Electrical Power Generation in Aircraft: Review, Challenges, and Opportunities
Electrical Power Generation in Aircraft: Review, Challenges, and Opportunities
Electrical Power Generation in Aircraft: Review, Challenges, and Opportunities
net/publication/325002832
CITATIONS READS
91 18,750
3 authors:
Mikiel Galea
University of Nottingham
149 PUBLICATIONS 1,445 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
low cost , high force density Tubular Linear Machine for aerospace actuation systems View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Vincenzo Madonna on 09 May 2018.
This work is funded by the INNOVATIVE doctoral programme. The Nottingham, Nottingham, NG72RD, UK (1 eexvm3@nottingham.ac.uk;
2
INNOVATIVE programme is partially funded by the Marie Curie Initial p.giangrande@nottingham.ac.uk; 3 Michael.Galea@nottingham.ac.uk).
Training Networks (ITN) action (project number 665468) and partially by the Michael Galea is also with the School of Aerospace, University of
Institute for Aerospace Technology (IAT) at the University of Nottingham. Nottingham Ningbo China, Ningbo 315100, China
Vincenzo Madonna1, Paolo Giangrande2, and Michael Galea3 are all with the
Power Electronics, Machines and Control (PEMC) group, University of
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON TRANSPORTATION ELECTRIFICATION
the two world wars, electric services, such as lighting, V-Bombers were decommissioned, however, their power
signalling and heating, were brought into use [3, 11, 12] and generation system is still in service today on the VC-10
with them the power generated by the wind-driven generators air-to-air refuelling tankers. Generating AC voltage at constant
escalated from 250W up to 1000W. Higher power ratings were frequency required a coupling mechanical gearbox between the
achieved by increasing the generated voltage levels. Indeed, the variable-speed prime mover (i.e. engine shaft) and the generator
6Vdc system (already in use in the automotive industry) was [16]. This complex hydromechanical unit introduced reliability
soon replaced by the 12Vdc system, which had been upgraded issues, due to increased component count (with several moving
to the 28Vdc system by 1936 [13]. parts), which needed frequent maintenance [17]. In the early
1990s, the need for more energy-efficient aircraft promoted the
MEA concept, which was already known since 1940s. As a
result of this trend, commercial aircraft implementing more-
electric features are nowadays available and some examples are
the A380 and the B787 [3].
Starting from the dawn of aviation, this paper presents a
survey on the evolution of electrical power generators for
aerospace applications. In particular, DC power generation is
discussed in Section II, where the technologies implemented
pre- and post- World Wars are examined. In Section III, the AC
power generation technologies, such as constant frequency
(CF) and variable speed constant frequency (VSCF) systems,
are described and their main advantages and drawbacks are
highlighted. Section IV deals with “unconventional systems”,
such as switched reluctance machine (SRM) based systems, for
Fig. 1. Evolution of electrical power need (in grey short to medium range
generating electric power on-board of military aircraft. Recent
aircraft and in black medium to long range aircraft). achievements and today’s generation systems employed in
MEA are considered in Section V. The challenges and
forthcoming developments regarding the power generation on
the future aircraft (i.e. multi-spool generation and HVDC
systems) are briefly reviewed in Section VI. Finally, Section
VII provides a summary through more than a hundred years of
electric power generation on-board of aircraft.
II. DC GENERATION
In the early days, electric power on aircraft was mainly used
for communication and ignition systems. Indeed, the first DC
generators were typically rated for less than 500W and usually
adopted 6Vdc and 12Vdc voltage levels [11, 12]. As previously
mentioned, the installation of lighting, signalling and heating
systems increased the electric power requirements. Hence, the
generator capacity rose up to 1kW (value retained till the
Fig. 2. Electric generation systems evolution.
beginning of World War II [18]), as well as the voltage level,
which was increased to 28Vdc. Higher generated voltage
As the aircraft travelling (ground) speed begun to exceed
allowed for savings on cables and commutators weight [13, 19,
280km/h (around 1934), the drag forces related to wind-driven
20].
generators started to become a significant issue [14]. For this
reason, wind-driven generators were superseded by engine- A. Pre-World War II
driven generators. During Second World War (1939-45), The majority of the first DC generators relied on wind-driven
engine-driven generators were improved, in terms of
technologies [19]. This topology of generator was most
power/weight ratio and reliability, however generation was still
commonly mounted externally on the aircraft’s landing gear
in DC. In the 1940s and 1950s, twin 28Vdc engine-driven
strut. However, as aircraft speeds increased, requirements for
generators became a standard on-board of many aircraft. Apart
from its main two 12kW engine-driven generators, it employed more refined flight dynamics started to push towards fully
one or two batteries (as emergency power source) and a power retractable landing gear and thus wind-milling generators
converter, which fed the AC electric loads [14]. In the 1950s, became obsolete. The era of engine-driven generators thus
three-phase generators were mounted on British V-Bombers. began [21]. Table I combines the two ‘families’, i.e.
These military aircraft used four AC generators providing about wind-driven and engine-driven generators, and reports the main
40kVA each, at 400Hz frequency and 115/200Vac voltage [1]. characteristics of some of these early DC aircraft generators
At that time, V-Bombers were one of the first aircraft to [11, 12, 19, 21]. Engine-driven DC generators were designed
implement parallel AC generators [15]. Thirty years later, the for speeds between 3200rpm and 6000rpm, according to the
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON TRANSPORTATION ELECTRIFICATION
prime mover speed, and allowed for short time overloads [19].
The overload capability was usually aimed at 50% of the rated
power. In order to ensure light weight, the generator housing
and its accessories, such as supporting brackets, were typically
made of magnesium alloys [20, 22]. Indeed, these alloys were
preferred to aluminium alloys, because their mass density is
about two thirds of the aluminium ones.
