A Comparitive Study of Chronic Miasms Yr Aggarwal
A Comparitive Study of Chronic Miasms Yr Aggarwal
A Comparitive Study of Chronic Miasms Yr Aggarwal
OF
CHRONIC MIASMS
Dr. Y.R. A g r a w a l
Life Member : The Rajasthan Homoeopathy Association and The
Delhi Homoeopathic Medical Association. Editor: Advent of Homoeopathy
(Delhi), Ex-Chief Editor : The Hahnemannian Homoeopathic Sandesh
(Delhi). Ex-Member Editorial Board : The Torch of Homoeopathy (Jaipur).
Author of: A Practical Solu tion To Potency Problem; Cautions in Homoeopathy;
What A Homoeopath Should Know; The Dose and its Repetition; A Comparative
Study of Chronic Miasms; Prophylactics in Homoeopathy; Drug Relationship-
Antidotal & Inimical; A Repertory of Desires & Aversions; Measles &
Small-pox; Symptoms and Totality of Symptoms; A Treatise on Bowel
Nosodes; Homoeopathy in Surgery; Diseases of Hair and Nails; Materia
Medica of Glandular Medicines; Homoeopathy in Accidents and Injuries;
Insomnia and Sleep; Homoeopathy in Asthma; Dreams and Nightmares;
Homoeopathy in Diseases of Teeth and Gums.
1 9 9 5
VIJAY PUBLICATIONS
DELHI
Published by :
Smt. Vijay Agrawal
For : VIJAY P U B L I C A T I O N S
> better
less pain
more ease
< worse
painful
uneasy
Printed at:
SHIBA O F F S E T PRESS, 794/95, Guru Ram Dass Nagar Extn.,
Gurudwara Road, Laxmi Nagar, Delhi - 110 092.
Preface to the First Edition
H a h n e m a n n discovered the 'Law of Similars and enunciated the
theory of 'Miasms' basing his k n o w l e d g e on practical experiences. This
is why his findings have been maintaining status quo. A c c o r d i n g to him
the acute diseases respond quickly to h o m o e o p a t h i c medicines given on
the basis of totality of s y m p t o m s but c h r o n i c d i s e a s e s p o s e c e r t a i n
d i f f i c u l t i e s u n l e s s they are attacked through their m i a s m a t i c base.
Psora, Sycosis and Syphilis are the three miasms which are behind every
chronic disease either jointly or severally.
This little book which is mainly based on the paper presented by me
on 5.12.76 in the monthly meeting of the Delhi Homoeopathic Association
contains a vivid description about the miasms and their c o m p a r a t i v e
study with one another. The characteristic s y m p t o m s of each miasm and
c o m b i n e d effects of the two miasms are the peculiar features of this book.
A list of Anti-Miasmatic remedies has been given at the end of the book
and doubts regarding categorisation of some remedies have also been
clarified. A b o v e all. the book has been written in layman's language
except that I have to use certain medical terms for which I could not find
better simple terminology.
5) Syphilis 29
6) Pseudo-Psora 38
7) Scrofula 44
8) Cancer 47
9) Mixed Miasm 49
10) Characteristic Symptoms of
i) Psora 51
ii) Sycosis 53
iii) Syphilis 55
iv) Pseudo-Psora 57
Comparative Study of
i) Psora Vs. Sycosis 59
ii) Psora Vs. Syphilis 62
iii) Psora Vs. Tuberculosis 64
iv) Sycosis Vs. Syphilis 66
v) Sycosis Vs. Tuberculosis 69
vi) Tuberculosis Vs. Syphilis 70
vii) All the Miasms 72
12) Treatment of Psora. Sycosis, Syphilis and Mixed Miasm 83
13) Treatment Plan 96
14) Anti Miasmatic Remedies 98
15) More about the Medicines ill
16) Miasmatic Concept in Organon 115
17) Repertory of Miasms 126
18) Bacteriology and Homoeopathy 138
19) OtherConstitutions 146
What is Miasm ?
The word miasm* derived from Greek means 'taint' or
'contamination'. Hahnemann used it for the manifestations in
chronic diseased conditions. Foster defines a miasm as a morbific
emanation which affects individuals directly and not through the
medium of another individual. Stedman's medical dictionary defines
miasm as noxious effluvia or emanations, formerly regarded as the
cause of malaria and of various epidemic diseases.
According to Hahnemann the disease is a state of disturbance
of the vital force which maintains harmony and health. The
disturbance is caused by something called miasms which are also
harmful inherent dynamic forces on the same ethereal plane as the
life force itself. Hahnemann thought of his theory of chronic disease
in the years 1816-17, though he did not make it public for a further
decade. In 1827 he summoned two of his most faithful disciples,
Gross and Stapf, to Kothen to receive the new doctrine, and in the
following years he began to publish his last major work, the
'Chronic Diseases', in which miasm** theory was set forth.
Hahnemann was led to formulate his theory when he found during
12 years of experiments and critical observations that certain
diseases were easily cured with simple remedies or had a natural
and spontaneous cure, but he was disappointed to see that many
other patients returned with old complaints and or with new
symptoms. He studied all such cases carefully and deeply and the latent
* Recurring diseases mean diseases which occur in the same fashion more
than once in life e.g., cholera. Non-recurring diseases have no tendency to
recur-e.g., measles, small-pox, chicken-pox etc.
Psora
* Quick change of moods, often very merry and exuberantly so, often again and,
indeed, very suddenly, dejection; e.g., on account of his disease, or from other
trifling causes. Sudden transition from cheerfulness to sadness, or vexation without
a cause.
in school. Adults find it difficult in concentrating their mind. Their
thoughts keep on changing, shifting from one subject to another.
The mental anxiety of psora often makes its appearance about the
new moon or at the approach of the menses in women. Weeping
often palliates these patients for a time.
The unfulfilled desires of psora derives satisfaction through
imagination, fantasies and dreams, (psoric individuals are day
dreamers).
Mental:— The mind of the psoric is not exactly deformed
but is tied down or say inhibited; that is why a psoric is timid,
taciturn, weak and seeks protection. The death of the psoric will
be part of his disposition to disintegration or dissolution, but even
in his anxiety he has logical hope and vision of eternal life and an
unending desire for absolute protection—either a belief in God or
confidence in something immense as a substitute for it.
Sensorial Sphere:— Psora produces vertigo of all types and
modalities, due to functional derangement of thfe sensoria, and also
hypersensitivity* of all sensory organs, special as well as general,
with abnormal or excessive response or reaction. Vertigo worse by
motion or rising from seat or looking up. Vertigo in a warm room
or when the air is not good.
Head:— Chronic headaches, hunger during the attacks. The
brain feels large. Pain in occiput. Psoric headaches are sharp and
severe. Bilious headaches, migraine, sun headaches (from sunrise
to sunset and worse at noon). All pains of psora are better by lying
down and covering warmly.
Dry eruption on the scalp. Gray hair; dry hair. Hair turns
gray too soon. Severe itching of the scalp. Painful boils, very
sensitive, but no suppurating, (suppurating when there is a mixture
of psora and sycosis.) Crusta lactea in the scalp, face, cheeks and
ears covered with dry scabs.
Eyes:— Psoric eye troubles are aggravated and ameliorated
* As long as there is any trace of the disease Sycosis in the system, it prevents
any other acute attacks in many patients. (J.H. Allen)
** Vaccinosis is a sub-division of the sycosis of Hahnemann. Vaccinosis does not
express merely the same thing as vaccinia, for the latter means the febrile reaction
which occurs in an organism after vaccination, with special reference to local
phenomena at the point where the vaccinial pus, or lymph, is inserted. Sometimes,
also, the term vaccinia is applied to a general varioloid eruption following
vaccination; but here, vaccinia is commonly held to end. By vaccinosis
Continued to page 19
Sycosis, however, very rarely results after the primary
vaccination, because it is generally followed by physiological
reaction in the form of pustules. On the contrary, the repetition
of anti-variolic vaccinations may be dangerous especially in cases
when they do not take up. It may be evidently accounted for by
clinical examination of the patient. You will know that the patient
is suffering from different troubles of nervous origin, neuralgias,
neuritis after an unsuccessful vaccination. Thirdly it is also said
that the action of other curative vaccinations, used as preventive,
leaves the taint of sycotic miasm. Let us see what Dr. J.H. Allen
says on page 119 of his book 'Chronic Miasms—Sycosis'.
"Vaccination causes all the races to be sycotic, and is the
father of a multitude of skin diseases such as erysepelas,
impetigo, psoriasis, morbilliform rashes, some forms of gangrene,
erythemas, roseola, papular and pustular eruptions of different
forms, urticaria, eczema, dermatitis, herpetiformis, pemphigus of
one form, lupus vulgaris and many others that might be
mentioned. All cry out, stop the death dealing process of
vaccination or the whole race will soon become degenerated."
Evolution of Sycosis:— Sycosis is generally understood as
gonorrhoeal* poison. Gonorrhoea** is the acute infection of the
Continued from page 18
Dr. Burnett means "long lasting morbid constitutional state engendered by the
vaccine virus"... "and in it are not included any other disease whose causes may be
accidentally or incidentally contained in the vaccine pus, such as scrofulosis,
syphilis or tuberculosis"
The word vaccinose (vaccinosis) is used in homoeopathic literature of Germany.
