Chapter 1. Issues in Traditional Project Management
Chapter 1. Issues in Traditional Project Management
1
1. Contemporary Issues in Project Management
• Learning objectives
1.0. Introduction
1.1 Contemporary Issues
1.2. Generic Contemporary Issues in Project Management
1.3 Issues in Traditional Project Management
1.3.1 Scope a TPM project
1.3.2 Planning a TPM Project
1.3.3. Launching a TPM Project
1.3.4. Monitoring & Controlling a TPM Project
1.3.5. Closing a TPM Project
Learning objectives
After completing this unit you should be able to:
• Plan and handle issues in Project Scoping.
• Identify and manage issues in project planning
• Identify and manage issues in project launching
• Identify and Handle issues in project monitoring
and evaluation
• Identify and Handle issues in project closing
3
1.0. Introduction
• Contemporary issues are problems, gaps,
inconsistencies or conflicts that occur
unexpectedly during the life cycle of a project.
• Contemporary issues in project management
are critical current contentious problems that
are associated with project management.
Knowledge of these issues is important to deal
and improve the management of projects.
4
Generic Contemporary Issues in Project
Management
1. Scope creep
2. Lack of communication
3. Lack of clear goals and success criteria
4. Budgeting issues
5. Inadequate skills of team members
6. Inadequate risk management
7. Lack of accountability 5
Generic Contemporary Issues in Project Management…
• Effective
communication in project management is
extremely important for a successful project.
You need to have timely and transparent
methods of communication to ensure that all
stakeholders are involved in the process.
• Miscommunication is also dangerous for
project teams because it affects their
teamwork. It can cause conflicts among team
members and can potentially delay the project.
9
Lack of communication…
• How to deal with it:
• Project managers often rely on various collaborative
and project management software available in the
market in order to ensure that everyone stays updated.
• Project collaboration tools not only make it easier for
managers to carry on their duties but also ensure
greater transparency in projects and accountability
within the team.
• This is achieved through features such as contextual
comments, and priority assignment capabilities.
• In addition, regular, short stand-up meetings a few times
weekly can go a long way in preventing miscommunication.
10
Manage Barriers to Effective
Organizational Communication
18
Teamwork
• “Teamwork is the ability to work
together toward a common vision. The
ability to direct individual
accomplishments toward organizational
objectives. It is the fuel that allows
common people to attain uncommon
results.” Andrew Carnegie
19
Teamwork…
• A good team leader can make or break a team
when it comes to troubleshooting development
issues.
• A team leader that takes an active role in team
development can help avoid establishing negative
norms.
• Leadership skills include a combination of soft and
technical skills, such as using your interpersonal
skills to motivate your team or applying your
technical knowledge to solve problems and complete
tasks.
20
5. Leadership
• Ability to influence.
• Inspiring passion and motivation in
followers
• Influence, inspire and help others
become their best selves, building
their skills and achieving goals along
the way.
21
Leadership Style
• A leader’s methods and behaviors
when directing, motivating and
managing others.
–Autocratic
–Democratic
–Laissez-faire
22
Balancing Task and Process
Creating an effective project team
• The key components making up
effective teams can be grouped into
four variables( key components of an
effective team):
–Context,
–Composition,
–Work design, and
–Process.
6. Inadequate risk management
• Having the foresight to identify
potential ‘what if’ scenarios and
making up contingency plans is an
important aspect of project
management.
• Projects rarely go exactly as planned
because there are so many variables
that can create unlimited possibilities.
26
Inadequate risk management…
• How to deal with it:
• It is the job of every project manager to come
up with alternate plans that the team may adopt
if the project begins to spiral out of control.
Having a project risk management system
helps in identifying the types of risks and
mitigating them. Having a contingency plan in
place is critical. This plan should identify all
risks that the course of action to be taken if
they materialize it.
27
7. Managing Conflict
• Conflict is a relationship between
two or more parties (individuals or
groups) who have, or think they
have, incompatible goals and who act
on the basis of those perceived
incompatibilities”,
Schneider et al, 2016
28
Types of Workplace Conflict
Four different types of team
conflicts common to workplace
environments:
Task-based conflicts
Leadership conflicts
Work style conflicts
Personality clashes
Conflict Management Strategies
Which of these strategies are suitable and not
suitable for you?
