Paul Newman: A Life, by Shawn Levy - Excerpt
Paul Newman: A Life, by Shawn Levy - Excerpt
Paul Newman: A Life, by Shawn Levy - Excerpt
PAUL NEWMAN
A Life
Levy_9780307353757_5p_fm_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 2:05 PM Page ii
PAUL NEWMAN
A Life
SHAWN LEVY
Harmony Books New York
Levy_9780307353757_5p_fm_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 2:05 PM Page iv
Levy, Shawn.
Paul Newman: a life/Shawn Levy.
p. cm.
1. Newman, Paul, 1925–2008. 2. Motion picture actors and
actresses—United States—Biography. I. Title.
PN2287.N44L48 2009
791.4302'8092—dc22
[B] 2009011220
ISBN 978-0-307-35375-7
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
First Edition
www.HarmonyBooks.com
To purchase a copy of
Paul Newman: A Life
visit one of these online retailers:
Amazon
Barnes & Noble
Borders
IndieBound
Powell’s Books
Random House
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_01_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:55 PM Page 1
Part One
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_01_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:55 PM Page 3
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_01_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:55 PM Page 4
4 Shawn Levy
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_01_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:55 PM Page 5
PA U L N E W M A N 5
One has just turned thirty, has been married for six years, and has
three children, the oldest not quite five. The other is seventy-eight,
with his forty-fifth anniversary coming up and five grown daughters
and a pair of grandkids with whom to celebrate it.
Physically, they share some traits: wavy hair, icy blue eyes, a classi-
cal handsomeness that looks patrician on the old fellow and preppy on
the kid, and a springy grace that makes the young man seem coltish
and the old man seem spry.
But their personalities are pretty distinct. The old guy is serious, a
World War II vet who attended Kenyon College and the Yale School
of Drama on the GI Bill and dreamed of becoming a teacher and takes
an active part in politics; he’s raised hundreds of millions of dollars for
charity and served as president of the Actors Studio. The young guy is
famous for his beer drinking and his practical jokes and his goofball
sense of humor and his love of fast cars and motorcycles and his roles
as antiauthoritarian rebels; he’s already created a couple of parts on
Broadway that have maintained a place in the national repertoire and
made a few indelible TV dramas.
The older man you know: Paul Newman, playing the Stage Man-
ager in the Westport County Playhouse production of Our Town as
filmed at the Booth Theater on Broadway in early 2003.
And the younger man, well, you know him too: Paul Newman,
playing George Gibbs in the same play, adapted as a musical for NBC
television’s Producers’ Showcase in September 1955.
Between those two performances sits an entire career and, indeed,
an entire life—not only of one man but of the culture in which he
thrived.
The blind, impetuous vigor of youth; the wry, still acceptance of ma-
turity; the progress of an artist in his craft; the maturation of a soul, a
mind, a body; the life of a man and the half-century of history he lived
and echoed and symbolized and even shaped: Paul Newman’s story is
all of it.
From a burgeoning Jazz Age suburb to a torpedo bomber in the
Pacific, from the womb of academia to the free-for-all of Broadway
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_01_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:55 PM Page 6
6 Shawn Levy
and live TV, from the gilded cage of a Hollywood studio contract to
the wild freedom of directing films for his own production company,
from the filth and noise and danger of professional auto racing to the
staid and venerable confines of the Philanthropy Hall of Fame, Paul
Newman’s life is a blazon of the American century, incorporating the
very best national traits in a compact and comely package.
For fifty years, on-screen and off, Newman vividly embodied cer-
tain tendencies in the American male character: active and roguish and
earnest and sly and determined and vulnerable and brave and humble
and reliable and compassionate and fair. He was a man of his time, and
that time ranged from World War II to the contemporary era of digi-
tally animated feature films. He was equally at home on Hollywood
soundstages, in theatrical workshops, in the pits of racetracks, and es-
pecially on the blessedly raucous fields and in the log cabins and swim-
ming holes of the camps he built and maintained for seriously ill
children. The world was his for the claiming—and he claimed only
the bit that he felt was reasonably due him, and he gave back more, by
far, than he ever took.
