Apple Inc.

’s Business Strategy in China: Analysing Key Challenges and

Opportunities

Course

Student’s Name

Student’s Number

1
 Abstract

The critical overview in the report below relates to the activities done by Apple Inc. in

the People's Republic of China and concerns problems and strategic recommendations

for sustainable development. For Apple, the Chinese market has, essentially, both

provided it with and offered challenges since it is one fraught with regulatory

complexities, supply chain dynamics, and intense market competition. Another major

regulatory challenge is the "Great Firewall," which subscribes to heavy internet

censorship. This in turn affects the business that Apple engages in, as some of the

services are restricted and the respect accorded with local laws should be upheld since

this also affects user experience and efficiency in its operation. Other key issues involve

the risks and challenges in supply chain management and competitive pressure put by

local and international tech companies. To get these solutions in place, the

recommendation is to actively engage with the regulatory authorities beforehand, to

diversify the operations of supply chains and reduce their dependence on suppliers. In

this way, the implementation of these recommendations will greatly help Apple

maximise its competitiveness and sustain growth in the very dynamic Chinese market

while ensuring that it is placed rhythmically as a significant player in the technology

industry globally.

2
Table of Contents
Abstract..............................................................................................................................2
Introduction.......................................................................................................................4
Main Body.........................................................................................................................5
Overview of Apple Inc...................................................................................................5
Key Issues......................................................................................................................7
Regulatory Issues.......................................................................................................7
Supply Chain Management........................................................................................8
Market Competitiveness...........................................................................................10
Recommendations........................................................................................................11
Addressing Regulatory Challenges..........................................................................11
Enhancing Supply Chain Management....................................................................12
Making Stronger Competitive Position....................................................................12
Limitations...................................................................................................................14
Conclusion.......................................................................................................................15
References.......................................................................................................................17

3
 Apple Inc.’s Business Strategy in China: Analysing Key Challenges and

Opportunities

Introduction

This report contains a critical analysis of the business strategy of Apple Inc. in relation

to its international business, considering the operational base in the Chinese market.

Therefore, this report mainly seeks to identify and analyse the main strategic challenges

that face the Apple Company in China by using relevant theoretical frameworks,

including the Institutional-based view and the Resource-based view. This report will be

organised with an overview of Apple Inc., an analysis of its three major strategic issues,

a recommendation in the light of identified major strategic issues, limitation of the

recommendation, and finally, a conclusion.

Apple Inc. is an elite, well-known multinational technology company established in

1976 by Steve Jobs, Steve Wozniak, and Ronald Wayne. Headquartered in Cupertino,

California, the company develops and markets high-end, reputable products and

services, which include the iPhone, the iPad, the Mac, the Apple Watch, and a series of

related software and digital services. It has a large international market, operating in

over 100 countries and getting big revenue shares from its international markets.

The reason why the Chinese market is being focused on within this analysis is based on

several reasons. China is one of the largest and most important markets for Apple,

providing great revenue to the company among the rest of the countries in the world

(Richter, 2024). This market has unique challenges and opportunities arising out of its

regulatory environment, competitive landscape, and critical position within the Apple

supply chain. More to the point, rapid technological accomplishments in China and the

creation of the mammoth consumer market make China a crucial market for Apple’s

4
development and strategic moves. However, an analysis of Apple’s operations in China

gives valuable insight into how the company navigates difficult international business

environments and maintains its competitive edge in one of the world’s most dynamic

markets.

Apple’s net sales in Greater China Since Fiscal Year 2010 (Richter, 2024)

This critical analysis of Apple’s strategies in China should provide evidence-based

recommendations that are useful for improving the performance and sustainability of

this company in one of the most important markets.

Main Body

Overview of Apple Inc.

Apple Inc., founded in 1976 by Steve Jobs, Steve Wozniak, and Ronald Wayne, went

from being a small computer company in a garage to one of the most valuable and

influential technology behemoths on earth (Isaacson, 2021). To almost anybody, history

5
might just be labelled a series of innovations and iconic product launches, forever

pushing the limits in technology and design.

