Chapter 50
Chapter 50
• Even if the system is isolated and has fixed energy, the mean values of
the macroscopic parameters of the system are still related to its
temperature T as though it were in thermal contact with a heat reservoir
of this temperature.
• Thus the calculation is again reduced to the evaluation of the partition
function Z.
• If one knows the particles which constitute the system and the
interactions between them, it is possible to find the quantum as well as
classical states of this system 2
Calculation of thermodynamic quantities
• Let us take an ideal gas of non-interacting atoms and calculate
the partition function (classical approach)
• Consider a gas consisting of N identical monatomic molecules
of mass m enclosed in a container of volume V.
• Let us denote the position and momentum vectors of the ith
molecule by ri and pi, respectively. Then the total energy is
2
N
pi
E U ( r1 ,..., rN )
i 1 2m
• Since the gas is ideal, there are no interatomic forces, and the
total energy is simply the sum of the individual kinetic
energies of the molecules:
N 2
pi
E
i 1 2m 3
• If the system can be treated in the classical approximation,
then its energy E ( qI., . . , qf, pl, . . . , pf) depends on some f
generalized coordinates and f momenta.
• In this approach, we divide up phase-space into cells of equal
volume h0f.
• Here, f is the number of degrees of freedom, and h0 is a small
constant with dimensions of angular momentum
• If phase space is subdivided into cells of volume hof the
partition function can be evaluated by first summing over the
number (dql … dqf , dpl ,.. . dpf)/hof of cells of phase space
which lie in the element of volume (dql . . . dqf, dpl … dpf) at
the point (q1, . . . q f , Pl , . . . , pf ) and which have nearly the
same energy E(q1, . . . , qf, pl, . . . , pf) and then summing (or
integrating) over all such elements of volume. 4
• Each cell in phase-space corresponds to a different state.
• The partition function is the sum of the Boltzmann factor exp(−βEr)
over all possible states, where Er is the energy of state r.
• Classically, we can approximate the summation over cells in phase-
space as an integration over all 3phase-space.
3 Thus,
3 3
d r ...d r d p ...d pN
Z ...exp E
/ 1 N
3N
1
h0
• where 3N is the number of degrees of freedom of a monatomic gas
containing N molecules.
Since the position integrals for each r i can be done immediately and
yields the volume of the container, V,
∫d3ri ≡ V
There are N such kind of integrals
∫d3r1d3r2…d3rN = VN 5
• There are such integrals, so we obtain the factor in the above
expression. Note, also, that each of the integrals over the
molecular momenta in Eq. () are identical: they differ only by
irrelevant dummy variables of integration.
VN 2 3 2 3
Z
h0
3N ...exp p1 d p1 ... exp
2m
pN d pN
2m
V 2 3
Z , 3 exp
N
p d p
h0 2m
• This is the partition function for a single molecule.
6
• The integral in Eq. () is easily evaluated
2 3 2
2m p
exp
d p
exp 2m p x dp x
2 2
exp
2 m
p y
dp y exp 2m p z dp z
• Finally
3
2 3 2m
exp 2m p d p
• Thus, 3
2m 2
V 2
h0
3 3 2m
ln Z N ln N ln V ln ln 2
one 2can immediately
• From this partition function 2 h0 calculate
other
physical quantities. Hence the expression for the mean pressure
yields 1 ln Z 1 N
P
V V
• which reduces to the ideal gas equation of state
PV NkT RT 7
• The total mean energy of the gas is given by
ln Z 3 N 3
E RT N
2 2
• Where ϵ =3/2kT is the mean energy per molecule.
• Note that the internal energy is a function of temperature alone, with
no dependence on volume.
• For 𝝂 is the number of moles and N, is Avogadro's number. the
molar specific heat at constant volume of a monatomic gas is
1 E 3
cV R
T v 2
• where R = Nk is the gas constant. so the mean energy can be written
E cV T
8
• Let us now use the partition function to calculate a new result.
The entropy of the gas can be calculated quite simply from the
expression
S k ln Z E
• Thus
S R ln V 3 ln T ,
2
3 2mk 3
2 ln 2
ho 2
• However, our expression for the entropy S is modified by this additive term. The new
expression is
• This gives
• Where
• It is apparent that the extra term involving avoids the difficulties of the Gibbs
paradox. The entropy S in above equation behaves properly like an extensive quantity;
i.e., it does get multiplied by a factor if both V and N are
• multiplied by .