Vaccinosis shows itself as a formidable acute disease that may terminate fatally, or
it may manifest itself as a chronic affection.
The vaccinated person is poisoned by the vaccine virus; what is called the
"talcing" is, in point of fact, the constitutional re-action where by the organism frees
itself more or less from the inserted virus. If the person do not "take", and the virus
has been absorbed, the "taking" becomes a chronic process-paresis, neuralgiae,
cephalagiae, pimples, acne, and c. The less a person "takes", therefore, the more
is he likely to suffer from chronic vaccinosis.
* The suppressed gonorrhoeal infection is very apt to first show itself in attacking
the blood and producing an anaemic condition, and a general catarrhal condition i£
set up. Often times an inflammatory rheumatism develops; inflammation follows
in the soft tissues, and changes in the fibre of the muscles. In fact, the whole
Continued to page 20
gonococci, which takes from 5 to 10 days to develop a urethritis
after an exposure. During this incubation period, it is purely an
infection; then the local manifestations are thrown outward by
nature at the point of attack. If the gonorrhoea is thoroughly and
completely cured no sycosis will develop. Sycosis is established
after suppressed gonorrhoea, when the acute infection is driven
in upon the vital energy by external methods of suppression, and
it then becomes a systemic stigma, permeating every living cell
of the organism, and transmitting its destructive forces to the
offspring as well as retaining the full destrutiveness of power in
the original individual, and impregnating the mother of the child
(H.A. Roberts). As for example, in an individual suffering from
gonorrhoea at the age of 20, which was more or less suppressed,
has silent period and in consequence of which there appears the
warts, then chronic rheumatism (especially if he had rheumatism
during the attack of gonorrhoea) or chronic enterocolitis,
neuralgia, neuritis, asthma etc.
Sycosis is not a new name for gonorrhoea, neither is it
gonorrhoea in any sense of the word. The history of the two
diseases differs widely in their constitutional developments and
progress. Gonorrhoea simplex is not a basic miasm, while sycosis
comprises one of the chronic miasms of Hahnemann. The early
history of gonorrhoea simplex is a history of painful and
spasmodic symptoms, and of decided vesical irritation, of
chordee, and marked specific urethritis, while the history of
typical cases of sycosis in its initial stages is lacking in many of
the above symptoms. As a rule, in sycosis very little pain is
present—sometimes not always, a decided tenderness is felt along
the anterior surface of the organ.
Continued to page 30
seventh and 14th day, rarely sooner or later mostly on the
membranes infected by the miasms, first as a little pustule which
changes into impure ulcer with raised border and stinging pain
which, if not cured, remains standing on the same place during
a man's life time only increasing with the years, while the
secondary symptoms of the venereal disease (syphilis) cannot
break out as long as it exists.... In a few days after taking a dose
of mercury, the chancre (without external application) becomes
a clean sore with a mild pus and heals itself..... as a convincing
proof that a venereal malady is fully extinguished within.
Hunter says, "Not one patient in fifteen will escape syphilis
if the chancre is destroyed by external applications," and
again, "The result of destroying the chancre over so early and
even on the first day of its appearance, if this is effected by local
application was always the consequent outbreak of syphilis." And
he quotes Fabre's Venereal Diseases, "Syphilis always follows on
the destruction of the chancre by local application."
And Hahnemann says, "I have never, in my practice of more
than fifteen year, seen any trace of venereal disease break out,
so long as the chancre remained untouched in its place, even if
this were a space of several years But whenever anyone is
so imprudent as to destroy this vicarious local symptom, the
organism is ready to cause the internal syphilis to break out into
the venereal disease; since the general venereal disease dwells in
the body fro n the first moment of infection The miasm has
already become the property of the whole organism. All wiping off
and washing off however speedy, and with whatever fluid this be
done, is too late-is invain."
* Mentally, the patient with the syphilitic miasm will openly or in a veiled
manner, be prepared for violence in his reaction to his family and to society ;
he upraids those close to him on the slightest pretext or harangues the
multitudes to take up arms and commit acts of terrorism.
utter. Sometimes we see this so marked in tubercular children all
through their school days, despite the attempt to whip them into
line with other children whose minds are clear and strong and who
have no such mental depression or devitalizing element in their
organism.
Syphilis has a marked irritability, an aversion to those
intimately associated with the family, or the business partner. It
is critical and destructive and is related to varying shades and
degree of anti social conduct, hatred, jealousy, vindictiveness.
These patients live under constant taint of modern perversion,
which is shown by the frequent washing of hands (Syphilinum).
This represents a deep seated depravity, a subconscious accep-
tance of the same, and a desire to cleans the temple, a factor seen
in the gradual destruction of the cerebral cells in paresis.
Head:— Syphilitic headaches are persistently occipital or
occur on one side of the head. They are worse from heat, sunset
till down, from motion, from exertion mental or physical and
better by cold application. Headache is always at night. It runs
on for the whole night in the heat of the bed, and it disappears
in the morning. The aggravation begins in the evening and
increases as the night advances and decreases with the gradual
approach of morning. Headache worse from warmth. A child with
syphilitic headaches will bore his head into the pillow or roll the
head into the pillow or roll the head from side to side. Often times
the syphilitic patient complains of a band about the head, which
is probably due to a slight effusion from the meningeal surfaces.
Besides the headache, the syphilitic head has profuse sweating
and this sweat is invariably fetid smelling. The headaches that
come on rest days are usually psoric and syphilitic. Syphilitic
headaches are usually < riding, > by motion, < by exertion, either
mental or physical.
Headache of neuralgic character that causes insomnia and
delirium at night, begins at 4 P.M. and is worse at 10 or 11 P.M.
and ceases at day break. Headache with sea-sickness, intolerable
pains, the arteries leading to the head congested and pulsating
violently.
A lancinating pain in the occiput that causes insomnia at
night and ceases with daylight. Gravitative, contusive, incisive
pains from one part of the base of the cerebellum to the other.
Headache from one temple to the other, and from there vertically
in the form of the letter T. Headache lasting many months, sharp,
oppressive, over the right eye and penetrating deeply as it were
into the brain.
Syphilitic patients frequently have high blood pressure, due
to atheroma or nephritic obstruction. Their hair is moist, greasy,
offensive and falls out in bunches, first on the vertex. Hair on
other parts falls. The hair of the beard is often ingrowing, the
eyelashes break off and turn inward, especially in elderly patients.
The scalp continuously perspires, and may be covered with a
scabby, oozing eruption.
Eyes and Vision:— Syphilitic miasm makes serious
inroads upon the structure of the eyes; e.g. ulceration of cornea
and lid. The eyes are apt to be astigmatic and donot tolerate
artificial light. Ptosis of the eye lid and greenish yellow discharge
from eyes are syphilitic. Changes in the lens are always syphilitic
or tubercular. The child who squints is very often a product of
hereditary syphilis. Syphilitic eye troubles are worse in the
artificial light.
Chronic blistery infection, periodically, of the cornea,
successive outbreak of vesicles on the epithelial cap of the cornea
with photophobia. Interstitial keratitis. Swollen eyes, closed lids;
from them pus oozes; night aggravation. Sensation as if a current
of cold air were blowing on the eyes. Left ocular globe covered
with fungus vegetation, with pains that are worse at night. Iritris
with photophobia, congestion of the conjunctiva and the sclera, with
swelling, chemosis supra-orbital pain.
Opthalmia acuta of the new born, with the eyelids swollen
during sleep and intensely painful at night. In the eyes; ptosis;
paralysis of the superior oblique, sleepy aspect from ptosis. Diplopia,
they see one image below the other.
Nose and Smell:— Bones of the nose are destroyed.
Ulceration, thick crusts often fill whole nasal cavity. The crusts
are dark, greenish, black or brownish. Nasal discharges or
snuffles may or may not be offensive.
Caries of nasal bones, palate and septum, with perforation.
E A R — Abscess in the left ear exuding a large quantity of
pus. Scarce humor, acrid, watery, that flows from time to time
from the ears without deafness (syphilis and psora). Deafness that
increases gradually until the patient hears nothing. Thick yellow
crusts, and oozings thick yellow pus. Eczema behind ears having
thick foetor pus are a combination of syphilis and psora.
Face, Mouth and Teeth:— In syphilitic patients the face
has a greyish, greasy appearance. The infant too has a grey
appearance. Sunken nasal bridge, prominent forehead are syphi-
litic stigmata in the new born. It looks old, puckered, weakened,
dried up, wrinkled like an old man. Actual ulcer in the mouth is
syphilitic. Psora never develops ulcers of itself, but the syphilitic
taint is very prone to this. Pathological and structural changes
take place in the dental arch and the teeth come through deformed,
irregular shape and irregular in order of eruption. Teeth decay
along the edges of the gums; edges like a saw. The decay of teeth
is even before they are entirely through the gums. Saliva is apt
to be increased. Excessive flow of saliva from the mouth during
sleep, (if it is not from taenia.)
