Updated Value Addition Material 2024
Updated Value Addition Material 2024
DISASTER MANAGEMENT
Contents
1. Introduction to Disaster Management.......................................................................................2
1.1. Disasters...............................................................................................................................2
1.2. Hazards, Vulnerabilities and Risks........................................................................................2
1.3. Classification of Disasters.....................................................................................................3
2. Disaster Management Cycle........................................................................................................4
2.1. Introduction to the Disaster Management Cycle.................................................................4
2.2. Disaster Preparedness..........................................................................................................5
2.3. Disaster Risk Reduction and Planning..................................................................................6
2.4. Relief and Rehabilitation......................................................................................................9
2.5. Post-Disaster Recovery and Reconstruction........................................................................9
3. Disaster Management in India....................................................................................................9
3.1. Legal and Institutional Framework in India..........................................................................9
3.2. Vulnerability Profile of India..............................................................................................16
3.3. Natural Hazards..................................................................................................................17
3.3.1. Earthquake..................................................................................................................17
3.3.2. Tsunami.......................................................................................................................21
3.3.3. Volcano........................................................................................................................23
3.3.4. Floods..........................................................................................................................24
3.3.5. Urban Floods...............................................................................................................27
3.3.6. Landslides....................................................................................................................29
3.3.7. Cloudburst...................................................................................................................32
3.3.8. Cyclone........................................................................................................................33
3.3.9. Drought.......................................................................................................................36
3.3.10. Heat Wave.................................................................................................................40
3.3.11. Cold Wave.................................................................................................................42
3.3.12. Wild Fire....................................................................................................................45
3.4. Anthropogenic Disasters....................................................................................................48
3.4.1. Biological Disasters......................................................................................................48
3.4.2. Industrial Chemical Disasters......................................................................................50
3.4.3. Nuclear Disasters.........................................................................................................52
3.4.4. Oil Spills.......................................................................................................................54
3.4.5. Stampedes...................................................................................................................55
3.5. Evolution of Global Framework on Disaster Management................................................58
3.6. International Cooperation on Disaster Management........................................................61
3.7. Miscellaneous.....................................................................................................................63
4. UPSC Previous Years' Questions Years......................................................................................65
5. Vision IAS Previous Years' Questions........................................................................................66
Student Notes:
1.1. Disasters
According to the United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction (UNDRR), a disaster is a
serious disruption to the functioning of a community, which causes human, material,
economic and environmental losses beyond a community's ability to cope. It results from the
combination of hazards, conditions of vulnerability and insufficient capacity or measures to
reduce the potential negative consequences of risk.
Disaster damage is usually measured in physical units (e.g., square meters of housing,
kilometers of roads, etc.), and describes the total or partial destruction of physical assets.
In the following sections, we will assess each of the three stages of the disaster management
cycle in detail.
It covers activities which support preparedness, prevention and mitigation from a local to an
international level. The disaster risk reduction framework is composed of the following fields of
action:
A policy framework backed by legal and institutional mechanism that focuses on risk
management must be outlined.
Risk assessment based on hazards and community resilience must be done.
Risk Awareness: Having assessed the risk the next step is to make the stakeholders and
the decision makers aware of the risk enabling government and civil society to take
decisions.
Implementation of the plan: The plan must be implemented taking all stakeholders into
account including measures like environment management, urban planning etc.
Early Warning Systems are a key part of risk reduction through provision of timely and
reliable information through identified institutions.
Use of Knowledge: Effective disaster risk management depends on the informed
participation of all stakeholders. The exchange of information and easily accessible
communication practices play key roles.
The Prime Minister has enunciated ten-point agenda on Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR) during
the Asian Ministerial Conference on Disaster Risk Reduction (AMCDRR) held in New Delhi in
November 2016. The all-inclusive agenda presents a holistic approach to disaster risk reduction
and addresses a whole range of issues, from community preparedness to use of technology and
international cooperation. Each of the ten points on the Prime Minister’s ten-point agenda is
aligned with one or more priorities of action of Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction
2015-2030.
