Modulation Techniques
Modulation Techniques
Prof. Tzong-Lin Wu
EMC Laboratory
Department of Electrical Engineering
National Taiwan University
Because the IF signal in a receiver contains noise from the antenna and receiver circuitry, as well as
the desired signal, the characteristics of the demodulator play a critical role in the overall performance
of the wireless system.
Note that the demodulator LO is identical in frequency and phase with the modulator
LO; this is called a synchronous, or coherent, demodulator.
We have normalized the input voltage so that the total DSB-SC input power is identical
to the input power of the SSB case.
Why?
2011/2/21 MW & RF Design / Prof. T. -L. Wu 9
The noise power of the output voltage
where the factor of four accounts for positive and negative frequency portions of the
filter response.
which is seen to be identical to the result for the SSB case given in (9.13). This implies
that the coherent SSB and DSB-SC demodulators have the same SNR performance,
when expressed in terms of a uniform input white noise level; this is a more meaningful
comparison than that of (9.21)
This is an advantage in that the carrier signal, even if much lower in amplitude than the
sidebands, can be used as a reference signal to phase-lock the local oscillator to
synchronization with the incoming signal.
The amplitude, m, of the modulating signal relative to the carrier is called the modulation index.
The carrier power thus increases the total input power, but does not directly contribute to
the output power after demodulation since it does not contain any modulation information.
Mixing the input voltage of (9.24) with the LO and low-pass filtering gives
the demodulator output voltage as
SSB and DSB-SC demodulators require a synchronous local oscillator for proper operation.
An advantage of DSB with a carrier component (DSB-LC) is that detection can be done
without a local oscillator and mixer, by using an envelope detector (noncoherent
demodulator).
It is the preferred method for broadcast AM radio, where it is desired to make the receiver
as inexpensive as possible.
The DSB-LC signal waveform
The output of the envelope detector shown in Figure 9.6a has a DC level that must
be removed with a series capacitor. This may limit the low frequency response of the
detector.
Thus broadcast radio systems must ensure that the modulation index is always less
than 100% in order to avoid signal distortion.
The output signal power is given by the time-average of the square of the envelope
voltage with the noise terms set to zero:
The first term in (9.34) represents power of a DC component, which would generally be
filtered with a DC block.
This is identical to the result of (9.28) for the synchronous demodulation of a DSB-LC signal, showing
that no degradation in SNR occurs with the much simpler method of envelope detection for high input
SNR.
2011/2/21 MW & RF Design / Prof. T. -L. Wu 21
2011/2/21 MW & RF Design / Prof. T. -L. Wu 22
Frequency modulation (FM)
Better SNR then AM at expense of bandwidth
where
In fact, good transmission fidelity generally only requires those sidebands whose
amplitude is 1 % or larger relative to the unmodulated carrier (the n = 0 term)
Note that (9.61) indicates that the SNR of a demodulated FM signal can be improved
by a factor of
Using
Improved performance in the presence of noise and fading, lower transmit power
requirements, and better suitability for transmission of digital data with error correction
and encryption.
It can be shown
After low-pass filtering only the DC term from (9.67a) remains, resulting in a positive
pulse at the output of the summer, indicating that a "1" has been received.
In PSK modulation the phase of the carrier wave is switched between two states, usually
0" and 180".
The spectrum of the PSK waveform is relatively wide in bandwidth due to the sharp
transitions caused by phase reversal. These are usually smoothed by filtering, but the
resulting bandwidth is usually still wide enough that PSK is impractical for multichannel
wireless systems.
Since the PSK waveform has a constant envelope, it cannot be demodulated with an
envelope detector.
Synchronism implies that both frequency and phase are identical, a result that is
generally difficult to achieve in practice.
As an example, if we set a criteria of requiring less than 45" phase error at a carrier
frequency of 1 GHz, synchronization of the LO to the carrier must be better than T/8 =
0.125 nS. A free-running local oscillator will virtually never exhibit such synchronism
because of frequency drift, Doppler effects, and the arbitrary (and sometimes variable)
distance between the transmitter and receiver.
Two ways in which a local oscillator can be synchronized with an incoming carrier wave:
transmit a pilot carrier, or use a carrier-recovery circuit. Transmitting a low-level carrier is
probably the easiest way, as this signal can be used to phase-lock the local oscillator.
ASK and FSK can use envelop detector but bad BER.
In the transmitter these PCM signals are used to modulate a carrier by amplitude, frequency, or
phase modulation.
In the receiver, as we have shown, synchronous demodulation or envelope detection (for ASK or FSK)
can be used to recover s(t) = s1(t) or s2(t).
The demodulated signal is then used to make the decision as to whether a binary "1" or "0" has
been received. In the absence of noise this can simply be done by setting a detection threshold,
where "1" or "0 is decided using a comparator circuit.
Although the effect of the (zero mean) noise voltage is minimized by averaging over
the bit period, the random nature of the noise results in occasional errors, and the
likelihood of an error increases with the power of the input noise.
The likelihood that a single bit is received incorrectly is called the probability of error, or
the bit error rate (BER).
The noise power output from an integrator with a bandlimited white noise input was
derived in (3.38) as
Assume that a binary "0" has been transmitted in an ASK system, in the presence of
bandlimited Gaussian white noise.
An error will occur if the output signal and noise voltage is greater than the threshold VT/2.
Then we have s(t) = s2(t) = -V and so(T) = -VT, with a detection threshold of zero.
An error will occur if the sampled output voltage from the integrator is greater than the
threshold.
This implies that, for the same probability of error, PSK requires only one-fourth the
power of an ASK system.
Since an ASK signal is off half the time, however, the average transmit power of an ASK
system is half that of a PSK system, for the same peak power (same signal voltage, V).