Taste:— Metallic or copper taste. More of metallic taste
is purely syphilitic while syphilis with psora has a saliva which
is ropy and viscid with blood taste.
Desires and Aversions:— An aversion to meat, desires
cold things to eat and drink. Does not like animal food, nor
tolerates them. Amongst animal foods, he has some liking for milk
only, but he does not tolerate it so well.
Skin:— Eruptions are crusty and oozing pus, and the skin
is greasy and sweaty and there is much offensiveness to the
odours. The hair tends to fall out. Eruptions found around the
joints, or in the flexure of the body are of a copper coloured or
raw hem coloured and are prone to assume a crescentric form.
No itching and very little soreness. Scales and crusts thick and
heavy patches in circumscribed spots are syphilitic. The gan-
grenes of the skin and dry gangrenes show their destructiveness
of the syphilitic stigma. The most striking feature of syphilitic
eruptions is that they are not sensitive and do not itch. Itching starts
if psora is present.
Upper and Lower Extremities:— Syphilis attacks the long
bones of upper or lower extremities. Pain in the periosteum and
long bones is the result of syphilitic miasm. The bones are soft,
rickety and curved, as seen frequently in bow legged children.
They lack the hard earthy matter necessary to make a firm bone.
They are so soft and flexible that many a time children, will not
bear the weight of their body and when they first begin to walk,
their feet become deformed or the long bones become curved or
bowed like a barrel stave.
Bone pains and deformities and gangrene are seen in
syphilitics.
The pains of syphilis are lancinating, boring; or dull, heavy.
Above all, they are persistent, continuous, and always worse at
night and from heat. The patient longs for the light of the day
and dreads the coming of the night.
Organs of Generation:— Syphilis seldom attacks the
ovaries or the uterus. Abortions are the cause and result of
syphilitic miasm. Malignancies develop when syphilis is com-
bined with other miasms.
Leucorrhoea profuse, soaking through the clothes and
running through to the heels: equal to that produced by the alum
used in the aqueducts.
Discharges:— Syphilitic patients are aggravated by the
natural avenues of elimination; sweating aggravates rather than
ameliorates; profuse urination and diarrhoea never ameliorates.
On the other hand he feels greatly improved by unusual discharges,
viz. catarrhal or leucorrhoeal discharges or the discharge from an old
ulcer.
Bowel:— Obstinate constipation for years together. The
rectum seems to be obstructed. Enemas cause labour like pains.
After bowel movement, exhaustion. Ano-rectal fissures; rectal
prolapse. Indurated ulcers in the anal orifice, excoriated, itching,
(syphilis and psora)
Modalities:;— Syphilitic troubles, whatever these troubles
may be, are always worse at night, worse from heat of bed at night
which continue till morning. The growing pains of children are
syphilitic especially when aggravated at night, in storms or
change of weather. The syphilitic patient is worse by heat, during
rest and better in open air, cold and uncovering. The malignancy
of syphilitic miasm are prone to develop at the age of forty.
To sum up, the person with a large and bulging head, moist
hair, greasy appearance, who goes by ill faced and mistrustfully
as if despising us with his offensive looks, who is ready for a
defiant act or an aggressive movement, whose spirit is clouded
with degenerative deprivation with its tendency towards destruction
and death, presents a picture of syphilitic miasm.
Tubercular Diathesis
(Pseudo Psora)
* Since 1939, Dr. Grimmer has said that the cancer had a tubercular base, sure
enough, symptoms of tuberculosis alternated with those of cancer, one evidently
suppressing the other for the time being. There was never the expectoration of phthisis
cough; dyspnoea was bad, even to almost suffocation when windows must be opened;
night sweats profuse and soreness in chest quite distressing; also emaciation during
the last six monthes. (Julian M. Green)
Mixed Miasm
(a) Psora
(1) Timidity, mental disquietude for no apparent cause,
moroseness, want of courage and energy, vanishing of thoughts
while reading, sudden transition from cheerfulness to sadness or
to peevishness without any apparent cause; fearfulness, fear of
falling in the business, precipitation, restlessness and impatience.
Great indolence and repugnance to all exertion, both mental and
physical.
(2) One sided headache (Hemicrania), sharp, severe usually
frontal headache. A tendency for such headache on the slightest
cause, various kinds of pains and various kinds of sensations in
the head.
(3) Chronic headaches. Hunger during the attacks. The brain
feels large. Pain in occiput.
(4) Harsh, irritable temper; want of affection for anybody,
tendency to do evil to others.
(5) Hair is dry, lustreless, tangles easily, breaks and splits.
Falling off of hair and premature grayness of hair. Itches and
ringworm on the head, beneath the hair. Dandruff in the hair.
(6) Sensation as if blood is rushing upward the head with
simultaneous sensation of suffocation, causing both physical and
mental restlessness. This, however, is relieved by a partial
sweating of the face and forehead.
(7) Sensation of nervousness as of ants crawling is character-
istic of psora.
(8) Waves of heat (surges) during change of life.
(9) Pallor of the face; want of usual lustre in the eyes. Redness
of the borders of the lids; tendency to rub the eyes.
(10) Tendency of epistaxis in the children and youths.
(11) Running of nose on the slightest or no cause; or no running of the
nose even from excessive exposure, or there are other kinds of illnesses
but no running of nose.
(12) Crusts in the nose and the tendency to dislodge them with
the finger. Stuffy nose, compelling, respiration by the mouth.
(13) Various kinds of coating on the tongue, fetid smell, dirty
gums; salivation out of proportion.
(14) Vomiting and tendency of vomiting in the morning;
waterbrash, dryness of the tongue. Taste is sour, sweet or bitter.
A burnt taste.
(15) Toothache for slight or no cause. Bleeding from the gums.
(16) Craving for or aversion to particular things. A psoric
patient has a special liking for fried things; he is averse to boiled
food. Desire for sweets and for sour things. Marked craving for
tea, coffee, tobacco or any stimulant.
(17) They are always smelling cooked food, dinners, flowers,
plants etc., and there are odours that cause them nausea,
vomiting, headaches, fainting and vertigo.
(18) Tendency to boils and abscesses in various parts of the
body. Itches, ringworms or rhagades in particular seasons.
(19) Ulceration in the feet and between the fingers in particular
seasons.
(20) Corns in the toes; pain in the corns.
(21) Pains in the stomach aggravated or ameliorated by
particular kinds of food or at particular hour.
(22) The patient does not wish to be touched when in pain as
the least pressure makes him worse.
(23) Unnaturalness of the appetite-either a complete want of
appetite or canine hunger. Hungry but, appetite vanishes at the
sight of food. Hungry immediately after eating.
(24) Unnatural constipation; and diarrhoea alternatively, diar-
rhoea from the slightest irregularity of diet.
(25) Various kinds of pain and sensation in the rectum; bloody
or other kinds of discharge with stool; haemorrhoids! growths.
(26) Worm symptoms in children. They have a tendency for this
parasitical growth in their intestines causing itching, creeping in
the anus, irritability of temper and tearfulness.
(27) All sorts of menstrual disorders, discharge scanty or
profuse; abnormality in the colour and smell of the discharge.
Menses painful.
(28) Excessive sexual appetite, nymphomania, masturbation,
impotency etc.
(29) Exhaustion out of proportion to exertion. Tendency to suffer
long from slight illness. Long lasting pain in the muscles, bones and
nerves on the slightest injury.
(30) Tendency for erysipelas on slight injuries. Any slight injury
on any part of the body causes ecchymosis, and this is gradually
followed by fever putrefaction etc., of the injured part. A tendency
of hyperaemia in any part of the body.
(31) All kinds of unnaturalness of sweats, i.e., excessive sweat
in particular parts only, like forehead, hands and feet, face and
rectum, complete want of sweat or fetid sweat etc.
(32) Unnaturalness of sleep, loss of sleep, sleeping in catnaps,
startling during sleep, crying, grinding of teeth during sleep,
various kinds of sounds in the mouth during sleep, laughing
during sleep. Sense of suffocation during sleep; snoring, restless-
ness and constant changing of sides during sleep; salivation
during sleep. Morning sleep too much prolonged. Sleep full of
dreams-dreams of fear; sweating during sleep; evacuations
during sleep.
(33) Aggravation and amelioration of all kinds of pain in
particular season, during walking, or sitting or lying down.
(34) Different kinds of sounds like gliding in jaw bones during
eating, in knees and other joints during walking, while standing
up from sitting posture or while sitting down.
(b) Sycosis
(1) Cross, irritable; absent minded, memory is disastrously
affected; can not rememeber the names of places, of man, of
things, addresses, dates, names of days etc., cannot find
appropriate words to express his idea. Recollection of recents
events is difficult; while the things long past are well remembered.
(2) Tendency to keep every thing secret; will not like to
disclose even facts about his illness. Keeps every thing secret
about his family.
(3) Tendency to shift from one doctor to another. His mind is
tenaciously attached to his ailment, cannot remain long under any
particular treatment; lacks patience, changing disposition.
