. A fingerprint impression thus obtained is a reverse of
the actual pattern on the skin surface. It is very true that each fingerprint
is different from the other. Yet it is true that all finger print having common
characteristics among themselves, which make classification possible. The
common character that makes up the pattern is pattern type, type line, delta
and core.
The characteristics of Fingerprints are given below.
A) Pattern Area
It is the part of the loop or whorl which appears in the core, deltas, and ridges
that we are concerned with classifying. It is present in all patterns of course
but in most arches it is indefinable. Type lines enclose the pattern area of loops
and whorls.
B) Type Lines
Type lines are ridges that determine the pattern area of the loop and whorls.
The arch lacks presence of type line. These lines may be defined as two inner
most ridges, which start parallel, diverge and surround the pattern area. Type
lines are not always two continuous ridges in fact, they are more often found
to be broken. It is important to know the distinction between divergence and
bifurcation. A bifurcation is the dividing or working of a single ridge into two
or more branches while a divergence is the spreading partly of two ridges in
different direction which had been running parallel or nearly with in the pattern
areas of loops and whorls are enclosed the focal points which are important
for identification and classification of the pattern. These points are learned as
Delta (Triradius) and core.
C) Delta/ Triradius
The word Delta is the fourth letter of the Greek alphabet and corresponds to
the English letter D. As this Greek Letter is triangular in shape hence it is applied
68
to fingerprint pattern. There is great resemblance between the delta in Geography Dermatoglyphics
D) Core
Core is the central point of the pattern. The type of core varies according to
the type of pattern. In loop pattern they may consist of stable or an even or
uneven number of ridges not joined together which we are called as ‘rods’.
The core is placed upon the innermost sufficient recurve core which is absent
in arches. In core of whorl pattern, the centre of first ring, elliptical or circular
is taken as core point. In case of spiral, the point from which the spiral begins
to revolve is taken as core point. The core is considered very important because
it is the landmark for ridge counting by the connection of triradius in a straight
line.
CLASSIFICATION OF FINGERPRINTS
Fig. 14 : Fingertip patterns representing (A) arch pattern with neither a core nor a delta
point, (B) ‘loop’ pattern containing one core and one delta point (C) ‘whorl’ pattern with one
core and two delta points
Source: Holt SB. Br Med Bull 1961;17:247-50
These three basic types are subdivided into nine subtypes for the purpose of
classification:
69
Field Work Manual Arch
Plain Arch
Tented Arch
Loop
Radial Loop
Ulnar Loop
Whorl
Plain/True Whorl
Composite
Central Pocket Loop
Lateral Pocket Loop
Twin Loop
Accidentals
Arch
An arch is the simplest pattern referred to as pattern of less configuration. They
are characterised by slight rise (elevation) in the ridges, which enter on one side of
finger print pattern and exit on the opposite side. The Arch is of two subtypes:
Plain Arch (A)
It is simple of all the fingerprint patterns. The plain arch ridges enter on one side of
the impression and flow or tend to flow out on the other side with a slight rise or
wave in centre. It has no Triradius and core.
Tented Arch (T)
It is the one in which most of the ridges enter on one side and flow upon the other
side making the sufficient recurve. Tented arch appears to have triradius near the
mid axis of the finger towards the proximal end. The erect radiant is associated
with abrupt elevation of transversely coursing ridges forming the “tent” which give
the name to pattern.
It is one of the most common patterns found in fingerprint. A Loop is the type of
fingerprint pattern in which one or more ridge enter on either side of the impression,
recurve, touch or pass on imaginary lines drawn from delta to core terminate or
lend to terminate towards the same side where such ridge entered. It has only one
delta. Loops are subdivided into two main types:
Radial Loop (RL)
It is so called because ridge flow or terminate in the direction of radius bone of
forearm. In case of right hand finger, ridges slant toward left and in left hand finger,
the slant is toward right side.
Ulnar Loop (UL)
It is so called because the ridges flow or terminate in the direction of ulna bone of
the forearm. In case of right hand finger, the ridges slant toward right side and for
left hand finger, ridges slant towards left side.