• It is clear that the entropy behaves properly as an extensive quantity in this Equation.
In other words, it increases by a factor α when ν, V, and N each increase by the same
12
Validity of the classical approximation
• An approximate criterion for the validity for this classical description can be
obtained by appealing to the Heisenberg uncertainty principle
q ħ
• This relates the uncertainties q and p introduced by quantum effects in any
attempt at simultaneous specification of a position q and corresponding
momentum p of a particle. Suppose that one tries to describe the motion of
the gas molecules by classical mechanics. Denote the magnitude of the
mean momentum of a molecule by and the mean separation between
molecules by . Then one would certainly expect a classical description to be
applicable if
>>ħ
when the above equation implies that quantum mechanical effects are not
important. Equivalently >>ħ expresses the condition that
>>
i.e., that the mean separation between particles is much greater than their
mean de Broglie wavelength =2=
13
• When >> is satisfied so that >> , the quantum description ought to be
equivalent to the motion of wave packets describing individual particles
which move independently in a quasi-classical manner.
• In the opposite limit, where << , a state of the whole gas will be shown in
Chapter 6 to be described by a single wave function which cannot be
decomposed in any simple way; it thus results in correlations between the
motions of the particles even if no forces exist between them.
• The mean intermolecular separation can be estimated by imagining each
molecule at the center of a little cube of side , these cubes filling the
available volume V. Then
N = V or =
• The mean momentum can be estimated from the known mean energy of a
molecule in the gas at temperature T. By = KT
= KT
thus and 14
• This shows that the classical approximation ought to be applicable if the
concentration N/V of molecules in the gas is sufficiently small, if the temperature T
is sufficiently high, and if the mass of the molecules is not too small.
• Numerical estimates Consider, for example, helium (He) gas at room temperature
and pressure. Then one has mean pressure = 760mm Hg dynes/ cm2
17
Equipartition Theorems
• Suppose that the energy of a system is determined by some f
generalized coordinates qf and corresponding f generalized momenta
pf, so that
E E q1 ,..., q f p1 ,..., p f
where εi involves only one variable pi, and the remaining part E’
does not depend on pi.
2. The function εi is quadratic in pi, so that
i pi bpi
2
18
• What is the mean value of ϵi in thermal equilibrium if
conditions 1 and 2 are satisfied?
• If the system is in equilibrium at the absolute temperature T =
(kB)-l, it is distributed in accordance with the canonical
distribution; the mean value
19
Equipartition Theorem
20
Simple applications
• Mean kinetic energy of a molecule in a gas
• Consider a molecule in a gas (not necessarily an ideal gas) at
temperature T.
• If this molecule has mass m and a center-of-mass momentum p = mv, its
kinetic energy of translation is
• The eq. contains three quadratic terms, the equipartition theorem allows
one to conclude immediately that
• For an ideal monatomic gas the entire energy is kinetic, so that the mean
energy of gas is simply
1 2 1
KE m v x kT
2 2
1 2 1
PE k x kT
2 2
E E KE PE kT
22
Quantum Mechanical Simple Harmonic Oscillator
• Quantum mechanical results for a simple harmonic oscillator
with classical frequency ω=sqrt(k/m): The energy is quantized
E 1
nn n n = 0,1,2,3,..
2
• Energy levels are E
equally spaced!
23
• The mean energy of the oscillator is then given by
exp
2
Z exp n exp exp n
0 2 0 1 exp
geometric series
ln Z ln 1 exp
2
24
Harmonic oscillators
1 E
k BT 2
25
Specific heats of solids
• Consider any simple solid with Avogadro's number N, of
atoms per mole.
• Assume that the heat supplied to a solid is transformed into the
vibrational kinetic & potential energies of the lattice
3N Pi 2 1 2
E k i qi
i 1 2m 2
Thus the total energy is the same as that of 3N independent one dimensional
harmonic oscillators.
If the temperature T is high enough so that classical mechanics is applicable (and
room temperature is usually sufficiently high for that), application of the
equipartition theorem allows one to conclude immediately that the total mean energy
per mole is
E 3Nk T
E
Thus the molar specific heat at constant volume becomes C v 3R
T v
The result asserts that at sufficiently high temperatures all simple solids have the
same molar specific heat equal to 3R 26
Con’d
• The validity of this result was first discovered empirically and is known as the law
of Dulong and Petit.
