Maintaining Records of Stock Levels: Paper vs.

Electronic

Maintaining accurate records of stock levels is crucial for any business to avoid stockouts,
overstocking, and ultimately, to optimize inventory management. Here are illustrations of how this can
be done using both paper-based and electronic methods:

1. Paper-Based Stock Level Records

Paper-based systems rely on physical documents to track inventory. While less common today due to
the efficiency of electronic systems, some smaller businesses or specific situations might still utilize
them.

Illustration 1: Stock Cards (Bin Cards)

• Concept: A physical card is attached to each storage bin, shelf, or location where a specific
item is kept. Every time stock is added or removed, the card is manually updated.

• Information Typically Included:

o Item Name and Code

o Unit of Measure (e.g., each, kg, liter)

o Maximum Stock Level

o Minimum Stock Level (Reorder Point)

o Date of Transaction

o Quantity Received (+)

o Quantity Issued (-)

o Balance (Current Stock Level)

o Reference (e.g., invoice number, order number)

o Initials of the person updating the card

• Visual Representation (Conceptual):

Imagine a physical card hanging on a shelf next to the "Milk" cartons. It might look something like this:

------------------------------------

| Item Name: Milk |

| Item Code: MILK-123 |

| Unit: Liter |

| Max Stock: 100 |

| Min Stock: 30 |

------------------------------------

| Date | Received | Issued | Balance | Ref. | Initials |

|-----------|----------|--------|---------|----------|----------|

| 2025-05-08| 50 | | 80 | INV-001 | AB |

| 2025-05-08| | 10 | 70 | SALE-005 | CD |

| ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... |

------------------------------------

• Maintenance: Requires manual entry for every stock movement. Regular physical counts are
needed to verify the accuracy of the cards.

Illustration 2: Stock Registers or Logbooks

• Concept: A bound notebook or ledger is used to record all inventory transactions

chronologically. Separate pages or sections might be dedicated to different item categories.

• Information Typically Included: Similar to stock cards, but all items are listed together in a
running log.

• Visual Representation (Conceptual):

Imagine a page in a notebook:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

| Date | Item Name | Item Code | Received Qty | Issued Qty | Balance | Ref. |

|-----------|-----------|-----------|--------------|------------|---------|-----------|

| 2025-05-08| Milk | MILK-123 | 50 | | 80 | INV-001 |

| 2025-05-08| Cream | CRM-456 | 30 | | 30 | INV-001 |

| 2025-05-08| Milk | MILK-123 | | 10 | 70 | SALE-005 |

| 2025-05-08| Cheese | CHS-789 | |5 | 15 | SALE-006 |

| ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... |

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

• Maintenance: Requires diligent and accurate manual recording of every transaction. Periodic
stocktaking is necessary to reconcile the register with the physical inventory.

2. Electronic Stock Level Records

Electronic systems utilize software and digital databases to manage inventory data, offering significant
advantages in terms of efficiency, accuracy, and reporting capabilities.

Illustration 1: Spreadsheets (e.g., Microsoft Excel, Google Sheets)

• Concept: A spreadsheet is created with columns representing different inventory attributes

and transaction details. Formulas can be used to automatically calculate current stock levels
and inventory value.

• Visual Representation (Conceptual):

Imagine a table in a spreadsheet:

| Item No. | Item Name | Category | Unit | Opening Stock | Received Qty | Issued Qty | Current Stock |
Reorder Level | |----------|-----------|----------|------|---------------|--------------|------------|---------------|--------------
-| | 1 | Milk | Dairy | Liter| 30 | 50 | 10 | 70 | 30 | | 2 | Cream | Dairy | 500ml| 0 | 30 | 5 | 25 | 20 | | 3 |
Cheese | Dairy | kg | 20 | 5 | 3 | 22 | 15 | | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... |

Formulas Example (Excel/Sheets):

o Current Stock (Column H): =C2 + D2 - E2 (assuming Opening Stock is in C,

Received in D, and Issued in E for row 2)

o Conditional Formatting: Can be used to highlight items below the reorder level.
 • Maintenance: Data entry is still required for each transaction, but calculations and reporting
can be automated. Data validation rules can be implemented to improve accuracy.

Illustration 2: Inventory Management Software (IMS) / Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP)

Systems

• Concept: Dedicated software solutions designed specifically for managing inventory. These
systems often integrate with other business functions like sales, purchasing, and accounting.

• Features Typically Include:

o Real-time stock level tracking

o Automated reorder point alerts

o Barcode scanning for efficient data entry

o Reporting and analytics (e.g., stock valuation, sales trends)

o Integration with suppliers and customers

o Batch and serial number tracking

o Multi-location inventory management

• Visual Representation (Conceptual - Screenshot Snippets):

Imagine a user interface with:

o A Dashboard: Showing an overview of key inventory metrics (e.g., low stock items,
total inventory value).

o An Item List: A table displaying all inventory items with details like name, code,
current stock, location, etc.

o Transaction Logs: Records of all stock movements (receipts, issues, adjustments)

with timestamps and user information.

o Low Stock Alerts: Notifications highlighting items that have fallen below their reorder
level.

o Reporting Modules: Allowing users to generate reports on inventory levels, turnover

rates, etc.

• Maintenance: Primarily involves accurate data entry for receiving and issuing stock. The
software automates calculations, alerts, and reporting. Regular system maintenance and data
backups are important.

Comparison Summary:

Paper-Based Inventory Management

Feature Electronic Spreadsheets
Systems Software

Higher risk of manual Moderate risk if formulas are Generally high with data
Accuracy
errors incorrect validation

Time-consuming, More efficient with Highly efficient with automation,

Efficiency
manual updates automation barcode scanning

Real-time
Not easily available Requires manual updates Real-time visibility
Data
Scalability Difficult to scale Limited scalability Highly scalable

Laborious, manual Requires manual report Automated and comprehensive

Reporting
compilation creation reporting

Low initial cost (software

Cost Low initial cost Higher initial and ongoing costs
might be needed)

Can be complex depending on

Complexity Simple Moderate
features

Conclusion:

While paper-based systems can work for very small operations with limited inventory, electronic
methods, especially inventory management software, offer significant advantages in terms of
accuracy, efficiency, and the insights they provide. As businesses grow, transitioning to an electronic
system becomes increasingly crucial for effective inventory control and overall business success.

Sources and related content