Emaan Assignmnt
Emaan Assignmnt
Emaan Assignmnt
Knowledge theory
Identifies mental faculties in terms of soul.
* Abstraction
* Perception
* Manipulation
Termed as Relation
Meta Physics
lbne-sina makes distinction b/w Essence & Existence of everything except
God.
1. Essence : (names of things) air, water, Fire, earth.
2. Existence: (Physical & Mental Realizations).
a. casuality
b.necessity
Existence of God:-
The central subject matter of Metaphysics is God and the proof of his
existance. lbn-e-Sina proposes that are essential. Cause & effect will
coexist & cannot be a part of an infinite chain, the nexus of causes must &
its effect must have a first cause, which necesarily exist for itself.
Concept of soul:-
In dealing wilth prophecy, metaphysics and knowledge, Ibn-e-Sina
proposes that must be an incorporated substance because intellectual
thoughts itself are indivisible -The soul is incorporeal implies that it must be
immortal, the decay, and destruction of the body does affect the soul. so it
will makea person unique and unified. "Man can decay, but his soul Never
Decay".
In his theory of knowledge, Ibn Sina identifies is the mental faculter the the
soul in terms of their epistemological function. As the discussion of logic in
has already sunnested, knowledge begins with abstraction Sense
perception, being already mental, is the yem of the object.perceived, sense
perception responds to the particular with ets given form and material
atcidents. As a mental event, being a perception of an object rather hai the
object itself, perception occurs in the particular. To analyze this responsu,
classifying its formal features in abstraction from material accidents, we
must both ret the Images given by sensation and also manipulate them by
disconnecting parts and alighing them according to their formal and other
properties. However, retention ang manipulation are distinct
epistemological functions, and cannot depend on the same psychological
faculty; therefore lum Sina distinguishes faculties of relation and
manipulation as appropriate to those diverse epistemological functions.
Ibn Sina identifies the retentive faculty as 'representation' and charges the
imagination with the task of reproducing and manipulating images. To
conceptualize our expence and to order it according to its qualities, we
must have and be able to reinvoke image of what we experienced but is
now absent. For this we need sensation and representation at least; in
addition, to order and classify the content of representon we must be able
to discriminate, separate out and recombine parts of images, and therefore
must possess imagination and reason. To think about a black flag we must
in able to analyze its color, separating this quality from others, or its part in
the image from other images, and classify it with other black things, thereby
showing that the concept of black applies to all such objects and their
images. Imagination carries rut this. manipulation, allowing us to produce
images of objects we have not seen in fact out of the images of things we
have experienced, and thereby also generating images for intelligible and
prophecies.
*Cognitive faculty:-
directs intellectual conduct
As the highest point above the Active Intellect, God, the pure intellect, is
also the highest object of human knowledge. All sense experience, logic
and the faculties of the human soul are therefore directed at grasping the
fundamental structure of reality as it emanates from that source and,
through various levels of being down to the Active Intellect, becomes
available to human thought through reason or, in the case of prophets,
intuition. By this conception, then, there is a close relation between logic,
thought, experience, the grasp of the ultimate structure of reality and an
understanding of God. As the highest and purest intellect, God is the
source of all the existent things in the world. The latter emanate from that
pure high intellect, and they are ordered according to a necessity that we
can grasp by the use of rational conceptual t. sught These interconnections
become clearer in Ibn Sina's metaphysics.
1. Metaphysics
We should also note that both Judaic and Islamic philosophy failed to
escape the fate so narrowly avoided in Latin Christendom. The
conservatives among Jewish and Islamic leaders found the free inquiry of
philosophy too dangerous to revealed "truth" to be tolerated. Philosophy
and its works were prohibited, so that after the time of ibn-Rushd (died
1198) there was no independent, nontheological philosophy among Jews or
Muslims. As we shall see in a later section of this chapter, a similar
persecution just failed of its object in fourteenth century Europe. In unified,
absolutist Islam, thought control could succeed; in politically diverse Europe
it could not.
*Medieval Psychology* :-
"He who knows his soul, knows his creator".
Proverb of the Muslim Brethren of Purity
This proverb could stand as the motto of early and high medieval
psychology. Augustine, as we have seen, wanted to know God and the
soul. He believed that by turning inward and inspecting the soul one could
come to know God, who is present in every soul. Augustine saw a unity of
Creator and Creation so that the three mental powers-memory,
understanding, and will, mirror the three beings of the Holy Trinity as any
three related things were thought to.