He was ridiculously handsome and trim, with a face that belonged
on an ancient coin, eyes that stunned and dazed even cynics, and an
athlete’s compact, lithe, and peppy body. Having fallen into acting as a
profession, he would have been guaranteed at least minimal success by
sheer virtue of his physical charms. If he’d had no talent or tenacity or
intellect or drive, he might still have enjoyed fame and riches. Put him
in a dinner jacket, and he could sit confidently at table with presidents
or poets or kings. He looked the part—in fact, he looked any part, vir-
tually, that he was asked to play.
But he was smart and cagey and suspicious of fortune too easily
won, and he was scrupulous in distinguishing the things that came to
him through luck from those he felt he’d earned. He opted to live as
far as reasonable from Hollywood, preferred barn coats and blue jeans
to tuxedos, and chose the company of troupers and mechanics and
beer-swillers over that of celebrities and swells and hobnobbers every
time. There was crust and vinegar to him, and he relished the oppor-
tunity that his position in life afforded him to startle big shots with his
sometimes downmarket tastes and preferences. And vice versa: he
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_01_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:55 PM Page 7
PA U L N E W M A N 7
Few have lived fuller or richer lives than Paul Newman, and at the
time of his death, the world seemed to take stock for the first time of
all the Paul Newmans it had known: the actor, the driver, the public
citizen, the entrepreneur, the philanthropist, the family man. But as
Newman always knew, it all began with luck—the genetics, upbring-
ing, education, and career fortunes that uniquely enabled him to be-
come a movie star. And it was as a movie star that he made his most
obvious mark on the world.
In ways, he did it through the back door. Rarely appearing in obvi-
ous blockbusters, striving to reinvent himself by shedding his skin
every few years, he compiled a cinematic résumé over five decades that
was studded regularly with milestone films and performances: Some-
body Up There Likes Me; The Long, Hot Summer; The Left Handed Gun;
Cat on a Hot Tin Roof; Exodus; The Hustler; Paris Blues; Hud; Harper;
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_01_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:55 PM Page 8
8 Shawn Levy
Hombre; Cool Hand Luke; Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid; The Life
and Times of Judge Roy Bean; The Sting; The Towering Inferno; Buffalo
Bill and the Indians; Slap Shot; Fort Apache the Bronx; Absence of Malice;
The Verdict; The Color of Money; Blaze; Mr. & Mrs. Bridge; The Hud-
sucker Proxy; Nobody’s Fool; Road to Perdition; Empire Falls; Cars. This is
more than just a litany of estimable (and in some cases commercially
gigantic) film titles. It’s the trajectory of an actor determined to squirm
away from preconceptions and to sharpen his artistic abilities at the
same time. It stands against the very few similar lists of films ever com-
piled, and it spans eras, styles, generations. He wasn’t the greatest
American actor, and he was not even the greatest actor of his own vin-
tage. But he was arguably the most American actor, the fellow whose
roles and accumulated persona best captured the tenor of his times and
his people.
Newman arrived in movies with the Method actor invaders of the
1950s and rode out their splashy heyday, becoming a commercial
superstar while insistently pushing forward the boundaries of his craft.
If you approached him initially only at the superficial level—the level
of beauty, as it were—you might have mistaken him for Rock Hudson
or Tony Curtis or Robert Wagner, handsome and capable, sure, but
movie stars principally rather than craftsmen. Newman, though, had
an internal discipline that demanded he make more of himself, and he
earned, through sheer perseverance, a place alongside—and in ways,
above—the Method gods Marlon Brando, Montgomery Clift, and
James Dean. He was ultimately the one true superstar to emerge from
the original Actors Studio generation, the most popular and enduring
Stanislavskyan actor in American screen history, the only one who
could sit comfortably alongside big-time Golden Era movie stars and
newfangled subversive interlopers.
