CDEV 123 Teaching Notes For Odel
CDEV 123 Teaching Notes For Odel
Course Purpose
The main purpose of the course is to equip learners with knowledge and skills to disseminate new
innovations to the community for the purposes of improving their lives.
i. Define extension
ii. Identify various characteristics of an extension agent
iii. Discuss factors that influence change
iv. Identify various methods of extension
v. Discuss the theories of extention
Course Description
Definition of key terms, Characteristics of an extension staff, Effective communication, Use of visual
aids, Selecting extension methods and tools, Extension objectives, Diffusion and adoption process,
Factors influencing change, Extension methods, Individual methods/techniques, Group methods, Mirror
techniques, Mass methods, Demonstration plan, Student demonstrations and presentations.
COURSE CONTENT
Week Topic
1-2 Introduction:
Definition of key terms
Elements of Extension
Guide for the Extension Programs towards effective results
Objectives and principles of extension
Extension worker/change agent
Qualities of an effective Extension worker/change agent
3-4 Communication
Elements of communication
Effective communication
Listening
Shared meaning and its aspects
5-6 Visual aids – Defination
Planning for visual aids
Factors to Consider when planning to use Visual Aids
Diffusion and adoption process
7-8 CAT 1
Extension methods/techniques
Individual teaching method
Group methods
9-10 Demonstration
Lecture
Mirrror technique
Group Discussion
11 -12 Mass Technique
PRA
13-15 Student demonstrations and presentations
Teaching Methodology
Lectures and tutorials, group discussions and class discussion, class presentations, case studies
Course Evaluation
Assessment Marks
C.A.T’s and Assignments 30%
Final Exam 70%
Total 100%
References:
Jones G.E and Rolls MJ. (1982). Progress in rural extension and community development.
Vol 1. Extension and relative advantage in rural development. New York: John Wiley
Carrey, H.A and Heather N. (2007) Communication in Extension. A teaching and Leaning
Guide FAO
Lahiri B. Mukhopadhyays (2012) Mass Media in Agricultural Extension.
It is an informal system of education aimed at giving advisory assistance and/or material assistance
if possible so as to bring about continuous all round improvement of living standards through individual
to co-operating efforts. (Mama Mbogas, jua kali,)
2. Extension is an informal educational process directed toward the rural population. This process
offers advice and information to help community solve their problems. Extension also aims to increase
the efficiency of the family farm, increase production and generally increase the standard of living of the
farm family.
3. Extension is a process of working with rural people in order to improve their livelihoods. This
involves helping communities to improve the productivity of their agriculture and also developing their
abilities to direct their own future development.
Bottom line; Professional communication, it is a process, aim at improving the lives of people
History of Extension
The dissemination of relevant information and advice to farmers, however, has a long history prior to the
emergence of modem forms of agricultural extension in the nineteenth century.
The first known example was in Mesopotamia (roughly, present-day Iraq) around 1800 B.C.
Archaeologists have unearthed clay tablets of the time on which were inscribed advice on watering crops
and getting rid of rats - important for mitigating any potential loss of taxation revenue from farmers
(Ahmed, 1982, as quoted in Bne Saad, 1990). Some hieroglyphs on Egyptian columns also gave advice
on avoiding crop damage and loss of life from the Nile's floods. An important advance was the
beginning of agricultural writings. Though few have survived, the earliest were written during the
ancient Greek and Phoenician civilizations, but some of them were adapted by Roman writers. From the
second century B.C. to the fourth century A.D., several important Latin texts were written, frequently
drawing on practical farming experience, which aimed to help Roman landowners to maintain and
improve then-estates and their revenues (White, 1970, 1977).
