REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES

REGIONAL TRIAL COURT

7
th
Judicial Region
Banch !!!!
Ce"u Cit#
X INCORPORATED,
Plainti$$
%&e'u'% CI(IL CASE NO)!!!!!!!!!!!!
FOR* S+eci$ic Pe$o,ance -ith
.a,age'
Y CORPORATION, RD And AY,
Re'+ondent)
/%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%0
COMPLAINT
COMES NOW1 Plainti$$ e+e'ented "#!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1 and to thi'
Honoa"le Cout ,o't e'+ect$ull# allege1 a' $ollo-'*
2) Plainti$$ 3 inco+oated i' a co+oation dul# ogani4ed and e/i'ting
$o and "# &itue o$ the la-' o$ the Re+u"lic o$ the Phili++ine' -ith o$$ice adde''
at Unit C1 220F 5eto"an6 Pla4a Bldg)1 O',ena Bl&d)1 Ce"u Cit# -hee the# ,a#
"e 'e&ed -ith 'u,,on' and othe +oce''e' o$ thi' Honoa"le Cout
heeina$te e+e'ented "# it' (i',in 5anage !!!!!!!!!!!!!! +e Seceta#7'
Ceti$icate heeto attached a' Annex A and ,ade an integal +at heeo$8
9) Re'+ondent Y CORPORATION i' a co+oation dul# ogani4ed and
e/i'ting $o and "# &itue o$ the la-' o$ the Re+u"lic o$ the Phili++ine' -ith
+inci+al o$$ice at :
th
Floo Ba#antel Bldg)1 Ja6o'ale, St)1 Ce"u Cit# -hee it ,a#
"e 'e&ed -ith 'u,,on' and othe +oce''e' o$ thi' Honoa"le Cout8
;) Re'+ondent R. i' i,+leaded in hi' ca+acit# a' Pe'ident o$
Technet <o6' Co+oation and the +i,a# +e'on -ho dealt Plainti$$ 3
Inco+oated8
:) Re'+ondent A= i' i,+leaded in he ca+acit# a' the +ucha'ing
o$$ice o$ Re'+ondent = Co+oation and one o$ the +e'onnel handling the
tan'action' -ith Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated8
CAUSE OF ACTION
>) Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated i' co+oation engaged in the "u'ine'' o$
+o&iding co,+ute 'e&ice'1 '#'te,' and net-o6 ad,ini'tation and
a''i'tance) One o$ the 'e&ice' Plainti$$ +o&ide' it' client' ae the 'ale o$
co,+ute oute' to ,eet the '+eci$ic need' o$ it' clientele' a' -ell a' in'tallation
o$ 'aid oute' and ,aintenance o$ the 'a,e -ithin the -aant# +eiod8
?) Re'+ondent = Co+oation on the othe hand i' a technical 'u++ot
'e&ice +o&ide -hich engaged the 'e&ice' o$ Plainti$$ 3Inco+oated $o the
+ucha'e o$ AS>;>@ CISCO Route -ith the $ollo-ing '+eci$ication'1 to -it*
% High .en'it# (oice -ith 9E21 AS>/%P(.59%?:1 IP A IOS1 AS>;>@
.ual E20PRI .RF cad
% AS>;>@ Se IOS IP PLUS
% AS>;>@%.FC%9CE21 AS>;>@ .ual E20PRI .FC cad
% AS>;>35%AC%P<R1 AS>;>@35 AC Single Po-e Su++l#
% CAB%AC1 Po-e Cod1 22@(
% 5E5%>295%AS>351 AS>;>@35 and AS>:@@35 >295B 5ain
S.RA5
% 5E5%29BCF%AS>35 and AS:;@@35 29B5 Co,+act Fla'he'
% AS>3%FC1 AS>@@@ Featue Cad -ith Si/ P(.5 .SP 5odule Slot'
% ; Unit' AS>/%P(.59%?:1 AS>@@@ ?:% channel Pac6et &oice0Fa/
.SP 5odule
% CON%SNT%AS>;>9E2(1 B/>/NB. S&c1 AC AS>;>@ (oice8 9e21 ?@
+ot'1 IP A IOS
% Ca"le <ie
7) On Fe"ua# 91 9@@71 Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated 'u",itted to
Re'+ondent Co+oation a +ice Cuotation o$ the a$oe'aid AS>;>@ CISCO
Route in the a,ount o$ SIX HUNDRED NINETY FOUR THOUSAND FIVE
HUNDRED FIFTY ONE PESOS AND 40/00 !P "#4,$$%40& $o the
a"o&e,entioned '+eci$ication along -ith the te,' o$ Plainti$$ 5o4co,) The 'aid
+ice Cuotation and lette -a' adde''ed to Re'+ondent R. -hich -a'
con$o,ed to and acce+ted "# Re'+ondent A= on Fe"ua# D1 9@@7) A co+# o$
the lette con$o,ed to "# Re'+ondent i' heeto attached a' Annex '8
B) On Fe"ua# B1 9@@7 Re'+ondent Co+oation 'ent a lette
to!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1 Co+oate Account E/ecuti&e o$ Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated
egading the +ucha'e ode o$ the AS>;>@ CISCO Route -ith the
'+eci$ication' ageed u+on and the a,ount o$ P?D:1>>2):@ a' the total
