AHLPakistanStrategy2025_Conqueringnewheights
AHLPakistanStrategy2025_Conqueringnewheights
AHLPakistanStrategy2025_Conqueringnewheights
AHL Research
D: +92 21 32462742
UAN: +92 21 111 245 111, Ext: 322 Best Securities House: ‘23 Best Investment Top 25 Companies Excellence Award Leading
E: research@arifhabibltd.com Best Investment Bank: ’23 Bank:’22 (‘17-’19) Brokerage House for RDA ’21
Pakistan Investment Strategy
2025
Valuations are still compelling: Even with a 50.8% return during CY24TD, the Target 2025 Current Index
KSE100 index remains undervalued across various valuation perspectives. 120,010 94,192
▪ On P/E basis, the KSE100 index is trading at 5.3x; 36.1% discount to last 10-year
average of 8.3x.
▪ The KSE-100 Index is trading at market cap to GDP of 11.1%, a discount of 34.3% Expected Return 2025
compared to last 10-year average. 27.4%
Sectoral views:
▪ Banks: Subdued interest rates to suppress earnings, but banks to focus on
volumetric growth to ensure profitability.
▪ E&P: Earnings to remain broadly unchanged, higher payouts and circular debt
resolution will keep the sector in limelight.
▪ Fertilizer: Stable urea and higher DAP offtake alongside margins to propel
earning growth of 11.4%.
▪ Cement: Margins to remain elevated due to better power mix and low coal prices
leading to 32.1% earnings growth.
▪ OMCs: The sector is expected to witnessed 39.1% earnings growth amid
reduction in inventory losses, alongside improved OMC margins.
▪ Textile: Global recovery to drive demand, however higher taxes to hurt
profitability.
▪ Technology: Earnings growth of 39.3% is driven by a stable demand
environment, innovation, and increasing adoption of digital solutions.
▪ Autos: Demand to recover following economic stability and lower interest rates,
with EVs to gain prominence.
Top picks: OGDC, PPL, PSO, NBP, FABL, UBL, FFC, LUCK, FCCL, MLCF, INDU,
HUMNL, AIRLINK, SYS and HTL.
Closing as of 14-Nov-2024
Table of Contents
AHL Portfolio
Outperforms, yet again!
AHL Model portfolio has been consistently outperforming all the benchmark indices
since inception. The portfolio has outperformed the benchmark KSE-30, KMI-30 and
KSE-100 indices by 107.9%, 92.9% and 70.5% respectively since inception. From the
last rebalancing (Jul’24), AHL model portfolio outperformed KSE-30, KMI-30 and
KSE-100 indices by 18.0%, 19.9% and 13.5%, respectively.
For CY25 we are rebalancing our model portfolio. We have closed our position in
MARI (previously 5.0%) and HUBC (previously 5.0%) and added PSO, HUMNL,
AIRLINK and HTL with a weight of 10.0%, 5.0%, 2.5% and 2.5% respectively. We
have increased FFC weight to 7.5% (previously 5.0%) while reducing UBL, MEBL,
MLCF and LUCK weight to 5.0%, 7.5%, 7.5% and 5.0% respectively (previously 7.5%,
10.0%, 10.0% and 10.0%). Due to recent developments in the banking sector,
specifically the imposition of MDR requirements on Islamic banks, we have closed our
position in MEBL.
Figure: AHL model portfolio performance (since inception) Figure: AHL model portfolio performance (Jun-2024)
AHL Model Portfolio KSE100 KSE30 KMI30 AHL Model Portfolio KSE100
KSE30 KMI30
330% 139.00%
300% 132.00%
270%
125.00%
240%
118.00%
210%
111.00%
180%
150% 104.00%
120% 97.00%
90%
90.00%
Dec-22
Jun-23
Dec-23
Jun-24
Apr-23
Aug-23
Oct-23
Apr-24
Aug-24
Oct-24
Feb-23
Feb-24
Jul-24
Jul-24
Jul-24
Jul-24
Jun-24
Aug-24
Aug-24
Aug-24
Aug-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
Sep-24
Sep-24
Sep-24
Nov-24
Nov-24
Oct-24
Oct-24
Oct-24
Oct-24
Source (s): Bloomberg, PSX, AHL Research Source (s): Bloomberg, PSX, AHL Research
Pakistan at a glance
Exhibit: Pakistan at a Glance
Economy Equities
Lower Middle-Income Class (of population) 40.5% Benchmark Index KSE100 Index
Per Capita Income (USD, FY24) 1,673 Total Market Cap (USD bn, Nov'24) 43.8
GDP size (USD bn, FY24) 374 Free Float Market Cap (USD bn, Nov'24) 12.1
Sovereign Rating Fitch: CCC+, Moody's: Caa2 Avg. Daily Traded Value (USD mn, CY24TD) 67.1
SBP Reserves (USD bn, Nov'24) 11.3 Avg. Daily Traded Volume (mn shr. CY24TD) 480.0
Current Account Balance (USD mn, 1QFY25) (98) MSCI Category Frontier Markets
Domestic Debt as % of GDP (FY24) 44.6% Net Foreign Flows (USD mn, CY24TD) (35.7)
Politics
Stability is crucial
The current environment suggests that the PSX is on the brink of a fresh era
characterized by long-awaited re-rating and value realization, offering promising
opportunities for investors. As the government seeks to reassure both local and
international stakeholders, maintaining a stable political environment will be essential
for fostering continued investment and economic growth.
Going forward, we remain optimistic that the incumbent government will remain
committed to the IMF and fulfill the benchmarks laid out under the EFF to ensure that
Pakistan achieves sustainable economic growth. Adhering to these benchmarks is
vital not only for restoring investor confidence but also for stabilizing the
macroeconomic environment. By meeting the stipulated requirements, the
government can pave the way for structural reforms that enhance fiscal discipline,
bolster external reserves, and create a more conducive environment for both domestic
and foreign investments.
Figure: Average CPI and policy rate Figure: SBP reserves and PKR/USD
Average CPI Policy Rate (Period End) SBP Reserves Average PKR/USD (RHS)
(USD bn)
40% 12.00 310
35%
10.00 300
30%
8.00 290
25%
15%
4.00 270
10%
2.00 260
5%
0% - 250
Jul-23
Jul-24
Jun-23
Aug-23
Sep-23
Nov-23
Dec-23
Jan-24
Jun-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
Mar-23
Apr-23
Oct-23
Mar-24
Apr-24
Oct-24
Nov-24*
Feb-23
May-23
Feb-24
May-24
Jul-23
Jul-24
Jun-23
Feb-23
Nov-23
Dec-23
Jan-24
Jun-24
Nov-24
Apr-23
Aug-23
Sep-23
Oct-23
Apr-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
Oct-24
Mar-23
May-23
Feb-24
Mar-24
May-24
Source (s): PBS, SBP, AHL Research Source (s): SBP, AHL Research, *as of 1st Nov
Figure: Trend of consumer confidence index Figure: Trend of business confidence index
Next six months CCI
Next six months BCI
51.00 62.00
48.00 56.00
45.00 50.00
42.00 44.00
39.00 38.00
36.00 32.00
33.00 26.00
30.00 20.00
Jul-23
Jul-24
Jun-23
Nov-23
Dec-23
Jan-24
Jun-24
Apr-23
Aug-23
Sep-23
Oct-23
Apr-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
Oct-24
Feb-23
Mar-23
May-23
Feb-24
Mar-24
May-24
Jul-24
Jul-23
Jun-24
Jun-23
Nov-23
Dec-23
Jan-24
Apr-23
Aug-23
Sep-23
Oct-23
Apr-24
Feb-23
Mar-23
May-23
Feb-24
Mar-24
May-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
Oct-24
Source (s): SBP, AHL Research Source (s): SBP, AHL Research
Economy
From challenges to changes
Path to consolidation: The fiscal outlook for Pakistan in FY25e reflects an ambitious,
yet achievable, path toward fiscal consolidation, building on the progress made in FY24.
For FY25b, the government has laid out a fiscal adjustment plan aimed at reducing the
overall fiscal deficit from 6.8% of GDP in FY24 to 5.9% (our expectation is 4.9%). This
plan includes both revenue-enhancing and expenditure-controlling measures. The
government projects gross revenue at 14.3% of GDP and total spending at 15.2% of
GDP. While these targets are ambitious, there is potential for the deficit to be reduced
even further, potentially down to 4.9% of GDP (we view), if reforms are successfully
implemented. Key to achieving this will be the government’s commitment to improving
tax collection through direct and indirect taxes, including bringing the retail, export, and
agricultural sectors fully into the tax net and curtailing markup expense.
9.0%
7.9% 7.8%
8.0%
7.1%
6.8%
7.0%
6.1%
6.0% 5.5%
4.9%
5.0%
4.0%
3.0%
2.0%
1.0%
0.0%
FY20 FY21 FY22 FY23 FY24 FY25e FY26f
Source (s): MoF, AHL Research
Revenue assumption remains aggressive: On the revenue front, the FBR target of
PKR 12.9trn set for FY25 faces significant challenges as economic conditions and tax
collection trends reveal potential shortfalls. With roughly 40% of FBR’s revenue
historically dependent on import taxes, the high tariffs and restrictions on non-essential
imports, combined with PKR stability, mean customs duties and import sales tax
collections may struggle to meet their targets. Although the FBR projects additional
revenue from GDP and LSM growth, inflation, and recent tax measures, the first four
months already missed its target by ~ PKR 190bn. Achieving FY25’s 40% YoY revenue
growth increase will hinge on robust enforcement and favorable economic shifts.
Moreover, the authorities aim to generate significant non-tax revenue, with the SBP alone
contributing PKR 2.5trn in profits. This revenue boost, alongside targeted tax policy
reforms, will be essential for meeting fiscal targets. As per the Budget FY25, personal
10.0 9.3
8.0 7.2
6.1
6.0 4.8
4.0
4.0
2.0
-
FY20 FY21 FY22 FY23 FY24 FY25e FY26f
Source (s): MoF, FBR, AHL Research
Lower current expenditure to provide respite: While the revenue side of the fiscal
equation is critical, managing expenditures remains a pressing challenge. Non- ▪ FBR's FY25 revenue target of PKR 12.9trn
overambitious.
development expenditures continue to weigh heavily on the budget, largely due to
▪ Significant interest rate cuts may help reduce
soaring mark-up payments, which surged by 42% in FY24 and are projected to rise debt-servicing costs to PKR 7.8trn (Budgeted:
another 20% in FY25, reaching an anticipated PKR 9.8trn. However, substantial interest PKR 9.8trn).
rate cuts could help ease debt-servicing costs. The government’s recent T-bill buyback ▪ Develop. exp likely to fall short of the PKR
1.7trn budgeted number.
program, funded by SBP profits, also aims to reduce debt levels. We estimate that these
measures could bring debt servicing down to approximately PKR 7.8trn 4.1% lower YoY
than FY24's PKR 8.2trn and well below the budgeted PKR 9.8trn for FY25. Additionally,
with a tighter grip on expenses, development spending may also fall short of the
budgeted PKR 1.7trn, potentially landing closer to PKR 1trn by year-end.
Figure: Total public debt (%) Figure: Markup expense as % of FBR revenue
FY16
FY17
FY18
FY19
FY20
FY21
FY22
FY23
FY24
FY25e
Source (s): MOF, AHL Research, *including IMF Source (s): FBR, MOF, AHL Research
Economic revitalization via privatization: The need for privatization has never been
more critical. Historically, SOEs have been a substantial drain on Pakistan’s public
finances, contributing to chronic budget deficits and stifling economic growth. In FY23
alone, 23 of these entities collectively posted a staggering loss of PKR 905bn, while the
country’s top 15 profit-making SOEs only managed to generate a profit of PKR 687bn.
The inefficiencies within these enterprises have diverted much-needed resources away
from essential sectors such as healthcare, education, and infrastructure, underscoring
the necessity of privatizing these assets to improve fiscal stability.
Figure: Top 10 profit making entities Figure: Top 10 loss making entities
(PKR bn)
(PKR bn) OGDC NHA
PPL QESCO
PARCO PESCO
NBP PIA
PNSC SEPCO
GEPCO MEPCO
PKIC SSGC
- 50.0 100.0 150.0 200.0 250.0 - 100.0 200.0 300.0 400.0 500.0
Source (s): MoF, AHL Research Source (s): MoF, AHL Research
Further reforms are in the pipeline, with plans to bring all SOEs under the new legal
framework by Jun’25 and to revise the Sovereign Wealth Fund Act by Dec’24. These
legal adjustments will be complemented by efforts to improve the governance structures
Beyond SOE reform, the government is also focused on enhancing transparency and
governance across the public sector. Anti-corruption initiatives are being strengthened,
with a Governance and Corruption Diagnostic Assessment report set to be published by
July 2025. Moreover, asset declarations of high-level public officials are expected to be
publicly accessible by Feb’25, with appropriate safeguards for personal data. These
measures are expected to reduce corruption, enhance public trust, and create a more
transparent business environment. On the trade front, as per the latest IMF report, the
authorities are working to further liberalize trade policies by reducing tariffs and
simplifying import/export documentation. These reforms are part of the National Tariff
Policy (2025-2029) and are aimed at boosting competitiveness, facilitating private sector
growth, and promoting export-led economic development.