1) Avoiding,
2) Defeating,
3) Compromising,
4) Accommodating,
and
5) Collaborating
Which one is best?
Choosing a conflict management style is often intuitive.
It is possible to train yourself on using different conflict
management styles based on the situation at hand.
There is no BEST way to handle conflict. Each conflict
is different and requires a different response.
However:
“Two heads are better than one.” (Collaborating)
“Kill your enemies with kindness.” (Accommodating)
“Split the difference.” (Compromising)
“Leave well enough alone.” (Avoiding)
“Might makes right.” (Competing)
Finding Your Management Style
• Each statements on the next two slides provides
a strategy for dealing with a conflict
• Rate each statement on a scale of 1 -4
indicating how likely you are to use this strategy
1. Rarely
2. Sometimes
3. Often
4. Always
Finding Your Management Style...
43
Unrealistic deadlines…
• How to deal with it:
• In agile project management, velocity, which is the
measure of work completed in a single sprint, is
decided collectively by taking inputs from all
stakeholders.
• This is done during the planning phase of the project.
• Further, frequent monitoring of deadlines by the
project manager is a must.
• This ensures that any increase in scope (scope creep)
during the execution of the project is either avoided or
timelines modified as required.
44
12. Absence of structure
• A common challenge that managers
face in the workplace is the absence of
structure, especially when overseeing a
new team.
• Depending on the work environment,
some teams may need to be supervised
more closely than others in order to
maintain productivity levels.
45
Absence of structure
• How to deal with it:
• Take time to develop an
organizational structure that helps
employees know what you expect of
them.
• In addition, show your team respect
to encourage loyalty.
46
13. Inadequate Top Management Support
• Managers sometimes need approval
from the executive team of a company
or the business owner before moving
ahead with a project.
• When the decision-making process
takes longer than expected, it may slow
down their team's progress overall.
47
Inadequate support…
• How to deal with it:
• The most important thing to do in this
situation is to be honest with your team
members. Let them know that you are
waiting for information from the executive
team, and if possible, allow them to work on
other projects.
• Try to arrange for a one-on-one with the
decision-maker to expedite progress.
48
14. Weak workplace culture
• When teams feel like they're not
connected with the rest of the
workplace, they could experience a
decrease in motivation.
• Teams that feel they are part of a
larger group, experience more
confidence and trust.
49
Weak workplace culture
• How to deal with it:
• Promote a strong work culture
by planning outings and
rewarding employees who
exceed expectations.
50
Project Teamwork
External Factors
Context Definition
Politics
Objectives
Environment
Community Strategy
Geophysics Design
Finance Technology
Cost/Benefit Standards
Financeability
Timing
Phasing
Overlaps
Organization
Structure Behavior Systems
Life cycle Decision making Planning and Reporting
Project/Matrix/Functional Staffing Systems and Procedures
orientation Sponsor/ Champion IT Strategy
Sponsor/Owner/Contractor role
role Stakeholders
Procurement Team building
Aims Communication
Supply chain configuration Conflict
Risk allocation Industrial Relations
54
Project management issues
• Project management issues may
be classified into two categories:
–Traditional project management
issues (Chapter 1)
–Contemporary
project ,management issues
(Chapter 2)
55
Traditional Project Management
56
Traditional Project Management (TPM) Issues
57
Traditional project management
• The traditional project management uses
orthodox methods and techniques in the
management process. These methods and
techniques have been evolved for decades
and are applicable for most of the domains.
But for some domains, such as software
development, traditional project
management is not a 100% fit.
58
Traditional Project Management…
61
How to Scope a TPM project
• The Scoping Process Group defines all of
the tools, templates, and processes needed to
answer two questions: “What will you do?”
and “How will you know you did it?”