Whorl (W)
A whorl is characterized by a circular pattern having one or more ridges revolve around
the core making a complete circle, at least two deltas are present with in a recurve
in front of each whorl type. It is the most complex of all the three types. According
to Henry there are two kinds of whorl i.e. true whorl & composite whorl.
Plain/True Whorl
True whorl possesses two triradius and at least one ridge making a complete circuit
which may be spiral, oval, circular or any variant of the circle. A frequent configuration
is a succession of rings or eclipse. If this ring happens to be concentric then such a
whorl is called as whorl concentric circle. Another common arrangement is spiral
course around the core which is either clockwise or anticlockwise directions. This
pattern is called spiral whorl when the ridges form one spiral around the core, it is
called single spiral. If there are two spirals distinct in nature with two different cores,
it is called as whorl double spiral.
Composite Pattern
Composite patterns are compound pattern in which two or more designs each
conforming to general aspect of one of the simpler types combined in pattern area.
Two or more triradius are present. There are four main type of composite recognized:
Central Pocket Loop
Central pocket loop is a composite pattern in which most of the ridges take the
form of a loop. It is essentially a whorl of reduced size lying in the interior of pattern
area, which is constructed mainly as a loop, the central pocket loop has two deltas.
It is a pattern intermediate between a whorl and pure loop.
Lateral Pocket Loop
In a lateral pocket loop, one loop serves as a side pocket to two other pocket to
another loop. The pocket is formed by downward bending on one side of ridge of
71
Field Work Manual other loop before they recurve. The ridges about the centre, the lines containing
the point of core of loops have their exit on same side of delta.
Twin Loop
In a twin loop there are two distinct loops, one resting upon or encircling the other
and the ridges containing the point of core have their exit toward different deltas.
According to United States Federal Bureau of Investigation expert, the lateral pocket
loop and twinned loop should be consolidated under double loop pattern because
of the complexity involved in locating and tracing the loops.
Accidentals
Accidentals are certain composite patterns within the whorl group that occur rarely
and formulated purely by chance. The Accidental whorl is a pattern consisting of
combination of two different types of patterns excepting plain arch possessing two
or more delta formation like whorl and loop, tented arch and loop triple, loops
and other bizarre configuration not original to the standard type.
PALMAR DERMATOGLYPHICS
In palm, there are six elevated areas of varying prominence. These are thenar,
hypothenar and four interdigital areas namely I, II, III and IV (Figure 3.4). The
thenar eminence occupies a large area of the base of the thumb and the hypothenar
eminence lies opposite to thenar area and is present in the ulnar portion of the palm.
Generally speaking, there are four triradii normally located at the base of digits II,
III, IV and V and called a,b,c, and d. A triradius is a meeting point of three opposing
systems. Ideally, it subtends three angles of 120Ú. In practice, the angles may range
from 90Ú to 180Ú as limiting values.
72
Dermatoglyphics
The margin of the palmar area is divided into 14 points and intervals. The number
sequence begins with the proximal part of the thenar eminence. On the radial side
of the axial triradius and at the base of the thumb, number 1 is given; this area
continues around the proximal, ulnar, distal and radial borders of the palm. Number
2 position is allotted to axial triradius which is a point. The approximate midpoint
of the ulnar margin is designated as 4; the digital areas are represented by 6,8,10
and 12. The interval between the points 4 and 6 is numbered 5, which is further
divided into 5’ which is the proximal half, and 5’’ which is the distal half. Here the
rule is that, each of the marginal areas of the palm are numbered following the principle
that points are given even numbers, 2, 4,6, 8,10 and 12 beginning as mentioned
above from the base of the palm behind the thumb (No.1), moving from ulnar to
radial side, and odd numbers 1,3,5,7,9,11 and 13 are given to intermediate areas
as shown in Figure 3.5. It is the radiants of the triradius that traces the lines in the
form of loops and whorls which are called as the Type line. One can identify the
pattern on the basis of these lines. The longest radiant of digital triradius is the main
line, hence the designation of main lines as D, C, B, A and T lines (Figure 3.5).
