Titanium-dioxide_ExecSummary
Titanium-dioxide_ExecSummary
nanoparticles
in cosmetics:
a safety review
TiO2 particles can also vary in structure, and are found as both anatase and rutile crystal forms. Nano-TiO2 used in
sunscreens is mostly of the rutile crystal structure or a rutile/anatase combination; they are rarely made up of the anatase
structure alone.(2, 3)
Finally, nano-TiO2 is photoreactive with a resulting increase in reactive oxygen species (ROS) known to be implicated in
cellular damage. This issue has been solved by coating nanoparticles with alumina or silica, to reduce the production
of ROS. As coating improves the dispersion of TiO2 nanoparticles and their compatibility with other ingredients within
sunscreen formulations, nano-TiO2 is always used in its coated form in cosmetics.(4)
Nano-TiO2 has been accused of penetrating dermal, respiratory or gastrointestinal barriers, and disseminating in the body,
and therefore presenting a potential risk for the consumer.(6)
It is worth noting that many toxicological studies of nano-TiO2 use AEROXIDE P25 (Evonik, Germany), consisting mostly of
nano-TiO2 less than 25 nm in size under their anatase form.(7) However, P25 is not used in cosmetics and P25 nano-TiO2 is
not coated to reduce photoactivity.
This safety review concerning the use of nano-TiO2 in cosmetic products to provide UV protection is based on data
published by the Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS) and the French Agency for Food, Environmental
and Occupational Health and Safety (ANSES) and data available in the scientific literature since those opinions were
published.(3, 6, 8)
Available: www.skin-alliance.com
Titanium dioxide nanoparticles in cosmetics: a safety review
This executive summary is a short version of the complete article available in the JEADV supplement :
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/toc/14683083/2019/33/S7
References
1. 1223/2009 EN. Commission Regulation (EU) on cosmetic products No 1223/2009. Official Journal of the European Union.
(30 November 2009).
2. Warheit DB, Brown SC. What is the impact of surface modifications and particle size on commercial titanium dioxide particle
samples? - A review of in vivo pulmonary and oral toxicity studies - Revised 11-6-2018. Toxicol Lett. 2019;302:42-59.
3. SCCS. Opinion on titanium dioxide (nano form), 22 July 2013, revision of 22 April 2014. 2014.
4. Rowenczyk L, Duclairoir-Poc C, Barreau M, Picard C, Hucher N, Orange N, et al. Impact of coated TiO2-nanoparticles used
in sunscreens on two representative strains of the human microbiota: Effect of the particle surface nature and aging.
Colloids Surf B Biointerfaces. 2017;158:339-48.
5. Burnett ME, Wang SQ. Current sunscreen controversies: a critical review. Photodermatol Photoimmunol Photomed. 2011;27(2):
58-67.
6. SCCS. Guidance on safety assessment of nanomaterials in cosmetics. 2012.
7. Jacobs JF, van de Poel I, Osseweijer P. Sunscreens with Titanium Dioxide (TiO(2)) Nano-Particles: A Societal Experiment.
Nanoethics. 2010; 4(2)103-13.
8. ANSES. Le dioxyde de titane sous forme nanoparticulaire. Valeurs toxicologiques de référence. Avis de l’Anses. 2019.
9. Adachi K, Yamada N, Yoshida Y, Yamamoto O. Subchronic exposure of titanium dioxide nanoparticles to hairless rat skin. Exp
Dermatol. 2013;22(4):278-83.
10. Osmond-McLeod MJ, Oytam Y, Rowe A, Sobhanmanesh F, Greenoak G, Kirby J, et al. Long-term exposure to commercially
available sunscreens containing nanoparticles of TiO2 and ZnO revealed no biological impact in a hairless mouse model.
Part Fibre Toxicol. 2016;13(1):44.
11. Auttachoat W, McLoughlin CE, White KL, Jr., Smith MJ. Route-dependent systemic and local immune effects following exposure
to solutions prepared from titanium dioxide nanoparticles. J Immunotoxicol. 2014;11(3):273-82.