Incident Command System (2003)- The Incident Command System or ICS broadly refers to a
management system to be used for incidents of various kinds. The system provides scope to
organize various functions, tasks and staffs within the overall response process while emphasizing
greater coordination and communication among different organizations involved
Local Authorities
Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRI), Municipalities, District and Cantonment Boards, and Town
Planning Authorities, which control and manage civic services, ensure capacity building of their
employees for managing disasters, carrying out relief, rehabilitation and reconstruction
DELHI | JAIPUR | PUNE | HYDERABAD | AHMEDABAD | LUCKNOW | CHANDIGARH |
1 www.visionias. # ©Vision
Student Notes:
The Indian Naval Hydrographic Department plays a crucial role in disasters affecting coastal
areas. During the Indian Ocean Tsunami of 26th December 2004, seven survey ships were
deployed to open the sea lines of communication apart from providing the medical aid. They
were engaged to urgently re-chart the area and bring out the latest bathymetry information.
6. Ensuring Implementation: Aggressive capacity building requirements for the local people
and the administration for facing the disasters in wake of tsunami and cyclone, ‘based on
cutting edge level’.
Awareness generation and training among the fishermen, coast guards, officials from
fisheries department and port authorities and local district officials etc., in connection
with evacuation and post tsunami storm surge management activities. Regular drills
should be conducted to test the efficacy of the DM plans.
The Indian Tsunami Early Warning System has been established in collaboration with the
Department of Space (DOS), Department of Science and Technology (DST) and the Council of
Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR).
3.4.5. Stampedes
A stampede is a deadly and dangerous situation that occurs when a crowd surges beyond the
capacity of a space, moving in the same direction at the same time. During a stampede, people
collide and pile up against or on top of one another.
When crowd density is critical at any place, people’s movement is governed by involuntary
forces which include pushing each other in a tightly packed situation. Such uncoordinated rush
or push of people, may result in crowd disaster or stampede.
Incident of Stampede/Crowd Disaster
The majority of the crowd disasters in India and developing countries have occurred at
religious places while stadia, venues of music concerts, nightclubs, & shopping malls have been
the typical
DELHI | JAIPUR | PUNE | HYDERABAD | AHMEDABAD | LUCKNOW | CHANDIGARH |
5 www.visionias. # ©Vision
places of disasters in the developed countries. With population explosion and rapid Student Notes:
urbanization, Indian cities are likely to be susceptible to crowd disasters at such venues in the
days to come.
A global database of deaths from crowd accidents shows more than 1,477 people have lost
their lives since 2000 in over 50 disastrous mass gatherings in India (excluding the very recent
incident). India remains one of the biggest hotspots for deadly crowd accidents in the world,
particularly over the past two decades. Other major hotspots include Saudi Arabia, mainly due
to incidents during the annual Hajj pilgrimage, and some parts of West Africa.
Major Incident:
In 1954, millions gathered for a religious pilgrimage at the Prayag Kumbh Mela in northern
India, resulting in a crowd disaster that claimed around 800 lives. This incident remains the
deadliest crowd disaster in India’s history.
In 29 October 2022, a crowd surge occurred during Halloween festivities in the Itaewon
neighborhood of Seoul, South Korea. According to the South Korean government, 159 people
were killed and 196 others were injured.
The worst stampede in recorded history took place in Chongqing (China) during World War II
when the Japanese Bombed the city in June 1941, which triggered mass panic at an air raid shelter,
killing approximately 4,000 people.
Causes
Stampedes can occur due to various reasons. Factors that may prompt crowd disasters are as
follows
Structural: Disaster caused by collapse of structures. Example, Morbi Bridge Collapse
across Machchhu River in Gujarat.
2. Tsunami is a disaster beyond boundaries, which affects many countries at the same
time. In this context analyze the need for international cooperation in Tsunami
disaster management. Discuss in light of the recent steps taken by the world
community towards Tsunami preparedness.
Approach:
Introduce by mentioning the effect of Tsunami across borders through historical
experiences. Explain the need for international cooperation in Tsunami disaster
preparedness at both the prevention stage and relief stage. Mention the recent effort
made by the world community towards boosting cooperation towards Tsunami
preparedness. Conclude by emphasizing on the need for international cooperation.
Answer:
A decade after the Indian Ocean tsunami hit several countries in the Asia-Pacific region
killing over 200,000 people, Asian-Pacific countries have not only developed an
effective early warning system but are also capable of providing advisories to 25
countries on the Indian Ocean rim.
With the experience of Tsunami disasters in past it was realized that international
cooperation in Tsunami disaster management is a must.
At the state of disaster prevention
A tsunami is capable of destruction in a particular geographic region, generally
within about 1,000 km of its source. The instruments to analyze the sea waves
need to be placed across the seas falling in different borders. It can only be
predicted by gathering information from its source which can be far away in a
different country. Hence various Tsunami prediction centers can be established
throughout the oceans.