Power
DC Electrical Speed Weight Approx.
density
Generator parameters [krpm] [kg] date
[kW/kg]
12V, 250W 3.5 5.5 1924 0.05
Wind 12V, 500W 4.5 6.4 1924 0.08
Driven 0.08 Fig. 3. 1kW at 28Vdc engine-driven DC generator, stored in the Shuttleworth
12V, 1kW 3.5 12.3 NA
Museum (Biggleswade, UK).
12V, 500W 3.8 to 6 9.8 1934 0.05
28V, 1kW 3.8 to 6 16.3 1936 0.06
28V, 1.5kW 3.3 to 6 15.4 1941 0.10
28V, 3kW 3 to 6 27.2 1943 0.11
Engine 3.25 to 0.24
28V, 6kW 25.4 1944
Driven 4.8
28V, NA
6 NA 1953
11.2kW
112V, 0.36
2.9-10 63 1956
22.5kW
TABLE II - CHARACTERISTICS OF MODERN ENGINE DRIVEN DC GENERATORS transmit high power over a convenient distance, while still low
FOR AIRCRAFT (COURTESY OF THALES GROUP) [29]
enough to avoid the devastating phenomena associated to
Power corona effects at altitude [11, 12, 19, 21]. An important step
Electrical Speed Weight Approx
Density towards the AC generation was made in 1949 with the entry
parameters [krpm] [kg] Date
[kW/kg]
28V, 4.8kW 8-12.15 7.8-8 2014 0.6-0.62
into service of the Convair B 36, which was equipped with four
28V, 6kW 7-12.15 9-11 2014 0.54-0.67 30kVA synchronous generator (one per engine) [21, 32]. In the
28V, 9kW 4.5-12.3 16-21 2014 0.43-0.56 next sub-paragraphs, the most common AC electric power
28V, 12kW 7-12.8 17-19 2014 0.63-0.71 systems are discussed and analysed.
in civil aircraft), AC generation is then generally preferred, for These aircraft are characterized by an intensive electrification,
the reasons discussed in Section III. since services like the ECS (for B787) and flight-control electro
hydrostatic actuators (for A380) are electrically powered.
Consequently, their electric generation capability is roughly of
an order of magnitude greater than all other aircraft. Both the
B787 and A380 have replaced the traditional generation system
employing IDGs, by VFGs directly coupled to the engines. The
B787 main electrical power generation relies on four 250kVA
VFGs (two per each main engine), while the A380 uses four
150kVA VFGs (one per engine), as reported in Table IV [3].
The implementation of the so-called bleed-less architecture
permits to electrically supply services (e.g. ECS and wing ice
protection), which were pneumatically operated on
conventional aircraft. In bleed-less technology, no HP air is
extracted from the engines (i.e. no-bleed air), allowing more
efficient thrust production and engine operations [7, 8, 76].
Fig. 10. F-22 power generation and distribution system [58]. Indeed, in most conditions, conventional pneumatic systems
withdraw more power than needed, causing excess energy to be
V. THE MORE ELECTRIC AIRCRAFT ERA dumped overboard [8].
The above is all related to existing and consolidated systems TABLE IV - POWER GENERATION CAPABILITIES FOR SOME MODERN AIRCRAFT
for on-board electrical power generation. However, as
Boeing 787 Airbus A380
previously mentioned, a considerable shift towards more
No. of engine 2 4
electric systems is in play today. The MEA concept revolves No. generator per engine 2 1
around the idea of replacing most of the aircraft secondary Generator rating 250kVA 150kVA
systems, currently operated by mechanical, hydraulic and Generating output voltage 230V AC 115V AC
pneumatic power, with systems powered by electricity [38, 75]. No. generator per APU 2 1
Some early examples of the MEA concept go back to the mid- Generator rating per APU 225kVA 120kVA
1950s with the Vickers Valiant V-Bomber and the Bristol
Brabazon 167 [1]. Albeit the feasibility and availability of the The bleed-less architecture of the B787 reduces the fuel
MEA concept is debatable and is still in question today, a consumption by 2% (at cruise condition) with respect to a
revamped interest in the MEA initiative started in the early similar-sized traditional aircraft (e.g. B767) [8]. Nonetheless,
1990s, when the US Air Force began several research programs removing the pneumatic system increases the complexity of the
concerning MEA. In particular, these programs focused on electric power distribution network [9]. This aspect is
highlighted in Fig. 11, where the B787’s distribution system is
improving reliability, fault tolerant capability and power quality
schematically compared with that of a traditional aircraft,
of existing MEA systems, with the final purpose of reducing
together with some examples of electrically-operated loads [9,
both fuel burn and weight of aircraft secondary power systems
43]. As earlier mentioned, several energy-consuming loads are
[2]. An immediate consequence of the MEA concept is the frequency-insensitive. Therefore, they are directly supplied by
significant increase (in the absolute numbers) of the required the VFGs, without the need of PECs (see Fig. 11, B787
electric power. For this reason, today, electrical power diagram). The other loads (operating at 115Vac, 270Vdc or
generation is a major game-changing factor across the whole 28Vdc), are connected to the VFGs through transformers and/or
industry. PECs, implementing the so-called hybrid distribution system.
A. Modern MEA programmes The transition to a more electric architecture, the adoption of
energy efficient engines and the intensive use of lightweight
A number of aircraft have been claimed to incorporate MEA composite materials have contributed to a considerable
designs, nevertheless it is widely acknowledged that the two reduction of the B787’s operating cost with respect to its
programmes, which have really and seamlessly integrated the predecessor the B767-300/ER [77, 78]. In particular (based on
MEA concepts, are the long-haul, wide bodied commercial airlines’ data), the block hour operating cost reduction is about
aircraft known as the Boeing 787 and the Airbus A380 [38]. 14% [78-80].
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON TRANSPORTATION ELECTRIFICATION
Fig. 11. Simplified diagrams of electric distribution systems for both B787 and traditional aircraft.
