Approaches-Methods-in-Extension
Approaches-Methods-in-Extension
EXTENSION AND
COMMUNICATION
RYAN PAUL C. CAALEM, LPT, RA
Approaches in
Extension
THREE TERMS OF
APPROACHES IN EXTENSION
Approaches
Approaches
Method
Method
Technique Technique
3
Approaches
Embraces the entire spectrum of the process. It
states a point of view, a philosophy, an article of faith.
Within an approach, there can be several methods.
4
Method
It is procedural consisting of a series of
actions arranged logically for the smooth
operation of a particular teaching task or techno
promotion.
Method is the procedure or step by step
way by guiding perspective Clients or Adopters
and knowing trying and adopting specific
technology
5
Technique
It is implemental, having an
immediate applicability to the Extension
Worker or teacher owning to its specificity,
feasibility and convenience to the one using
it.
6
Extension Approach
An Extension Approach is an organized and coherent
combination of strategies and methods, designed to make rural
extension effective in a certain area designed to make rural
extension effective in a certain area.
7
EXTENSION APPROACHES
1. General Agricultural Extension Approach
2. Commodity Specialized Approach
3. Project Approach
4. Farming Systems Development Approach
5. Training and Visit System Approach
6. The Cost-Sharing Approach
7. Agricultural Extension Participatory Approach
8. Educational Institution Approach
9. Mass Approach
10. Single-Purpose Approach
11. Community Approach
12. Area Approach
13. Integrated Approach
8
1. General Agricultural
Extension Approach (GAE)
c. Purpose:
a. General Nature:
› To help farmers increase their
› Transfer of Technology production.
(TOT)
d. Program Planning:
› Controlled by government
b. Basic Assumption:
› Changes in priority, from time to
› Technology and information time are made on a national basis
are available but are not with freedom for local adaptation.
being used by the farmers. If
e. Implementation:
these could be
communicated to farmers, › Carried by a large field staff
farm practices would be assigned throughout country
improved. Demonstration plots are major
techniques.
9
ADVANTAGES &
DISADVANTAGES
g. Advantages:
f. Advantages:
› Lacks two-way flow of
› Interpret national communication.
government policies and
› Fails to adjust extension
procedures to the local
messages to different
people; covers the whole
localities.
nation: relatively rapid
communication from the › Field staff not accountable
ministry level to rural to rural people.
people. › Expensive and inefficient.
h. Measure of Success:
› Increase in national production of commodities being
emphasized in national program.
10
2. Commodity Specialized Approach (CSA)
a. General Nature: c. Purpose:
› Highly specialized › Increase production of a
particular commodity
› Focuses on one export crop or
one aspect of farming › Sometimes to increase
utilization of a particular
b. Basic Assumption:
agricultural input
› The way to increase
d. Program Planning
productivity and production of
a particular commodity is to › Controlled by commodity
concentrate on that one organization
grouping extension with such e. Implementation :
other functions as research, › Carried by a large field staff
input supply, output assigned throughout the
marketing, credit, and country
sometimes price control, will
make the whole system › Demonstration plots are
productive. major techniques
11
ADVANTAGES & DISADVANTAGES
f. Advantages:
g. Disadvantages:
› Technology tends to "fit" the
production problems and so › Interests of farmers may
extension messages tend to be have less priority than those
appropriate because of of commodity organization.
coordination with research and › Does not provide advisory
marketing people, messages tend service to other aspects of
to be delivered in a timely manner farming.
Focus on a narrow range of › Commodity organization
technical concerns Higher salary maybe promoting its
incentives. commodity even in
› Focus on narrow range of situations where it is no
technical concerns longer in the national
› Higher salary incentives interest to be increasing
production of that particular
› Closer management and commodity.
supervision Fewer farmers per
extension worker easier to monitor h. Measure of Success:
and evaluate Relatively more cost › Increase in yield and total production
effective. of the crops being emphasized.