The international cooperation can help prepare a country of Tsunami disaster by
providing warning much before the disaster hits its territories.
The experience, research and innovation of Tsunami prone countries like Japan,
Australia, U.S (Hawaii region which is Tsunami prone) can be put to use for entire
population vulnerable to Tsunami disaster.
At the stage of providing relief
It is a disaster of huge magnitude, and the most vulnerable nations are small island
nations of Asia pacific region thus the resources for meeting relief prove to be
extremely helpful for them.
5. What are the causes for occurence of frequent stampedes at various public places in
India? What steps can be deployed to effectively check such events? Discuss in
context of the guidelines issued by NDMA on this issue.
Approach:
List the reasons for frequent stampedes in India.
Discuss steps which may be taken as outlined in NDMA guidelines.
Answer:
According to the National Crime Records Bureau figures, from 2000 to 2013, almost
2,000 people died in stampedes in India. For instance stampede occurred in 2008 at
Naina Devi in Himachal Pradesh (killing more than 100 pilgrims), in 2011 during Makara
Jyothi Day at Sabarimala in Kerala, in 2013 at Allahabad railway station during Kumbh
Mela etc.
A 2013 study published by International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction (IJDRR)
points out that religious gatherings and pilgrimages have been venues for 79% of the
stampedes in India. Deaths from stampedes occur primarily from compressive
asphyxiation, not trampling.
Accommodating nature of Indian people unlike the west, location of functions at
infrastructure-deficient places (banks of rivers, hilly terrains or mountain tops etc.) ,
lack of proper crowd management system, lack of coordination among various agencies
etc. are some of the major causes of stampede related disasters in India.
The surge of individuals in a crowd leading to stampede, is caused in response to a
perceived danger or loss of physical space. It often disrupts the orderly movement of
crowds resulting in irrational and dangerous movement for self-protection, leading to
6. India's first National Disaster Management Plan may fulfill the legal requirement of
having a plan but it may not be very effective in achieving its objective of building
resilience. Critically analyse.
Approach:
Outline the salient provisions of the NDMP.
Critically assess the plan and its effectiveness in addressing needs arising out of
disasters.
DELHI | JAIPUR | PUNE | HYDERABAD | AHMEDABAD | LUCKNOW | CHANDIGARH |
7 www.visionias. # ©Vision
Student Notes:
8. What are the priorities for action identified under the Sendai Framework for Disaster
Risk Reduction? Elaborate how India's National Plan for Disaster Management has
tried to integrate Sendai Framework.
Approach:
Give a brief overview of the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction and
state its priority action areas.
State how India’s National Plan for Disaster Management has tried to integrate the
Sendai Framework.
Mention the weaknesses of NDMP in this regard.
Answer:
The Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction (2015-2030) is a 15-year, voluntary,
non-binding agreement, which recognizes that the State has a primary role in reducing
disaster risk. However, the responsibility should be shared with other stakeholders
including local government, private sector etc.
The four priority action areas identified under the framework include:
Understanding disaster risk.
Strengthening disaster risk governance to manage disaster risk.
Investing in disaster reduction for resilience.
Enhancing disaster preparedness for effective response and to "Build Back Better"
in recovery, rehabilitation and reconstruction.
India’s National Disaster Management Plan (NDMP) has been aligned broadly with the
goals and priorities set out in the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction. Some
aspects of the NDMP are:
For each hazard, the NDMP incorporates four priorities enunciated in the Sendai
Framework under five thematic action areas including:
o Understanding risk
o Inter-agency coordination
o Investing in disaster risk reduction (DRR) – structural measures
o Investing in DRR – non-structural measures
o Capacity development
The response part of the plan identifies eighteen broad activities arranged into a
matrix to be served as a ready reckoner and includes measures such as early
warning, maps, satellite inputs, evacuation and search and rescue of people and
animals, medical care etc.
It covers all phases of disaster management: prevention, mitigation, response and
recovery.
It provides for horizontal and vertical integration of all agencies and departments
of the government at various levels.
It emphasizes on the need for dissemination of disaster-related information to
communities.
However, the NDMP also has some shortcomings that need to be addressed. These
include:
It does not set any goals or targets, or spell out how the Sendai goals and targets
shall be achieved.
9. What are the causes of forest fires and their effects on the ecosystem? How can forest
fires be prevented? Also mention the steps that have been taken by the government
in this regard.