And he was able to bridge the space between those two brands of
actors for decades. In a half-century of movies, the characteristic New-
man role morphed from almost-too-pretty to dangerously sleek to de-
liberately wily to weathered and weary-wise. At his best he played
against his looks—which may be why he is widely regarded as improv-
ing as an actor as he aged. And his instinct to cut against himself meant
that he couldn’t personify scions of wealth and privilege as well as he
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_01_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:55 PM Page 9
PA U L N E W M A N 9
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_01_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:55 PM Page 10
10 Shawn Levy
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_01_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:55 PM Page 11
PA U L N E W M A N 11
genuinely humble, believing in work and family and luck and commu-
nity and the greater good—and if a surfeit of that good slopped up
onto his plate over the years, he would be sure to share it, and he
would do so in the best humor he could. Somehow he had turned the
gifts life and luck had granted him into things he could multiply and
give back. Occasionally along the way he would misstep or be discour-
teous or make a wrong aesthetic choice or drive ill-advisedly or what-
not, but what he never did was hole up, retreat, give in, surrender, or
fail to engage.
“What I would really like to put on my tombstone,” he once said,
“is that I was part of my time.”
And he was.
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_02_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:56 PM Page 13
Part Two
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_02_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:56 PM Page 15
One
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_02_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:56 PM Page 16
16 Shawn Levy
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_02_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:56 PM Page 17
PA U L N E W M A N 17
industry than with its soul. Anyone with a head to make a business for
himself could create wonders in such a freewheeling environment;
local boy John D. Rockefeller had already risen from dubious roots to
become a metaphor for unimaginable wealth created out of thin air.
But anyone with a head to make a life for himself would seek more
easeful and commodious surroundings. And on the anticipation of ful-
filling that urge the Van Sweringens’ plan was realized.
By 1920, when the Shaker Heights Rapid Transit line was inaugu-
rated to speed riders to and from Cleveland, Shaker Heights had more
than 1,600 residents; ten years later, it had swelled to more than
17,000, all living in single-family homes, none of which, per the Van
Sweringens’ plan, were exactly alike. Among the newcomers were
Arthur S. Newman and his wife, Theresa, who invested in the dream
of Shaker Heights in 1927, moving with their two sons, three-year-old
Arthur and two-year-old Paul, into a big but not ostentatious $35,000
house at 2983 Brighton Road.
That was a lot of money for the time—nearly a half-million dollars
in contemporary terms—but it was a remarkably flush moment for the
national economy, and Art, as he was commonly known, wouldn’t have
spent it if he couldn’t afford it. As secretary and treasurer of Newman-
Stern, Cleveland’s largest and best-liked sporting goods and consumer
electronics store, he was a man who had created out of whole cloth a
business built on a nation’s increased devotion to entertainment and
leisure time. The 1920s were a golden age of sports heroes—Babe Ruth,
Red Grange, Bobby Jones, Bill Tilden, Jack Dempsey—and Newman-
Stern could sell you not only all the gear and accoutrements that you’d
require to emulate those greats but also a radio on which to listen to ac-
counts of their achievements. As long as Clevelanders had money in
their pockets and free time in which to spend it, the sporting goods and
electronics business was sure to thrive.
So why not buy a nicer home? Previously the Newmans had lived in
Cleveland Heights at 2100 Renrock Road, a small, trim, undistin-
guished single-family dwelling in a neighborhood close by a pair of busy
streets—not the nicest part of Cleveland Heights but conveniently near
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_02_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:56 PM Page 18
18 Shawn Levy
the home of Arthur’s older brother Joseph, who also happened to be his
business partner and, probably, best friend in the world.
Brighton Road was an obvious step up. An English Tudor house
with a peaked roof, it was a pleasant stroll away from Shaker Boule-
vard, the town’s main artery, and it was set back from the curling street
on which it stood by two rectangles of lawn and a handful of oak and
maple trees. A fireplace dominated the front room, and big windows
looked out over the front and back yards. There were more imposing
homes on the street—indeed, there were outright mansions nearby.
But the Newmans’ home would certainly satisfy anyone’s idea of com-
fort, modest luxury, and good taste.
For Arthur and Theresa, the house was a physical realization of the
dreams of all those immigrants who had left Europe for America and a
chance to make something of themselves. Arthur’s parents were both
born in the old country, as was Theresa herself. Their ability to rise
from those roots to the prosperity of Shaker Heights was an instance
of what many would call the American dream, and it was also a crucial
element in what would become the character of their younger son.