Fig. 13. Power rating of the main generators of some common aircraft (in red medium to long range aircraft, in black short to medium range aircraft).
A. Multi-spool generation and HVDC systems PMSMs are: 1) excellent power density, 2) high efficiency and
Currently on modern large aircraft, turbofan engines are 3) well-established control strategies; whilst, their drawbacks
generally employed for propulsion. The main electrical power are: 1) high cost, 2) inability to operate at elevated temperatures,
generator is usually driven by the HP spool (as shown in Fig. 7 3) dependent on power electronics and 4) medium reliability
and discussed in Section III), principally because the higher and fault tolerance capability. As matter of fact, the excitation
speed of the HP spool allows smaller size generators. Further, field produced by the PMs is practically uncontrolled and can
assuming N1 and N2 as rotational speeds of the LP and HP supply winding faults [96-98]. On the contrary, a good level of
spools respectively, N2 varies in a narrower range (from idle to reliability and fault tolerance capability is ensured by IMs,
full power) with respect to N1 [50, 52]. For these reasons, no which however do not ‘enjoy’ the power density levels of their
generation activity was traditionally done on the LP spool (i.e. PM counterparts. SRMs cannot compete with PMSMs in terms
low speed). In conventional turbofan engines, the electric of power density and control strategy, albeit their rotor
power extracted from the HP spool is a small fraction of the robustness makes SRMs suitable for working in harsh
total engine power. However, the trend towards (and beyond) environments [72, 99, 100]. Finally, SRMs are also intrinsically
the MEA is resulting in an ever-growing demand for more on- fault tolerant, for the reasons discussed in Section IV.
board electric power; thus, any potential source of power needs
TABLE V –SHAFT ROTATIONAL SPEEDS FOR COMMON DUAL SPOOL
to be fully utilised. Therefore, generating through multiple
TURBOFAN ENGINES
spools (i.e. exploiting both HP and LP spools, as prime mover
for electrical generation) is fastly becoming justifiable [34, 65, Engine Aircraft N1(100%) N2(100%) 𝑵𝟏𝑴𝒂𝒙 𝑵𝟐𝑴𝒂𝒙
91, 92]. The main challenge rising from using both HP and LP Series (example) [rpm] [rpm] 𝑵𝟏𝒎𝒊𝒏 𝑵𝟐𝒎𝒊𝒏
GP7200 A380 2467 10998 6.1 1.9
spools [5, 93] consists in the particular design attention required CFM56 B737 5175 14460 5.2 1.8
by the LP spool driven generator, due to the wider speed range GEnx-
B747-8 2560 11377 6.7 2.3
and harsher operating conditions [67]. Indeed, N2’s full-power 2B67
to idle ratio (N2Max/N2min) is usually around 2:1, whereas PW1100G A320neo NA NA 5.7 1.8
Business
N1Max/N1min can be more than 6:1 for high bypass ratio engines CF34-8C1 7400 17820 NA 1.8
Jet
[52]. For sake of completeness, full-power to idle ratios are V2500 A320 5650 14950 4 NA
reported in Table V for some common dual spool turbofan Business
PW300 10608 26956 NA 1.6
Jet
engines, together with the “normal” operating speed of N1 and GE90 B777 2261 9331 6.1 1.7
N2 [52].
With regard to the electrical machine topology, permanent Aside from incrementing the generation capability, future
magnet synchronous machines (PMSMs), induction machines aircraft concepts aim to improve the overall electrical power
(IMs) and SRMs are possible candidates for the LP spool system and its architecture. In next generation aircraft, a
generators [68, 94, 95]. Nevertheless, each of these machines significant weight saving could be achieved by increasing the
reveals advantages and disadvantages. The principal benefits of distribution voltage [33, 101]. As previously mentioned,
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON TRANSPORTATION ELECTRIFICATION
considering the same transmitted power, a higher voltage (for hybrid/electric light aircraft, for short endurance missions [90,
the distribution system) will result in smaller cable cross- 109, 113, 114]. Nonetheless, for energising a fully-electric,
section area. Furthermore, raising the voltage will allow greater short-haul civil aircraft, the energy density of the currently
line voltage drop [101]. In fact, the minimum allowed voltage available battery technologies needs to improve by at least eight
is 108Vac, for distribution system at 115Vac, instead 250Vdc or ten-fold.
are accepted on 270Vdc systems (as per MIL-STD-704F) [100].
C. Electrical systems and sub-systems in future aircraft
For these reasons, high voltage DC (HVDC) distribution
systems at 270Vdc and 540Vdc are under investigation [101, As previously pointed out, high power density and reliable
104]. Regarding the HVDC systems, the most obvious concerns electrical machines and PECs will be the key enabling
are safety and the increased risk of electrical system failures, technologies, in future aircraft systems. Significant work across
caused by the low pressure phenomenon, such as corona effects a range of aviation authorities has recently gone into defining
and insulation breakdown. road-maps for the technology requirements of such systems [86,
The migration to HVDC systems, together with the 87, 115].
implementation of LP spool generators, will also influence the
design of PECs. In this area, some of the main challenges are 1) High power density specifications
imputable to: a) higher operating voltage; b) elevated amount For electrical systems, it is clear that today’s state of the art
of power to be handled; and c) wider generators’ operating is still not at the demanded power density levels for future
(fundamental) frequency (for LP spool generation). Wide band- aircraft, comprising all electric and hybrid electric propulsion.
gap semiconductors, such as silicon carbide (SiC), are A quantitative analysis, whose results are compiled in Table VI,
recognised, by the scientific and industrial communities, as a indicates the predicted electrical machine power density
technology enabler [105-107]. specifications for the short-, mid- and long-term future [86,
The major features (particularly convenient for aerospace 117]. Considering the analysis outcomes, the long-term goal is
application) of SiC-based PECs, over traditional silicon-based only achievable by the practical application of non-
PECs, are a) lower losses, b) better temperature tolerance, c) conventional technologies, such as superconductivity; whereas
higher operating voltage and d) faster switching capability the short- and mid-term targets are feasible using more
[105-107]. Reduced losses and high temperature tolerance help conventional technologies strengthened by a high level of
to decrease thermal management specifications [106], hence innovation. Indeed, electrical machines with power densities
smaller and less expensive cooling systems are necessary for higher than 10kVA/kg have already been manufactured and
SiC-based PECs. Further, high operating voltage and fast tested [117], and an example is reported in the following
switching capability lead to a potential decrement of both sub-section.