Turning to trade dynamics, we project a trade deficit of USD 30bn for FY25e, reflecting
an increase from the previous fiscal year. This reflects an increase from the previous
fiscal year, driven by a robust 10% YoY rise in imports, while exports are expected to
grow at a more conservative 3%. Despite the challenges posed by the global economic
climate, the government’s strategic initiatives aimed at enhancing export-oriented
sectors, along with declining oil prices, offer a glimmer of hope for improving the trade
balance.
FY18
FY20
FY21
FY22
FY23
FY24
FY25e
FY26f
Others
8.5
Source (s): SBP, AHL Research Source (s): SBP, AHL Research
40,000 35%
3.69 FY26
35,000 28%
3.41
Textile Group 30,000 21%
3.95
4.05 25,000 14%
Food Group
FY25 18.04 20,000 7%
- -21%
FY17
FY18
FY19
FY20
FY21
FY22
FY23
FY24
FY25e
FY26f
Source (s): AHL Research Source (s): SBP, AHL Research
FY18
FY17
FY19
FY20
FY21
FY22
FY23
FY24
FY25e
FY26f
Others Countries 1,196 1,174 1,114 1,055
Total 27,333 30,251 34,688 36,308
Source (s): SBP, AHL Research Source (s): SBP, AHL Research
Figure: Historical trend of current account deficit Figure: Historical trend of trade balance
(USD mn) Current Account Deficit YoY (RHS) Trade Deficit YoY (RHS)
(USD mn)
25,000 680% 48,000 54%
32,000 18%
15,000 340%
24,000 0%
10,000 170%
16,000 -18%
5,000 0%
8,000 -36%
0 -170% - -54%
FY17
FY18
FY19
FY20
FY21
FY22
FY23
FY24
FY25e
FY26f
FY23
FY17
FY18
FY19
FY20
FY21
FY22
FY24
FY25e
FY26f
Source (s): SBP, AHL Research Source (s): SBP, AHL Research
Bridging funding gap: For FY25, financing includes about USD 16.8bn in rollovers of
existing short-term financing and an additional USD 2.5bn in commitments from key
partners, such as China, Saudi Arabia, ADB, and the Islamic Development Bank (IsDB).
Additionally, authorities have received firm commitments from essential bilateral partners
to maintain their existing exposures throughout the program, ensuring continued rollover
of existing short-term liabilities, which will help meet financing needs during the remaining
program period. Loans from foreign commercial banks totaling USD 6.6bn, renewed
during the previous EFF and SBA, are also expected to continue during this new
program. Together with commitments from multilateral institutions, these arrangements
provide necessary financing assurances.
Recent media reports indicate that Pakistan has formally requested ~USD 1bnn from the
IMF under the Resilience and Sustainability Facility (RSF), in addition to its ongoing EFF.
The RSF, established in 2022, is designed to provide long-term concessional financing
to help low and middle-income countries address climate-related risks. This funding will
support essential climate-related initiatives, including adaptation measures and the
transition to cleaner energy sources. To highlight, in our report titled Pakistan’s Path to
Enhanced IMF Support, published on March 16, 2024, we emphasized the potential for ▪ EFF program requires reforms to address
structural challenges, emphasizing
Pakistan to engage in an Extended Fund Facility complemented by the newly established
improvements in economic policies,
Resilience and Sustainability Facility. expanding the tax base, and enhancing the
management of SOEs.
Taking cues from the recent IMF’s program for Bangladesh: Amid discussions for a ▪ Pakistan has formally requested ~ USD 1bn
more extensive IMF program, Pakistan can draw insights from Bangladesh's recent from the IMF under RST.
According to the IMF's country report, Pakistan faces a gross financing requirement of
USD 51bn for the fiscal years 2025 to 2027. Of this total, ~USD 10-11bn is rolled over
annually, reflecting a consistent figure each year. The net repayable amount stands at
around USD 8-9bn per year, with an estimated USD 4-5bn comprising payments to
multilateral creditors. Positively, Pakistan receives roughly the same amount annually in
inflows from these multilateral sources, indicating that the net repayable amount can be
managed effectively, provided timely rollovers continue. However, rather than relying
solely on annual rollovers, it would be more prudent for the government to seek loan
reprofiling to distribute the debt burden over a more extended period, thereby easing
fiscal pressures. Continued engagement with the IMF is crucial for Pakistan as it
addresses these economic challenges. This relationship is vital for attracting inflows from
other lenders, securing FDI, and reentering international capital markets.
Following the IMF disbursement, the country is well-positioned to attract inflows from
multilateral and bilateral lenders. Initiatives to boost Foreign Direct Investment, enhance
export performance, and eventually re-enter international capital markets are expected
to bolster the external account further. With these strategic initiatives, the SBP is
projected to close FY25 with reserves estimated at USD 13bn. The strengthening of
reserves has played a vital role in stabilizing the PKR. A key catalyst for this recovery
was the nine-month SBA with the IMF, which provided essential policy support and
reinstated effective operations in the foreign exchange market. Additionally, the
government's removal of multiple currency practices and lifting of restrictions on import
advance payments have further contributed to stabilizing the PKR. The recovery of the
PKR has been particularly noteworthy, rebounding from declines of 23% and 28% in
FY22 and FY23, respectively, to a 4% appreciation against the USD in FY24. This
impressive turnaround is a direct result of the increased foreign exchange reserves,
which have instilled confidence in the currency market and attracted investor interest.
Moreover, the recent successful execution of the IMF EFF program has not only
enhanced foreign exchange reserves but is likely to unlock additional funding and
facilitate new borrowing and rollovers from international partners. The IMF program ▪ Strengthened reserves have stabilized the
PKR, supported by the IMF program and the
underscores the importance of maintaining a market-determined exchange rate as a removal of multiple currency practices.
fundamental strategy to rectify external imbalances and support the gradual buildup of ▪ We expect PKR/USD will be around 280 by
reserves. Dec’24 and 288.4 by Jun’25.
Improved reserves to support parity: Looking ahead, forecasts indicate that by Dec’24
and Jun’25, the PKR/USD exchange rates are likely to hover around 280 and 288.4,
respectively. Rebuilding reserves is crucial to ensuring that gross reserves cover at least
three months of imports, supported by disbursements from multilateral and bilateral
loans, along with foreign exchange purchases. Should outflow pressures resurface, the
SBP remains committed to allowing flexible exchange rate adjustments while refraining
from intervening against a trend depreciation. The foreign exchange market has shown
significant improvement, with the interbank-open market spread remaining negligible,
enabling the SBP to make substantial foreign exchange purchases, effectively doubling
its reserves. Our projections for SBP reserves for FY25 are as follows.
Figure: Historical trend of PKR/USD Figure: Historical trend of SBP reserves and PKR parity
SBP Reserves Period end PKR/USD (RHS)
(USD bn)
350 18 16.1 350
300 15 300
13.1
250 13 250
11.2
10.3
200 10 9.4 200
150 8 150
100
5 4.1 100
50
3 50
-
FY20 FY21 FY22 FY23 FY24 FY25e 0 -
FY20 FY21 FY22 FY23 FY24 FY25e
Source (s): SBP, AHL Research Source (s): SBP, AHL Research
Base effect verses real measures: The initial success in curbing inflation was relatively
straightforward, primarily attributable to base effects. The rapid escalation of energy
prices, driven by geopolitical tensions, could not sustain its steep upward trajectory,
leading to a moderation in year-over-year increases. Moreover, the sharp rise in food
prices, initially exacerbated by shortages, has begun to stabilize. These developments,
coupled with disciplined monetary and fiscal measures, have played a pivotal role in
fostering a sustained reduction in inflationary pressures. The impact of higher interest
rates is increasingly evident, as they systematically alleviate inflationary pressures on
the headline CPI. The momentum of rising prices is diminishing, signaling that monetary
tightening is gradually bringing inflation under control. Should this trend persist, the State
Bank of Pakistan (SBP) is likely to approach its medium-term inflation target of 5-7% by
Sep’25. Current forecasts suggest that inflation may further decline, averaging around
7.5% in FY25, representing a reduction from FY24's average of 23.4%.
35.00%
29.04%
30.00%
25.00% 23.88%
5.00%
0.00%
FY20 FY21 FY22 FY23 FY24 FY25e FY26f
Sales tax sensitivity analysis: One of the proposals to bridge the tax collection gap is Exhibit: Sensitivity Analysis - Sales tax on POL
to implement a sales tax on petroleum products. In 4MFY25, the revenue shortfall has
Sales Tax Revenue FY25 Avg
reached ~PKR 190bn. Since Jan’22, the government has been charging zero sales tax tax (PKR bn) Inflation
on these products. However, we have already factored in a 5% sales tax on petroleum Base Case 5.0% 130 7.50%
products starting from Dec’24 in our base case. To provide more insight, we have run a
Case-1 10.0% 260 7.67%
sensitivity analysis on the potential increase in sales tax and its impact on both inflation
Case-2 15.0% 391 7.84%
and tax revenue. Please refer to the table.
Case-3 18.0% 469 7.95%
To support economic growth, the SBP implemented its first rate cut in June 2024, Source (s): AHL Research
reducing the policy rate by 150bps, followed by a 100bps cut in July, 200bps in
September, and a 250bps reduction in November, bringing the rate down to 15%.
However, given that inflation projections suggest the base effect will end by the close of
1QCY25, we believe the SBP will adopt a more cautious stance going forward, likely
reducing the policy rate to 12% by the end of FY25. Pakistan's real interest rate remains
exceptionally high, reaching ~7.8% on a spot basis. Even on a forward 12-month basis,
real interest rates hover around 694bps. Historically, Pakistan's average real interest rate
has ranged between 1.5% and 2%, indicating substantial room for rate cuts to bring the
real interest rate closer to historical norms.
Figure: Trend of National CPI and Core Figure: Real Interest Rates in Pakistan
Core Inflation Food Inflation CPI (RHS) RiR (RHS) Core Inflation Policy Rate
29% 30% 24% 12%
21% 9%
24% 25%
18%
6%
19% 20%
15%
3%
14% 15% 12%
0%
9%
9% 10%
-3%
6%
4% 5% -6%
3%
-1% 0% 0% -9%
Jul-24
Jan-24
Jun-24
Jan-25
Jun-25
Apr-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
Oct-24
Nov-24
Dec-24
Apr-25
Feb-24
Mar-24
May-24
Feb-25
Mar-25
May-25
Jul-24
Jan-24
Jun-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
Nov-24
Dec-24
Jan-25
Jun-25
Mar-24
Apr-24
Oct-24
Mar-25
Apr-25
Feb-24
May-24
Feb-25
May-25
Source (s): PBS, AHL Research Source (s): PBS, SBP, AHL Research
In its recent statement following the signing of the Staff-Level Agreement for the
Extended Fund Facility program, the IMF underscored the need for monetary policy to
prioritize disinflation in order to protect real incomes, particularly for vulnerable
populations. Lowering the policy rate to 13.5% by Dec’24 and 12% by Jun’25 aligns with
the IMF's guidance, as the current rate of 15% remains higher than what is needed for a
disinflationary stance, we believe.
Agriculture growth to remain subdued: The robust 16.8% increase in major crops
during FY24 has been a defining factor in Pakistan's economic growth narrative.
However, as we look ahead to FY25e, the outlook appears less favorable, with a
projected slight increase in output of 0.42%. In light of this, farmers are reassessing their
sowing strategies for staple wheat, particularly after the Punjab government’s failure to
procure grain last season an issue of significant concern, given that Punjab contributes
70% of the nation’s wheat production. Additionally, challenges such as water scarcity
and rising temperatures have already begun to adversely affect cotton sowing and yields.
The situation is further complicated by India’s re-entry into the global rice export market,
which poses a risk to Pakistan's multibillion-dollar rice exports.
We anticipate that the growth momentum in the services sector will persist into FY25,
bolstered by developments in commodity-producing sectors and increased goods
imports. Specifically, LSM is expected to contribute positively to this growth. Merchandise ▪ Agri- sector growth est. to grow at +0.42%
imports are projected to rise to USD 59.4bn in FY25e, up from USD 53bn last year, in FY25.
reflecting an expansion in economic activities that will positively impact wholesale and ▪ Industry is expected to grow by 2.62%.
▪ Services are projected to grow by 3.23%.
retail trade as well as the transport sectors during the review period. In addition to these
▪ LSM and wholesale & retail trade -key
trends, the services sector particularly wholesale and retail trade, along with finance and contributors to economic growth.
insurance is poised to maintain its upward trajectory, supported by favorable policies
from the SBP. A standout area is Pakistan’s rapidly expanding IT industry, which has
demonstrated remarkable growth in export earnings for FY24.
Key risks: However, the path to sustained growth is not without its challenges.
Geopolitical uncertainties, global inflationary pressures, and a potential rise in oil prices
could drive up inflation, increasing costs for consumers and businesses alike. These
factors will play a crucial role in shaping the country’s overall economic performance in
the coming fiscal year. Overcoming these challenges will be essential for maintaining
growth momentum. Continued monetary easing, coupled with efforts to lower business
costs such as cutting energy prices could create a more supportive environment for
economic growth. Attracting foreign investment and boosting export potential will be key
in strengthening the economy. Additionally, addressing the effects of climate-related
risks, especially in the agricultural sector, will be crucial to keeping the recovery on
course.