(4) Suspicion and dissatisfaction. The sycotic has hardly any
reliance upon anything or anybody.
(5) Most selfish and arrogant, internally mean and imprudent
but poses as a pious and holy man. In other words he is one type
within and another type outside and nobody can ever get a true
idea of his actual personality.
(6) The sycotic mind is grossly debased, it makes him liar and
a vicious scoundrel, markes him destitute of all love and
affections of others, makes him mean and selfish.
(7) All the vicious individuals on earth, the thieves, robbers,
murderers are the products of sycosis. It makes a beast of a man.
(8) Sometimes a certain degree of insanity is observed. The
patient keeps on mentioning the same matter again and again. A
sycotic manifests symptoms of insanity from an insignificant to
a remarkable degree.
(9) Vertex headache, headache worse on lying; relieved by
motion. Vertigo on closing the eye (i.e., withdrawing the visual
aid to coordination), disappearing on opening eyes.
(10) Warts, condylomatous growths of various sizes and
colours.
(11) Peculiar anaemia characterised by a waxy, shining, grey
appearance of face with hollow cheeks and voice.
(12) Unable to eat breakfast. Food never seems sufficiently
salty.
(13) Joints — rheumatic and gouty arthritis; the lower limbs and
especially the feet are very painful on walking.
(14) Corona glandis covered with red points or spots.
(15) Sycotic babies often get snuffles. The sycotic usually has
red nose with prominent capillaries. The sense of smell is lost.
(16) A putrid, musty or fishy taste.
(17) Craves bear, meats.
(18) Sub acute or chronic inflammation of various types. We
meet with such a condition in diseases like nephritis, urethritis,
buboes, prostatitis, orchitis, epididymitis, seminal-vasculitis,
salpingitis, chronic lumbago, ovaritis etc.
(19) Anaemia, weakness, chilliness, want of interal heat,
sensitive to cold, dampness and wet weather; leucophlegmatic or
hydrogenoid constitution.
(20) Insidious advent of disease manifestations.
(21) Suppurative appendicitis, peritonitis and haemorrhoidal
tumours, painful and bleeding.
(22) Bowels and intestinal troubles; whether it is diarrhoea or
haemorrhoids both have symptoms of colic. Stools are forcible,
sour, acrid and preceded by colic. After vaccination many
children suffer from this sycotic diarrhoea and colic.
(23) Pelvic troubles; in women ovaritis, salpingitis, pelvic
cellulitis, ovarian cysts, fibroids, leucorrhoea, sterility or one
child sterility. In men orchitis, prostatitis, urethritis, stricture
urethra, offensive moistness of perineum and anal region.
(24) Uterine walls are invaded by mucous cysts. Nodular growth
on the external walls of the uterus are due to sycotic infection.
(25) Motion ameliorates conditions arising from sycotic taint. A child
if kept in motion is comparatively quiet.
(26) Worse from sunrise to sunset i.e., 4 AM to 6 PM, irritable
during cloudy weather, rainy weather. The sycotic patient is a
barometer.
(c) Syphilis
(1) Introvert, melancholic, sad, heavy and depressed, self
condemnation, thoughts of suicide, fixed ideas, stubborn, sullen
and morose but restless and anxious at nights; tendency to make
mistakes when speaking, weakness of memory, loss of will power.
r /
!
1. Psora spends its force when suppressed upon the nervous and
mental phenomena of a serious character. Sycosis attacks internal
organs especially the pelvic and sexual organs in the worst specific
forms of inflammation, producing hypertrophies, abscesses, cystic
degeneration, mucous cysts, etc., and when thrown upon the brain
it produces headaches, severe acute mania, insanity, moral degen-
eracy, dishonesty etc.
2. Psora leads the man astray and keeps him off his true
objectives of life. Sycosis leads him towards the satisfaction of
vicious and obscene desires. The restlessness which is brought by
psora is already there but the sycosis makes him more fond of
satisfaction of depraved and worthless desires.
3. The psoric patient is absent minded in general and momen-
tary but the sycotic patient is absent minded specific for words,
sentence, recent events. He forgets words, sentences and previous
line that he has just read.
4. In sycosis and syphilis the reasoning powers are slow and
there is self condemnation, while these symptoms may be present
in psora, they are constant in a mixed miasm. The desire to kill
* Hahnemann always talks of best preparation of Mercury, and I have lately had
a great deal of experience with the wondertul power of the Cyanide, in high
potencies Of course when the disease has become chronic one has to continue
the treatment for a long time. Chronic syphilis will not cure up with one dose.
(Tyler)
The child who squints very often is a hereditary syphilitic. Causticum will be
his remedy but he will also use spectacles.
When the child in the second infancy or a bit later, has tics, spasms, who
stammers, it will be necessary to think of a very far away syphilitic ground.
Treatment of Mixed Miasm
* See page 93
** See also page 122
97
Anti-Miasmatic Remedies
(a) Anti-psoric Cadmium Sulph
Abrotanum Cal Arsenicum
Acetic Acid Calcarea Carb
Aconite Calcarea Phos
Agaricus Calcarea Sulph
Aloe Socotrina Carbo Animalis
Alumina Carbo Veg
Ambra Grisea Capsicum
Amnion Carb Causticum
Ammon Mur Cinchona
Anacardium Cistus Canadensis
Antim Crud Clematis
Apis Mellifica Coccus Cacti
Argentum Metallicum Coffea
Argentum Nitricum Colocynthis
Arsenicum Album Conium
Arsenicum Bromatum Crotalus
Arsenicum Iodatum Croton Tig
Arsenic Sulph Rubrum Cuprum Met
Arum Triph Digitalis
Aurum Metallicum Dulcamara
Aurum Muriaticum Eucalyptus
Baryta Carh Euphorbium
Belladonna Ferrum Met
Benzoic Acid > Ferrum Phos
Berberis Vulgaris Fluoric Acid
Boric Acid Graphites
Borax Guaiacum
Bovista Hepar Sulph
Bufo Rana Hydrastis Can
Hyoscyamus Phosphoric Acid
Ignatia Platinum
Iodine Plumbum
Ipecacuanha Podophyllum
Kali Bichrom Psorinum
Kali Carb Pyrogenium
Kali Iod Ranunculus Bui
Kali Nit Rhododendron
Kali Phos Ruta Graveolens
Kali Sulph Sarsaparilla
Lac Caninum Secale Cor
Lachesis Selenium
Ledum Pal Senega
Lilium Tig Sepia
Lobelia Inflata Silicea
Lycopodium Stannum Met
Mag Carb Staphisagria
Manganum Strontium
Mezereum Sulphur
Morgan Pure Sulphuric Acid
Morgan Gaertner Tarentula His
Moschus Tellurium
Muriatic Acid Theridion
Nat Ars Tuberculinum
Nat Carb
Vipera
Nat Mur
Zincum
Nat Sulph
Nit Acid (b) Anti-Sycotic*
Nux Vom Actea Racemosa
Origanum Aesculus Hip
Petroleum Agaricus
Alumen
* Sycotic remedies are tinctures of plants which thrive in swamps, such as Thuja.
Remedies containing chlorine, and remedies containing a combination of elements
of low atomic weight, such as Fluoric acid and Nitric acid, are also primarily anti-
sycotic.
Alumina Cannabis Indica
Ammonium Carb Cannabis Saliva
Ammonium Mur Cantharis
Anacardium Capsicum
Anantherum Carbo Animalis
Angustura Carbo Veg
Anthrokokali Carbolic Acid
Antim Crudum Carboneum Sulph
Antim Tart Castor Equi
Apis Mellifica Castoreum
Aranea Diadema Causticum
Argentum Met Cedron
Argentum Nit Chamomilla
Armoracea Chrysarobinum
Arsenic Album Chimaphila Umb
Arsenic Iod Cinnabaris
Asparagus Clematis
Asterias Rubens Cocculus Indicus
Aurum Met Colchicum
Aurum Nit Conium
Bacillinum Copaiva
Balsam of Peru Crocus
Baryta Carb Crotalus
Baryta Mur Croton Tig
Benzoic Acid Cubeba
Berberis Vulg Digitalis
Bismuth Doryphora
Bondonnean Dulcamara
Borax Epigea Repens
Bromium Erechthites
Bryonia Erigeron Canadense
Bufo Rana Eryngium Aquaticum
Caladium Eupatorium Purpureum
Calcarea Ars Euphorbia Pilulifera
Calcarea Phos Euphrasia
Fagopyrum Picric Acid
Fluoric Acid Piper Nigrum
Gelsemium Plantago
Gnaphalium Poly Platina
Graphites Proteus
Hepar Sulph Prunus Spinosa
Hydrastis Psorinum
Iodium Pulsatilla
Kali Bichromicum Pyrogenium
Kali carb Rhus Tox
Kali Iod Sabina
Kali Mur Saccharum Lactis
Kali Sulph Sanicula
Lachesis Sarracenia Purpurea
Lac Caninum Sarsaparilla
Lithium Carb Secale Cor
Lycopodium Selenium
Magnesia Carb Senecio Aureus
Magnesia Mur Senega
Magnesia Phos Sepia
Manganum Silicea
Medorrhinum Staphisagria
Mercurius Stillingia
Mezereum Strontia Carb
Muriatic Acid Sulphur Iod
Natrum Ars Sycotic Co
Natrum Carb Tabacum
Natrum Mur Tellurium
Natrum Sulph Terebinthina
Nitric Acid Thuja
Palladium
(c) Anti-Syphilitic'
Petroleum
Aethiops
Petroselinum
Alnus
Pertussin
Anacardium
Phytolacca
Phosphorus Antim Crudum
Phosphoric Acid Apis Mellifica
* The remedies which are homoeopathic are consequently found among the heavy
elements such as Aurum, Mercurius, Baryta etc.