12
3. The Project Approach (PA)
c. Purpose:
a. General Nature: › To demonstrate, within project area,
› Fixed period of time, large what can be accomplished on a
funding relatively short period of time
14
4. The Farming Systems Development Approach
a. General Nature: d. Program Planning
19
ADVANTAGES &
DISADVANTAGES
f. Advantages: g. Disadvantages:
› Some measure of local control › More difficult for central
of program planning increases government to control either
relevance of program content program or personnel
and methods to need of
clients.
› Higher adoption rates.
h. Measure of Success:
› Effective communication › Farm people's willingness and
between local people and ability to prove some share of
extension worker. the cost, individually or
› Lower cost of central through their local government
government and local people. units.
› Local people tend to have
strong voice in program
planning.
20
7. Participatory Approach
a. General Nature: c. Purpose:
› Puts responsibility of determining › To increase production of
agricultural extension programs in the farming people, increase
hand of farmers making them partners consumption and
with GOs and NGOs. enhance the quality of life
b. Basic Assumption: or rural people.
› The farming people have much wisdom d. Program Planning
regarding food production from their
land.
› Controlled locally often
by farmers association.
› There is IKS different from the scientific
e. Implementation :
knowledge system but there is much to
be gained from the interaction of the › Features meeting and
two. discussions of farmers
› Needed is participation of farmers, problem.
research and related service. › Exploring situations with
› There is a reinforcing effect in group extension officers.
learning and group action.
› Extension efficiency is gained by
focusing on important points based on 21
expressed needs of farmers.
ADVANTAGES & DISADVANTAGES
f. Advantages: g. Disadvantages:
› Relevance or fit of the › Lack of control of program
program. from central government
› Mutually supportive › Difficulty of managing ,
relationship which develop reporting and accounting
among participants. › Pressure people might bring
› Lesser cost. on central units
› Stimulates increased › People influenced on
awareness, confidence, and personnel management like
activity among farm people transfer , selection,
promotion etc.
h. Measure of Success:
› Continuity of local extension organisations and the benefits to the
community.
› Extent of participation of key stakeholders in programme planning and
implementation
22
8. Educational Institution
Approach
23
9. Mass Approach
24
10. Single-Purpose Approach
25
11. Community Approach
The local political structure spearheads and play
active role in designing the development program. The
local development councils at barangay, municipal, city
levels are mobilized as planning bodies. Using the IRA
(Internal Revenue Unit) and other funding sources.
Various social institution such as school, church, market,
family are involved in the development.
26
12. Area Approach
27
13. Integrated Approach
28
METHODS AND TECHNIQUES OF
EXTENSION DEFINITION
APPROACH
• IS AN ORGANIZED AND COHERENT COMBINATION OF
STRATEGIES AND METHODS, DESIGNED TO MAKE
RURAL EXTENSION EFFECTIVE IN A CERTAIN AREA.
METHODS/TECHNIQUES
• GENERAL ESTABLISHED WAY OR ORDER OF DOING
ANYTHING
• MANNER BY WHICH YOU PRESENT OR TEACH YOUR
SUBJECT MATTER
• SYSTEMATIC PLAN ADOPTED IN PRESENTING
INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS
Definition of Important Concepts
◆ Teaching - is the process of transmitting ideas, information, technologies
from one person to another with the intent of enhancing and modifying
the learner's, knowledge, attitude and skill.
◆ Method - refers to the systematic procedure employed by extension
worker in getting the vital information across the client learners.
TECHNIQUES
DEVICE
Factors to consider in the choice of
teaching method to use
1. Human factors
2. The objectives
3. Subject matter
4. Available materials and facilities
5. Time consideration
6. Available budget support
• TOOLS IN APPROACHING , WORKING WITH AND
INFLUENCING PEOPLE TO BECOME INTERESTED AND
HAVE SUCCESSFUL EXPERIENCES IN SOLVING THEIR
PROBLEMS THROUGH THEIR OWN EFFORTS MAKING
MAXIMUM USE OF THE GUIDANCE AND TECHNICAL
RESOURCES OF THE GOVERNMENT.