Various organizations have forecasted Pakistan's GDP growth with differing outlooks for
the ongoing fiscal year FY24-25. BMI, a Fitch Solutions company, projects growth at
3.2%, while the Asian Development Bank (ADB), in its Asian Development Outlook,
anticipates GDP growth of 2.4% for 2024 and 2.8% for 2025. The International Monetary
Fund (IMF) offers a more optimistic estimate of 3.5% for FY2024-25. Additionally, the
State Bank of Pakistan (SBP), in its recent State of the Economy report, expects GDP
growth to fall within the range of 2.5% to 3.5%, supported by lower borrowing costs and
a gradual recovery in the large-scale manufacturing and services sectors.
Figure: Historical trend of GDP growth Figure: Historical trend of Per Capita GDP (in USD)
(USD)
7.0%
6.2% 1,900 1,847
6.0% 5.8%
1,800 1,767
1,745
5.0% 4.7%
1,700 1,677 1,673
4.0%
1,600 1,553
3.0% 2.5% 2.4%
1,500 1,458
2.0%
1,400
1.0%
1,300
0.0%
FY20 FY21 FY22 FY23 FY24 FY25e FY26f 1,200
-0.2%
-1.0% FY20 FY21 FY22 FY23 FY24 FY25e FY26f
-0.9%
Source (s): MoF, AHL Research Source (s): MoF, AHL Research
Figure: Industrial sector breakdown Figure: Agriculture sector breakdown Figure: Service sector breakdown
-2.0% 3.0% 8.0% 13.0% -10.0% 0.0% 10.0% 0.0% 3.0% 6.0% 9.0%
Capital Market
Thrills and gains
Earnings for the E&P sector are projected to decline by 0.6%, amid lower oil and gas
production and the absence of exchange gains. The banking sector is expected to see a
Weight
6.4% decline due to anticipated reductions in interest rates impacting net interest
margins. In contrast, the fertilizer sector is poised for a 11.4% growth, driven by improved
50% 50%
margins and enhanced pricing power. Cement sector growth is forecasted at 32.1%,
underpinned by relatively better demand, stable product prices, and the decline in
interest rates. OMCs are anticipated to post a strong 39.1% increase in earnings,
supported by higher volumes amid economic growth. The auto sector is expected to grow Index
by 19.6%, supported by a revival of demand and increased auto financing facilitated by
lower interest rates. On the downside, the power sector is projected to experience a 119,459 120,561
significant 27.0% decline, primarily due to the termination of HUBC’s base plant. The
textile sector is likely to witness a steep 35.9% decline in earnings, driven by higher tax
rates and shrinking profit margins. Meanwhile, the chemicals sector is projected to
Target 2025 Current Index
achieve a promising 31.6% growth, attributed to better margins compared to the previous
120,010 94,192
year. Finally, the technology sector is set to benefit from the export of IT services and
improved consumer demand for smartphones, expected to post a 39.3% growth.
Expected Return 2025
27.4%
Rising investor
confidence: Boom in M&A
Business confidence activity:
level up 15pts to Next Leg of The country is
54.2pts, default risk experiencing a surge in
at 1,496bps Valuation Re-rating M&A activities, which is
compared to expected to drive
4,740bps (Oct’23) enhanced valuation
discovery.
Supportive macro
FDI inflows on the environment:
horizon:
Declining inflation and
Attracting export-led FDI interest rates, increasing
in agriculture, mining, FX reserves,
and IT, ensuring balance stabilized current account
of payments stability and and stable currency.
unlocking valuations.
Earnings growth:
Earnings growth expected
at 4.2% in 2025, led by
Cement, Fertilizer, OMCs,
Technology, Chemicals
and Autos.
Key Risks:
1. Macro-economic imbalances during the IMF program
2. Volatility in the commodity prices
3. Political instability
Our analysis of the past 12 years shows that the KSE-100 index’s P/E multiple has re-
rated during four distinct years. The comparison of the key economic indicators from
those periods, specifically, FY14, FY15, FY17 and FY24 with our expectations for FY25,
we observe striking similarities.
The key economic indicators projected for FY25 including inflation, current account as
% of GDP, and foreign exchange reserves are closely aligned with historical benchmarks
observed during previous market re-rating periods. Moreover, robust remittances
momentum (% of imports) expected to be on the higher side during FY25. However,
GDP growth in FY25 is expected to be lower in comparison to the re-rating period.
We believe that this alignment reflects a narrowing gap between market performance
and economic fundamentals. Given this convergence and anticipated improvements in
the country's macroeconomic position, we expect the market's P/E multiple to experience
a re-rating, driving further momentum for the KSE-100 index.
Additional
Figure: KSE-100 historical P/E Figure: Historical trend of market cap to GDP
KSE100 PE 10Y Average Mkt Cap to GDP 10Y Avg. 15Y Avg.
16 40%
14
33%
12
10
10Y Avg. PE: 8.3x 26%
8
15-Yr Avg
6 19%
4 10 - Yr Avg 16.9%
12%
2
- 5%
Jul-16
Jul-21
Nov-24
Nov-14
Dec-16
Jan-19
Jun-19
Nov-19
Dec-21
Jan-24
Jun-24
Apr-15
Sep-15
May-17
Oct-17
Aug-18
Apr-20
Sep-20
Oct-22
Feb-16
Mar-18
Feb-21
May-22
Aug-23
Mar-23
Jun-01
Jun-02
Jun-03
Jun-04
Jun-05
Jun-06
Jun-07
Jun-08
Jun-09
Jun-10
Jun-11
Jun-12
Jun-13
Jun-14
Jun-15
Jun-16
Jun-17
Jun-18
Jun-19
Jun-20
Jun-21
Jun-22
Jun-23
Jun-24
Nov-24
Source (s): Bloomberg, PSX, AHL Research Source (s): Bloomberg, PBS, AHL Research
The strong returns (50.8% CY24TD) in 2024 highlight the role of compelling valuations Com pany Shares (m n) PKR m n USD m n
and ample domestic liquidity, enabling local investors to absorb the impact of foreign
UBL 38.40 10,337 37.20
selling amounting to USD 35.7mn. Our data suggest that foreign holdings in the KSE-
LUCK 7.13 6,074 21.86
All shares have significantly decreased to 3.2% of free float market cap as compared
HBL 41.20 4,320 15.55
to 28.7% back in 2017. In 2024, major events including liquidation of the BlackRock
Pakistan ETF (USD 30mn outflow) and FTSE-related selling by Vanguard (~USD OGDC 42.18 8,024 28.88
100mn) has been easily absorbed by the market. After incorporating these, we estimate HUBC 47.36 2,556 9.20
that current foreign holdings now stand at approximately USD 388mn, representing ENGRO 16.94 3,088 11.11
3.2% of the free-float market capitalization. PPL 74.07 8,976 32.30
Looking ahead, Pakistan stands to benefit from potential reclassification changes within FFC 30.63 3,901 14.04
the MSCI Frontier Markets index. Vietnam, which currently holds a significant weight of NBP 101.83 6,216 22.37
around 30%, is expected to migrate to Emerging Market, redistributing its weight across EFERT 22.17 3,744 13.47
remaining FM constituents. The weight of Pakistan can potentially increase from the PSO 17.80 2,123 7.64
current level (~4.5%), positioning well to attract incremental foreign flows. BAFL 8.88 596 2.14
POL 6.35 2,034 7.32
Exhibit: Net Foreign Portfolio Investment
SEARL 5.38 452 1.63
(300.00)
(400.00) (359.04)
(500.00)
(600.00)
(571.50)
(700.00)
Source (s): NCCPL, AHL Research
These M&A transactions are expected to unlock significant value within the local stock
market, enhancing the attractiveness of key sector / stocks and supporting a broader
market re-rating. These M&As activities can drive operational efficiencies and growth in
targeted companies, thereby improving market perceptions, valuation metrics and
contribute to a re-rating of the overall market, aligning valuations more closely with
underlying growth potential.
As macroeconomic conditions stabilize and policy reforms take root, Pakistan is poised
for a steady increase in FDI inflows. These investments are expected not only to inject
capital but also to bring in advanced technology and expertise, bolstering export
potential, industrial capacity and creating jobs. The anticipated rise in foreign investment
will strengthen economic resilience specially on the balance of payment front, enhance
sectoral productivity, and help the country meet its sustainable growth objectives in the
coming years.
1320 MW Thar Coal Based Power Copper Gold Expl. & Min. in Chagai Baluchistan
1000 MWH Battery Energy Storage System Lead-Zine Expl. & Min. in Khuzdar Baluchistan
Additionally, the outlook for real estate as an investment avenue remains subdued, with ▪ Fixed-income returns are projected to
remain in single digits
rising costs and regulatory hurdles dampening its appeal. Stringent measures to combat
dollarization, coupled with a stable balance of payments outlook, are expected to limit
investment in foreign currency, further curbing investment in dollar-denominated assets.
Furthermore, the previously attractive auto sector as an investment class has also lost
its attraction amid lower purchasing power and higher car price and is unlikely to recover
in the near term.
Historically, equities have consistently outperformed other asset classes over the mid to
long term, driven by their potential for higher capital appreciation and the ability to
generate sustainable returns through dividends and growth. We have summarized the
table below, which highlights the performance of equities relative to other asset classes
demonstrating outperformance in all tenures.
on the economic environment. This surge in confidence is driven by various factors, ▪ CDS has declined to 1496 bps, reflecting a
including improved macroeconomic stability and optimism surrounding fiscal reforms. reduction in perceived sovereign risk.
60.0
55.0
50.0
45.0
40.0
35.0
Jan-24
Mar-24
Jun-24
Jul-24
Nov-23
Dec-23
Feb-24
Sep-24
Sep-23
Aug-24
Oct-23
Apr-24
May-24
Oct-24
Donal Trump
wins US
92,000 Presidential
Elections
Saudi Delegation
visit for USD 2bn
88,000 investment talks 800
Uncertainty over the
settlement of Chinese IPPs SBP cut
dues policy rate by
FFC and FFBL
announces to evaluate 250bps to
84,000 potential merger 15.0%
UAE pledges
USD10Bn investment
National Assembly
80,000 IMF’s mandates passes 26th 600
removal of Constitutional
subsidies for new Amendment Bill
program
Supreme Court
76,000 Approval of PIA’s Rs268 verdict to allot
billion debt restructuring reserved seats to PTI
OGDC and PPL
Anticipation of Tension in reported stellar
MiddleEast
72,000 imposition of hefty improvement in 400
capital gain and collection from gas
Uncertainty over dividend tax sales, curtailing
the result circular debt
Asif Zardari Policy rate cut by SBP
General
sworn in as PM visit to KSA, by 150bps
Elections 2024.
68,000 President of focusing on potential
Pakistan USD 1bn Saudi Reko
Diq deal
SLA with IMF
for 3rd SBA
64,000 200
Shahbaz Sharif elected Post Federal Budget
as Prime Minister of FY25 Rally
Approval of 2nd Stand- Pakistan
by arrangement tranche
60,000 of USD 700mn by the Announcement of a
IMF's Executive Board coalition government
by major political
parties
56,000 -
Apr-24
Oct-24
Jan-24
Jun-24
Mar-24
Feb-24
Nov-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
May-24
Jul-24
Changan to launch its electric vehicle named Changan Lumin Nov-24 USD 126mn repayment to IMF May-25
Prime minister to visit cop29 event in Azerbaijan Nov-24 USD 155mn repayment to IMF Jun-25
MSCI Quarterly Review Nov-24 Electricity base tariff hike expected Jul-25
USD 157mn repayment to IMF Nov-24 Saudi Arabia debt of PKR 2bn to be rolled over Jul-25
Completion of FFC & FFBL merger Dec-24 Monetary policy meeting Sep-25
Unwinding of production cut by OPEC Jan-25 2nd Review of IMF's EFF Program Sep-25
Completion of pipeline to connect MARI's field Shewa to gas
Jan-25 USD 126mn repayment to IMF Sep-25
network
Pakistan Govt international bond of USD 500mn to
Rollover of USD 3bn UAE deposits Jan-25 Sep-25
mature
Disbursement of USD 1.3bn by IMF post conclusion of
USD 246mn repayment to IMF Jan-25 Oct-25
2nd review
EPCL's Hydrogen Peroxide plant to reach completion Feb-25 OGDC's Uch development Project to complete Oct-25
Zorlu Solar Pakistan Ltd's 100 MW solar project to
MSCI Quarterly Review Feb-25 Oct-25
complete
USD 154mn repayment to IMF Feb-25 Monetary policy meeting Nov-25
Monetary policy meeting Mar-25 Saudi Arabia debt of PKR 3bn to be rolled over Nov-25
1st Review of IMF's EFF Program Mar-25 MSCI Quarterly Review Nov-25
Rollover of USD 2bn of Chinese debt Mar-25 OPEC + increases production by 2.2mnb/d Nov-25
Sale of thermal asset of ENGRO concludes Mar-25 USD 138mn repayment to IMF Nov-25
USD 168mn repayment to IMF Apr-25 TAY Powergen's 30 MW bagasse project to complete Dec-25
CIHC Pak Power Co.'s 300 MW coal-based plant in
MSCI Quarterly Review May-25 Dec-25
Gwadar to complete
Source (s): AHL Research
E&Ps Banks
FABL | NBP
OGDC | PPL
Subdued interest rates to
100% recovery of suppress earnings, but
receivables which has banks to focus on
raised prospects of high volumetric growth to
dividends ensure profitability
Fertilizer Cement
FFC FCCL | LUCK | MLCF
Stable offtake and Margins to remain
margins. elevated due to better
power mix and low coal
prices
Technology Auto
SYS | AIRLINK INDU
Focus towards Demand to recover
sustainable and long-term following economic
growth will boost stability and lower interest
technology services rates, with EVs to gain
exports prominence.
