Odin Stone
Odin Stone
Odin Stone
Abstract:
The two principle myths from the Odinic tradition are the Mead of Poetry and the Well of Mimir,
which are also related to the theft of the soma from Indian mythology. The drink attained is one
if inspiration encompassing immortality, poetry and wisdom. The basic elements being the
creation of the liquid, its theft with the killing of its source, then going to a giant who is
beheaded and the secret of the liquid is revealed. This is also associated with the explanation
that the eagle brought this drink of the gods down to mankind. The basic purpose of the myth
was to explain the Moon. In myth the round shape of the Moon is explained as being Odin’s
eye; the phases are either a well, a bowl, or a drinking horn; while images on it are seen as Mimir
with his drinking horn, Heiddraupnir’s Skull, or Dadhyanc’s horse head. The liquid revealed is a
real intoxicating drink in the Indian tradition, while in the Nordic it appears only as a metaphor
for inspiration, albeit a mead. At some point then this mythical drink was equated with
intoxicating drinks.
Timothy J. Stephany
Rochester Institute of Technology
One Lomb Memorial Drive
Rochester, NY 14623-5603
Introduction
The primary myth of the Odinic tradition involves Odin’s theft of the Mead of Poetry as told in
Snorri’s Edda, however reference to the same episodes also occurs in ‘Havamal’. Although this
is well known, in the mythology the mead is also linked to the use of the runes and to Mimir, the
Well’s guardian. It has also been noted by scholars that there is a direct association between the
theft of the Mead by Odin in Norse mythology and the theft of the soma by Indra in Indian
mythology. Taking these together it may be possible to establish details in the original myth, and
show how it varied in time and place to form the details that were eventually recorded.
Although there is no detailed myth concerning Mimir and Odin, there are details that are
interspersed and even an account of how Mimir lost his head in “Ynglinga Saga”. That this latter
episode is not mentioned in Snorri’s Edda implies it is nothing more than a literary attempt by
Snorri himself to explain these unexplained events. Given the absence of any other direct
references, this has been used as the proxy myth about Mimir’s beheading. However, there is
also a myth that appears to recall the original telling, this being Odin’s visit to the wise giant
Vafthrudnir.
The story of the Mead occurs in two distinct versions, one in each Edda. Snorri’s version is by
far the most complete and even shows signs of having been a blending from different stories into
a coherent whole. In both of these versions Odin takes the name of Bolverk, but their details also
2
match, such as references to Fialar and Gunnlod and drilling through the cave wall. The version
The wise Kvasir (fermented juice) is formed for the peace treaty between the Aesir and the
Vanir. Kvasir is killed by the dwarfs Fialar and Galar, who blend his blood into the Mead
“whoever drinks from which becomes a poet and scholar” (Sturluson 1987: 62). They put it into
two pots, Son (amends) and Bodn (vessel), and the cauldron Odrerir (intoxicating). The dwarfs
then have a visit from the giant Gilling who drowns when their boat capsizes, and they kill his
wife by dropping a millstone on her head. So Gilling’s son Suttung (drunk) threatens them with
death and receives the mead in remuneration, which he puts in the mountain Hnitbiorg (clashing
rock), guarded by his daughter Gunnlod (battle-ready). Odin, under the name of Bolverk (evil-
doer), heads out and works for Suttung’s brother Baugi in return for a drink from Suttung’s
mead, but when the time comes Suttung refuses. Odin uses the drill Rati (drill)1 to get into the
mountain to Gunnlod and spends three nights with her for three swigs of the mead.2 With the
mead in his mouth he flies out in the form of an eagle. Suttung pursues him in eagle form but
Odin spits out the mead into containers the Aesir have put out to receive it. Some of this escapes
The phrases used for the word ‘poetry’ largely reflect this same story:
Kvasir’s blood and dwarfs’ ship, dwarfs’ mead, giants’ mead, Suttungi’s mead, Odin’s mead, Aesir’s mead,
recompense for giants’ father, liquid of Odrerir and Bodn and Son and their contents, liquid of Hnitbiorg,
Odin’s booty and find and cargo and gift. (Sturluson 1987: 70)
1
In India ‘rati’ means sexual pleasure, and the Hindu Rati is its goddess.
2
This is referred to in Kormak’s Saga when the poet says: Let me not be forced into silence by scoundrels; I’m
being charged for a daughter’s gift; but still I’ll keep paying Odin his due. (Whaley 2002: 53) The ‘daughter’s gift’
here is of course a reference to Gunnlod giving the mead.
