Industrial Oxygen: Its Generation and Use
Industrial Oxygen: Its Generation and Use
Industrial Oxygen: Its Generation and Use
Prakash Rao and Michael Muller, Center for Advanced Energy Systems, Rutgers, the State
University of New Jersey
ABSTRACT
This paper will look at the industrial uses for oxygen. It will categorize oxygen using
processes into: 1) the purpose of oxygen in the process and 2) the effect oxygen enrichment has
on the overall process. The paper will also look at four methods of producing oxygen:
cryogenics, pressure swing absorption, membrane filter technology and electrolysis. It will
compare each against one another in categories such as first time costs, running costs, percent
oxygen enrichment attainable, and by-product capability. Furthermore, the paper will then select
the appropriate process for each industry discussed. This paper is intended to address the above
issues in such a way that a facility manager would be able to make an educated decision on
whether or not to consider creating/using oxygen enhanced air in his/her process as well as
which technology would be best suited for his/her process.
Introduction
Atmospheric air is comprised of 21% O2, 78% N2 and the remaining 1% is mostly argon
and CO2. Air is a chief constituent in combustion. In the combustion process, the oxygen in air is
broken down to make carbon dioxide, water, and energy. Nitrogen is not an essential part of the
process. In fact, nitrogen in air has negative impacts on combustion processes. Nitrogen gets
heated by the reaction to very high combustion temperatures and is carried out through the flue.
Essentially, the heated nitrogen leaving the flue is like throwing fuel out of the stack. Also,
during the combustion process nitrogen in the air and fuel will break down to form harmful NOx
gasses.
Combustion processes can be improved by lowering the amount of nitrogen used in the
combustion air and increasing the amount of oxygen. The benefits include: higher combustion
efficiencies due to a drop in heat loss (as a result of lower mass flow rates) out of the stack,
lower NOx emissions, and higher process temperatures.
Gasification is the process by which coal or another carbon based fuel is transformed into
a synthesis gas (“syn gas”). This syn gas is made up of mostly CO and H2. This gas can be used
to produce electricity or steam. Gasification has many values, including the ability to use low
BTU fuels for energy production, easier carbon dioxide capture as compared to traditional
sequestration methods, and the ability to produce hydrogen gas.
Gasification is carried out in steps. First, the fuel is ground up into slurry. Next, the fuel
is pyrolized in an oxygen starved environment. This turns the majority of the carbon into a gas.
The next step is to add oxygen or air (“direct gasification”) or steam (“in-direct gasification”) at
high temperatures to form carbon monoxide and hydrogen. This is the syn gas that can be used
Description of Technologies
Cryogenic Separation
Cryogenic air separation units (ASU) is an old process used to produce high purity
oxygen or nitrogen at high volumes. The process was first developed by Carl Von Linde in 1895
and it remains pretty much the same today. Cryogenics is also the chief method by which liquid
oxygen can be produced. The technology is centered on the fact that each of air’s constituents
has different boiling points. The idea behind the process is to lower the temperature of the air
such that nitrogen and oxygen separate based on their boiling points. This occurs at around -
300oF.. If higher purity oxygen or liquid oxygen is required, further distillation is required. For
liquid oxygen, nitrogen is used as the heat transfer fluid to further cool the oxygen.
Cryogenic separation is most effective when any of the three criteria need to be met: high
purity oxygen is required (>99.5%), high volumes of oxygen are required (≥102 tons of
oxygen/day), or high pressure oxygen is required. Cryogenic air separators take more than an
hour to start up. Additionally, since cryogenics can produce such a high purity of oxygen, the
waste nitrogen stream is of a usable quality [Smith 2001]. This can add significant financial
benefits to a process integrated with a cryogenic ASU.
Pressure swing adsorbers (PSA) are a much newer technology as compared to cryogenic
ASU. PSA devices take atmospheric air into a pressurized tank. Inside the tank are zeolites.
Zeolites, under pressure, have the ability to deform and create a dipole. Depending on the zeolite
chosen, this dipole allows for the collection of nitrogen, but allows oxygen to pass. For oxygen
enrichment, the PSA is generally pressurized to a minimum of 1.5 atm. After a certain volume of
air has been separated, the zeolite will become saturated with nitrogen. At this point, it needs to
be regenerated. This is done by dropping the pressure of the tank back to atmospheric pressure,
thus returning the zeolite to its original polarity. This liberates the nitrogen. Vacuum Pressure
Swing Adsorbers (VPSA) lower the pressure in the tank to sub atmospheric values, thus
improving the regeneration process. In both processes, while one tank is regenerating, another
tank is usually charging. This allows for a continuous production of oxygen.
PSA devices are best suited for processes that do not require extremely high purities of
oxygen (<95%). While PSAs can achieve as high as 99.9%, the cost associated with going above
Also, the usability of by-product nitrogen in PSA systems is limited because the nitrogen
will have significant levels of oxygen. [Smith 2001].