73
Field Work Manual
Pattern Intensity Index: The Pattern Intensity Index on fingers or toes is an estimation
of triradii per finger or toe. It is to be noted that a whorl consists of two triradii, a
loop has one, and arch has none. “The value of pattern intensity may be stated
either as the number triradii per individual or as the average number of triradii per
finger”. The number of triradii is approximated by adding the frequency of loops
to twice the frequency of whorls, the total being divided by the number of individuals
when the frequencies are in absolute numbers, or by ten for percent frequencies.”
(Cummins and Midlo, (1962).
Material used: Magnifying Glass; Inking Plate (Metal or ¼” Glass) 6" wide x 14"
long; Card Holder; Hardwood stand 2’ length x 1’ height and width; Cleaning Fluid
or CreamPaper Towels; RollerInking Plate Cleanser; Printer Ink/Stamp Pad Ink
(heavy black paste),Note: Printing ink or ordinary ink or any other coloured inks
are not advisedfor fingerprinting work. The reason being they are too light, thin
and do not dry quickly.
Finger Print Method
a) Clean the hand of the participant and dry with clean towel.
74
b) Smear the ink over the fingers. Dermatoglyphics
c) Hold the terminal knuckle of the finger and roll it from radial to ulnar side. The
thumb should be rolled from the opposite side.
d) The ideal finger prints should be square in shape. The triradii should be visible
in the print. One triradius for loop, two triradius for whorl and three triradius
on a super whorl.
Palmar Print Method
a) Hold the wrist of the participant and place the hand on the inked slab
uniformly.
b) Lift it up slowly from the ulnar end of the palm.
c) Place the palm on the paper.
d) Press the interdigital areas and hollow in the centre of the palm.
e) Remove the palm from the paper slowly without any jerk pressing the centre
of the palm.
f) Roll the palm on the ulnar end.
g) Take care that there is uniformity in the print including that of the hollow in the
centre and ulnar end of the palm
How did the methods you select help you find and interpret material?
Did those problems tell you something about the phenomenon you studied, or
about your methods?
Provide examples of data you gathered that are relevant to your argument. Make
sure you collect enough ethnographic data to be able to argue your thesis.
Is the example representative of what you studied or is it rather unusual?
Does it fit a pattern? Or does it break a pattern?
77
Production and You can paraphrase or directly quote the interviewees. Where you have multiple
Commercial Practices
people who said similar things, do not repeat what they said. You should group
them together and either paraphrase their overall sentiments, or use a direct quote
from one of them that is representative of the rest. This should be both descriptive
and interpretive. In other words, you want to report what people say, and why
they say it. If you have other kind of data, people’s personal histories, economic
status, age, etc., that you think contribute to why they expressed a certain opinion
or idea, you can use it.
Analysis is the process of isolating the constituent parts of a configuration; collected
data is identified from the field notes and arranged in a systematic way. What
information must be put first, what information to be put next, and what information
must be put finally will be judged by the investigator. The data thus arranged becomes
meaningful when considered in totality. This totality is the configuration. Each part
this configuration may usually appear as a chapter in the write-up or report prepared
by the researcher.
Each part deals with a specific aspect of the problem. If the total picture gained
after going through the report is considered as a configuration, what has been gained
by going through every chapter is a constituent part of the configuration. To put it
in another way, the researcher isolates the constituent parts of the totality and presents
them in a meaningful manner. It is a very important step and should be carried out
properly.
Data analysis needs thorough concentration as you need to make proper notes,
assign codes and transfer the raw data into a sheet on which various statistical
techniques can be applied. The information obtained through personal notes,
interviews and case studies can also be utilised in providing supporting evidence
in the report.
