Kamala Dass
Kamala Dass
Kamala Dass
– A PSYCHOLOGICAL APPROACH
Submitted by
J. SUGANYALAKSHMI
(Reg.No.P4333)
DEPARTMENT OF ENGLISH LANGUAGE STUDIES
MADURAI KAMARAJ UNIVERSITY
(University with Potential for Excellence)
MADURAI – 625021
TAMIL NADU
JUNE -2019
1
SYNOPSIS
– A PSYCHOLOGICAL APPROACH
1.0 Introduction
passionately sexual in her literary oeuvre, Everyone wants to express one’s self identity,
emotions, feelings, thoughts, perceptions, artistic sense, profound and trivial ideas through
some means including various art forms such as novel, short story, painting, plays, poetry,
autobiography, short stories, sculpture etc as the modern life of human beings, is becoming
more and more complex in every sense the word, the 20th century, ever in the history of the
human civilization, especially after the two great world wars and after various revolutions
which are both industrial and political in nature, is becoming quirky, zappy and funnier in
one sense and more philosophical and psychological in other ways. Through the various
vicissitudes of life, every stage of man is full of a strange feeling having a touch of esoteric,
The existentialist problem is gripping every man and woman and the advancement of
science is making it more intricate. The psychological and social aspects of human life is
facing ever more challenges and bottlenecks. In this context, a woman’s position is not an
unenviable one given the oppressive forces working against them. Their marginalized
position at home and social ladder make them more vulnerable to all sorts assaults in every
direction. And the suppressed and shackled mind wants to release from the prison of
oppression. Across the world, many women began to break the shackles and began to express
their suppressed feelings and emotions and wanted to express their identity. In India too,
there were many women who attempted to boldly express their identity and one among them
2
is Kamala Das. What did Kamala Das make to come out brazenly and break the social taboo?
What were the obstacles and difficulties she faced? How was the writer ostracized in the Nair
society which is matriarchal basically? And how was she received in the feudal-like society
with her new writings which some termed sexual, obscene, and sometimes pornographically
explicitly and graphically portrayed in her works of poetry, autobiographical novels and short
works of art? Some of these issues have already been dealt with but a relook has become
essential and a revaluation has become critical as new books have been published about her
after her death. And as any canonized literary work needs to be re-evaluated in a new context
to ferret out the inner and hidden meanings as the author intended. Now and then articles and
news items appear in news papers about the creativity of the author. As a scholar, I became
interested in Kamala Das and her works of art which span many decades.
Now, even after 10 years, exactly after a decade, her life story is currently being paid
homage to in two rival biopics that will showcase different aspects of her life – one by Tamil
filmmaker Leena Manimekalai and the other by Malayalam director Kamal which will star
Manju Warrier as Kamala Das. This is really a great way of paying to the homage to one of
the greatest Indian woman author. After reading “The Love Queen of Malabar – Memoir of
a Friendship with Kamala Das” written by Merrily Weisbord, a Canadian writer who
befriended Kamala Das and had a friendship for more than a decade, it could be understood
that the ideas and perceptions Kamala Das had on her life and her literary works have
changed to a level which could be said that mellowness has set in her later life. She is talking
to Ms. Weisborad in freewheeling mode for nearly 10 years after they started a friendship.
Published in 2011 in India, the book reveals the changes from inside out and how she
perceives after the publication of “My Story- An Autobiography” which shook the Indian
literary world with groundbreaking openness. Her frank and no-hold-bar confession in the
3
autobiography stunned the readers for its openness. Merrily Weisbord shrewdly enters into
the heart and mind of Kamala Das, broker a deal for a long term friendship and share their
experiences in which Kamala Das relooks at her life, love and her literary oeuvre. This
seminal work has thrown in more lights on Kamala Das who impulsively and innocently
wrote many things in her autobiography and poetry and other works. After reading the book ,
my interest in her increased and the dormant feeling i had for many years came out and i
decided to explore her works of art again in tandem with new findings about her and her
In this context, it must be admitted that she was one of the writers whose artistic
output such as poetry and novels helped to put Indian writing in English in the world arena.
The seed of Indian Writing in English was sown during the period of the British rule in India.
Now the seed has blossomed into an ever green tree, fragrant flowers and ripe fruits. The
fruits are being tasted not only by the native people, but they are also being 'chewed and
digested' by the foreigners. It happened only after the constant caring, pruning and feeding.
Gardeners' like Tagore, Sri Aurobindo, R.K.Narayan, Raja Rao - to name only a few, looked
after the tender plant night and day. In modern time, it is guarded by a number of writers who
Indian Writing in English, from being a singular and exceptional, rather gradual
native flare - up of geniuses, it has turned out to be a new form of Indian culture and voice in
which India converses regularly. Indian Writers - poets, novelists, essayists, and dramatists
have been making momentous and considerable contributions to world literature since
pre - Independence era, the past few years have witnessed a gigantic prospering and thriving
of Indian English Writing in the global. It has already put an imprint as an independent status
4
in the realm of world Literature. Wide ranges of themes are dealt with in Indian Writing in
English. While this literature continues to reflect Indian culture, tradition, social values and
even Indian history through the depiction of life in India and Indians living elsewhere, recent
Indian English fiction has been trying to give expression to the Indian experience of the
modern predicaments. There are critics and commentators in England and America who
appreciate Indian English novels. Prof. M. K. Naik remarks "one of the most notable gifts of
English education to India is prose fiction for though India was probably a fountain head of
story-telling, the novel as we know today was an importation from the west".
