Political Science Solution

WESTERN POLITICAL THOUGHT  PLATO  PLATO'S THEORY OF JUSTICE

Plato: Exploring the Philosopher King, Educational

Theory, and Communism
By: Politicalsciencesolution.Com
15 September 2023

Introduction
Plato, born in 427 BC in Athens, is regarded as the Father of Political Philosophy and the founder of
Philosophical Idealism. A student of Socrates, Plato laid the philosophical foundation for Western political thought,
influencing generations of thinkers. His work introduced utopian thinking and emphasized the pursuit of ideal forms
beyond material appearances. As a rationalist and revolutionary, Plato envisioned an ideal society that challenged the
existing order. While some criticized his ideas as impractical, his legacy endures, with many idealists considering
him their teacher. Plato’s influence remains unparalleled in philosophy, political theory, and Western intellectual
tradition.

Table of Contents
Events Shaped Plato’s Life

Influences on Plato

Plato’s notable works

Plato’s Methodology

Philosophical Foundations of Plato’s Political Thought

Theory of Ideas

Theory of Souls

Theory of Justice

Theory of Education

Theory of Communism
Theory of Philosopher King

Criticism:

Ideal State: The Ruling Class/Philosophic Ruler by Plato

Quotes by Plato

Conclusion

Commentaries on Plato
Events Shaped Plato’s Life

Plato was born in 427 BCE in Athens during the Peloponnesian War, a conflict that saw the eventual fall of Athens.
He came from an aristocratic family, with his father, Ariston, descending from the last tribal king Codrus and
possibly the god Poseidon. His mother, Perictione, was related to Solon, the famous lawgiver of Athens. After his
father’s death, his mother married Pyrilampes, a political associate of Pericles. Though Plato initially aspired to a
political career, his experiences soon led him in a different direction.

In 399 BCE, Plato’s mentor, Socrates, was executed by the Athenian government on charges of corrupting the youth
and impiety. This event profoundly influenced Plato, leading him to criticize the flaws of democracy. The political
turmoil and the unjust trial of Socrates convinced Plato that true justice could only emerge from philosopher-
kings, an idea central to his later works.

In 387 BCE, Plato founded the Academy in Athens, an institution that became a cornerstone of intellectual and
philosophical learning in Europe. The Academy provided a broad curriculum, including subjects like philosophy,
astronomy, biology, and mathematics. Plato’s inscription on its entrance famously read, “Those having no
knowledge of mathematics need not enter here.”

In 367 BCE, Plato sought to implement his philosophical ideas in practical politics by traveling to Syracuse to tutor
Dionysius II, the ruler of Syracuse, in the hopes of creating a philosopher-king. However, political tensions arose,
and the experiment failed. Plato made a second attempt in 361 BCE, but it also ended in failure, leading to his arrest
and imprisonment by Dionysius.

Plato spent his final years teaching at the Academy and writing some of his most influential works. He died in
348/347 BCE, leaving the management of the Academy to his nephew, Speusippus, ensuring the continued influence
of his ideas on Western thought.

Influences on Plato
Plato’s philosophical ideas were substantially shaped by the prevailing intellectual climate of his time and the
teachings of notable thinkers such as Pythagoras, Parmenides, Heraclitus, and, most significantly, Socrates.

Context of Plato’s Times in Athens:

During Plato’s lifetime, Athens experienced defeat by Sparta in the Peloponnesian War. This defeat fueled Plato’s
desire to understand the reasons behind Athens’ downfall. He lived through a tumultuous period in Greek history,
witnessing the tyrannical rule of reactionaries, which he deemed corrupt. This experience motivated his quest to
establish an Ideal State, with the Rule of the Philosopher King as the solution.

Influences from Other Philosophers:

From Pythagoras, Plato adopted the concept of the Transmigration of Souls and the idea that the universe is
based on mathematical and logical principles, suggesting that society should also adhere to these principles.
Plato’s affinity for geometry can also be traced to Pythagoras, emphasizing its logical nature.

Heraclitus‘s belief in the continuous change of life influenced Plato’s view that change is fundamental in the
world.

