Indian Standard: Specification For On-Load Tap-Changers 0. Foreword
Indian Standard: Specification For On-Load Tap-Changers 0. Foreword
Indian Standard: Specification For On-Load Tap-Changers 0. Foreword
Indian Standard
SPECIFICATION FOR
ON-LOAD TAP-CHANGERS
0. FOREWORD
0.1 This Indian Standard was adopted by the Indian Standards Institution
on 26 May 1977, after the draft finalized by the Transformers Sectional
Committee had been approved by the Electrotechnical Division Council.
0.2 This standard is based on lEG Doc: 14B (Central Office) 10, revision
of Publication 214 (1966) ‘On-load tap-changers’, issued by the Inter-
national Electrotechnical Commission.
0.3 For selecting an on-load tap-changer for a particular application re-
ference should be made to IS: 8478~l977*.
0.4 For the purpose of deciding whether a particular requirement of this
standard is complied with, the final value, observed or calculated, expressing
the result of a test shall be t~oundedoff in accordance with IS: 2-1960t.
The dumber of significant places retained in the rounded off value should
be the same as that of the specified value in this standard.
SECTION I GENERAL
1. SCOPE
1.1 This standard covers on-load tap-changers for power transformers,
and their motor-drive mechanisms. It relates mainly to oil-immersed tap-
changers.
1.2 Tap-changers for transformers for railway rolling stock are not covered
by this standard.
NOTE I — As this standard deals only with on-load tap-changers the expression is
shortened to ‘tap-changer’ in the remainder of this standard.
NOTE 2 — For the purpose of this standard a synthetic insulating liquid, for example,
askarel is regarded as an oil.
2. DEFINITIONS
2.0 For the purpose of this standard, the following definitions shall apply.
*Application guide for on-load tap-changers.
~Rules for rounding off numerical values (revised). -~ -
3
IS : 8468 - 1977
and breaking current, combining the duties of a tap selector and a diverter
switch.
2.1.5 Change-Over Selector A device designed to carry, but not to make
—
the transition impedance at the time when two tappings are bridged during
a tap-change operation and which is due to the vkltage difference between
the tappings.
2.1.12 Switched Current The prospective current to be broken during
—
end of its range to the other and the return to its original position.
2.1.16 Insulation Level The withstand values of the impulse and power
—
frequency test voltages to earth, and where appropriate between the phases
and between those parts where insulation is required.
2.1.17 Rated Through-Current (ia) The current flowing through the
—
5
IS 8468 - 1977
positions for half a cycle of operation for which a tap-changer can be used
according to its design.
2.1.22.2 Number of service positions The number of tap positions for
—.
the tap winding of the transformer, but the tap-changer when electrically
operated through these taps continues to run to the next tap without stop-
ping at these particular taps.
2.1.23 Type Test A test made on a tap-changer or the components of a
—
design of which has been verified by type tests, to establish that the tap-
changer is without manufacturing defects.
2.2 Definitions Relating to Motor-Drive Mechanisms
2.2.1 Motor-Drive Mechanism A driving mechanisms (see 2.1.7), which
—
tion of the tap-changer beyond either end position but allowing operation
towards the opposite direction.
2.2.5.2 Mechanical end stop A device which physically prevents
—
operation of the tap-changer beyond either end position but allows operation
towards the opposite direction.
2.2.6 Parallel Control Devices Electrical control devices to move, in the
—
6
IS 8468 1977
-
for stopping the motor-drive mechanism at any time in such a way that a
special action should be performed before the next tap-change operation
can be started.
2.2.8 Overcurrent Blocking Device An electrical device preventing or
—
tap-changes accomplished.
2.2.10 Manual Operation of Tap-Changer Operation of the tap-changer
—
mechanism,
3. SERVICE CONDITIONS
3.1 Temperature of Tap-Changer Environment Unless more —
NOTE — Tap-changers, like other switching devices, usually have ashorter thermal time
constant than electromagnetic devices of the same current ratings.
*Specification for power transformers: Part I General (first revision).
tGuide for loading of oil-immersed transformers.
~Application guide for on-load tap-changers.
7
IS 8468-1977
separate oil containers breathing freely to the atmosphere, oil level gauges
shall be provided.
