DISTRICT COOLING Design and Water Managementcode 2016
DISTRICT COOLING Design and Water Managementcode 2016
DISTRICT COOLING Design and Water Managementcode 2016
PREFACE:
Part 1
Part 2
Page 03 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
CONTENT
2.2.3 DC Plant 19
2.2.4 Water Management 22
2.2.5 Distribution Pipelines 26
2.2.6 Building Connection 27
2.2.7 Commissioning 30
List of Tables
Table 1: Quarterly Water Quality Reports 25
Table 2: Metering Equipment Accuracy Requirements 30
Page 04 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
Page 05 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
1.1 Definitions
Term Definition
Building Side The Building System side at the Point of Delivery. Also
sometimes referred to as Secondary Side.
Page 06 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
Chilled Water Return Chilled Water which has a flow direction toward a DC
Plant (in a DC Network) or toward ETS Equipment (in a
Building System).
Chilled Water Supply Chilled Water which has a flow direction toward a
Building (in a DC Network) or toward Air Conditioning
units (in a Building System).
Coincident Peak Load The sum of Cooling Loads for all Customers at the time
of the DC System Peak Cooling Load.
Cooling Load Diversity Factor The sum of Cooling Loads for all Customers at the time
of the DC System Peak Cooling Load (Coincident Peak
Load) divided by the sum of all individual Customer
Peak Cooling Loads regardless of when those individual
Peak Cooling Loads occurred (Non-coincident Peak
Page 07 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
DC Provider Facilities Any and all facilities including the DC Plant, DC Network
and Bulk-Service ETS Equipment, and any other type of
equipment installed, designed, constructed, operated
and maintained by the DC Provider for the purpose
of providing Cooling Services to DC Retailers or to
Customers up to the applicable Points of Delivery and
Points of Return.
Page 08 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
Drift Loss Loss of water from a Cooling Tower into the atmosphere
resulting from water droplets that are carried out of the
Cooling Tower with the exhaust air.
Evaporation Loss The loss of water from a Cooling Tower resulting from
evaporation into the atmosphere.
Foul Water Network Piping network for collection of sewage and other
wastewater for conveyance to a sewage treatment
plant.
Page 09 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
Ground and Surface Water Water recovered from groundwater dewatering pumping
or surface runoff collection. Ground and Surface Water
that has been treated by Ashghal and made available for
beneficial use is included in the broader term Recycled
Water.
Chilled Water.
Page 10 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
Life-Cycle Cost Analysis A process of evaluating the total capital and operating
costs of design alternatives, in which all costs over the
life of the DC System are calculated on a Net Present
Value basis by discounting future costs at a discount
rate equal to the Weighted Average Cost of Capital.
Makeup Water CHW Makeup: Water source to be used for filling the
DC Network with Chilled Water, or replacing water lost
from the DC Network.
Page 11 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
a.
Page 12 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
Page 13 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
Total Dissolved Solids The combined content of all inorganic and organic
substances dissolved in a given volume of water and
expressed in units of mg per unit volume of water (mg/L),
also referred to as parts per million (ppm). Generally the
operational definition is that the solids must be small
enough to survive filtration through a filter with two-
micrometer (nominal size) or smaller, pores.
TSE/RW Quality Expectations A set of criteria for minimum quality of TSE or other
RW, which shall established through joint action of the
Regulator and Ashghal.
Variable Frequency Drive Motor drive systems to control AC motor speed and
torque by varying motor input frequency and voltage.
Also sometime referred to as Variable Speed Drive.
Weighted Average Cost of Capital The rate that a company or other legal entity is
expected to pay on average to all its security holders to
finance its assets, in which each category of capital is
proportionately weighted.
Page 14 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
1.2 Abbreviations
Abbreviation for
C Celsius
DC District Cooling
F Fahrenheit
RO Reverse Osmosis
RW Recycled Water
Page 15 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
T Temperature
2.1.1 Purpose
This document deals with the mandatory, minimum requirements for the design and operation of
Water Cooled Central Air conditioning Systems for comfort cooling or process cooling applications.
