Plionis PP3
Plionis PP3
Plionis PP3
Chapter Three
Policy, Program and Administrative
Structure of Direct Practice
Importance of Context of
Practice
• What a direct social work practitioner can
or cannot do to meet client needs is
constrained by the context within
which the practitioner works
• A context of practice has eight elements
Elements of Context of Practice
1. Desired end goals: Contained in Mission
Statements that articulate agency purpose and
values (Social Justice)
2. Field of practice –An area of specialized
practice i.e.Child and Family Welfare; Health
and Mental Health; Each field has specific
knowledge and terminology
3. Setting i.e. a place where services are offered
i.e. social service agency, schools, hospitals,
club houses
Elements of Context-Continued
4. Program i.e. TANF; Medicaid-Medicare
5. Programs have procedures for determining
eligibility and benefits
6. Policy regulates the program (TANF) and its
procedures i.e. the Personal Responsibility and
Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act
(PRWORA, 1996) is a policy enacted into law
that regulates TANF
Elements of Context-Continued
7. An Organizational and Administrative
Structure i.e. the Department of Family
and Child Welfare administers the TANF
program in a manner consistent with
PRWORA policy and procedures
8. A client population i.e. Impoverished
children and families
Overview of Social Policy as a
Context of Practice
• In the Western world, Nation-states (i.e. Canada,
the United States, the United Kingdom etc) enact
certain policies to support two macro institutions:
the economy (capitalism) and the government
(democracy). These policies are often referred to
as social (or welfare) policies.
• There are two major social policy models:
Keynesian and Schumpeterian.
Keynesian Model of Social
Welfare Policy
• Holds that profitable growth and full employment
are possible in a closed national economy; Belief
in Capitalism and Democracy
• Citizenship enables individuals to access a range
of welfare benefits which may be universal (social
security) or residual and need-based (TANF)
• Model rectifies market failures but does not
eradicate the market system
Schumpeterian Workfare Model
of Social Welfare Policy
• Replaced Keynesian model
• Model reflects government tendency to reduce
social expenditures and curtail social spending
• Imposes more demanding eligibility requirements
and requires recipients of benefits to engage in
paid employment
• Places a CAP on benefits that may be received
within a given time period; no longer universal
entitlement to minimum economic support
Comparison of Keynesian and
Schumpeterian Models
• Both models assume that an individual can attain a
decent standard of living despite the unequal
distribution of market-based incomes
• Both models provide universal and selective-
residual welfare services; safety net philosophy
• In both models, local and regional state
governments are relays for policies framed at the
national level
• Both rely on non-profit and private faith-based
charities to augment services
Ideology and Social Welfare
• Values and ideology determine the desired end-
goals of social policy
• Science and evidence can document need (what is
the prevalence and incidence of an identified
social problem i.e. domestic violence?) and
evaluate outcome (does a policy or program
work?) but cannot determine policy goals.
• Policy goals are value-based, normative, and
prescriptive (desired good, what should be)
Concept of Social Welfare
• Because of competing ideologies, social welfare is
a complex concept that carries certain tensions and
contradictions; both stigmatizing and non-
stigmatizing
• It is a concept that reflects the end result of policy-
advocacy aimed at reforming social institutions in
order to respond to populations in need
• It is a concept that acts as a function of social
control and/or mechanism to maintain the status
quo
Desired End Goals
Competing Ideologies
• Radical Ideology: Structural change of major
societal institutions (management/labor, health
care, capitalism, education etc.)
• Liberal Ideology: Reform of major societal
institutions. Creation of a universal safety net i.e.
Universal Health Care
• Conservative Ideology: Residual, means-tested,
temporary, safety-net. Individual and family
responsibility. Faith-based and charitable
initiatives.
Welfare
Social Justice and Social Control
• Social Justice: Through welfare, social work
policy advocates seek to reform institutions to
build a humane and just society
• Social Control: Through the norm of reciprocity
(linked to work) and emphasis on individualism
(linked to personal responsibility), welfare also
functions as a means of social control designed to
maintain the status quo
Two Methods and Two Skill Sets
• The ability to analyze, propose, advocate,
implement (political/legislative social work ) and
administer policy-based programs in social
welfare requires skills in the methods of indirect
practice.
• The ability to deliver policy-based concrete
services in face–to-face contact with individuals
and families in an agency setting requires skills in
the methods of direct practice
Regulatory Context of Practice