• FOR CONVENIENCE , THESE METHODS ARE GROUPED
INTO THREE
CATEGORIES ACCORDING TO NUMBER OF CLIENTELE TO BE
SERVED:
• INDIVIDUAL METHODS (PERSONAL CONTACTS)
• GROUP METHODS
• MASS METHODS
Interrelated Factors to consider in selecting
extension teaching method
1. CLIENTELE/AUDIENCES SPECIFIC: INDIVIDUAL/S
groups: primary, secondary
masses: cosmopolitan, homogenous
Source/receiver
❑ Communication skills
❑ Knowledge of subject matter, receiver, language
attitude towards self, subject matter, receiver
❑ Socio-cultural factors: role position in membership
group,
❑ Prestige other people attach to him/her; norms &
rules; beliefs & values.
Interrelated Factors to consider in selecting
extension teaching method
❑ highly controversial
❑ very scientific
❑ personal in nature
❑ general
3. DESIRED CHANGES
❑ Attitude
❑ Knowledge
❑ Skill
❑ Aspiration
What are the classifications of extension
methods?
A. According to forms:
1. Written
. Bulletins . Personal Letters
. Leaflets . Circular Letters
. News Articles
2. Spoken
. General & Special Meetings of all Kinds
. Farm & Home Visits
. Telephone Calls
. Office Calls
. Radio
Classification of extension methods according
to forms:
3. Objective Or Visual
a. Result Demonstration
b. Motion Pictures, Charts, Slides, Tapes, Video & Etc.
c. Exhibits
d. Posters
4. Spoken And Objective Or Visual
a. Method Demonstration Meetings
b. Meetings At Result Demonstration
c. Meetings Involving Motion Pictures, Charts, Etc.
Classification of extension methods according
to use:
B. According to use
1. Individual Methods
Farm & Home Visit Personal Letters
Office Calls Informal Contact
Telephone Calls Electronic Media (Fax
etc.)
2. Group methods
a. lecture e. field day
b. demonstration f. meetings
c. tours and field trips
d. group discussion
◼ Purposes:
a. A service call made on request to give
advice or assistance on a wide range of
farm& home problems;
b. Securing a cooperator or demonstrator,
arranging a meeting, or discussing a local
activity;
c. In the interest of good public relations with
officers of local organizations, elected
officials, or other key individuals;
d. Broadly speaking, for the purpose
of giving information or obtaining
information.
INDIVIDUAL METHODS OF EXTENSION
a) giving/getting information,
b) enlisting cooperation,
c) giving recognition for good work
& thanks for cooperation,
d) giving instruction, for
example, on how to manage a
result demonstration and
avoiding a misunderstanding
INDIVIDUAL METHODS OF EXTENSION
6. Result Demonstration
Advantages:
◼ Furnishes local proof of the desirability of the
recommended practice;
◼ Appeals to the eye and is effective in convincing those
who question the practice;
◼ A good way to introduce a new project.
Result Demonstration
◼ Limitations:
◼ May be hard to find a responsible
cooperator,
◼ May arouse jealousy among families
because of number of visits extension
workers make to cooperators,
◼ May be affected by many uncontrollable
factors like weather,
◼ May lessen effectiveness of extension
worker if demonstration is not successful,
and
◼ Is not adaptable to many kinds of subject
matter.
Informal contacts . These are unstructured and/or planned
meetings with clientele .Such meetings provide the extension worker
with an opportunity to meet clientele in an informal situation , which
facilitates the establishment of personal bond , discussion of problems
and the recommendation of solutions . informal contacts can take
place on the street, in the marketplace, or at local celebrations.
GROUP METHODS OF EXTENSION
1. Lecture
is a process whereby the
resource speaker or facilitator
delivers a prepared talk and may
distribute handouts and use audio-
visual aids.
It is used to describe and explain
a subject matter, present new
information and explain procedure.
Purposes of talks:
a. to inform or instruct,
b. to convince or persuade,
c. to entertain or amuse, and
d. to generate action
GROUP METHODS OF EXTENSION
Lecture
Advantages:
◼ many topics can be covered in a short period
◼ the facilitator is in complete control
Disadvantages:
◼ the communication is primarily one-way
◼ the retention rate is low.
◼ lack of involvement of participants
◼ it can be a boring
GROUP METHODS OF EXTENSION
◼ 2. Demonstration couldbe:
a. Method demonstration
b. Result demonstration
c. Action demonstration
Advantages:
◼ effective in teaching skills.