3
Snorri adds in “Skaldskaparmal” that the Mead of Poetry was made in the cauldron Odrerir
(Sturluson 1987: 72). The inclusion of names for other pots holding the mead, Bodn and Son, by
Snorri suggest that these might have been from a different rendering of the tale.3
The version in the Poetic Edda includes the use of the drill to get away from Gunnlod’s cave.
in Suttung’s hall.
This reference to Odrerir is here a reference to the Mead itself, and certainly reflected in the
name, which means ‘what brings intoxication’ (Simek 1993: 250). The eagle and Kvasir, the
3
There is a passing resemblance too between the words Son and Soma.
4
source of the mead in Snorri’s version, are absent here, but this does not mean they were
sleeping, sun-radiant;
5
a bitch I found then tied on the bed
The Billing referred to here appears to be another spelling of Gilling, the giant killed by Fialar
and Galar. A phrase for the Mead of Poetry is “Billing’s son’s drink” (Sturluson 1987: 116),
also suggesting that the story of how Odin came to possess the Mead referred to here is a slightly
The alternate myth referred to in the Poetic Edda might have followed this sequence: A giant
or dwarf named Fialar was possessor of the mead Odrerir in the vessel Bodn, but because Fialar
had been responsible for Billing’s death, was forced to give it to Billing’s wife. Odin first visited
Fialar then Billing’s widow, but was frustrated. The mead went to Suttung, so Odin made
promises to him and proposed to his daughter Gunnlod. On their wedding night, she was willing
to let him have a single drink of the mead. After taking it all in one draught, Odin made his way
out through the stone wall by the use of a drill, and the giants searched for him high and low.
6
Mimir the Giant4
Snorri mentions that the root of Yggdrasill among the frost giants “is where Mimir’s well is,
which has wisdom and intelligence contained in it, and the master of the well is called Mimir”
(Sturluson 1987: 17). In the story “Fiolsvinnsmal” within Svipdasmal a tree is called Mimameid
(Mimi’s tree) and would seem to be Yggdrasill (Simek 1993: 216). Here the giant is called
Fiolsvidr (knows-much), which is an epithet for Mimir. Mimi’s tree is similar to Hoddmimir’s
Brimir, another primal giant, was also to live in the underworld drinking in his beer-hall in
Okolnir (uncold place), perhaps a warm place in the cold north. It also recalls the Rig Veda’s
reference to Yama: Beneath the tree with beautiful leaves where Yama drinks with the gods,
there our father, the head of the family, turns with longing to the ancient ones. (O’Flaherty 1981:
55) This idea of a primal giant sitting under a tree and drinking is thus a common mythological
image. The tree would lie in the north, at the axis of the stars, where the world of the dead was
thought to be.5
The story of Odin’s drink from the Well of Mimir is the other distinct mythical event in the
Odinic tradition. The origin of this comes from the Moon: the ‘Man in the Moon’ is the giant
himself and its phases mark it as a well. Mimir’s Well is also identical with the Well of Fate, as
both represent the Moon. The verse “The sons of Mim are at play and Fate catches fire at the
4
In Snorri’s Edda it seems the term for heaven ‘storm-Mimir’ means rain, and ‘winter-Mimir’ means ice, and the
term for a sword ‘flesh-Mimir’ means blood. So the name Mimir is used as a substitute for ‘water’.
Mimir’s name also arises in the German river Mimling and the Swedish river Mimeså near Mimessjö
(MacCulloch 1964: 169). Grimm writes: “It is the vulgar belief in Norway, that whenever people at sea go down, a
söedrouen (sea sprite) shews himself in the shape of a headless old man”. (Grimm 2004: 491)
The name also appears as the master smith who made incredible swords with special powers: Mimir in Thidriks-
saga, Miming in Saxo, and Mime the old in the German hero-saga Biterolf (MacCulloch 1964: 169), although there
is no direct connection to the giant here.
5
Even in Greek mythology the axis of the sky, held up by Atlas, was in Hyperborea. There Hercules went to seek
the golden apples and took them after slaying the tree’s guardian snake. (Apollodorus, p. 83)
7
ancient Giallar-horn” (Larrington 1999: 10) seems to be speaking of the Well of Fate (Urd)
catching fire, indicating also that this and the Well of Mimir were interchangeable. Snorri
includes a quotation about Weird’s Well (Urd’s Well) that says “Weird rose from the well”
(Sturluson 1987: 121), which intimates Urd and Mimir were the same.