Membrane Technology
Conventional membrane technology involves passing air over a membrane filter. The
filter will allow fast gasses to pass and slow gasses will stay. Oxygen is considered a fast gas and
nitrogen and argon are considered slow gasses. Varying levels of purity can be achieved by
varying the time that the gas spends undergoing filtration. Previous membrane technology could
only produce purity levels of less than 50%. Membrane technology has quick start-up times and
operates at near ambient conditions. Capital costs with membrane systems increase linearly with
output volume desired. Currently, membrane technologies can satisfy needs of up to 20 tons of
oxygen/day. [Smith 2001]
However, recently there has been a significant technological break through in membrane
technology. The ion transport membrane (ITM) was developed by Air Products and Chemicals,
in conjunction with the United States Department of Energy and Ceramatec. Reports have shown
that this technology can produce greater than 99% purity O2 at much lower costs than cryogenic
separation. [Dyer 2000]
Three separate ITM technologies have been developed: SEOS™ Oxygen Generator, ITM
Oxygen, and ITM Syngas.
The SEOS™ system consists of electrochemical cell stacks. These cell stacks are heated
to greater than 6000C and a voltage is applied. Under this electric potential, the oxygen in the
feed air is ionized, recombined, and collected at an outlet [Dyer 2000]. Figure 1 illustrates the
process.
ITM Oxygen can generate extremely high purity oxygen streams (in excess of 99.9%)
and high volume (equivalent to volumetric flow of cryogenic separation systems). It takes in
high pressure, high heat air. This air is passed over a ceramic membrane made of metals that are
oxygen depleted. The membrane accepts the oxygen where it is ionized and diffused through the
membrane due to a difference in oxygen partial pressures across the membrane. Since the
membrane is not attracted to any other compounds, the process only filters oxygen [Allam 2002].
The oxygen stream is sub-atmospheric [Dyer 2000]. ITM Oxygen represents competition to
cryogenic separation units.
Figure 2 illustrates the process.
ITM Syngas is a process still under development. The technology will pass air on one
side of a membrane and natural gas and steam on the other. The two by-product streams will be
syngas and oxygen depleted air [Dyer 2000].
Research work is still continuing for ITM technology and is expected to be concluded by
2007. At this time, Air Products aims to be able to produce an economically viable ITM system.
By-Product Oxygen
In some of the processes mentioned above, high volumes of nitrogen will be available to
the user for use in another process. Similarly, in processes that produce nitrogen, large volumes
of oxygen are readily available. One of the many applications of nitrogen is in the food industry,
$80.00
$70.00
$60.00
Mean PSA cost
Mean Cryogenic cost
$50.00
$/ton
$40.00
$30.00
$20.00
$10.00
$-
25% 38% 50% 68% 75% 88% 100%
% purity O2
Figure 4
.
Source: From Universal Industrial Gases Inc
In one example, Air Products linked an ITM Oxygen supply into an IGCC plant and a
cryogenic air separation unit into another. Details of the project will be discussed later. The
installation cost of the cryogenic air separation unit was $61.2 million as compared to $41.6
million for the ITM technology. Moreover, the ITM plant produced oxygen at a cost of
$14,300/ton of oxygen/day compared to $22,200/ton of oxygen/day for the cryogenic plant
Oxygen’s use in the glass industry has been well-documented. Oxygen enriched air fed
into the furnace has proven to reduce fuel consumption, lower NOx emissions, and improve glass
quality. The effects of oxygen combustion on fuel input, NOx, and CO2 emissions are shown in
Figure 5 for a glass melting furnace [Kato 2005]:
As is evident, all the parameters shown above were reduced drastically with the
implementation of oxycombustion.
Although the benefits are well established, there is still room for improvement as is
evident by the amount of research being conducting on oxycombustion glass furnace design.
One of the most efficient applications of syn gas is in Integrated Gasification Combined
Cycle (IGCC) plants. Here, the syn gas is used to run an electric turbine which produces
electricity. The waste heat from the turbine and gasification plant is used to make steam, which
in turn is run through a steam turbine, thus producing more electricity.
Traditionally, cryogenic air separators were used to create the oxygen for direct-
gasification. Cryogenics enabled operators to produce the volume and purity of air desired.
As mentioned previously, Air Products and Chemicals ran two IGCC plants. Both were
identical with the only difference being in the method of oxygen generation: one used ITM
Figure 6: Comparison between ITM Oxygen and Cryogenic Air Separation in IGCC
Source:Allam 2002
Figure 7 shows the installed costs of the two systems. There is no significant change in
overall cost. While the cost of oxygen plant is much less in the ITM Oxygen case, the other costs
are higher. However, when one considers that the ITM Oxygen plant produced 29 MW more
than the cryogenic plant, the turnkey cost ($/kW produced) proves to be lower for the ITM
Oxygen plant.
Municipal Solid Waste (MSW) is everyday trash created by people. Originally land
filled, MSW is now most commonly incinerated in the United States in lieu of diminishing land
fill space. Incineration reduces the volume of trash, however, it does produce greenhouse gases
and toxic emissions that require costly clean-up technologies. The systems today are also
producing energy. For example, the Essex County Resource Recovery facility manages 1 million
tons of trash per year and produces 45,000 MW in the process. However, as mentioned above,
incineration of trash can lead to very pollutants that become airborne in the incineration process.