6.3 Suitable protective devices may be provided in the tap-changer.
*Application guide for on-load tap-changers.
B
IS : 8468 - 1977
7. MARKING
7.1 Each tap-changer shall be provided with a name-plate of weather-proof
material fitted in a visible position showing at least the items indicated
below. The entries shall be indelibly marked (for example by etching,
engraving or stamping).
a) Number of this standard, Ref: IS: 8468,
b) Manufacturer’s name,
c) Manufacturer’s serial number,
d) Manufacturer’s type designation,
e) Year of manufacture,
f) Rated through-current,
g) Rated step voltage, and
h) Rated insulation level.
7.1.1 The tap-changers may also be marked with the 1ST Certification
Mark.
NOTE — The use of the 1St Certification Mark is governed by the provisions of the
Indian Standards institution (Certification Marks) Act and the Rules and Regulations
made thereunder. The 1St Mark on products covered by an Indian Standard conveys
the assurance that they have been produced to comply with the requirements of that
standard under a well-defined system of inspection, testing and quality control which is
devised and supervised by ISI and operated by the producer. ISI marked products
are also continuously checked by 1St for conformity to that standard as a further safe-
guard. Details of conditions under which a licence for the use of the ISI Certification
Mark may be granted to manufacturers or processors, may be obtained from the Indian
Standards Institution.
8. TESTS
8.1 Type Tests The type tests shall be performed on the samples of the
—
8.2 Routine Tests The following shall constitute the routine tests:
—
9
IS : 8468 - 1977
8.3 Mechanical Test With the tap-changer fully assembled, but
—
OC
Plain copper 20
Silver-faced copper 20
Other materials 20
and breaking capacity tests, shall simulate the most onerous conditions for
which the tap-changer is rated. Where reactor switching is concerned, the
most onerous condition shall be subject to agreement between the manu-
facturer and the purchaser. Unless otherwise agreed, it is assumed that
no reversal of power flow occurs in service.
Attention is drawn to Appendix A where the most onerous conditions for
resistor transition switching are indicated for the majority of contact
arrangements.
10
IS 8468 - 1977
The switching tests may be limited to the diverter switch or selector switch
after proving that the contact operating conditions are not affected by such
limitation.
If the diverter switch or selector switch has several sets of contacts which
operate in a definite sequence, it is not permitted to test each set of contact
separately from the other unless it can be proved that the operating condi-
tions of any one set ofcontacts are not affected by the operation of the other
sets of contacts.
Where resistors are used as transition impedances these may be placed
outside the apparatus if necessitated by the construction of the tap-changer
or the test circuit, and they may have a higher thermal capacity than those
which are employed in service unless otherwise specified.
The value and type of the transition impedance shall be stated.
Contacts, and transformer oil in the case of oil-immersed tap-changers,
shall not be renewed during each of the tests.
In the case of three-phase switches, it is normally sufficient to test the
contacts of one phase.
If a particular tap-changer has more than one combination of rated
through-current and rated step voltage at least two braking capacity tests
shall be performed, one at maximum rated through-current ‘m and its
relevant step voltage U1 and one at the maximum rated step voltage Urn and
its relevant rated through-current I,~.
Interpolation may be facilitated by obtaining the mid-current point of
the curve between the extremes by calculating this mid-point X as:
(Isn+Iu) (Ux)~/UtImX Urn jn
The arrangement for testing shall be such that, except where otherwise
specified, neither the switched current, nor the recovery voltage, nor the
product of these shall, in any case, vary more than —5 percent to + 10
percent of the calculated values appropriate to the switching cycle (see
Table 5) at the appropriate through-current and relevant rated step voltage.
8.6.1 Service Duty Test — This test shall be performed in accordance with
8.6.1.1, 8.6.1.2 or 8.6.1.3.
After the tests, inspection of contact wear shall be done, the results of this
test shall leave no doubts as to the suitability of the tap-changer for service.
NOTE — The results of this test may be used by the manufacturer to demonstrate that
the contacts used for making and breaking current are capable of performing, without
replacement of the contacts, the number of tap-change operations declared by the manu-
facturer at the rated through-current and at the relevant step voltage.