.
GROUP METHODS OF EXTENSION
◼ 3. Meetings are the oldest and most
important group method of extension teaching.
◼ Newspaper
◼ Newspaper prints anything timely that interest a number of
persons and the best news is that which has the greatest
interest for the greatest number.
◼ It is a chief means of getting information about
extension activities to rural & urban people who are
not contacted individually, do not attend meetings,
or participate in other activities.
◼ It appears to the sense of sight only. It is a chief means of
getting information about extension activities to rural and
urban people who could be contacted individually, do not
attend meetings or participate in other extension
activities.
MASS METHODS OF EXTENSION
What makes news?
a. Timeliness - information should be linked to major current
events or the season when the information is relevant.
b. Closeness - the nearer the information is to the reader
either psychologically or geographically, the greater its news
value.
c. Importance - the greater the consequences for the reader,
the more readily will the editor accepts the story.
d. Significance - prominent people and places have news
value.
e. Human interest - readers are attracted by human
interest elements such as novelty, conflict, progress and
emotion.
MASS METHODS OF EXTENSION
How to write a ‘comprehensible’ publication?
a. Use simple language- technical terms should be
explained in short and simple sentences using common
words which have concrete meanings.
b. Structure and arrange arguments clearly – ideas
should be presented in a logical order, clearly
distinguishing between main and side issues.
c. Make main points briefly – arguments should be restricted
to the main issues and clearly directed towards achieving
stated goals without unnecessary use of words.
d. Make writing stimulating to read – the style should be
interesting, inspiring, exciting, personal and sufficiently
diversified to maintain the readers’ interest.
Extension publications use pictures and other visual
materials to increase effectiveness of communication
through:
a. Information that cannot be conveyed by words alone
may be transmitted visually;
b. Information given in words and pictures is remembered
more easily; and
c. The reader’s interest in increased.
MASS METHODS OF EXTENSION
◼ Printed Instructional Materials (IMs)
1. Primer consists of more than 4 pages containing
essential information of a technology addressed to
producer/farmer and written in the dialect.
◼ Printed Instructional
Materials
❑ Folders
❑ Posters
❑ Wall newspaper
❑ Fact sheets
To avoid confusion, the different publications can be
described as the follow;
1. Poster 8. Handouts
2. Leaflets 9. Newsletter
3. Circular letters 10. Factsheets
4. Newspaper 11. Photo novel
5. Primer 12. Wall Newspaper
6. Brochures 13. Flyers
7. Booklets 14. Bulletin
Poster – are useful publicizing forthcoming events and reinforcing
messages that farmers receive through other media. They should be
displayed in prominent places where a lot of people regularly pass by. The
most effective posters carry a simple message, catch people’s attention
and are east to interpret.
Leaflets – summarize the main points of a talk or demonstration, provide
detailed information that would not be remembered simply by hearing it,
such as fertilizer application rates or names of seed varieties. It is a single
sheet printed material containing brief information that is not necessarily
a step-by-step procedural instructions to follow but is also needed by the
farmers. It may bear on both sides and may be folded.
Circular letters – are used to publicise local extension activities, to give
timely information on local farm problems and to summarise results of
demonstrations so that the many farmers who cannot attend them may
still benefit.
Newspapers – are not widely available in rural areas. However, local
leaders often read newspapers and a regular column on agricultural topics
is useful to create awareness of new ideas and to inform people of what
other groups or communities are doing. This provides available channel for
transmission of educational information.
Primer – is a pamphlet or more than four pages containing essential
information on a technology package. Essentially, this is in the popular or
layman's level.
Brochure – thin, unbound book containing a specific topic, more detailed
than a leaflet.
Booklet – consist of up to 20 pages joined at the spine, longer than a
brochure.
Handouts – supplemental to lectures contain some topics or important
information discussed in the lecture.
Newsletter – a regularly issued publication, keeps people abreast to what
is happening in their field of interest.
Factsheet – contains useful information or instructions about a specific
subject matter; one-page, continuous publication.