Textile OGMC’s
ILP PSO
Global recovery to drive Revival of economic
demand, however higher growth and higher
taxes to hurt profitability automobile sales to drive
demand
Commercial Banks
Strong Balance Sheets
navigating headwinds
Banking on resilience
Testing times: As banks grapple with the ripple effects of lower interest rates and
looming ADR related tax obligations, the outlook for Pakistan’s banking sector in CY25f
seems challenging. The SBP eased its policy stance in Jun’24, reducing the policy rate
by a cumulative 700bps throughout CY24TD, putting pressure on rupee-lending rates in
the second half of the year. Subsequently, the weighted average lending rate on new
loans fell to 18.42% by Sep’24, down from 20.25% in Sep’23, while the average deposit
rate decreased to 9.53% from 11.2%. Despite these pressures, the sector’s profitability
gained momentum in 3QCY24, bolstered by lower interest expenses and significant
capital gains. Management indicators, particularly the cost-to-income ratio,
demonstrated upward trends, rising to 42.4% as of 9MCY24 compared to 41.8% in the
previous year, supported by higher operational costs due to inflationary pressures. As
we look to CY25, maintaining profitability will be an uphill task. The cost-to-income ratio
is expected to stabilize around 40%, with inflation forecasted to remain low at 8.6%, down
from an estimated 13.3% in CY24e. However, total income growth could be restricted by
lower interest rates, which are anticipated to average 12.1% in CY25f against 19.4% in
CY24e. Additionally, incremental tax liabilities could arise for banks failing to meet the
50% ADR threshold, further weighing on sector profitability.
Robust CAR and dividend growth signal sector stability: Capital adequacy ratio
(CAR) for KSE-100 banking sector remains robust at 21.6%, compared to 18.5% in the
same period last year, comfortably above the regulatory requirement of 11.5%. The
slowdown in credit growth, coupled with increased investments in risk-free debt
instruments, has contributed to a controlled expansion of risk-weighted assets. With
strong balance sheets supporting their positions, banks have rewarded shareholders
with substantial dividends, totaling PKR 191bn in 9MCY24, representing an impressive
25% increase YoY. Going forward, we anticipate that banks will maintain attractive
payout ratios to keep investors engaged.
(PKR trn) Advances ADR (RHS) (PKR trn) Investments IDR (RHS)
13 60% 34 102%
12 55% 29 90%
10 50% 24 78%
9 45% 19 66%
7 40% 14 54%
6 35% 9 42%
4 30% 4 30%
Dec-19 Dec-20 Dec-21 Dec-22 Dec-23 Sep-24 Dec-19 Dec-20 Dec-21 Dec-22 Dec-23 Sep-24
Source (s): SBP, AHL Research Source (s): SBP, AHL Research
Figure: Deposit growth remains high in CY24 Figure: Spreads decline post rate cuts
(PKR trn) Deposit Deposit Growth (YoY) (RHS) Deposit Rate Lending Rate Spreads (RHS)
31 23%
20% 11%
30 22%
16% 10%
29 21%
28 20% 12% 10%
27 19%
8% 9%
26 17%
25 16% 4% 9%
24 15%
0% 8%
Jul-24
Jul-23
Jan-24
Jun-24
Aug-23
Sep-23
Aug-24
Sep-24
Oct-23
Nov-23
Dec-23
Feb-24
Mar-24
Apr-24
May-24
Jul-23
Jul-24
Nov-23
Dec-23
Jan-24
Jun-24
Aug-23
Sep-23
Aug-24
Sep-24
Oct-23
Feb-24
Mar-24
Apr-24
May-24
Source (s): SBP, AHL Research Source (s): SBP, AHL Research
12.0/share. This settlement figure, lower than the initially estimated PKR 60bn, will ADTV (mn) - PKR 271 269 204
help lift the burden on NBP's balance sheet, paving the way for growth. While this ADTV (000) - USD 976 967 732
one-off expense impacts CY24 earnings, the outlook beyond CY24 is robust, with High Price - PKR 69.9 69.9 69.9
projected earnings growth of 26% CAGR over the next three years. Low Price - PKR 43.7 34.9 24.5
NBP currently trades at a substantial discount relative to its private sector peers, Source: Company Financials, AHL Research
with a CY25f P/B of 0.31x and a P/E of 3.3x, well below the industry averages of
0.8x P/B and 3.74x P/E. NBP's transformation is underway, leveraging a strong Relative Performance
capital position, distinctive fee-based income streams, and improved coverage ratio.
300% NBP KSE100
We believe these factors will help unlock the bank's earnings potential. NBP remains
an attractive proposition in our view, with favorable P/B multiples and a strong 270%
dividend outlook placing it among the highest-yielding stocks in the banking sector. 240%
210%
180%
150%
120%
90%
Jan-24
Jun-24
May-24
Mar-24
Feb-24
Apr-24
Oct-24
Jul-24
Nov-23
Dec-23
Nov-24
Sep-24
Aug-24
Figure: Improving profitability and RoE Figure: Resumption of payout on the cards
40 12% 40%
8.0
32 10% 30%
6.0
24 8% 20%
4.0
16 6% 10%
8 4% 2.0 0%
- 2% - -10%
CY21a CY22a CY23a CY24e CY25f CY26f CY21a CY22a CY23a CY24e CY25f CY26f
Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research
120%
90%
Jan-24
Jun-24
May-24
Mar-24
Feb-24
Apr-24
Oct-24
Jul-24
Nov-23
Dec-23
Nov-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
- 8% - 8%
CY20a CY21a CY22a CY23a CY24e CY25f CY26f CY20a CY21a CY22a CY23a CY24e CY25f CY26f
Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research
International oil
Tug of war in oil prices
In CY24TD, oil prices have been influenced by a blend of supply cuts, economic
slowdown-induced demand fluctuations, and geopolitical tensions that introduced
volatility into the market. Prices of WTI, Brent, and Arab Light declined by 1.2%, 1.8%,
and 2.9%, respectively. The year started with an anticipated recovery in global oil
demand, yet tensions from the Middle East conflict pushed prices upward. High inflation
in major oil-consuming economies brought demand concerns and recession fears into
focus. Additionally, Ukraine's attack on Russian refineries briefly stirred supply disruption
worries in Eastern Europe, and a Gulf Coast hurricane in the U.S. temporarily lifted
prices. In Jun’24, OPEC+ extended its 2.2mn b/d production cuts through Dec’24, with
a phased increase planned through Nov’25. Although these moves, along with the
geopolitical climate, initially supported oil prices, weaker demand from the U.S. and
China ultimately tempered gains.
Unwinding supply
The non-OPEC oil supply growth for CY25 is project to arrive at 71.94 mb/d, showcasing
a growth of 1.48 mb/d YoY mainly due to growth from OECD countries such USA (+0.45
mb/d) and Canada (+0.25mb/d). Similarly, supply by OPEC is forecasted to augment by
0.55 mb/d to 32.60mb/d in CY25 versus 32.04 mb/d in CY24.
60 91.7 93.0
50 90.0
40 87.0
30 84.0
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024* 2025*
Source (s): EIA, AHL Research, *estimated
Figure: World oil production in relation to oil price Figure: World oil consumption
Source (s): EIA, AHL Research Source (s): EIA, AHL Research
120 34
15.0
33
100
11.0 33
80 32
7.0 32
60
3.0 31
40 31
20 -1.0 30
30
- -5.0
Jul-22
Jul-23
Jul-24
Nov-21
Jan-22
Nov-22
Jan-23
Nov-23
Jan-24
Sep-21
Sep-22
Sep-23
Mar-24
Sep-24
Mar-22
May-22
Mar-23
May-23
May-24
Oct-16
Apr-17
Oct-17
Apr-18
Oct-18
Apr-19
Oct-19
Apr-20
Oct-20
Apr-25
Apr-21
Oct-21
Apr-22
Oct-22
Apr-23
Oct-23
Apr-24
Oct-24
Oct-25
Source (s): EIA, AHL Research Source (s): EIA, AHL Research
80 Iran attacks
Israel
Russia cuts
OPEC+ production by
Ukraine attacks
70 announced a 0.3mn b/d
Russian oil Hurricane in
surprise cut of refinery US Gulf of
1.15mn b/d Houthi rebels Mexico
attack
commercial
Saudi Arabia ships at Red China announces
60 Russia plans to cut pledges OPEC+ stimulas package
Sea
0.5mn-0.7mn b/d of oil additional 1mn extends
b/d production
OPEC+ member Air & sea
cut till
extended their strikes by US & OPEC+
Sep'24
cuts and made Russia extends UK on Houthi extends
50 voluntry cuts production cut to target at Red production
with total cut 0.5mn b/d Sea cut till
clocking in at Dec'24
3.66mn b/d
40
Apr-23
Oct-23
Apr-24
Oct-24
Jan-23
Jun-23
Jan-24
Jun-24
Mar-23
Mar-24
Feb-23
Nov-23
Dec-23
Feb-24
Nov-24
Aug-23
Sep-23
Aug-24
Sep-24
May-23
May-24
Jul-23
Jul-24
Arif Habib Limited 48 58
Pakistan Investment Strategy
2025
Curtailment of Pakistan’s oil and gas production: Pakistan’s oil production during
FY24 witnessed an uptick of 1% YoY to settle at 70,524 bopd against 69,513 bopd
during FY23. The jump in oil production is owed to commencement new discoveries Figure: Historical exploration activity
and increase production from matured fields post production enhancement initiatives.
(No.) Wells Spud Discoveries
However, gas production declined by 4% YoY to arrive at 3,116 mmcfd in FY24 vis-à-
vis 3,259 mmcfd in FY23. The decrease in gas production is owed to natural decline at 35
major fields coupled with curtailment by SNGP amid reduction in demand from gas from 30
5
25
industrial sector. In order to address the natural decline, the E&P companies have taken 4 6
20
intervention measures to improve production. 3
15 7 5
25
Govt. introduces Tight Gas policy: In Feb’24, the Govt. introduced the Tight Gas 10 20 20 3
16 13 13
Policy 2024, offering exploration companies a 40% premium over the Petroleum Policy 5 10
2012 price as an incentive to tap into untapped tight gas reserves. The policy also allows -
FY18
FY19
FY20
FY21
FY22
FY23
FY24
for a lease period of up to 30 years, with the option to extend for an additional 10 years.
Following this, E&P companies are now focusing on wells with tight gas potential. In
Apr’24, OGDC announced a tight gas discovery at Nur West-1 with an output of Source (s): PPIS, AHL Research
1.24mmcfd and plans to conduct fracking on 6-7 wells in Sindh. Meanwhile, PPL intends
to appraise four tight gas discoveries Naushahro Firoz, Hadi, Hub, and Morgandh while
MARI is assessing tight gas prospects in the Kawagarh Formation at its Shewa-2
appraisal well.
Drilling at Abu Dhabi Block: In Abu Dhabi’s offshore Block-5, where OGDC, PPL, and
MARI each hold a 25% stake, appraisal wells BuDana-003 and Al Bateen-002 have
reached completion, while drilling on the first exploration well, Marwah (XF003-1V), is
currently underway. Additionally, the appraisal wells BuDana-003, Al Manhal, and Al
Bateen are now undergoing a Pre-FEED study alongside technical and commercial due
diligence. Any major discovery here could potentially deliver a significant boost to
revenue and earnings for the stakeholders involved.
Divestment of Reko Diq Mining Project under consideration: The copper and gold
extraction project at the Reko Diq Mine in Balochistan, where OGDC and PPL each
hold an 8.33% stake, is currently in the feasibility study for the project is ongoing,
expected to conclude by the end of 2024. Following this, construction will begin, with
mining operations anticipated to commence in 2028. Additionally, OGDC and PPL are
considering divesting a portion of their stake in the project to a sovereign foreign
investor.
Risk (s):
Jun-24
Mar-24
Feb-24
Jul-24
Apr-24
Oct-24
Earnings outlook
Nov-23
Sep-24
Dec-23
Aug-24
Nov-24
For FY25 and FY26, we project OGDC's earnings to arrive PKR 48.78/share and PKR
49.25/share, respectively. The scrip is currently trading at FY25e P/E, P/B and D/Y of
Source: Bloomberg, AHL Research
4.0x, 0.6x, and 7.7%, respectively.