12. Smulders S, Golanski L, Smolders E, Vanoirbeek J, Hoet PH. Nano-TiO2 modulates the dermal sensitization potency of
dinitrochlorobenzene after topical exposure. Br J Dermatol. 2015;172(2):392-9.
13. TGA. (Therapeutic Goods Administration), Department of Health. Literature Review on the safety of titanium dioxide and zinc
oxide nanoparticles in sunscreens. Scientific review report Version 11, August 2016 Australian Government. 2016.
14. Yin JJ, Liu J, Ehrenshaft M, Roberts JE, Fu PP, Mason RP, et al. Phototoxicity of nano titanium dioxides in HaCaT keratinocytes--
generation of reactive oxygen species and cell damage. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol. 2012;263(1):81-8.
15. Rancan F, Nazemi B, Rautenberg S, Ryll M, Hadam S, Gao Q, et al. Ultraviolet radiation and nanoparticle induced intracellular
free radicals generation measured in human keratinocytes by electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy. Skin Res
Technol. 2014;20(2):182-93.
16. Wright C, Iyer AK, Wang L, Wu N, Yakisich JS, Rojanasakul Y, et al. Effects of titanium dioxide nanoparticles on human
keratinocytes. Drug Chem Toxicol. 2017;40(1):90-100.
17. ECHA. CfRAR. Opinion proposing harmonised classification and labelling at EU level of Titanium dioxide. EC Number: 236-675-5
CAS Number: 13463-67-7 CLH-O-0000001412-86-163/F. 2017.
18. Konstantinova V, Ibrahim M, Lie S. Nano-TiO2 penetration of oral mucosa: in vitro analysis using 3D organotypic human buccal
mucosa models. J Oral Pathol Med. 2017;46:214-22.
19. Jones K, Morton J, Smith I, Jurkschat K, Harding AH, Evans G. Human in vivo and in vitro studies on gastrointestinal absorption of
titanium dioxide nanoparticles. Toxicol Lett. 2015;233(2):95-101.
20. Teubl BJ, Leitinger G, Schneider M, Lehr CM, Frohlich E, Zimmer A, et al. The buccal mucosa as a route for TiO2 nanoparticle
uptake. Nanotoxicology. 2015;9(2):253-61.
21. Cho WS, Kang BC, Lee JK, Jeong J, Che JH, Seok SH. Comparative absorption, distribution, and excretion of titanium dioxide
and zinc oxide nanoparticles after repeated oral administration. Part Fibre Toxicol. 2013;10:9.
22. Kreyling WG, Holzwarth U, Schleh C, Kozempel J, Wenk A, Haberl N, et al. Quantitative biokinetics of titanium dioxide
nanoparticles after oral application in rats: Part 2. Nanotoxicology. 2017;11(4):443-53.
23. INERIS. Proposition d’un repère toxicologique pour l’oxyde de titane nanométrique pour des expositions environnementales
par voie respiratoire ou orale (DRC-16-157027-10246A). 2016.
24. Wang J, Zhou G, Chen C, Yu H, Wang T, Ma Y, et al. Acute toxicity and biodistribution of different sized titanium dioxide particles
in mice after oral administration. Toxicol Lett. 2007;168(2):176-85.
25. Shi H, Magaye R, Castranova V, Zhao J. Titanium dioxide nanoparticles: a review of current toxicological data. Part Fibre Toxicol.
2013;10:15.
26. Bettini S, Boutet-Robinet E, Cartier C, Comera C, Gaultier E, Dupuy J, et al. Food-grade TiO2 impairs intestinal and systemic
immune homeostasis, initiates preneoplastic lesions and promotes aberrant crypt development in the rat colon. Sci Rep.
2017;7:40373.
27. Hu R, Gong X, Duan Y, Li N, Che Y, Cui Y, et al. Neurotoxicological effects and the impairment of spatial recognition memory in
mice caused by exposure to TiO2 nanoparticles. Biomaterials. 2010;31(31):8043-50.
