Emerging Wireless Standards - Wifi, Zigbee and Wimax: Bhavneet Sidhu, Hardeep Singh, and Amit Chhabra
Emerging Wireless Standards - Wifi, Zigbee and Wimax: Bhavneet Sidhu, Hardeep Singh, and Amit Chhabra
Emerging Wireless Standards - Wifi, Zigbee and Wimax: Bhavneet Sidhu, Hardeep Singh, and Amit Chhabra
308
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology 25 2007
These new uses, as well as the growing number of Uncontrolled, multipath distorts the original signal, making it
conventional WLAN users, increasingly combine to strain more difficult to decipher and degrading Wi-Fi performance.
existing Wi-Fi networks. Fortunately, a solution is close at MIMO harnesses multipath with a technique known as space-
hand. The industry has come to an agreement on the division multiplexing. The transmitting WLAN device
components that will make up 802.11n, a new WLAN actually splits a data stream into multiple parts, called spatial
standard that promises both higher data rates and increased streams, and transmits each spatial stream through separate
reliability. Though the specification is not expected to be antennas to corresponding antennas on the receiving end. The
finalized before end of 2007, the draft is proving to be current 802.11n draft provides for up to four spatial streams,
reasonably stable as it progresses through the formal IEEE even though compliant hardware is not required to support
review process. [2] that many [2]. Doubling the number of spatial streams from
A wireless LAN (WiFi) is a data transmission system one to two effectively doubles the raw data rate. There are
designed to provide location-independent network access trade-offs, however, such as increased power consumption
between computing devices by using radio waves rather than a and, to a lesser extent, cost. The draft-n specification includes
cable infrastructure. Wi-Fi is meant to be used generically a MIMO power-save mode, which mitigates power
when referring to any type of 802.11 network, whether consumption by using multiple paths only when
802.11b, 802.11a, 802.11g etc. The first 802.11b networks communication would benefit from the additional
could move data at up to 11 megabits per second (Mbps). performance. The MIMO power save mode is a required
Then came products using 802.11a, followed shortly feature in the draft-n specification.
thereafter by 802.11g, each with maximum speeds of 54Mbps 3) Improved Throughput and Higher Data Rates
and throughput of around 25Mbps. WLAN hardware built Another optional mode in the 802.11n draft effectively
around 802.11g was quickly embraced by consumers and doubles data rates by doubling the width of a WLAN
businesses seeking higher bandwidth. [1] The next Wi-Fi communications channel from 20 MHz to 40 MHz. The
speed standard, 802.11n, will likely offer a bandwidth of primary trade-off here is fewer channels available for other
around 108Mbps [2]. And because it will be an industry devices. In the case of the 2.4-GHz band, there is enough
standard, n-compliant devices will be interoperable. room for three non-overlapping 20-MHz channels. Needless
to say, a 40-MHz channel does not leave much room for other
A. Characteristics of 802.11n
devices to join the network or transmit in the same airspace.
The emerging 802.11n specification differs from its This means intelligent, dynamic management is critical to
predecessors in that it provides for a variety of optional modes ensuring that the 40-MHz channel option improves overall
and configurations that dictate different maximum raw data WLAN performance by balancing the high-bandwidth
rates. This enables the standard to provide baseline demands of some clients with the needs of other clients to
performance parameters for all 802.11n devices, while remain connected to the network.
allowing manufacturers to enhance or tune capabilities to
accommodate different applications and price points. With TABLE I
every possible option enabled, 802.11n could offer raw data MAJOR COMPONENTS OF DRAFT 802.11N [1]
rates up to 600 Mbps. But WLAN hardware does not need to Feature Definition
support every option to be compliant with the standard. In the Better OFDM Supports wider bandwidth & higher code rate to
current year, for example, most draft-n WLAN hardware bring maximum data rate to 65 Mbps
available is expected to support raw data rates up to 300 Mbps Space-Division Improves performance by parsing data into
Multiplexing multiple streams transmitted through multiple
[1]. In comparison, every 802.11b-compliant product support antennas.
data rates up to 11 Mbps, and all 802.11a and 802.11g Diversity Exploits the existence of multiple antennas to
hardware support data rates up to 54 Mbps. improve range and reliability. Typically employed
1) Better OFDM when the number of antennas on the receiving end
is higher than the number of streams being
In the 802.11n draft, the first requirement is to support an transmitted.