At around the same period in imperial China, early forms of advancing and disseminating agricultural
information also began. That landowners and their tenants should improve their production was a matter
of concern to the state since, from the sixth century B.C. onwards, it relied heavily on land taxes for its
revenues. The support of relevant agricultural research and the dissemination of information and advice
had certainly begun by the late Han Dynasty (25-220 A.D.). The oldest fully surviving Chinese
agricultural treatise, Essential Techniques/or the Peasantry, dating from 535 A.D., aimed to show
landowners how to improve their estate management through the advice they gave to their tenants. The
Sung and Yuan Dynasties (960-1368) with their firm local government administrations were notable in
organizing and promoting agricultural research, extension work, and the teaching of agriculture and
sericulture, much facilitated by the invention of woodblock printing, which allowed agricultural treatises
and practical handbooks to be widely distributed. Similar activities continued during the succeeding
Ming (1368-1644) and Chi'ing (1644-1912) Dynasties, driven not only by the growing population and
periodic threats of famine, but also by the state's recognition of the importance of well-coordinated
extension work on agricultural recommendations if the most benefit was to be achieved (Perkins, 1969;
Elvin, 1973; Bray, 1984; Delman, 1991)
Elements of extension:
1. Knowledge and skills - (transfer of knowledge that can be applied to help someone)
Although communities already have a lot of knowledge about their environment and system within the
community, extension can bring them other knowledge and information which they do not have. For
example, knowledge about the cause of the damage to a particular crop, the general principles of pest
control, or the ways in which manure and compost are broken down to provide plant nutrients are all
areas of knowledge that the agent can usefully bring to farmers. The application of such knowledge
often means that the farmer has to acquire new skills of various kinds: for example, technical skills to
operate unfamiliar equipment, organizational skills to manage a group project, the skill to assess the
economic aspects of technical advice given, or farm management skills for keeping records and
allocating the use of farm resources and equipment.
The transfer of knowledge and skills to communities and their families is an important extension activity
and the extension agent must prepare himself thoroughly. He must find out which skills or areas of
knowledge are lacking among the communities in his area, and then arrange suitable learning
experiences through which the communities can acquire them.
2. Technical advice and information and skills: are the job-specific knowledge and techniques
needed to proficiently perform tasks that require particular expertise
Extension also provides advice and information to assist communities in making decisions and generally
enable them to take action. This can be information about, new technologies, prices and markets, for
availability of credit and inputs etc. Much of the advise is based on research and benchmarking.
3. Community organization
As well as knowledge, information and technical advice, communities also need some form of
organization, both to represent their interests and to give them a means for taking collective action.
Extension, therefore, should be concerned with helping to set up, structure and develop organizations of
local communities. This should be a joint venture and any such organization should only be set up in
consultation with the communities. Such organizations act as a link between extension agents and
communities.
One of the main constraints to development that many communities face is isolation, and a feeling that
there is little they can do to change their lives. Some communities live in vicious cycles of poverty thus
they feel weak and uninspired to get out of poverty. It is important for extension to work closely with
communities, helping them to take the initiative and generally encouraging them to become involved in
extension activities. Equally important is to convince communities that they have the capacity and
ability to liberate themselves from poverty.
Principles of Extension
Extension helps people with self-development by helping them apply educational resources to
their own needs and desires.
Extension helps people manage change in the social, economic and political arenas.
Extension develops programs and activities that address people's needs and the priorities agreed
upon by the federal, state and local partners.
Extension works with groups for cost-effectiveness, greater creativity and the encouragement and
strengthening of democratic processes.
Extension helps people become educators by encouraging them to participate in development of
the learning activities.
Extension is flexible and innovative in program approaches.
Extension uses a team approach to program development, priority setting and problem solving.
Extension works with rural people. Only the people themselves can make decisions about their way of
life and an extension agent does not try to take these decisions for them. People can and do make wise
decisions about their problems if they are given full information including possible alternative solutions.
By making decisions, people gain self-confidence. Extension, therefore, presents facts, helps people to
solve problems and encourages communities to make decisions that lead to behavioural change. People
have more confidence in programmes and decisions which they have actively participated than in those
which are imposed upon them.
Extension services and agents have two sets of masters. On the one hand, they are accountable to their
senior officers and to the government departments responsible for creating policies that the extension
programme is working around. Agents are expected to follow official policies and guidelines in their
work.
