2010-08-25 Guns, Germs, and Steel Outline
2010-08-25 Guns, Germs, and Steel Outline
2010-08-25 Guns, Germs, and Steel Outline
1. 2 centuries ago- New Guineans lived in Stone Age 2. whites arrived a. brought cargo i. steel axes, matches, meds, clothing, soft drinks, umbrellas b. despised New Guineans- primitive 3. Yali- local polition a. Question: Why is it that you white people developed so much cargo and brought it to New Guinea, but we black people had little cargo of our own? b. Why is it that people of Eurasian origin (especially those in Europe, eastern Asia, and transplanted to N America) dominate the modern world in wealth and power? i. Possible Explanations: 1. Genetics a. However not likely based on intelligence i. New Guineans might actually be more intelligent 1. Europeans- natural selection based on disease; New Guinean- natural section based on murder- required intelligence 2. Europeans had TV, radio, movies; New Guineans actively do activities. 2. The seasonably variable climates at high latitudes require people to be more technologically inventive to survive. 3. Importance of lowland river valleys in dry climates, where highly productive agriculture depended on largescale irrigation systems that in turn required civilized bureaucracies 4. Immediate factors that enabled Europeans to kill or conquer other peoples- especially guns, disease, and steal tools
5. During Great Leap Forward (50,000 years ago) a. extension of human geographic range since colonization into Australia and New Guinea (both joined as a single continent at that time) i. during Ice Ages, sea levels were much lower 1. nevertheless, reaching Australia/New Guinea still required a crossing of 8 channels 2. earliest evidence of watercraft ii. the human settlers caused the 1st mass extinction of large animal species by humans- that is why no animals in Australia are larger than kangaroos- it remains unknown how this was done. b. Human range expanded into the coldest parts of Eurasia i. May have been responsible for extinction of Eurasias woolly mammoth and woolly rhino 6. 14,000 and 35,000 years ago- Americas were first colonized with Clovis (1st unquestioned remains found around 12,000 B.C.) a. Americas filled up with humans so quickly that people were motivated to keep spreading south toward Patagonia b. 17,000-12,000 years ago extinctions similar to those in Australia occurred in the Americas i. discovery of mammoth skeletons with Clovis spear-points between their ribs suggests that they were exterminated by hunters- however it is also believed that they became extinct due to the Ice Age c. however possible, evidence of pre-Clovis people cannot yet be proved 7. at this point it cannot be predicted which continent would develop most quickly
Collision at Cajamarca
1. November 16, 1532- 1st encounter between the Inca emperor Atahullpa and the Spanish conquistador Francisco Pizarro at the Peruvian highland town of Cajamarca a. Pizarro led a rag-tag army of 168 soldiers while Atahullpa was in the middle of his empire with an army of 80,000 soldiers b. However, Pizarro captured Atahullpa i. Set high ransom but when it was delivered, Pizarro executed Atahullpa anyway 2. Why did Pizarro capture Atahullpa? a. Pizarros steal weapons armor b. Horses and cavalry c. Early guns, however they played only a minor role d. Small pox spread by Spanish caused the death of the Inca emperor and left the Incas divided and weak (Atahullpa had won decisive battles in the war) e. European maritime technology f. Spains writing (communication) g. Spains literacy i. Gave the Spaniards access to a huge body of knowledge about human behavior and history h.
Farmer Power
1. last 11,000 years- people turned to food production a. domesticating wild animals and plants b. eating the resulting livestock and crops 2. food production was a prerequisite for the development of guns, germs, and steel a. availability of more consumable calories = more people = stronger military b. hunter gathers cannot carry more than one infant with them, creating lower birth rates than the farmers c. settlement allows for storage of food surpluses d. settlement allows for the development of government which also allows organized conquest e. government that collects taxes can feed professional soldiers f. domestication of Eurasian horses helped military conquest g. germs developed in societies from domestic animals
y 5. There were several differences in food production systems around the world. a. Old World- broadcast seeding, monoculture fields, and eventually plowing
b. New World- fields were hand tilled and seeds were individually, mixed gardens, no plows 6. By Roman times, almost all of todays leading crops were being cultivated somewhere in the world
Apples or Indians
1. Fertile Crescent- site of origin of several of the worlds major crops 2. New Guinea and E. U.S. did domesticate crops, but these crops were very few in variety and only one of them gained worldwide importance 3. Did the flora and enviorment of the Fertile Crescent have clear advantages over those of New Guinea and the eastern US a. Fertile Crescent has Mediterranean climate (long, dry season) i. Selects of annuals (plants that die in dry season) 1. Annuals do not have inedible wood or fibrous material but must make big seeds (to survive the dry season), which are often edible by humans ii. Fertile Crescent crops were already abundant and highly productive in the wild 1. Some hunting-gathering peoples had settled before they began to cultivate the plants and few additional changes were needed to cultivate the plants 2. Fertile Crescent had high % of hermaphroditic selfers (usually pollinate themselves) a. Favorable traits would automatically be passed on to offspring iii. 5 Advantages of Fertile Crescent over other Med. Zones 1. Largest (more diversity) 2. Great climate variation (favored evolution) 3. Range of altitudes (more diversity and staggered) 4. Rich in harvest seasons 5. Large domesticated mammal species b. Difference was not due to the people in the areas- all knowledgeable about their enviroment