• One can obtain an approximate idea of the behavior of cv at all temperatures by
making the crude assumption (first introduced by Einstein) that all atoms in the
solid vibrate with the same angular frequency ω.
• Then ki= mω2 for all terms i in eq(), and the mole of solid is equivalent to an
assembly of 3N, independent one dimensional harmonic oscillators.
• These can be treated by quantum mechanics SO that their total mean energy is just 3N times
that of the single Oscillator discussed previously 1 1
E 3 N
2 exp 1
• Hence the molar specific heat of the solid on the basis of this simple Einstein model is given by
E E E
1 2
C v e k BT
T v v T k T 2 Cv k B
e
v
B
2 2
k T
k BT
1
2
Let Einstein e T
Cv k B
e
2
temperature k T
T
1
27
If the temperature is so high that kT >> ℏω or T >> θ, then θ/T < < 1 and
for T>> θ
expansion of the exponentials in eq() yields again the classical result. Simply
However, if the temperature is so low that kT << ℏω or T<< θ θ/T >>1, and
Cv = 3R
the exponential factor becomes very large compared to unity. The specific heat
then becomes
•The specific heat at constant volume Cv depends
qualitatively on temperature T as shown in the
figure below.
For high temperatures, Cv (per mole) is
close to 3R (R = universal gas constant. R 2 cal/K- mole).
So, at high temperatures Cv 6 cal/K-mole
The figure shows that
3R Cv = 3R
at high temperatures for all substances. This
is the classical Dulong-Petit law.
Cv
This states that specific heat of a given number
of atoms of any solid is independent of
T, K temperature & is the same for all materials!28
General calculation of magnetization
• Consider system consisting of N noninteracting atoms in a substance at absolute
temperature T and placed in an external magnetic field H pointing along the z
direction. Then the magnetic energy of an atom be written as
where is a standard unit of magnet moment( usually the Bohr magneton ,m being
the electron mass) and where g is n number of the order of unity, the so-called g factor of the
atom. By combining one obtain
Since H points in the z direction. In a quantum-mechanical description the values which can
assume are discrete and are given by =m
Where m can take on all values between –J and +J in integral steps; i.e.
m = -J, -J+1, -J+2, …, J-1, J
Thus there are 2J+1 possible values of m corresponding to that many possible projections of the
angular momentum vector along the z axis. By virtue of the possible magnetic energies of the
atom are then
For example if J =1/2 as would be the case for an atom with a single net electron spin, there are
only two possible energies corresponding to m =±1/2 29
• The probability that an atom is in a state labeled m is given by
Here the numerator can conveniently be written as a derivative with respect to the external
parameter H, i.e.,
is the partition function of one atom. Hence the above equation becomes
30
• To calculate introduce the abbreviation
• which is simply a finite geometric series where each term is obtained from the
preceding one as a result of multiplication by This can immediately be summed to
give
• This can be brought to more symmetrical form by multiplying both numerator and
denominator by Then
31
• The function () thus defined is sometimes called the "Brillouin function.“
• Let us investigate its limiting behavior for large and small values of the
parameter . The hyperbolic cotangent is defined as
Conversely, for y << 1, both and can be expanded in power series. Retaining all terms quadratic
in y, the result is
32
• Applying these results to the function () defined in above equation yields
If 𝜂 << 1, the above equation implies that One can write this relation in
the following form:
One gets then saturation behavior where each atom has the maximum z component
of magnetic moment, gJ, that it can possibly have.
34
Maxwell Velocity Distribution
• Laplace claimed that it is possible to know everything about an
ideal gas by knowing the position and velocity precisely
• There are six parameters—the position (x, y, z) and the velocity
(vx, vy, vz)—per molecule to know the position and instantaneous
velocity of an ideal gas.
• These parameters make up 6D phase space
• The velocity components of the molecules are more important
than positions, because the energy of a gas should depend only
on the velocities.
• Define a velocity distribution function = the probability of
finding a particle with velocity between
where
35
Maxwell Velocity Distribution
• Maxwell proved that the probability distribution function is
proportional to
Therefore .
where C is a proportionality constant and β ≡ (kT)−1.