Parmenides taught Plato that despite the ever-changing world, there exists something permanent: Ideas. Plato
amalgamated these views to assert that knowledge was a virtue attainable solely through intellect.
Socrates:


Socrates profoundly influenced Plato’s philosophical development, with Plato regarding him as the wisest man on
Earth. Socrates introduced Plato to the dialectical method and imparted three fundamental doctrines: Virtue is
Knowledge (which became the foundation of Plato’s political philosophy), the Theory of Reality, and the Theory
of Knowledge. This influence is highlighted by Professor Maxey, who notes that Plato’s writings feature an
“apotheosized Socrates,” blending Socratic thought with Plato’s imaginative interpretations. While the extent to
which Plato’s works reflect Socrates’ actual ideas is debated, it is clear that Socrates was a crucial figure in shaping
Plato’s philosophy.

It is well said by George Sabine in A History of Political Theory (1973) that the fundamental idea of The
Republic came to Plato through his master’s doctrine that virtue is knowledge: “The proposition… implies that
there is an objective good to be known and that it can in fact be known by rational or logical investigation rather
than by intuition, guesswork, or luck.” Plato embraced this doctrine, emphasizing that true goodness can be
understood rationally. He identified four key elements of human nature—reason, courage, temperance, and justice
—through which individuals could achieve virtue, inspiring them to pursue their ends effectively.

Additionally, Plato adopted the notion that rulers should be knowledgeable, akin to artists or navigators, an idea
rooted in Socratic thought. Socrates asserted that the public was “ill,” indicating a need for capable leaders.
This notion of governance as an art, along with the intellectualist perspective that salvation lies in having adequately
educated rulers, illustrates how deeply Socrates’ influence permeated Plato’s works. Ultimately, Socrates remains a
central character in Plato’s dialogues, underscoring his lasting impact on Plato’s philosophy.

Plato’s notable works

“The Republic” (386 BC): A comprehensive work that explores justice, education, communism, and the institution
of the philosopher-king within an ideal state. Republic was basically a dialogue between Socrates, Cephalus and his
sons – Polemarchus, Thrasymachus, Glaucon, and Adeimantus. In Republic Plato also gave the concept of
“Kallipolis” – A Utopian City

Note – “Republic of Plato is all about Education” – Rousseau

“The Statesman” (360 BC): Reflects Plato’s stance on democracy, featuring classifications of states and
constitutions. In this book he gave preference to “rule of law”.

“The Laws” (347 BC): Demonstrates Plato’s evolving thoughts, moving away from the concept of the philosopher-
king to embrace the Rule of Law. This is the Plato’s longest dialogue.

In Laws Plato also described Magnesia, the envisioned settlement on Crete, an independent agricultural community
positioned approximately nine to ten miles away from the coast. Its isolated location is designed to discourage the
influence of outsiders who might disrupt Magnesia’s cultural integrity. Nevertheless, Magnesia will still
accommodate a population of enslaved individuals and foreigners responsible for tasks that citizens are prohibited
from engaging in, such as trade and menial labor.

The political structure of Magnesia will be a hybrid, combining elements of democracy and authoritarianism. This is
evident in the management of political offices, with the most prestigious being the “nocturnal council.” This
council’s primary responsibility will involve delving into the philosophical underpinnings of law and providing
insights on how these principles can be applied within the Magnesian society.
Note – Al-Farabi wrote the summary of Plato’s Laws.


Some other important works are:

The Symposium – Metaphysics of Love

Apology – Novel

Phaedo – Theory of Soul

Gorgias

Crito

Critias

Meno

Sophist

Timaeus – The Sphere of Physics

Noble Lie

Plato’s Methodology
Plato’s methodology is primarily deductive, starting with general principles and applying them to specific
situations. This approach contrasts with induction, where conclusions arise from observation. Plato aimed to identify
the characteristics of an ideal state based on his vision of “what ought to be,” often clashing with the realities of
ancient Greek society, which left him feeling disillusioned. While his methodology is chiefly deductive, it also
incorporates inductive elements, reflecting the interplay between theory and practice.

Another vital aspect of Plato’s method is dialectics, a technique inherited from Socrates. Through dialogues, he
examined competing viewpoints, exposing contradictions and guiding others toward understanding complex
concepts, especially justice. This process involved debates among characters like Cephalus and Thrasymachus,
showcasing how dialectical reasoning deepens philosophical inquiry.

Additionally, Plato employed analytical, teleological, and historical methods. He broke down phenomena into parts,
assigning roles to different social classes based on qualities like appetite and reason. His teleological perspective
emphasized that every phenomenon has an inherent purpose, evident in his theory of Forms. He was an idealist,
concerned with envisioning “what ought to be” rather than describing “what is.” By examining historical
contexts in works like Statesman, Plato blended deductive reasoning with real-world insights, creating a rich and
multifaceted approach to philosophy.

Philosophical Foundations of Plato’s Political

Thought

Theory of Ideas by Plato

Plato’s Theory of Ideas asserts that reality reflects perfect and eternal Forms, distinguishing the unchanging realm
of Ideas from the ever-changing material world. He illustrates this concept through the “Allegory of the Cave,”
which shows how individuals must move from the shadows of ignorance into the light of knowledge. This theory is
foundational to Plato’s philosophy, linking knowledge, psychology, ethics, and politics. He believed that true
knowledge is certain and infallible, contrasting it with mere appearances.


In The Republic, Plato differentiates between opinion, based on the physical world, and knowledge, which involves
reason and understanding of higher realities. His allegory depicts prisoners chained in a cave, seeing only
shadows. When one escapes, he discovers the true world, realizing that what they saw were mere illusions.
Plato emphasizes that achieving true knowledge requires moving from appearances to the realm of Forms.

At the top of Plato’s hierarchy of Forms is the Form of the Good, which illuminates all other Ideas and represents
the ultimate goal of existence. For Plato, virtue is knowledge; understanding leads to virtuous action. He argued that
rulers should be philosophers, as those with knowledge would govern wisely, ensuring societal peace. Thus, Plato’s
Theory of Forms serves as a practical guide, emphasizing the essential connection between knowledge and virtue in
ethics and governance.

Theory of Souls by Plato

Plato’s Theory of Souls, often referred to as the Myth of Metals, can be traced back to the influence of Pythagoras.
According to Plato’s philosophy, every human possesses a soul, which he believes is composed of three distinct
elements: reason, courage, and appetite.

Plato emphasizes that not all souls are created equal; rather, they exhibit varying degrees of dominance among these
three elements. The rare individuals in whom reason dominates are classified as the “Man of Gold.” In contrast,
those in whom courage dominates are known as the “Man of Silver.” The majority of individuals, in whom appetite
prevails, are labeled as the “Men of Copper.”

In Plato’s Ideal State, he envisions a society organized into three distinct classes based on the quality of souls or
spiritual characteristics. These classes include the ruling class, associated with wisdom; the soldier class, embodying
courage; and the producing class, representing temperance.

Theory of Justice by Plato

For Plato, justice is rooted in the inner nature of the human spirit and transcends mere law adherence. It protects the
weaker members of society and is achieved when rulers, soldiers, and producers fulfill their designated roles for the
common good. In a just state, rulers are wise, soldiers are brave, and producers exhibit self-control.

Central to The Republic, subtitled “Concerning Justice,” justice (or “Dikaiosyne”) is a moral concept linked to
righteousness and social ethics. Barker says: “Justice is, for Plato, at once a part of human virtue and the bond
which joins men together in the state. It makes man good and makes him social.” Sabine adds that “Justice (for
Plato) is a bond which holds a society together.” Plato critiques existing theories, rejecting Cephalus’ and
Polemarchus’ views focused on reciprocity, as well as Thrasymachus’ claim that justice serves the stronger. Instead,
he maintains that true justice benefits everyone.

Plato argues that justice involves performing one’s duties without interference rather than merely enjoying
rights and serves as a bond that holds society together. Through dialogues with Glaucon and Adeimantus, he
asserts that justice is a natural and universal principle, advocating for individuals to fulfill their roles based on their
abilities. His theory promotes specialization and harmony in society, positioning justice as both a public and private
virtue essential for the collective good. Ultimately, while justice emphasizes duty and virtue, it also reflects a
totalitarian aspect that prioritizes the state over individual interests.
Theory of Education by Plato

Plato’s Republic is not just a governmental essay; as Rousseau highlights, it serves as a treatise on education.
Its aim is to reform ancient Greek society—politically, economically, socially, morally, and culturally—by
establishing justice. For Plato, education is essential for achieving social justice and addressing societal issues.

Plato’s Theory of Education serves as a means to identify the spiritual qualities of a soul and establish an Ideal State.
According to Plato, “State is the reflection of individuals“. He combines elements of the Spartan and Athenian
education systems to create a holistic approach to education, considering it vital for the harmonious functioning of
both the state and society. Barker rightly says that Plato’s scheme of
education brings the soul into that environment which in each stage of its growth is best suited
for its development.

Key features of Plato’s educational scheme include state-controlled education for both men and women, strict
censorship of literature, compulsory education, a focus on both mental and moral development, and a strong
connection with the soul. Plato envisions the production of philosopher-kings through education.

The stages of Plato’s education system consist of:

Stage I (0-18 years): Primary and secondary education, involving music, gymnastics, moral stories, and basic
education in various disciplines.

Stage II (18-20 years): Compulsory military education and the first filtration process, where those who fail join
the producer class.

Higher Education (20-35 years): In-depth education in subjects like mathematics, astronomy, logics, and
sciences, with a focus on geometry, leading to a second filtering process. Those with logical aptitude continue,
while others join the soldier class. The age of 30-35 involves dialectical method training.

Practical Training (35-50 years): Individuals become eligible to become philosopher-kings at the age of 50.

Plato’s perspective on education is comprehensive and emphasizes that it should be a lifelong process.

Theory of Communism by Plato

Plato’s Theory of Communism is a vital part of his political philosophy, influenced by the city-state of Sparta. It
advocates for communal ownership of property and the family, aiming to eliminate personal wealth and familial ties
among the ruling and soldier classes.

Key Aspects:
1. Communism of Property: Members of the ruling and soldier classes cannot own private property. This
restriction ensures that their focus remains on serving the state without the distractions of personal wealth.

2. Communism of Family: Plato goes further by proposing that marriages and children be shared among the
guardian class. The state determines marital arrangements to promote a more intelligent and capable citizenry. In
this framework:
The entire state is considered one family.

There is no permanent marriage; men and women are shared under state authority.

Child-rearing becomes a state responsibility, which ensures that all children are treated equally, relieving
women of domestic duties.
Plato’s notion of justice is intrinsically linked to his communism theory. He argues that justice is achieved when the
rulers (guardians) and auxiliaries abandon property and familial connections, as these elements create discord within

society. As Barker states, the abolition of family life among the guardians is a direct consequence of renouncing
private property. Dunning echoes this by asserting that both private property and family relationships are significant
sources of conflict in communities.

Criticism:
Plato’s theory has faced criticism from several thinkers, including Aristotle and Karl Popper:

Aristotle criticizes Plato for ignoring natural acquisitive instincts and creating a partial scheme by excluding the
producing class, deeming it ascetic and aristocratic.

Karl Popper raises concerns about the practicality of Plato’s ideas, suggesting:
The communism of families may not create unity, as shared relationships could lead to confusion.

Common children might be neglected, as “everyone’s child” could become “nobody’s child.”

State-controlled mating may reduce individuals to mere animals, undermining genuine human relationships.

The entire scheme is too rigid and idealistic, lacking realism.

Overall, Plato’s communism emphasizes eliminating personal interests to establish a just society, with a strong focus
on communal property and family structures. However, its feasibility and implications for human relationships face
significant critiques from philosophers throughout history.

Ideal State: The Ruling Class/Philosophic Ruler by

Plato
Plato’s political philosophy presents a strong case for an omni-competent state, emphasizing that while living is one
thing, living well is another. The government’s role is to help people achieve a complete life. Plato’s focus is not
merely on creating a government but establishing a just and ideal one.