OFDM implementation that improves upon the one employed MIMO Power Save Limits power consumption penalty of MIMO by
in the 802.11a/g standards, using a higher maximum code rate utilizing multiple antennas only on as-needed
basis.
and slightly wider bandwidth. This change improves the
40 MHz channels Effectively doubles data rates by doubling channel
highest attainable raw data rate to 65 Mbps from 54 Mbps in width from 20 MHz to 40MHz.
the existing standards [2]. Aggregation Improves efficiency by allowing transmission
2) MIMO Improves Performance bursts of multiple data packets between overhead
communications.
One of the most widely known components of the draft Reduced Inter-frame One of several draft-n features designed to
specification is known as Multiple Input Multiple Output, or Spacing (RIFS) improve efficiency. Provides a shorter delay
MIMO [2]. MIMO exploits a radio-wave phenomenon called between OFDM transmissions than in 802.11a or
multipath: transmitted information bounces off walls, doors, g.
Greenfield Mode Improves efficiency by eliminating support for
and other objects, reaching the receiving antenna multiple 802.11a/b/g devices in an all draft-n network.
times via different routes and at slightly different times.
309
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology 25 2007
310
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology 25 2007
proprietary wireless systems manufactured today to solve a 1) Low power consumption, with battery life ranging from
multitude of problems that also don’t require high data rates months to years.
but do require low cost and very low current drain. 2) Maximum data rates allowed for each of the frequency
The ZigBee Alliance is not pushing a technology; rather it bands are fixed as 250 kbps @2.4 GHz, 40 kbps @ 915
is providing a standardized base set of solutions for sensor and MHz, and 20 kbps @868 MHz.
control systems. To allow vendors to supply the lowest 3) High throughput and low latency for low duty-cycle
possible cost devices the IEEE standard defines two types of applications (<0.1%).
devices: full function devices (FFD) and reduced function 4) Channel access using Carrier Sense Multiple Access with
devices (RFD) [4]. An IEEE 802.15.4/ZigBee network Collision Avoidance (CSMA - CA).
5) Addressing space of up to 64 bit IEEE address devices,
requires at least one full function device as a network
65,535 networks.
coordinator, but endpoint devices may be reduced
6) 70-100m range.
functionality devices to reduce system cost.
7) Low cost (device, installation, maintenance). Low cost to
The ZigBee Standard has evolved standardized sets of the users means low device cost, low installation cost and
solutions, called ‘layers'. [4] These layers facilitate the low maintenance. ZigBee devices allow batteries to last
features that make ZigBee very attractive: low cost, easy up to years using primary cells (low cost) without any
implementation, reliable data transfer, short-range operations, chargers (low cost and easy installation). ZigBee’s
very low power consumption and adequate security features. simplicity allows for inherent configuration and
Network and Application Support layer: The network layer redundancy of network devices provides low maintenance.
has been designed to allow the network to spatially grow 8) High density of nodes per network: ZigBee’s use of the
without requiring high power transmitters. The network layer IEEE 802.15.4 PHY and MAC allows networks to handle
also can handle large amounts of nodes with relatively low any number of devices. This attribute is critical for
latencies. The APS sub-layer's responsibilities include massive sensor arrays and control networks.
maintenance of tables that enable matching between two 9) Fully reliable “hand-shaked” data transfer protocol.
devices and communication among them, and also discovery, 10) Different topologies like: star, peer-to-peer, mesh
the aspect that identifies other devices that operate in the B. Applications of ZigBee
operating space of any device.
ZigBee networks consist of multiple traffic types with their
Physical layer: The IEEE 802.15.4 physical layer
own unique characteristics, including periodic data,
accommodates high levels of integration by using direct
intermittent data, and repetitive low latency data. The
sequence to permit simplicity in the analog circuitry and
characteristics of each are as follows:
enable cheaper implementations.
• Periodic data – usually defined by the application such as
Media access control layer: The IEEE 802.15.4 media
a wireless sensor or meter. Data typically is handled using
access control layer permits use of several topologies without
a beaconing system whereby the sensor wakes up at a set
introducing complexity and is meant to work with large time and checks for the beacon, exchanges data, and goes
numbers of devices. to sleep.
• Intermittent data – either application or external stimulus
User-defined Application Profiles defined such as a wireless light switch. Data can be
ZigBee defined Object Layer handled in a beaconless system or disconnected. In
disconnected operation, the device will only attach to the
network when communications is required, saving
significant energy.
• Repetitive low latency data – uses time slot allocations
Network and Application Support Layer such as a security system. These applications may use the
guaranteed time slot (GTS) capability. GTS is a method
IEEE Media Access Control Layer of QoS that allows each device a specific duration of time
as defined by the PAN coordinator in the Superframe to
do whatever it requires without contention or latency.
