Sarah Bustin
12/17/2022
Exoplanets
Final Project
One of the most intriguing aspects of the study of exopianets is that new
observations, and analyses of these observations, shape the current body of
knowledge. An example of this atmosphere of discovery is a planet that appears to have
migrated into an orbit around the star 51 Pegasi. According to Lin, Bodenheimer, and
Richardson, the planet is a gas giant yet orbits close to its star. Their 1996 paper aims
to address the problem that the planet is too close to have formed there on its own and
attempts to provide a plausible explanation. The authors assert that 51 Pegasi's
planetary companion formed much further away, where it was colder and rocks, ice, and
gasses could coalesce under the influence of gravity. Then, the planet moved to its
present position “through interactions with the remnants of the circumstellar disc”. If
true, other planets may have migrated in the past or may migrate in the future in a
similar way.
To calculate how the planet may have moved closer to 51 Pegasi, Lin,
Bodenheimer, and Richardson make several assumptions. First, they infer that the
object is in fact a gas giant planet. This inference is justifiable because the planet is
about the size of Jupiter, which is also a gas giant. Secondly, the authors claim that the
planet formed in the usual method a gas giant is born: gradually building up smaller ice
and rock particles until enough mass accumulates to attract gasses. The planet
completed its formation before migrating to its new location. Such an assumption is
reasonable because “at 0.05 AU the temperature is about 2000 k”, but at largedistances it is cold enough for rocks and ices to be present in the disc. Finally, Lin,
Bodenheimer, and Richardson assert that “atmospheric motions and convection in the
interior redistribute the heat so that the dark side and the bright side have nearly the
same temperature”. This is true of most planets with an atmosphere, such as Earth. A
new type of observation that would invalidate this work would be the formation of gas
giant planets at close distances to their host stars.
Another article that presents an interesting finding on exoplanets was written by
Vidal-Madjar et. al in 2003, claiming to have observed “an extended upper atmosphere
around the extrasolar planet HD209458b". The scientists found evidence of atomic
hydrogen absorption during three transits of the planet. This means that the planet is
likely a gas giant orbiting close to its star, similar to the planetary companion of 51
Pegasi. The hydrogen line the authors observed is special because it shows little error.
Because of this, the authors can remove contamination from the star and look at only
the absorption from the planet, Vidal-Madiar et. al also investigated the error and
reported that “systematic errors generated through the background corrections are
small compared to the statistical errors’. Those errors represent photon counting noise.
The authors assume that the observed light is passing through the atmosphere of the
planet and the atmosphere of the Earth. Not only do the authors rely on the
observations themselves, but also they noticed a bright hot spot on the surface of the
star, After a few calculations, Vidal-Madjar et. al concluded that the hot spot did not
contribute significantly to the results.