On the other hand, extension is the servant of the people and it has the responsibility to fulfill the needs
of the people in its area. This means that the community should have a say in deciding how effective
extension actually is. One measure of effectiveness is to see how well policies and plans have been
carried out. An equally important measure is the extent to which incomes and living standards of the
rural people have increased as a result of extension work.
Extension programmes, therefore, are based on people's needs, as well as on technical and national
economic needs. The extension agent's task is to bring these needs together. For example, an important
part of government policy may be to increase the amount of food grown and sold in the country. By
choosing to encourage the mass of small communities to increase their output by improving their
farming methods, national needs and communities' needs can be satisfied together.
3. Extension is a two-way link
Extension is not a one-way process in which the extension agent transfers knowledge and ideas to
communities. Even though advise is based on thorough research, extension agents should be willing
to listen to communities. The two-way link can occur in the following stages:
When the problem is being defined. Being in regular contact with the people, the extension agent
can help research workers to understand the problems of the area and the limitations under which
communities work and live.
When recommendations are being tested in the field. E,g A new farm practice or crop variety
might produce good results at a research station but not do so well on a farmer's field. Trials on
communities' fields are an opportunity to test research recommendations and provide feedback
for research staff.
When communities put recommendations into practice. E.g Sometimes communities discover
problems with a recommendation which the research station failed to note. With the feedback the
recommendations can be adjusted accordingly.
Extension services and agents should work closely with the other organizations that provide essential
services to communities and their families. Extension is only one aspect of the many economic, social
and political activities that seek to produce change for the better in the society. Extension, therefore, mus
t be prepared to collaborate with all other such organizations, both government and non-government, and
to take them into account when preparing to implement extension policies. The kinds of organizations
with which extension services should cooperate include:
Political institutions and local political leaders whose active local support will help the extension agent,
who may thereby be brought into closer touch with local communities.
Support organizations such as those which supply agricultural or other inputs, credit facilities or
marketing services. Such inputs must be available in sufficient quantity, in the right place and at the
right time if they are to be of any use.
Health services, so that the extension agent is kept aware of local health problems, particularly
nuritional levels. health and nutrition are a major aspect of community life and the agent must keep
closely in touch with health programmes and projects and adapt his programme to conform to local
health requirements for development for wholistic communities.
Local schools, so that the agent can have early access to the communities of the future, and begin to
equip them with the knowledge and skills required to achieve the target.
Community development, whose objectives will be very similar to the educational work of extension.
Extension agents often work very closely with community development workers to break down local
social and cultural barriers to change, and to encourage community action programmes.
It is essential that the extension agent in the field know what his colleagues in other services and
government departments are doing, and that they understand what he is doing. Close cooperation not
only avoids duplication but provides opportunities for integrated farm programmes.
Objectives of extension
1. Dissemination of useful and practical information related to areas of need to the clients
2. Ensure practical application of this information and knowledge so as to help people analyse
their patterns
3. Assisting the farmers/rural community to use technical knowledge gained to solve their
problems
4. Change communities’ outlook toward their difficulties. Extension is concerned not just with
physical and economic achievements but also with the development of the rural people
themselves. Extension agents, therefore, discuss matters with the rural people, help them to gain
a clearer insight into their problems and also to decide how to overcome these problems
AN EXTENSION WORKER
Extension workers are the main force in community improvement. They are professionals who influence
innovation and decision in a direction deemed desirable by the change agency as well as the community.
Their main function is to seek adoption of new ideas and innovations from their organization to
community members. They are usually technically trained with excellent people’s skills.
3. A guider
A community development agent helps a community find means of achieving its own goals. He/she helps the
community to Improve into the direction it has decided and he/she may suggest the alternative course of action.
Worker provides the facts and leaves the community to produce their own judgment. You should also take
initiative by going to the community.
4. An advisor-Consultant
A change agent may not be involved in day today community work but travel to the field ever now and then. As
an advisor the change agent provides a link between the agency and the community and to this the change agent
relies on the periodic information through periodic visit and the advice he/she gives to the agency would be about
the reality of the community situation.