• If you don’t know where you are going, how
will you know when and if you ever get
there? So many times we have seen projects
get off to a terrible start simply because
there never was a clear understanding of
exactly what was to be done. 62
How to Scope a TPM project,,,
65
How to Scope a TPM project,,,
70
How to Scope a TPM project,,,
71
How to Scope a TPM project,,,
• Types of Requirements
• Requirements are separated into the
following four categories:
– Functional requirements
– Non-functional requirements
– Global requirements
– Product and/or project constraints
72
How to Scope a TPM project,,,
81
How to Plan a TPM Project…
83
How to Plan a TPM Project…
• Deliverables
• The deliverables from the JPPS:
– Work Breakdown Structure
– Activity Duration Estimates
– Resource Requirements
– Project Network Schedule
– Activity Schedule
– Resource Assignments
– Project Notebook
84
How to Plan a TPM Project…
• Contents of the Project Proposal
• Executive Summary
• describing one of the following topics:
– Business situation (expanded from the POS)
– Your project goal (expanded from the POS)
– Business value (expanded from the POS)
• Background
• Objective
85
How to Plan a TPM Project…
86
How to Plan a TPM Project…
• Gaining Approval to Launch the
Project, basic considerations:
– The cost-benefit
– The risks of failure
– The total project cost and available
funding
– Other projects competing for the same
resources
87
Basic Steps on project planning
1. Define your goals and objectives
2. Set success matrics
3. Clarify stakeholders and roles
4. Set your budget
5. Align on milestones, deliverables, and
project dependencies
6. Outline your timeline and schedule
7. Share your communication plan
88
Launch a TPM project
• Recruiting the Project Team
– Core team
– Client team
– Contract team
• Selection Criteria for Core Team Members
– Commitment to the project
– Shared responsibility
– Flexibility
89
Launch a TPM project…
• Selection Criteria for Core Team Members,,,
– Task-oriented
– Ability to work within schedules and
constraints
– Trust and mutual support
– Team-oriented
– Open-minded
– Ability to work across structure and
authorities
– Ability to use project management tools 90
Launch a TPM project…
• Conducting the Project Kick-Off
Meeting
– Purpose of the Project Kick-Off Meeting
• This is the meeting that gets the project
started. You will want to make it an event
to remember.
91
Launch a TPM project…
• Sample Project Kick-off Meeting agenda:
– Introduce the sponsor to the project team
– Introduce the importance of the project by the sponsor
– Introduce the project (client)
– Introduce the project (project manager)
– Introduce the project team members to each other
– Write the PDS
– Establish the team operating rules
– Review the project plan
– Finalize the project schedule
– Write work packages 92
Launch a TPM project…
• Attendees For Project Kick-Off
Meeting:
– Sponsor
– Other managers
– Project team
– Contractors and vendors
93
Launch a TPM project…
• Conflict Resolution
• The other area for which operating rules are
needed deals with how the team resolves
conflicts.
• Conflicts arise when two or more team
members have a difference of opinion, when
the client takes issue with an action to be
taken by the project team, or in a variety of
other situations involving two parties with
different points of view. 94
Launch a TPM project…
• Conflict resolution styles:
– Avoidant
– Combative
– Collaborative:
95
Launch a TPM project…
• Managing Scope Changes
• Regardless of the project management life cycle (PMLC)
model you choose, you will have to deal with scope change
requests coming from the client and from the project team.
In some cases, you’ll be expecting these change requests,
and you’ll be ready to process them. In other cases, you will
not be expecting them (or at least won’t want them), but
that doesn’t absolve you from having a way to process
them.
• You need to have a scope change management process in
place as you start the project so you can deal with both the
expected and unexpected changes that will come your way.
96
Monitor and control a TPM project
• The project plan is a system as defined by the
scope triangle.
• As such, it can get out of balance, and a get-well
plan must be put in place to restore balance to the
system.
• The longer the project manager waits to put the fix
in place, the longer it will take to restore balance.
• Regularly measuring progress on a project to
ensure it continues meeting objectives and
addressing current organizational needs.
97
Monitor and control a TPM project…
• Activity reviewing the status of project as it
proceeds, evaluating potential obstacles and
implementing necessary changes.