IEEE Physical Layer
For example, an automatic meter reading application
Fig. 3 IEEE 802.15.4 / ZigBee Stack Architecture represents a periodic data traffic type with data from water or
gas meters being transmitted to a line powered electric meter
A. Characteristics of ZigBee and passed over a powerline to a central location. Using the
ZigBee is poised to become the global control/sensor beaconing feature of the IEEE standard, the respective
network standard. It has been designed to provide the Reduced Function Device (RFD) meter wakes up and listens
following features: [3] for the beacon from the PAN coordinator, if received, the
RFD requests to join the network. The PAN coordinator
accepts the request. Once connected, the device passes the
meter information and goes to sleep. This capability provides
311
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology 25 2007
for very low duty cycles and enables multi-year battery life. WiMAX also makes ubiquitous Internet access possible.
Intermittent traffic types, such as wireless light switches, WiMAX, operating at comparable distances as cellular
connect to the network when needed to communicate (i.e. turn phones, can be installed on cellular towers and allow Internet
on a light). For repetitive low latency applications a data access in as many places as cellular phone access. This
guaranteed time slot option provides for Quality of Service adds a new dimension to what Internet access providers can
with a contention free, dedicated time slot in each super frame offer: a broadband connection that a person can take with
that reduces contention and latency. Applications requiring them when they travel.
timeliness and critical data passage may include medical alerts WiMAX Forum was formed in April 2001, to promote
and security systems. In all applications, the smaller packet conformance and interoperability of the standard IEEE
sizes of ZigBee devices results in higher effective throughput 802.16. The forum was formed solely for development &
values compared to other standards. ZigBee networks are promotion of devices supported by the 802.16 standard. In
primarily intended for low duty cycle sensor networks (<1%). September 2004, Intel introduced initial samples of a WiMAX
A new network node may be recognized and associated in chipset, named Rosedale. Intel has plans to ship WiMAX
about 30 ms. Waking up a sleeping node takes about 15 ms, as devices for use in the office and home by 2007. [5]
does accessing a channel and transmitting data. ZigBee The IEEE 802.16 standard is versatile enough to
applications benefit from the ability to quickly attach accommodate time division multiplexing (TDM) or frequency
information, detach, and go to deep sleep, which results in low division duplexing (FDD) deployments and also allows for
power consumption and extended battery life. both full and half-duplex terminals. WiMAX uses microwave
radio technology to connect computers to the Internet.
C. Comparison of ZigBee and Bluetooth
WiMAX works very much like cell phone technology in that
The bandwidth of Bluetooth is 1 Mbps; ZigBee's is one- reasonable proximity to a base station is required to establish a
fourth of this value. The strength of Bluetooth lies in its ability data link to the Internet. Users within 3 to 5 miles of the base
to allow interoperability and replacement of cables, ZigBee's, station will be able to establish a link using non line- of-sight
of course, is low costs and long battery life. (NLOS) technology with data rates as high as 75Mbps. Users
Most important in any meaningful comparison are the up to 30 miles away from the base station with an antenna
diverse application areas of all the different wireless mounted for line-of-sight (LOS) to the base station will be
technologies. Bluetooth is meant for such target areas as able to connect at data rates approaching 280Mbps [6].