From the launch of the Apple I personal computer in 1976 to the revolutionary

Macintosh in 1984 and the game-changing iPod in 2001, Apple had shown it was in the

business of inventing new products that changed the rules of the game and touched

consumers around the world (Mallin and Finkle, 2011). Today, Apple operates in

different parts of the world, and its products are sold in various corners of the world.

The company’s retail footprint extends to over 500 stores in more than 25 countries,

providing customers with immersive experiences and personalised services (Tien,

2019).

Furthermore, Apple’s online properties and digital ecology, in particular the App Store,

iTunes, and iCloud, have all added up to making it a leader in the digital era, with strong

integration on the devices and solid user experience (Mallin and Finkle, 2011).

In the context of world business practices, Apple’s business in China is one of the most

significant operations in the world. China, being the country with the largest population

and a growing middle class, represents great opportunities and unique challenges for

Apple. However, regulatory barriers, heavy competition from domestic players, and the

need for colossal investments in China, including manufacturing facilities and retail

stores, characterise the firm’s operations. Apple has found a strong base in the market of

China with an ever-growing base of faithful customers and a strong network of supply

chains, to the extent that its contribution to the global revenue streams of the company

is highly significant.

6
The operations of Apple in the country of China include manufacturing, retail, and

marketing. The company partners with local companies and suppliers to meet Chinese

customers’ needs while ensuring that government requirements and cultural sensitivities

are adhered to (Ian, 2024). The ability of Apple to tailor its products and services in line

with Chinese customers’ preferences and needs has allowed it to operate successfully

amidst the complexities of the Chinese market, emerging as one of the top companies in

the technology field (Zeng, 2021).

Key Issues

Regulatory Issues

The regulatory environment that foreign companies have to work with while doing

business in China is complicated by the country’s centralised government structure and

rigorous regulations. The regulatory framework of China requires a great deal of keen

attention to compliance and adaption to the local laws and policies.

The extent of the regulatory environment in China includes intellectual property rights,

data privacy, and censorship, among others, of investments by foreigners. Adherence to

the set regulations will go a long way in ensuring that the business operations are not

only safeguarded but also in the prevention of legal infringements by any multinational

corporation, for instance, Apple.

One of the most critical aspects of the regulatory dimension in China is that it imposes

censorship and content control. The Chinese government is cautious about online

content. It has a hawk’s eye over it by using the Great Firewall to regulate and control

the internet, blocking websites and services that are uncomfortable for the government

or that are alleged to threaten national security (Froese et al., 2019). For a company like

7
Apple, which is engaging in the operation of digital platforms and services under the

mentioned condition of government scrutiny, the process is filled with problems.

More so, inherent in the regulatory environment of China are inclusive measures meant

to protect local industries and motivate indigenous innovation. Companies engaging in

foreign enterprises in China have to deal with market barriers, investment restrictions,

and requirements for technology transfer or joint ventures with local players. Market

access is restricted for Apple Inc. as a result of this regulation, which is costly to comply

with and might lower the company’s capability to develop and compete effectively in

the Chinese market. The effect of regulatory challenges on Apple’s operations in China

varies: some of the demands to stay in line with censorship and content regulations

include product and service modifications to fit in harmony with governmental edicts,

possibly compromising the user experience and functionality, respectively (Froese et al.,

2019). The other one is the foreign investment prohibition and technology transfer,

which will lead to Apple not being able to increase investments within the nation and

lead to the formation of strategic alliances with a local corporation in China (Kothari,

Kotabe and Murphy, 2013). Navigating through the challenges of the regulations in

China, therefore, requires Apple to strike a very delicate balance between regulatory

compliance, market competitiveness, and corporate values.

