CHS 3 - G (Overpopulation)
CHS 3 - G (Overpopulation)
CHS 3 - G (Overpopulation)
B. Definition of terms
a. Overpopulation - the state whereby the human population rises to
an extent exceeding the carrying capacity of the ecological setting
b. Health Risk -the chance or likelihood that something will harm or
otherwise affect your health
c. Resource management -is the practice of planning, scheduling,
and allocating people, money, and technology to a project or
program. In essence, it is allocating resources to achieve the
greatest organizational value.
d. Social inequality -is the condition where people have unequal
access to valued resources, services, and positions in the society
e. Socio-economic development- is the process of social and
economic progress in a society. Socio-economic development is
measured with indicators, such as GDP, life expectancy, literacy
and levels of employment.
D. Dilemma
a. While limiting family sizes aligned with parental capabilities could
help address overpopulation and its strains on resources, it raises
ethical dilemmas around government intervention in private
reproductive choices.
b. While limiting family sizes aligned with parental capabilities could
help address overpopulation and its strains on resources, it raises
ethical dilemmas around government intervention in private
reproductive choices.
c. On one hand, unchecked population growth poses risks to public
welfare, the environment, and standards of living for future
generations. Having more children than parents can adequately
care for burdens social services and exacerbates poverty, health
issues, emotional neglect, and moral instruction deficits. From a
utilitarian perspective, regulating family sizes could maximize
societal well-being.
d. On the other hand, reproduction is a fundamental human right.
Enforcing limits could be viewed as a government overreach into
personal privacy, autonomy, and family decisions. It discriminates
against cultural/religious views favoring large families. There are
also concerns about potential for abuse, such as selective
enforcement against minorities.
e. The dilemma pits societal interests in curbing overpopulation
against individuals' reproductive freedoms. It questions whether
benefits to the collective justify restricting personal liberties around
family planning. Striking a balance between population control and
civil rights proves challenging but necessary for an ethical solution.
f. Ultimately, the dilemma compels examination of competing moral
philosophies - obligations to the greater good versus protection of
individual liberties and prevention of discriminatory policies.
Resolving it requires weighing societal costs against personal costs
through a well-reasoned ethical framework.
E. Cause of Overpopulation
a. (2011), one primary cause of overpopulation in the Philippines is
the lack of family planning and education. The country has been
struggling to provide comprehensive reproductive health services
and access to contraception. This leads to higher fertility rates,
resulting in an increased population growth rate.
Land area (sq. km) in Singapore was reported at 718 sq. Km in 2021, according to the
World Bank
Observations about population and land mass when comparing the Philippines and
Singapore:
Population:
Land Area:
Population Density:
● Due to the vast difference in land area and population size, the population
density of Singapore is much higher than that of the Philippines.
● With a population of over 6 million and a land area of only 718 square kilometers,
Singapore has an extremely high population density.
● On the other hand, the Philippines, with a population of over 118 million and a
land area of 295,633 square kilometers, has a relatively lower population density
compared to Singapore.
Implications:
● The high population density in Singapore puts significant strain on the limited
land resources, necessitating efficient urban planning, housing, and resource
management strategies.
● In the Philippines, while the overall population density is lower, the large
population size still exerts pressure on natural resources, infrastructure, and
public services, particularly in urban areas.
● The disparity in population density between the two countries highlights the
differing challenges they face in terms of urban development, environmental
sustainability, and resource allocation.
Manila vs Mabinay
14,942,000 people in the year 2024 - 82,953 people in the year 2020
Labor Force: A large population can provide a significant labor force, which can be
advantageous for economic growth. With a large working-age population, there is
potential for increased productivity and innovation, leading to economic development
and prosperity.
