P1 Define and Compare The Different Roles and Characteristics of A Leader and A Manager

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 6

P1 Define and compare the different roles and characteristics of a leader and a manager

A leader is the man who guides and directs a team to achieve the desired result of the
organization. Business leaders do a lot for the firm. He needs to keep all the responsibilities in
his hand that he needs to perform the best. No business can success without a hardworking and
clever leader head.

On the other side, managers are those who manage every part of their duties and make things
finished properly. A manager is the one who is responsible to administrate an organization or a
team.

Leaders and managers are having so different fundamentals though they might be seemed similar
or close. The roles and characteristics they carry do vary and keep different motives. There can
be some chart description through which their differences can be easily shown.

Differentiating Roles

Roles Leaders Managers


Activities During job performances, Oppositely, managers prefer
leaders have the role to pick “Doing things right”.
the right thing. “Doing the Managers do work with the
right thing” is their intention. handed over works in an
They are always concerned accurate manner to bring out
for the correct concept to be best results.
picked.
Innovation/Administration Leaders are called the Managers do work with the
innovator of an organization. business objectives and they
They invent and highlight do tasks according to that.
their visons and innovates
that.
Process of working Leaders do transformational Managers do the transactional
acts. activities.
Decision making Leaders facilitates the Managers take the decision to
decision and put work with the given work.
responsibilities on mangers. They wait for the directors’

1
facilitation. When they get it,
they feel necessity of making
a decision.
Directing/Planning Leaders are to direct. In accordance with the
directions, these people plan
and that works as guidance to
the lower or bottom level
subordinates.

Differentiating functions of a leader and a manager

Functions Leaders Managers


Organizing The organizing that leaders Requirements are observed
build requires the by managers.
establishment of structures,
hierarchies and relationships
among people and resources.
Goal/Planning Leaders set the goals. Managers do plan according
to the goals thus their desired
obligation can be met.
Controlling Leaders need to face the Managers are controlling the
public, press and all. At the activity and stability of the
same time they need to put subordinates.
control on different levels.
Linking/Staffing Leaders link among different Managers maintain the link
levels of an organization and get guidance from upper
structure. level to direct the lower level.
Managers do staffing here.

M1 Analyze and differentiate between the role of a leader and function of a manager by
effectively applying a range of theories and concepts.
Management by Objectives

2
This is a strategic management model which is aimed to improve performances of a business
organization through objectives defining. Management and employees both agree to this
improvement process. The Model is given below,

Figure: MOB Model

Source: https://www.pinterest.com/pin/669136457108596894/?lp=true

1. Set Corporate Objectives


2. Set and Align Employees Objectives
3. Monitor Performance
4. Evaluate Performance
5. Reward Employee

Classical Management Theories

This theory is based on a belief that the employees only have physical and economic needs from
the organization. There are three major divisions in this theory. They are given below,

3
Scientific Administrative Bureaucratic
Management Principles Organizations

Figure: CMT Model

Source: Self

1. Scientific Management: F.W Taylor was the engineer of scientific model of CMT.
According to this model, each task must be designed, workers must be selected and
trained scientifically. It demands the division of labor and cooperation between the
management and employees.
2. Administrative Principles: This theory came from the investigation made by Henry Fayol,
who was a mining engineer in a company in France. There are five major functions of
this theory according to his model; Planning, coordinating, organizing, controlling and
commanding. Also, 14 principles are developed through this theory.
3. Bureaucratic Organizations: The maximum of this concept was introduced by Max
Weber. This implies a firm characterized by elaboration, rules, impersonal relations,
procedures and fairly rigid hierarchy that is of relationships came from authority
responsibilities. But the thing is bureaucracy is a paper mill. All are written on the paper
and data moves through unlimited channels resulting uncertain and unwanted delays.
Also the communication is reduced.

Behavioral Theory

4
This theory seeks for explaining the human behavior through the analyses of the antecedent and
consequence that are present in an individual environment. Various theories and constructs are
able to be applied to different stages of this theory model. Some elements enriched the
behavioral model that is to be described,

Figure: Behavioral Theory

Source: https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Theory-of-Planned-Behaviour-Ajzen-
1991_fig1_5407720

Contingency Theory

It is an organizing theory which acclaims that no best way is there to organize a corporation,
make decisions or to lead a company leaving contingency theory. This leadership theory was

Capability Personal Traits Task


Leaders
Followers

Situations

Motivation Behavior Structure


Experience Environment

5
developed by Fred Fiedler in 1958 while he was doing a research on leader effectiveness inside a
team or group. Contingency theory is made of three basic variables,

Figure: CT Variables

Source: Self

You might also like

pFad - Phonifier reborn

Pfad - The Proxy pFad of © 2024 Garber Painting. All rights reserved.

Note: This service is not intended for secure transactions such as banking, social media, email, or purchasing. Use at your own risk. We assume no liability whatsoever for broken pages.


Alternative Proxies:

Alternative Proxy

pFad Proxy

pFad v3 Proxy

pFad v4 Proxy