In the long line literary luminaries in Indian Writing in English, Rabindranath Tagore
is a celebrated name in the sphere of English literature. He was born in 1861 and died in the
year 1941 spanning long years of creativity. His creative genius is so much accounting and
his literary output is so much rich and varied that the phrase 'myriad - minded', which
Mathew Arnold had used for Shakespeare, can aptly be used for him also. He won Nobel
Prize for literature in 1913, for his immortal poetic work Gitanjali (1913). Besides being a
great universal poet, the genius Tagore is also a novelist, dramatist, Short - Story writer,
musician, philosopher, painter, educationalist, reformer and critic in every field and had
earned a niche for himself. The setting of his novel is representative and reflective, their
characters are natural, realistic, full - blooded and life - like. The socio - religious culture of
Bengal is brilliantly portrayed in his novels. Through his novels he brings out some of the
problems of the woman of his age. Different kinds of human relations are portrayed and
analyzed through the different social settings. Some of his novels deal with the modern
problems of our society and the interest in them centers round the psychological development
of characters under the compelling stress of circumstances. To his credit, there is a long list of
5
poems and plays, both in Bengali and English which had made his place among the world's
greatest writers.
modernism and feminist statements. The last two decades have witnessed phenomenal
success in feminist writings of Indian English literature. Today is the generation of those
women writers who have money and are mostly western education. Their novels consist of
the latest burning issues related with women as well as those issues that exist in the society
since long. The publishers feel that the literature actually survives because of these types of
bold topics and commercials used by the women novelists. They describe the whole world of
women with simply stunning frankness. Their write - ups give a glimpse of the unexplored
female psyche, which has no accessibility. The majority of these novels depict the
Critiquing about Kamala Das’ poetry is most moving and tortured. There is a sexual
‘brazenness to her persona’, which barely hides her inmost ferment. Credited as the most
outspoken - and even controversial writer, Kamala Das now earned fame as the ‘voice of
women’s sexuality’. Apart from writing in English, Das also wrote under the pen name
Madhavikutty in Malayalam before her conversion to Islam ten years ago . She had not only
established herself as an English writer. Her popularity in Kerala was credited mostly to her
short stories and the autobiographical My Story, which was translated into 15 languages, a
book where she openly discussed her unsatisfactory sexual life with her husband Madhava
Das.
6
While her autobiography My Story gives several descriptions of her own marriage as
unsatisfying and unfulfilling, her poems presented an image of a marriage with lifeless,
empty and dull. Born into a literary family, Kamala Das’ mother, Balamani Amma and Uncle
Nalapat Narayana Menon, were both leading poets. Das began writing only after her early
marriage – only to cope up with – the emotional strain she was undergoing. She was born on
Das once herself said in an interview to the Warrior, "I always wanted love, and if you
don't get it within your home, you stray a little". Though some might label Das as "a
feminist" for her candour in dealing with women's needs and desires, Das, according to many
others has never tried to identify herself with any particular version of feminist activism. Poet
Eunice de Souza claims that Das has "mapped out the terrain for post-colonial women in
social and linguistic terms". Kamala Suraiyya Das had ventured into areas unclaimed by
society and provided a point of reference for her colleagues. She had transcended the role of a
poet and simply embraced the role of a very honest woman. Kamala Das has published many
novels and short stories in English, as well as in Malayalam. Some of her work in English
includes the novel Alphabet of Lust (1977), a collection of short stories called Padmavati,
The Harlot and Other Stories (1992), in addition to five books of poetry: Summer in
Calcutta (1965), The Descendants(1967), The Old Playhouse and Other Poems (1973), The
Anamalai Poems (1985), and Only the Soul Knows How to Sing (1996) - a collection of
poetry with Pritish Nandy (1990) and her autobiography, My Story (1976). Some of her
Dayarikkurippukal (1992). Kamala Das lived alone in her world with feelings of loneliness
and yet she maintained her tradition, the security of her home. She always felt that poetry
7
meant studying life and its objectivity in a very realistic way. Kamala Das died at the
age of 75.
storing the review of related literature about the topic the scholar has chosen for pursing
research in that particular area in order to find out what other scholars have done on the
particular topics and how they had already dealt with it. This component of research would be
a guiding force to the scholar as their ideas would be a sort of guiding force as pointed
earlier. Therefore, the scholar is supposed to give much importance and prepare the ground
before jumping into the other components. In order to prepare and study and review the
related literature, the scholar has go far and wide and attempt to collect as much literatures as
possible leaving no stone unturned otherwise the attempts by the scholar would a repetition
of the research work. Therefore, this has taken particular interests and paid serious attention
to the collection of primary and secondary data about the related literature. One must the
question what is the definition of a review of related literature. It means a relentless search
and evaluation of the available literature in the given subject or chosen topic area. It
documents the state of the art with respect to the subject or topic you are writing about.
This is what Sheryl Sebastian paints about Kamala Das autobiographical story in “My
Story: An Autobiography” which was published in 1973, her autobiography ‘Ente Kadha’
(My Story) was released in Malayalam. It consisted of a compilation of her weekly columns
in Malayalanadu that had already become a sensation across the state. Fifteen years later, it
was translated into English with more text added, many parts rewritten and published with
the title ‘My Story’. Among the major critics on Kamala Das, K.Sachithananthan, is a very
8
important one with his bold views on her literary works. In the beginning of her career itself,
This is how she continues to explore about Kamala Das’ autobiography. The book is
about her personal and professional experiences as a woman in a patriarchal society and her
quest for love in its truest form. Her writing consisted of vivid descriptions of menstruation,
puberty, love, lust, lesbian encounters, child marriage, infidelity and physical intimacy. She
introduced her readers to the concept of female sexuality, a notion that was nonexistent until
then. She talked of her ‘brush with love’ with an eighteen year old girl, right before Das was
about to be married off. She talked of having to look for love ‘outside its legal orbit’ because
she was unhappy in her loveless marriage. She talked with an audacity never seen before as
she wrote unapologetically about everything the conservative Kerala society had managed to
box in for very long. It managed to evoke such a widespread reaction which was equal parts
shock and equal parts adoration that it has become a cult classic in the genre of Indian
autobiographies ever since. On being asked why her book shocked the Malayali audience, she
felt that it never actually did, that they were pretending to be shocked to prove their
‘innocence’. She believed she was merely being vocal about things that had been happening
for years.
In her critical review of Kamala Das, Ms. Sebastian opines that Das went on to
produce what is considered some of the best work in modern Indian literature. Some of her
notable works in English are the novel Alphabet of Lust (1977), the collection of short stories
Padmavati the Harlot and other stories (1992) and a compilation of her poetry Summer in
Childhood), Chandanamarangal (Sandalwood Trees) and many more. Her literary work
9
earned her a lot of recognition and won her numerous accolades. She won the P.E.N.’s Asian
Poetry Prize in 1963, the Kerala Sahitya Academy Award in 1969 for the short story
Thanuppu (Cold) and the National Sahitya Academy Award in 1985. She was also shortlisted
for the Nobel Prize for Literature in 1984. So wide was her reach that much of her work has
been translated into numerous foreign languages including French and German.
Devindra kholi , one of the early critics who assessed the literary of oeuvre of
Kamala Das at the beginning of her writing career, has come out with excellent and incisive
critical analysis all these years. His critical assessment about Kamala Das’ works is being
considered the touchstone for measuring the literary values. In 2011, in a freewheeling
recollections, in the Hindu, Kohli summed up succinctly about Kamala Das and her works
as :
In 1968, 10 years before I first met her, in response to my rather harsh criticism of
some of the poems in The Descendants in comparison with what I considered the
unattained or unattainable love and happiness? The question, “Does the imagination
dwell the most/ Upon a woman won or woman lost?” haunted W. B. Yeats throughout
his poetic career; and Maud Gonne, his unrequited Muse, applauded him for making
“beautiful poetry out of what you call your unhappiness and you are happy in that”.
10
1.8 Merrily Weisbord’s “The Queen of Malabar – A Memoir”
One of the most important books on Kamala Das was published by Merrily Weisbord
in 2010 in Canada and in 2011 in India after the author’s death. The book came to be
necessitated after Merrily Weisbord brokered a friendship deal with Das to share their
experiences each other and have good literary career. Therefore, Merrily Weisbord came to
Kerala and live with the author and Das went to Canada to live with Merrily Weisbord. It was
a wonderful friendship while both of them were widows, writers and had lots of time to share
their experiences as feminists too. The Love Queen of Malabar: Memoir of a Friendship
with Kamala Das presumably the last of the critical analysis in full book length. Earlier there
have been critical essays being done on Kamala Das. There have been re-interpretations,
relooks, reinventions and a kind of rewriting on her literary oeuvre. This particular book The
Love Queen of Malabar: Memoir of a Friendship with Kamala Das raised literary storm by
bringing in new ideas and perceptions which Das shared with Merrily Weisbord especially at
the fag end of her life. Das’ conversion to Islam and her subsequent marriage were surprises to
Merrily Weisbord as she was in dark even though both of them had close relationships for
more than 10 years viz., 1995 -2005. Weisbord’s account and assessment of Kamala Das’ life
and literary works throw new lights which are attention seeking and demand a new look at her
ideas and perceptions. At one point, Das informs Weisbord that she was happy with her
married life, for she enjoyed the safety and security and love and care given by her husband
even though she accused of marital rape during her first night after marriage at a tender age 16.
When asked if she changed her view, she informs her that she had per se safety and security
and love from her husband (The Love Queen of Malabar: Memoir of a Friendship with
11
1.9 Objectives of the Study
1. To re-evaluate the Kamala Das’ literary works viz., her autobiography, poetry
2. To study the Indian social taboos and its impact on women’s life as found in her
Das’ poetry.
4. To explore the writing style and strategies employed by Kamala Das in her
literary oeuvre
5. To explore human relationship and study the implications on the persona of Kamala
Das
6. To critically examine the literary style employed by Das in her novels especially the
7. To study the motifs, symbols and other aspects of Indian culture in the literary works
of Kamala Das
T.S. Eliot wrote that he wrote poetry which is complex and abstract because modern
life is complex and abstract. Kamala Das, even though her style is minimalist, took upon
herself and began to redefine about the human relationship between husband and wife,
between friends, between man vs. Woman in general. The significance of this research work
is that Kamala Das chose many media to express herself through poetry, prose, stories and
even autobiography which she was compelled to write on her deathbed. With various aliases,
Kamala Das has chosen to primarily write poetry to express her feelings, emotions, ideas,
thoughts and passions. She took this mode to express herself identity and thereby free herself
from the shackles of social oppressions and suppressions. In each and every poem or work of
12
art, Kamala Das attempts to articulate the inner meaning of relationship on various plane i.e.,
between man and woman husband and wife, father and mother, father and sons, mother and
sons and vice versa. Between friends and between man and animals and plants, man vs
nature - all kinds of relationship is investigated at various layers. Both on the surface and
subtext level, the authors attempt to uncover the inner feelings and hidden human thoughts.
The psyche of woman with various personas is being expressed in her poetry and other works
of art. The significance of this study is that the interpretations being already advanced need to
be relooked and reinterpretated taking into account the new studies coming out recently. As
the studies have close relationship with the writer, there is much significance in this study to
the effect that new ideas about Kamala Das and Her literary works would come out.
It is true that the works of Kamala Das been researched in a substantial level. To
prove the fact that she is a still great writer to reckon with, her has been in news and in the
academic circle all these years even after her death. However, there has been a new set of
articles, research studies and full length books and biopic Kamala Das which have helped to
stoke the embers of literary values of Kamala Das. Every literature which has undergone
various investigations and measured on various benchmarks, the works of Kamala Das need
to be re-evaluated critically in the light of new publications and old critical analysis.
Everything has a second opinion. Therefore, the scholar felt that the literary oeuvre of
Kamala Das , especially after her death, need to have a relook and her literary works must be
made to be put on the literary anatomical table and dissected to have new ideas and
interpretations about her poetry and autobiography. Of course, Das has been condemned,
praised, ridiculed, reviled, denounced and criticized unfairly and unfairly. Without her, there
is no Indian Writing in English which has come a long way after the British left India
13
leaving a great legacy which is the English language. In the anthology entitled “ Twelve
Modern Indian Poets” edited by Aravind Krishna Mehrotra and published by Oxford
University Press in 1993, she was touted as an indispensable poet in the arena of Indian
literary scene.