Supply Chain Management

In the case of Apple, China serves as the hub for the multinational’s global supply chain,

with all critical manufacturing and assembly operations taking place there. Key reasons

China plays an important role in Apple’s supply chain include a well-trained labour

force, an established infrastructure, and proximity to component suppliers (Enderwick

and Buckley, 2019).

8
The reliance of Apple on China in terms of manufacturing and assembly can be

underlined by the vast network of suppliers and contract manufacturers it has within this

territory. Foxconn, also known as Hon Hai Precision Industry Co. Ltd., is one of the

major manufacturing partners of Apple, running enormous manufacturing plants in

China, responsible for the production of products, including iPhones and iPads (Chan,

Pun, and Selden, 2016). Besides these, there are thousands of other suppliers and

subcontractors in China, again being critical to Apple’s overall supply chain ecosystem.

Besides cost efficiency and economies of scale, the concentration of all the production

activities in China has brought lots of benefits for Apple, ranging from streamlined

logistics. This creates an opportunity for Apple to take advantage of a large workforce in

China and the very vast manufacturing expertise that the country provides to expedite

and enhance production processes while keeping lead times at a minimum by

consolidating all production activities within the country(Chan, Pun, and Selden, 2016).

In addition, the strategic location of China allows the effective distribution of final

goods to global markets, thereby giving appropriate answers to the needs of customers.

At the same time, however, dependence on China in supply chains also comes with a lot

of risks and challenges to Apple. This is mainly sensitive to disruptions due to

geopolitical tensions, trade disputes, and natural disasters.

The US-China Trade War and COVID-19 pandemic have shown vividly how breakable

such chains are and, therefore, have placed an emphasis on the need for strategies in

diversification and risk mitigation (Zaheer, Mubariz, and Farooq, 2020). Besides, issues

related to labour, environmental standards, and ethical considerations collectively pose

additional challenges for Apple and its suppliers in China, meaning that compliance and

ethical sourcing always have to be worked on (Clarke and Boersma, 2017). In other

words, while China is a key player in Apple’s supply chain, it is relevant at the same

9
time in terms of the risks and challenges it poses. Resilience and sustainability also need

to be counterbalanced with operational efficiency and cost-effectiveness, which are two

major strategic imperatives that Apple needs to pursue in managing its supply chain in

China.

Market Competitiveness

China’s technology market is very competitive; international and local players are

fighting for a place and Chinese consumers’ attention. The competitive landscape is

dynamic and multifaceted within smartphones, tablets, wearables, and digital services

(Enderwick and Buckley, 2019).

In China, other companies such as Huawei, Xiaomi, Oppo, and Vivo also gave stiff

competition to Apple in the smartphone segment. These players rapidly gained share

with aggressive pricing strategies, product innovation, and strong brand presence on the

domestic front. Furthermore, in the country, Chinese tech giants such as Tencent and

Alibaba continue to find dominance in the digital services space with a wide variety of

products and platforms. These can rival the Apple ecosystem (Xing and Huang, 2021).

Further, Apple resorts to marketing and branding so that it can be more robust and more

appealing within the Chinese market. Being an iconic brand, it develops aspiration

marketing campaigns that would connect with the Chinese and create brand loyalty

among them (Ghar, 2024). What is more, Apple retail and online stores offer immersive

experiences and personalised service to customers, making long-term relationships with

them (Tom and Han, 2022).

Apple pays particular attention to customer service and after-sales support to make itself

more distinctive in the competition, and that increased customers’ satisfaction with the

brand. The strong emphasis on early updates, repairs, and technical support ensures a
10
positive ownership experience, hence building brand loyalty among Chinese consumers

to Apple(Kim. and Yim, 2022). In other words, even if there is intense competition in

the Chinese technology market, it is only in the strategic aspect of differentiation,

branding, and customer-centred actions that Apple can utilise to sustain and thrive in the

market for a long time.

Recommendations

While moving forward in this complex market, Apple ought to think through a few

strategic initiatives, especially in relation to regulatory, supply chain, and competitive

position issues. These are recommendations based on evidence-based insights that seek

to promote long-term sustainability and growth in China.