Approach:
Introduce by mentioning the state of forest fires in India.
Discuss the reasons for forest fires and its impact on the ecosystem.
Mention the measures to prevent forest fires.
Then enumerate steps taken by government in this regard.
Answer:
In the last two years, India has witnessed 125% spike in the incidents of forest fires.
According to India State of Forest Report (ISFR) 2015, as much as 64.29 per cent of the
Recorded Forest Area (RFA) is prone to fires.
Causes
Natural causes are largely related to climatic conditions such as temperature, wind
speed and direction, level of moisture in soil and atmosphere and duration of dry
spells. Other natural causes are the lightning, friction of bamboos swaying due to
high wind velocity and rolling stones that result in sparks setting off fires in highly
inflammable leaf litter on the forest floor
Anthropogenic causes result from human activity as well as methods of forest
management. These can be intentional or unintentional such as fires started by
locals to clean the forest floor, burn undergrowth, to destroy evidence of illicit
felling or to scare wild animals etc.
Effects on the Ecosystem
Forest fire causes damage to vegetation cover and loss of natural regeneration, loss
of wildlife habitat, change in micro-climate, loss of biodiversity and invasion of
weeds, adverse effect on the local livelihood, loss of carbon sink, and addition of
greenhouse gases.
Fire frequency also determines the floristic composition of an area by selecting
species at site. A species can be removed if fire occurs too often, too early, or late
in its life cycle.
Fire may also play a role in recycling nutrients from the ground-layer vegetation
and litter and counters the infertile substrates and arrested decay.
Prevention of forest fires
Removal of Chir Pine: as it is highly inflammable due to its high resin content.
10. Identify different factors that trigger Glacial Lake Outburst Floods. Also, suggest
certain measures that need to be taken to minimize their impact.
Approach:
Define Glacial Lake Outburst Floods.
Enumerate its triggering factors.
Mention measures that are required to minimize the impact of these floods.
Answer:
Glacial Lake Outburst Floods(GLOFs) refer to release of melt water, moraines and the
entire content of the ice-dam glacial lake due to dam failure. GLOFs often result in
catastrophic flooding downstream, with major geomorphic and socio-economic impact.
Causative Triggers for the Glacial Lake Outburst Floods
Glacial retreat due to Global Warming increases the number of glacial lakes and
also expands the size of existing ones. Rapid Slope Movement into the lake and
melting
11. Explain the reasons behind earthquakes in Himalayas being more intense and
frequent than the ones occurring in Alps region. Why are scientists predicting a
largescale earthquake in northern India? Also, elaborate upon some prominent
earthquake forecasting techniques.
Approach:
Explain the reasons behind earthquakes in Himalayas being more intense and
frequent than the ones occurring in Alps region.
State the reasons for scientists predicting a large-scale earthquake in northern
India.
Elaborate upon some prominent earthquake forecasting techniques
Answer:
Earthquakes are on-ground manifestation of energy released during shattering and
movement of crustal plates. The amount of energy released depends up on the depth
of earthquake and the intensity of collision of plates. In regions of ongoing and faster
movement of plates, earthquakes are more frequent.
Himalayas are relatively younger fold mountains than Alps. Also, the Indian plate’s
movement toward the eurasian plate is occuring at a relatively faster pace. Since the
rocks in this region have not stabalised, they are brittle and shatter frequently. This is
the reason why there are more intense and frequent earthquakes in Himalayas than
the Alps, where the plates converge slowly, and hence, there is less seismic activity.
Reason behind prediction of a largescale earthquake in northern India
The frontal thrust in the central Himalayas (covering parts of India and eastern Nepal)
has remained seismically quiet for 600 to 700 years. This implies an enormous build-up
of strain in the region. This stacking up of strain in the region may cause at least one
earthquake of magnitude 8.5 or more in one of the overlapping segments of the central
Himalayas anytime in the future.
12. Highlight the factors responsible for occurrence of heat waves and its effects on life
and economy. In the light of recent guidelines given by NDMA, describe measures to
reduce the negative impact of heat waves.
Approach:
Briefly define heat wave and mention various factors responsible for it.
Highlight its impact on life and economy.
Mention some recent guidelines to reduce the negative impacts of heat waves.
Conclude briefly with a way-forward.