-Manufacturing Sector: The manufacturing sector in the Philippines plays a crucial role
in providing employment opportunities. Industries such as electronics, automotive,
garments, and food processing employ a substantial portion of the labor force,
especially in industrial zones like the Cavite Economic Zone, Laguna Technopark, and
the Mactan Export Processing Zone. Other labor forces are BPO Industry , Tourism and
Hospitality and Agriculture
Recent economic data shows that the Philippines economy has continued to show
robust expansion, with GDP growth of 5.9% year-over-year (y/y) in the third quarter of
2023. Latest S&P Global Purchasing Managers Index survey results for November 2023
also showed that the Philippines manufacturing sector is one of the fastest growing
amongst the major economies worldwide
Cultural Diversity: High population density also increases cultural diversity due to the
influx of people from different backgrounds and cultures living together in one region or
city. A diverse population enriches the cultural landscape of the country, contributing to
a vibrant society with a wide range of traditions, languages, and perspectives. Cultural
diversity can promote creativity, tolerance, and social cohesion.
Cons:
Some factors lead to Limited Job Opportunities Overpopulation it can strain public
services and infrastructure, leading to inadequate investment in education, healthcare,
and transportation. We have Pressure on Public Services and Infrastructur,
overpopulation can strain public services and infrastructure, leading to inadequate
investment in education, healthcare, and transportation. This can result in a workforce
that lacks the necessary skills and qualifications to compete in the job market,
contributing to higher rates of unemployment and underemployment. Skills Mismatches,
overpopulation can exacerbate skills mismatches within the labor market. While there
may be a large pool of job seekers, many may lack the skills and qualifications
demanded by employers. This can result in higher rates of unemployment as job
seekers struggle to find employment that matches their skills and experience.
Increased Pollution: High population density often leads to increased pollution levels
due to the concentration of people living together in one region.
It results from numerous vehicles and factories producing goods necessary for daily life,
emitting harmful emissions into the atmosphere, contaminating air quality, which can
cause health problems over time.
While overpopulation is not the sole cause of pollution in the Philippines, it certainly
contributes to increased pressure on the environment and exacerbates existing pollution
challenges.
Main factors that lead to Pollutions are Air Pollution from Transportation ,Overpopulation
often leads to increased urbanization and a higher concentration of vehicles on the
roads. In major cities like Metro Manila, where population density is high, the number of
cars, motorcycles, and public transportation vehicles contributes to air pollution through
emissions of particulate matter, nitrogen oxides, and volatile organic compounds.
Social Problems: Large numbers of people living close can also lead to social issues,
such as crime, gang activity, and drug use.
When people feel they have no other options or cannot meet their basic needs, they
may turn to criminal activities to achieve their goals.
Overcrowding could also make it difficult for authorities to properly monitor what’s
happening within the region, making it easier for criminals or gangs to operate without
fear of being caught.
Poverty and Population Growth - Families with multiple children: The first causal
relationship pertains to the idea that high population levels and growth rates are usually
associated with higher levels of poverty. From the perspective of a household, an
additional member that will naturally require additional expenditures effectively reduces
family savings rate. Income, which would have originally been spent on other activities
such as increasing the quality of life of other household members or perhaps
entrepreneurial undertakings, is instead spent to sustain the additional member.
Similarly, from an aggregate perspective, a larger population may hinder the effective
and efficacious provision of social services as limited funds are spread too thinly across
a huge number of individuals. Families with multiple children can contribute to the
challenges associated with overpopulation in the Philippines that can and may lead to
Increased Resource Consumption , Pressure on Education System and Healthcare
Access.
1. Ethical Considerations
From a philosophical perspective, overpopulation in the Philippines prompts ethical
inquiries into how resources are distributed among individuals and communities.
Philosophers may question the fairness of resource allocation and explore principles of
justice and equity. They may argue that ensuring access to essential resources such as
food, water, and shelter is not only a matter of social responsibility but also a moral
imperative. Discussions about the ethical dimensions of overpopulation also touch upon
issues of social justice, as the burdens of overpopulation often fall disproportionately on
marginalized communities
2. Environmental Ethics:
3. Population Ethics:
Genesis 1:28 God blessed them and said to them, “Be fruitful and increase in
number; fill the earth and subdue it. Rule over the fish in the sea and the birds in the sky
and over every living creature that moves on the ground.”