Arg Cyanatum Echinacea
Argentum Met Erythrinus
Argentum Nitricum Euphorbium
Arsenic Alb Ferrum Iod
Arsenic Bromatum Ferrum Phos
Arsenic Iod Fluoric Acid
Ars Sulph Flavum Franciscea
Asafoetida Gaertner Co,
Asclepias Gelsemium
Aurum Arsenicum Graphites
Aurum Bromatum Guaco
Aurum Iod Guaiacum
Aurum Met Hecla lava
Aurum Muriaticum Hepar Sulph
Aurum MuriaticumNatronatum Hydrastis
Badiaga Iodium
Baptisia Jacaranda
Belladonna Kali Ars
Benzoic Acid Kali Bichrom
Berberis Aquifolium Kali Carb
Cal Ars Kali Iod
Cal Fluor Kali Mur
Cal Iod Kali Phos
Cal Sulph Kali Sulph
Carbo Ani Kalmia
Carboneum Sulph Kreosote
Carbo Veg Lac Caninum
Cinnabaris Lachesis
Clematis Lasiodora Cubana
Conium Ledum
Corallium Lonicera Xylosteum
Corydalis Lycopodium
Crotalus Mercurius Auratus
Cundurango Merc Bin Iod
Daphne Indica Merc Bromatus
Merc Corrosivus Staphisagria
Merc Cyanatus Stillingia
Merc Iodatus Flavus Sulphur
Merc Nitrosus Sulphuric Acid
Merc Phos SulphurIod
Merc Precipitatus Rubber Syphilinum
Mercurius Tannicus Thuja
Merc Sol Tuberculinum
Merc Vivus Viola Tri
Mezereum Zizia
Muriatic Acid
(d) Anti-Psuedo Psora*
Natrum Mur
Acetic Acid
Natrum Sulph
Aesculus
Nitric Acid
Agaricus(Syco-Tub)
Nux vomica
Alumina
Petroleum
Ammon Carb
Phosphorus
Ammon Mur
Phosphoric Acid
Apis Mellifica
Phytolacca
Arsenic Iod
Platinum
Arum Triph
Psorinum
Aurum Ars
Pulsatilla
Bacillinum
Rhus Glabra
Bacillinum Testium
Sarsaparilla
Belladonna
Secale Cor
Berberis Vulg
Sepia
Borax
Silicea
* Many weakly constitutions are tubercular at base, although they may give no
evidence of actual disease. In these cases Tuberculinum and Bacillinum—the two
are particularly identical—are remedies which may do very useful work. Kent says
that Tuberculinum is a very deep acting remedy and is often required when other
deep acting remedies fail. It is allied to Psorinum and both Kent and Burnett point
out this connection. Burnett says that Tuberculinum is often the acute remedy and
Psorinum the chronic. Other allied remedies are Calcarea carb and Silicea and these
are frequently of great use in tubercular conditions. When Bacillinum indicated but
fails to act, a few doses of Thuja may be required. This possibility should not be
overlooked in these days of frequent inoculations and injections, for Thuja is, par
excellence, the remedy for poisoning with animal toxins.
Bovista ~ Kreosote
Bromium Lac Defloratum
Bryonia Lachesis
Bufo Rana Lachnanthes
Cal Ars Lilium Tig
Cal Carb Lycopodium
Cal Fluor Manganum Aceticum
Cal Iod Mercurius
Cal Phos Merc Vivus
Carboneum Sulph Mezereum
Carbo Veg Millefolium
Causticum Muriatic Acid
Chelidonium Myosotis
China Ars Myrtus
Coca Nat rum Ars
Cocculus Ind Nat rum Carb
Conium Natrum Mur
Coto Bark Natrum Sulph
Cuprum Met Petroleum
Drosera Phosphoric Acid
Ferrum Ars Phosphorus
Ferrum Met Pineal Gland Ext
Graphites Pix Liquida
Guaiacum Platinum
Hamamelis Podophyllum
Helix Tosta Polygon Av
Helonias Psorinum
Hepar Sulph Pulsatilla
Hippozaeninum Ranunculus
Iodium Rhus Tox
Ipecac Sarracenia
Kali Bich Selenium
Kali Carb Sepia
Kali Iod Silicea
Kali Nit Spongia
Stannum Met Arsenic Met
Stramonium Arum Maculatum
Sulphur Asafoetida
Theridion Asclepias Tub.
Thyroidinum Aurum Iod
Tuberculinum Aurum Met
Tuberculin from birds (Aviare) Aurum Mur
Tuberculinum Bossan Aurum Mur Nat
Tuberculinum Bovinum Aurum Sulph
Tuberculin of Denys Badiaga
Tuberculin of Koch Baryta Carb
Tuberculin (Serum of Baryta Mur
Marmorek) Baryta Phos
Tuberculinum of Rosenbach Belladonna
Tuberculinum Residuel Berberis Aquifol
Tuberculinum Spengler Bromium
Vaudremer Tuberculins Bufo
Urea Calcarea Carb
Vanadium Calcarea Iod
Yerba Calcarea Mur
Zincum Met Calcarea Silicate
Calendula
(e) Anti-Scrofula
Capsicum
Aethiops
Carbo-Animalis
Agaric us
Causticum
Alnus
Chimaphila Umb
Alumen
Cinnabaris
Alumina
Ammon Carb Cistus Canadensis
Antim Tart Clematis
Anthrokokali Coca
Apis Mel Condurango
Arctium Lappa Conium
Argentum Nitricum Corallium
Arsenic Alb Cornus
Arsenic Iod Corydalis
Curare Mezereum
Dulcamara Natrum Carb
Ferrum Acetate Natrum Mur
Ferrum lod Natrum Phos
Ferrum Met Natrum Sulph
Ferrum Mur Nitric Acid
Ferrum Pernitricum Nux Mosch
Ferrum Phos Nux Vomica
Ferrum Sulph Oleum Jec
Fluoric Acid Petroleum
Galium Pinus Sylvestris
Gettysburg Phosphorus
Graphites Plumb Iod
Hecla Lava Psorinum
Helliborus Pulsatilla
Hepar Sulph Phytolacca
Hippozaeninum Rhus Tox
Hydrastis Rumex
Iodium Sambucus
Iodoformum Sanicula
Iris Versicolor Sarsaparilla
Kali Bichrom Sepia
Kali Carb Silicea
Kali Iod Solidago
Kreosote Spigelia
Lac Caninum Spongia
Lachesis Staphisagria
Lapis Albus Stillingia
Lithium Carb Strontiana
Lycopodium
Sulphur
Magnesia
Sulphuricum Acid
Merc Cor
Theridion
Mercurius
Thuja Occ
Merc Bin Iod
Tuberculinum
Merc Vivus
Viola Tri
(f) Anti-Cancer Choline
Acetic Acid Cicuta Virosa
Alumen Cinnamonum
Alumina Silicate Cistus
Anantherum Clematis
Anthracinum Condurango
Ant Chlorid Conium
Apis Mel Crotalus Hor
Argentum Met Curare
Arsenicum Copr Acet
Ars Brom Elaps Coral
Arsenic Iod Eosin
Asterias Rubens Epihysterinum
Arum Ars Eucalyptus
Aur Mur Nat Euphorbia
Baptisia Ferrum Phos
Belladonna Formica Acid
Bismuth Formica Rufa
Bromium Fuligo Lign
Bufo Galium Ap
Cadmium Sulph Geranium Maculatum
Calcarea Carb Guaco
Calcarea Fluor Graphites
Calcarea Iod Hamamelis
Calcarea Phos Hepar Sulph
Cal Oxalica Hoang Nan
Calendula Hydrastis
Carbolic Acid lodium
Carbo Ani Kali Ars
Carbon Sulph Kali Cyanatum
Carcinosin Kali Iod
Causticum Kali Mur
Chelidonium Kali Phos
Chimaphila Umb Kali Sulph
Cholesterinum Kreosote
Lachesis Taxus Baccata
Lapis Albus Thuja
Lycopodium Trifolium Pratense
Malandrinum Tuberculinum
Mercurius Ustilgo
Mezereum Zincum
Murex Purp
(g) Anti-Psora Syphilis*
Muriatic Acid
Asafoetida
Nat Cacodyl
Argentum Nitricum
Nectrianinum
Arsenic Sulph
Nitric Acid
Aurum Met
Nuphar
Aurum Mur
Ornithogalum
Borax
Phosphorus
Calc Sulph
Phosphoric Acid
Carbo Ani
Phytolacca
Cinnabaris
Plumbum Iod
Corallium
Psorinum
Crotalus
Radium
Fluoric Acid
Rumex
Guaiacum
Ruta Grav
Hepar Sulph
Sanguinaria
Kali Bich
Scirrhinum
Kail Iod
Secale Cor
Kreosote
Sedum Repens
Lachesis
Sempervivum Tectorum
Magnesia Carb
Sepia
Mercurius
Silicea
Mezereum
Spigelia
Nitric Acid
Staphisagria
Petroleum
Symphytum
Phosphorus
Sulphur
Phosphoric Acid
SulphurIod
Phytolacca
Tarentula Cub
See also t h e l i s t u n d e r A n t i - P s e u d o P s o r a a n d A n t i - S c r o f u l a .
Sarsaparilla (i) Anti-Syco-Syphilis
Staphisagria Medicines common to
Sulphur sycosis and syphilis group are
antisyco syphilis. Even then the
(h) Anti-Psora Sycosis prominent medicines in this list
Agaricus are :
Alumen Asafoetida
Alumina Phos Cinnabaris
Anacardium Merc Duicis
Antim Tart Merc Iod Flav
Arsenicum Nitric Acid
Berberis Thuja
Bovista Syco-Syphilinum
Calcarea Carb (j) Anti-Mixed Miasm
Calc Silicate The high rank remedies run-
Cicuta Virosa ning through the three miasms
Coccus Cacti are as follows :—
Colocynthis There are 13 bold medicines
Crocus Sativa which are of the first rank and
Dulcamara others are also very useful ones.
Helonias Argentum Met
Kali Carb Aurum Iod
Ledum Aurum Mur
Lilium Tig Aurum Met
Magnesia Carb Aurum Sulph
Murex Benzoic Acid
Natrum Mur Calcarea Sulph
Oleum Jec Carbo Veg
Ranunculus Bui Causticum
Sabina Conium
Sepia Ferrum Met
Silicea Fluoric Acid
Sulphur Hepar Sulph
Sulphuric Acid Iodium
Kali Ars Nitric Acid (Predominantly
Kali Bich Syphilitic)
Kali Silicatum (Predominantly Phosphorus
Sycotic) Phosphoric Acid
Kali Sulph Phytolacca
Lachesis Sarsaparilla
Lycopodium Silicea
Manganum Aceticum Staphisagria
Medorrhinum Stillingia
Mercurius Sulphur
Merc Cor Syphilinum
Merc Iodatus Flavus Thuja
Merc Iodatus Ruber Thyroidinum
Mezereum (Predominantly
Syphilitic)
* Bacteria are tiny one celled plants, without green colouring matter, that can be seen
only under a compound microscope that magnifies them from 600 to 1200 times.
Bacteria come in many different sizes but in three principal shapes : (1) Rod or pencil
shaped, the bacilli, which produces disease like tuberculosis and leprosy: (2) Spherical
or dot shaped, the cocci, and (3) Spiral or comma shaped, such as the cork screw
spirochete of syphilis or cholera vibrio. The cocci come in pairs (diplococci), strings or
chains (streptococci), or clusters, like grapes, (staphylococci). Typical diplococci are
the gonococcus, cause of gonorrhoea, and the pneumonococcus, cause of pneumonia.
Streptococci are responsible for 'strep' infections, such as the sore throat that is often
fore-runner of rheumatic fever. Staphylococci are often present in boils.
** Atharvaveda Samhita-By D.B. Satvalekar
propagating rapidly." He named the responsible agents a contagium
vivum. He also spoke of the germs of consumption.
Father Athanasium Kircher in 1658 gave creditable theory of
micro-organism in Scrutinium Physico Medicum Pestis. In 1671,
using simple lenses of low magnification, he observed what he called
'peculiar worms' in the blood of persons suffering from the plague.
Thus, he was the first person who suggested, on experimental ground
that disease might be caused by living organisms. It was in
September, 1683 when Atoni van Leeuwenhoek described spermatozoa
and protozoa and also demonstrated micro-organism on the teeth.
These minute bodies he named as 'animalcules'. His contemporary
Diacento Cestoni (1637-1718) of Leghorn described acarus as the
aetiological agent in scabies. This was the first proof of an organism
being the cause of definite disease. A century later Plenciz of Vienna
took up the work of Leeuwenhoek and the experiments carried out
by him showed that each disease had its own specific agent which
multiply in the body. Plenciz also worked out in 1762 (e.g., during
the first decade of Hahnemann's life) a well sounded germ theory of
disease. He examined the minute animals found in decomposing
organic material and named these 'infusoria'. Even Linnaeus listed
these in classification, and Christian Ehrenberg's classification had
appeared during Hahnemann's life time.
Between 1720 and 1880, the science of immunology based on
the principles of bacteriology was at an empirical stage. In 1846,
Ignaz Philippe Semmelweiss had reduced mortality due to puerperal
sepsis from 12.24% to 1.27% by introducing aseptic procedures in
maternity ward. In 1865, Pasteur showed that by avoiding infection
with micro-organisms, it was possible to raise a healthy stock of silk
worms in farms surrounded by infected farms. Pasteur also noted
that inoculation with stale cultures of a micro-organism immunized
the animal against future infection, even if the second infection be
virulent to healthy but not to inoculated animals. This incident even
to the non homoeopath Shryock was reminiscent of Hahnemann's
doctrine that like cures like. It is clear from this that immunity and
susceptibility are relative, and that sub clinical infection itself
increases immunity. Such an observation is in the line with the
observations of Hahnemann.
Koch's famous postulates (1882) on the relationship of an
organism to the disease it causes were an elaboration of Jakob
Henlay's suggestions of 1840. They were:
(a) that the organism should always be associated with the disease
it is supposed to cause.
(b) that the organism should be isolated in pure culture, and
(c) that the culture organism should produce disease in susceptible
animals.
Ilya Metchnikoff noted in 1883 that amoebae could engulf solid
particles, and later that leucocytes engulfed and destroyed pathogenic
microbes in a similar manner. Further studies revealed that
leucocytes were more effective after the host had been immunized
against the given disease than they were before. Then Pleiffer
observed that bacteria placed in immune serum lost vitality and died.
In 1888, Roux and Yersin observed that the broth used to culture
diphtheria bacilli possessed poisonous qualities. Kitasato noted
similar qualities in culture media that had once contained tetanus
bacilli. These experiments show that microbes produce poison and
they do not destroy it.
After Sir Alexander Fleming discovered penicillin in 1929,
more and more substances, antibiotics, have been used to destroy
bacteria in the body. No doubt, these antibiotics have some
undesirable effects and that they have their limitations, yet no patient
suffering from an infectious disease has died simply because the
bacteria in his body has been wiped out.
In October, 1984, three researcher Mr. Niel Jerne of Denmark,
Mr. George Koechler of West Germany, and Mr. Cesar Millstein of
Argentina were awarded Nobel Prize on medicine for their work on
the immune system and discovery of the principle for production of
monoclonal antibodies. Mr. Jene's 'Network Theory' on immune
response published in 1974 led to new insights into the immune
system, which defends the body against bacteria and viruses. The
theory has been applied in transplant surgery and in treatment of
certain tumours and allergies.
Hahnemann's Views and Relationship of Bacteriology to
Homoeopathy
According to Dr. Stuart Close, "Hahnemann was the first to
perceive and teach the parasitical nature of infectious or contagious
disease." Dr. B.K. Sarkar in his book 'Organon of Medicine' says
that the idea of contagium vivum originated with Hahnemann and
he can be called as the father of bacteriology. But this belief is not
based on facts in as much as the name bacilli was not given during
Hahnemann's time; nor the microscope, with which Robert Koch was
able to verify was invented. Hahnemann had no microscope. Hence,
he can not be called as the father of bacteriology.
Hahnemann, however kept pace with the scientific developments
of his times. In his translation of Monro's Materia Medica (1791)
he wrote with regard to itch: "I agree with those who attribute the
disease to a living cause." In the Allzeigar (1792) he worte," It
has its origin in small living insects or mites which take up their
abode in our bodies the cause of itch given above is the only true
one, the only one founded upon experience." In 1795 he wrote, "Is
not the eruption-contagion (of crusta lactea) perhaps due to small
animalculae or miasms as an underlying cause." This shows that
Hahnemann subscribed to the view that living beings can cause
specific diseases. In his 'Hailkunde der Erfahrung' (1805) he states
that some disease (the miasmatic maladies) arise "rom a contagion
principle that always remains the same. These diseases always retain
the same characteristic and follow the same course. These views of
Dr. Hahnemann are very close to those of Plenciz. It is important
to note here that according to Hahnemann disease matter is a living
substance.
His views about the contagious principle, the miasm, become
explicit in his 'Chronic Diseases':" have these various, acute miasms
the peculiar characteristics that like parasites (they) grow up (within
the body of the host)....On the other hand, are not the chronic miasms
disease parasites, which continue to live as long as man seized by
them is alive....and....which do not die off of themselves." Further
on in the same work he mentions about "germs of internal itch, or
psora," and again "this miasm like a parasite seeks to inroot its
hostile life in the human organism and to continue it here."
Hahnemann's views about micro-organism become still more clear
in his famous essay on Asiatic Cholera (1831): "the cholera miasm
finds a favourable element for its multiplication and grows into an
enormously increased brood of those excessively minute, invisible
creatures of which the contagious matter of cholera most probably
consists, and the invisible cloud is composed of probably of millions
of those miasmatic animated beings...."
Dr. J.T. Kent says, "He who considers disease results to be
disease itself, and expects to do away with these as disease, is insane.
It is an insanity in medicine, an insanity that has grown out of the
milder forms of mental disorder in science, crazy whims. The
bacteria are the results of disease the microscopical little fellows are
not the disease cause, but what they come after, they are scavangers
they are perfectly harmless in every respect. They are the outcome
of disease." He further says: "they (allopaths) tell you that a bacillus
is the cause of tuberculosis*. But if a man had not been susceptible
to the bacillus he could not have been affected by it. As a matter
of fact, the tubercles come first and the bacillus is secondary. It has
never been found prior to the tubercles.... Allopaths are really taking
the sequence for the consequences, thus leading to a false theory, the
bacteria theory. Hahnemann did not adopt any such theory as
bacteriology." He adds that a recently dead body is poisonous and
later if the cadaver has remained for some time it is full of bacteria
and has no poison. The bacteria are there to remove the poison; the
typhoid stool, when it has a very scanty allowance of bacteria, is
very poisonous, but when it is swarming with bacteria it is benign;
bacteria are sent to destroy the poison of the disease; man lives
longer with bacteria than he would be without them; if we would
succeed in destroying the bacteria in the blood of a consumptive, he
would die soon.
As already said earlier the name bacilli was not invented during
Hahnemann's time, nor the microscope, with which Robert Koch was
able to verify was invented. Hence, Kent's statement that Hahnemann
did not adopt any such theory as bacteriology holds no grounds. With
regard to Kent's remarks that, "psora was susceptibility to disease,
* Professor Virchow declared in his address before the tuberculosis congress held in
Berlin on May 27, 1899, "that there is no evidence that tuberculosis is inherited, as I
have never, in the course of microscopic investigations, found any trace of its presence
in the unborn baby," although he admitted that it could acquire the deseaseone day after
its birth.
142
being the effect of man's evil thoughts—a moral leprosy...." Dr.
Koppikar said, "Hahnemann never thought of psora as man's state
before the infection; he spoke only about the miasm, the infection.
In one place he says he was completely free of psora, though quite
susceptible to most of acute diseases (Chr. Dis. Page 44). Though
a venereal disease originates in sin, it is contracted only when one
partner is infected, never otherwise. None can contract syphilis from
a non syphilitic prostitute."
Dr. M.L. Tyler says, "True natural chronic diseases are those
which owe their origin to a chronic parasitical miasm or germ (or
we should say, chronic parasitical micro-organism) They are fixed
Chronic Miasms, which extend their parasitical ramifications to
spread through the human organisms and to grow without end. (Chr.
Dis. 1.23)
It requires hardly any judgement to ascertain whether Hahnemann
was for or against bacteriology. In case of cholera Dr. Hahnemann
said that there must be something in water that people drink and get
cholera even though could not see cholera germs, you must boil the
water in order to kill the germs (which are the cause. The word
'cause' here has been purposely used—S.P. Koppikar) because
cholera becillus is the cause of cholera and not just one of the
aetiological factors ? More flows in Kent's arguments become
evident when we study development in bacteriology that took place
after Hahnemann's death and before Kent delivered his lecture on
Philosophy of Homoeopathy, and finally the developments that
contradict Kent's predictions. Further Kent's contention that a sick
person lives longer with bacteria than he would without them is also
wrong. Ever since Sir Alexander Fleming discovered penicillin in
1929, more and more substances, the antibiotics have been used to
destroy bacteria in the body. Another point that may arise is that all
of us are all the time exposed to bacteria, but we do not catch the
disease. How is that ? The answer is very simple. It all depends upon
the resistance power of the men. It is true that all people may not
have the same resistance power. Only when a man's resistance is
lowered due to whatever reason he gets infection. In such a case, if
we can get some extra help to kill our enemies that should be most
welcomed provided we do not depend on it for all the time.
Not only has the homoeopathic view point helped scientists to
exploit bacteriology for the benefit of ailing humanity, but
Homoeopathy's claims have also been substantiated by bacteriological
techniques J. Paterson and William Boyd, in 1931, demonstrated an
alteration in the Schick test from positive to negative in 60% of cases
following administration by mouth of a 30C potency ,of toxoid or
201C potency of diphtherinum. This alteration occurred only in 5%
of cases not so treated. Paterson in 1936 also showed that non lactose
fermenters could be isolated from 25% stool specimens examined and
that many chronic symptoms were related to the presence of these
non-lactose fermenters. It was further shown that vaccines of these
non-lactose fermenters, in homoeopathic doses, given by mouth
would eliminate the chronic symptoms. The same is true of micro
doses of other vaccines like pneumococcin, influenzin, streptococcin
etc., etc.
Emil von Behring, a Berlin homoeopath, succeeded in saving
thousands of babies suffering from diphtheria by injecting them with
attenuated bacterial toxin. About this he wrote: " by what
technical term could we more appropriately speak of this influence
excited by similar virus (e.g., toxin) than by Hahnemann's word
homoeopathy "
The science of bacteriology has brought in two main useful
procedures in the practice of internal medicine, viz., the use of
immunisation and the use of antibacterial agents which are very
specific in certain situations. The former is one which is based on
homoeopathic technique. The antibacterial agents have provided
tools to tackle acute infections with much greater ease and certainity.
Success of such measures in tuberculosis and leprosy is of such
proportions that it needs our recognition as a reality of great
significance. Anti-bacterials have enabled surgery to reach into the
inner most recesses of the body. Immuno-suppressive drugs enable
a person to retain a suitable transplanted organ longer.
Louis Pasteur who was the real father of bacteriology and
immunisation was not a doctor. He set out to find out why sheep
were dying of anthrax. He advised isolation of the affected sheep and
thus prevented the spread of the disease. Then he tried immunisation
for healthy sheep and saved the industry. He also applied the same
principle in hydrophobia which was causing 100% mortality. His
technique of vaccination to protect others is a standard even today.
It was the most beautiful use of homoeopathy by a non homoeopathic
man.
About syphilis being a microbial infection there was no doubt
and its remedy was the best preparation of Mercury. For gonorrhoeal
infection, Hahnemann gave just two remedies, Thuja and Nitric Acid.
Why did the psoric infection need more remedies; though Sulphur
was the most important one ?
See what Tyler says: "Some day, someone among the
pathologists will demonstrate his perspicacity in regard to psora
also, by proving that the acarus is the intermediate host of some
micro-organism responsible for one or more chronic diseases of
manifold manifestation."
The science of bacteriology is too advanced to be just pooh-
poohed by our elders. The acceptance of the role of bacteria in no
way reduces the work or scope of homoeopathy, either for curing
or prevention. (Dr. S.P. Koppikar)
Other Constitutions
Constitution* is that aggregate of hereditarial character
influenced more or less by the environment, which determines the
individual's reaction, successful or unsuccessful to the stress of
environment.
According to the modern medical science there are three types
of constitutions, viz., 1) Bilious, 2) Phlegmatic and 3) Rheumatic.
Bilious Constitution:- It is a constitution attributed to an
excess of bile in the system. It represents Pitta of Ayurved. It is
characterised by a very great activity of liver and of the venous
sanguine system, by a yellow or brown colour of the skin, black
colour of the hair, by leanness and an angular form. Bilious persons
are lively, susceptible, obstinate. They are predisposed to affection
of the liver and intestines and to derangement of digestive function,
to constipation and to piles. Their regime should be principally
vegetarian.
Homoeo Remedies:- Aeon., Aesc h., Ailan., Ambr., Ant c.,
Ant t., Bell., Bryo., Cann i., Cocc., Ipec., Lach., Merc., Nux v.,
Plat., Podo., Puis., Sul.
Phlegmatic Constitution:- Characterised by mucus (Phlegm),
it is equal to Ayurved Kaph constitution. If any person easily suffers
from cold, cough and coryza; from heat or cold, he is said to be
phlegmatic. His sensory function is the weakest function so it is
easily deranged by heat and cold. The respiratory function is,
however, stronger than the sensory function but weaker in compari-
son with other function and it is deranged after derangement of the
sensory function. The patient is indolent, slow and torpid and is
advised to be careful about heat or cold.
* Stedman defines constitution as the physical make up of the body, including the mode
of performance of its functions, the activity of its metabolic processes, the manner and
degree of its reactions to stimuli, and its power of resistance to the attack of pathogenic
organisms.
Homoeo Remedies:- Aloe., Amm m., Ant t., Bell., Calad.,
Calc., Caps., Cocc., China., Clem., Cycl., Dul., Ferr p., Hep.,
Kreos., Lach., Merc., Mez., Natr c., Natr m., Puis., Seneg., Sep.
Rheumatic Constitution:— It is equal to Vat constitution in
Ayurved. If a man suffers from rheumatism caused by cold or heat
or due to indulgence in food, he is said to be of rheumatic
constitution.
Homoeo Remedies:—Aeon., Act rac., Act spic., Badiag.,
Benz ac., Calc., Kalm., Med., Phyt., Rhod., Rhus tox., Sabin., Sal
ac., Spig., Sul., Tereb.
Dr. Von Grauvogl gave three types of constitutions according
to excess or deficiency of certain elements in the tissues and blood.
These are: i) Hydrogenoid Constitution, ii) Oxygenoid Constitution
and iii) Carbo-nitrogenoid Constitution.
Hydrogenoid Constitution:— It is characterised by an excess
of hydrogen and consequently of water in the blood and tissues. It
corresponds closely with Hahnemann's sycosis but it covers a much
wider area and is not by any means confined to the acquired or
inherited results of gonorrhoel infection. Intermittent fevers and
periodicity come within its sphere. The vaccinosis or the constitu-
tional sufferings from cowpox infection should be included under it.
Hydrogenoid constitution can be recognised by the circum-
stances accompanying the disease. If the patient is worse in cold or
damp weather, and the rain, one has to choose among the remedies
which are similar to his disease, and contain c (cold) and h (hot).
The symptoms are aggravated by everything which increases the
amount of water in the organism, by bath or eating animal flesh of
those animals which remain in water. Conditions are aggravated by
living near water, and especially standing in water. Thuja is the
principal remedy for this constitution.
Oxygenoid Constitution:—It is characterised by an excess of
oxygen, or atleast by an exaggerated influence of oxygen, on the
organism. It corresponds to Hahnemann's syphilis. Mercury is the
principal remedy. Due to influence of oxygen on the body, remedies
of carbon and nitrogen series which prevent the oxidation of tissue
are suitable. Carbon and alkalies rich in carbon have a different
effect as Graphites, Petroleum, Kreosote, Benzoic acid, Citric acid,
Hydrocyanic acid, Laurocerasus and Nitric acid. Some narcotics
such as Aconite, China and Arsenic and metals that are capable of
suspending a process of decomposition such as Chromium and Kali
Bichromicurn are useful.
Carbo Nitrogenoid Constitution:—It is characterised by an
excess of carbon and nitrogen and by insufficient oxygenation. The
diseases it produces are called diseases of the retarded nutrition.
The patient becomes thin after a period of obesity. Albuminoids
are decomposed like the hydrocarbons. There is pseudo albuminuria,
phosphaturia acetonemia, rickets and osteomalacia. General symp-
toms are great frequency of perspiration with shallowness, short
breath, frequent pulse, melanotic cellulitis, constipation or diar-
rhoea, flatulence, urinary troubles, gouty pains, swellings, vertigo,
dullness of the head, yawning, hypochondriasis, irritability and
impatience. Copious uric acid and oxalates in urine, expistaxis and
haemorrhoids, pruritus, baldness, cerebral fatigue, unhealthy skin,
boils and urticaria.
Carbo-nitrogenoid lacks ozone and is rich in carbon and
ni.rogen. Consequently it finds its remedy in ozone and ozonated
water. Aconite, Apis, Argent nitricum, Aurum met, Belladonna,
Bovista, Camphor, Chamomilla, Cuprum, Digitalis, Dulcamara,
Hepar sulph, Lobelia, Lycopodium, Nux vom, Phosphorus, Platina,
Plumbum, Rhus tox, Sulphur, Terebinthina are the medicines for this
constitution. It is Hahnemann's Psora.
Physiological Constitutions
Sanguine Constitution:— It is characterised by the predomi-
nance of the sanguine system, by the strong impulsion of the heart,
by the rosy colour of the skin otherwise white, by black or brown
hair. Sanguine persons are very active, lively, violent and change-
able. Their bodily health is generally good, but if they get sick they
easily succumb. Their muscular powers at times very much
developed and they are disposed to inflammation, haemorrhages and
rheumatism. Their regime should be mild and more vegetable than
animal.
Homoeo Remedies:— Aeon., Ars., Aur met., Calc., Cham.,
Chin s., Coff., Ferr., Hyos., Ign., Murex., Nitr ac., Nux v., Phos.,
Plat.
Lymphatic Constitution:— It is characterised by the lyrnph
or white blood, by the scarcity of hair which are either brown or red,
by white skin and light complexion, a full rounded frame, whereas
the flesh is soft and flaccid. Lymphatic persons are generally mild,
timid, amiable and easy going. The circulation of blood is sluggish,
the pulse slow and their muscular power relaxed. They are subject
to catarrh and glandular swellings, to dropsy and abcesses. Their
regime is both vegetable and animal, but not farinaceous. Spices and
fermented drinks do them good.
Homoeo Remedies:— Amm c., Apis., Arn., Ast r., Aur mur.,
Bapt., Bar c., Bar m.. Bell., Calc., Calc ars., Cann i., Carb v.,
China., Dul., Ferr., Graph., Hepar., Kalm., Lyco., Merc., Murex.,
Natr m., Nitr ac., Petr., Phos., Puis., Rhus., Sep., Sil., Sul., Thuja.
Nervous Constitution:— It is characterised by the predomi-
nance of the brain and the nervous system, by paleness and dryness
of the skin, by moderate stoutness, often leanness. Their complexion
is pale and colour of their hair variable; often brown. Nervous
persons are extremely sensitive, excited, impressionable, lively,
spirited and very active. They are liable to nervous disorders and
neuralgias. Their regime should be milk, vegetables and animal food.
Homoeo Remedies:— Aeon., Agar., Alum., Ambr., Anac.,
Arg n., Ars., Bar c., Bell., Calc., Cann i., Carb v., Cham., Chin s.,
China., Con., Cupr m., Dig., Graph., Hepar., Hy< s., Ign., Lach.,
Laur., Lyco., Magn c., Magn p., Mar v., Merc., Natr c., Natr m.,
Nux m., Nux v., Phos., Phos ac., Plat., Puis., Rhus., Sabin., Sec.,
Sep., Sil., Stann., Stram., Sul., Val., Viol., Zinc.
Bilious constitution:— See page 146.
Pathological Constitutions
Herpetic Constitution:— It is characterised by the vivacity
of the impressions by a natural heat more than ordinary, by rapidity
of digestion and all other functions in general, by leanness, a red
complexion, and rough skin. The vegetable regime suits it best.
Homoeo Remedies:— Bov., Calc., Graph., Lyco., Sil., Sul.
Hysterical Constitution:— It is characterised by great
nervousness. Hysterical persons are very impressionable and their
functions are very irregular. Their regime must be varied.
Homoeo Remedies:— Aeon., Gels., Phos ac.
Gouty Constitution:— It is characterised by stoutness or
atleast a florid nutrition, by the largeness of the articulations and
the bones, by diminished and feeble muscular strength, and an
inclination to good cheer. Their regime is vegetable.
Homoeo Remedies:— Apis., Aspar., Benz ac., Calc p., Caps.,
Carb s., Cham., Colch., Crot., Guaiac., Led., Lith., Lyco., Magn c.,
Menyanth., Sabin., Urt ur.
Haemorrhoidal Constitution:— It is characterised by
haemorrhages, fall of the anus in childhood, largeness of traite,
frequent cold and catarrh and irregularity of the intestinal functions.
Vegetable regime.
Homoeo Remedies:— Aes h., Calc., Caps., Caust., Crot.,
Graph., Ham., Mur ac., Nux v., Plat.
Tubercular Constitution:— It is characterised by sluggish
circulation of blood and nutrition by the fineness and delicateness
of the skin, the narrowness of the chest and natural openings, by the
prominence of the shoulders and the cheek bones, by the round spade
like shape of the end of the fingers. A milk and vegetable diet is
best for them, notwithstanding of the opinion of some that roast beef
and crude meat is good for tuberculous patients.
Homoeo Remedies:— Acet ac., Agar., Ars., Ars iod., Arum
t., Brom., Calc., Calc ars., Calc p., Hepar., Iod., Kali c., Kali iod.,
Lach., Lyco., Mang., Merc., Natr m., Natr s., Phos., Pix., Psor.,
Rhus., Sep., Sil. Spong., Stann., Stram., Sul., Tuber.
Occupation, regime, education and climate have a great
influence on constitution and modify them very much in time.
Children are generally lymphatic, young sanguine and old people
bilious.
References
Sarabhai Kapadia
P. Sankaran Impact of Bacteriology on Homoeopathic
J.N. Kanjilal Practice (Indian Journnal of Homoeopathic
Prakash Kumta Medicine—Oct./Dec. 1978)
S.P. Koppikar & others -
« » A P» i -d^als P u b l i s h e d
InthMfc % Pc'-iodicafe Publish&B
Bii.w*<5'/er2 Dcv
Basil. N e w D e l t i - l l 0 0 G 5 .
DR. Y. R. AGRAWAL