An Overview of Arc Welding Control Systems
An Overview of Arc Welding Control Systems
Abstract—In this paper an overview of arc welding control enable the bonding of the surfaces. An alternative is the so
systems is given. At first some basic physical background of called fusion welding, where the heat input must be intense
the process is given. Then the two most important subtypes enough to locally melt the two weldpieces. In the case of a
Gas tungsten arc welding (GTAW) and Gas metal arc welding
(GMAW) are presented in some detail. In order to understand surface heat source the minimum rate of energy release per
the logic of feedback control systems, the most essential control unit area P required to maintain a molten weld pool of radius
theory is outlined shortly. In the overview of control systems r is approximately [3]:
a feedback signal is used a means of division. The analysis of
recent research papers in the area has shown that recently image AkTm
P = (1)
processing based control systems seem to be the most popular r
ones. where k is thermal conductivity, Tm is melting temperature
Index Terms—arc welding, control, overview, GTAW, GMAW, and A is a factor dependent on welding speed, weld size and
TIG, MIG/MAG. thermal diffusivity. The weld pool size is of course limited
by practical considerations. The typical values are within 10-
I. I NTRODUCTION 20mm range, which for steels results in the required power
W
density of around 107 m 2 . As shown in Fig. 2 this is a typical
Vaporisation
or without the application of pressure, or by the application No welding possible
dominated
of pressure alone, with or without the use of additional filler 1013
Vaporisation
metal. A schematic overview of the better known welding 1012 conduction
Electron and melting
processes is shown in Fig. 1. Although there are some 40 or so 1011
beam
Power density [W/m2]
(keyholing)
1010
CO2 laser Radial
9
Welding Process
10 Plasma conduction
108 dominated
with
107 Arc processes welding
Resistance High Beam Solid State
Gas Welding Arc Welding
Welding Energy Welding Welding 6
10
No welding possible Negligible
105 melting
4
- Butt - Carbon arc - Friction 10
- Oxy-acetylene - Metal arc - Ultrasonic
- Spot - Plasma arc - Electron beam - Diffusion
- Air-acetylene - Explosive
- Seam - Gas Metal Arc - Laser - Magnetically
Fig. 2. Power density for various welding processes [3]
(MIG) impelled Arc
- Oxy-hydrogen
- Projection - Gas Tungsten Butt Welding
Arc (TIG) (MIAB)
- Cold Metal
- Induction Pressure
Welding (IPW)
is one of the reasons for its widespread usage.
Transfer (CMT) - Flash Butt welding
(FBW)
An arc (see Fig. 3) refers to strong electric fields that cause
- Magnetic Pulse -
Welding (MPW)
cold welding process
Gas plasma Protection nozzle
Fig. 1. An overview of welding processes [1] Electrode
Nozzle constriction
welding processes, only a few processes are really important
Electric arc
[2]. One of the most important ones, if not the most important
Shielding gas
one, is arc welding. The term arc welding refers to a broad
group of welding processes that employ an electric arc as the
source of heat to melt and join metals. It is believed that in
the entire metal fabrication industry, arc welding is the third Fig. 3. Arc plasma [1], [4]
largest group of processes behind assembly and machining in
metal fabrication industry [2]. gas to induce an electric breakdown and continuous discharge
From the historical perspective the first type of welding was of plasma [5]. Thus, the current passes through insulation
forge welding, where the weldpieces are first heated and then media in a manner similar to air. A typical arc welding setup
hammered or pressed together to remove slag and oxides and is shown in Fig. 4. The welding current can be DC or AC
and the electrode can be consumable or non-consumable. In
P. Podržaj is with the Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Uni-
versity of Ljubljana, Askerceva 6, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia e-mail: many cases the welding region is protected by a shielding
primoz.podrzaj@fs.uni-lj.si gas. A power source is also needed in order to get the voltage
Company Registration No.: 201427293E
7030 Ang Mo Kio Avenue 5#04-155
Northstar @ AMK Singapore (569880)
www.Whioce.com
electrode holder characterized by a much higher arc energy density and higher
electrode plasma gas velocity due to the arc plasma being forced through
a constricting nozzle [11].
