Language and Argument Guide
Language and Argument Guide
Language and Argument Guide
1
Persuasive language techniques
When you are confronted with a piece of persuasive writing, it is useful to think
about how the writer is using language to persuade. Writers can use numerous
strategies to convince you of their point-of-view.
2
People's concern about ‘The government is going - Positions the reader to
Appeal to the
positions readers to feel money out of purses and who want to raise prices,
threatened by those who wallets.’ fees etc.
nerve
Suggests that people’s ‘If we don’t act now we - Pressures the reader to
safety, security or will be in mortal danger’ feel that solutions are
freedom are at risk. needed urgently so they
Appeal to fear
Suggests that traditional The government needs - Leads the reader to view
family life provides the to make the well-being of traditional nuclear families
family values
fundamental human
rights’
Overused phrases that a ‘Let’s hope he turns over - Reassure the reader
wide range of readers a new leaf’ through a family
can recognise. expression that can
position the reader to
accept an idea because
they are lulled into an
Cliché
uncritical mindset.
3
Is convincing someone of My three decades of - Ethos confirms the
the character or experience in public credibility of the
credibility of the service, my tireless writer/speaker, making
persuader. commitment to the them more trustworthy in
people of this the eyes of their
community, and my readers/listeners, who are
willingness to reach then more easily
across the aisle and persuaded by their
cooperate with the arguments.
opposition, make me the
Ethos
4
Using “we”, “our”, “us”, “We all know that…” - The reader is positioned
etc. to include the to agree with the writer
readers in the same because it appeals to their
group as the writer. desire to belong to the
Language
Inclusive
through the words that ones who made the well as creating a “them
they use. decision. and us” mentally.
reader a new
perspective/way of looking
at an idea, or person.
- Connotation refers to The stupid mutt needs a - Words may have positive
the additional meaning leash, so he doesn’t run or negative connotations
we associate with a away at the park. depending on the social,
word other than its cultural, personal
explicit/literal meaning. experiences of individuals.
- Negative connotation is For example, the words
Negative Connotation
meanings.
Rebuttal refers to an However this isn't - The purpose of a
attempt to disapprove, entirely true as... rebuttal is to prove that
contradict or argue the opposing argument is
against an opposing false, this may mean that
argument, by using the author suggests an
Rebuttal
6
The use of irony to “English is definitely my - To discredit an argument
mock or convey favourite subject, because through mockery.
contempt. I really love all the
reading and I never get
bored of writing essays,
they are the best.”
Sarcasm
7
Identifying persuasive techniques
• According to a recent survey, 67% of Australians agree.
• Professor Andrew Horner once described the proposal as a ‘disgrace’.
• Surely, we all agree that this is the right course of action.
• The money is a drop in the bucket compared to what the government spends on other
services.
• It’s a more humane, more sensible option.
• Can’t you do anything right?
• The government’s decision is nothing short of disgraceful and will cause untold trauma
and anguish for those involved.
• It will be the end of civilisation as we know it.
• There’s a million reasons the proposal won’t work.
• The decision was a kick in the guts for workers everywhere.
• He was as fit as a fiddle.
• The slaughter of sheep in overseas abattoirs is hideously brutal.
• It’s a problem that we can’t turn away from.
• The government has been working like dogs to achieve this change.
• Why should I have to put up with foul-mouthed language on public transport?
• Experts agree that treating drug addiction like a disease is the right thing to do.
8
Appealing to emotions
Writers will often appeal to different emotions to convince you of a particular point
of view. When you are reading a piece of persuasive writing, think carefully about
how the writer is trying to make you feel. Persuasive writers commonly appeal to
these emotions:
Compassion
Writers often make arguments that rely on exploiting the reader’s sense of compassion. This
type of argument makes the reader feel sorry for a particular group of people who have endured
some kind of hardship.
Fairness
No one likes being treated unfairly. Persuasive writers frequently play on their readers’ sense of
fairness to persuade. If a writer attempts to convince you that something is unfair or that people
have been treated poorly, they may be exploiting your sense of fairness.
Family
Everyone believes that family is important. As such, persuasive writers often appeal to a sense of
family and family values. These arguments often build support for a particular point of view by
claiming that the issue will have a damaging effect on family life.
Fear
Fear is a strong motivator and writers often use it to rally support for their point of view. An
argument in support of law and order, might create a sense of fear that the reader will be a victim
of crime.
Money
Money is important and we don’t like to feel that we’ve been ripped off. Writers often exploit
this to convince readers of a particular point of view, pointing out that they will be worse off
financially or might benefit from a particular decision. This is often called appealing to the ‘hip
pocket nerve’.
Patriotism
Belief in your country is a powerful emotion. Writers often stir up patriotic feelings to persuade.