8.6.1.1 Service duty test at rated step voltage — The contacts on diverter
switches and selector switches shall be subjected to a number of operations
corresponding to 20 000 tap-change operations in normal service when
carrying a current corresponding to not less than the maximum rated
through-current and the relevant rated step voltage.
11
IS : 8468 - 1977
In order to approximate to service conditions, selector switches shall have
the test performed over not more than eight tap-change positions (excluding
dead positions), these being centrally disposed about the change-over
selector if such is incorporated in the tap-changer design.
Comparison of oscillograms taken at regular intervals during the test
shall show that there is no significant alteration in the characteristics of the
tap-changer in such a way as to endanger the operation of the apparatus.
Twenty osdilograms shall be taken at the start of the test, and 20 after each
succeeding 5 000 operations, making a total of 100 oscillograms.
NOTE — Generally it is sufficient to compare the series of oscillograms taken at the
beginning and at the end of the test.
8.6.1.2 Service duty test at reduced step voltage Provided that the manu-
—
facturer supplies reasonable proof that the rate of wear is not affected,
a test at reduced step voltage may be performed under the following
conditions:
a) A service duty test of 20 000 operations shall be performed at a
current corresponding to not less than the maximum rated through-
current and a reduced step voltage. This voltage level shall be
such that the switched current is not less than that occurring during
operations at the relevant rated step voltage; furthermore, current
chopping shall not occur. In order to obtain the specified test
conditions, the value of the transition impedance shall be suitably
modified.
b) Using the same contacts and oil, 100 operations at the maximum
rated through-current and the relevant rated step voltage shall be
performed, each operation being oscillographically recorded.
Provided the oscillograms taken during these operations indicate
that the arcing time does not exceed -~ second (where f is the
rated frequency) this service duty test with the calculated switched
current and reduced step voltage will enable the mnufacturer to
demonstrate directly the number of operations likely to be achieved
without replacement of contacts.
c) When the oscillograms indicate that arcing times in excess of
seconds are occurring then further operations shall be performed at
the maximum rated through-current and the reduced step voltage.
The number of such additional operations shall be:
~0x20 000
MAXIMUM RATED
Tas~rCuaar~rr
THROUGH CURUNT RMS VALUR
(1) (2)
A kA
100 2
200 3
400 4
800 8
1 250 125
1 600 16
2 000 20
2 500 25
3 150 315
14
IS : 8468 - 1977
At the conclusion of the test, the contacts shall not have welded together
and shall not show abnormal signs of current marking or burning.
Current-carrying parts shall not show signs of permanent mechanical
distortion.
8.8 Transition Impedance Test
8.8.1 Transition Resistors The test shall be performed at the maximum
—
in accordance with the specification for the transformer with which the
tap-changer is intended for use.
Nom Precautions should be taken in the design of the transition reactors to avoid
—
design it shall be assembled and filled with clean transformer oil, or immersed
in a test tank filled with clean transformer oil, and operated as for normal
service conditions. The contacts shall not be energized and the full range
of tappings shall be utilized until 200 000 tap-change operations have been
performed.
During the test there shall he no failure or undue wear of the mechanical
parts.
Normal servicing according to the manufacturer’s handbook shall be
permitted during the test.
It shall be permitted to perform this mechanical endurance test sepa-
rately on diverter switches, selector switches, tap selectors or other com-
ponents, provided that in each case the operation duplicates mechanically
its normal service operation.
15
IS 8468 - 1977
CLASS APPLICATION
16
IS I 8468-1977
may not always be necessary. Their requirement shall be subject to agreement between
the manufacturer and the purchaser.
Nom 2 Item (b) above does not apply to single-phase tap-changers.
—
NOTE 3 — Partial discharge measurements and switching impulse test are specified in
IS: 2026(Part III)~l977* for transformers greater than 145 kV class. Consideration
should be given to the application of the appropriate tests to earth and where applicable
between phases of the tap-changer.
preferably comply with the appropriate values from Table 4. For tests
8.lO.3(c) to 8.10.3(e), appropriate withstand values shall be declared by
the manufacturer of the tap-changer.