God has a plan for the happiness of all who live on the earth, and the birth of
children within loving families is central to His plan. The first commandment He gave to
Adam and Eve was to “be fruitful, and multiply, and replenish the earth.”1 The scriptures
declare, “Children are an heritage of the Lord.”2 Those who are physically able have the
blessing, joy, and obligation to bear children and to raise a family. This blessing should
not be postponed for selfish reasons. Many religious faiths center on the belief that God
intends for humans to have families and children. In Christianity, for example, the Bible
emphasizes that having children and raising a family is part of God's plan for happiness
and fulfillment. The commandment given to Adam and Eve to "be fruitful, multiply, and
replenish the earth" is frequently used as proof of this divine responsibility. Similarly, the
Bible teaches that children are a gift from God, and that those who are physically
capable have both the blessing and the responsibility of bearing children and raising a
household. As a result, delaying or avoiding having children solely for selfish reasons is
viewed as contrary to God's plan and the divine purpose of human existence
In the Philippines, a predominantly Catholic country, there is a cultural and
religious emphasis on having large families. The idea of "being fruitful and multiplying"
is often interpreted quite literally, and this has contributed to the country's high
population growth rate.
While the verse encourages reproduction, it also implies a responsibility to care
for the earth. Overpopulation poses a challenge specially in the Philipines, which only
have limited resources, including land, water, and food, are under immense pressure,
leading to environmental degradation, resource depletion, and increased vulnerability to
natural disasters
According to Chester L. Hunt, ‘s article on Catholicism and the philippine
population problem, The Philippines has two characteristics that differentiate it from
other countries in Southeast Asia. It is the only predominantly Christian country in the
region and it has one of the highest rates of population growth. Non-Catholic Christians
make up only about 9% of the population compared with around 82% for Roman
Catholics. Given the Catholic Church's objections to both contraception and abortion, it
is reasonable to hypothesize that the religious composition of the population, with its
overwhelming Catholic majority and the Church's teachings on contraception and
abortion, could contribute to the higher population growth rate in the Philippines.
Proverbs 14:28 “A large population is a king’s glory, but without his subjects a prince is
ruined”.
Before, a large population can be seen as a blessing but it also requires a wise
governance and management of resources to avoid ruin. Without proper governance,
an overpopulated kingdom may struggle to provide for its citizens, leading to poverty,
social unrest, and ultimately the downfall of the ruler.
The Philippines faces the challenge of balancing the biblical principle of viewing a
large population as a blessing with the practical realities of limited resources and social,
economic, and environmental strains. While a large population can be seen as a source
of pride and strength for the nation, it also requires prudent/wise leadership and
effective governance to ensure the well-being of its citizens and the sustainability of its
resources. This means they have to think carefully about things like family planning,
making sure everyone is treated fairly, and protecting the environment.
”the greatest resource we have, it's not fossil fuels, it's not electricity, it's
not nuclear power, it's the human brain and the human person”
“We have more food per person on the planet now than we had thirty years
ago; the human mind, human productivity, has been able to to provide so much
that the world, even though there's poverty in the world there's, there's less
poverty in the world now than there was fifty years ago and a hundred years ago.
So the idea that we're going to somehow save the planet by having fewer
children, that is totally mistaken.”
“You know, the best thing we can do for our country is to have a large
family with parents that live together and stay together and pass on our culture
and our faith to them. Because--why do we have crime? Why do we have
poverty? You look at the statistics, it's broken families.”
For Fr. he says we shouldn’t limit what God can do citing the ff. examples St.
Ignatius alone, the founder of the Jesuits, was number 13 in his family. Saint Catherine
of Siena, when she, you know, criticized the Pope and got him to go back from Avignon
to Rome in the 14th century, she was a twin, number 21 and 22. He further advises to
trust in God’s plan and to not limit the children that you may have.
Islamic leaders originally encouraged Muslim population growth, but today the
Muslim population is very large, and is growing fast, which given the changed
circumstances, some believe it’s time for qualified mujtahids to evaluate the situation,
notably to decide whether a ruling is necessary to more strongly promote family
planning to reduce population growth
To further explain what he means, Kamali is talking about how Islamic scholars
can update their legal rulings to fit modern times. He mentions a concept called
ijtihad, which is when these scholars use their own judgment and hard work to
come up with new rules based on the Quran, teachings of the Prophet
Muhammad, agreements among scholars, and reasoning from past cases.