Addressing Regulatory Challenges

Apple may engage proactively with the Chinese regulatory authorities to imbibe

transparency and cooperation. Simply put, it gives Apple the potential to mitigate its

risks associated with changes in government policies and regulations through the

creation of open lines of communication and the demonstration of commitment to its

regulatory authorities. The company may also invest in technology and infrastructure to

improve the level of compliance with content moderation and censorship, in line with

Chinese regulatory needs, with only minimal or no effects on the user experience at all

(Froese et al., 2019).

Similarly, it can also diversify the product line and sources of revenue in a manner that

is not specific to a strict regulatory environment. Offering services other than hardware

products, such as digital content, cloud computing, and subscription-based services, will

11
ensure that Apple taps into extra revenues and can offer services not constrained by

regulations as much as other products do (Karhu et al., 2020).

Enhancing Supply Chain Management

Apple can approach being integrated to allow diversification, resilience, and

sustainability in supply chain risks and challenges. Accordingly, the company is also

looking at the most effective strategies to reduce this concentration by diversifying its

manufacturing and assembly activities across China (Russell and Taylor, 2019). For

instance, Apple has to diversify its manufacturing and assembling activities to more

places in China to minimise the associated risk to its supply chain.

In addition to that, Apple can further invest in advanced technologies, including

automation, artificial intelligence, and data analytics, to help optimise supply chain

processes, improve efficiency, and reduce dependency on manual labour. In the same

breath, Apple could enhance closer collaboration with its suppliers and subcontractors

to effect responsible sourcing practices, environmentally friendly stewardship, and

ethical labour standards being implemented across the entire operation of the supply

chain (Dash et al., 2019). As such, Apple will put itself in a position to mitigate against

reputational risks and, on the contrary, enhance a positive brand value by relating to

different stakeholders in long-term partnerships.

Making Stronger Competitive Position

Innovation, localisation, and customer-centric strategies could be the ways to allow

Apple to regain a competitive position in China’s dynamic market. The company may

invest in research and development of products and services that meet the preferences

and needs of Chinese consumers based on market research and consumer feedback

12
(Bereznoy, 2019). In addition, Apple could enhance the ecosystem of digital services

and content offerings with compelling value propositions and user engagement, which

are currently core functions of its platform (Zhang and Chen, 2019 ).

In addition to this, Apple could increase the number of its retail stores in China and

invest in more immersive experiences in-store to showcase its products and services.

Differentiated retail experience, combined with personalised services, will deepen brand

engagement, foster customer loyalty, and drive incremental sales for the company

(Reinartz and Linzbach, 2018).

Resource-Based View Analysis of Apple: Exploiting VRIO Framework

The RBV framework, with specific use on the VRIO model, explains the analysis by

which Apple tangible and intangible resources and capabilities provide a sustained

competitive advantage.

Value: Aesthetic Design: Apple has fashionable and minimalistic designs that add to the

experience of the user. This leads to a highly priced premium brand. Design excellence

is what brings loyal customers, allowing them to command high prices (Johnson et al.,

2012). Apple will continue remaining relevant among design-conscious consumers with

additional innovation in design.

Rarity: Outstanding Customer Service: A very broad support ecosystem, including the

Genius Bar and strong warranty programs for its product, enables qualitatively high

personalised help. This enables greater levels of customers' satisfaction and brand

allegiance through investment in infrastructure supporting customers (Pan, 2024).

Inimitability: Proprietary software and security Apple's bundled software and

hardware; iOS and macOS provide a seamless working experience for the user that is

almost impossible to emulate. Strong security controls further enhance inimitability

13
(Cusumano, Gawer, and Yoffie, 2019). Continued investment in software and security

innovation sustains Apple's market edge.

Organisational Support: In terms of readiness and infrastructure, as Apple's strong and

responsive organisational culture ensures that its vast resources are put to good use. This

is through efficient logistics combined with a very strong capability in R&D which has

sustained the innovativeness and competitiveness of Apple Inc (Tomongkhon, 2022).