Thus, in terms of average transmit power, the PSK result is better by a factor of two (3
dB), compared with ASK.
In the synchronous FSK demodulator output noise consists of the difference between
noise that has passed through both the channels.
The result of (9.80) shows that the total noise power of the FSK demodulator is doubled
relative to the synchronous ASK or PSK demodulator.
Observe that synchronous FSK requires 3 dB more signal power than an equivalent
PSK system for the same probability of error, and 3 dB less power than an ASK system
on a peak power basis.
FSK and ASK, however, have equal error rates when compared in terms of average
transmit power, since an ASK system transmits power only half the time.
Statistics of r(t) depends on m(t), We will discuss m(t)=0 and m(t)=V, respectively.
Let x’ = x + V
Error (V2)
Note that the rician distribution reduces to the Rayleigh pdf when V = 0, as expected;
it can be shown that the rician pdf approaches a Gaussian distribution when the
argument is large.
2011/2/21 MW & RF Design / Prof. T. -L. Wu 60
Rician probability distribution
The probability of error when sending m(t) = V
The integral in (9.96) cannot be evaluated in closed form, but must be calculated
numerically.
Derivation of the probability of error for noncoherent FSK is similar to the procedure
used for noncoherent ASK, since the two channels of the FSK demodulator of Figure
9.16a essentially decompose the FSK signal into two ASK signals.
If we temporarily assume a fixed value of r1(t), the probability of error can be computed
as
Let Rb be the bit rate of the binary message signal, with dimensions of bits per second
(bps).
Thus the probability of error is determined solely by the carrier power, the bit rate,
and the PSD of the input noise.
Depending on the type of modulation, the required receiver bandwidth may range from
one to several times the bit rate.
Thus, for example, an analog telephone circuit having a bandwidth of 2400 Hz (600 Hz-
3 kHz) is limited to a maximum data rate of (2400 Hz)(1 bps/Hz) = 2400 bps when
used with binary modulation.
We will see later in this chapter that substantially greater data rates can be achieved
with multilevel modulation methods that transmit more than one bit per period. Such
methods have bandwidth efficiencies greater than 1 bps/Hz.
Thus the terms data rate and bandwidth are not synonymous, in spite of the often-
heard (but incorrect) use of the word "bandwidth" when referring to high data rates.
This conclusion only applies, however, when using the peak power for ASK, when the
average power of the ASK signal is used the error rate for coherent ASK and coherent
FSK are identical.
ASK transmitters are very simple, and efficient since no power is radiated when no
data is being sent. ASK receivers are also simple, if envelope detection is used. Because
the bit error rate is poor in comparison to other modulation methods, ASK is limited to
low data rates. In addition, the fact that the detection threshold depends on the received
signal level makes ASK performance very poor in a fading environment. For these reasons,
ASK applications are usually limited to short-range, low-cost telemetry and RFID.
An FSK transmitter is only slightly more complicated than for ASK, and an FSK receiver
using envelope detection can be made simply and inexpensively.
Noncoherent FSK has found widespread historical application in a wide variety of both
baseband and modulated data transmission systems, such as data modems, teletype, and
fax.
This causes sharp reductions in received signal power over short time intervals, or with
movement over small distances, due to phase cancellation.
Although the average receive power is not greatly reduced, fading has a major impact
on error rates because the presence of brief but deep drops in received power results in
very large error rates for short periods.
Account for Rayleigh fading by considering the conditional probability of error for a
fixed signal amplitude, then integrating over the Rayleigh probability distribution
function for this amplitude.
If we consider r(t) to be a fixed multiplier, then the probability of error derived in (9.78)
can be modified to give
using
the horizontal axis represents the in-phase (I) component, while the vertical axis
represents the quadrature (Q), component that is shifted 90" in phase.
The QPSK modulator thus takes the form shown in Figure 9.26. A 90" hybrid divider can
be used to provide the I and Q components of the LO from a single oscillator.
Because the average transition between phase states is 90°, the bandwidth of the QPSK
spectrum is narrower than the spectrum of a BPSK signal.
Since QPSK is a constant envelope modulation, the detectors can use a zero threshold.
But the above choice has the very useful property that when an error occurs in the
detection of a symbol, it is most likely that only one of the bits will be in error, rather
than both bits.
This is because an error is most likely to result in a shift from the correct phase state
to the immediately adjacent phase, rather than the diametrically opposite phase
By symmetry the error rates for all si are equal, so let us assume that s1 is received
Since the overall probability that a symbol is received correctly is the product of the
probabilities that each correlator operates correctly, the overall probability of error for
a symbol is
Then since each symbol contains two bits, the bit error rate for QPSK will be one-half
the symbol error rate:
Note that because the symbol period T is twice the bit period, E, = 2Eb, where Eb is
the bit energy.
This shows that the expression of (9.125) is equivalent to the probability of error for
BPSK as given in (9.78).
where
Valid for
We can therefore say that 4-QAM is identical to QPSK, if the signal amplitudes are
constant.
Because of the high bandwidth efficiency that can be obtained with QAM, it is increasingly
being used in modem wireless systems, including point-to-point microwave radios, LMDS
systems, and the DVB-C digital video cable broadcasting system.
Table 9.5 summarizes the ideal performance of several types of coherent digital
modulation methods.
Since Eb = S/Rb, this also implies that, for a fixed signal power S, there is a critical
value of the data rate Rb for which the error rate can be made as small as desired.
This particular value is called the channel capacity, and is given by a formula derived by
Claude Shannon:
Shannon limit:
Practical modulation methods usually perform at only a fraction of this value, but the
use of error correcting codes can provide performance close to the Shannon
limit.