2
con'ideation) The 'aid +ucha'e ode -a' 'igned "# Re'+ondent
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! a' Head o$ the Pucha'ing and Accounting .e+at,ent
and noted "# Re'+ondent !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! a' Pe'ident o$ Re'+ondent
Co+oation) A co+# o$ the +ucha'e ode i' heeto attached a' Annex CE8
D) Thu'1 u+on ecei&ing the t-o notice' na,el# the con$o,e lette
dated Fe"ua# D1 9@@7 and the Pucha'e Ode dated Fe"ua# B1 9@@7 the
contact "eca,e "inding u+on heein Plainti$$ and Re'+ondent'8
2@) It "ea' to 'te'' that in the contact1 the deli&e# o$ the AS>;>@
CISCO oute' -ill ta6e a"out ;@%:> -o6ing' da#' $o, date o$ ecei+t o$ the
Pucha'e Ode -hich i' Fe"ua# D1 9@@7 con'ideing the $act that the 'aid
ite,' and eCui+,ent ae to "e 'hi++ed "# Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated $o, a"oad8
22) In all good $aith1 Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated i,,ediatel# +oceeded to
+oce'' the 'hi+,ent o$ the ite,' +ucha'ed "# Re'+ondent Co+oation and
e&en ad&anced it' o-n $und' to ha&e the ite,' 'hi++ed and Fu't 'o it can co,+l#
-ith it' co,,it,ent and agee,ent to deli&e the 'a,e -ithin ;@%:> da#') A' a
'ign o$ good-ill1 Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated e&en +o&ided Re'+ondent Co+oation
a 'e&ice unit o$ AS>;@@ $o it' te,+oa# u'e +ending the deli&e# o$ good'
de'+ite the $act that 'uch aange,ent -a' not +at o$ the te,' and condition'
in the contact8
29) On 5ach 71 9@@7 -hile the AS>;>@ ite,' -ee alead# enoute to
Ce"u1 Re'+ondent !!!!!!!!!!!!! 'ent a lette to!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1 Co+oate
Account E/ecuti&e o$ Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated telling the latte that it i' canceling
the contact -ithout an# &alid ea'on and due noti$ication) A co+# o$ the lette i'
heeto attached a' Annex D(
2;) On 5ach 2;1 9@@7 Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated in$o,ed Re'+ondent
Co+oation that the ite,' ae alead# enoute and ,a# no longe "e cancelled
and thu' the# ,u't co,+l# -ith thei +at o$ the contact) A co+# o$ the lette i'
heeto attached a' Anne/ GEE8
3
2:) U+on the ai&al o$ the AS>;>@1 Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated
i,,ediatel# in$o,ed Re'+ondent Co+oation egading the ite,' and that the
'a,e -ee no- ead# to "e deli&eed and in'talled a' +e agee,ent in the
contact) And that +e agee,ent1 Re'+ondent Co+oation ,u't tende
+a#,ent) Re'+ondent Co+oation e$u'ed and continue' to e$u'e to ecei&e
the AS>;>@ CISCO Route' it ha' odeed $o, Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated8
2>) Fo 'e&eal occa'ion'1 Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated ha' e/eted eane't
e$$ot' to 'ee6 +e$o,ance and co,+liance $o, Re'+ondent Co+oation on
thei +at o$ the o"ligation ho-e&e1 the latte -ould e&en e$u'e to co,,unicate
-ith Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated8
2?) Plainti$$ ha' 'ent 'e&eal de,and $o +e$o,ance to Re'+ondent
"ut all ha&e "een ignoed) Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated though it' coun'el ha' 'ent
de,and lette' to Re'+ondent "ut all ha&e "een ignoed and neithe ha&e the#
co,,unicated -ith Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated) In 'hot1 the# ha&e uttel#
di'egaded -ith "ad $aith thei o"ligation and "eached the contact the# ha&e
enteed into -ith Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated $o the +ucha'e o$ the AS>;>@ CISCO
Route') A co+# o$ the de,and lette' i' heeto attached a' Annexe) F *nd
+(