wireless USB's, handsets and headsets, whereas ZigBee is
meant to cater to the sensors and remote controls market and A. Characteristics of WiMAX
other battery operated products. Technical aspects of 802.16a that are instrumental in
In a gist, it may be said that they are neither complementary powering robust performance include following
standards nor competitors, but just essential standards for characteristics:
different targeted applications. The earlier Bluetooth targets • Power: Varies with band. Profiles from 100 Mw up to 2W
interfaces between PDA and other device (mobile phone / • Configuration: P-P and P-MP Cellular
printer etc.) and cordless audio applications. Bluetooth has • Spectrum: Initially 3.5 GHz licensed and 5.8 GHz
addressed a voice application by embodying a fast frequency unlicensed bands
hopping system with a master slave protocol. ZigBee has • Radio interface: OFDM, using 256 tones
addressed sensors, controls, and other short message • Access Protocols: Downstream - TDM (Broadcast),
applications by embodying a direct sequence system with a Upstream - TDMA with access contention
star or peer-to-peer protocols. • Security via station authentication and encryption
• Data rates variable with channel bandwidth 3.5 MHz in 3.5
IV. WIMAX (WORLDWIDE INTEROPERABILITY FOR GHz band, 20 MHz in 5.8 GHz band
MICROWAVE ACCESS) – 802.16
• Actual realizable data rates are ~ 2b/Hz
Yet another wireless network technology may have an • Maximum range ~2Km for indoor Non-LOS cellular
impact over the next few years: 802.16, better known as service at 3.5 GHz
WiMAX. The IEEE approved the 802.16 standards in June
2004 [5]. This technology supports speeds as high as 70Mbps B. Applications of WiMAX
and a range of up to 48 kilometers. WiMAX can be used for WiMAX will allow people to go from their homes to their
wireless networking like the popular WiFi. WiMAX allows cars, and then travel to their offices or anywhere in the world,
higher data rates over longer distances, efficient use of all seamlessly. [7] WiMAX can serve the business, residential
bandwidth, and avoids interference almost to a minimum. and mobile segments. The applications in these areas are listed
WiMAX can be termed partially a successor to the Wi-Fi below:
protocol. Current technologists envision a WiMAX receiver in Residential users
a person’s home, with a WiFi transmitter to serve in-home • Basic voice services, low cost domestic & international calls
connections, and longer term having laptops and personal • Basic (dialup speed) to advanced (over 1Mbps) data
devices capable of transmitting directly to WiMAX towers. connections
312
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology 25 2007
• Bundled voice and data services Fi as its primary backhaul service of choice. WiMAX
Business users promises to help corporations expand business, drive down
• Basic data connectivity for small businesses costs, increase overall profitability, increase the quality of
• Advanced data services to medium and large businesses service, and increase the number of users that connect to the
• Feature-rich, low cost voice services (VoIP) Internet.
Mobile users (mobile WiMAX only)
• Data connectivity for mobile workforce REFERENCES
• Data connectivity for international visitors [1] Introduction to Wi-Fi technology, Retrieved on September 24, 2006
from www.wi-fitechnology.com
[2] Broadcom, 802.11n: Next-Generation Wireless LAN Technology, White
V. COMPARISON OF WIRELESS TECHNOLOGIES Paper dated April 2006
[3] Homepage of 802.15 WPAN Task Group 4 (TG4),
The use of wireless technologies is beginning to appear http://grouper.ieee.org/groups/802/15/pub/TG4.html
similar to the initial development of the railways. Each [4] P. Kinney, ZigBee Technology: Wireless Control that Simply Works,
technology seems to have a different “gauge” and White Paper dated 2 October 2003.
[5] IEEE 802.16 and WiMAX: Broadband Wireless Access for Everyone,
compatibility issues seem to confuse the novice. The main Intel Corporation, 2003.
points of comparison of the three technologies that have been http://www.intel.com/ebusiness/pdf/wireless/intel/80216_wimax.pdf
discussed in this paper are listed in table III. [6] Specifications of WiMAX. Retrieved on October 10, 2006 from
http://wimax.com
[7] Westech Communications Inc. on behalf of the WiMAX Forum, Can
TABLE III
WiMAX Address Your Applications? White paper dated October 24,
COMPARISON OF EMERGING WIRELESS TECHNOLOGIES
2005.
Technology WiFi - ZigBee WiMAX
802.11n
Application Wireless Sensor Metro Area
LAN, Internet Networks Broadband
Internet
connectivity
Typical Range 100m 70-100m 50 km
Frequency 2.4 GHz 2.4GHz 2-11GHz
Range
Data Rate 108 - 250Kbps 75Mbps
600Mbps
Modulation DSSS DSSS QAM
Network IP & P2P Mesh IP
IT Network Yes No Yes
Connectivity
Network Infrastructure Ad-hoc Infrastructure
Topology (Ad-hoc also
possible)
Access Protocol CSMA/CA CSMA/CA Request/Grant
Key Attributes Wider Cost, Throughput,
Bandwidth, Power Coverage
Flexibility
VI. CONCLUSION
This paper has presented an overview of emerging wireless
technologies. 802.11n is viewed as the most likely contender
for the home network backbone. ZigBee, on the other hand, is
likely to make best use of its low-power and high-speed
operation in short-range equipment interconnects, such as
personal computers and portable equipment. ZigBee networks
are primarily intended for low duty cycle sensor networks
(<1%). 802.11n is viewed as being superior in maintaining
compatibility with existing wireless LAN, while ZigBee is
generally thought more likely to achieve lower levels of
power consumption. Our vision of the future is that WiMAX
will enable mobile broadband at an affordable price. This will
be achieved through the adoption of WiMAX by a cellular
provider seeking to make a jump to this disruptive technology.
WiMAX is not expected to completely eliminate the Wi-Fi
technology in the near future, but will be a complement to Wi-
313