10 40
20 60
28 75
38 95
50 125
70 170
95 250
149 325
185 450
230 550
275 650
325 750
360 850
395 950
460 1 050
8.10.5 Ajplication of Test Voltages For the voltage tests, the tap-changer
—
17
IS 8468-1977
18
IS : 8468-1977
operate satisfactorily within the limits of 85 to 110 percent of rated voltage
for an ac voltage and between 80 and 110 percent for a dc voltage.
9.3 Step-by-Step Control — The step-by-step circuit shall be designed in
such a way as to operate the tap-changer by one complete voltage step only
in the case of signals which may be continuous or immediately repetitive as
well as simultaneous from separate sources within one tap-change operation.
9.4 Tap Position Indicator
9.4.1 The position of the tap-changer shall be indicated on the motor-
drive by means of a mechanically operated device. This tap position shall
be visible through an inspection window while the motor-drive cubicle is
closed.
9.4.2 If required, an electrical remote position transmitter may be pro-
vided for indicating the tap-changer position in the control room.
9.5 Tap-Change in Progress Indication — If required, a suitable device
may be fitted to operate a means of indicating at a remote point that the
motor-drive mechanism is performing a tap-change operation.
9.6 Limiting Devices All motor-drive mechanisms shall be provided
—
with both electrical and mechanical limiting devices. The contacts of the
electrical limiting device shall be connected into the control or motor
circuits.
9.7 Parallel Control Devices — Provision of the necessary devices is to
be agreed, the purchaser being responsible for ensuring that the correct
requirements are specified.
9.8 Direction of Rotation Protection — If required, a device for pre-
vention of incorrect rotation of three-phase motors may be fitted by agree-
ment between the manufacturer and the purchaser.
9.9 Overcurrent Blocking Device — If required by the operational
condition of the transformer, this device may be fitted by agreement be-
tween the manufacturer and the purchaser.
9.10 Operation Counter — An operation counter shall be provided.
19
IS : 8468 - 1977
11. TESTS
11.1 Type Tests — The following shall constitute the type tests:
20
IS 8468 - 1977
11.3.2 Following the test under 11.3.1, two further cycles of operation
shall be performed, one at the minimum and one at the maximum level of
the rated voltage of the auxiliary supply, also without failure.
NOTE — The mechanical tests may be performed on the motor-drive mechanism
separately or as under 8.9.
11.4 Auxiliary Circuits Insulation Test Auxiliary circuits, except the
—
motor and such elements which are to be tested with lower test voltages ac-
cording to the appropriate Indian Standards shall withstand a power-
frequency test of 2 kV applied for one minute between all live terminals and
the frame.
11.5 Mechanical Load Test — The motor-drive mech:inism output shaft
shall be loaded by the largest tap-changer for which it is designed or by an
equivalent simulated load, based on service conditions. At such a load
200 000 operations shall be performed across the whole tapping range.
NoTE — Additional cooling of the motor-drive is permissible during this test.
During this test 5 000 operations shall be performed at the minimum
voltage and 5 000 operations at the maximum voltage as specified in 9.2.
The correct functioning to the requirements of 9.4.1, 9.6, 9.10 and 9.11
shall be verified during this test.
The test shall be completed without failure of the mechanical parts.
Normal servicing according to the manufacutrer’s handbook shall be
permitted during the test.
11.6 Overrun Test—It shall be demonstrated that in the event ofa failure
of the electrical limit switches, the mechanical end stops prevent operation
beyond the end positions when a motorized tap-change is performed and the
motor-drive mechanism shall not suffer either electrical or mechanical
damage.
11.7 Protection of Motor-Drive Cubicle — When applicable, the motor-
drive cubicle shall be tested in accordance with IS: 2l47~J962*.
*Degrees of protection provided by enclosures for low voltage switchgear and controlgear.
21
IS : 8468.1977
APPENDIX A
(Clause 8.6)
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION ON SWITCHING DUTY
RELATING TO TAP-CHANGERS WITH RESISTOR
TRANSITION ONLY
which the through-current is diverted from the main contacts before the
circulating current starts to flow.
NOTE — This cycle requires that the through-current connection is at the mid-point
{E-RI) U
2
-~E*
~l
‘The derivation of the designations ‘flag cycle’ and ‘pennant cele’ arises from the appear-
ance of the vector diagrams showing the change in output voltage of the transformer in
moving from one tapping to the adjacent one. In the ‘flag cycle’ the change of voltage
comprises four steps, while in the ‘pennant cycle’ only two steps occur (see Fig I to 3).