The only tale directly relating to Mimir is not told in either of the Eddas, but is rather a part of
Snorri’s other work, Heimskringla, regarding the exchange of hostages after the war between the
The Vanes gave them their highest men, Niord the Wealthy and his son Frey, and the people of Asaland in
return gave the man called Haenir, whom they thought well fitted to be a leader, being a big and handsome
man. With him they sent Mimir, the wisest of men, and the Vanes in return gave the wisest of their men
called Kvasir, and when Haenir came to Vanaheim he was chosen as leader and Mimir gave him every
advice. But when Haenir was at the thing or at gatherings, where any difficult matter came before him, then
he always answered the same (unless Mimir was present), “Now get the counsel of others”, said he. Then the
Vanes had a suspicion that the Asaland people had played them false in the exchange of men. They therefore
took Mimir and beheaded him and sent his head to the Asaland people. Odin took the head, smeared it with
such herbs that it could not rot, quoth spells over it and worked such charms that it talked with him and told
That this myth does not appear in Snorri’s Edda means that it was not among the original
mythographic material used for its composition. That it is also not referred to elsewhere is also
important, as the most palpable explanation is that it was itself a literary invention of Snorri
himself. However, even if it was not his invention, there is good reason to believe that it was not
8
The myth “Vafthrudnismal” (Vafthrudnir’s Sayings) presents the tale of Odin’s visit to a wise
giant in a contest in which they wager one another’s heads on the outcome of their competition.
in my hall?
Although the giant’s name given is Vafthrudnir (great riddler) this might be another epithet for
Mimir. The hall Odin arrives at is one that belongs to Im’s father, either implying that
9
Vafthrudnir is Im’s father or that Im is Vafthrudnir. If it means that Im is his name, this too
could be equivalent to Mim. Of further relevance is that Vafthrudnir like Mimir is a wise giant
and that he and Odin both wager their heads, suggesting that the fate of Vafthrudnir is the same
son of Midvidnir.’
Given that Sokkmimir (deep Mimir) is Mimir6, then Odin claims responsibility for having slain
the wise giant himself, thus drawing an even further identification between the two (even though
in Vafthrudnir’s myth he goes by Gagnrad and not Svidur or Svidrir). In addition, Sokkmimir’s
father’s name ‘Midvidnir’ could mean ‘mead robber’ (miod-vitnir) (Simek 1993: 215). So in the
same way Suttung took the mead and set his daughter as guardian, so might Miodvitnir have
placed his son Sokk-mimir to guard it, though there is nothing to verify this.
This does not imply that the Vafthrudnir myth itself is of ancient origin, rather it contains a
wide sample of mythological material that was likely composed later rather than earlier.
6
Sokkmimi is also referred to in ‘Ynglinga Saga’, where he is used as a generic name for a giant (Sturlason 1990:
9).
10
Likewise, in “Sigrdrifumal” (Song of Sigrdrifa), a certain drink is implied to have been the
inspiration for the carving of runes, but it is said to have come from the skull of Heiddraupnir
Hropt himself is Odin and seems to have drunk mead from the Well of Mimir. Mim too appears
as the one who teaches Odin how the runes are to be used.7 This also includes other references
to the Moon, such as the skull visible on its surface and seeing the Moon itself as a drinking horn
(which explains the origin of the Moon’s phases for the same reason a well would explain them).
7
Odin is referred to as ‘Mim’s friend’, but because he consults him, not because he cut off his head. (This reference
is only made as Mim and not as Mimir.)
11
The reference to Brimir’s sword relates back to the giant named in “Voluspa” and even
without an explanation implies that Brimir might have been a giant equivalent to Ymir, killed by
(Larrington 1999: 5)
Whoever Brimir was, he was certainly attested to have been dead and residing at his beer-hall in
Hel.
(Larrington 1999: 9)
Thus in this version, Odin does not attain a drink from the well through a sacrifice of his eye, but
because he got access by beheading its guardian with Brimir’s sword. This also equates with the
implications of “Vafthrudnismal”. Then after Odin learns the meaning of the runes, the mead
All [the runes] were shaved off, those which were carved on,
12
and sent on wandering ways;
they are among the Aesir, they are among the elves,
The stories of “Sigdrifumal” and “Havamal” compare in this manner: in the first Odin takes a
drink from the Well of Mimir to learn the runes, then gets advice from wise Mim’s head to learn
how to use them, in the second Odin learns the runes from hanging on the World Tree to retrieve
them from the Otherworld, then drinks the Mead of Poetry to learn how to use them. Also there
is the myth of the Mead of Poetry where the runes are not even mentioned. This implies three
distinct Odinic variations, but there is no way to learn from where each originated or how far
Odin’s source of wisdom was the Moon (his sacrificed eye in a well) with the Sun being his
remaining eye that traverses the sky. The Well is thus tied to the soma of Indian mythology in
the Rig Veda: Here I saw your highest form eager for nourishment in the place of the cow. As
soon as a mortal gets the food that you enjoy, the great devourer of plants awakens him.
