Grade 12 Economics Unit 3 Note
Grade 12 Economics Unit 3 Note
Grade 12 Economics
Unit 3
Market Failure and Consumer
Protection
By: Muhdin Z Secret Training Institute
MUHDIN M. Z SECRET TRAINING INSTITUTE 11/21/2024 1
Part-1
Market Failure
Definition of Market Failure
Common Types of Market Failures
Solutions to Market Failures
Public Goods
Definition and features of Public Goods
Public goods Vs Private Goods
Mechanisms of Efficient Provision of Public Goods
1
11/21/2024
Part-2
Externalities
• Definition of Externalities
• Nature and Types of externalities
• Externalities and Economic Efficiency
• Solutions to avoid externalities
Part-3
• Asymmetric Information
• Definition of Asymmetric Information
• Implications of Asymmetric Information
• Consumer Protection
• Concept of consumer protection
• The need for consumer protection
• Consumer protection experience in Ethiopia
2
11/21/2024
Part-1
Market Failure
Definition of Market Failure
Common Types of Market Failures
Solutions to Market Failures
Public Goods
Definition and features of Public Goods
Public goods Vs Private Goods
Mechanisms of Efficient Provision of Public Goods
Market Failure
Although the free market has numerous merits, it may not allocate
resources efficiently or distribute goods and services equitably.
3
11/21/2024
Market failure occurs when the free market fails to allocate resources
efficiently or distribute goods and services equitably.
Market Failure: occurs when the price mechanism fails to account for all of the costs
and benefits that are necessary to provide and consume a good.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 7
Furthermore, market failure implies that the individual incentives for rational
behavior do not lead to rational outcomes for the group.
Such a group either incurs too many costs or receives too few
benefits.
4
11/21/2024
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 9
Market failure does not describe inherent imperfections in the market economy-
there can be market failures in government activity, too.
Example: Rent-seeking by special interest groups.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 10
5
11/21/2024
Additionally, not every bad outcome from market activity counts as a market
failure.
Nor does a market failure imply that private market actors cannot
solve the problem.
Not all market failures have a potential solution, even with prudent
regulation or extra public awareness.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 11
6
11/21/2024
Public goods: Occurs when goods and services are non-excludable and
non-rivalrous.
Example: National defense, Street lighting
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 13
7
11/21/2024
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 15
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 16
8
11/21/2024
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 17
9
11/21/2024
Public Goods
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 19
10
11/21/2024
Goods that fulfill both these properties are known as “pure public goods”.
Examples of such goods are national defence, clean air, biodiversity,
wilderness, etc.
At the other extreme, pure private goods which are rivalrous in consumption and
excludable.
Most goods around us fall into this category.
E.g. Food items, clothes, household furniture, houses.
There are also goods which fall in between these two extremes.
These goods satisfy one part of the definition of a public good and not another
They are called “impure public goods”.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 22
11
11/21/2024
Examples
Radio/ TV Program Subscription
Toll roads- roads with payment (Adama-Addis Express Road)
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 23
2- Although everyone consumes the same quantity of Public goods, they may
not value them equally.
Example: for some individuals, national defence is very
important while others do not care for it, some others still
value it negatively though it is equally available to all.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 24
12
11/21/2024
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 26
13
11/21/2024
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 27
“a person who benefits from a good or service without contributing to its cost.”
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 28
14
11/21/2024
It is this free rider problem that causes markets to operate inefficiently for public
goods.
Market failed to supply public goods.
The private market may provide no output as no one is willing to
purchase it.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 30
15
11/21/2024
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 31
Summary-Public Goods
At the other extreme, pure private goods which are rivalrous in consumption and
excludable.
There are also goods which fall in between these two extremes.
16
11/21/2024
Part-2
Externalities
• Definition of Externalities
• Nature and Types of externalities
• Externalities and Economic Efficiency
• Solutions to avoid externalities
17
11/21/2024
Externalities
“Externality occurs when action of one party affects the other party without in
unintended manner without due compensation.”
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 35
18
11/21/2024
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 38
19
11/21/2024
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 39
NB:
While public goods always generate external benefits,
externalities can generate either benefits or costs.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 40
20
11/21/2024
This concept is related to the question that whether the injured or injurer is
responsible in car accident.
Externalities are not the result of one person’s action, but results from
combined action of two or more parties.
Hence,
the externality affects both consumers and producers, creating a
reciprocal relationship.
This can make it more difficult to address externalities through
market-based solutions alone, as both parties may be affected by
the same issue.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 42
21
11/21/2024
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 43
MSC=MPC+MEC
MSC is marginal social cost
MPC marginal private cost
MEC marginal external cost
22
11/21/2024
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 45
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 46
23
11/21/2024
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 48
24
11/21/2024
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 49
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 50
25
11/21/2024
This type of solution was proposed for the first time by A.C. Pigou in 1920 on the basis
of the following assumptions.
Externality is the difference between MSC and MPC.
There is competitive industry.
A firm producing output and emitting smoke.
Pollution per unit of output is constant.
The external cost of pollution is borne by others.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 51
The optimum outcome depends on the bargaining power of the parties this
is known as the Coase theorem.