22
IS : 8468 - 1977
*The derivation of the designations ‘flag cycle’ and ‘pennant cycle’ arises from the appear-
a nec of the vector diagrams showing the change iii output voltage ofthe transformerin moving
from one tapping to the adjacent one. In the ‘flag cycle’ the change of voltage comprise,
four steps, while in the ‘pennant cycle’ only two steps occur (see Fig. 1 to 3).
23
TABLE 5 DUTY ON MAIN AND TRANSITION CONTACTS
(Clauses 8.6, 8.6.1.3, A-il. A-2.2 and A-2.31
Diverter
switch
Selector
‘switch
NoTE 1 — Reversed load direction only affects contact T where the through.current and circulating current shall then add.
Nom 2 — Other circuits involving multiple resistors are not included, as they are extensions ofthe above basic circuits.
No’rs 3—For purpose ofclarity, the diagram of connections and contact operating order are given forone direction of movement ofthe switch, The expressions so
for contact duty and number of operations, however, take into account the movement of the switch in both directions. -.1
IS : 8468-1977
NoTe — Tap-changers employing the asymmetrical pennant cycle are normally used
withload euti’rcnt flow in one direction only,
APPENDIX B
(C/a?,se 8.6.3)
SiMULATED CIRCUITS FOR TESTS
B~1.Two proven simulated test circuits are shown in Fig. 4 and 5, Fig. 4
being a transformer method and Fig. 5 a resistance method.
These figures are given for information only and the use ofdiffercnt circutits
is not excluded.
IS: 8468 - 1977
AUTOTRANSFORMER
(OR TRANSFORMER) WITH
STEP-ADjUSTABLE VOLTAGES
DIVERTER SWITCH
1, 4 = Mains contacts
Transit ion contacts
2, 3
— Transition resistor
R
Adjttstablc reactor
Xa
NOTE — In order to meet the requirements under 8.6J and 8.6.2 and to take into ac-
count the reactances of the circuit and supply, the current and voltage values occurring
on the four contacts shall be controlled and when necessary suitably adjusted, for example
by means of variations of the (~
5,,X5and R values and!or of the mutual phase of the
voltage vectors.
28
IS 8468. 1977
POWER DIVIDER
1, 4 = main contacts
2, 3 = transition contacts
U
5 = single pitase supply
voltage
/? , = ohmic resistors
forming the
power divider
DIVERTER SWITCH
NOTE ‘11w calculated current and voltage values occurring in the whole tap-change
opcratuon on the four contacts shall he used to calculale the power divider. In the case
under consideration (flag cycle on a 4-contacts diverter switch) the formulae for the most
ortcrous conditions, are:
R •—
— U, U,)
I4(U5_L4) +L781,’
, R L1 (U. —
J~J~(U~U~)
— 14(U5
U, (Li,U4) +U,)u,I,
—
— R U,
T —
U8 (U5
1~(U3
_—
—
U,)
(14)
-
R U, U,
~i u5—u4’
where -
29
IS 8468. 1977
APPENDIX C
(Clause 8.8)
METHOD OF DETERMINING THE EQUIVALENT TEM-
PERATURE OF THE TRANSITION RESISTOR USING
POWER PULSE CURRENTS
I
:~
E(I 1~t
5 1)
= ~i e1 t~
where
= the cut-rent values;
= the time dewing which the current I~is flowing, botis quantities
taken as the mean valise from the 100 oscillograms recorded
at the service duty test according to 8.6.1.1 or if relevant to
8.6J.2(b); arid
k = a coefficient chosen to suit the testing requirements of the re-
sistor, the value adopted to be between 5 and 10 bearing in
mind that the heating phenomenon shall remain adiabatic.
The resistor shall be subjected to the above current for a number of times
corresponding to one half of one cycle of operations. The current appli-
cation time shall be determined from:
ip =k. j~l
C—4. The rest period, during which cssrt’ent cioe~not flow through the re-
sistor shall be equal to the minimum time interval that can occur between
two consecittive operations of’ the tap-changer.
C-5. To determine the peak temperature, extrapolation of recorded valties
may be necessary.
30 ~,
-j