PECs’ weight and size [107]. In particular, higher switching TABLE VI – ELECTRICAL MACHINE POWER DENSITY
frequencies contribute to the reduction of filtering passive SPECIFICATIONS FOR FUTURE AIRCRAFT
component size [107], while less series-connected modules
Time- Predicted Power
(than traditional silicon-based counterpart) would be adopted Enabling Technology
lines Density
for managing higher voltages [106]. Liquid cooling, Low Loss Steel,
By 2025 10kVA/kg High Breakdown-Strength
B. Future aircraft concepts Insulating Materials, Additive
Some of the most attractive concepts for future aircraft are Manufacturing, Nanocomposite-
By 2035 20kVA/kg Based Magnetic Materials [86,
represented by hybrid electric (e.g. Pipistrel Hypstair) [108, 116, 118, 119]
109], distributed electric (e.g. NASA-DEP) [110], turbo electric All the above + Superconducting
By 2050 40kVA/kg
(e.g. Rolls Royce / Airbus E-Thrust) [111] and fully electrical materials
(e.g. Airbus E-Fan) aircraft [112]. All these configurations are
characterised by an intensive electrification, since electric 2) Enabling technologies
power is not only used for secondary systems, but also for In order to reach such performance, a number of technology
propulsion purposes. For instance, the Airbus / Siemens / Rolls enablers are today being studied and investigated by research
Royce “E-Fan X hybrid-electric technology demonstrator” is communities. These include new magnetic and electrical
anticipated to fly in 2020 [85]. This program has two objectives, materials [118, 119], advanced modelling [120, 121] and
such as: a) replacing one of the four gas turbine engines of a manufacturing processes [122, 123], new thermal management
traditional British Aerospace 146 (as well-known as BAe 146) techniques [124-126], high-speed systems [116] and better
with a 2MW electric motor; and b) introducing a 2MW generator understanding of failure mechanisms [127, 128]. The latter
(in the classical turbo-electric system style), powered by a involves advancements in power electronics (e.g. wide band-
Rolls-Royce AE 2100, which is used as an auxiliary power unit gap devices), machines (e.g. new, high strength, low losses
(APU) [85]. The success of these concepts, besides from relying steels) and controllers (e.g. high bandwidth control algorithms).
on high performance electrical machines and PECs, will be The relationship between the technology impact of the enablers
strongly dependent on the technological development of energy on the drive (or its components) general performance and the
storage systems. Modern electrochemical batteries have proven technology maturity is illustrated in a visually-representative
to be suitable for powering unmanned aerial vehicle and manner in Fig. 14.
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON TRANSPORTATION ELECTRIFICATION
REFERENCES
Fig. 14. Enablers: impact vs. readiness.
[1] I. Moir, A. Seabridge, and M. Jukes, "Electrical Systems," in Civil
Avionics Systems 2nd Edition, ISBN: 978-1-118-34180-3, ed: John Wiley
A power generation system for a more electric business-jet, & Sons, 2013, pp. 235-290.
implementing some of the aforementioned features, is the [2] J. A. Rosero, J. A. Ortega, E. Aldabas, and L. Romeral, "Moving towards
electrical machine described in [129-131], which was a more electric aircraft," IEEE Aerospace and Electronic Systems
Magazine, vol. 22, pp. 3-9, 2007.
developed within the authors’ organization. This generator is a
[3] B. Sarlioglu and C. T. Morris, "More Electric Aircraft: Review,
45kVA surface mount PMSM, capable of working also as Challenges, and Opportunities for Commercial Transport Aircraft," IEEE
engine starter (i.e. starter-generator), and it is shown in Fig. 15. Transactions on Transportation Electrification, vol. 1, pp. 54-64, 2015.
[4] M. Galea, C. Gerada, T. Raminosoa, and P. Wheeler, "Design of a high
force density tubular permanent magnet motor," in The XIX International
Conference on Electrical Machines - ICEM 2010, 2010, pp. 1-6.
[5] C. R. Avery, S. G. Burrow, and P. H. Mellor, "Electrical generation and
distribution for the more electric aircraft," in Universities Power
Engineering Conference, 2007. UPEC 2007. 42nd International, 2007,
pp. 1007-1012.
[6] X. Roboam, "New trends and challenges of electrical networks embedded
in “more electrical aircraft”," in Industrial Electronics (ISIE), 2011 IEEE
International Symposium on, 2011, pp. 26-31.
[7] X. Roboam, B. Sareni, and A. De Andrade, "More electricity in the air:
Toward optimized electrical networks embedded in more-electrical
aircraft," IEEE industrial electronics magazine, vol. 6, pp. 6-17, 2012.
[8] M. Sinnett, "Boeing: 787 No-Bleed Systems: Saving Fuel and Enhancing
Operational Efficiencies," AERO Quaterly QTR_04 07, 2007. Available:
http://www.boeing.com/commercial/aeromagazine/articles/qtr_4_07/AE
RO_Q407.pdf Accessed: Dec. 2017.
[9] T. Nelson, "787 Systems and performance," Available:
Fig. 15. A state of the art, PM generator developed at the University of http://myhres.com/Boeing-787-Systems-and-Performance.pdf Accessed:
Nottingham. Dec. 2017.