Gasification, as described above, is emerging as a potential method of dealing with MSW
in a much cleaner manner than incineration. Gasification was proven to reduce emissions of
MSW, thus reducing operating costs. Furthermore, valuable syn gas can be produced. This syn
gas can also be converted to H2 gas or liquid methanol [Larson 1996]. Thus, MSW could be used
as a fuel for Gas-to-Liquid systems. Liquid energy would expand the potential mediums in which
MSW gas can be used. These new mediums include vehicular power.
Currently, the Thermoselect system of Switzerland offers an established and proven
technology for converting MSW to syn gas. Additionally, these systems gasify using oxygen
provided by a cryogenic plant. Other systems exist, however, they: a) require the MSW to be
turned into a refuse-derived-fuel (RDF) and b) they use steam in the gasification process. RDF
fuels require all combustibles from MSW to be removed before gasification. [Larson 1996]
The use of steam also demands that the syn gas be reformed because hydrocarbons
(methane and methanol) are formed in the gasification process. These hydrocarbons are reformed
into H2 and CO. When using oxygen, the hydrogen in steam is absent. Therefore, no
hydrocarbons are formed. The result is that no additional reforming is needed in oxygen blown
gasifiers. This lowers the energy input to the system.[Larson 1996]
Figure 8 compares the energy balance for methanol and hydrogen reforming between the
two RDF technologies (BCL and MTCI) and the Thermoselect process. As the figure shows, the
energy ratio for the Thermoselect process is much higher than for the RDF processes. Here, the
energy ratio is defined as the HHV of the fuel produced divided by the HHV of the input MSW.
The Thermoselect process has a higher energy ration because no energy is lost due to syn gas
reforming. As mentioned, this is a direct result of using oxygen rather than steam. From this data,
Some gas-to-liquid applications have already been mentioned, such as in the case of
MSW gasification. In Gas-to-Liquid applications, the cryogenic air separation unit would be a
more efficient means at this time to produce oxygen due to the fact that it produces an excellent
quality of by-product nitrogen. As current oil and coal reserves diminish, GTL technology could
provide an excellent means of using the fossil fuels stored in remote locations of the world, such
as many places in Alaska. Furthermore, it could be used to turn natural gas that is usually flared
in oil fields into usable liquid gas.
Figure 9 shows one method by which a cryogenic air separation unit could be employed
in a Fischer-Tropsch system:
The oxygen is used in the same manner as in any other gasification process. The
advantage now, however, is that the waste nitrogen could be used for a variety of applications.
These applications include: injection into the gas turbine to increase turbine output, refrigeration
for the turbine inlet air, and low process nitrogen could be used for chilling applications.
Current research at universities and industry are focusing on using oxy-enhanced air to
lower the temperature of air used in oxidizing metals. In one specific application, cuprous oxide
is made by passing 8000C air over copper. One study at Rutgers University hypothesizes that the
temperature of this air can be reduced by oxidizing in an oxy-enriched environment using a
fluidized bed. By adding more air, the number of oxygen molecules in contact with the copper
increases. The high temperature serves as a catalyst to the copper to cuprous oxide reaction.
Conclusion
At this time, cryogenic ASU are the most well-established and used systems for oxygen
generation. However, advances in PSA and membrane technology have and will continue to
challenge cryogenic ASU.
The uses for oxygen are many (not all discussed in this paper) and include: glass
furnaces, coal gasification, MSW gasification, gas-to-liquid technologies and metals oxidation.
References
Allam, Rodney J., Edward P. Foster, and VanEric E. Stein. April 2002. “Improving Gasification
Economics through ITM Oxygen Integration.” For the 5th (IChemE) European
Gasification Conference. Noordwijk, The Netherlands.
Dyer, Paul N., Robin E. Richards, Steven L. Russek, and Dale M. Troyer. “Ion transport
membrane technology for oxygen separation and syngas production”, Solid State Ionics
134 (2000) 21-33.
Larson Eric D., Ernst Worrell, and Jeffrey Chen. “Clean fuels from municipal solid waste for
fuel cell buses in metropolitan areas”, Resources, Conservation and Recycling 17 (1996)
273-298.
Smith, A.R., and J.Klosek. “A Review of air separation technologies and their integration with
energy conversion processes”, Fuel Processing Technology 70 (2001) p.115-134.
Tuson, Geoffrey B., Hisashi Kobayashi, and M.J. Campbell. “Oxygen enriched combustion
system performance study: Phase II Final report 100 percent oxygen enriched combustion
in regenerative glass melters” August, 1994. Work performed under DOE contract
No.DE-FC07-88ID12833.
Note: This service is not intended for secure transactions such as banking, social media, email, or purchasing. Use at your own risk. We assume no liability whatsoever for broken pages.
Alternative Proxies: