Urban Landscape As Palimpsest
Urban Landscape As Palimpsest
Urban Landscape As Palimpsest
net/publication/299488320
CITATIONS READS
13 2,348
3 authors, including:
Daniel-Gabriel Vâlceanu
Institutul Naţional de Cercetare-Dezvoltare în Construcţii, Urbanism şi Dezvoltare Teritorială Durabilă
11 PUBLICATIONS 62 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Daniel-Gabriel Vâlceanu on 05 August 2016.
Daniel-Gabriel VÂLCEANU
Scientific Researcher, PhD (Geography), N.R.D.I URBAN-INCERC,
Urbanproiect Branch, Department of Research-Development in Habitat and
Architecture, e-mail: danielvalceanu@yahoo.com
Robert-Alexandru KOSA
Editor, Anthropologist, N.R.D.I URBAN-INCERC, Incerc Branch,
Specialized Technical Library, e-mail: kroberto76@yahoo.com
Diana-Georgiana TĂMÎRJAN
Translator, Philologist, N.R.D.I URBAN-INCERC, Urbanproiect Branch,
Department of Research-Development in Habitat and Architecture,
e-mail: diana.tamirjan@yahoo.com
Abstract. The current urban morphology and the identity building of the city
construction can be designed as a palimpsest; the spatial development
stages of urban systems represent the result of their evolution over
time. The characteristics of urban palimpsest depend mainly on the
emergent factors that influenced the territorial dynamics and the
configuration of urban bodies. Urban life and its quality are directly
influenced by spatial and temporal factors of the city evolution. For
this reason the study aims to achieve a research to explain the concept
of urban palimpsest and the current morphology of urban tissue
because they are products of landscape transformations along the
history. The current knowledge on urban palimpsest characteristics is
very important and useful to plan the current and future evolution of
urban systems. The case study presents a vast view on the history of
spatial development and urban system as well as a dynamics of the
landscape interconditioned by the elements of such development in
the context of reference historical eras.
1
Urbanism. Arhitectură. Construcţii • Vol. 5 • Nr. 4 • 2014 •
2
Urban landscape as palimpsest • D.-G. Vâlceanu, R. A.
Urbanism
Kosa, D.-G. Tămîrjan
The term is used in urban literature and The 90s printed materials on geography
nowadays it is used also in geographic analyze the physical landscape as
literature, specifically in urban geography palimpsest generated by multiculturalism
where it is explain the spatial and (Daniels, 1988; Barnes and Duncan, 1992).
temporal development of a town, the
current urban morphology and the In other words, urban landscape as space
physical geography(geomorphology) that of social interaction can be interpreted and
describe the landscape and its analyzed as palimpsest taking into account
neighborhood. the cultural diversity and ethnic categories
(Van Aschee and Teampău, 2009).
According to Bloom (2002), the landscape
as palimpsest is one in which the Thus, the identity construction of Dej city
different relief forms haven’t the same was carried out in different historical eras
characteristics (age, appearance, etc.). and it has the impression of different
cultures.
The impact of human actions on
landscape can be observed at the levels of In the field of town planning, Assargård
urban ecosystems, transport routes, (2011) try to develop an urban landscape
human settlements and architecture/ methodology; he wants to classify
archetypes (Bailey, 2007). palimpsest as one of many strategies
using a stratified layer.
Chevallier (1976) defines landscape as a
result of a dynamic yet instable The stratification is described as a
combination of physical, biological and structuring model for different place
anthropologic interrelated elements that components, the landscape describes a
form a unique and inseparable ensemble global stratification of different urban
in continuous evolution. systems; the natural, cultural and
historical perspectives are clearly defined.
Zonneveld (1979) defines landscape by an
ecological perspective : “part of the space In 1980, the palimpsest concept was used
on the Earth's surface, consisting of a for the first time by the American
complex of systems formed by the architect Peter Einsenman; this concept
activity of rock, water, air, plants, animals was used in urban renewal projects of
and man and that by its physiognomy brownfields in Western Europe and
forms a recognizable entity”. North America (Krinke, 2006).
3
Urbanism. Arhitectură. Construcţii • Vol. 5 • Nr. 4 • 2014 •
period of time (Walker and Bamback, and temporal evolution of the urban
1971). system;
− To identify the stages of reference
Physical transformations that occur in the urban system evolution in Romania –
urban systems are the result of socio- Dej city – and of territorial
economic, political and technological transformations over reference
processes and different values, styles and historical eras with direct implications
cultures that can be found in the current on landscape.
landscape morphology.
2. Methodology
The role of time in the evolution of land The city can be considered as a
and landscape as palimpsest is very sedimentary layer formed during a long
important to identify the profile and period of time (Min, 2009).
current urban image.
The characteristics of each place are the
Urban space is treated, based on the result of the transposition on time into
concept of urban topography as space.
palimpsest, as a scroll where buildings
give identity to space and provide the From the historical point of view, the
premises of past, present and future method used in the analysis of the urban
development (Samuelson, 2008). landscape consists in observing the spatial
transformations and image of the complex
1.2. Study objectives urban system. The current image of the
This study aims to analyze the palimpsest Romanian medieval cities is the product of
concept and how it is used in comparison a complex of historical, social, economic
with the urban palimpsest and environmental factors.
transformations and to emphasize its
potential as theoretical and practical tool Over time, the morphology and urban
used in territorial analysis of the architecture are two important elements
reference urban system - Dej in the transformation process of urban
Municipality. image.
The main objective of this study is to In the context of the continuous territorial
develop public policies and identify development of urban systems, local
planning, design and management identity becomes a defining peculiarity
methods of urban landscape in order to for each city.
increase the attractiveness of urban
environment to the potential investors; a The reference architectural elements for
sustainable urban development and the local identity were destroyed in certain
quality of life of resident population. key stages during the urbanization
The specific objectives of the study are: process.
− To clear up the palimpsest concept
and its utilization in the field of town Urban landscape as palimpsest can be
planning and architecture, in spatial analyzed from the perspective of urban
and temporal context; transformation in time and space, and are
− How the concept of palimpsest can be important for the configuration of its
used as a research tool of the spatial current image.
4
Urban landscape as palimpsest • D.-G. Vâlceanu, R. A.
Urbanism
Kosa, D.-G. Tămîrjan
5
Urbanism. Arhitectură. Construcţii • Vol. 5 • Nr. 4 • 2014 •
6
Urban landscape as palimpsest • D.-G. Vâlceanu, R. A.
Urbanism
Kosa, D.-G. Tămîrjan
monuments have led to a situation where built in 15th century, and an old city. The
the urban heritage conservation becomes city central area is a mix of styles, from
a real problem for the local authority Gothic style (Reformed church) to neo
(Karimi, 2000). renaissance style (central buildings
Ensemble built by architect Reményik
Their responsibility as future experts in Károly project in 1987; Prefecture Palace,
preserving historic spaces is to identify 1987) and neo baroque style (National
the current morphology factors of the College Andrei Mureşanu”, 1900).
space; to recognize and respect the social
and cultural history of urban systems
(Assi, 2000). The old city is a central core
round which the new urban morphology
is defined (Fig. 6).
Revitalizing the cultural heritage and The Millennium Monument (Fig. 8) and
enhancing its value become priorities for Soviet Monument (Fig. 9) are two
the sustainable, balanced, coherent and symbols of the historical central area of
inclusive development of cities with a Dej city; in the current morphology of the
rich historical past. local landscape, these monuments can
not be found.
Compared with scientific approach of
palimpsest concept, the current scientific
approach is base d on the changes of the
urban image over time, as reflected in
the configuration of the studied city (Fig.
7).
7
Urbanism. Arhitectură. Construcţii • Vol. 5 • Nr. 4 • 2014 •
8
Urban landscape as palimpsest • D.-G. Vâlceanu, R. A.
Urbanism
Kosa, D.-G. Tămîrjan
Urban Forms in the Age of Tourism, innovative design, Journal of Urban Design
Routledge mot E F & N Spon, New York, 9(2):225-248.
pp. 1-34. Graburn N. H. H. (2001), Learning to consume: what is
Assargård H. (2011), Landscape urbanism: from a heritage and when is it traditional, in:
methodological perspective and a conceptual AlSayyad, N. (Editor), Consuming Tradition,
framework, Master’s thesis, Swedish Manufacturing Heritage: Global Norms and
University of Agricultural Sciences, Urban Forms in the Age of Tourism,
Department of Urban and Rural Routledge mot E F & N Spon, New York.
Development, Uppsala. Holling C.S., Orians G. (1971), Toward an Urban
Assi E. (2000), Searching for the concept of Ecology, Bulletin of the Ecological Society
authenticity: implementation guidelines, of America 52:2–6.
Journal of Architectural Conservation Huber A. (2002), The city over time. Incursion into
6(2):60-69. the local history [in Hungarian], Editura
Azimzadeh M., Bjur H. (2007), The urban Gloria, Cluj, ISBN 973-8267-07-2, p. 7.
palimpsest: the interplay between the Jansen-Verbeke M. (1998), Tourismification of
historically generated layers in urban spatial Historical Cities, Annals of Tourism
system and urban lyfe, Proceedings, 6th Research 25(3):739-742.
International Space Syntax Symposium, Karimi K. (2000), Urban conservation and spatial
Technical University Faculty of transformation: preserving the fragments or
Architecture, Istanbul, pp. 1-14. maintaining the “spatial spirit”, International
Bailey G. (2007), Time perspectives, palimpsests and Journal of Urban Design 5(3):221-231.
the archaeology of time, Journal of Kádár J. (1900), Solnoc Dăbâca shire monography [in
Anthropological Archaeology 26:198-223. Hungarian], Editura Demeter and Kiss,
Barnes T.J., Duncan J.S. (1992), Writing Worlds. Vol. III, Dej, pp. 6-219.
Discourse, Text and Metaphor in the Khirfan L. (2010), Traces on the p alimpsest: Heritage
Representation of Landscape. Routledge, and the urban forms of Athens and
London. Alexandria, Cities 27:315-325.
Bloom A.L. (2002), Teaching about relict, no-analog Kjerrgren L. (2011), Layers of Land. The Palimpsest
landscapes, Geomorphology 47:303-311. Concept in Relation to Landscape
Borzan S.C. (2012), History and Economy. From the Architecture, Bachelor’s project at the
“Uprising from the Bridge over Someş” to the Department of Urban and Rural
communist aggregate works [in Romanian], Development Swedish University of
Editura Texte, Dej, ISBN 978-606-92392-8, Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala.
pp. 5-386. Kostof S. (1991), The City Shaped: Urban Patterns
Chan W.Y., Ma S.Y. (2004), Heritage preservation and Meanings through History, Fifth
and sustainability of China’s development, Printing 2004 eds. Bulfinch Press, Time
Sustainable Development 12(1):15-31. Warner Book Group, NYC.
Chevallier R. (1976), Le paysage palimpseste de Krinke R. (2001), Overview: design practice and
l'histoire: pour une archéologie du paysage, manufactured sites, in: Kirkwood N. (Ed.),
Mélanges de la Casa de Velázquez 12:503- Manufactured sites, Spon Press, London.
510. Krinke R. (ed.) (2005), Contemporary Landscapes of
Crang M. (1996), Envisioning urban histories: Bristol Contemplation, Ed. Routledge Taylor &
as palimpsest, postcards, and snapshots, Francis Group, London and Ne w York,
Environment & Planning A 28:429–452. pp. 201.
Crow T., Brown T., De Young R. (2006), The Larkham P.J. (1996), Conservation and the City,
Riverside and Berwyn experience: Contrasts Routledge, NYC.
in landscape structure, perceptions of the Luck M., Wu J. (2002 ), A gradient analysis of urban
urban landscape, and their effects on people, landscape pattern: a case study from the
Landscape and Urban Planning 75(3- Phoenix metropolitan region, Arizona, USA,
4):282-299. Landscape Ecology 17:327-339.
Daniels S. (1988), Landscape, Image, Text, Lynch K. (1981), Good City Form, ninth ed. The
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Feilden B. M., Jokilehto J. (1998), Management Martin A.J., Warner B.S. (1997), Urban
Guidelines for World Cultural Heritage Sites, conservation: sociable, green, and affordable,
second ed. ICCROM, Rome. in: Nassauer J.I. (Editor), Placing Nature,
Gospodini A. (2004), Urban morphology and place Culture and Landscape Ecology, Island
identity in European Cities: built heritage and Press, Washington DC, pp. 109–122.