[10] I. O. Hockmeyer, "The generation and regulation of electric power in
aircraft: a survey of design features of generators and their control,"
Some of the innovative attributes characterizing this machine Electrical Engineers - Part II: Power Engineering, Journal of the
are: 1) a carbon fibre PMs retention mechanism, 2) low losses, Institution of, vol. 93, p. 2, 1946.
high grade, non-oriented silicon steel 3) novel thermal [11] "Aerospace Industries Association of America; The 1939 Aircraft Year
Book," Washington, D.C: Aeronautical Chamber of Commerce of
management involving the use of direct oil cooling of the stator America.
core, 4) advanced high energy density PMs, 5) multi-level PEC [12] "Aerospace Industries Association of America; The 1938 Aircraft Year
design configuration and 6) the use of higher voltage rating Book," Washington, D.C: Aeronautical Chamber of Commerce of
America.
materials, that allows operation at the new 540V HVDC buses, [13] W. K. Boice and L. G. Levoy, "Basic considerations in selection of
being considered for future aircraft. These characteristics have electric systems for large aircraft," Electrical Engineering, vol. 63, pp.
contributed to achieve a power density higher than 16kVA/kg, 279-287, 1944.
[14] I. Moir and A. Seabridge, "Electrical Systems," in Aircraft systems:
confirming the high impact of some of the technology enablers mechanical, electrical and avionics subsystems integration. ISBN:
reported in Fig. 14 and highlighting the way towards the future 1119965209. vol. 52, ed: John Wiley & Sons, 2011, pp. 181-237.
of the aircraft industry. [15] "Paralleled A.C. The case for constant-frequency systems," Flight and
Aircraft Engineer 30 Jan. 1959 - 0337 pp. 164-166 Available:
https://www.flightglobal.com/pdfarchive/1959.html Accessed: Dec. 2017.
VII. CONCLUSION [16] M. A. Cordner, W. A. Flygare, and D. H. Grimm, "Integrated drive-
generator system," U.S. Patent 4,252,035, 1981.
This paper provides a ‘journey’ along the evolution of
[17] J. L. Lando, "Fixed frequency electrical generation system and
electric power generation on-board of aircraft, by addressing corresponding control procedure," U.S. Patent 7,064,455 B2, 2006.
the main technologies adopted over more than a hundred years [18] A. I. Bertinov, "Aircraft Electrical Generation," Air Force System
time span. The advantages and disadvantages of the most Command, 1959.
[19] "Aerospace Industries Association of America; The 1941 Aircraft Year
common generation systems are analysed. The aircraft power Book," Washington, D.C.: Aeronautical Chamber of Commerce of
requirements and the generation power trends are reported and America.
discussed. The level of generated power was firstly affected by [20] W. J. Clardy, "Electric power for airplanes," Electrical Engineering, vol.
59, pp. 385-388, 1940.
the transition from DC to AC generation. Then a constant
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON TRANSPORTATION ELECTRIFICATION
[21] A. K. Hyder, "A Century of Aerospace Electrical Power Technology," [48] A. E. Reyad Mohamed Abdel-fadil, "Electrical Distribution power
Journal of Propulsion and Power, vol. 19, 2003. systems of modern civil aircrafts," 2nd International Conference on
[22] B. Adkins, W. Philipp, and A. Hossle. (1956, Electrical machines for Energy Systemss and Technologies, Feb. 2013, Cairo, Egypt, 2013.
aircraft. Proceedings of the IEE - Part A: Power Engineering 103(1S), [49] "European Aviation Safety Agency ; Type-Certificate Data Sheet for
116-127. Available: http://digital- GE90 Series engines," Available: https://www.easa.europa.eu/document-
library.theiet.org/content/journals/10.1049/pi-a.1956.0017 library/type-certificates Accessed: Dec. 2017.
[23] "[Online] Available: http://content.aviation-safety- [50] Rolls-Royce, "Accessory drive," in The Jet Engine 5th edition. ISBN: 0
bureau.com/allmembers/faa-h-8083-31-amt-airframe-vol- 902121 2 35, ed Derby, England, 1996, pp. 65-71.
1/sections/chapter9.php Accessed: Feb. 2018." [51] J. R. Bart, B. A. Beutin, P. Charles, and G. Morel, "Twin spool turbine
[24] "Aerospace Industries Association of America; Aircraft year book 1953," engine with power take-off means on the low-pressure and high-pressure
Washington, D.C.: Aeronautical Chamber of Commerce of America. rotors, and power take-off module for the turbine engine," Safran Aircraft
[25] E. Sili, F. Koliatene, and J. P. Cambronne, "Pressure and temperature Engines SAS. U.S. Grant US7552591B2, 2006.
effects on the paschen curve," in 2011 Annual Report Conference on [52] "European Aviation Safety Agency; Engines Type-Certificate Data
Electrical Insulation and Dielectric Phenomena, 2011, pp. 464-467. Sheets," Available: https://www.easa.europa.eu/document-library/type-
[26] W. L. Berry and J. P. Dallas, "Higher-voltage D-C Aircraft Electric certificates Accessed: Dec. 2017.
Systems," Transactions of the American Institute of Electrical Engineers, [53] [Online] Available: https://grabcad.com/library/2-spool-high-bypass-
vol. 63, pp. 843-849, 1944. turbofan Accessed: Feb. 2018.
[27] Airbus, "WRC-15 Agenda Item 1.17 - Industry’s Motivation," EC - CEPT [54] M. J. Cronin, "Aircraft providing variable and constant electric power,"
Workshop on World Radiocommunication Conference 2015, 2015. U.S. Patent 4587436 A, 1986.