One of the main objectives of this dissertation is to look into the odyssey of Kamala
Das to find out herself and self identity. She pours out from her heart her passions, emotions,
feelings, intense thoughts and ideas the raison d’ etre of human life. There is a sort of
existential problem in her inner self and she seeks answers for all. Through her literary works,
she seeks to show who she is, what the constitution of her mind and body and her purpose of
life in this planet. That is why she goes on in many plume de noms including Madhavikutty,
Kamala Das, and Kamala Surayya. And one must remember that she was earlier eulogizing
Lord Krishna in her poems and later she converted to Islam dumping Hinduism. How such a
metamorphosis was possible is big question for any serious reader of Kamala Das. What went
on her mind and what inner thoughts drove her to drastically change her ? As is bound by a
sort of witchcraft , how Kamala Das metamorphosed from one persona into another persona ?
The original text books of Kamala Das were are to be taken up for a close reading to
reassess critically textually and contextually. How she has transformed herself would be
assessed to have relook and rereading of her literary works. All the major secondary sources
would be taken up for discussion including printed books, journals, magazines, dictionaries,
encyclopedia, yearbook, online sources, audio and video sources available in the web and
14
1.14 Hypotheses
1. That Kamala Das needs to be relooked in the context of new articles and books
2. Kamala Das is an author who has been negatively riled for wrong reasons and
3. That Kamala Das was a victim and the victimhood made her to go through
4. All through the poems of Kamala Das, she endeavored to express herself identity
and seek a sort of fulfillment through her works of art especially her poetry.
In this age of digital era, women’s rights group are voicing their concern over the
safety of women and girl children. That many accuse and confess that harassment of
women and children start at home is true in many cases. Women , in spite of their progress
economically and socially, still feel they are being oppressed and suppressed and are not
given equal opportunity like the male children. There are lots of partialities even at home.
Even in highly educated families, women complain of harassment. Now many women are
attempting to come out of their chained self and seek freedom of thought and equal
opportunity. The study of Kamala Das who was a pioneer as feminist and fighter for women
rights through words and deeds would help the womenfolk to have relook at their own lives
and the awareness would help them to adjust according to the context. The beginning of the
21st century is not supportive to women as violence against women and girl children are
15
increasing incessantly. Therefore, the research scholar is confident that the outcome of the
study of Kamala Das about how she struggled against male dominated society and how she
could singlehandedly won the battle would be a great strength to the womenfolk.
In Chapter One the scholar has earmarked for a comprehensive survey of Indian
Writing in English and the role of Kamala Das and her contribution to it. The chapter also
discusses how every human being wants to express emotions, feelings, thoughts, perceptions,
artistic sense, profound and trivial ideas in some ways. There are a slew of ways to express
their identity such as art, photography, dramatic arts, poetry, prose, stories etc., as the
modern life of human beings, is becoming more and more complex in every sense the word,
the 20th century, ever in the history of the human civilization, especially after the two great
world wars and after various revolutions which are both industrial and political in nature, is
becoming quirky, zappy and funnier in one sense and more philosophical and psychological
in other ways. Through the various vicissitudes of life, every stage of man is full of a strange
feeling having a touch of esoteric, exotic, a sense of déjà vu. In the Chapter Two, the review
of related literature is discussed in detail. Furthermore, the significance of the study, the need
for the study, the hypotheses of the dissertation, the social significance, the objectives of the
study are being given. In the Chapter Three, the works of Kamala Das have been taken up
for detailed discussion and the scholar has attempted to have second look at the critical
knowledge about the literary oeuvre of Kamala Das. In the Chapter Four the scholar has
evaluated in the context of new ideas generated after and before the death of Kamala Das.
After the publication of My Story- An Autobiography, lots of new ideas and perspectives
regarding her life and literary oeuvre have come out. The literary works have been taken up
and investigated textually. How she herself has self-contradicted in her persona and literary
16
works and her perspectives on various issues including religion and culture have been put
forth to the readers. All her major literary work has been taken up for investigation
Kamala Das, to her credits, had touched almost all genre viz., poetry, prose, short
stories, novels, autobiography and was bilingual - Malayalam and English. The following
literary works to be taken up for discussion and for reinvestigation are given here in under.
The genre has been taken for revaluation in the order of autobiography, poetry, novel, short
Before Kamala Das, some other Indian women writers have been lauded for their
psychological approach to their characters in their novels and works of art. Among them,
Toru Dutt stands first with her two literary outputs. Even though young, she was able to
create two important novels which were published posthumously. One was written in English
language and another one was written in French language. In both the novels, Dutt had
description even in those olden days was critically acclaimed but unfortunately, she died very
young. Even her own father came to know of her literary value only after her death.
Therefore, in the history of modern India, Toru Dutt could be counted as the first woman
writer to explore female characters’ psychological working of the minds. Meena T. Pillai,
renowned writer and critic, “Kamala Das : On translating My Story “ postulates that an
autobiography is considered a genre of literature where the umbilical cord between the story
and the reality, the writer and the text, the signifier and the signified is yet intact. Kamala Das
is one of the few writers in India who could snip this cord with élan, explicating in the
17
process that all writings are constructed and all realities staged in language. Further, she notes
that James Olney speaks of how it is impossible for an autobiographer to write the image
double of her life instead having to create herself afresh at every moment within the text. This
might be the reason why Das chose not to go for a literal translation of Ente Katha into
English but a creative retelling aiming towards textual equivalence. This is what she has to
say in an interview “.
Mondal asserts that the entire account written in the format of a novel is captivating with all
the intimate details of her childhood followed by her youth and middle age. Born with skin
not so fair–a dusky complexion to be precise, Kamala portrays herself as an inquisitive child
who faced the triggers of race especially when India was gripped by the British imperialists.
Brought up in convent schools Kamala faced discrimination at an early age when the word
“racism” probably did not enter her vocabulary. Struggling through her life amidst the
parochial, patriarchal society, Kamala had to submit when she had to marry an almost brutal
man against her wish, that too, at the tender age of sixteen. Almost molested and raped by
this insensitive man in the name of a husband, Kamala makes an attempt to find happiness in
the world of her own–the world inhabited by the muses of literature enabling her in poetic
and prosaic compositions. It will be wrong to say that she found bliss only in the world of
creation. This is because, frustrated and exasperated by husband’s treatment and doomed in
an unhappy marital bond, Kamala determines herself not to be tied up by the established
norms of a ‘pativrata naari’ (a women devoted solely to one’s husband) and makes every
attempt to respond to the charms bestowed upon her by other men. In this manner, she is
shown to have a string of short and long term relationships, perhaps in on her way of being
the rebel in a society of the late 20th century when traditionalism was the established norm
18
and rebellion, that too among women, was considered a taboo. The scenario has remained
almost the same in the present day to a large extent. Such acts reflect the spirit of boldness
The novel comprising of 50 chapters, consist of self composed poems expressing the
core of meaningfulness or meaninglessness pervading her life at large. The poems occurs in
the last 13 chapters (from chapter 27 onwards) when her life becomes preoccupied with
greater responsibilities and when she starts fearing the presence of the Spiritual power
controlling all our lives, the power whom we are unable to fight with our meager human
prowess. Other than the relationship with her husband at home with whom she starts
inhabiting from an early age, her relationship with her great grandmother is given
prominence. For her, the figure of the great grandmother is portrayed as a silent listener who
listened to her disturbed soul without any interruptions as she was unable to move under the
burden of perpetual paralysis that confined her to the bed. But such a lack of response didn’t
prevent her to develop an intimate relationship. This was precisely the reason that helped in
nurturing the relationship in a way she wanted. The old lady due to her paralyzed state was
the only one whom she could trust and open her heart out without the fear of being punished
In this context, the research would like to throw some lights on the definition of
This is a style of poetry that emerged in the United States during the 1950s. It has been
experience, the psyche, and personal trauma, including previously and occasionally still taboo
matters such as mental illness, sexuality, and suicide, often set in relation to broader social
19
themes. It is sometimes also classified as Postmodernism. It also may be noted here that ‘the
school of "Confessional poetry" was associated with several poets who redefined American
poetry in the 1950s and 1960s, including Robert Lowell, Sylvia Plath, John Berryman,
Anne Sexton, Allen Ginsberg, and W. D. Snodgrass.’ Among other key texts of the
American "confessional" school of poetry include Plath's Ariel, Berryman's The Dream
Songs, and Sexton's To Bedlam and Part Way Back, though Berryman himself rejected the
label "with rage and contempt". In this genre, another significant, if transitional figure was
Adrienne Rich; while one of the most prominent, consciously "confessional" poets to emerge
in the 1980s was Sharon Olds whose focus on taboo sexual subject matter built off of the
work of Ginsberg. However, among the confessional writers, Sylvia Plath was one of the
Sylvia Plath is commonly seen as a confessional poet, although some critics dispute
her placement within this movement, arguing that her work is more universal than commonly
assumed. Nevertheless, Ariel, published posthumously in 1965, deals with the very personal
issues of suicide, sex, her children, and, most dramatically, her complicated relationship with
her deceased father. Poems like "Daddy," "Ariel," and "Lady Lazarus" are stunning in their
According to Grade saver, Anne Sexton wrote poetry that dealt with her personal life,
including her experiences with psychotherapy, sex, depression, and rage. One of her most
significant works, To Bedlam and Part Way Back (1960), dealt with such excruciating topics
as molestation by a father. The confessional poets have garnered a lot of critical interest, but
there is a tendency to conflate their art and lives too fully - the usage of a personal pronoun in
20
their work is not an unequivocal invitation to assume that the subject of the poem is always
the poet.
Earlier from the Hindu outfits, she faced death threats. And more intrigue in the life of
Kamala Das is that she, at the verge of her death, she almost disowned Islam. And she
confessed to Merrily Weisbord that it is not she wants to disown Islam but the religion as a
system. But happily, she met death and willed that she should be buried in a graveyard near a
mosque. That was how Kamala Das change from persona to persona and went through a
troubled life. If one reads Merrily Weisbord’s “The Queen of Malabar- A Memoir of
Friendship”, her life and story entirely different from what one reads her “My Story”. In the
former, she repudiates many things which she has confessed in My Story which includes her
rubbishing her husband and his loveless attitude towards her. Later she confided to Merrily
that she was grateful to Mr. Das for having provided a safe and secured live with, of course,
love.
One of the mysterious and inexplicable things in her life her conversion to Islam.
Born in a conservative Hindu Nair (Nallappattu) family having royal ancestry, After being
asked by her lover Sadiq Ali, an Islamic scholar and a Muslim League MP, she embraced
Islam in 1999 at the age of 65 and assumed the name Kamala Surayya. After converting, she
wrote:
Life has changed for me since Nov. 14 when a young man named Sadiq Ali walked in
to meet me. He is 38 and has a beautiful smile. Afterwards he began to woo me on the
phone from Abu Dhabi and Dubai, reciting Urdu couplets and telling me of what he
would do to me after our marriage. I took my nurse Mini and went to his place in my
car. I stayed with him for three days. There was a sunlit river, some trees, and a lot of
21
laughter. He asked me to become a Muslim which I did on my return home.( TOI,
2001)
Das’ conversion was rather controversial, among social and literary circles, with The
Hindu calling it part of her "histrionics". She said she liked being behind the protective veil of
the purdah. Later, she felt it was not worth it to change one's religion and said "I fell in love
with a Muslim after my husband's death. He was kind and generous in the beginning. But I
now feel one shouldn't change one's religion. It is not worth it.".
Her desire to revert to Hinduism was discouraged by her eldest son, who feared that
Muslim radicals would murder her and the entire family. Though never politically active
before, she launched a national political party, Lok Seva Party, aiming asylum to orphaned
mothers and promotion of secularism. In 1984 she unsuccessfully contested in the Indian
Parliament elections. She had a sexual relationship with Sadiq Ali, an Islamic scholar who
was much younger in age. She herself describes her visit to Sadiq Ali's home as follows:
“I was almost asleep when Sadiq Ali climbed in beside me, holding me, breathing
softly, whispering endearments, kissing my face, breasts ... and when he entered me, it
was the first time I had ever experienced what it was like to feel a man from the
inside."
She once claimed that "poetry does not sell in this country," but her forthright
columns, which sounded off on everything from women's issues and child care to politics,
were popular. Das' first book of poetry, Summer In Calcutta was a breath of fresh air in
Indian English poetry. She wrote chiefly of love, its betrayal, and the consequent anguish.
Ms. Das abandoned the certainties offered by an archaic, and somewhat sterile, aestheticism
for an independence of mind and body at a time when Indian poets were still governed by
22
"19th-century diction, sentiment and romanticized love." Her second book of poetry, The
Kamala Das expresses the identity and distinction both as a woman and writer. Her
other works are good but her autobiography is certainly better. It is written in the form a
novel, well designed, informative, and delightful. It can be read as a confession. She has
never tried to hide anything from her readers. In other way, this is a revolutionary book. It is
a story of a shameful society where males do not properly respect women. Women writers
focus on the conflicts in man-woman relationship and the female psyche conditioning it to
survive the oppressive forces. The post-independence Indian woman is aware of her rights,
virtues, and duties and of convention. She has complete knowledge of her heritage and is
proud to be part of the great tradition. Social obligations and moral responsibilities have
conditioned her .she is also aware of her fears, weaknesses and limitations; the length of the
road she can tread upon, the dangers she has to overcome. An Apology to Cantama deals
with the adultery of the woman persona. While her husband holds her woman form, her lover
holds her very soul. The Testing of the Sirens also deals with adultery. The husband persona
23
1.22 Das’ Lord Krishna's Vision vs Prophet Mohammed’s Luminance
In her poem "Love", we find the same note of religious dilemma. It ironically depicts
the mood of confession and revulsion that takes possession of the poet. Once again, she
compares the mouth of the lover to the sun which brings both the heat and the loss of love
and due to failure in achieving fulfillment of love, she longs for God's love i.e., Krishna's
love: Of what does the burning mouth Of sun, burning in today's sky Remind me oh yes his
mouth and... His limbs like pale and carnivorous Plants reaching out for me The sad lie of my
unending lust. Although Das regards the rituals and observances of Hinduism and it shows
the one unified force the primal flood, the moving fount of Being in Hindu mythopoeia, the
Brahman of the Advait philosophy:- "The undying reality/Which doesn't dissolve though?/All
beings dissolve". (150) It is obvious that Das does not look for God head in the figure of Lord
Krishna, she rather seeks for an ideal lover in the figure of Krishna. In fact, her search for an
ideal lover is rooted in her deep sense of alienation. She languished in the folds of a
matrilineal society that was quickly shifting its centre of gravity towards a male hegemonic
society.
Besides, Kamala Das's philosophical dilemma finds true expression in her collected
and series of "Annamalai Poems". Here, we find the poet is vacillating between truth and
falsehood, deception and no deception, to be and not to be. It means, she lives in the world of
desires, devices, love, sex, frustration and falsehood. She can never dream of deceiving others
without being undeceived. In this attempt to manipulate the world through her frustrated life,
she loses the war of motives frequently and hence she is on the altar of liberation. In spite of
all difficulties, she goes on revolting and proves the wisdom of youthfulness for spiritualism.
24
She tries to keep herself aloof in order to hear the voice of God but it is not possible for her
because of the restricting orthodox and crazy Nair society. So she is disappointed but
sometimes she also gets consolation that God Krishna can never be heard in the crazy and
crowded surrounding if one sticks to truth like Ezekiel. She went to Annamalai mountain
serves as a symbol of woman's indomitable will power and long lasting endurance. Women,
at large, have been put on ordeals be it Sita, Savitri or Lady Lazarus or miserable women at
grass roots level. In every trial, they have stood exceptionally enduring and victorious that
certifies their miraculous capability to lead society to a better and balanced future. These
poems are untitled yet they are called "Annamalai Poems"."Annamalai Poems" express the
poet's philosophical dilemma about the idea of certainty and uncertainty. The first poem of
the series dwells on the severe torture of her body and mind. It relates her frequent visit to the
hill region's serpentine path that leads the traveller up and down where tattered peasants
beckon her
Kamala Das is essentially an introvert and her mood is feministic and confessional.
Through her feminism and confessional mode, she always expresses her note of tension and
dilemma. She has always responded to the situations of human suffering and pain with great
sensitivity and compassion. The ethnic violence in Sri Lanka and the situation of pain,
distress and suffering prevailed. On the island especially after 1983, have created
compassionate stirring and indignation in Kamala Das. She is one of the few Indian poets
who have assimilated the passion and emotion let loose by the Sri Lankan imbroglio.
The "Colombo Poems" mark the widening of the poet's dilemma from caste
oppression outside India. The poems inspired by the poet's Sri Lankan experiences remarked
Nair in The Poetry of Kamala Das: "are an indication that she is capable of breaking the self
25
mode cocoon of brooding over male inequity and female vulnerability". These poems are a
testimony to her involvement in the fate of people with whom she is racially related. With
these poems, the poet covers all forms of oppression i.e. men vs. women, state vs individual,
dominant cultures vs. marginal sub-cultures, rich vs poor and the White/Aryans vs. Black
Dravidians. The main preoccupation in the "Colombo Poems" revolves round the human
beings that suffer on account of racial prejudice, cultural and linguistic chauvinism.
Alphabets of Lust, and Padmavati the Harlot and Other Stories. Kamala Das is an enfant
terrible of the Indian literary scene. Even well into late middle age. Rakishly sensual in her
poems and prose, Das, in this collection of short stories, no longer seeks to shock. With
sensitivity Das takes us behind the purdah into the tattered world of the down-and-out
woman - prostitutes, some with the proverbial golden heart. And some more sinned against
than sinning.
There are no villains, only the force of circumstance and the weakness of men.
Underneath the sadistic exterior of the policeman who likes little girls, lies compassion.
Padmavati, the middle-aged prostitute who sells herself for her family, only to be shunned by
them, yearns only for the gods, who treat her no better than her clients did. As the other
woman, the kept woman who only wants her man's love. Das doesn't shriek about
oppression, which sits like a bell jar over her protagonists who lead lives of quiet desperation.
There's no whisper of sloganeering or feminism. But by unfolding the everyday life, she has
Doll for the Child Prostitute, the centre piece of this volume. Through Rukmani, the 12-year-
26
old girl sold to a brothel by her mother, Das shows that neither compassion nor emotions
have entirely fled these sordid surroundings. Kamala Das’s short story A Little Kitten is part
of a new anthology – The Parrots of Desire – that puts together Indian erotic writing
composed over 3,000 years. In this short story, A Little Kitten, Kamala Das looks at marriage
When they had finally settled themselves down after weeks of honeymooning in a
small flat at Dadar, she told her husband that she felt miserable and lonely from eight in the
morning to six in the evening while he worked in his insurance firm at the heart of the city. If
only you could get me a pet, she murmured, nestling closer to his chest, a little kitten, even a
kitten would be such a comfort... And, he threw back his head and laughed. What a sweet and
innocent creature he had married! He tickled her until she rolled over on their double bed and
screamed out for mercy. You are killing me, please stop, PLEASE STOP. Then, he began to
lick her toes, mumbling, you see, I am your kitten, I am your little kitten. After three months
of ardour, they began to quarrel. Nothing very serious, of course. Just a few probing queries
regarding his relationship with Miss Nadkar, his secretary, and his mysterious silences that
would last for hours. Speak to me, I cannot bear these silences. Leave me alone, he would say
and disappear into the bathroom. One day, she climbed upon a stool and peeped into the
bathroom through the ventilator. He was seated on the edge of the tub, frowning. What are
you doing there, she shouted at him. He got up and pulled the ventilator shut. It nearly
snapped off her fingers. No wonder she was angry and frustrated. When they were on the best
of terms she used to take a bath in the evening after tea and buy a jasmine strand from the
Therefore, the existential question is: to write or to die? Kamala Das chose the former
rather than meeting death. So, we, the readers, got her “My Story- An Autobiography”. And
27
Das’ decision to go all out in pouring her emotions, inner feelings led her to become one of
the celebrated writer – poet, short story writer, novelist, travelogue writer etc., Shahnaz Hibib
, in the Guardian Obituary, in 2009, observed that the passing of Kamala Das is a great loss
to the corpus of Indian writing in English. In My Story (1976), she recounted the trials of her
marriage and her painful self-awakening as a woman and writer. She became an icon for
women, in India and elsewhere, struggling to liberate themselves from sexual and domestic
subtitled "the compelling autobiography of the most controversial Indian writer") Das later
admitted that there was plenty of fiction in My Story. Perhaps "biomythography" would have
been a fairer description of the book. Das's rebellions were more multidimensional than she
was given credit for. Her female protagonists were not simply in pursuit of sexual freedom,
they were in search of poetry, intimacy and divinity. Characters such as Padmavathi the
harlot, who drags her bruised body to a holy shrine, personify the unworldly wisdom with
which Das endowed her best female protagonists. She also created several nuanced male
characters, for example, the hapless father in the 1991 short story Neypayasam, who shelters
In this context, one must understand that all the needs are not compartmentalized
rigidly. The needs of human beings are arranged in hierarchical order which need not be
independent and progressive step by step and linear. There may be overlapping in their needs
and it depends on individual person whose needs attention according to the psychological
traits. Therefore, if certain needs are not achieved, it leads to an increase in displeasure
within an individual. In return, when individuals feel this increase in displeasure, the
both traits and a state. Physiological needs as traits allude to long-term, unchanging demands
28
that are required of basic human life. Physiological needs as a state allude to the unpleasant
decrease in pleasure and the increase for an incentive to fulfill a necessity In order to pursue
intrinsic motivation higher up Maslow's hierarchy, physiological needs ‘must be met first’.
This means that if a human is struggling to meet their physiological needs, then they are
1. Homeostasis
2. Food
3. Water
4. Sleep
5. Clothes
6. Shelter and
7. Sex
The following pyramid diagram shows the needs of every human being according to
Abraham Maslow:
29
In the above diagram the needs are arranged in hierarchical order according to the
theory of Maslow. However, certain other psychologists have disagreed this Need theory and
they have come out with their own Need Theories. In the following diagram, the overlapping
could be noticed with the four needs crisscrossing and extending beyond the individual
domain. In the case Kamala Das, she attempts to reveal different persona and the
metamorphosis is complex and astounding to the lay readers as she changes her persona
according to her need. The basic need for love and sex are not fulfilled according to her first
novel My Story- An Autobiography. Of course, she is changing her stand very often and she
perplexes the readers with her ever changing perceptions on various issues. As for the Social
and Safety needs, she goes to the extent of converting to Islam as she has confessed at various
points of her life that she finds safety in the Islam religion. Therefore, she writes various
poems to put faith in Allah. The self-actualization does happen when she gives up Hindu
religion. Earlier, Kamala Das was holding Lord Krishna as lover, husband, friend, and what
not. She sees Lord Krishana in her first son before his birth. When she feels him kicking in
her womb, she pray to Lord Krishna to give her a son like Him. However, later the same poet
converts and goes on writing a number of poems in praise of Prophet Mohammed in the place
of Lord Krishna. There is, of course, so much self-contradiction, but can one blame Kamala
Das for changing her stance in different faiths turning the table upside down. In the
following diagram, one can understand the need intensity of a human being and the needs
30
Next to Maslow, there are others who propounded with various Need theories
encompassing various human traits and psychological characteristics . in 1960s , there was
David McClelland’s Acquired Needs Theory who also came out with need theory which is to
writer.