Kamali believes that Islamic law isn't set in stone and can change as society
changes.
If a scholar sees that old rulings don't work well anymore because society has shifted,
they can use ijtihad to make new rules that better match what's happening today.
This means making sure the law meets the needs of people and fits with what's
going on in the world.
So, Kamali is saying that Islamic law should keep up with the times by being
reinterpreted and adjusted when needed. This way, it stays relevant and helps
solve the problems we face today, while still staying true to the core values of
Islam.
In the catholic church's perspective it's more static as Fr. emphasizes continuity
and adherence to traditional teachings on family size, viewing the command to "be
fruitful and multiply" as timeless and unchanging and uses historical examples of large
families among saints to justify having more children, suggesting that limiting the
number of children may hinder what God can accomplish through individuals.
While in the Islamic perspective Professor Kamali has a more dynamic approach
towards overpopulation and allowing for reinterpretation and adaptation of Islamic law
to ensure it remains relevant and effective in addressing modern issues. As he says
the need to reassess traditional views in light of contemporary challenges, such as
environmental degradation and sustainability, suggesting that new rulings can better
align with the overarching objectives of shariah.
Shariah is the moral code and religious law of Islam covering the
rules, regulations, teachings, and values that govern the lives of
Muslims
With all the information that we have provided from different contrasting perspectives, the group
has decided collectively on the stand on overpopulation. As a group, we hold the perspective that
overpopulation is not just solely a matter focused on population size, but rather an issue of
responsible family planning and resource management. We believe that every individual has the
right to how many children they decide to have, in line with that of their beliefs and values.
However, it is part of the responsibility of parents to be able to provide the essential resources
needed such as food, education, healthcare, and a safe environment for their children. And with
that, as a group, we believe that responsible parenting is a fundamental principle that would align
to our Christian beliefs. Because of this, we highly believe in the need to empower and educate
parents through informative seminars conducted by experts, that would aim to educate and
encourage thoughtful decision-making, with regards to family size and resource allocation.
Promoting the balance between the call to be fruitful and multiply and the practical responsibility
to provide for each child’s needs.
As a group, our approach to this issue emphasizes the importance of informed choices, and
personal responsibility within the context of Christian values. We recognize the command to “be
fruitful and multiply”, and is significant within our faith, but it also carries the implicit
responsibility for us to take care for the well-being of our families and communities. By fostering
open dialogue and education, we seek to entrust individuals to make conscientious decisions
about family planning. As a group this effort would not only promote a sustainable population
growth, it also would support the holistic development of families in line with our Christian
principles.
Nelson, R. (n.d.). Members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (Birth
Control). Www.churchofjesuschrist.org.
https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/study/manual/gospel-topics/birth-control?lan
g=eng
https://www.usccb.org/committees/pro-life-activities/myth-overpopulation-and-folks-who-
brought-it-you
https://sites.psu.edu/aspsy/2015/09/24/catholicism-and-overpopulation/#:~:text=In%20a
ddition%2C%20the%20Catechism%20of,Catechism%20of%20the%20Catholic%20Chu
rch.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12309377/#:~:text=The%20Catholic%20Church%20of
%20the,the%20church%20in%20the%201960s.
https://en.islamonweb.net/islamic-perspective-on-population-control
https://www.jstor.org/stable/41056850
Person. (2024, April 22). What are the implications and impacts of overpopulation?.
Population Media Center.
https://www.populationmedia.org/the-latest/understanding-the-overpopulation-crisis-in-k
enya#:~:text=Overpopulated%20areas%20often%20face%20social,%2C%20education
%2C%20and%20employment%20opportunities.
Project, O. R. (2021, July 13). The moral case for population reduction. The
Overpopulation Project.
https://overpopulation-project.com/the-moral-case-for-population-reduction/
https://www.spglobal.com/marketintelligence/en/mi/research-analysis/philippines-econo
my-shows-robust-growth-into-the-new-year.html#:~:text=Philippines%20amongst%20w
orld%27s%20fastest%20growing,the%20second%20quarter%20of%202023.