[28] C. Sciascera, P. Giangrande, C. Brunson, et al., "Optimal design of an [55] A. Eid, H. El-Kishky, M. Abdel-Salam, and M. T. El-Mohandes, "On
electro-mechanical actuator for aerospace application" in 2015 Annual Power Quality of Variable-Speed Constant-Frequency Aircraft Electric
Conference of the IEEE Industrial Electronics Society, Japan. Power Systems," IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery, vol. 25, pp. 55-
[29] "DC Starter-Generator Solutions," Thales Group, 2014. 65, 2010.
[30] T. B. Holliday, "Applications of electric power in aircraft," Electrical [56] A. Al-Timimy, P.Giangrande, M. Degano, et al, "Comparative study of
Engineering, vol. 60, pp. 218-225, 1941. permanent magnet-synchronous and permanent magnet-flux switching
[31] D. W. Exner, "Parallel Operation of Airplane Alternators," Transactions machines for high torque to inertia applications", 2017 IEEE Workshop
of the American Institute of Electrical Engineers, vol. 62, pp. 755-760, on Electrical Machines Design, Control and Diagnosis, Pages 45-51,
1943. 2017.
[32] C. Severns, "Reflections on the preliminary electrical power system [57] F. Cupertino, G. Pellegrino, P. Giangrande, et. al., "Model based design
design for a large transportation airship," in 18th AIAA Lighter-Than-Air of a sensorless control scheme for permanent magnet motors using signal
Systems Technology Conference, 2009, p. 2865. injection", in 2010 Energy Conversion Congress and Exposition, Atlanta,
[33] K. Emadi and M. Ehsani, "Aircraft power systems: technology, state of GA, USA, September 2010.
the art, and future trends," IEEE Aerospace and Electronic Systems [58] I. Moir and A. G. Seabridge, "Vehicle Managment Systems," in Military
Magazine, vol. 15, pp. 28-32, 2000. Avionics Systems, ed: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, 2006, pp. 399-401.
[34] Y. Jia and K. Rajashekara, "Induction Machine for More Electric Aircraft: [59] K. Vijayakumar, R. Karthikeyan, S. Paramasivam, R. Arumugam, and K.
Enabling New Electrical Power System Architectures," IEEE N. Srinivas, "Switched Reluctance Motor Modeling, Design, Simulation,
Electrification Magazine, vol. 5, pp. 25-37, 2017. and Analysis: A Comprehensive Review," IEEE Transactions on
[35] R. J. Kennett, "Integrated drive generators for aircraft," Electronics and Magnetics, vol. 44, pp. 4605-4617, 2008.
Power, vol. 17, pp. 73-76, 1971. [60] D. A. Torrey, "Switched reluctance generators and their control," IEEE
[36] N. Jiao, W. Liu, J. Peng, S. Mao, and H. Zhang, "Design and control Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 49, pp. 3-14, 2002.
strategy of a two-phase brushless exciter for three-stage starter/generator," [61] M. E. Elbuluk and M. D. Kankam, "Potential starter/generator
in 2014 IEEE Energy Conversion Congress and Exposition (ECCE), technologies for future aerospace applications," IEEE Aerospace and
2014, pp. 5864-5869. Electronic Systems Magazine, vol. 12, pp. 24-31, 1997.
[37] S. Nuzzo, M. Galea, C. Gerada and N. Brown “Analysis, Modeling, and [62] P. Giangrande, F. Cupertino and G. Pellegrino, "Modelling of linear motor
Design Considerations for the Excitation Systems of Synchronous end-effects for saliency based sensorless control", in 2010 IEEE Energy
Generators” in IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 65, issue Conversion Congress and Exposition, Atlanta, GA, USA, September
4, pp. 2996 - 3007, 2018. 2010.
[38] P. Wheeler and S. Bozhko, "The More Electric Aircraft: Technology and [63] A. Al-Timimy, M. Degano, P. Giangrande, et al., "Design and
challenges," IEEE Electrification Magazine, vol. 2, pp. 6-12, 2014. optimization of a high power density machine for flooded industrial
[39] B. Stephen, "Constant speed drive and generator," U.S. Patent 3576143 pump," in 2016 International Conference on Electrical Machines,
A, 1971. Lausanne, 2016, pp. 1480-1.
[40] L. Setlak, "Overview of aircraft technology solutions compatible with the [64] A. V. Radun, C. A. Ferreira, and E. Richter, "Two channel switched
concept of mea," Electronical Engineering Issue 1-E (8) 2015, vol. 2015, reluctance starter/generator results," in Proceedings of APEC 97 - Applied
2015. Power Electronics Conference, 1997, pp. 546-552 vol.1.
[41] R. M. Richard Secunde, David Repas, "Integrated Engine-Generator [65] A. J. Mitcham and N. Grum, "An integrated LP shaft generator for the
Concept for aircraft Electric Secondary Power," in Nasa Technical more electric aircraft," in IEE Colloquium on All Electric Aircraft (Digest
Memorandum TM X-2579, ed, 1972. No. 1998/260), 1998, pp. 8/1-8/9.
[42] S. B. Barnhardt, "Cooling arrangement for an integrated drive-generator [66] J. A. Weimer, "Electrical power technology for the more electric aircraft,"
system," U.S. Patent 4284913 A, 1981. in [1993 Proceedings] AIAA/IEEE Digital Avionics Systems Conference,
[43] L. Andrade and C. Tenning, "Design of the Boeing 777 electric system," 1993, pp. 445-450.
in Proceedings of the IEEE 1992 National Aerospace and Electronics [67] C. Gerada, M. Galea, and A. Kladas, "Electrical machines for aerospace
Conference (NAECON 1992), 1992, pp. 1281-1290 vol.3. applications," in 2015 IEEE Workshop on Electrical Machines Design,
[44] T. Glennon, "Sundstrand Corp: The 400-Hz aircraft power-generation Control and Diagnosis (WEMDCD), 2015, pp. 79-84.