Once the data has been analysed, you can proceed to the stage of interpreting
the results. Like any science, the discipline of anthropology does more than simply
describe specific cultures. Interpreting data, perhaps the most difficult step, involves
explaining the findings. The process of interpreting is essentially one of stating
what the results show. It is not a routine and mechanical process, but calls for a
careful, logical and critical examination of the results obtained after analysis, keeping
in view the limitations of the sample chosen, and the tools selected and used in
the study.
There is always an element of subjectivity, which should be reduced to the minimum
by the researcher while interpreting the results. In the light of interpretation of results,
you have to use great care and caution in formulating the conclusions and
generalisations. These finals steps in the research work demand critical and logical
thinking in summarising the findings of the study and comparing them with the objectives
and hypothesis formulated (if any) in the beginning. The generalisations drawn on
the basis of research findings should be in agreement with facts and should not conflict
with the known laws of nature.
Your writing should be clear and logically consistent.
Having read a lot on your topic you may think that much of the ideas, arguments,
issues and terms are obvious; it is essential to assume that your reader does not
78
know much about the topic. This means instead of assuming something about your Non-agricultural
Production
topic from common knowledge,you should explain:
what activities are carried by people,
who the people are, and
how it all fits together.
The presentation of the project should be logical and concise, making use of simple
common words and sentence structure. The language should be formal and
straightforward, avoiding colloquialism or slang. The personal pronouns I, we, you,
my, our and us should not be used. Their use should be avoided by the use of
such expression as ‘the researcher’ or ‘the investigator’. The use of abbreviations
should be avoided in the main text of the project report.
The writing process often takes more time than most people think. So, do not
leave the writing until the last few weeks before the submission deadline; instead
start writing as soon as possible. It is not necessary to start writing from chapter
one. You can begin writing in the middle of a chapter too. Start where your
evidence is strongest and your ideas are clear. Prepare an outline of what each
chapter of your dissertation will include. This will assist you to plan and organise
the writing process. It will also enable you to estimate how long each chapter
will take to write, what areas need more work, which information needs to go
where.
Break up large amounts of text with headings and subheadings. The more signposts
the reader is given, the easier the dissertation will be to navigate and understand.
The chapter scheme of the report should be outlined and the purpose of each chapter
is to be stated. Chapter plan or chapterisation will give a tentative plan for writing
the report. This exercise will help in completing the dissertation smoothly and in a
systematic way. The length of each chapter should be more or less the same.
Each chapter will bear:
Chapter number
Chapter title
Introduction
Main titles, sub-titles, sub-sub titles
Conclusion
Graphics/illustrations etc
Well presented with proper layout
Do not fill up chapters with unnecessary tables
It is not necessary that every chapter should have tables
Choose only the most important areas for presentation in tabular form
Rest of the findings can be given in a narrative form
79
Production and A project report is an outcome of a research work, so while presenting it due care
Commercial Practices
should be taken to systematically arrange the contents of the fieldwork. The following
structure is recommended:
Title of the Dissertation
Table of Contents
List of Tables and Photographs or Figures
Acknowledgements
Introduction
Literature Review
Study Area and People
Materials and Methods
Data Analysis and Results (to be presented in chapters or sections or
paragraphs)
Discussion and Conclusion
References
When the same author has more than one work referred in a single year
... is discussed by many workers (Bindon 1994; Bindon and Crews 1993;
Simons et al. 2011)
List those references that are actually cited in the project report and not the ones
which you consulted but did not cite. Author’s name must be included in every
reference, even if there are multiple publications by the same author or authors.
The list of references must be in alphabetical order of the authors’ name and multiple
sources by the same author or authors should be arranged chronologically. More
than one publication by the same author in the same year must be designated a, b,
etc. in the order they are encountered in the text and listed in the references in the
same order.
Now in the ‘References cited’ section the following format should be followed for
clarity and uniformity:
Journal articles
Bindon, J.R. 1994. Some implications of the diet of children in American Samoa.
Collegium Anthropologicum, 18:7-15.
Bindon, J.R., and Crews, DE. 1993. Changes in some health status characteristics
of American Samoan men: A 12 year follow up study. American Journal of Human
Biology, 5:31-38.