• Elements
– Time and cost aspects
– Planning and scheduling
– Risk management(includes identification and
assessment)
– Cost estimating and management
98
Monitor and control a TPM project…
99
Close a TPM project
103
Traditional Project Management…
• Traditional project management is a
step-by-step predictive approach to
project management-also called the
Waterfall methodology-in which you
breakdown and plan an entire project
before launching it.
• Process in the requirements stage help
you predict and mange risks.
104
Traditional vs Contemporary
Project Management
• Traditional project management is a
well-established approach in which
projects are completed in sequential
order.
• Traditional project management methods
place a strong focus on linear
procedures, documentation, upfront
planning, and priority.
105
Traditional vs Contemporary…
• Since time and money are variable and
requirements are set in the traditional
technique, it frequently encounters
financial and timeframe challenges.
There are tools and procedures
established by the standard
methodology for each phase that
project managers use.
106
Traditional vs Contemporary…
108
Contemporary Project Management
109
Benefits Of CP M
• Flexible prioritization
• Early and predictable delivery
• Predictable costs and schedules
• Improves quality
• More transparency
• Scope for Feedback
• Customer Satisfaction 110
Summary Of Differences Between
Contemporary And The Traditional Approach
Characteristics Contemporary Approach Traditional approach
Customers are involved from the time work is Customers get involved early in the project but
Customer involvement
being performed not once the execution has started
Model preference Agile model favors adaption The traditional model favors anticipation
Product or process Less focus on formal and directive processes More serious about processes than the product
Test documentation Comprehensive test planning Tests are planned one sprint at a time
Scrum master facilitates, and the team does The project manager provides estimates and gets
Effort estimation
the estimation approval from PO for the entire project
Reviews and approvals Reviews are done after each iteration Excessive reviews and approvals by leaders
111
Contemporary Project Management…
• CPM emphasizes four key values:
–Individuals and relationships are prioritized
above processes and tools.
–Comprehensive documentation is less
essential than working software.
–Customer cooperation is more important
than negotiating.
–Rather than simply following a plan, the
process should adjust to change.
112
Project Management Methodologies
• Project management plays a vital role in
accomplishing goals, following schedules,
and course correction during projects.
However, getting your team organized and
keeping the project on track can be a
daunting task.
• This is where project management
methodology can help project managers
make the best use of available resources for
achieving desired project outcomes. 113
Project Management Methodologies…
• Lean Methodology • PRINCE2
• Agile Methodology • PMI’s PMBOK
• Six Sigma • Joint Application
• Critical Path Development
• SCRUM • Hybrid Project
Management
• Kanban
Methodologies
• XP or eXtreme – Agile and Waterfall
Programming
– Scrumban
• Waterfall Methodology
– Lean Agile
• Iterative PMLC Model
114
Project Management Methodologies…
• Lean Methodology
• Lean methodology is a method for optimizing
resources to create value for the end-user or
customer. With principles of continuous
improvement, it is used in many industries
ranging from software development to sales.
‘Lean’ was originally developed at Toyota to
reduce waste and inefficiency. Lean
methodology aims to value customers and
provide perfect value through a process of zero
waste. 115
Project Management Methodologies…
• Agile Methodology
• Agile methodology is a new approach to project
management. It is more of an umbrella term that
consists of a number of methodologies. Agile
methods are more flexible and focus on an
iterative approach towards software
development, with a focus on the delivery of
outcomes rather than one-time. Agile
methodologies divide the project into smaller
tasks, with scope for reversal in case of errors.
116
Project Management Methodologies…
• Six Sigma
• Aims to streamline business processes while reducing
errors and improving customer satisfaction
• Six Sigma prioritizes dara and statistical analysis to
remove any chance pf operating based on gut assumptions-
this methodology helps teams make objective decisions,
which in turn leads to more efficiency and less waste.
• The goal of this methodology is continuous improvement,
which is especially helpful if you notice customer retention
dropping or have data reasily available about the project.
• Six Sigma is popular in large organizations.
117
Project Management Methodologies…
• Critical Path
• Works well with projects with multiple dependencies.
• Iy focuses on using resources efficiently to complete
project tasks.
• The critical path is the longest stretch of dependent
activities based on particular resource( a team
member, resource, budget, time window, etc.) and
measuring them from start to finish.