Answer:
According to Indian Meteorological Department (IMD), heat wave is considered if
maximum temperature of a station reaches at least 40°C or more for Plains, 37°C or
more for coastal stations and at least 30°C or more for Hilly regions. Following criteria
are used to declare heat wave:
Based on Departure from Normal
o Heat Wave: Departure from normal is 4.5°C to 6.4°C
o Severe Heat Wave: Departure from normal is >6.4°C
Based on Actual Maximum Temperature (for plains only)
o Heat Wave: When actual maximum temperature ≥ 45°C
o Severe Heat Wave: When actual maximum temperature ≥47°C
Factors responsible for occurrence of heat waves:
High pressure: Heat waves occur when high pressure trough moves into an area,
which forms a "cap" over the region by trapping heat. This environment of
minimal
14. What do you understand by impact based forecasting in disaster management? How
can such forecasting strengthen the disaster management preparedness?
Approach:
Briefly explain impact-based forecasting.
Explain the role of impact-based forecasting in disaster management preparedness.
Conclude accordingly.
Answer:
Impact based forecasting is an advancement over weather-based forecasting. While
weather-based forecasting is limited to only prediction of impending weather
conditions, impact-based forecasting also assesses the impact of weather conditions.
For example, a weather based forecast of a cyclone would be like- “A
tropical cyclone category 3, wind speed of 125 km/h is
expected in the next 48 hours” whereas impact based
forecasting of the same event would be- “A tropical
cyclone category 3, wind speed of 125 km/h is
expected to make landfall in 12 hours, in X and Y
regions, likely to damage critical infrastructure such as
bridges, blocking transport from region X to region Y”.
Under the impact-based system:
The hazards, risks and vulnerability related data are collected and integrated to
predict the impending disasters and their impact on people living in vulnerable
areas.
Further, geographical and population data are analysed to assess risk levels and
accordingly warnings are issued to areas that are prone to damage posed by
disaster.
The forecasts and warnings will mainly focus on sector and location specific impact
and the need to develop responses to mitigate the impact.
In this way, it provides information needed to act before disasters to minimise the
socioeconomic costs of weather and climate hazards.
Ways such forecasting strengthen the disaster management preparedness
Improved understanding of risk: As part of the new system, location or district-
specific tailored warnings, which factor in the local population, infrastructure,
settlements, land use and other elements, will be prepared and disseminated.
Therefore, it presents an in-depth risk profile.
Proactive planning: It will help the government to generate various impact
scenarios in disastrous situations therefore enable authorities to appreciate and
understand impacts and accordingly make plans for different scenarios based on
different impacts.
Effective response: ‘Pre-event scenario’ will help authorities to closely monitor
impact of impending disasters and take real-time decisions. Therefore, it will help
to effectively manage the disastrous situation similar to floods in Kerala.
Better coordination: All disaster management agencies will have access to
cartographic, geological and hydrological data available for the district concerned.
15. The recent “Disaster Management Plan of Ministry of Panchayati Raj (DMP–MoPR)”
aims to develop disaster resilience at the grassroots level. In this context, discuss the
rationale behind the formulation of the Plan and highlight its key components.
Approach:
Introduce by explaining the context of the statement given in the question.
Discuss the rationale behind formulation of disaster management plan at
Panchayat level.
Highlight the key components of the plan.
Conclude accordingly.
Answer:
India has been vulnerable, in varying degrees, to many natural as well as human-made
disasters on account of its unique geo-climatic and socio-economic conditions.
Considering the important role that local communities can play in reducing
vulnerabilities and early recovery, the Ministry of Panchayati Raj has prepared the
Disaster Management Plan so that all Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) along with
communities can be prepared for any disaster.
The aim is to build disaster resilience at the grassroots level among the Panchayats and
establish a framework to align the disaster management measures in rural areas to that
of the National Disaster Management Authority.
Rationale behind Disaster Management Plan at the panchayat level:
Institutional proximity and capacity: PRIs have proximity and capacity to involve
people and make them prepared for countering disasters by involving them in all
possible preventive and protective activities so that the impact of the disasters is
mitigated.
Ensure Participatory Planning Process: Such a plan would ensure a participatory
planning process for disaster management through the Gram Panchayat
Development Plan (GPDP) for addressing disasters across the country and initiate a
new era of community-based disaster management.
o People participation is crucial for identification of vulnerable groups and extent
of their vulnerability as well as response measures such as reconstruction of
damaged houses, crop protection measures, etc.
Social mobilization for traditional wisdom: PRIs can act as catalysts to the social
mobilisation process and tap the traditional wisdom of the local communities to
complement the modern practices in disaster mitigation efforts.