systems: Advancing the baseline," NASA. Lewis Research Center Aircraft [68] S.A Odhano, P.Giangrande, R.Bojoi and Gerada, "Self-commissioning of
Elect. Secondary Power; p 1-12; (SEE 19840001988), 1983. interior permanent magnet synchronous motor drives with high-frequency
[45] I. Moir, "More-electric aircraft-system considerations," in IEE current injection", 5th Annual IEEE Energy Conversion Congress and
Colloquium on Electrical Machines and Systems for the More Electric Exhibition, Pages 3852-3859, 2013
Aircraft (Ref. No. 1999/180), 1999, pp. 10/1-10/9. [69] A. Al-Timimy, M. Degano, Z. Xu, et al. "Trade-off analysis and design of
[46] J. F. Gieras, "High speed machines," in Advancements in Electrical a high power density PM machine for flooded industrial pump," in 2016
Machines 1st edition, ISBN 978-1-4020-9007-3, ed: Springer, 2008, pp. Annual Conference of the IEEE Industrial Electronics Society, Florence,
81-109. 2016, pp. 1749-1754.
[47] A. Abdel-Hafez, Power Generation and Distribution System for a More [70] E. Richter and C. Ferreira, "Performance evaluation of a 250 kW switched
Electric Aircraft-A Review: INTECH Open Access Publisher, 2012. reluctance starter generator," in Industry Applications Conference, 1995.
Thirtieth IAS Annual Meeting, IAS '95., Conference Record of the 1995
IEEE, 1995, pp. 434-440 vol.1.
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON TRANSPORTATION ELECTRIFICATION
[71] A. Radun, "Generating with the switched reluctance motor," in Applied [94] W. Cao, B. C. Mecrow, G. J. Atkinson, J. W. Bennett, and D. J. Atkinson,
Power Electronics Conference and Exposition, 1994. APEC '94. "Overview of Electric Motor Technologies Used for More Electric
Conference Proceedings 1994., Ninth Annual, 1994, pp. 41-47 vol.1. Aircraft (MEA)," IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 59,
[72] A. G. Jack, B. C. Mecrow, and J. A. Haylock, "A comparative study of pp. 3523-3531, 2012.
permanent magnet and switched reluctance motors for high-performance [95] G. Rizzoli, G. Serra, P. Maggiore, and A. Tenconi, "Optimized design of
fault-tolerant applications," IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, a multiphase induction machine for an open rotor aero-engine shaft-line-
vol. 32, pp. 889-895, 1996. embedded starter/generator," in IECON 2013 - 39th Annual Conference
[73] P. Wheeler, "The more electric aircraft: Why aerospace needs power of the IEEE Industrial Electronics Society, 2013, pp. 5203-5208.
electronics?," in 2009 13th European Conference on Power Electronics [96] D. Golovanov, M. Galea, and C. Gerada, "High specific torque motor for
and Applications, 2009, pp. 1-30. propulsion system of aircraft," in 2016 International Conference on
[74] R. I. Jones, "The More Electric Aircraft: the past and the future?," in IEE Electrical Systems for Aircraft, Railway, Ship Propulsion and Road
Colloquium on Electrical Machines and Systems for the More Electric Vehicles & International Transportation Electrification Conference
Aircraft (Ref. No. 1999/180), 1999, pp. 1/1-1/4. (ESARS-ITEC), 2016, pp. 1-6.
[75] J. A. Weimer, "The role of electric machines and drives in the more [97] M. Galea, T. Hamiti, and C. Gerada, "Torque density improvements for
electric aircraft," in Electric Machines and Drives Conference, 2003. high performance machines," in 2013 International Electric Machines &
IEMDC'03. IEEE International, 2003, pp. 11-15 vol.1. Drives Conference, 2013, pp. 1066-1073.
[76] V. Crespo Cavalcanti and C. Andrade, "A Trade-off Study of a Bleedless [98] P.Giangrande, C.I.Hill, S.V.Bozhko and C.Gerada "A novel multi-level
and Conventional Air Conditioning Systems," presented at the 2008 SAE electro-mechanical actuator virtual testing and analysis tool" in 2014 IET
Brasil Congress and Exhibition, 2008. International Conference on Power Electronics, Machines and Drives,
[77] J. Hale, "787 Design for Maintainability," ATEC, Apr. 2007. Available: 2014 pp. 1-6.
http://www.vaughn.edu/assets/downloads/ATEC-2008-01.pdf Accessed: [99] S. R. MacMinn and W. D. Jones, "A very high speed switched-reluctance
Dec. 2017. starter-generator for aircraft engine applications," in Proceedings of the
[78] "Aircraft Commerce; Can the 787 & A350 transform the economics of IEEE National Aerospace and Electronics Conference, 1989, pp. 1758-
long-haul services?," Aircraft Commerce Issue No. 39; February/March 1764 vol.4.
2005, 2005. [100] C. A. Ferreira, S. R. Jones, W. S. Heglund, and W. D. Jones, "Detailed
[79] "Reported Operating Cost and Utilization of More Than 500 Wide-body design of a 30-kW switched reluctance starter/generator system for a gas
Aircraft," [Online] Available: http://www.planestats.com/bhsw_2014sep turbine engine application," IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications,
Accessed: Dec. 2017. vol. 31, pp. 553-561, 1995.
[80] "Aircraft Operating Costs," Aviation Week June 30, 2014; Page 6. [101] J. Brombach, T. Schröter, A. Lücken, and D. Schulz, "Optimized cabin
Available: http://aviationweek.com/site- power supply with a +/- 270 V DC grid on a modern aircraft," in 2011
files/aviationweek.com/files/uploads/2014/06/avd_06_30_2014_cht1.pdf 7th International Conference-Workshop Compatibility and Power
Accessed: Dec. 2017. Electronics (CPE), 2011, pp. 425-428.