• This methodology helps project managers minimize
risk and increase the likelihood of completing projects
on schedule.
118
Project Management Methodologies…
• SCRUM(Simple Project Management
Methodology)
• SCRUM is an agile framework for project
management, which focuses on teamwork,
accountability, and an iterative approach for
achieving defined goals. In software
development, SCRUM is considered a
popular methodology with Agile concepts
by empowering self-managing teams.
119
Project Management Methodologies…
• Kanban
• Kanban is a Lean manufacturing system that focuses
on work that is continually released in better quality.
• Kanban project managers use sticky notes or
online tools for whiteboards and workflow
management. Trello is a famous Kanban
tool for representing a teams workflow. Trello can
be used for a variety of task and project management
purposes, including one-time projects or ongoing
activities like content project management.
120
Project Management Methodologies…
• XP or eXtreme Programming
• XP or eXtreme programming is an Agile software
development framework. It provides processes
and defined values meant for improving the
quality of software.
• Similar to SCRUM, the values revolve around
communication, feedback, courage, simplicity,
and respect. If you’re confused regarding the
value of ‘courage’ in the framework, it implies
that software developers evaluate their work and
are ready to adapt to make changes. 121
Project Management Methodologies…
• Waterfall Methodology
• The Waterfall methodology, which is also known as the
Software Development Life Cycle or SDLC is a
methodology which unlike the Agile approach, focuses on
doing things once, in the appropriate manner.
• In this methodology, the requirements are defined at the
beginning, this is followed by work completion in phases.
• In a waterfall approach, the outcomes of the next phase
are typically the input of the previous phase. The term
waterfall implies that the project is executed in a
cascading manner, where one phase is completed before
the next can begin.
122
Project Management Methodologies…
• PRINCE2
• PRINCE2 (PRojects IN Controlled Environments) is a process
based project management methodology. It was developed as an
information systems standard for the UK government. The
methodology has its roots in PROMPT II (Project Resource
Organization Management Planning Techniques).
• The six aspects of PRINCE2 are tolerances or what you can call
performance goals. These include scope, timescale, risk, quality,
benefits, and costs. Furthermore, PRINCE2 consists of seven
principles including continued business justification, learn from
experience, defined roles and responsibilities, manage by stages,
manage by exception, focus on products and tailor to suit the
project environment. PRINCE2 is a great project management
methodology for large scale and predictable projects.
123
Project Management Methodologies…
• PMI’s PMBOK
• A framework of standards, Project Management
Body of Knowledge or PMBOK provides
standards, conventions, best practices, guidelines,
terminologies and processes which make up the
project management industry. Due to this it is
often considered as a methodology on its own,
though this can be considered debatable. PMBOK
has five process steps for project management
which include initiating, planning, executing,
monitoring and closing. 124
Project Management Methodologies…
• Joint Application Development
• JAD focuses on including the client in the early
stages and getting user participation in project
design.
• This method is design to improve communication
by allowing the client to provide feedback and
ideas as early as possible in collaborative setting.
• Clients are included in meetings throughout the
project lifecycle to develop a greater sense of
partnership and consensus, leading to an
increased commitment to the project. 125
Hybrid Project Management & Methodologies
127
Project Management Methodologies…
• Agifall
• The Agifall approach uses both the
speed and fluidity of the Agile
approach, while introducing more
project information beforehand like
the waterfall method.
128
Project Management Methodologies…
• Scrumban
• The Scrumban methodology is a
combination of both SCRUM and Kanban.
It limits the work in progress by allowing
teams to focus on their current tasks.
Scrumban retains the aspects of reviews and
retrospectives for improvement, whereas it
uses aspects of Kanban for managing small
iterations of teams using a visual board.
129
Choosing the Right Project Management
Methodology
130
Factors affecting choice of Methodologies
• Strategic goals
• Core values
• Business drivers
• Constraints
• Stakeholders
• Risk
• Project complexity
• Project size/scope
• Flexibility
131
Choosing the Right Project Management
Methodology…
• Factors which can help you identify the right project management
methodology.