Bindon, J.R., Crews, D.E and Dressler, W.W. 1991. Lifestyle, modernization, and
adaptation among Samoans. Collegium Anthropologicum, 15:101-110.
1.3.4 SUMMARY
Anthropologists conduct their research first-hand by means of direct fieldwork. How
anthropologists actually do their fieldwork is discussed in this manual. A number of
preparations must be made before any fieldwork is begun. Although every fieldwork
project in anthropology has its own unique character, all projects go through the
same basic stages:
1. selecting a research problem,
2. formulating a research design,
3. collecting the data,
4. analysing the data, and
5. interpreting the data.
82
Because no two fieldwork experiences are identical, it is important that anthropologists Non-agricultural
Production
match the appropriate data-gathering techniques to their own fieldwork situations.
During fieldwork the following methods, tools and techniques are used:
ethnographic method,
participant observation,
interviewing,
genealogies, and
case studies.
1.3.5 REFERENCES
Anil Kumar, K. 2012. Fieldwork manual, fieldwork and dissertation (MANP-
001). Indira Gandhi National Open University, New Delhi.
Bhasin, M.K., & Chahal, S.M.S. 1996. A laboratory manual for human blood
analysis. Delhi: Kamla-Raj Enterprises.
Cummins, H., & Midlo, C. 1962. Finger prints, palms and soles: An introduction
to dermatoglyphics. New York: Dover Publications Incorp.
Dooley, D. 1995. Social science research methods (3rd ed.). Englewood Cliff, New
Jersey: Prentice-Hall.
Fontela, P.C., Winkelmann, E.R., Viecili, P.B. 2017. ‘Conicity index: An anthropometric
measure to be evaluated’. Cardiologia, 36(5), 365-366.
https://www.discoveranthropology.org.uk/about-anthropology/fieldwork.html (accessed
on September 09, 2020).
Joshi, P.C. 2015. People of India. Symposium on People of India, by P.C. Joshi
(Ed.). Department of Anthropology, University of Delhi.
Kapoor, S., Verma, D., Bhasin, P., & Dhall, M. 2012. ‘Skinfolds as prognosticators
of nutritional status among adult undernourished males of India’. International Journal
of Sociology and Anthropology. 4(9), 257-265.
Khalil, S., Mohktar, M., & Ibrahim, F. 2014. ‘The theory and fundamentals of
bioimpedance analysis in clinical status monitoring and diagnosis of diseases’. Sensors,
14(6), 10895–10928. https://doi.org/10.3390/s140610895
83
Production and Krishnan-Kutty, G. 1986 . Peasantry in India. 18 Abhinav Publications, New Delhi.
Commercial Practices
Lamba, D.S., Kaur, R., & Basu, S. 2013. ‘Clinically significant minor blood group
antigens amongst North Indian donor population’. Advances in Hematology. https://
doi.org/10.1155/2013/215454
Lee, Y., Kwon, O., Shin, C.S., & Lee, S.M. 2015. ‘Use of bioelectric impedance
analysis for the assessment of nutritional status in critically ill patients’. Clin Nutr Res.
4(1), 32-40.
Mead, M. 1964 . Anthropology: A human science. New York: D. Van Nostrand
Co., Inc.
Miller, B.D. 2012 . Cultural anthropology (7th ed.). Pearson.
Mitra, R., Mishra, N., & Rath, G.P. 2014. ‘Blood group systems’. Indian J Anaesth,
58:524-528.
Mukherji, D., Mukherjee, D.P., & Bharathi, P. 2009. Laboratory manual for
biological anthropology. New Delhi: Asian Books Pvt Ltd.
Nath, S. 1996. Forensic anthropology. Delhi: Ashtam Prakashan.
Nelson, K . Doing Fieldwork: Methods in Cultural Anthropology. Inver Hills
Community College.