Photo novel – generic for printed material in comics format; including
illustrations and text; a subtle way of putting a message where in a
development message is incorporated in the story.
Wall newspaper – this material is similar size and appearance to poster. One
difference though is that the world newspaper usually attempts to
communicate more than one idea and has more illustrations. Usually, it is
posted at busy and strategically located bulletin boards or walls or reading
centres, schools or barangay halls.
Flyers – is a single sheet printed material summarising information on
technology package or component technology. It bears illustrations and brief
text, preferably in the audience dialects. It is used as reference for further
technical assistance and for use as advanced handout information. It bears
print only on one side.
Bulletin – is a semi technical publication on a package of technology intended
for extension worker.
Broadcast media - radio and television are
included under this section. Radio is a
presentation medium which basically makes
use of the audio mode in disseminating
information simultaneously to thousand or
even millions of potential receivers.
Television adds another dimension to the
capability of radio, i.e. One does not only
hear but can also see the event, object or
the person disseminating the information.
Exhibits - can be regarded as a public display
of technologies, innovations, products or
even services available to the farmers,
fisherfolks, entrepreneurs, in particular and
the public, in general.
MASS METHODS OF EXTENSION
2. Television is an electronic
transmission of moving images
accompanied by sounds which is
mainly used for entertainment.
◼ Farmers are somewhat confused
by the competitive claims of the
advertisements.
◼ It appears to more than one
sense.
◼ It offers less opportunity for
review and interaction.
MASS METHODS OF EXTENSION
3. Radio is the most available home appliance
in rural areas which reaches great numbers of people
simultaneously but no assurance that it actually
motivates people to adopt recommended practices.
◼ It could be used to make people aware of new
developments in agriculture as well as exhort them to
action (example: school-on-the-air broadcast).
4. Puppetry
5. Popular theater
◼ 8. Projected visuals
◼ 9. Lanternslides
AUDIO-VISUAL AIDS
• They assume considerable importance in extension
works. People learn through all their senses . the
more senses are used , the more learning is
increased . audio-means pertaining to hearing. So,
audio-visual aids are those using sight and hearing
together . the types of visuals are:
Presentation visual – these is used to reinforce or clarify
a speaker’s message. They include sample and specimens,
models, photographs, blackboards, flannel graphs and
flashcards.
DISPLAY VISUALS
• D.2.1. Posters – use to announce extension activities or to
publicize campaign objectives .
• D.2.2. Wall charts – provide explanatory support to the
main teaching activity . they contain graphically certain
processes , like the life cycle of the pest and the pest
control techniques.
• D.2.3. Bulletin board – carry posters, wall charts,
bulletins, handouts and announcements of extension
activities , agricultural information and news.
• D.2.4.1 – Bulletins- contain complete summary of the
information available on a particular subject e.g. Certain
specialized poultry , livestock or crops.
Leaflets – provide practical advice on farming/Homemaking
problems and practices.
Handouts – used to aid recall of the message .
Projected visuals – these includes color slides, lantern slides,
filmstrips , overhead projectors and cinema films.
Tape recorders – store sound on a tape for reuse .
Music, Plays and Puppets. – Folk songs , dance and drama have
a great fascination for people like a lecture, movie , discussion,
socio-drama is a tool that may be used either in the classroom,
meeting or out in the open in the barangay. Role play teaches
the very important skills in pitting yourself in the other fellow’s
shoes in order to understand how will he react in particular
situation and enables one to see and appreciate his point of view.
Puppet are dolls which can be made to move about and appear
to speak.
Multimedia-media/inter-active
Characteristics of the internet (online media) :
internet has more advantages than any media, even the
television. The internet has more than aural, visual and
motion. Internet users can get access to print , radio and tv
programs anytime they want it .They can see what is
happening in other places on “real-time video” and can
chat with friends and net pals wherever they are in the
world because of the internet’s worldwide reach. The
internet has storability of information, can be reviewed
anytime and highly interactive. The disadvantage ,
though, are languages are not localized, needs audience
literacy not only in reading but in computer use, and it is
very expensive because one needs a computer sets, fax
modem, a telephone system and server in the area.