1. Project Factors
• Are you developing software? Does your project include
large-scale infrastructure development or the production
of a standard product? Your project management
methodology will depend on your project factors such as
project needs, constraints, available resources, and
finances. Some projects might need a more traditional
Waterfall approach. Whereas other projects might need to
be more fluid in output and project management
approach, requiring Lean or Agile frameworks. 132
Choosing the Right Project Management
Methodology…
2. Organizational Goals
• Does your organization intend to satisfy
customers amidst changing needs, or
wishes to provide a high-quality product
which is old school and standardized?
Your organizational goals will play a
major role in the type of methodology
you use.
133
Choosing the Right Project Management
Methodology…
3. Organizational and Team Values
• It isn’t easy incorporating Lean and Agile
frameworks in a working environment
where people are not used to adaptability.
The corporate culture, values of an
organization and team values instilled by the
senior management play an important role
in what methodology is used for project
management in an organization.
134
Choosing the Right Project Management
Methodology…
4. The Rigidity or Flexibility of Your Work
Environment
• Organizations in the IT industry are always looking
to adapt to ever changing environments, new
devices released every year if not every quarter
amidst the need to address customer needs. On the
contrary, the need for producing a standard product
such as infrastructure for a government department
might not be as fluid, with rigid controls, lengthy
paperwork and red tape.
135
Choosing the Right Project Management
Methodology…
5. Methodology which Delivers the Most Value
• A methodology which adapts quickly to changes
after an operating system update cannot be
applied for a rigid environment, where customers
like to stick with a traditional product, with little
or no change. The methodology which adds the
most value and addresses customer needs should
be a top consideration when picking a project
management methodology.
136
Choosing the Right Project Management
Methodology…
• In conclusion, while there is a debate over whether the
traditional, Agile or Hybrid project management
methodologies and frameworks provide more value, we can’t
disagree with the fact that the modern project manager needs
to adapt to an environment where technology and customer
needs can usually be hard to predict on a long-term basis.
• Even when using the Waterfall approach, the modern project
manager might need to use tools which might be similar to
Kanban boards.
• As new technology, methods and changes in the way we
conduct business shape our future, we are likely to see more
hybrid and perhaps something even more novel in terms of
project management methodologies. 137
Common Project Management Methods
143
Modern Project Management …
• One clear benefit of using agile or adaptive
methodologies is that they sync well with
smart automated software. With a platform
that logs time, tracks utilization and offers
increased visibility over your team and
projects, you’ll be able to see when a certain
task is putting a project at risk of going over
budget. You can address the issue before any
real damage is done to your bottom line or
client relationships. 144
Activity
• Modern Vs. Traditional
Project Management:
Which Is Better?
145
Activity…
• Every business size, from small to medium to
giant, relies on project management to effectively
carry on their business operations.
• Modern has taken the world of project
management and software development by storm
in recent years. This project management
technique appears to be gaining popularity. Part of
the reason is that the business world is changing
rapidly, and so, companies are seeking techniques,
systems, and methodologies that will help them
run their operations in a highly responsive way.146
Key project management softwares
1. Asana
• This is a tool that helps teams
orchestrate their work, from strategic
initiatives to smaller projects.
• It provides a living system where team
members can discuss, execute, and
make changes to project prioritirs and
tasks.
147
Key project management softwares…
2. Smartsheet
• Provides users with an enterprise
platform for dynamic work.
• This cloud-based platform makes it
easy for organizations and teams to
plan, execute, and report on work for a
more efficient process and more
successful otcomes.
148
Key project management softwares…
3. monday,com
• This is an open platform where it’s
simple to create the tools needed for
every aspect pf work.
• It is easy-to-use, provides a visual
interface with tons of apps, and
allows teams to customize
dashboards to their exact preferences.
149
Key project management softwares…
4. ClickUp
• Is more than just task and project
management, it boasts reminders,
goals, calendars, docs, and more
• Plus, its fully customizable and works
well with all different types of teams
and organizations.
150
Key project management softwares…
5. Wrike
• This is used daily to manage
projects across the marketing
team.
• Wrike helps us stay on track
customizing task statuses
151
Chapter 1 Ends
152