b. Development of world trade routes 6. Most microbes responsible for our own unique diseases have come from our domesticated animals 7. Microbes in history a. More Native Americans died from germs than in battle (kill many and lower morale of survivors) i. Cortes + Spaniards defeat Aztecs ii. Pizarro defeated Incas (Ch 3)
8/25/2010 5:15:00 PM
1. Writing System Strategies a. Alphabet- provide a unique sign for each basic sound b. Logograms- 1 written sign stands for a whole word c. Syllabaries- a sign for each syllable 2. 2 indisputably independent inventions of writing a. Sumerians of Mesopotamia- 3,000 BC b. Mexican Indians- 600 BC c. (Egyptian writing of 3,000 BC and Chinese writing of 1,300 BC may also have arisen independently) 3. Sumerian cuneiform a. Thousands of years before cuneiform people of some farming villages used clay tokens for accounting b. 1st writing signs- recognizable pictures of the object i. gradually became more abstract and signs were combined to create new meanings
Necessitys Mother
1. 1700 BC- Phaistos disk a. oldest printed document b. ahead of its time (lacked receptive circumstances and supporting technology) and did not lead to proliferation of printing c. although necessity is sometimes the mother to invention, invention often precedes the creation of necessity i. examples: airplane and lightbulb 1. have arisen cumulatively from creative geniuses building by trial and error on the discoveries of the capable predecessors 2. Early inventions often perform poorly and appear to be unconvincing, for an invention to spread, it must be accepted within a society a. Requirements for acceptence: i. Economic advantage ii. Social value + prestige iii. Compatibility w/vested interests iv. Easy to observe advantages 3. Most new developmements arrive by diffusion, which for places w/geographic or ecologic barriers is limited 4. food production + large population = more rapid technological development 5. some inventions can allow a culture to overrun another a. examples of rejection of important inventions i. Japan- samurai restricted the adoption of guns until 1853 ii. Tansmanians- rejected fishing iii. China- rejected ocean going ships iv. Polynesians- some rejected pottery b. Technology is autocatalytic- with technology, the rate of development can increase dramatically 6. Reasons for difference in technological development between the Europeans and Native Americans a. Level of food production b. Barriers to diffusion c. Differences in human population
i. may justify kleptocracy 1. kleptocrats-maintain power by disarming the populace and arming the elite, making the masses happy by redistributing the tribute, keeping order and preventing violence l. especially good at developing weapons of war 5. States arise in response to needs for irrigation and regional population size, which requires intensive food production.
Yalis People
1. Australian climate and terrain a. Mostly inhospitable/supports small population of primitive peoples b. 10,000 years ago was once united with New Guinea c. New Guinea: Wetter than Australia but grows very little protein 2. European Penetration of New Guinea was slow a. Due to disease such as Malaria and thriving of their cattle and crops b. Australia was easier to settle 1. Allowed the decimation of aborigines by Europeans who imported their technologies
Speedboat to Polynesia
8/25/2010 5:15:00 PM
1. 40,000 B.C.-Austronesian migrations a. Islands of the Pacific were colonized by waves of colonists from Asia (became the New Guinea Highlanders) b. Began from Chinese mainland 1. Reached Taiwan 3500 B.C. 2. Reached Philippines 3000 B.C. 3. Reached Sumatra and Java 2000 B.C. 4. Reached N. New Guinea by 1600 B.C. 5. Reached Samoa by 1200 B.C. 6. Reached Hawaii, Easter Island, and Madagascar by 500 A.D. c. These migrants became the Polynesians 1. Displaced less capable peoples but not the central or southern New Guineans- had no competitive advantage 2. Had trouble establishing themselves in west and north Australia
Hemispheres Colliding
1. Factors leading to the European conquest of the Americas a. Better food production b. Better domesticated plants and animals c. Better metallurgy d. Better weapons and cavalry e. Better transport and communication via wriing f. Better political organization 2. Development in the New World was more primitive due to: a. Later arrival of humans there b. Later domestication c. Geographic and ecological barriers d. Migration through Siberian Arctic which had stripped away technologies for warmer climates e. The wheel had not been invented except as a toy in the New World f. writing was limited to a few locations 3. New World shows much less major language diffusion 4. 1st European visitors to the New World a. the Norse i. 1000 A.D. ii. from Greenland and Iceland iii. could not sustain their colony on Newfoundland and it died out (15th century)