The optimum pollution does not mean zero pollution as the
latter implies zero production.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 52
26
11/21/2024
c. Defining and enforcing property rights for those who would like to pollute the
environment.
This means the sale of property rights.
Since producers incur some additional costs due to the
property rights, they will take this consideration into their
production decisions and hence, produce relatively smaller
quantities, as a result of which less pollution occurs.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 53
b. The government itself can supply the product at a price of Ps and hence, bear
the loss.
27
11/21/2024
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 55
Summary- Externalities
An externality occurs when the consumption or the production of goods has positive
or negative effects on other people’s utility where these effects are not reflected in the
price.
28
11/21/2024
In the presence of externality, the free market economy will not allocate resources
efficiently.
inefficiency is created due to over production and under production
In general, all solutions to externality (positive and negative) problems recognize that
the need for internalizing externalities.
29
11/21/2024
Part-3
• Asymmetric Information
• Definition of Asymmetric Information
• Implications of Asymmetric Information
• Consumer Protection
• Concept of consumer protection
• The need for consumer protection
• Consumer protection experience in Ethiopia
Asymmetric Information
Definition
Asymmetric information is a situation in which different agents have a different
amount of information about a good.
30
11/21/2024
In certain transactions,
Sellers can take advantage of buyers because asymmetric
information exists whereby the seller has more knowledge of
the good being sold than the buyer.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 61
It is sometimes known as
“hidden information problem” or
“anti-selection problem” or ‘
“negative selection problem”.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 62
31
11/21/2024
Examples:
Used car market: Sellers know more about the quality of their
used cars than buyers.
Health Insurance Market: Health insurance is more likely to be
purchased by people who are more likely to get sick.
Job Market: Workers may have hidden characteristics that make
them less desirable to employers
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 63
In simple words, it is the inability to observe and/or verify the agents’ action.
32
11/21/2024
A moral hazard problem arises when an individual or situation does not bear
the full consequences of its actions.
Therefore, there is a tendency to act less carefully than it
otherwise would.
Examples:
Employment: An employee who knows they are unlikely to be fired
may be less productive or motivated.
Car Insurance: A person with comprehensive car insurance might be
less careful, knowing that the insurance will cover any damages.
Government Programs: Welfare recipients may reduce their work
effort if they believe that their benefits will not be affected.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 65
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 66
33
11/21/2024
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 67
Limitations:
Signals requires significant cost
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 68
34
11/21/2024
Screening
Refers to a strategy of combating adverse selection.
Assume there are two individuals Hana and Hikma. Hana knows more about
herself than Hikma knows about Hana.
If they are going to engage in some sort of transaction, they
need to develop a long term relationship.
Banks often screen people who are interested in borrowing money in order to
weed out those who will not be able to repay the debt.
They might also ask potential borrowers for their financial
history, job security, reason for borrowing assets, education,
experience, etc.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 69
Summary-Asymmetric Information
Asymmetric information is when one party in a transaction is in possession of more
information than the other.
Symmetric information means that all parties have complete information
about the economic variables that are relevant for their decisions.
35
11/21/2024
Consumer Protection
Concept of Consumer Protection
Consumer protection means safeguarding the interest and rights of consumers.
In other words, it refers to the measures adopted for the protection
of consumers from corrupted and unethical malpractices.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 71
36
11/21/2024
g) Charging more than the maximum retail price fixed for the product.
i) Misleading advertisements
i.e., advertisements that falsely claim a product or service is of
superior quality, grade or standard.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 73
The consumers have the basic right to be protected from the loss or
injury which is caused by defective goods and deficiency of services.
But many consumers do not exercise their rights due to lack of awareness,
ignorance, or laziness.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 74
37
11/21/2024
The other main arguments in favor of consumer protection are outlined below:
Social Responsibility
The business must be guided by certain social and ethical norms.
It is the moral responsibility of the business to serve the
interest of consumers.
It is the duty of producers and traders to provide the right quality and
quantity of goods at fair prices to consumers.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 76
38
11/21/2024
Increasing Awareness
Consumers are becoming more mature and conscious of their rights
against the malpractices by business.
They take up their cases at various levels and helping them to
enforce their rights.
Consumer Satisfaction
Consumers’ satisfaction is the key to the success of a business.
Business should take every step to serve the interests of
consumers by providing them the quality goods and services at
reasonable prices.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 77
Principle of Trusteeship
Manufactures and producers are not the real owners of business.
This is because resources are supplied by the society.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 78
39
11/21/2024
2. Consumers should buy goods and services on the basis of their own
choice.
40
11/21/2024
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 81
The main objectives of the Consumer Protection Act in Ethiopia are to:
1. Protect the
business community from anti-competitive and unfair market
practices,
consumers from misleading market conducts, and
to establish a system that is conducive to the promotion of a
competitive free market.
2. Ensure that consumers get goods and services safe and suitable to their
health and equivalent to the price they pay.
MUHDIN M. 11/21/2024 82
41
11/21/2024
The necessity of adopting measures to protect the interest of consumers arises mainly
due to the helpless position of the consumers.
In Ethiopia, the Trade competition and Consumer Proclamation No. 813/2013 has
provided the rights to consumers.
THANK YOU!
84
42