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_02_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:56 PM Page 19
PA U L N E W M A N 19
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_02_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:56 PM Page 20
20 Shawn Levy
creative and successful group of offspring. Their hat shop, for in-
stance, would one day be immortalized in 1943 in Polly Poppingay,
Milliner, a popular chapter book for children written by Gertrude
Newman, who by then had already published another children’s book,
The Story of Delicia, a Rag Doll. Lillian, too, was a writer, producing
verse in Yiddish. Ottile would become a schoolteacher and go on to
head the drama group at the Euclid Avenue Temple, probably the
most prominent synagogue in Cleveland; one of her sons, Richard
Newman Campen, would graduate from Dartmouth College and
forge a career as a noted historian of midwestern art and architecture.
The Newman boys were also to make marks on the world. Aaron
attended some college and then became a reporter for the Cleveland
World and, in 1906, the cofounder and business manager of the Jewish
Independent, one of several Jewish papers in town. In 1927, that incred-
ibly flush year, he inaugurated two enterprises: the Little Theater of
the Movies, the first cinema in Cleveland devoted exclusively to for-
eign films, and the Cleveland Sportsman’s and Outdoors Show, a trade
fair at which manufacturers and retailers exhibited the latest recre-
ational gear. During the Depression he wrote several satirical pam-
phlets about the fear of Communist strains in the New Deal.*
Quite a character. And yet his brother Joseph made even more of a
splash in the world. No history of twentieth-century Cleveland is truly
complete without mentioning, at least in passing, the ingenious, loqua-
cious, mercurial, professorial, practical, affable, quixotic sprite born
Joseph Simon Newman. Poet, inventor, orator, journalist, gadabout,
boulevardier, and mensch, Joe Newman published science columns and
light verse in newspapers, held patents on electronic communications
gizmos, wrote the annual musical comedy revue for the City Club for
more than three decades, taught at Cleveland College, served as a
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_02_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:56 PM Page 21
PA U L N E W M A N 21
-
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_02_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:56 PM Page 22
22 Shawn Levy
Arthur Sigmund Newman was born on August 29, 1893, and soon
afterward the family was altered forever; by the time of his second
birthday, his father had died. Art, as he was always known, would be
raised by his sisters and brothers, all still living at home as late as 1900.
Hannah ran Newman’s Millinery in the bustling Jewish commercial
district on Cleveland’s West Twenty-sixth Street. Like Joe, who was
only two years older, Art attended Central High School; like Aaron, he
was drawn into newspaper work. Not long after high school he
founded, published, wrote, and solicited ads for a local business circu-
lar, the Home Advertiser. He parlayed that into a job in the advertising
and news departments of the Cleveland Press, where he proved unlucky:
in 1915, phoning into the newsroom to report a scoop regarding a
contentious strike at the Mechanical Rubber Company, he was inad-
vertently connected to the rival Cleveland News, which published his
story while his own paper got nothing; they canned him.
And so Art went straight to work at Electro-Set, finding in Joe not
only a surrogate parent (Hannah had died in 1913 when Art was seven-
teen) but a perfectly complementary partner as well. A few years
later, interviewed in a Cleveland business journal, Joe said: “Art and I
are as alike as sunup and sundown. I am the maniac of the business—
the long-haired dreamer. At least that’s Art’s diagnosis. He is the
hard-shelled, brass-tacks man. Every business needs both types. One
counteracts the other.” The brothers would work together side by
side for decades: Joe a wise and wacky jester filled with unpredictable
energies, Art balding and sad-eyed and diligent and upright and
exact. (Even in his twenties he looked older than his older brother.)
The Newman-Stern Company they built would break all sorts of
new ground: it was the first entity in Cleveland to broadcast election
results by radio and the first to offer steel fishing rods and steel-shafted
golf clubs; its sale of microscopes for children virtually invented the
field. In 1921 the business relocated to a large downtown storefront,
where it would expand again after just seven years and then again after
World War II, by which time it had become the premier destination in
the region for sporting equipment: baseball, camping and fishing gear,
skis, small boats, tents, as well as radios, even television sets. And it al-
ways had a hand in gizmos: in 1946 Art stumbled upon a sweet deal on
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_02_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:56 PM Page 23
PA U L N E W M A N 23
* A version of this coup is credited to a character in the 1984 film Harry & Son, which
Paul Newman cowrote and directed.