Popkin, B., Monteiro, C., & Swinburn, B. 2013. ‘Overview: Bellagio conference on
program and policy options for preventing obesity in the low- and middle -income
countries’. 14(1), 1-8. Department of Nutrition, North Carolina, USA. Retrieved from
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24102826/
Redfield, R. 1941. The folk culture of Yucatan. University of Chicago Press.
Rosnow, R.L., & Rosenthal, R. 1996. Beginning behavioral research. A conceptual
primer. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall.
Sanjek, R. 2000. ‘Keeping ethnography alive in an urbanizing world’. Human
Organisation 59(3): 280-88.
Shenoy & Jagdamba. 2017. ‘Influence of central obesity assessed by conicity index
on lung age in young adults’. J Clin Diagn Res. 11(4).
Srivastava, V.K. 2015 . Tribes in India. Symposium on People of India, by P.C. Joshi
(Ed.). Department of Anthropology, University of Delhi.
Uzogara, S.G. 2016. ‘Assessment of obesity, presumed and proven causes and
prevention strategies: A review’. Medcrave, 5(1), 199-217.
Wang, Youfa & Chen, Hsin-Jen. 2012. ‘Use of percentiles and Z-scores in
anthropometry.
strategies: A review’. Medcrave, 5(1), 199-217.
Welsch, R.L., & Vivanco, L.A. 2018. Asking questions about cultural anthropology:
A concise introduction., Higher Education Group, Oxford University press, USA.
World Health Organization Monograph Series No. 53. 1966. The Assessment of the
Nutritional Status of the Community. Geneva. World Health Organisation.
84
Guidelines for Writing
1.4 GUIDELINES FOR DISSERTATION Dissertation and Submission
SUBMISSION
Contents
1.4.1 Structure of the Dissertation
1.4.2 Format of the Dissertation and Submission
89
Field Work Manual Appendix I
(Signature)
Name of the Supervisor:
Date:
91
Field Work Manual Appendix III
Date: SignaturewithSeal:
92
Appendix IV Appendix
93
Field Work Manual Certificate of Originality
This is to certify that the dissertation titled”———————————————
————————————————————————————————
————————————————————————————————
———————————————————————————————’’
submitted to Indira Gandhi National Open University in partial fulfillment of there
quirement for the award of Bachelor of Science (Honours) in Anthropology
(BSCANH) is an original work carried out by Mr./Mrs./Ms.————————
————————————————————————
Enrollment Number:—————————————————
The contents of this dissertation are a genuine work done by the student and has
not been submitted whether to this University or to any other University/Institute
for the fulfillment of the requirement of any course of study.
94
Appendix V Appendix
FOR SUPERVISOR
Remuneration Bill for Guidance of Dissertation
To
The Registrar (SED) IGNOU, Maidan Garhi NewDelhi–110068
1. Programme Code: MAAN
2. Course Code: MANP001
3. Name of the Mentor——————————————————————
4. Residential Address———————————————————————
——————————————————————————————
5. Designation:—————————————————————————
6. Official Address:————————————————————————
——————————————————————————————
7. Telephone No.Office:——————————————————————
Mobile:———————————————————————————
Residence:——————————————————————————
Sl. No. Project Title:
Enrolment No.
Name of the Amount: Student
1
2
3
4
5
Certified that I have guided the above listed student(s) for the irresearch work.
Dated:———————————Signature of the Supervisor:———————
Note: The remuneration payable for guidance of Dissertation Work is Rs.300/-
perstudent.
Note: A Mentor can guide a maximum of 5 candidates Per Session.
Certified that the above supervisor was approved and recommended by the concerned
school of study and the aboveclaimmay be admitted.
Dy./Asst Registrar Section Officer Dealing Assistant
95
Field Work Manual Appendix VI
FOR EVALUATOR
Research Proposal/Synopsis Feedback Form
Name of the Candidate.........................................Enrolment No..................................
1. Topicof the Study:.........................................................................................
Suggestions to Improve the Topic..................................................................
2. Introduction/Background
Suggestions for Improvement.........................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
4. Review of Literature
6. Methodology
Suggestions for Improvement........................................................................
...................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
(Signature)
97