If a writer points out how great your home country is, they might be playing on your sense of
patriotism.
This is not an extensive list of emotions. Whenever you are reading a piece of persuasive writing, think
about the emotions and attitudes that the writer might be playing on to persuade the audience of a
particular point of view. Think about how the author might have picked a particular emotional appeal to
target their specific audience, i.e. appealing to family values to convince mothers that they should not buy
sugary products, as those products are harmful to their children.
9
Tone! What is tone?!
When you are thinking about the use of persuasive language in a piece of writing, it
is also important to consider the tone. The word ‘tone’ refers to the overall feeling
of a piece of writing, or the feeling that the author is trying to express about their
subject.
When you are presented with a piece of persuasive writing, it’s useful to think
about how tone helps to persuade the audience. A humorous article, for example,
might persuade by gently poking fun at the people who support a particular idea. A
logical article might persuade by presenting a well-organised case supported by
evidence. In your analysis, always identify the tone of the article and explain how it
helps to persuade the audience.
10
Logical – Reasonable, moderate, rational, straightforward,
Sarcastic – Sharp, satirical, scathing, cutting, razor-edged, caustic, harsh, severe, spiteful,
vicious, venomous, vindictive, malicious.
Keep in mind that these words and phrases are not an extensive list. When identifying the tone of a piece
of writing, think about how it sounds, then use your dictionary or thesaurus to find the right word to
describe its tone.
11
Identifying tone
• Our public parks and waterways are thriving, thanks largely to highly effective
environmental protection laws and the hard work of enthusiastic volunteers around
Australia. It’s terrific to see that we really care about our environmental legacy.
• The Prime Minister should hang his head in shame. The treatment of asylum seekers is
nothing short of a disgraceful blight on Australia’s international reputation. To the rest of
the world, we’re selfish and cruel and insular.
• We should feel sorry for the friends and families. They’re the real victims of road
accidents. Imagine the grief and sorrow that tears through a community in the aftermath
of a tragic accident like this.
• Thanks to the government’s broadband policy, we’re looking at a period of great promise
where Australians will have access to new, exciting employment opportunities and
business will experience incredible new growth.
• You should feel ripped off. After all it’s your tax dollars that have paid for this terrible
idea.
• Seeing people whose lives have been affected by gambling in this way is a harrowing
experience. You begin to understand the way that it tears apart families and harms the
most vulnerable people in our society.
• There are numerous reasons why we should start treating drug addiction like a disease.
First, punitive measures simply aren’t working. Second, it has been demonstrated time
and time again - in countries like Sweden - that this type of approach simply works.
12
Preparing your analysis
Before you write a language analysis essay, you must read and annotate the text to
better your understanding of it. The process of read, chunk, annotate will help you
to understand the key arguments and the techniques that are used to support the
author’s point of view (contention). It is important to understand the whole
text and how the author develops their argument across the text.
Read the article several times before you start writing and following the following
steps:
• Step One: Read
While you are reading you should be trying to identify the contention, audience, purpose
and tone of the piece. Think about how the tone might change throughout the piece.
• Step Two: Chunk
What are the key arguments/reasons that the author has used to support their
contention? Identify the key points that the author uses to support their contention. How
do the arguments connect/flow from each other? Does the author revisit arguments at
different points during the article?
• Step Three: Annotate
Identify and label all of the
persuasive techniques that you
can, in each chunk. Decide which
persuasive techniques you are
going to analyse in your writing
and note the effect(s) of those
techniques – how do they support
the argument? How do they
target/influence the audience?
13
Writing your analysis
Once you have read the article several times, and started to consider how the
writer is using language to persuade, it is time to start writing your analysis.
Remember, your analysis is a clear and straightforward discussion of how a writer
is using language to persuade.
Introduction
A good introduction is critical for all forms of analytical writing, and language analysis is no
different! Your introduction should show your understanding of the article and the issue, you
must identify and describe the following:
• Contention: What is the author’s overall argument? What is their stance on the issue?
• Audience: Who are they targeting? Who did they want to read this piece of writing?
• Purpose: What do they want their audience to think/do?
• Tone: What is the tone of the article, and what effect does it have on the reader?
• Issue: What is the issue that the author is exploring?
• Publication: Where is this article being published? (This should help you to identify the
audience).
Body paragraphs
In the body of your analysis, you need to clearly identify the different techniques that the writer
has used, and explain how they help to persuade the reader. Your body paragraphs should follow
this structure:
• Argument: Explain one the arguments (reasons) the author makes to support their
contention.
• Technique: Explain one of the persuasive techniques the author employs to make this
argument.
• Evidence: Provide evidence of this technique.
• Effect: What is the effect/impact of the technique? What does it make the reader
think/feel/do?
• Technique: Explain a second (different!) technique that the author uses to make this
argument.