27) The continued e$u'al on the +at o$ Re'+ondent' Co+oation1
!!!!!!!!!!!! and !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! to +e$o, it' o"ligation -hich i' to
ecei&e the AS>;>@ CISCO Route' it ha' odeed and to +a# Plainti$$ 5o4co,
Inco+oated the ageed +ucha'e +ice o$ SIX HUNDRED NINETY FOUR
THOUSAND FIVE HUNDRED FIFTY ONE PESOS AND 40/00 !P "#4,$$%40&
ha' cau'ed 'e&ee lo''e' to Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated) Con'ideing that the
contact i' &alid "et-een the t-o +atie'1 and that Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated ha'
co,+lied -ith it' +at o$ the contact1 it i' incu,"ent and i,+eati&e on the +at o$
Re'+ondent Co+oation to li6e-i'e) Hence1 Re'+ondent' Co+oation1
!!!!!!!!!!! and !!!!!!!!!!!!!! ,u't "e co,+elled to Fointl# and 'e&eall#
+e$o, it' o"ligation -hich i' to ecei&e the ite,' odeed and +a# Plainti$$ 3
4
Inco+oated the a,ount o$ SIX HUNDRED NINETY FOUR THOUSAND FIVE
HUNDRED FIFTY ONE PESOS AND 40/00 !P "#4,$$%40& -ith legal intee't o$
?H +e ,onth $o, the ti,e o$ de,and and non+a#,ent1 a,ong othe' 8
2B) Becau'e o$ Re'+ondent Co+oation7' e$u'al to +e$o, it'
o"ligation and it' utte di'egad o$ the contact a' -ell a' thei intentional 'ilence
de'+ite de,and' and coe'+ondence $o, Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated1 the latte
ha' 'u$$eed lo''e' in the a,ount o$ P 9@@1@@@)@@ -hich Re'+ondent'
Co+oation1 !!!!!!!!!!!! and !!!!!!!!!! ,u't co,+en'ate Plainti$$ "# -a#
o$ No,inal .a,age'8
2D) In ode to dete othe +e'on' $o, co,,itting 'uch act' o$ "each
o$ contact1 non+e$o,ance o$ o"ligation and nonco,+liance o$ agee,ent
&alidl# enteed into -hich i' cleal# &iolati&e o$ the ight' o$ indi&idual' and
ini,ical to 'ociet#1 Re'+ondent' Co+oation1 !!!!!!!!!!!!!! and
!!!!!!!!!!!!! ,u't +a# P 9@@1@@@)@@ "# -a# o$ E/e,+la# .a,age'8
9@) .ue to Re'+ondent' e$u'al to co,+l# and +e$o, it' o"ligation a'
-ell a' it' $ailue to co,,unicate -ith Plainti$$ de'+ite de,and1 Plainti$$ 3
Inco+oated -a' co,+elled to engage the 'e&ice' o$ a legal coun'el in ode to
en$oce it' ight'1 clai,' and $ile thi' ca'e "e$oe thi' Honoa"le Cout) Thu'1
Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated -a' ,ade to +a# attone#7' $ee' to coun'el in the a,ount
o$ P>@1@@@)@@ -ith a++eaance $ee o$ P91@@@)@@ $o e&e# heaing) Thee$oe
Re'+ondent' ,u't inde,ni$# Plainti$$ $o 'uch Attone#7' $ee'8
P R A Y E R
WHEREFORE, +e,i'e' con'ideed it i' ,o't e'+ect$ull# +a#ed o$ thi'
Honoa"le Cout a$te due heaing and tial1 to ende Fudg,ent in $a&o o$
Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated and ode Re'+ondent' Co+oation1 !!!!!!!!!!!!!
and !!!!!!!!!!!! to co,+l# -ith the agee,ent dated Fe"ua# D1 9@@7 and
the +ucha'e ode i''ued dated Fe"ua# B1 9@@78 to ecei&e the AS>;>@
5
CISCO Route' $o, Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated8 to +a# the +ucha'e +ice o$ SIX
HUNDRED NINETY FOUR THOUSAND FIVE HUNDRED FIFTY ONE PESOS
AND 40/00 !P "#4,$$%40& -ith intee't +e ,onth $o, date o$ de,and and to
inde,ni$# Plainti$$ 3 Inco+oated the $ollo-ing*
a) No,inal .a,age' a,ounting to P 9@@1@@@)@@8
") E/e,+la# .a,age' a,ounting to P 9@@1@@@)@@8
c) Attone#7' Fee' a,ounting to P >@1@@@)@@ and a++eaance $ee o$ P
91@@@)@@ $o e&e# heaing)
Such othe elie$ a' ,a# "e Fu't and eCuita"le in the +e,i'e' ae li6e-i'e
+a#ed $o)
Ce"u Cit#1 Phili++ine') Fe"ua# :1 9@@B)
INCORPORATED
',-
......................
A))/)0ed 1,-
........................
2 ASSOCIATES LAW FIRM
Ce"u Cit#
B#*
.......................
Roll o$ Attoe# No) !!!!!!!!!
IBP Li$eti,e 5e,"e No) !!!!!!!! Ce"u Cit#
PTR NO) 7:B>>>> @20220@B Ce"u Cit#
6