[81] D. V. Makarov, A. S. Khlebnikov, A. V. Geist, and P. A. Bachurin, [102] J. Brombach, A. Lücken, B. Nya, M. Johannsen, and D. Schulz,
"Generation system with variable frequency and constant amplitude," in "Comparison of different electrical HVDC-architectures for aircraft
Proceedings of the 2011 3rd International Youth Conference on application," in 2012 Electrical Systems for Aircraft, Railway and Ship
Energetics (IYCE), 2011, pp. 1-9. Propulsion, 2012, pp. 1-6.
[82] M. Hirst, A. Mcloughlin, P. J. Norman, and S. J. Galloway, [103] "Department of Defence, United States of America; MIL-STD-704F
"Demonstrating the more electric engine: a step towards the power Aircraft Electric Power Characteristics," 2004.
optimised aircraft," IET Electric Power Applications, vol. 5, pp. 3-13, [104] L. Tarisciotti, A. Costabeber, C. Linglin, A. Walker, and M. Galea,
2011. "Evaluation of isolated DC/DC converter topologies for future HVDC
[83] Airbus, "Airbus Global Market Forecast 2017-2036," Available: aerospace microgrids," in 2017 IEEE Energy Conversion Congress and
http://www.airbus.com/aircraft/market/global-market-forecast.html Exposition (ECCE), 2017, pp. 2238-2245.
Accessed: Dec. 2017. [105] R. Raju, "Silicon carbide high voltage high frequency conversion," in
[84] Boeing, "Current Market Outlook 2017-2036," Available: NIST High Megawatt Variable Speed Drive Technology Workshop, 2014.
http://www.boeing.com/commercial/market/current-market-outlook- [106] A. Elasser and T. P. Chow, "Silicon carbide benefits and advantages for
2017/ Accessed: Dec. 2017. power electronics circuits and systems," Proceedings of the IEEE, vol.
[85] Airbus, "Airbus, Rolls-Royce, and Siemens team up for electric future.," 90, pp. 969-986, 2002.
[Online] Available: http://www.airbus.com/newsroom/press- [107] H. Zhang and L. M. Tolbert, "Efficiency impact of silicon carbide power
releases/en/2017/11/airbus--rolls-royce--and-siemens-team-up-for- electronics for modern wind turbine full scale frequency converter,"
electric-future-par.html Accessed: Dec. 2017. IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 58, pp. 21-28, 2011.
[86] M. Hepperle, "Electric flight-potential and limitations," Energy Efficient [108] "Siemens, Airbus and Rolls-Royce; HYPSTAIR – System Architecture,
Technologies and Concepts of Operation, 22-24 October 2012, Lisbon, Certifiability and Safety Aspects," Symposium E²-Fliegen 2016,
Portugal, 2012. Stuttgart. Available: http://www.hypstair.eu/wp-
[87] NASA, "Visions of the Future: Hybrid Electric Aircraft Propulsion," content/uploads/2013/10/E2-Fliegen-Symposium-Stuttgart_SAG.pdf
AIAA Aircraft Electric/Hybrid-Electric Power & Propulsion Workshop, Accessed: Dec. 2017.
July 28, 2016. Available: [109] R. Glassock, M. Galea, W. Williams, and T. Glesk, "Novel Hybrid
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20170002633.pdf Electric Aircraft Propulsion Case Studies," Aeronautics and
Accessed: Dec. 2017. Astronautics, MDPI Journal on, vol. vol. 4, iss. 3, article 45, 2017.
[88] Y.-H. Chang and P.-C. Shao, Operating cost control strategies for airlines [110] M. D. Moore, "Distributed Electric Propulsion (DEP) Aircraft," briefing
vol. 5: African Journal of Business Management 5.26 (2011): 10396, slides, Hampton, Va.: NASA Langley Briefing Center, 2012.
2011. [111] Airbus, "E-Thrust: Electrical distributed propulsion system concept for
[89] C.I. Hill, S. Bozhko, T. Yang, et al. "More Electric Aircraft Electro- lower fuel consumption, fewer emissions and less noise," Available:
Mechanical Actuator Regenerated Power Management" in 2015 IEEE http://company.airbus.com/service/mediacenter/download/?uuid=64ea2
International Symposium on Industrial Electronics, pp. 337-342. c23-91b1-4787-9d1d-5b22b7d716b9 Accessed: Dec. 2017.
[90] R. Glassock, M. Galea, W. Williams, and T. Glesk, "Hybrid Electric [112] Airbus, "E-FAN The New Way To Fly," Available:
Aircraft Propulsion Case Study for Skydiving Mission," Aerospace. 2017; http://company.airbus.com/news-media/media~item=19bf802f-1fad-
4(3):45, 2017. 4ce7-b61c-b5d6eab6b51d~.html Accessed: Dec. 2017.
[91] T. Feehally, "Electro-mechanical interaction in gas turbine-generator [113] G. Avanzini, E. L. de Angelis, and F. Giulietti, "Optimal performance
systems for more-electric aircraft," PhD, University of Manchester, 2012. and sizing of a battery-powered aircraft," Aerospace Science and
[92] A. Colin, "Turbojet having an electricity generator arranged in its fan Technology, vol. 59, pp. 132-144, 2016/12/01/ 2016.
(U.S. Grant US7952244B2)," ed: Google Patents, 2009. [114] M. Gatti, F. Giulietti, and M. Turci, "Maximum endurance for battery-
[93] Y. Jia and K. Rajashekara, "An induction generator based AC/DC hybrid powered rotary-wing aircraft," Aerospace Science and Technology, vol.
electric power generation system for more electric aircraft," in 2015 IEEE 45, pp. 174-179, 2015/09/01/ 2015.
Industry Applications Society Annual Meeting, 2015, pp. 1-7. [115] NASA, "On-Demand Mobility: Goals, Technical Challenges, and
Roadmaps," Available:
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON TRANSPORTATION ELECTRIFICATION