Special Education Analysis
Special Education Analysis
Although the discrepancy model has dominated the school system for
many years, there have been significant criticisms of this approach (e.g.,
Aaron, 1995, Flanagan & Mascolo, 2005) among researchers. One reason for
criticism is that the diagnosis of learning difficulties is based on the difference
between performance and IQ and does not predict the effectiveness of
treatment. In the case of poor academic performance, those who also have
low IQs seem to benefit from treatment.
Sternberg (1999) has argued that early intervention can reduce the
number of children who meet criteria for learning disabilities. He has also
suggested that the focus on learning disabilities and the provision of
accommodation at school fails to take into account that people have a range
of strengths and weaknesses, and places excessive emphasis on academics,
insisting that people should be supported in this area rather than music or
sport.