5. An advocate
The change agent is committed you the aspirations and desires of the members of the community and the agency.
6. A broker
The change agent helps the community to locate resources and stimulate collective work. Sometimes the agent
helps the community locate resources outside the community.
7. Change agent
The change agent brings change to community by helping them identify and solve their problems.
8. As an expert
Provide advice and provide informati0on on matters where you are knowledgeable and thus provide information
in your area of competence and you will be able to interpret and evaluate the community in order to give useful
information.
9. A Therapist
The worker provides diagnosis and treatment of the community as a whole. He/she deals with deep and
unconscious problems that threaten to disrupt a community organization process.
10. A Teacher
The community development worker searches his/her knowledge and passes it on his/her information to the
community.
13. A Catalyst
The agent is expected to speed up development activities in the community. Despite the dragging of members of
the community, the agent as to strive to pull up their efforts.
13. A Facilitator
The agent is expected to work with the people by being there for any doubt and uncertainties
Communication In Extension
What is communication
Communication is the process of sending and receiving messages through verbal or nonverbal means
including speech or oral communication, writing or written communication, signs, signals, and behavior.
More simply, communication is said to be "the creation and exchange of meaning."
Communication forms a large part of the extension agent's job. He or she passes on ideas, advice and
information to influence the decisions of community. An extension worker must also be able to
communicate with his supervisors and research workers about the situation faced by community in his
area.
Any act of communication, be it a speech at a public meeting, a written report, a radio broadcast or a
question from a community member, includes five important elements of communication:- source,
message, channel, receiver and feedback.
What should the content be? A balance must be achieved between what the receiver wants to
know and what the source feels the receiver ought to know.
What form should the message take? In other words, how can the message be put into the words,
pictures or symbols that the receiver will understand and take notice of?
Does it need a visual presentation, as when crop pests are being described? Is it necessary to
show movement or detailed actions (in which case, film, video or a demonstration will be
needed)?
What channels are available to the receivers? Do they see newspapers? Can they read? Do many
of them have radios?
What are the receiver's expectations? A senior government official, for example, is more likely to
take notice of a written submission followed by a personal visit.
The receiver :who is the person for whom the message is intended.
Feedback - The term feedback is a reaction to the message passed. It could be helpful information or
criticism about the message. Feedback can be used to adjust and improve current and future actions and
behaviors.
Information often passes through several channels before it reaches a particular receiver, but it is rarely
passed on in exactly the same words in which it was received. In particular, technical information is
often distorted as it goes from one person to another. Extension agents should aim at being accurate
sources and channels of information, and should make sure that community have heard and fully
understood any information passed on to them. Leaflets and posters can be useful reminders of the
spoken word.
Not all communication is deliberate. For example, people's behaviour, the way they speak to each other
or the clothes they wear reveal much about them and their attitudes. If an extension agent is always late
for meetings with community" groups, the members may come to the conclusion that he does not take
them seriously. If he wears casual clothes when addressing a formal village meeting, villagers may say
that he has no respect for them. Even if this is not so, the fact that they think it is will affect their
relationship with the agent and, therefore, his effectiveness. The message that is received is not always
the one that the source intends to pass.
Listening
A good communicator listens more than he speaks. An extension agent who does not listen to
community and engage in a dialogue with them is unlikely to be very effective. There are four main
reasons why a two-way exchange or dialogue is more effective than a monologue.
Misunderstandings that occur during the exchange can quickly be identified and cleared
up.
Relationships of mutual respect can develop. If an agent listens, community will know
that one agent is interested in them, and they will be more likely to pay attention to what
the agent has to say.
Shared meanings
Communication is only successful when the receiver can interpret the information that the source has put
into the message. An extension agent may give what he feels is a clear and concise talk, or an artist may
be satisfied that he has designed a poster that conveys over the desired message, but there is no
guarantee that those for whom the talk and poster are intended will interpret the message correctly.