Figure: OGDC’s receivable compared to collection Figure: Hydrocarbon production in relation to EPS
Change in OGDC's Rec. OGDC collection (Mn BoE) BOE Sold EPS (RHS)
(PKR bn) (%) (PKR)
150.0 105.0 90 60
80 50
120.0 91.0
70 40
90.0 77.0
60 30
60.0 63.0
50 20
30.0 49.0
40 10
- 35.0 30 -
FY18
FY19
FY20
FY21
FY22
FY23
FY24
FY18
FY23
FY19
FY20
FY21
FY22
FY24
Source (s): Company’s Financials, AHL Research Source (s): PPIS, AHL Research
Optimistic production forecast for FY25 Avg. Volume (000) 6,357 5,586 8,499
In FY24, oil and gas production declined by 5% and 14% YoY, respectively, primarily ADTV (mn) - PKR 836 707 1,008
due to natural depletion, lower offtakes from GENCO-II, and excessive back pressure ADTV (000) - USD 3,011 2,545 3,601
from SNGP due to system constraints. To address this, the company has started re- High Price - PKR 154.2 154.2 154.2
routing gas to SSGC and is considering reallocating gas production to other Low Price - PKR 103.4 103.4 78.5
customers to counter lower GENCO-II offtakes. As a result, we expect oil and gas
production to grow by 4% and 3% YoY in FY25, driven by new discoveries and the Shareholding Pattern
revival of production from existing fields. Others,
Modaraba
& Mutual 11%
Augmenting production from existing wells
Funds,
PPL has implemented many initiatives over the past 1.5 years to boost production 3.90%
from mature fields. The revamping of the Sui SML Compressor Station in FY24 FI's , 3%
increased production potential by ~19 mmcfd. Additionally, a low-cost, rig-less
Individuals,
production enhancement campaign added 37 mmcfd of gas and 630 bopd of 7%
condensate. To address natural decline at Adhi, three development wells were spud,
along with multiple production optimization efforts. In FY25, the company plans to PPL -
Emplyees Govt. of
spud 8 exploratory and 2 development wells to tap new reserves. Pakistan,
Empow erment
Trust, 7% 68%
Update on international blocks
The company has reached a settlement agreement with Midland Oil Company (Iraqi Source: Company Financials, AHL Research
oil company) to conclude the Exploration, Development, and Production Service
Contract at Block-8 in Iraq. As part of the settlement, PPL will receive USD 6mn (PKR Relative Performance
1,665mn). Meanwhile, at Abu Dhabi Offshore Block-5, the PPL-led consortium PIOL 200% PPL KSE100
has completed drilling two appraisal wells, with an exploratory well currently being
180%
drilled. The reserve size will be assessed upon completion of the appraisal phase.
160%
Renewal of Sui lease
The government has approved the Sui Mining Lease until 31st May’25. As a result, 140%
the company will enter into a D&P and Petroleum Concession Agreement to fulfill
120%
financial obligations (lease extension bonus, production bonus, and others) totaling
PKR 52.5bn or PKR 19.29/share. PPL plans to apply for an extension upon lease 100%
expiry in May’25.
80%
May-24
Jan-24
Jun-24
Feb-24
Mar-24
Jul-24
Apr-24
Oct-24
Nov-23
Dec-23
Aug-24
Nov-24
Sep-24
Earnings outlook
We forecast bottom-line to arrive at PKR 42.41/share and PKR 43.67/share in FY25
and FY26, respectively. The scrip is trading at an attractive FY25 P/E 3.6x, along with Source: Bloomberg, AHL Research
P/B and D/Y of 0.6x and 6.6%, respectively.
Figure: Sui Gas price in relation of oil price Figure: Change in receivable compared to collection
Arab Light Price Sui Gas Price (RHS) Change in PPL's Rec. PPL collection
(USD/bbl) (USD/mmbtu) (PKR bn) (%)
108 2.1 150.0 110.0
95 2.0
120.0 90.0
83
1.8
70 90.0 70.0
1.7
58
60.0 50.0
1.5
45
1.4 30.0 30.0
33
20 1.2 - 10.0
FY22a
FY18a
FY19a
FY20a
FY21a
FY23a
FY24a
FY18a
FY19a
FY20a
FY21a
FY22a
FY23a
FY24a
Source (s): Bloomberg, AHL Research Source (s): PPIS, AHL Research
Fertilizer
Profitability outweighs
agricultural issues
Gas Price Revision: In Feb’24, in line with the IMF's condition to reduce the gas
circular debt and eliminate subsidies, the government significantly increased the
feedstock price by 2.8x to PKR 1,597/mmbtu from the previous rate of PKR 580/mmbtu.
Simultaneously, the fuel stock price depicted a slight rise of 1%, reaching PKR
1,597/mmbtu, compared to the previous rate of PKR 1,580/mmbtu. Consequently,
fertilizer manufacturers such as EFERT and FFBL, which operate on the SNGP and
SSGC networks respectively, passed on the higher costs to consumers by increasing
urea prices. In contrast, FFC, which receives gas from the MARI network, continues to
benefit from the old rates, as no price hike has yet been announced for MARI's
consumers. Therefore, if gas price increase is notified to MARI’s customers, FFC will
likely have to jack up the urea prices by PKR 1,120/bag.
Homogenous urea prices: After over a year of disparities in urea prices among
manufacturers, the price gap has significantly narrowed. As of Feb’24, EFERT and FFC
were selling urea at PKR 4,435/bag and PKR 3,652/bag, respectively. By Nov’24,
however, all manufacturers have aligned their prices at PKR 4,308/bag, achieving price
harmony. On the other hand, the international price of urea in Nov’24 stood at USD
293/ton, a 26 YoY decrease from USD 397/ton, due to a slowdown in global urea demand.
Looking ahead to CY25, local urea prices are expected to rise following an anticipated
revision in gas prices. Among manufacturers, FFC is projected to experience the highest
price increase, potentially exceeding PKR 1,120/bag, due to the delayed impact of the
gas price hike that was last implemented in Feb’24.
Weak purchasing power taking toll on offtake: During the 10MCY24, the urea sales
depicted decline of 9% YoY to 4.9mn tons compared to 5.4mn tons in SPLY. The decline
in urea sales is attributed to weak farm economics and a 58-day BMR shutdown of
EFERT’s EnVen plant. Meanwhile, DAP sales rose by 3% YoY to 1.2mn tons, driven by
higher purchasing in anticipation of rising DAP prices. By the end of CY24, urea and DAP
offtake is expected to reach 6.1mn tons and 1.6mn tons, respectively. Looking ahead,
urea and DAP sales are expected to stabilize at 6.6mn tons and 1.7mn tons, respectively,
in CY25.
Kissan Card Program- Solution to farmers woe? In an attempt to support the farmers,
the Punjab Govt has announced PKR 400bn Kisan Card Program on 29th Oct’24. The
government plans to increase the number of Kisan Cards from 500k to 750k. Under this
program, free laser levelers will be provided to farmers cultivating wheat on 12.5 to 25
acres of land coupled with tractors to famers to cultivating above 25 acres. Moreover, the
agricultural machinery offered under the program will be on a no profit rental basis to
farmer. The card holders will now be able to buy seeds, fertilizers, and pesticides at
subsidized rates of ~PKR 150,000. The program comes at the time of commencement of
Rabi season and will encourage the farmers (some of whom plan to skip planting wheat
crop) to grow wheat.
Figure: Offtake and prices of Urea and DAP Figure: International Urea and DAP prices
Urea Offtake DAP Offtake Urea DAP
Urea Price (RHS) DAP Price (RHS) (USD/ton)
(Tons) (PKR/bag) 650
7,000 14,000 600
6,000 12,000 550
5,000 10,000 500
4,000 8,000 450
3,000 6,000 400
2,000 4,000 350
1,000 2,000 300
- - 250
Jul-24
Dec-23
Jan-24
Mar-24
Nov-23
Jun-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
Apr-24
Oct-24
Nov-24
Feb-24
May-24
CY14a
CY15a
CY16a
CY17a
CY18a
CY19a
CY20a
CY21a
CY22a
CY23a
CY24e
Source (s): NFDC, AHL Research Source (s): Bloomberg, AHL Research
Figure: Phosphoric acid in relation to international DAP price Figure: Urea prices of major Urea producers
Jul-24
Jan-23
Jan-24
Nov-22
Sep-23
Nov-23
Sep-24
Nov-24
Mar-23
May-23
Mar-24
May-24
0 150
CY20a
CY19a
CY21a
CY22a
CY23a
CY24a
Source (s): Bloomberg, AHL Research Source (s): Fertilizer Dealers, AHL Research
Jun-24
Mar-24
Feb-24
Apr-24
Oct-24
Jul-24
Nov-23
Dec-23
Nov-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
Balance Sheet
Shareholder's Equity 76,328 91,071 105,396
- - - 60.0
CY22A CY23E CY24e CY25f CY26f CY22A CY23E CY24e CY25f CY26f
Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research
Cements
Robust margin game
Margins Expansion
“Renewables” the only option for survival: Industries experienced some relief when
government raised the consumer base tariff by PKR 5.72/kWh in Jul’24, leaving industrial
base tariffs unchanged. However, the cost of grid electricity for industrial consumers
remains higher than that of neighboring countries. This continues to hinder Pakistan’s
competitiveness in the region. To mitigate the impact of these high tariffs, many cement
companies have turned to renewable energy sources, such as solar, waste heat recovery,
and wind power.
Additionally, some have installed coal power plants to reduce reliance on the national grid,
thereby lowering their overall energy costs. These strategic shifts have helped cement
companies protect profitability and maintain their margins. The sector's average energy
mix consists of 24% from the grid, 32% from waste heat recovery, 25% from captive, and
18% from renewables.
Coal the largest cost contributor: Coal is a vital raw material, accounting for
approximately 40%-45% of the total cost of cement production. It is used as a primary
input, and the price of cement is highly correlated to the cost of coal. In FY23 coal prices
were recovering from the effects of Russia-Ukraine conflict, which in Mar’22 took coal
prices to a peak level of USD 460/ton. In FY23, the coal price averaged at ~ USD 202.4/ton
and closed at USD 100/ton due to slowdown in the global activity and excess supply of
coal. The momentum was carried in FY24, majorly due to suppressed demand from
China, resulting in commodity price to be soft during the year arriving at an average of
USD 108/ton.
This lower international coal prices helped the cement industries improve their margins
hence boosting the profitability. Furthermore, to be protected from the fluctuations in the
international coal prices and PKR against the greenback, the cement companies
incorporated a diverse mix of fuel, by adoption of alternative coal sources, such as Afghan
and local coal. Due to this, the cement companies in FY24 experienced an increase in
profitability by 61% YoY to PKR 81.0bn compared to PKR 50.4bn in FY23. Although, some
companies were adversely impacted by the change in tax on exports regime from
presumptive to normal tax.
Exhibit: International coal prices witnessed a decline of 47% YoY during FY24 Exhibit: Cement Sector Profit after tax
International Coal Prices Avg. Coal Prices PKR m n FY24 FY23 YoY
(USD/ton) LUCK* 28,107 13,726 105%
250 BWCL 13,769 11,892 16%
214.0
202.4 KOHC 8,893 5,821 53%
200
FCCL 8,223 7,440 11%
MLCF 6,891 5,771 19%
150
107.8 CHCC 5,500 4,404 25%
94.0 88.0
100 80.0 PIOC 5,176 2,611 98%
67.7
DGKC 542 -3,636 nm
50 Others 3,920 2,337 68%
Total 81,022 50,365 61%
0
FY18 FY19 FY20 FY21 FY22 FY23 FY24
Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research
*Unconsolidated
Source (s): Bloomberg, AHL Research
Figure: Policy rate Trend and forecast Figure: Local cement dispatches in FY24 down by 5% YoY
Aug-24
Sep-24
Oct-24
May-24
Nov-24
Dec-24
Jan-25
Jun-25
Feb-25
Mar-25
Apr-25
May-25
- -23%
FY24
FY15
FY16
FY17
FY18
FY19
FY20
FY21
FY22
FY23
Source (s): SBP, AHL Research Source (s): APCMA, AHL Research
Risk
1. Cement price cut scenario
2. Slower rebound in cement demand.
3. Uptick in international coal prices also rendering higher coal prices in Afghanistan,
Mozambique and local market.
4. Slowdown in the economy with need for higher tax revenue to force the government
to impose more taxes on industries.
IPPs renegotiations might reduce profitability Source: Company Financials, AHL Research
Potential challenges could arise due to the government’s renegotiation efforts with
IPPs aimed at reducing the power tariff. We have prepared a sensitivity of the impact Relative Performance
of reduction in the RoE component, this would also impact the SoTP valuation. LUCK KSE100
190%
Despite these potential setbacks, LUCK’s diverse portfolio mix is expected to cushion
the impact and mitigate significant downside risk. 170%
EPS (PKR)
RoE SoTP (PKR) 130%
FY25e FY26f
Base case 13.6% 186.8 163.9 1,256 110%
Case 1 16.3% 190.3 170.8 1,288
90%
Case 2 19.0% 193.7 177.6 1,319
May-24
Jan-24
Jun-24
Mar-24
Feb-24
Jul-24
Apr-24
Oct-24
Nov-23
Dec-23
Aug-24
Sep-24
Nov-24
10.0 70%
0.0 45%
2024a 2025e 2026f 2027f 2028f
Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research, *Dividends from LEPCL included Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research
share, enhance its competitiveness, and open doors to international markets. ADTV (mn) - PKR 277 253 217
ADTV (000) - USD 996 909 777
Quest for cheapest alternate fuel and power
High Price - PKR 35.1 35.1 35.1
During FY24, the company installed an additional 12.5MW solar plant, bringing its total
solar capacity to 52.5MW. Additionally, it added a 12MW waste heat recovery plant Low Price - PKR 19.4 19.3 15.4
(WHRP) to help mitigate high tariff costs. As a result, approximately 52% of the
company's power needs in FY24 were met through inhouse generation. To further Shareholding Pattern
reduce its reliance on the national grid, the company plans to install an additional Others,
Modaraba 5%
15MW of solar capacity by 3QFY25, with an expected payback period of 3.5 years. In & Mutual FI's, 4%
Funds,
terms of fuel mix, about 31% of the company's consumption was local coal, while the
4%
remainder was a blend of Afghan and imported coal. The company also used 5%
alternative fuel to cut production costs and aims to increase this to 10-11% by FY25, Joint Stocks
Cos., 5%
further enhancing its cost-efficiency.