arc
B. Gas metal arc welding
power
source weldpiece Gas metal arc welding (GMAW) (sometimes also referred to
by its subtypes metal inert gas (MIG) welding or metal active
gas (MAG) welding) is widely applied in various industries
because of its high productivity, flexibility, and low cost. It
can be operated in semiautomatic and automatic modes and
Fig. 4. Schematic representation of arc welding
can be used particularly well in a high-volume production
environment [12]. A typical setup is shown in Fig. 6. In
down to appropriate value. Welding processes in general need
Solid
lower voltages and higher currents. Advanced power sources electrode
are also capable of providing signals of various waveforms, wire
Shielding gas
which might be adjusted in real time based on some feedback input Current
signal. Power source related research is still very active [6], conductor
[5], [7]. There are several subtypes of arc welding, but only Wire guide and
the two most common ones will be described in some detail. Direction contact tube
of travel
Gas nozzle
A. Gas tungsten arc welding
Gasseous
Gas tungsten arc welding (GTAW), also known as tungsten Consumable electrode
shield
inert gas (TIG) welding is a widely used high-quality, high- Arc
precision welding process. In TIG welding, an arc is estab-
lished between a nonconsumable tungsten electrode and the
metal that is heated and melted (see Fig. 5). Filler wire may Weld
Base
metal
metal
Nonconsumable
tungsten electrode Gas nozzle
Shielding gas
Power source Direction of
Arc welding
Base metal
Solidifield Liquid weld
weld metal pool Fig. 7. Metal transfer modes (globular, spray, pulse) [15]
Fig. 5. Schematic representation of GTAW (TIG) welding [8] it is for example possible to achieve a stable one drop per
pulse mode and therefore a controllable metal transfer to the
be added for the weld. The inert gas [9]: weldpiece [16]. A feedback control system for this type of
1) shields the welding area from the air, preventing oxida- welding have already been proposed [17].
tion, Despite being one of the most common arc welding pro-
2) transfers heat from the electrode to metal, and cesses, GMAW also has shortcomings. One is the fact that
3) helps to start and maintain a stable arc (due to the low the same current is used to melt the wire and heat the
ionization potential material. That means, that by increasing the melting speed
Although pure argon is the most common choice, shielding for higher productivity we also increases the base metal heat
gas composition can also have effect on the resulting weld input resulting in increased distortion. To resolve this problem
in some cases [10]. The process can be used for many a modified approach called double-electrode GMAW or DE-
types of materials in all welding positions, and it provides GMAW has been proposed [18]. As each arc’s magnetic field
a concentrated, stable arc and a high-quality and neat weld influences the other, the process is still being researched [19],
deposit. Plasma arc welding (PAW) is an extension of GTAW [20].
Company Registration No.: 201427293E
7030 Ang Mo Kio Avenue 5#04-155
Northstar @ AMK Singapore (569880)
www.Whioce.com
II. CONTOL SYSTEM BACKGROUND made. Because of that, a lot of research is made based on
some more or less easily measured signal, which however is
In control system theory the system is usually presented by a
correlated with good quality weld. Some of the most common
block diagram as shown in Fig. 8. In the case of arc welding
systems will be discussed.
d d
x y ydes x y
A. Seam tracking
object controller object
Especially in robot arc welding applications it is very impor-
tant for the welding system to follow the seam accurately. This
type of arc welding control system do not exactly fit into the
Fig. 8. Open loop and close loop control system
idea presented in the following section, despite being a proper
the object is the welding process under consideration. The feedback control system. The main goal of seam tracking
input vector x is composed of all the parameters that influence control system is the elimination of one disturbance (improper
the process. These are welding voltage, distance between positioning of the electrode in relation to the weldpieces.
the electrode and the weldpiece, electrode geometry, wire There are various approaches in this group. Some researchers
feed rate (in GMAW), weldpiece thickness and composition, have for example used ultrasound [31], but the most common
shielding gas flow and composition, etc. The components of approach are image processing based control systems. An early
the output vector y are all the characteristics of the resulting example of such a system is shown in Fig. 9 [32]. The system
weld (weld strength, corrosion resistance, visual appearance,
Interupt signal
possible deformations etc.). The relationship between input
Video signal
and output can therefore at least in theory be given by some Driving wheel
Laser beam
vector function f Pre-processor
projector
y = f (x) (2) Rotary
encoder
Although we cannot write down this function, experience tells Image processor
us, that an appropriate combination of input parameters x, will Image sensor
usually (but not always) result in an acceptable output y. The Welding torch
problem lies in the fact that in some cases we lack experience
or there are some signals, which we cannot monitor or control
(the so called disturbances d. So, Eq. 2 can be rewritten into Servomechanism
the following form: x
y = f (x, d) (3)
L
The solution is the modification of the system from the so Welding
direction
called open-loop form (left side of Fig. 8) into the so called
close-loop form (right side of Fig. 8). In close loop form
Fig. 9. Seam tracking system [32]
the output y is monitored (measured) and fed back to the
controller. The controller compares the actual values y with uses structured laser light which reflects from the weld seam
the desired ones ydes . Based on this difference the input to the and forms an image in the image sensor. A typical image
object is calculated in such a way that the difference between obtained by this method is shown in the right part of Fig. 9.