• Because v2 = vx2 + vy2 + vz2,
36
• Since the probability is 1 when integrated over entire space, we obtain
Solve for C’
• Thus
38
The Maxwell Speed Distribution
• The probability that a molecule has an energy between and +d is:
1 1
P d g exp d g exp d
Z1 k BT nQ k BT
3/ 2
1 2m 2 2
g 2 2
3D
1/ 2 1/ 2 3 / 2 nQ P 3 / 2 1/ 2 exp
4 k T
B
g() g C P()
exp
k BT =
0 0 0
1
Now let’s look at the speed distribution for these particles: mv 2
2
The probability to find a particle with the speed between v and v+dv, irrespective of the
direction of its velocity, is the same as that finding it between and +d where d =
mvdv: Pv dv P d P mvdv
1/ 2 3/ 2
2 1 2 m mv 2 Maxwell
P v m v exp mv
3/ 2 2
4v exp
2
distribution
2 2 k BT 2 k BT
Note that Planck’s constant has vanished from the equation – it is a classical result.
39
The Characteristic Values of Speed
m
3/ 2
mv 2
Because Maxwell distribution is skewed (not symmetric in
Pv 4v exp
2
2 k BT 2 k BT v), the root mean square speed is not equal to the most
probable speed:
The root-mean-square speed is proportional to the
P(v) square root of the average energy:
1 2E 3k BT
E mvrms
2
vrms
2 m m
vmax v vrms v
dP v 2 k BT
The most probable speed: dv 0 vmax
v vmax m
m mv 2 8k B T
The average speed: v v Pv dv 4v exp
3
dv
0 2 k BT 0 2 k BT m
40
005, MB speed distribution)
• Consider an ideal gas of atoms with mass m at temperature T.
(a) Using the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution for the speed v, find the corresponding
distribution for the kinetic energy (don’t forget to transform dv into d).
(b) Find the most probable value of the kinetic energy.
(c) Does this value of energy correspond to the most probable value of speed? Explain.
3/ 2
• (a) m mv 2
dN v NPv dv N 2
4v exp dv
2 k BT 2 k BT
3/ 2
dv 2 1 2 m 8 1 2
dN NP d v dv d N exp d
d Problemm (final 2 2005,
m MB speed
2 k T
B m k
B T 2 m
3/ 2
distribution)
m 4 2 1/ 2
P exp
2 k BT
3/ 2
m k BT
P 1 1/ 2 1/ 2 1 1 max 1
(b) 0 exp exp 0 max k BT
2 k BT k BT k BT 2 k BT 2
43
• The results of the above equation are generally valid even if the gas is not in
equilibrium (although f might then also be a function of r and t). But if we consider
a gas in thermal equilibrium, f() = f() is only a function of l l. The element of volume
in velocity space can be expressed in spherical coordinate
The integration over φ gives 2ᴨ, while the integral over θ yields the value 1/2.
Hence
This can be expressed in terms of the mean speed already computed in. Thus
44
• since the integration over the angles θ andϕ is just the total solid angle 4ᴨ about a
point. Hence the above equation can also be written
• This rigorous result can be compared with our previous crude estimate in the
equation. We see that the latter was off by a factor of only 2/3.
• The mean speed was already computed from the Maxwell distribution. Combining
this with the equation of state, one obtains for
45
Effusion
• It is the escape of a fluid from anatomical vessels by rupture or exudation
• It is the flow of a gas through an aperture whose diameter is small as compared with
the distance between the molecules of the gas.
• In physics and chemistry, effusion is the process in which a gas escapes from a
container through a hole of diameter considerably smaller than the mean free path
of the molecules. Such a hole is often described as a pinhole and the escape of the
gas is due to the pressure difference between the container and the exterior. Under
these conditions, essentially all molecules which arrive at the hole continue and pass
through the hole, since collisions between molecules in the region of the hole are
negligible. Conversely, when the diameter is larger than the mean free path of the
gas, flow obeys the Sampson flow law.
46
• If a sufficiently small hole (or slit) is made in the wall of the container, the equilibrium
of the gas inside the container is disturbed to a negligible extent.
• In that case the number of molecules which emerge through the small hole is the same
as the number of molecules which would strike the area occupied by the hole if the
latter were closed off.
• The process whereby molecules emerge through such a small hole is called "effusion.“
• Let us consider the situation when the hole is sufficiently small so that molecules
emerge through the hole by effusion.
• If a vacuum is maintained outside the container, the effusing molecules can be
collimated further by additional slits so that one is left with a well-defined "molecular
beam." Such molecular beams have been extensively used in experimental physics
investigations because they provide one with the possibility of studying individual
molecules under circumstances where interactions between them are negligible.