In “The Republic,” he outlines the ideal state in three stages: the healthy state (or “the city of pigs”), which satisfies
basic needs through the division of labor; the luxurious state, emerging from the desires of the healthy state,
requiring auxiliary classes; and the just state, where philosophers guide the community. This illustrates the three
classes of the ideal state: the producing class, the auxiliary class, and the ruling class.

Plato’s rulers, whether philosophers in “The Republic,” statesmen in “The Statesman,” or laws in “The Laws,” are
tasked with promoting the community’s interests. Their goal is the greatest happiness of the whole, maintaining
order and justice. Rulers must be wise, courageous, temperate, and just, using their knowledge to perform their
responsibilities effectively. The use of analogies throughout his works highlights the importance of skilled
governance, comparing rulers to artists, shepherds, and physicians.

Knowledge is paramount for rulers to carry out their duties perfectly. They must know the science of politics and
apply it as artists apply their craft. To ensure rulers remain aligned with their ideals, Plato employs communistic
principles, emphasizing loyalty to customs and laws.

Plato’s Theory of the Philosopher King underscores the need for competent individuals to govern. He critiques
democratic systems, advocating for a government led by an intellectual elite. He posits that for a city to become
ideal, philosophers must rule or rulers must embrace philosophy, eliminating corruption and evil.
The Philosopher King must possess reason, undergo 50 years of education, and have no personal property or
family. They are granted absolute power, with their wisdom unchallengeable by public opinion, but cannot alter the

state’s constitution or laws.

In “Laws,” Plato assigns significant importance to law, viewing it as essential for maintaining order and justice
within the ideal state. He prioritizes duties over individual rights, leading some to label him as the first fascist
in history. Plato’s philosophy reflects authoritarian ideals, advocating for a society governed by a wise elite
committed to the common good.

Quotes by Plato

⮚ “Human behavior flows from three main sources: desire, emotion, and knowledge.”
⮚ “Ideas are the source of all things”
⮚ “Ignorance, the root and steam of all evil”.
⮚ “No law or ordinance is mightier than understanding.”
⮚ “Those states are best governed where the ruler is least interested to govern”
⮚ “It is foolish to limit an expert practitioner of medicine with the book of medicine”.

Conclusion

“One can be either Platonic or anti-Platonic but can never be non-platonic” – Karl Popper.
“Plato is Philosophy and Philosophy is Plato” – R.W. Emerson

The political philosophy of Plato has left a deep impact on the political thought and ideologies which emerged in the
subsequent centuries. It is rightly said – “Western political thought is nothing but footnotes to Aristotle and Plato”.

Commentaries on Plato
1. Justice for Plato is at once a part of human virtue and the bond which joins men together in the states – Barker .

2. Virtually all socialistic and communistic thought has its roots in Plato – Maxey

3. Plato may not be everybody’s saint, but undoubtedly he is everybody’s teacher – R. N. BERKI

4. Modern communist totalitarianism has been derived from Platonic communism – Karl Popper

5. Plato introduced authoritarianism in politics – Bertrand Russell

6. Plato’s Justice is a bound which holds the society together – Sabine

7. Plato was cynical, reactionary, inhumane, and highly imaginative – Toynbee

8. Plato was wrong for his time and ours – R.H Crossman

9. Plato as father of Philosophy, Politics and Literary idealism – Benjamin Jowett.

Some Important Books on Plato

1. “In Defense of Plato” – Ronald R. Levinson

2. “Plato’s Modern Enemies and theory of Natural Law” – John Wild

3. “Plato Today” – RHS Crossman

4. “The man and his work” – AE Taylor

5. “Lectures on the Republic of Plato” – RL Nettleship

6. “Platonic Legend” – W. Fite

Latest Topics to read –

21st ASEAN-India Summit 2024: India and Canada at a Crossroads: India’s Path to Escaping the Middle-
PM Modi’s 10-Point Plan for Unpacking the Nijjar Controversy Income Trap: Education, Innovation,
Strengthening India-ASEAN and Historical Roots and Jobs
Relations

Congress’s Major Setback: Ratan Tata’s Life and Legacy: 10

Analyzing BJP’s Victory in Haryana Inspiring Facts About the Man
and Jammu & Kashmir Elections Behind the Tata Group’s Global
Success