165%
140%
115%
90%
May-24
Jan-24
Jun-24
Mar-24
Feb-24
Apr-24
Oct-24
Jul-24
Nov-24
Nov-23
Dec-23
Aug-24
Sep-24
Profit after tax Gross Profit Margins (RHS) Local Exports Utilization (RHS)
(PKR bn) (mn tons)
18.0 17.2 40% 6.0 60%
15.6 15.4
15.0 5.0 0.79
13.0 37% 0.52 0.60 0.66 0.72 58%
12.0 4.0
34% 56%
9.0 8.2 3.0
31% 4.7 54%
4.6 4.4 4.6 4.4
6.0 2.0
28% 52%
3.0 1.0
MLCF in FY24 repurchased another 25.8mn shares, representing 2.4% of its paid-up ADTV (000) - USD 1,008 852 832
capital and 21.9% of its free float. High Price - PKR 43.0 43.0 43.0
Low Price - PKR 32.2 32.2 32.2
Better Energy Mix
MLCF is well positioned to mitigate rising electricity costs due to internal power
generation capabilities. Its subsidiary, Maple Leaf Power (MLPL), operates a 40 MW Shareholding Pattern
coal-fired power plant. Moreover, MLPL profits are exempt from charge of income tax Others,
Foreign , 5%
on profits, resulting in fall in effective taxation for MLCF. In addition, MLCF has Modaraba 5%
& Mutual
successfully installed a 12.5 MW solar power plant, offering partial protection from Funds,
escalating tariffs. The company has also completed a Waste Heat Recovery Plant 7%
(WHRP) for its new Line-4, expanding its capacity from 25 MW to 37 MW, which now FI's, 6%
covers one-third of the company’s total power expenses. These energy initiatives
have enabled the company to maintain higher margins than its competitors.
Kohinoor
Textile
Prudent steps taken to change the fuel mix
Mills, 58%
MLCF was the first in the industry to use Afghan coal. This has been a game changer Indviduals
, 19%
as local and Afghan coal became a substantial part of the fuel mix used by the cement
manufacturers in North. Furthermore, the company is also using biomass, such as Source: Company Financials, AHL Research
rice husk, to further lower its production cost, resulting in higher margins for the
company. Relative Performance
Market leader in white cement 180% MLCF KSE100
MLCF is one of the few cement producers in Pakistan with a presence in the white
cement market, commanding over 90% of the domestic market share. It is also the 160%
country's largest exporter of white cement. While, in FY24 white cement accounted
140%
for approximately 3.75% of MLCF’s total sales, it is sold at a premium compared to
grey cement, further enhancing its value contribution. 120%
100%
80%
May-24
Jan-24
Jun-24
Mar-24
Feb-24
Apr-24
Oct-24
Jul-24
Nov-23
Aug-24
Dec-23
Sep-24
Nov-24
Power generation
& distribution
Through turbulent waters
Reasons for increase: There are several reasons for the sharp rise in electricity tariffs
in the country over the past few years. Below, we have outlined one of the major factors
contributing to this increase;
1) Rise in Capacity Payments: The induction of new power plants and the Exhibit: Reference Capacity Charges for FY25
depreciation of the Pakistani Rupee (PKR) have caused a significant rise in Source PKR bn % Share
capacity payments. By FY24, these payments reached PKR 1,874bn (PKR
Nuclear 466 22.3%
17.01/KWh), up from PKR 275bn (PKR 3.08/KWh) in FY16. For FY25, the
Hydel 446 21.4%
government's projection is PKR 1,952bn (PKR 18.39/KWh). The largest share of
Coal (Imported) 395 18.9%
capacity payments is attributed to nuclear power plants (22.3%), followed by hydel
(21.4%), imported coal (18.9%), and local coal (12.2%). Other contributors include Coal (Local) 256 12.2%
RLNG, wind, gas, RFO, solar, and bagasse. RLNG 168 8.0%
Wind 168 8.0%
2) Currency Depreciation: The depreciation of PKR (62% since November 2017)
RFO 81 3.9%
has increased the revenue requirements of Independent Power Producers (IPPs),
whose tariffs are linked to the USD. This has led to higher electricity tariffs for Gas 61 2.9%
4) Decline in Demand: Electricity demand has been declining for the past two years,
primarily due to rising electricity prices, inflation, reduced industrial demand, and
increased solarization.
We have identified several measures that can lead to a reduction in electricity tariffs;
1) Power Holding Charges: As of May 2024, PKR 765bn of the total circular debt of
PKR 2,655bn is held by Power Holding Limited, with the associated finance costs
passed on to consumers. If the government absorbs this debt, electricity tariffs
could decrease by PKR 3.23/KWh.
As of Jun’24, the circular debt stood at PKR 2,393bn, up from PKR 2,310bn in Jun’23. Of
this total, ~PKR 683bn is managed by Power Holding (Pvt.) Limited (PHPL), while the
remaining PKR 1,710bn is owed to Independent Power Producers (IPPs) and Generation
Companies (GENCOs). Under the IMF’s Stand-By Arrangement (SBA) guidelines,
Pakistani authorities are required to keep the circular debt at PKR 2,393bn.
2,700
2,400
683
2,100
765
800
930
1,007
1,800
1,500
806
1,200
1,710
1,545
583
900
1,452
432
1,350
1,143
600
Jun-16 321 335
Jun-15 314 335
812
560
544
300
-
Jun-17
Jun-18
Jun-19
Jun-20
Jun-21
Jun-22
Jun-23
Jun-24
Source (s): PIDE, NEPRA State of Industry Report 2023, AHL Research
Circular debt management plan FY25: The ECC approved a plan from
the Ministry of Energy (Power Division) to reduce liabilities in the power sector and
improve financial sustainability. The Govt projects the stock of circular debt (CD) is
expected to reach at PKR 2,429bn at the end of FY25 compared to PKR 2,393bn at the
end of FY24. Further, the Government also intends to curtail the CD flow to minimum
possible level for FY25; the govt is to take the following actions;
HUBC holds a 46.0% stake in China Power Hub Generation Company (CPHGC), a
Recommendation HOLD
60.0% stake in Thar Energy Limited, and a 38.3% stake in ThalNova, all of which are
Price Performance
power plants under the China Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC). In past, China has
refused to renegotiate the terms of the plants. But due to recent developments in the 3M 6M 12M
sector, we have run a sensitivity analysis considering the impacts of a reduction in Return (%) -19.9 -13.5 9.2
return on equity (RoE) and a debt moratorium. Avg. Volume (000) 12,581 9,045 6,516
ADTV (mn) - PKR 1,487 1,155 821
Exhibit: Sensitivity Analysis ADTV (000) - USD 5,351 4,154 2,942
RoE EPS (PKR) SoTP High Price - PKR 146.0 157.5 157.5
Discount FY25e FY26f (PKR)
Low Price - PKR 97.4 97.4 97.0
Base case 0.0% 41.2 34.1 115.8
Without Debt Moratorium
Shareholding Pattern
Case 1 0.0% 41.2 34.1 115.8
Case 2 20.0% 39.6 30.9 105.8 Others,
14%
Case 3 30.0% 38.9 29.2 100.1
FI's, 8% Indviduals
Case 4 40.0% 38.1 27.6 86.9
, 30%
Case 5 50.0% 37.3 25.9 75.1
Insurance,
With Debt Moratorium
8%
Case 1 0.0% 33.9 18.2 115.8
Modaraba
Case 2 20.0% 32.3 14.9 105.8 , Mutual
Case 3 30.0% 31.5 13.2 100.1 Funds &
Leasing, Charitbale
Case 4 40.0% 30.8 11.6 86.9 Associted
9% Trusts, 10%
Case 5 50.0% 30.0 10.0 75.1 Cos., 20%
Source (s): AHL Research Source: Company Financials, AHL Research
Jun-24
Mar-24
Feb-24
Apr-24
Oct-24
Jul-24
Nov-23
Dec-23
Aug-24
Sep-24
Nov-24
vehicles, with Build Your Dreams (BYD) a leading Chinese EV manufacturer, through
its associate company, Mega Motor Company (Private) Limited. It is anticipated that
HUBC will commence the manufacturing of the EV and plug-in hybrid vehicles in 2027. Source: Bloomberg, AHL Research
We have also prepared a sensitivity, with respect to volume and price, to showcase the
impact on HUBC.
Moreover, The Hub Power Company Limited has formed a joint venture with Ark Metals
(Private) Limited to explore and develop mineral mines in Pakistan. Completion of this
joint venture agreement is contingent upon obtaining the necessary regulatory approvals
and consents. This partnership marks a strategic step for HUBC and is expected to
favorably affect the profitability of the company.
-
FY24a FY25e FY26f FY27f
Source (s): AHL Research Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research
Technology &
Communication
Unveiling the path to our future
MENA Expansion: BFSI Market Gains: The MENA region has become a strategic
market for Pakistan’s IT sector, especially in the Banking, Financial Services, and
Insurance (BFSI) segments. With established Pakistani IT presence in the Middle East
and Saudi Arabia, expatriates in these regions have also contributed to client growth.
Saudi Arabia, under Vision 2030, is driving rapid IT sector growth, spending increased
17.5% in CY23, the highest globally. This expansion, along with MENA’s projected IT
spending growth of 11% and 5% in CY24 and CY25, respectively, provides a robust
demand backdrop. However, key risks include potential corrections in oil prices and
geopolitical tensions, which could impact regional growth.
Smartphone segment
Domestic Production to support foreign reserves: Pakistan’s mobile phone market,
with an annual demand of around 34mn units, has witnessed a substantial shift toward
local manufacturing. This shift, which has replaced most imports with domestic assembly,
has significantly supported Pakistan’s foreign exchange reserves by reducing reliance
on imports. Only premium brands, such as Apple’s iPhone, remain primarily imported.
This local production also provides new economic opportunities, allowing manufacturers
to explore export markets and position Pakistan as a low-cost mobile manufacturing hub
in the region. This evolution in the mobile phone industry is closely aligned with
government incentives aimed at supporting domestic production and reducing the
country’s import burden.
Policy Support and Market Expansion: Government support remains a key catalyst
for growth in the mobile segment. In recent years, the introduction of policies favoring
local manufacturing and assembly, such as DIRBS, has not only curbed smuggling and
unauthorized imports but has also incentivized local production. Additionally, by
encouraging investment in digital infrastructure, the government has created an
environment conducive to increased smartphone penetration. This government support
aims to reduce dependency on imports while fostering a stronger digital ecosystem that
supports job creation and economic development within Pakistan.
Figure: Historical trend of technology exports Figure: Historical trend of volumetric sales
(USD mn) Technology Exports YoY (RHS) Volumetric sales (units) YoY (RHS)
45.0 50%
350 68%
310 332 40.0 40%
306
310 51% 35.0 30%
303 298 298 292
286
259 265 257 30.0 20%
270 238 34%
25.0 10%
206
20.0 0%
230 17%
15.0 -10%
5.0 -30%
150 -17%
- -40%
Jul-24
Dec-23
Jan-24
Apr-24
Jun-24
Sep-23
Oct-23
Nov-23
Mar-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
Feb-24
May-24
CY20
CY21
CY22
CY23
CY24e
CY25f
CY26f
Source (s): SBP, AHL Research Source (s): PTA, AHL Research
Focused Growth on Core Markets and High-Value Services Source: Company Financials, AHL Research
After experimenting with multiple geographies, SYS is consolidating its efforts in core
areas, primarily the MEA region, to leverage its established expertise. By partnering Relative Performance
closely with tech giants like Microsoft and SAP, SYS aims to stay agile and SYS KSE100
180%
responsive to shifts in the global IT landscape. The company has expanded its
service offerings in high-growth areas such as AI, cloud computing, and 160%
cybersecurity, supported by a growing foreign-based workforce, which now
constitutes around 40% of total employees. Moving forward, SYS plans to focus on 140%
securing high-value clients, leveraging its strong portfolio to target premium
120%
customers rather than casting a wide net, as it did previously.
100%
80%
May-24
Jan-24
Jun-24
Mar-24
Feb-24
Jul-24
Apr-24
Oct-24
Nov-23
Dec-23
Aug-24
Sep-24
Nov-24
Figure: PAT and Net Margins Figure: EBITDA and Gross Margins
(PKR mn) PAT Net margins (RHS) (PKR mn) EBITDA Gross margins (RHS)
11,000 32.0% 14,000 38%
CY22a
CY23a
CY24e
CY25f
CY26f
CY21a
CY22a
CY23a
CY24e
CY25f
CY26f
Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research
remarkable success, with 93% of domestic demand met through local production Return (%) -6.4 78.0 179.1
in 2023. Central to this shift has been the Device Identification Registration and Avg. Volume (000) 6,231 7,287 8,079
Blocking System (DIRBS), which discourages imports through added duties and ADTV (mn) - PKR 862 838 704
limits smuggled devices, making locally assembled phones more accessible and ADTV (000) - USD 3,099 3,011 2,522
affordable. As a leading assembler, Airlink is well-positioned to benefit, with
High Price - PKR 145.2 145.2 145.2
projected revenue growth in its assembly segment at an 18% CAGR through
Low Price - PKR 121.8 71.5 45.7
FY28.