These strategies will enhance the competitive standing of Apple if it is able to exploit

these VRIO dimensions, and this market success will be sustainable.

Limitations

Although the above recommendations offer strategies from which Apple can meet

regulatory challenges and improve its supply chain management to ensure competitive

strength in China, a few limitations and challenges need to be addressed.

First, internal stakeholders, such as management, employees, and shareholders, could

resist the implementation of these recommendations. There can be a resistance to

change and not much allocation of resources towards the recommendation, with other

competing priorities within the company that will not easily allow for the

implementation and execution of the recommended initiatives (Nadim and Singh,

2019).

Additionally, it should be noted that geopolitical tensions, any disturbances in trade

policies, and fluctuations in economic uncertainties in the external environment can also

be an acting challenge to the implementation of the recommendations. The changes in

government regulations, market dynamics, and consumer preferences may also require

alternations in the business strategies envisaged. So this would affect the effectiveness

and feasibility of their implementation (Moulton and Sandfort, 2017).

14
Aside from that, factors such as cultural issues, the language barrier, and typical

operational complexities of the Chinese market remain some that would likely inhibit

the smooth implementation of the recommendations. Alignment with local regulations,

the bureaucratic process, and the building of trust with stakeholders are issues of proper

preplanning, execution, and adaptability (Katsikeas, Leonidou and Zeriti, 2020).

The recommendations at least point the way toward dealing with the issues that have

hobbled Apple in the Chinese market. Overcoming these limitations and obstacles

would call for strategic foresight, organisational agility, and collaborative efforts with

internal and external stakeholders. Implementation should be proactive, and an iterative

approach with monitoring and evaluation should be realised to ensure high performance

and the success of proposed strategies.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the analysis of Apple’s operations in China shows how important the

Chinese market is in becoming a significant driver of growth and opportunity for the

company. While facing challenges from the regulatory environment to the supply chain

environment and under tough competition, Apple’s response showed resilience and

strategic agility in the wake of Chinese market complexities.

Key insights from the analysis include proactive engagement with regulatory

authorities, diversification of supply chain operations, innovation and a customer-

centric approach to drive sustainability and competitiveness in order to increase growth

in China. Going forward, Apple needs to make evidence-based recommendations that

target key regulatory challenges, improvements in supply chain management, and

increased competitive advantages. Its brand equity, technological know-how, and

15
customer-centric ethos should be used as a base upon which to further flourish and

innovate in the dynamic landscape of China’s markets.

16
 References

Bereznoy, A., 2019. Changing competitive landscape through business model

innovation: The new imperative for corporate market strategy. Journal of the

Knowledge Economy, 10(4), pp.1362-1383.

Chan, J., Pun, N. and Selden, M., 2016. Apple, Foxconn, and China’s new working

class. ILR Press, an imprint of Cornell University Press.

Clarke, T., and Boersma, M. (2017). The governance of global value chains: Unresolved

human rights, environmental and ethical dilemmas in the apple supply chain. Journal of

business ethics, 143, 111-131.

Cusumano, M.A., Gawer, A. and Yoffie, D.B., 2019. The business of platforms: Strategy

in the age of digital competition, innovation, and power (Vol. 320). New York: Harper

Business.

Dash, R., McMurtrey, M., Rebman, C. and Kar, U.K., 2019. Application of artificial

intelligence in automation of supply chain management. Journal of Strategic Innovation

and Sustainability, 14(3).

Enderwick, P. and Buckley, P.J., 2019. Beyond supply and assembly relations:

Collaborative innovation in global factory systems. Journal of Business Research, 103,

pp.547-556.

Froese, F.J., Sutherland, D., Lee, J.Y., Liu, Y. and Pan, Y., 2019. Challenges for foreign

companies in China: Implications for research and practice. Asian Business &

Management, 18, pp.249-262.