It is important that the same meanings for the words, pictures and symbols used in communication be
used by the source and the receiver. If this does not happen, various kinds of problems can arise.
Language. Even if source and receiver speak the same language, local variations or dialects may use
similar words with different meanings.
Jargon. The technical language of specialists has to be translated into words that are familiar to the
receiver. Extension agents need to learn what words and phrases community use when talking about
their farming activities.
Pictures and symbols. Attempts to communicate through pictures and visual symbols often fail because
the receiver does not recognize what they represent. Interpreting pictures is a skill which, like reading,
has to be learned.
Effective communication
Information, knowledge and skills serve no useful purpose, if they are not effectively
transmitted/communicated to the community and utilized by the people for the desired purpose.
Defective and ineffective communication results in wastage of resources peoples efforts and time. This
can be a barrier for further work even if the innovation was good for the people. Any communicator
must consider four elements carefully, as they contribute to effectiveness communication.
b. Better recall
Research has shown that when people learn by hearing alone they remember about 20% of the material.
When they learn by sight alone, recall is about 35% but when sight and sound are combined they
remember 65% visual aids are also stronger persuasion because “seeing is believing”
c. Added interests
Pictures have an inherent appeal to most people. They make it possible to add variety and even suspense
to subjects which may be boring if we only talk about them. This is especially fine when the pictures are
colored and even more so when they move in motion pictures. The amount of curiosity in people to look
at things is almost infinity.
d. Time saving
Frequently we have to cover a lot of ground in limited time yet we must make sure that everything is
clearly understood. It is usually faster to show an object of a picture that illustrates it than to describe it
in words. It also takes less time to describe it verbally.
e. Organizing communication
Visual aids can be used to organize communication, making it easier to remember points made in a
presentation. The visual aid create a point of reference for the mind to quickly refer to. It helps the
speaker stay on track
EXTENTION METHODS/TECHNIQUES
A method/technique is a procedure or way of doing something systematically according to a plan. A.
method can also be defined as a systematic process of achieving certain ends with accuracy and
efficiency, usually in an ordered sequence of fixed steps
Selecting an extension method/techniques
Before choosing an extension method, the following should be considered:
a) No single method is better than another. The extension agent should choose those techniques most
suitable for the situation, because no technique is considered superior than the other.
b) Use a number of methods. Experience in extension work has shown that, the more methods used,
the new information is presented and the faster an individual learns.
c) Use Methods that can overlap. e.g. you can use a slide and demonstration. This also will stimulate
group discussion and will reinforce the information. One can also use visual aid and written material:
teaching can be reinforced and supported by use of visual aids and written material.
Methods/Techniques
a. Individual teaching method
b. Group teaching method
c. Mass teaching method
1. Individual methods
Learning is an individual process; therefore personal contact should be encouraged between the change
agent and the client. Clients will listen to the advice and suggestions of an extension worker who they
feel they know. Clients appreciate the attention and contact from with the extension worker.
Individual method can take place in a farm visit or home visits form:
Farm and home visits
This allows an extension agent to concentrate on clients’ problem, builds relationships with the family
and discusses client’s interests privately without interruptions unlike in group meetings. They also allow
the extension agent to develop better understanding of the area and of the individual, creating an
opportunity to explain new recommended practice as well as stimulate involvement in extension
activities
d. The extension staff should prepare specific information concerning the problem in form of
pamphlets to leave with the farmer.
e. Plan the visit at a time convenient with the client at home/business premise and at a time when the
client is ready to have you i.e. make an appointment with the client and the visit should not conflict
with other activities.
f. During the visit, if the client is busy come quickly to the point and end the interview as soon as the
purpose is accomplished.
g. If the clients wants to extend the visit then make time
h. The extension staff must have sound technical knowledge and should take the opportunity to arouse
interests of the clients to other activities in the programme. Provide sound technical information and
relate to clients and farm/business premise
i. In discussing with the client, listen carefully and allow the client to do more of the talking but guide
the conversation.
The extension staff should keep the record of the visits i.e. the purpose of the visit, time and place,
observations made, help given to the client, what results were achieved, and when the follow-up is
required.