9
Urbanism. Arhitectură. Construcţii • Vol. 5 • Nr. 4 • 2014 •
Mânzat G. (2006), Dej city monography [in Branding: Image Building and Building Images,
Romanian], Second edition, Editura Astra- NAI Uitgevers Publishers, Rotterdam.
Dej, Dej, ISBN 973-86591-6-7, pp. 10-11. Tiesdell S., Taner O., Heath T. (1996), Revitalizing
Min K. Y. (2009), An analogy of palimpsest as a Historic Urban Quarters. Architectural Press, an
strategy transforming urban structure into Imprint of Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford.
architectural discourse – focused on Dominique Tyler N. (2000), Historic Preservation: An
Perrault’s architecture of strata, in: 4th Introduction to Its History, Principles, and
Conference of the International Forum on Practice, Second edi tion, W.W. Norton &
Urbanism, Amsterdam. Company, New York.
Mol Térkép (2014), Plan of Dej and Ocna Dej van Synghel K. (2002), City branding for eight Dutch
municipalities [in Hungarian] cities: from conceptual to literal image
(1830),http://mol.arcanum.hu/terkep/o building, in: Vermeulen M, Florian B,
pt/a101205htm?v=pdf&a=start Mommaas H, Speaks M, van Synghel K
Norberg-Schultz C. (1991), Genius Loci: Towards a (Editors), City Branding: Image Building
Phenomenology of Architecture, Rizzoli, NYC. and Building Images, NAI Uitgevers
Nuryanti W. (1996), Heritage and postmodern tourism, Publishers, Rotterdam.
Annals of Tourism Research 23(2):249–260. Van Aschee K., Teampău P. (2009), Layered
Oke T.R. (1982), The energetic basis of the urban heat encounters: performing multiculturalism and
island, Quarterly Journal of the Royal the urban palimpsest at the “Gateway of
Meteorol ogical Society, 108, pp. 1–24. Europe”, The Anthropology of East
Romanian Parliament (2002), Law no. 451 8 July Europe Review 27(1):7-19.
2002 to ratify the European Landscape Vermeulen M. (2002), The Netherlands, holiday
Convention, adopted on 20 October 2000 in country: introduction, in: Vermeulen M,
Florence, Official Gazette 536(1). Florian B, Mommaas H, Speaks M, van
Pendlebury J. (2009), Conservation in the Age of Synghel K (Eds.), NAI Uitgevers
Consensus, Routledge, New York. Publishers, Rotterdam.
City Hall Dej (2006 ), General Urban Plan [in Walker K. R., Bambach R. K. (1971), The significance
Romanian], S.C. G&T Creator S.R.L., Dej. of fossil assemblages from fine-grained
Rafailaki E. (2006), The implications of the sediments: time-averaged communities,
“palimpsest” of the grids of the main city of Geological Society of America Abstracts
Piraeus on creation, transmission and with Programs 3:783-84.
application of cognitive knowledge, Weng Q., Lu, D. (2009), Landscape as a continuum:
University College of London Bartlett an examination of the urban landscape
School, Msc Built Environment, structures and dynamics of Indianapolis City,
Advanced Architectural Studies, London. 1991–2000, by using satellite images,
Samuelson M. (2008), The urban palimpsest: Re- International Journal of Remote Sensing
presenting Sophiatown, Journal of 30(10):2547–2577.
Postcolonial Writing 44(1):63-75. Wikipedia (2014), Plan of Dej and Ocna Dej
Scazzosi L. (2004), Reading and assessing the municipalities [in Romanian] (1773),
landscape as cultural and historical heritage, http://ro.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fi%C8%99ie
Landscape Research 29(4):335-355. r:Josephinische_Landaufnahme_pg053.jpg
Speaks M. (2002), Individualization without identity, in: Zonneveld I.S. (1979), Land Evaluation and
Vermeulen M., Florian B., Mommaas H., Land(scape) Science, ITC Textbook VII.4
Speaks M., van Synghel K. (Editors), City (Second edition), ITC Enschede, 134 pp.
10