47
The number of molecules which have speed in the range between υ and υ + d υ and which
emerge per second from a small hole of area A into a solid angle range dΩ in the forward
direction θ = 0 is given by
Note that this expression involves the factor rather than the factor which occurs in the
Maxwellian speed distribution
Fig. A container divided into two parts by a partition containing a small hole. The gas in the two
parts is at different temperatures and pressures.
• One may ask the following question: What is the relation between the mean gas
pressures and in the two parts when the system is in equilibrium, i.e., when a
situation is reached where neither or , nor the amount of gas in either part, changes
with time?
49
•
• If the linear dimension D of the hole is large (D >> l ) , then the conditions simply
= ; for otherwise the pressure difference would give rise to mass motion of the gas
from one side to the other until the pressures on both sides reach equality.
• But if D << l, one deals wi1.h effusion through the hole rather than with
hydrodynamic flow.
• In this case the equilibrium condition requires that the mass of gas on each side
remain constant, i.e., that [the number of molecules which pass per second through
the hole from left to right] equals [the number of molecules which pass per second
through the hole from right to left].
• By = n this leads to the simple equality
=
By ∝ this condition becomes
=
• Thus the pressures are then not at all equal, but higher gas pressure prevails in the
part of the container at higher temperature.
50
Pressure and momentun transfer
• It is of interest to consider from a detialed kinetic point of view how a gas exerts a pressure.
• The mean force exerted on a wall of the container is due to the many collision of molecules
with the wall.
• Suppose that we wish to calculate the mean force F exerted by the gas on a small element of
area dA of the container wall. (See Fig., where we have chosen the z axis to be normal to the
element of area.) Then we must calculate the mean rate of change of momentum of this element
of wall, i.e., the mean net momentum delivered to this wall element per unit time by the
impinging molecules.
• If we focus attention on an element of area dA lying inside the gas an infinitesimal distance in
front of the wall, then the above calculation is equivalent to finding the mean net molecular
momentum which is transported per unit time across this surface from left to right as the
molecules cross this surface from both directions.
• Let us denote by G(+) the mean molecular momentum crossing this surface dA per unit time
from left to right, and by G(-) the mean molecular momentum crossing this surface dA per unit
51
time from right to left. Then one has simply
• To calculate G(+), consider the element of surface dA in the gas and focus first
attention on those molecules with velocity between υ and υ + d υ. (See Fig.1, which
is similar to Fig.,2.)
• The mean number of such molecules which cross this area in an infinitesimal time
dt is again the mean number of such molecules contained in the cylinder of
volume ; i.e., it is equal to f (υ) .
• where we have put = υcosθ and where the integration is over all velocities for
which > 0. A similar expression gives the total mean molecular momentum
G(-)transported across this area from right to left, except that the integration must
now be over all molecules for which < 0. Thus
53
• The force from the equation is then given by the net mean momentum transported
across the surface, i.e., by subtracting the second equation from first equation . But
in first equation , where the integration is only over positive values of , one can
simply put = in the integrand. In second equation , where the integration is only
over negative values of , one can put = - in the integrand. Hence first equation
gives simply
where the two integrals have been combined into a single integral over all possible
velocities. This equation is a very general expression and would be valid even if the gas
is not in equilibrium, i.e., even if f is completely arbitrary.
If the gas is in equilibrium, then f(υ) is only a function of υ = l υ l. Note first that
54
• since the integrand is odd, having opposite signs for + and -. This equation
expresses the obvious fact that there can be no mean tangential force on the wall in
an equilibrium situation. The mean normal force does, of course, not vanish.
Measured per unit area it gives the mean pressure, which is thus, by the above
equation, equal to
55
• Hence the above equation can be written equivalently as
• This agrees substantially with our crudely derived result with the first equation
(except that the averaging is now done carefully so that what appears is rather
than ).
• Since is related to the mean kinetic energy K of a molecule, the above equation
implies the general relation
• i.e., the mean pressure is just equal to 2/3 the mean kinetic energy per unit volume
of the gas.
• Up to now we have not yet made use of the fact that the mean number density of
molecules f (υ) is given by the Maxwell velocity distribution.
• This information allows us to calculate explicitly and is equivalent to using the
equipartition theorem result that = kT. Then the above equation becomes
= nKT
so that one regains the equation of state of a classical ideal gas.
56