Check list for planning for home visit
• Make an appointment if possible
• Decide the purpose on the visit
• Review previous records and information
• Preparation of specialist subject matter that might be required
• Schedule the visit and the overall work
Record keeping
The extension agent should make a record of any visit that he makes, indicating the date, purpose,
conclusions and recommendations arising from the visit. This makes a useful reference for agents
coming after him.
Telephone calls or Sms: usually used to pass short messages and quick enquiry.
(i)Schedule the demonstration at the most convenient time and place for the client.
(ii)Arrange the audience so that everyone can see and hear the demonstration clearly e.g. semi-circle.
(iii)Introduce yourself and the presentation giving the background of the problem and why it is
important that they learn the skill and what will take place at the gathering.
(iv) Ask for help from the audience to help in demonstrating the various steps.
(v)Proceed with the presentation step by step answering questions and repeating difficult steps.
(vi)Encourage the members/audience to attempt the new method during the meeting. If time allows
each individual should have an opportunity to practice the skills.
(vii)Summarize the importance of the skill, the steps and the supplies and equipment needed.
(viii)Distribute illustrated literature, if available showing each step.
c) Follow up
(i)Evaluate the demonstration carefully noting the strengths and weaknesses.
(ii)Visit those clients who indicated an interest in the demonstrations e.g. if they have adopted or not.
b. Result demonstration
It is a demonstration which shows after a period of time what happened after a practice was adopted. In
result demonstration, comparison is the important ingredient.
Planning the demo
i) Identify the problem to be solved by the demonstration
ii) Decide upon the objectives to be accomplished. Three types of objectives.
d. Attitudinal objective – aim is to change their attitude
e. Knowledge objective
f. Skill objective
iii) Gather complete information about the practice
iv) Seek the assistance of the clientele in planning and carrying out the demonstration
Endorsement by the local leaders will add credence to the efforts; seek their recommendations
about good possible host farmers.
v) Develop a complete plan of work clearly delineating each individual stake and showing who has
responsibility for each task.
vi) Select accessible demonstration plot that are centrally located and near a road so that people can
easily visit the site.
vii) Visit the host farmer/client and work with him/her to make sure that he or she understands the
purpose of the demonstration and how it will be implemented. This is a very important step
Advantages
i) It shows convincingly why a practice should be adopted.
ii) It is an effective method of introducing new subjects.
iii) It appeals to the eye.
iv) Provides a good source of information for meetings, new items, pictures, radio etc.
v) It aims in developing local leaders
vi) It establishes confidence in extension staff and extension work
Disadvantages
i) It is time consuming
ii) It is costly especially if new technology which will require new gadgets is applied.
2. Lecture Method
A lecture is a formal verbal presentation by a single speaker to a group of listeners. Visual aids may
illustrate the lecture and a question-answer period may follow a talk.
Advantages
i) Much information can be transmitted in a relatively short time
ii) Large numbers of people can be addressed together
iii) Abstract ideas and unfamiliar subjects can be conveniently presented
Disadvantages
i) The subject matter of lectures is usually not well remembered
ii) The audience generally remains passive/minimum activity
iii) A lecture is not suited for teaching skills and only rarely so for changing attitudes. Whatever the
occasion the effectiveness of a lecture is not to be judged by what the lecturer says but what the
audience remembers.
Preparing a lecture
Having decided the objective, audience and subject, the lecturer should do the following;
1. Gather information
Carry out an extensive informative reading in order to acquire have overall familiarity with the subject.
2. Selective reading
Reading of the same material where the lecturer chooses and marks those points which have a direct
bearing on the lecture he/she is preparing.
3. Final reading
The lecturer goes over his/her notes and completes them with he/she knows from his/her own experience
subdividing all material into a series of sub heading and arranging them in a logical order.