Different lists of mental faculties had been drawn up before ibn Sina. The
five corporeal senses and intellect were not considered mental faculties, a
status reserved for the interior senses. Aristotle had proposed three
faculties-common sense, imagination, and memory-although the lines
between them were not sharply drawn. Later writers proposed three to five
faculties, but ibn-Sina produced a list of seven faculties that became the
norm. This list presented a Neoplatonic hierarchy from the faculty closest to
the senses (and the body) to the faculty closest to divine intellect.
Beginning with the parts of the mind closest to the body, ibn Sina discusses
the vegetative soul, common to plants, humans, and animals (which he
treats as did Aristotle), saying that it is responsible for the reproduction,
growth, and nourish- ment of all living things.
Next comes the sensitive soul, common to men and animals. At its lowest
level it comprises the five external or corporeal senses (which again follows
Aristotle). The second level of the sensitive soul comprises the internal
senses, or mental faculties, which are at the border between man's animal
and angelic natures. They, too, are hierarchically arranged. First comes
common sense which, as in Aristotle, receives, unites, and makes
conscious the various qualities of external objects perceived by the senses.
These perceived qualities are retained in the mind by the second internal
sense, retentive imagination, for further consideration or later recall. The
third and fourth internal senses are the compositive animal imagination and
the compositive human imagination, which are responsible for active,
creative use of mental images, for they relate together (compose) the
images retained by the retentive imagination into such imaginary objects as
unicorns. It animals this process is simply associative, while in man it may
be creative, hence the distinction of two faculties. The fifth internal sense
was estimation, a kind of natural instinct for making judgments about the
"intentions" of external objects. The dog avoids the stick because it has
learned the stick's punishing "intentions".
Ibn-Sina's faculty psychology. (Figure)
( from AGENT INTELLECT
A DIVINE LIGHT CREATING HUMAN KNOWLEDGE)
1.RATIONAL SOUL:-
*Contemplative Intellect-knows universals.
*Practical Intellect-manages everyday affairs
2.Sensitive Soul:-
a. Appetite:
b. Interior Senses:
~Recollection-recalls intuitions from memory
~Memory-stores intuitions from estimation
~Estimation-intuitions about benefit and harm
~Compositive human imagination-creative imagination
~Compositive animal imagination-combines images
~Retentive imagination-image-copies of object's
~Common sense-combines the five exterior senses
c. Exterior Senses:
Vision, Hearing, Reproduction,Touch, Taste, Smell
3.VEGETATIVE SOUL
Reproduction ,Growth and Nourishment.
_______________________________
The wolf seeks the sheep for it knows the sheep is edible. This power,
similar to the simple conditioning of modern psychologists, "estimates" the
value or harm of objects in the animal's world.
The highest internal senses are memory and recollection. Memory stores
the intuitions of estimation. These intuitions are not sensible attributes of
the object, but rather simple ideas of the object's essence. Recollection is
the ability to recall these intuitions at a later time. The material stored by
memory and recalled by recollection are thus not copies of objects, for this
function is performed by the retentive and compositive imaginations.
Instead, the material is a set of simple but abstract ideas, or general
conclusions, derived from experience. They are not, how- ever, true
universals, for only, the human mind has the power to form universals.
(explanation of figure):-
The final aspect of the sensitive soul treated by ibn Sina is motivation. As
Aristotle had pointed out, what sets animals apart from plants is that they
move themselves. Ibn Sina, following Aristotle, calls this motive power
appetite, and it has two forms. Animals sense pain or danger, and flee; this
may be called avoidance. On the other hand, animals sense or anticipate
pleasure, and move toward it; this is approach.
The mental powers and senses so far considered by ibn Sina are tied to
the body and brain and are held in common by man and animal. However,
man surpasses the animals in the ability to form universal concepts. This is
the unique power of the human soul that alone transcends the material
body and brain. Ibn- Sina distinguished two faculties within the human soul:
practical intellect and the contemplative intellect. The lower practical
intellect concerns itself with everyday affairs. It regulates the body,
maintains good behavior, and protects the contempla-
tive intellect so it may fulfill itself.