(O’Flaherty 1981: 87) Here the horse (Sun) goes to the place of the cow (Moon) from where he
attains what brings man great wisdom or awareness. This “devourer of plants” seems to be the
13
cow, who is the Moon, and might refer to a drink of inspiration found there.8 In addition the
Moon is called Soma, and the waxing and waning is likened to the soma bowl filling and
In Indian myth, the intoxicating drink soma was known as the “well of immortality”. It was
attained by Indra from his father Tvastr while its secret was held by Dadhyanc. Indra speaks to
his mother of the theft of the soma: In Tvastr’s house Indra drank the Soma worth a hundred
cows, pressed in the two bowls.10 (O’Flaherty 1981: 142) Dadhyanc yielded to tell the Asvins
the secret only to have Indra cut off his horse head, which then fell into a lake, where it
continued to prophesy.11 This horse head, like Mim’s head, is visible on the Moon, as shown in
Figure 1.
There is a reference in “Havamal” of Odin having become drunk both at Fialar’s and
Gunnlod’s dwellings. Here Odin is like Indra, who boasts of having gotten drunk from the soma
(Keith 1964: 20). The similarity of the names Tvastr and Kvasir is also striking. Given that the
story of Kvasir arising from a peace treaty is a later invention, it does not refute the identification
of the two as deriving from the same character. Kvasir himself seems best described as the god
of fermentation, a likely source for both the mead and the soma, though his origin might well go
8
This may provide an association between the Moon and the Indian Dadhyanc, whose name means ‘light milk’.
9
Soma in this regard is related to Heimdall (Hama), who is a moon god, and also with Haenir through their
association with fluid and their similar epithets. Soma is also similar to the Syrian drink Haoma. There is good
reason to speculate that they all arise from the same source.
10
That it is made from two bowls is rather reminiscent of the twin pots Son and Bodn.
11
The myth tells how Indra threatened that if Dadhyanc told the secret to anyone else that he would cut off his head.
The Asvins then replace his head with a horse’s head, so when Dadhyanc tells them about the soma, Indra cuts off
the horse’s head and the Asvins then restore his former head. (O’Flaherty 1981: 185) The Asvins (and their
association with the horse cult) might be a latter addition to an older myth where it was Indra who received the
secret in this way.
14
Figure 1.
Dadhyanc’s horse head visible on the Moon
Although soma is a drink of expansion rather than of wisdom they are both drinks of
inspiration. However, the soma was presumably a real intoxicating drink that was known to the
composers of the Rig Veda, while the Mead is merely a metaphor, without suggestion that it
The story then involves the eagle, who brings the soma down from the heavens. When speaking
‘O Maruts, the bird shall be supreme above all birds, the swift-flying eagle above all eagles, since by his own
driving power that needs no chariot wheels, with his powerful wings he brought to man the oblation loved by
the gods.’
Fluttering as he brought it down, the bird swift as though shot forth on the wide path; swiftly the eagle
came with the honey of Soma and won fame for that.13 Stretching out in flight, holding the stem, the eagle
brought the exhilarating and intoxicating drink from the distance. Accompanied by the gods, the bird
clutched the Soma tightly after he took it from that highest heaven. (O’Flaherty 1981: 129)
12
The original mythical drink of the gods might later have been associated with real fermented drinks.
13
Soma is here and elsewhere described as being honey, like a mead.
15
The eagle is also to have come from a “hundred iron fortresses” (O’Flaherty 1981: 129),
escaping with the soma and carrying the god Indra, which more closely matches the story of
Odin.
As the eagle came shrieking down from heaven, and as they led the bringer of abundance down from there
like the wind, as the archer Krsanu, reacting quickly, aimed down at him and let loose his bowstring, the
eagle bearing Indra brought him down like Bhujyu from the summits of heaven, stretching out in swift flight.
Then a wing feather fell in mid-air from the bird as he swooped on the path of flight.14 (O’Flaherty 1981:
129-130)
The theft of the soma is thus related both to the concept of the Mead of Poetry and Mimir’s Well.
It ties them together as being both alternate versions of the same mythic episode, principally
Gunnlod
Since the story of the soma and Mimir’s well are related to the Moon, and the story of the Mead
is related to these, it would seem that there might be something the Moon might provide in
explaining the story of Gunnlod. The episodes include Odin’s transgression into Hnitbiorg and
leaving Gunnlod after he attains the mead. Hnitbiorg means ‘clashing rock’ and relates well to a
mountain that opens and closes (Simek 1993: 154). This in a sense could relate to the phases of
the Moon, that appear to open and close with regularity. Then when they are fully open at the
14
This might relate to something real, such as an explanation for the Morning Star.