The material should be subdivided into;
i) Essential (e.g. by use of different pens, cards etc.). This is information that must be connected for
the lecturer to attain his objectives.
ii) Desirable (consists of additional information which could preferably/profitably be represented if
occasion arises and time permits)
iii) The optional material (information which no greater harm could be done if it is omitted)
4. Mirror technique
Presentation of situations, barriers or problems in a form that reflects the audience. The ‘mirror’
depicts a situation that the community can easily recognize and with which they can identify
themselves. This includes drama, role play, puppets shows, mimics, songs, poems, proverbs etc.
The mirror technique avoids antagonizing the audience as it does not attack them directly.
The technique is best used in sensitive situations to open up discussions on silent issues and help
people to reflect on their behavior without feeling pressurized.
The mirror technique is useful when creating awareness on sensitive issues like of condom and/or
change of attitude.
Areas where mirror technique can be used in general extension week include; school parent day,
field days, rallies, training sessions (movies, videos) barazas, groups etc.
Definitions
a. Drama: Information or message put across to the audience through actions by actors.
b. Role play: The activity in which a person imitates or acts out a situation by use of guidelines or
instructions or storyline.
c. Puppet: An art of manipulating small figures or dots which are made by strings attached to its limbs
or by cloth body to perform certain actions.
d. Proverbs: A wise saying providing guidance. They would provide a lot of useful information.
e. Poems: A comparison in verse usually characterized by words chosen from their sound and
suggestive to carry very informative messages to the audience.
f. Songs/dance: Songs usually sung in their traditional local tone but passing specific messages
sometimes accompanied by dances.
5. Group discussions
This can be used to exchange ideas and knowledge, to solve group problems, to air opinions and
disagreements and to work towards consensus on contested issues. It is therefore used quite frequently.
Successful discussions depend on the participant skills and attitudes, same to the official discussion
leader. The leader act is to draw the best out of a very lose and unstructured situation. Discussion is an
interchange of thoughts, ideas and opinions among different people.
In a genuine decision, participants must assume the possibility that he/she can learn something that
others may also be right and that the interchange of opinions can be more variable than the
predominance of any particular opinion.
The boundary lines between discussion, debates, arguments and lecturing are not fixed or always clear.
Disadvantages
a. It is time consuming
b. It can be done well and effectively only in relatively small groups
c. It is not suitable for teaching skills
d. It requires that participants have some communication skills and prior knowledge of the subject
Participatory Rural Appraisal (PRA) is considered one of the popular and effective approaches to gather
information in rural areas. This approach was developed in early 1990s with considerable shift in
paradigm from top-down to bottom-up approach, and from blueprint to the learning process.
PRA can be defined as an approach and method for learning about rural life and conditions from, with
and by rural people. He further stated that PRA extends into analysis, planning and action. PRA closely
involve community and local officials in the process.
Participatory – Means that people are involved in the process – a “bottom-up” approach that requires
good communication skills and positive attitude of the extension worker.
Rural – The techniques can be used in any situation, urban or rural, with both literate and illiterate
people.
Appraisal – it means judging the value of or analyzing the information collected about problems, or
needs, the community.
PRA is intended to enable local communities to conduct their own analysis and to plan and take action.
PRA requires the extension worker to learn together with community about their problems. It is based
on the principle that local people are creative and capable and can do their own investigations, analysis,
and planning. Therefore the aim of PRA is to help strengthen the capacity of community to plan, make
decisions, and to take action towards improving their own situation. It is a methodology of learning rural
life and their environment from the rural people. It requires extension workers to act as facilitators to
help local people conduct their own analysis, plan and take action accordingly. The basic concept of
PRA is to learn from rural people.
Elements of PRA
Principles of PRA
There are five key principles that form the basis of any PRA activity no matter what the objectives or
setting:
1. Participation - PRA relies heavily on participation by the communities, as the method is designed to
enable local people to be involved, not only as sources of information, but as partners with the PRA
team in gathering and analyzing the information.
3. Teamwork - Generally, a PRA is best conducted by a local team (speaking the local languages) with
a few outsiders present, a significant representation of women, and a mix of sector specialists, according
to the topic.