McClelland proposed three types of innate motivation that significantly influence our
behaviour. In the 1960s, Clayton Alderfer’s ERG Theory came out modelling Maslow’s
theory well reworked into three interrelated needs: existence, relatedness, and growth. In the
1980s, the Fundamental Needs Matrix was espoused by Manfred Max-Neef who
distinguishes 9 needs from a multitude of satisfiers which he grouped into 4 categories viz.,
qualities, things, actions, and settings. The needs of human beings have been put in different
way by Simon Hertnon with nine needs starting with existence and ending with philosophical
31
Happiness is the state every human wants to be in. It is a concept and there is much
difference between pleasure and happiness. It is a state in the mind. A person whose basic
need such as food and shelter are not fulfilled, can he or she be happy? This is , of course, an
existential question. Kamala Das, according to Simon Hertnon’s Nautilus Diagram, is in the
5th level where she wants to feel happy by expressing herself and she needs self- esteem
through her literary oeuvre. In My Story- An Autobiography and other collection of poems ,
she attempts to achieve happiness and attain self-actualization. To achieve them, she changes
her persona and she metamorphoses into various forms and state of mind changing her
human relationship. Here in under one may see the difference between the two theories
32
Alderfer divides human needs into three broad categories with Existence, Relatedness
and Growth – all these components to do basic and higher level of human needs. At this
point, what the research scholar points out is that every human being is led by his or her
psychological traits and characteristics. Here, Kamala Das, as found in various psychological
including through her confessional approach to reveal her real persona and her odyssey
through the endless artistic journey. Finally, she achieves contentment as Maslow and
Alderfer espoused in their theories starting with basic needs such as love and sex and then the
33
1.26 Conclusion
“Allah told me that in order to be effective, you should have political power” , this is
what Kamala Das told when she was asked why she converted to Islam. Kamala Suraiya in
her pre-Islamic days) continues to shock the straight-laced Malayalees. One of India's best-
known English poets and short story writers, Kamala Suraiya, who abandoned Hinduism to
convert to Islam last December, launched a national political party last week. Christened as
the Lok Seva Party, the new political party, she says, emerged from her conviction that social
change could be possible in India only through political power. But Suraiya, 68, and with
near-blind eyes puts forward another reason that compelled her to embrace the political
vocation -- Allah. "Allah inspired me to launch this party," she says. Before embarking on the
political mission, Suraiya says she carried out three months of meditation and prayer before
Allah. In an exclusive interview with Senior Associate Editor George Iype, Suraiya, clad in a
black purdah and her hands adorned with colourful bangles, spells out how her conversion to
Islam forced her to take the plunge into political life. When he asked her “What compelled
you to launch a political party?”, Kamala Das replied that the degeneration of the present set
of political parties is the main reason why I decided to start my own party. We have to give
truth some importance in political life. I have given truth a special status in my life. So it
pains me when our political parties continue in the most degenerated forms. But what is
gladdening is that a number of youngsters came to me with a request to start a political party.
These youngsters, most of them college boys and girls, are tired of the falsehood and avarice
which politicians display in great abundance these days. I thought it might be a good reason
to start a political party. Importantly, she was asked “So you never felt this strength and faith
as a Hindu?”, to which she replied that for me, all gods are the same, whether you are a
Hindu, a Muslim, a Christian or anyone. I believe in the concept of god. For me, god is the
34
guardian. When she was confronted with another intimidating question “Do you think that
these changes taking place in your life are out of your conviction?”, Das candidly replied
that “My conviction is growing. Islam has grown on me. In the beginning I was not at all
religious. Now I am really religious because of Islam.” When he asked her “Are you happy
with your new religious status? Are you happy with your new life as a Muslim?”, Das gave
the question “You had said you were depressed and disappointed as a Hindu all these years.
What were the reasons behind this disappointment?”, she replied that :
Kamala Das’s literary writings reproduce external reality in its mental aspect. She
employs the presentation of this mental aspect the literary products of kamala das’s are
mainly objective on character .but there is a controlled infusion of subject vision in her
representation of life that she witnesses around her own self in her period of life. Thus
literature of kamala Das’s is helpful in guiding reader to discover their inner strength through
self-definition and self-discover. Thus the literature of kamala Das’s awakens in the hearts of
all perceptive reader a stronger sense of justice and a more Christian like humanity.Iin all
these respect it has proved itself to be educative instructive and trendsetting. Addressing the
controversies surrounding her she once said in an interview with Shobha Warrier:
“[It is] probably because I have some courage to be what I am, and I don’t see my
faults as faults – I see them as characteristics; strengths too. Why not, if you realise
Other than the some limitations faced the research scholar, the whole of journey of
investigating and exploring the Das’ work is challenging and rewarding. The new writings
have put Das in higher pedestal than earlier. There are more fresh avenues to do more
research and reassess her literary works in terms of new approaches and principles such as
35
Cultural theory and Ecocritical theory. Since most of her works are replete with the place and
she is in love with her own place, Kerala , which is in other words known as God’s Own
Country. Kamala Das’ literary works are erotic, sexual, confessional, feministic,
psychological but a voice for the Indian women to show the world the suppressed cries and
she took upon herself the task of working as a mouthpiece for women’s freedom and the
psychologically and emotionally oppressed women not in only in India but also to the whole
world.