the actual values y and the desired ones ydes (the so called The lowest point in the image is very simple to determine
error signal) decreases or ideally equals zero. So the control by the most basic image processing algorithms. This setup is
algorithm programmed in the controller can be written in the used often in recent research [33], [34]. A very similar seam
following way: tracking system on a mobile robot welding platform has also
x = g(ydes − y) (4) been developed [35]. Some recent solutions within this set
Within the domain of arc welding related control systems by don’t even need a source of structured laser light anymore [36],
far the most common control algorithm is the so called PID [23]. Another approach, presented in [37], uses an asymmetry
control algorithm [21], [22], [23], [24]. The other commonly in the weld pool image in order to track the seam.
used control algorithms are based on fuzzy logic [25], [26], A system presented in [38] is also given in this subsection
neural networks [27], [28], [29], sliding mode control [59] and despite not being a seam tracking system. It uses a linear CCD
others [30]. sensor to determine the type of weld joint.
(X1,Y1) (X2,Y1)
Pyrometer
08H
(30, Y2)
Torch Y
Torch
Temperature
Measurement Electrode
Point 2.5 cm
Welding direction
Seam
Workpiece
Weld pool
Diffusive X
E. Other systems
plane P1
Laser lines There are also some other interesting control systems. When
arc welding is used in additive manufacturing, wire twisting
Horizontal
plane P0 is an important disturbance. An image processing system
Y addressing this problem is presented in [58]. A complex
Fig. 13. Weld pool observed by the reflection of structured light
control system used for an arc welding based shaped metal
deposition (SMD) system that is an innovative method for the
manufacturing of metal objects is outlined in [60]. Both visual
straight laser lines will be distorted differently. Accurately and acoustic signals were taken in consideration for control
computing the equations of these laser lines is necessary for purposes.
the subsequent weld pool shape estimation. A similar approach
using a 20mW laser with variable focus in order to project IV. C ONCLUSION
a 19-by-19 dot matrix structured light pattern on the weld Arc welding might be considered as a mature joining
pool region is presented in [8]. The measured characteristic process. The paper however showed that there is still an
parameters are then used to estimate the backside bead width. enormous amount of research going on in relation with arc
An adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system (ANFIS) is used for welding control. This might be attributed to the fact that it is
this purpose. An even more advanced system is presented in probably by far the most important welding process.
[49]. It uses three cameras and structured laser pattern to get The main conclusion based on the conducted overview
an accurate reconstruction of weld pool. could easily be that machine vision / image processing based
control systems are becoming the most hot topic. In arc
D. Arc Length based control systems welding control where process feedback is needed images may
For most welding situations, it is desirable to keep the be required of the arc, weld pool, underbead, surface bead, or
arc length constant to produce a high-quality weld [50]. The weld preparation. Observation of the arc length and electrode
common method used is to keep the arc voltage constant. In stickout can also give important information about the process.
order to explain the rationale behind the arc length control the Arc intensity is also affected by various process parameters
power supply is converted into the equivalent RL circuit as and disturbances. The weld pool also emits radiation in the
[51] visual part of the EM spectrum. As intensity levels are much
di lower than those emitted by the arc itself, it is often used
Up = L + Ri + Ua (5) to asses the weld quality. This is also attributed to the fact
dt
that this is where the weld strength comes from. So, it can
where Up is the voltage of the power source, L the inductance,
be concluded that there are still many possibilities for future
R the resistance and i the welding current and Ua the arc
research in the area of arc welding control, especially control
voltage. The arc voltage is determined by equation [52]:
system based on visual information, because the equipment
Ua = ka la + kp i + Uc (6) needed is getting more an more inexpensive.