• Evidence: Provide evidence of the second technique
• Effect: Explain the effect/impact of this technique, how does it work with the first
technique?
Conclusion
The conclusion should bring your analysis to a close, giving an overview of the different techniques
that the author has used to persuade. Advanced conclusions will comment on how the persuasive
language, and the arguments, are developed to lead the intended audience to agree/act on the
author’s contention.
14
Using quotes
In your analysis you will need to use short examples which help to explain how the
writer has used a particular technique to support their argument. Try to keep these
quotes (examples) short and appropriate. Integrating quotes – quoting a few words,
or part of a sentence – in a sentence of your own, can help to explain the impact
of language more successfully than copying a whole sentence.
If you need to include a whole sentence, use a colon to introduce the quote:
Towards the beginning of the article, the writer argues that people who download film
and television are doing the wrong thing: “Let’s face it. When we download a television
program, we’re little better than common thieves.” The use of inclusive language positions
the reader to accept the author’s argument by creating a friendly tone, whilst still showing
that the actions of downloading are wrong, and that everyone is responsible, not only for
the problem, but also the solution.
When you are writing your analysis, do not simply use a quote from the article without any discussion.
Remember, you need to explain how language and persuasive techniques are being used to persuade the
audience.
15
Punctuation in quotes
Important things to remember when integrating quotes into your sentences:
16
Integrating quotes
• “I've heard the argument that it tastes good, but you've been living under a rock if you
haven't had meat-free food that's delicious.”
• “Animal rights groups harp on about mistreated puppies and the slaughtering of whales,
but I can't help but think there's a very large white elephant in the room. Those things are
valid, but aren't the millions of farm animals being butchered each year as a luxury not
worth fighting for as well?”
• “We had a pet dog, a turtle, some mice, and a budgie or two who were my friends. I'd
feed them and play with them just like any normal kid. I never made the connection
between the animals I loved and the food on my dinner plate. One day something clicked
though. I was 18 at the time. It was not anything big or exciting, I just wondered why I
actually needed pepperoni on a pizza that was already delicious.”
• “Call me a tree-hugging hippie if you must, but the simple facts are that I live in the First
World, I'm not dying of starvation and I can buy thousands of delicious things that aren't
dead from the local supermarket.”
• “There is a truckload of statistics and facts that I could wheel out to put my case, but
there was one startling fact that always stuck out in my mind: You need to feed cattle five
kilos of grain to make one kilo of beef.”
• “I'm all about conserving life. I don't eat or kill animals anymore because it is just not
necessary.”
17
Useful phrases
When you are writing your analysis, finding the right words to show your
understanding of persuasive techniques can sometimes be difficult. Here are some
phrases that will help you to improve the expression of your analytical language.
Try to use a variety of different sentence starts and expressions, using the same words over and over,
becomes very repetitive and uninteresting to read!
18
Visual texts
Persuasive writing is often accompanied by visual material – including photographs,
cartoons, graphs, and charts – which can help to persuade the reader to agree with
a particular point of view. Visuals may inform, shock, engage, or manipulate the
emotions of a reader. They are deliberately chosen to accompany the written text
that they sit alongside, and they can be just as powerful as the words themselves.
Photographs
It is often a good idea to start by considering what has been included in the photograph and what
has been left out. Photographs, like all media texts, are constructed. When someone takes a
photograph, they make decisions about what will be included and left out of the photograph. In
newspapers, writers often don’t have a say about the images that accompany their article but
subeditors usually choose an image that will reinforce the point-of-view and tone of the article.
Cartoons
Cartoons often accompany opinion articles online and in newspapers. Political cartoons often
stand alone as persuasive texts. If they accompany an article, they are usually not the work of the
writer but often reinforce the message or tone of the article. Cartoons are often used to ridicule
and caricature politicians. They might comment on the absurdity of a situation. Although people
think about cartoons as light-hearted, they often use satire to highlight important issues.
20
Visual analysis
21
Final dos and don’ts
Some useful things to remember, and some things to avoid!
22
makes the reader feel’ or ‘this helps to make conclusion, bringing your discussion back to
the reader think’. the tone of the article can be an effective way
to show an understanding of the writer’s
DO Use short, relevant quotes
overall approach to persuasion.
Short and relevant quotations from the
article can help to explain how language and
DO Proofread
persuasive techniques are being used to When you’ve finished writing your analysis,
influence the audience. Never use a quote it’s a good idea to proofread your work. As
from the article without discussing its impact you’re reading, ask yourself whether you
on the audience. have clearly identified a range of persuasive
techniques and explained how they influence
DO Write a conclusion
the reader. When you are proofreading,
A good conclusion will provide closure to make sure you eliminate any points that
your analysis. When you’re writing the aren’t relevant or might be poorly explained.
23