GHAR, S., 2024. Apple’s Innovation Odyssey: Deciphering the Route to Market

Leadership.

17
Ian (2024) Tim Cook and China: Apple’s Relationship with the Chinese Market.

https://press.farm/tim-cook-apples-relationship-with-chinese-market/.

Isaacson, W., 2021. Steve Jobs. Simon and Schuster.

Jobber, D. and Ellis-Chadwick, F., 2019. EBOOK: Principles and Practice of

Marketing, 9e. McGraw Hill.

Johnson, M. W., Li, Y., Phan, P. H., Singer, J., & Trinh, H. (2012). The Innovative

Success that is Apple Inc. Harvard Business Review, 90(3), 50-56.

Karhu, K., Gustafsson, R., Eaton, B., Henfridsson, O. and Sørensen, C., 2020. Four

tactics for implementing a balanced digital platform strategy. MIS Quarterly

Executive, 19(2), pp.105-120.

Katsikeas, C., Leonidou, L. and Zeriti, A., 2020. Revisiting international marketing

strategy in a digital era: Opportunities, challenges, and research directions. International

Marketing Review, 37(3), pp.405-424.

Kim, S. and Yim, M.Y.C., 2022. Exploring consumers’ attitude formation toward their

own brands when in crisis: cross-national comparisons between USA and

China. Journal of Product & Brand Management, 31(1), pp.56-72.

Kothari, T., Kotabe, M. and Murphy, P., 2013. Rules of the game for emerging market

multinational companies from China and India. Journal of International Management,

19(3), pp.276-299.

Mallin, M.L. and Finkle, T.A., 2011. Apple Inc.: product portfolio analysis. Journal of

the International Academy for Case Studies, 17(7), p.63.

Moulton, S. and Sandfort, J.R., 2017. The strategic action field framework for policy

implementation research. Policy Studies Journal, 45(1), pp.144-169.

18
Nadim, A. and Singh, P., 2019. Leading change for success: embracing

resistance. European Business Review, 31(4), pp.512-523.

Pan, Y., 2024. Apple's Secret to Being Successful: Research on Apple's Commercial

Marketing Strategy Based on Multi-marketing Framework. Journal of Education,

Humanities and Social Sciences, 27, pp.413-418.

Reinartz, W. and Linzbach, P., 2018. Customer loyalty and reward programs in retail in

the digitalage. In Handbook of Research on Retailing (pp. 296-328). Edward Elgar

Publishing.

Richter, F. (2024) ‘How important is China for Apple?,’ Statista Daily Data, 5 February.

https://www.statista.com/chart/13246/apple-china-revenue/.

Russell, R.S. and Taylor, B.W., 2019. Operations and supply chain management. John

Wiley & Sons.

Tien, N.H., 2019. International distribution policy comparative analysis between

samsung and apple. International journal of research in marketing management and

sales, 2020(1), p.2.

Tom Dieck, M.C. and Han, D.I.D., 2022. The role of immersive technology in Customer

Experience Management. Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice, 30(1), pp.108-

119.

TOMONGKHON, J., 2022. A STUDY ON THE INFLUENCE OF

ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE ON INNOVATION MANAGEMENT: A CASE OF

APPLE INC (Doctoral dissertation, SIAM UNIVERSITY).

19
Xing, Y. and Huang, S., 2021. Value captured by China in the smartphone GVC–A tale

of three smartphone handsets. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics, 58, pp.256-

266.

Zaheer, F., Mubariz, S. and Farooq, A., 2020. The US-China Trade War and its

Implications for Global Economy. ASIAN Journal of International Peace & Security

(AJIPS), 4(1), pp.176-186.

Zeng, L., 2021. An Analysis of Apple’s Internationalization Strategy. International

Journal of Frontiers in Sociology, 3(17).

Zhang, M.L. and Chen, M.S., 2019. China’s digital economy: Opportunities and risks.

International Monetary Fund.

20