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_02_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:56 PM Page 24
24 Shawn Levy
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_02_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:56 PM Page 25
PA U L N E W M A N 25
and they either were overlooked by census takers or got hinky when
they came around: only in 1920 were they fully polled in the national
head count. And Theresa was even more elusive. Indeed, for much of
her early life, surmise is all that’s possible. In 1910 a seventeen-year-old
Theresa Fetzer was working as a domestic at the home of Meyer E.
Loeb of Cleveland. If it was she, it meant that she was a little older than
she later claimed. (Perhaps she and/or the Loebs lied about her age in
order to acquire or legitimize her working situation.) She didn’t appear
in the 1920 census, but she showed up in 1930, by which point the re-
ceived impression of her life story has begun to gel. There she’s a
thirty-two-year-old woman of Czech heritage, naturalized in 1902 and
living in Shaker Heights with her husband, Arthur (described as a shoe
store merchant), and their two boys, Arthur Jr., age six, and Paul, five.
But even then there’s a snag: Arthur, then thirty-six, asserted that he
was married for the first time seven years before, in 1923, at age
twenty-nine; Theresa, though, revealed that she was first married at
age nineteen—thirteen years earlier, in 1917, when she may have been
as old as twenty-four.
Decades later the murkiness of her early life outlived her. Just ask her
son: “My mother, on her deathbed, said, ‘Paul, you have to excuse me,
I’ve been lying all these years. I’m not eighty-three, I’m eighty-seven.’
And when we took her back to Cleveland to be buried next to my father,
her sister was there. And I said, ‘You know, Mother said that she had
been lying all these years, and that she wasn’t eighty-three, she was
eighty-seven.’ And her sister said, ‘Baloney! She was ninety-three!’ ”
The wedding of this rootless, pretty woman and her owlish, respon-
sible husband would also provide a mystery: unique among their par-
ents and siblings, they weren’t issued a marriage license in Cuyahoga
County. Wherever the ceremony was held, it was almost certainly a
civil one. Through his life Art belonged to the synagogue known as
the Temple in the old Woodland Avenue Jewish enclave of west Cleve-
land, but his son Paul remembered, “[He] was not a religious man
in the sense of going to synagogue or thrusting religion down our
throats.” And Theresa would soon leave her native Catholicism for
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_02_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 1:56 PM Page 26
26 Shawn Levy
* The Newman boys received no formal religious instruction after grade school, and
later on Paul would come more or less to see himself as an areligious Jew. He was so
out of touch with the faith, though, that he was once caught by a journalist declaring
frustration at not being able to reach anybody in the movie business on the phone—
only to learn to his surprise that it was, in fact, Yom Kippur.
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_bm3_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 2:04 PM Page 470
Acknowledgments
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_bm3_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 2:04 PM Page 471
Acknowledgments 471
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_bm3_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 2:04 PM Page 472
472 Acknowledgments
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_bm3_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 2:04 PM Page 473
Acknowledgments 473
www.HarmonyBooks.com
Levy_9780307353757_5p_bm3_r1.z.qxp 3/20/09 2:04 PM Page 474
474 Acknowledgments
me, and he was patient, keen-eyed, and sure as an editor; I’m lucky to
have gotten to work with him. Thanks as well to Anne Berry, Kate
Kennedy, and the many other people at Harmony whom I’ve gotten to
know only in the final weeks of my work, especially copy editor Janet
Biehl, a great eye. I feel in very good hands.
My chief thanks go to my family. The kids—Vince, Anthony, and
Paula—have always been cheerful and inspiring despite the mania that
settles on their dad when he gets to work. And their mother, Mary
Bartholemy, has demonstrated the most remarkable strength, loyalty,
insight, patience, and care. I can’t begin to compensate her for all she’s
done for me, taught me, and shared with me. All I can say is that with-
out her I couldn’t have created a page of this.
www.HarmonyBooks.com
To purchase a copy of
Paul Newman: A Life
visit one of these online retailers:
Amazon
Barnes & Noble
Borders
IndieBound
Powell’s Books
Random House
www.HarmonyBooks.com