28. Ze Y, Sheng L, Zhao X, Ze X, Wang X, Zhou Q, et al. Neurotoxic characteristics of spatial recognition damage of the hippocampus
in mice following subchronic peroral exposure to TiO2 nanoparticles. J Hazard Mater. 2014;264:219-29.
29. Gui S, Zhang Z, Zheng L, Cui Y, Liu X, Li N, et al. Molecular mechanism of kidney injury of mice caused by exposure to titanium
dioxide nanoparticles. J Hazard Mater. 2011;195:365-70.
30. Duan Y, Liu J, Ma L, Li N, Liu H, Wang J, et al. Toxicological characteristics of nanoparticulate anatase titanium dioxide in mice.
Biomaterials. 2010;31(5):894-9.
References
31. Sang X, Li B, Ze Y, Hong J, Ze X, Gui S, et al. Toxicological mechanisms of nanosized titanium dioxide-induced spleen injury in mice
after repeated peroral application. J Agric Food Chem. 2013;61(23):5590-9.
32. Gao G, Ze Y, Zhao X, Sang X, Zheng L, Ze X, et al. Titanium dioxide nanoparticle-induced testicular damage, spermatogenesis
suppression, and gene expression alterations in male mice. J Hazard Mater. 2013;258-259:133-43.
33. Elbastawisy YM, Almasry SM. Histomorphological evaluation of maternal and neonatal distal airspaces after maternal intake of
nanoparticulate titanium dioxide: an experimental study in Wistar rats. J Mol Histol. 2014;45(1):91-102.
34. Mohammadipour A, Fazel A, Haghir H, Motejaded F, Rafatpanah H, Zabihi H, et al. Maternal exposure to titanium dioxide
nanoparticles during pregnancy; impaired memory and decreased hippocampal cell proliferation in rat offspring.
Environ Toxicol Pharmacol. 2014;37(2):617-25.
35. SCCS. Opinion for clarification of the meaning of the term “sprayable applications/products” for the nano forms of Carbon
Black CI 77266, Titanium Oxide and Zinc Oxide, 23 September 2014, SCCS/1539/14, revision of 16 December 2014 and of
25 June 2015. 2015.
36. Kreyling W, Scheuch G. Clearance of particles deposited in the lungs. In: Heyder J, Gehr P, eds. Particle Lung Interactions. Marcel
Dekker, New York, 2000: 323–376.
37. Eydner M, Schaudien D, Creutzenberg O, Ernst H, Hansen T, Baumgartner W, et al. Impacts after inhalation of nano- and
fine-sized titanium dioxide particles: morphological changes, translocation within the rat lung, and evaluation of particle
deposition using the relative deposition index. Inhal Toxicol. 2012;24(9):557-69.
38. Pujalte I, Dieme D, Haddad S, Serventi AM, Bouchard M. Toxicokinetics of titanium dioxide (TiO2) nanoparticles after inhalation in
rats. Toxicol Lett. 2017;265:77-85.
39. Husain M, Wu D, Saber AT, Decan N, Jacobsen NR, Williams A, et al. Intratracheally instilled titanium dioxide nanoparticles
translocate to heart and liver and activate complement cascade in the heart of C57BL/6 mice. Nanotoxicology.
2015;9(8):1013-22.
40. Gate L, Disdier C, Cosnier F, Gagnaire F, Devoy J, Saba W, et al. Biopersistence and translocation to extrapulmonary organs
of titanium dioxide nanoparticles after subacute inhalation exposure to aerosol in adult and elderly rats. Toxicol Lett.
2017;265:61-9.
41. Zhang X, Li W, Yang Z. Toxicology of nanosized titanium dioxide: an update. Arch Toxicol. 2015;89(12):2207-17.
42. Heinrich U, Fuhst R, Rittinghausen S, Creutzenberg O, Bellmann B, Koch W, et al. Chronic Inhalation Exposure of Wistar Rats
and two Different Strains of Mice to Diesel Engine Exhaust, Carbon Black, and Titanium Dioxide. Inhalation Toxicology.
1995;7(4):533-56.
43. Chen JL, Fayerweather WE. Epidemiologic study of workers exposed to titanium dioxide. J Occup Med. 1988;30(12):937-42.