With local production now meeting Pakistan’s ~34mn unit annual mobile demand, 380%
export opportunities are emerging for manufacturers like Airlink. While exports are 340%
not included in our base case, the upside potential is noteworthy. Exporting 300%
400,000 units could yield an additional PKR 26.7bn in revenue, with a 4% 260%
government rebate on exports further boosting EPS by PKR 5.2/share, potentially 220%
enhancing FY25 EPS by 30%. 180%
140%
100%
Nov-23
Dec-23
Nov-24
Apr-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
Oct-24
Mar-24
Feb-24
Jul-24
May-24
Jan-24
Jun-24
Figure: Distribution and Retail revenue Figure: Gross margins vs. Net margins
Distribution and Retail revenue Assembly segment revenue Gross margins Net Margins
(PKR mn)
180,000 12.0%
150,000 10.0%
120,000 8.0%
90,000 6.0%
60,000 4.0%
30,000 2.0%
- 0.0%
FY27f
FY23a
FY24a
FY25e
FY26f
FY28f
FY23a
FY24e
FY25e
FY26e
FY27e
FY28e
Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research
Fueling ambitions
Petroleum sales to grow amid higher demand: The Pakistan oil marketing industry’s
sales have witnessed a decline of 8% YoY in FY24. However, petroleum offtake has
picked up in FY25TD, with petroleum sales volumes increasing by 2% YoY during the
4MFY25. This growth in petroleum offtake is attributed to i) a surge in demand due to
a decline in prices for MS and HSD, ii) restrictions on smuggled petroleum products
from Iran, and iii) an increase in sales of passenger cars. Product-wise, dispatches of
MS and HSD in 4MFY25 rose by 15% and 22% YoY, respectively. Consequently, we
expect MS and HSD volumes to grow by 5% year-on-year in both FY25 and FY26,
keeping in view economic growth. Currently, international oil prices are on a downward
trend due to weak demand in major economies such as the USA and China. However,
escalating tensions in the Middle East could drive oil prices upward.
Revision of OMC margins on the cards: During Oct’24, OGRA proposed a revision
in margins for OMCs and dealers to the government. The proposal was submitted after
PSO provided data on operating costs for the review and calculation of margins. The
proposed margins would increase OMC margins on MS and HSD from PKR 7.87/ltr to
PKR 9.22/ltr. Meanwhile, dealer margins on MS and HSD are proposed to increase by
PKR 1.40/ltr, bringing them to PKR 10.04/ltr. The final decision on this matter is
pending with the Federal Government. If approved, the revision in margins would have
an annualized earnings impact of PKR 11.63/share for PSO, PKR 8.36/share for APL,
and PKR 4.39/share for SHEL.
International oil groups entering the local arena: In FY24, the OMC sector
witnessed significant merger and acquisition activity. During this period, foreign
companies such as Shell Petroleum Company Ltd. exited the country by selling an
88% stake in Shell Pakistan to another foreign company, Wafi Energy Holding, in 2024.
Meanwhile, TotalEnergies, which holds a 50% stake in Total Parco Pakistan,
announced its intention to exit Pakistan and will be replaced by another international
company, Gunvor Group. Additionally, a major international oil giant, Saudi Aramco,
entered Pakistan’s retail oil distribution market by acquiring a 40% stake in Gas and
Oil Pakistan Ltd. (GO) in May’24. Following the entry of this oil giant, GO’s market
share rose to 10% in Oct’24 compared to 4% in the SPLY. Furthermore, the
government is considering to deregulate petroleum prices, allowing OMCs to set their
own prices, which is expected to attract more foreign investors to the local market.
Risk (s):
• Influx of smuggled MS and HSD
• Disruption of White Oil Pipeline (WOP)
• Prolonged delay in cargo of crude and petroleum due blockage in trade routes
0.8 1.0
0.9 1.1
15.0 2.1 0.8 1.1 0% 4MFY25 4MFY24
8.9 1.0 44.8%
2.8%
6.6 6.9
10.0 6.4 6.3 -10% 7.1% 50.1%
10.4%
3.3%
5.0 8.9 -20% 7.3%
7.4 7.1 7.5 7.9 8.8%
0.0 -30%
FY22a FY23a FY24a FY25e FY26f PSO APL SHEL HASCOL Others
Source (s): OCAC, AHL Research Source (s): OCAC, AHL Research
Figure: Average OMC margins Figure: MS & HSD ex refinery price in relation to oil price
Average OMC margins Growth MS HSD Arab Light Price
(PKR/liter) (PKR/liters) (USD/bbl)
12.0 60% 600 100
- 0% 0 40
FY22a FY23a FY24a FY25e FY26f FY20a FY21a FY22a FY23a FY24a
Source (s): OGRA, AHL Research Source (s): OGRA, AHL Research
Jun-24
Mar-24
Feb-24
Apr-24
Oct-24
Jul-24
Nov-23
Dec-23
Nov-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
FOTCO header. Not only this will enable direct MS and HSD supply to the WOP, but
also reduce costs and enhance the storage capacity of the terminal. Meanwhile,
during FY25TD, PSO signed a long-term LPG supply agreement with UEP, which
Source: Bloomberg, AHL Research
increased LPG allocation by 25%. Additionally, three lubricant tanks with a total
capacity of 3,000 tons at the Keamari Terminal B and LMPA facilities have been restored.
Figure: PSO receivables from SNGP in relation to RLNG sales Figure: PSO’s white oil sales
(PKR bn) SNGP Receivable RLNG Sales (PKR bn) (mn tons) MS HSD
20.0
350 1,200
0 0 -
FY20a FY21a FY22a FY23a FY24a FY22a FY23a FY24a FY25e FY26f
Source (s): Company Accounts, AHL Research Source (s): OGRA, AHL Research
Automobile
Assemblers
On the road to recovery
250,000 54%
50,000 -54%
- -81%
FY20 FY21 FY22 FY23 FY24 FY25f
Auto financing providing much needed support: The SBP has lowered the policy rate
by 700bps to 15% since Jun’24, offering much-needed relief to the auto financing rates.
As a result, auto financing has finally seen an increase, reaching PKR 228bn, after
experiencing a consistent decline over the past 27 months. Furthermore, with the
commencement of FY25, we have witnessed an increase in easy monthly installment
(EMI) plans offered by auto assemblers. We expect cheaper bank financing and
attractive EMI plans to emerge as a major factor to contribute to the auto assembling
sector’s volumes.
37.0% 350.0
30.0% 300.0
23.0% 250.0
16.0% 200.0
9.0% 150.0
2.0% 100.0
Jul-21
Jul-22
Jul-23
Jul-24
Jan-21
Nov-21
Jan-22
Nov-22
Jan-23
Nov-23
Jan-24
Sep-21
Sep-22
Sep-23
Sep-24
Mar-21
Mar-22
Mar-23
Mar-24
May-21
May-22
May-23
May-24
EVs and hybrids to change dynamics: The government is actively promoting hybrid
and electric vehicles in the country to mitigate fuel dependence and alleviate the burden
on the import bill. This is evident in the tax incentives it has provided within its auto policies,
which have allowed many auto assemblers like INDU and SAZEW to incorporate hybrid
vehicles in their product line to enhance their profitability. Furthermore, according to
market sources, the upcoming auto policy in FY26 will mainly focus on providing tax
incentives for EVs. As a result, many new players, such as BYD and DFML, along with
existing players like KIA have launched new electric models to benefit from these tax and
duty advantages.
New EV policy on the cards: The government is set to finalize its electric vehicle policy
by the end of this year to accelerate the adoption of EVs. To address the infrastructure
challenges associated with electric vehicles, the government plans to install 40 charging
stations along motorways, as well as an additional 300 stations at key locations
nationwide. Additionally, to ensure that charging remains affordable, the government has
set a power tariff of PKR 39.75/unit for these stations. These efforts are part of a broader
strategy to promote the widespread adoption of electric mobility in Pakistan.
Key risks
• Rising inflation will hurt consumer affordability and shrink demand.
• Any Interest rate hike will lead to expensive auto-financing
• Exchange rate volatility affecting the cost of production.
• Delay in auto policy 2026.
65% for Corolla, Yaris, and Cross, and 40%-50% for Fortuner and Hilux), and a High Price - PKR 2,026.5 2,026.5 2,026.5
favorable shift in the sales mix, particularly following the launch of the Corolla Low Price - PKR 1,627.9 1,500.1 940.7
Cross. Despite a 33% YoY decline in sales volumes, INDU achieved a significant
improvement in profitability with gross margins increasing to 13% in FY24, up 900 Shareholding Pattern
bps from 4.5% in FY23. With a recovery in sales volumes anticipated in FY25, the Others, 5%
Individuals,
company is well-positioned to build on this performance and drive continued 5%
growth.
Insurance, 6%
Robust cash position
INDU sits on massive piles of cash and cash equivalents (including short term Associated
Cos., 6%
investment) of PKR 83.7bn which translates to PKR 1064/share. This creates a
solid cushion for INDU and creates ample room for stunning dividend pay-outs, Foreign
new model launch and investment in capacity expansion. Also, availability of huge Investor,
78%
liquidity makes company less risky stock compared to listed peers.
Cheap Valuation
Source: Company Financials, AHL Research
We anticipate the company's bottom-line for FY25 and FY26 to stand at PKR
237.55/share and PKR 284.06/share, respectively. This valuation positions the Relative Performance
company at a FY25 P/E of 8.4x, signifying an undervalued P/E multiple. This is
200% INDU KSE100
supported by the expectation of earnings recovery due to INDU's persistent brand
image and the new launch of the Hybrid Corolla. We recommend a buy stance on 180%
INDU with a Dec'25 target price of PKR 2,459/share, implying an upside potential
of 22.9%. 160%
140%
120%
100%
Nov-23
Dec-23
Nov-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
Oct-24
Apr-24
Feb-24
Mar-24
Jul-24
May-24
Jan-24
Jun-24
Income Statement
Net Sales 152,481 177,759 243,344
Balance Sheet
Shareholder's Equity 67,226 74,658 83,624
Figure: Sales volumes and Gross margins Figure: PAT and Return on equity
PAT ROE (RHS)
Sales Volume Gross Margin (RHS)
(Units) (PKR mn) (%)
FY18a
FY19a
FY21a
FY22a
FY23a
FY24a
FY25e
FY16a
FY17a
FY18a
FY19a
FY20a
FY21a
FY22a
FY23a
FY24a
FY25e
Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research
Textile Composite
Facing the headwinds
Cotton supply and demand in Pakistan: Pakistan’s cotton demand stands at 11.0mn
bales, with a projected production of 7.0mn bales for FY25, requiring imports of around
4.0mn bales. As of 31st Oct’24, the cotton arrivals in Pakistan have dropped by 37% YoY
totaling 4.3mn bales. The contraction in cotton output is largely attributed to delays in
sowing, which stemmed from reduced farmer income on wheat. This income drops
resulted from the Punjab government’s decision not to purchase wheat at the support
price of PKR 3,099 per maund, which impacted farmers’ cash flow and planting
decisions. On a positive note, international cotton prices (Cotlook A) have significantly
declined by 9.5% YoY to USD 81.7/maund, relieving Pakistan’s textile sector from price
pressures and ensuring steady supply availability.
Elevated energy tariffs and financing costs still remains a hurdle: The textile
industry faces considerable headwinds from escalating gas and electricity tariffs, along
with increased Long-Term Financing Facility (LTFF) rates. The electricity rates went up
from 9 cents/kWh to 14 cents/kWh in FY24. Additionally, the LTFF, set at 3% below the
policy rate, has driven financing costs higher, adding strain to a sector reliant on
subsidized loans for capital investment.
Exhibit: Domestic cotton production compared to imports Exhibit: Historical trend of cotton prices
(mn bales) Imports Local Prodcution (PKR/maund) Local Prices Intl' Prices (USd/lb)
24,000 110
18.0
16.0 22,000
14.0 100
20,000
12.0
10.0 18,000 90
8.0
6.0 16,000
80
4.0 14,000
2.0
- 12,000 70
Jul-24
Nov-23
Dec-23
Jan-24
Jun-24
Feb-24
Mar-24
Apr-24
Aug-24
Sep-24
Oct-24
Nov-24
May-24
FY17A
FY25E
FY10A
FY11A
FY12A
FY13A
FY14A
FY15A
FY16A
FY18A
FY19A
FY20A
FY21A
FY22A
FY23A
FY24A
Source (s): PBS, Pakistan Economic Survey, AHL Research Source (s): Business Recorder, Bloomberg, AHL Research
Interloop, the leading textile company and a global frontrunner in the socks (hosiery) Last Closing 63.7
manufacturing sector, emerges as our top pick within the textiles industry. The Upside (%) 21.6
company operates a production capacity of 873mn pairs of socks per year through Shares (mn) 1,401.7
five vertically integrated manufacturing facilities. It serves international brands and Free float (%) 20
retailers globally, including Nike, adidas, STICHD, Target, H&M, C&A, Amazon, and Market Cap. (PKR mn) 89,233
Uniqlo. The recent acquisition of Top Circle has also helped the company expand Market Cap. (USD mn) 321
its manufacturing footprint to China. We forecast a 10% rebound in volumetric sales
within the hosiery segment for FY25, leading to an impressive projected 4-year
Recommendation BUY
CAGR of 34% in hosiery sales. Looking ahead, we expect gross margins for this Price Performance
segment to remain robust at 27% in FY25, strengthened by a decline in international 3M 6M 12M
cotton prices. Return (%) -6.4 -21.5 13.1
Avg. Volume (000) 971 1,073 860
Capacity expansion with new apparel plant
ADTV (mn) - PKR 66 76 61
Interloop’s apparel facility is setting new standards for textile manufacturing with a
fully integrated, automated process encompassing yarn spinning, fabric processing, ADTV (000) - USD 239 274 218
knitting, dyeing, garment laundry, and sewing. By FY26, annual production capacity High Price - PKR 75.4 81.3 81.3
is expected to nearly double, reaching 69.8mn pieces from 33.6mn in FY24. Low Price - PKR 62.1 62.1 55.8
Moreover, the denim garment segment, currently producing 7mn pieces annually,
is also on track for expansion to 1.5mn pieces per month by 2026. Shareholding Pattern
Foreign Others,
Leading export growth 4%
Cos., 2%
As one of Pakistan’s largest and fastest-growing textile exporters, Interloop
consistently outpaces industry growth. Ranking first among listed companies and Modaraba…
second among all textile firms in the country, Interloop achieved a substantial 33%
revenue growth from FY19 to FY24, compared to the sector average of 11%. With
Individuals
USD 529mn in export sales, the hosiery business remains the key driver, Directors,
, 19%
CEO,
contributing 74% of total revenue. Spouse &
Others,
Sustainability driven future 72%
Towards the end of FY26, the revenue of ILP is expected to touch USD 700mn.