The purpose of a SSI is to gain information from an individual or small group on an issue. SSI is guided
conversation where broad questions are asked, which do not constrain the conversation, and new
questions are allowed to arise as a result of the discussion. It is therefore a relatively informal, relaxed
discussion based around a pre-determined topic. SSI can be used with individuals, key informants,
interest groups or other small groups of community (i.e. women’s groups).
The weakness of this approach is that it does not permit the interviewer to pursue topics or issues of
interest that were not anticipated because interview guide is elaborated. Also, interviewer flexibility in
wording and sequencing questions may result in substantially different responses from different persons,
thus reducing comparability.
Maps
Mapping is one of the most powerful tool used to generate pictures on any aspect of the physical reality.
Usually mapping is used to depict infrastructures, natural resources, land ownership, settlement pattern,
soil types, cropping pattern etc. Usually the maps are drawn on the ground using on the spot available
materials. The location of the mapping session should be freely accessible to all groups of the
community. Maps can be also used according to a timeline like the community or group 30 years back to
now. A future model can be drawn to discuss peoples vision of the future how it will be or how they
want it should be. Such historical maps help to discuss the root cause of the present situation and
possible future developments.
Types of mapping
Social mapping
Social mapping is a PRA method that involves the sketching/drawing of houses and other social
facilities and infrastructure (i.e. churches, stores, rice mills, schools, pharmacies, trails and roads, water
pumps, irrigation, recreation facilities etc) in a community. Its main objective is to help learn about the
social structures in the community and the differences among the households by ethnicity, religion and
wealth and to learn about who is living where. This helps to visualize and situate the location of
households and other social facilities/infrastructure in a community. It serves as a baseline for planning,
implementation, monitoring, and evaluation of community development activities.
Resource Map
The community Resource Map is a tool that helps to learn about a community and its resource base and
how these resources are used. The primary concern is not to develop an accurate map but to get useful
information about local perceptions of resources. The participants should develop the content of the map
according to what is important to them.
During resource mapping the following questions are asked: 1. What resources are abundant? 2. What
resources are scarce? 3. Does everyone have equal access to land? 4. Do women have access to land? 5.
Do the poor have access to land? 6. Who makes decision on land allocation? 7. Where do people go to
collect water? 8. Who collects water? 9. Where do people go to collect firewood? 10. Who collects
firewood? E.t.c.
The facilitators meet small groups of community and discuss with them the most important events in the
community’s past and prepare with the information a historical timeline which serves as the base for
further work. It is important to involve different groups of the communities to get their usually different
perspectives. The timeline with basic events can be used for focussed discussions on problems, social
and technological innovations or on communities history of co operations and activities which helped
them to solve in past problems successfully.
A seasonal calendar is a PRA method that determines patterns and trends throughout the year in a certain
village. It can be used for purposes such as rainfall distribution, food availability, agricultural
production, income and expenditures, health problems, and others. The seasonal calendar can also be
used to collect information on how community allocate their time as well as their labour in various
activities within the village . A time chart or seasonal calendar is prepared by drawing a two-
dimensional matrix and writing the time period (i.e. month, year) on an axis and the different village
activities on the other axis. Community are encouraged to fill in the matrix of the chart/calendar by
marking the grid or by placing stones or other objects on the matrix.
Wealth ranking
Wealth ranking is a PRA method that determines the economic attributes of households in a village. It
shows information on the relative wealth and well-being of households in a community. It helps in
determining the social and economic status of households in a community. The information generated by
the wealth ranking exercise helps in identifying the poor households in the community. Ranking is done
by community themselves. It serves as baseline and as an opportunity to identify indicators for planning,
implementation, monitoring and evaluation of community development activities (including selection of
village organizing strategy).
Depending on the nature and scope of an inquiry, the investigator identifies appropriate groups from
which the key informants may be drawn, and then selects a few from each group. The accuracy of
information obtained from key informant interviews depends mainly on developing a suitable interview
guide, and the selection of the informants. The information received from the key informants has to be
cross-checked through group discussions and interviews with other people.