16
time of the full moon, then the image seen today as the ‘lady reading’ may have been seen as
Gunnlod weeping, holding the empty bowl, with the hole from which Odin escaped over her
shoulder. This is shown in Figure 2. The original tellers would have pointed this out to show
Figure 2.
Gunnlod within Hnitbiorg (the Moon)
(holding empty bowl, with drill-hole behind)
Conclusion
As there is no specific myth about Odin’s sacrifice, the sequence of events must be based upon
details within the myths that are then conjoined. The creation was initially by or from Kvasir.
Mim’s father robs the mead and puts his son Mim to guard it. Odin then subsequently goes there
and wins it back, sacrificing his eye or beheading Mim, and thus learning the wisdom. Then the
The stories of the Mead of Poetry and the Well of Mimir are tied together in the tellings of the
myths in India. Indra’s father Tvastr is the source of the soma, who is killed by Indra and the
soma is drunk. He then goes to Dadhyanc who tells its secret of the soma, but Indra cuts off his
17
horse head which falls into a lake. Then it is the ‘swift-flying eagle’ who brings this drink of the
gods down to mankind. This is then basically the same story in three parts: creation, theft, and
Figure 3.
Mythologic comparison of the myth concerning
the theft of the gods’ drink
(The chronology here is imprecise.)
Tvastr (Indra’s father) is the source of the Kvasir is the source of the Mead Odin’s uncle is the source of the rune-
soma spells
Indra takes the soma Fialar makes the Mead (Mim’s father steals the mead)
Indra goes to Dadhyanc Odin goes to the giant Suttung Odin goes to the giant Mim
Indra beheads Dadhyanc Odin beheads Mim (& sacrifices his eye)
Indra learns the secret from Dadhyanc Odin learns the secret (of the runes) from
Mim’s head
Indra drinks the soma Odin drinks the Mead Odin drinks from the Well of Mimir
The eagle takes the soma (and Indra) Odin escapes as an eagle with the Mead
The eagle brings soma to men Some of the Mead escapes to men The mead and runes are scattered to all
The first part of the Indian myth resembles the story of Mimir’s Well, while the latter dealing
with the bringing of the soma to humanity is more like the Mead of Poetry story. It could be that
either the two stories were separated out in Europe or combined together in India. Either way,
there is enough evidence to appreciate the close relationship between Indian and Nordic myth.
The mead of inspiration brings both poetry and wisdom, while a drink from Mimir’s well grants
wisdom. Although the soma is a drink of immortality, it arises out of an ecstatic state
18
experienced upon consumption, giving one the sense of expansion and endlessness. Thus it is
So the Mead would have been at some time the same as the liquid in Mimir’s Well, the Moon.
The basis of the myth then arises from a basic explanation for the Moon itself: its round shape,
its phases, and the images on its face. Thus in Nordic myth these things became Odin’s eye, a
well or a horn, and Mimir with his drinking horn or Heiddraupnir’s skull. In Indian myth it was
the soma bowl and Dadhyanc’s horse head in a lake. This implies that the common myth was
only later linked to recognized objects (or that these assignments changed through time), which
is why the general points equate more than the specific details.
Sources
Apollodorus. The Library of Greek Mythology. 1997. Trans. Robin Hard. New York: Oxford,
1998
Grimm, Jacob. Teutonic Mythology. 1883, 1888. Trans. Ed. James Steven Stallybrass. 4 vols.
Keith, A. Berriedale & Carnoy, Albert J. Mythology of All Races. Vol VI (Indian, Iranian).
Larrington, Carolyne, trans. The Poetic Edda. 1996. New York: Oxford, 1999.
19
MacCulloch, J. A. Mythology of All Races. Vol II (Eddic). New York : Cooper Square
Publishers, 1964.
Simek, Rudolf. Dictionary of Northern Mythology. 1984. Trans. Angela Hall. Cambridge: D.
S. Brewer, 1993.
Stephany, Timothy J. High Gods of the Northland. Rochester, New York, 2006.
Sturlason, Snorre. Heimskingla or The Lives of the Norse Kings. 1932. Trans. A. H. Smith. Ed.
Sturluson, Snorri. Edda. Trans. Ed. Anthony Faulkes. London: Everyman, 1987.
Whaley, Diana, int. Sagas of Warrior-Poets. Thorsson, Örnólfur, ed. London: Penguin, 2002.
20