44. Fryzek JP, Chadda B, Marano D, White K, Schweitzer S, McLaughlin JK, et al. A cohort mortality study among titanium dioxide
manufacturing workers in the United States. J Occup Environ Med. 2003;45(4):400-9.
45. Boffetta P, Gaborieau V, Nadon L, Parent MF, Weiderpass E, Siemiatycki J. Exposure to titanium dioxide and risk of lung cancer in
a population-based study from Montreal. Scand J Work Environ Health. 2001;27(4):227-32.
46. Boffetta P, Soutar A, Cherrie JW, Granath F, Andersen A, Anttila A, et al. Mortality among workers employed in the titanium
dioxide production industry in Europe. Cancer Causes Control. 2004;15(7):697-706.
47. Ellis ED, Watkins J, Tankersley W, Phillips J, Girardi D. Mortality among titanium dioxide workers at three DuPont plants. J Occup
Environ Med. 2010;52(3):303-9.
48. Ellis ED, Watkins JP, Tankersley WG, Phillips JA, Girardi DJ. Occupational exposure and mortality among workers at three titanium
dioxide plants. Am J Ind Med. 2013;56(3):282-91.
49. Ramanakumar AV, Parent ME, Latreille B, Siemiatycki J. Risk of lung cancer following exposure to carbon black, titanium dioxide
and talc: results from two case-control studies in Montreal. Int J Cancer. 2008;122(1):183-9.
50. Hougaard KS, Jackson P, Jensen KA, Sloth JJ, Loschner K, Larsen EH, et al. Effects of prenatal exposure to surface-coated
nanosized titanium dioxide (UV-Titan). A study in mice. Part Fibre Toxicol. 2010;7:16.
51. Boisen AM, Shipley T, Jackson P, Hougaard KS, Wallin H, Yauk CL, et al. NanoTIO(2) (UV-Titan) does not induce ESTR mutations in the
germline of prenatally exposed female mice. Part Fibre Toxicol. 2012;9:19.
52. Kyjovska ZO, Boisen AM, Jackson P, Wallin H, Vogel U, Hougaard KS. Daily sperm production: application in studies of prenatal
exposure to nanoparticles in mice. Reprod Toxicol. 2013;36:88-97.
53. Jackson P, Halappanavar S, Hougaard KS, Williams A, Madsen AM, Lamson JS, et al. Maternal inhalation of surface-coated
nanosized titanium dioxide (UV-Titan) in C57BL/6 mice: effects in prenatally exposed offspring on hepatic DNA damage
and gene expression. Nanotoxicology. 2013;7(1):85-96.
54. Stapleton PA, Minarchick VC, Yi J, Engels K, McBride CR, Nurkiewicz TR. Maternal engineered nanomaterial exposure and fetal
microvascular function: does the Barker hypothesis apply? Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2013;209(3):227.e1-11.
55. Stapleton PA, Nichols CE, Yi J, McBride CR, Minarchick VC, Shepherd DL, et al. Microvascular and mitochondrial dysfunction in
the female F1 generation after gestational TiO2 nanoparticle exposure. Nanotoxicology. 2015;9(8):941-51.
56. Stapleton PA, Hathaway QA, Nichols CE, Abukabda AB, Pinti MV, Shepherd DL, et al. Maternal engineered nanomaterial
inhalation during gestation alters the fetal transcriptome. Part Fibre Toxicol. 2018;15(1):3.
57. Engler-Chiurazzi EB, Stapleton PA, Stalnaker JJ, Ren X, Hu H, Nurkiewicz TR, et al. Impacts of prenatal nanomaterial exposure on
male adult Sprague-Dawley rat behavior and cognition. J Toxicol Environ Health A. 2016;79(11):447-52.
58. Hathaway QA, Nichols CE, Shepherd DL, Stapleton PA, McLaughlin SL, Stricker JC, et al. Maternal-engineered nanomaterial
exposure disrupts progeny cardiac function and bioenergetics. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol. 2017;312(3):H446-H58.