Interloop is a pioneer in sustainability, becoming the first large enterprise in Source: Company Financials, AHL Research
Pakistan’s manufacturing sector to have its science-based targets approved. The
company is expanding its renewable energy portfolio, aiming to increase solar Relative Performance
capacity to 25MW by FY26, up from the current 12.6MW. Furthermore, Interloop is
180% ILP KSE100
enhancing its clean energy initiatives with a biomass boiler for steam generation
and a water recycling facility at its Apparel Park. These investments highlight
Interloop’s commitment to environmentally responsible growth. 160%
140%
120%
100%
May-24
Jan-24
Jun-24
Feb-24
Mar-24
Apr-24
Oct-24
Jul-24
Sep-24
Aug-24
Dec-23
Nov-24
Nov-23
Exhibit: Payout ratio (trend and forecast) Exhibit: PAT Trend and forecast
EPS DPS Payout Ratio (RHS)
(PKR) (PKR bn)
Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research
Alpha Stocks
Following a recent price increase for essential medicines under the "hardship" category,
including flagship brands such as Augmentin, Amoxil, and Zantac, GLAXO reported
significant margin expansion in 2QCY24, reaching 24% compared to just 4% in the same
period last year. This margin improvement reflects effective price pass-throughs,
strengthened by strong demand across its essential portfolio.
The company recorded 9MCY24 earnings at PKR 11.25/share and is expected to close
CY24 with an earnings of PKR 17.2/share. With full impact of deregulation of non-
essential medicines and better margins, GLAXO's CY25 earnings are projected at PKR
26.5/share, yielding a P/E multiple of 12.1x as compared to pharma average P/E of 16.8x
GLAXO
Last Closing 316.7
Additionally, Shifa has extended its gastroenterology offerings by creating new revenue-
generating clinical spaces, including eight consultation rooms and a comfortable waiting
area for 35 individuals. Reinforcing its commitment to sustainability, Shifa has installed
a 900KW PV solar system, significantly reducing energy costs while repurposing heat
from generators via waste heat recovery boilers to minimize gas emissions. Shifa's
recent strategic expansions have positively impacted profitability, with EPS rising by 70%
YoY to PKR 10.1. Looking ahead, FY25 earnings are projected at PKR 44.2/share, which
translates into an attractive forward PE multiple of 8.5x as compared to its last 5-yr
average P/E of 14.2x.
SHFA
Last Closing 370.65
Shares (mn) 63.2
Market Cap. (PKR mn) 23,430.4
Market Cap. (USD mn) 84.4
Price Performance
3M 6M 12M
Return 181.1% 170.6% 187.7%
Average Volume (000) 113.51 69.76 42.87
ADTV (mn) - PKR 23.67 13.91 8.03
ADTV (000) - USD 85.16 50.02 28.82
High Price - PKR 375.03 375.03 375.03
Low Price - PKR 125.41 125.41 125.41
Key Financials
2023 2024 LTM
Earning Per Share PKR 18.69 21.55 25.27
Price to Earning x 6.5 6.4 14.7
Price to Book x 0.81 0.64 1.87
Dividend Yield % 1.1% 3.3% 1.1%
Return on Equity % 12% 12% 13%
Source (s): Company Financials, Bloomberg, AHL Research
TGL acquired 50% stake in MMM Holding Pvt Ltd during FY24, which holds an 84%
stake in Balochistan Glass Limited (BGL), which has expanded its portfolio into
pharmaceutical bottles. Post-acquisition, BGL’s Unit-1 plant in Hub, Balochistan,
resumed commercial operations in Jun’24.
Keeping in view high cost of power and fuel, TGL added 2.5 MWh of solar capacity,
raising total solar generation to 3.5 MWh, which has resulted in enhanced gross margins.
During FY24, the company’s profitability increased to PKR 25.41/share (PKR
22.05/share ex-bargain purchase gain) from PKR 14.63/share in SPLY. With economic
stability and better margins from reliance on solar power, TGL's FY25 earnings are
projected at PKR 21.50/share, yielding a P/E multiple of 6.0x
TGL
Last Closing 130.59
Shares (mn) 172.2
Market Cap. (PKR mn) 22,483.3
Market Cap. (USD mn) 81.0
Price Performance
3M 6M 12M
Return 16.1% 14.4% 39.9%
Average Volume (000) 294.05 300.16 404.13
ADTV (mn) - PKR 34.39 34.86 44.12
ADTV (000) - USD 123.71 125.33 157.48
High Price - PKR 132.86 132.86 132.86
Low Price - PKR 108.09 105.72 87.89
Key Financials
2023 2024 LTM
Earning Per Share PKR 14.63 25.41 25.10
Price to Earning x 4.3 4.2 5.2
Price to Book x 1.19 0.59 1.16
Dividend Yield % 5.7% 0.0% 0.0%
Return on Equity % 18% 26% 23%
Source (s): Bloomberg, PSX, Company Financials, AHL Research
Appliance Division: This division contributes ~58% to total revenue and provides a wide
variety of products such as refrigerators, air conditioners, washing machines, microwave
ovens, LED TVs, and other household appliances. The appliance segment's growth is
driven by addressing the product penetration gap, rapid urbanization, and improving
lifestyles, ensuring robust fundamentals. With improving macroeconomic conditions,
eased import restrictions, and controlled inflation, the division’s performance has
strengthened and is expected to continue driving growth as the country’s economy
undergoes further revitalization.
Power Division: Contributing around 42% to the total revenue, this division focuses on
manufacturing power transformers, distribution transformers, energy meters, switch
gears, and grid stations. The division is well-positioned to benefit from increasing
demand for electrical infrastructure driven by urbanization, lifestyle improvements, and
government initiatives to upgrade the country’s electricity transmission and distribution
networks. The rising demand from industrial growth, expanding housing, and greater
electricity consumption (due to the growing use of electrical appliances) further
strengthens the outlook for this division.
For the 9MFY24, PAEL posted earnings of PKR 2.14 per share. Full-year earnings are
expected to reach PKR 2.74 per share, with profitability projected to rise to PKR 4.11 per
share in 2025, offering an attractive forward P/E ratio of 6.3x.
PAEL
Last Closing 27.51
Shares (mn) 856.0
Market Cap. (PKR mn) 23,548.9
Market Cap. (USD mn) 84.8
Price Performance
3M 6M 12M
Return 9.0% 1.4% 73.2%
Average Volume (000) 8,535.9 8,599.7 10,992.5
ADTV (mn) - PKR 252.9 249.4 284.5
ADTV (000) - USD 909.5 896.6 1,017.2
High Price - PKR 29.01 29.01 29.01
Low Price - PKR 23.61 23.61 15.88
Key Financials
2022 2023 LTM
Earning Per Share PKR 1.25 1.55 2.62
Price to Earning x 10.4 11.3 10.5
Price to Book x 0.4 0.3 0.5
Dividend Yield % 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
Return on Equity % 2.9% 3.3% 5.3%
Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research
Ufone, a subsidiary of PTCL, provides mobile voice and data services, offering both
prepaid and postpaid plans. The company has a customer base of over 25mn. It also
holds the highest 4G net additions in the industry. Additionally, PTC has signed a share
purchase agreement to acquire 100% stake in Telenor Pakistan with cash and debt free
value of PKR 108bn. This acquisition will allow PTC to leverage synergies, significantly
expand its customer base, and enhance its network coverage, positioning the company
as a dominant player in the market.
In CY24, Telenor's EBITDA is projected to reach PKR 45.2bn. Assuming the same
profitability from Telenor going forward and depreciation expense of PKR 10bn annually
and expected interest cost of PKR 5.4bn on USD 400mn loan, the annual contribution
after tax expected to be PKR 15.8bn (EPS PKR 4.2/share).
PTC reported a consolidated loss of PKR 15.3bn (LPS: PKR 4.06) for 9MCY24, primarily
driven by substantial finance costs totaling PKR 38.7bn (PKR 10.2/share). As of Sep’24,
PTC’s long-term debt stands at PKR 106.5bn. In lieu of this leveraged position, we
estimate that a 1% reduction in interest rates could enhance PTC’s profitability by
approximately PKR 1.1bn (PKR 0.3/share), highlighting the company’s sensitivity to a
declining interest rate environment.
PTC
Last Closing 16.26
Shares (mn) 3,774.0
Market Cap. (PKR mn) 61,365.2
Market Cap. (USD mn) 220.9
Price Performance
3M 6M 12M
Return 30.9% 16.8% 127.7%
Average Volume (000) 8,364.69 7,064.93 9,604.73
ADTV (mn) - PKR 141.87 115.04 168.43
ADTV (000) - USD 510.53 413.71 602.22
High Price - PKR 16.76 16.76 18.42
Low Price - PKR 11.09 11.01 6.94
Key Financials
2022 2023 LTM
Loss Per Share PKR (2.06) (3.72) (5.16)
Price to Earning x nm nm nm
Price to Book x 0.70 0.56 0.52
Dividend Yield % 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
Return on Equity % -21% -35% -46%
Source (s): Company Financials, AHL Research
Contact list
Name Designation Email address Contact list
Shahid Ali Habib Chief Executive Officer shahid.habib@arifhabibltd.com 92 -21-3240-1930
Senior Management
Tahir Abbas Director – Equities tahir.abbas@arifhabibltd.com 92-21-3246-2742
Usman Taufiq Ahmed Director/Head – Trading & Sales usman.ta@arifhabibltd.com 92-21-3246-8285
Sana Tawfik Head of Research sana.tawfik@arifhabibltd.com 92-21-3828-0283
Bilal Khan Director – International Sales bilal.khan@arifhabibltd.com 92-21-3246-5894
Research Team
Rao Aamir Ali Deputy Head - Research amir.rao@arifhabibltd.com 92-21-3828-1106
Muhammad Iqbal Jawaid AVP - Research iqbal.jawaid@arifhabibltd.com 92-21-3828-0256
Muhammad Abrar Investment Analyst muhammad.abrar@arifhabibltd.com 92-21-3828-0264
Menka Kirpalani Investment Analyst menka.kumari@arifhabibltd.com 92-21-3246-2589
Naseem Akhtar Khattak Manager Database naseem.akhtar@arifhabibltd.com 92-21-3246-1106
Ali Muhammad Dhedhi Assistant Manager Database ali.muhammad@arifhabibltd.com 92-21-3246-1106
Rating Description
BUY Upside of subject security(ies) is more than +15% from last closing of market price(s)
HOLD Upside of subject security(ies) is between 0% and +15% from last closing of market price(s)
SELL Upside of subject security(ies) is less than 0% from last closing of market price(s)
Risks
The following risks may potentially impact our valuations of subject security (ies);
➢ Market risk
➢ Interest Rate Risk
➢ Exchange Rate (Currency) Risk
Disclaimer: This document has been prepared by Research analysts at Arif Habib Limited (AHL). This document does not constitute an offer or solicitation
for the purchase or sale of any security. This publication is intended only for distribution to the clients of the Company who are assumed to be reasonably
sophisticated investors that understand the risks involved in investing in equity securities. The information contained herein is based upon publicly available
data and sources believed to be reliable. While every care was taken to ensure accuracy and objectivity, AHL does not represent that it is accurate or complete
and it should not be relied on as such. In particular, the report takes no account of the investment objectives, financial situation and particular needs of
investors. The information given in this document is as of the date of this report and there can be no assurance that future results or events will be consistent
with this information. This information is subject to change without any prior notice. AHL reserves the right to make modifications and alterations to this
statement as may be required from time to time. However, AHL is under no obligation to update or keep the information current. AHL is committed to providing
independent and transparent recommendation to its client and would be happy to provide any information in response to specific client queries. Past
performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance. This document is provided for assistance only and is not intended to be and must not alone be
taken as the basis for any investment decision. The user assumes the entire risk of any use made of this information. Each recipient of this document should
make such investigation as it deems necessary to arrive at an independent evaluation of an investment in the securities of companies referred to in this
document (including the merits and risks involved), and should consult his or her own advisors to determine the merits and risks of such investment. AHL or
any of its affiliates shall not be in any way responsible for any loss or damage that may be arise to any person from any inadvertent error in the information
contained in this report.