For the ease of reference, hereafter in this document, Water cooled central air conditioning plants
DC DESIGN & WATER MANAGEMENT CODE
are named as District Cooling (DC) systems. This standard is applicable to all existing and new
DC plants.This document is not intended to comprehensively address all aspects of DC System
design and operation. Rather, it is intended to set key minimum requirements deemed critical for
achievement of the Key Performance Indicators (KPIs).
2.1.2 Exemptions
Mandatory requirements are not intended to prevent or hinder innovative design approaches. DC
Providers shall at all times seek to design DC Systems in the most effective and efficient way and
shall have the right to apply for an Exemption from any specific requirement in these Standards.
Evidence and related technical studies/justifications shall be submitted to the Kahramaa District
Cooling Service department for review and approval or rejection of any proposed Exemption.
The design, installation and operation of a DC System shall be in accordance with the Up to Date
jurisdictional authorities, laws and regulations of the State of Qatar. Government agencies having
jurisdiction governing DC System include, but are not limited to:
b. Ashghal (Public Works Authority), which owns and operates systems for Ground and Surface
Water (GSW) drainage, Foul Water (FW) Network, Sewage Treatment Plants, and supply of
Treated Sewage Effluent (TSE).
Page 16 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
c. Ministry of Municipality and Enviroment (MME), which regulates impacts on the natural
environment including dischanges to Ground and Surface drainage and to the sea.
d. Ministry of Interior, of which the Qatar Civil Defence (QCD) is responsible for building codes,
regulations and inspections.
Laws and regulations governing DC Systems include, but are not limited to:
a. Law No (30) of 2002 promulgating environmental protection, including associated bylaws and
standards, including:
b. Directive by the Permanent Water Resource Committee (PWRC) of the Secretariat General
Counsel of Ministers on Prohibition of Potable Water use for Cooling Purpose.
c. Low Voltage Electricity & Water Installations regulations latest edition, Qatar General Electricity
& Water Corporation (Kahramaa) Customer Services Department, State of Qatar, latest Edition:
d. Regulations of Internal Water Installations and Connection Works, Qatar General Electricity &
Water Corporation (Kahramaa) Customer Services Department, State of Qatar, Latest Edition.
The design, fabrication, installation and operation of a DC System shall be fit for purpose operating
in the State of Qatar. The DC Provider is accountable to ensure the DC System, once operational,
is capable of:
Page 17 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
If the design of DC System is found to not meet any of these Standards then the DC Provider shall
be required to carry out retrospective work at its own expense to ensure the DC System is compliant.
DC Providers shall operate the DC System based on the following four fundamental principles:
a. All Customers Cooling Load requirements can be fully met (up to maximum contracted) at all
times. (This does not preclude appropriate use of the Cooling Load Diversity Factor in the DC
System design.)
b. Interruption of Services shall be minimized and in all events DC System reliability shall be
compliant with KPI 1.
c. Energy and water consumption shall be optimized and in all events shall be compliant with
KPIs 2, 3, 4, 5 and 7.
d. Environmental, health and safety impact shall be minimized and in all events shall be compliant
with relevant laws, regulations and with KPIs 6 and 8.
a. DC Provider shall obtain approval from MME prior to the construction and operation of the DC
System pursuant to the MME requirements.
b. Any discharges from the DC System shall comply with applicable limits or standards for air,
noise, land and water.
c. DC Provider shall be compliant with all other laws, regulations and codes promulgated in the
State of Qatar relating to health, safety and environmental protection.
DC Provider shall permit any person authorized by MME or other jurisdictional agency access
to any facilities comprising the DC System to inspect at any time for the purpose of verifying
compliance with health, safety and environmental regulations.
For DC Plants where Potable Water is used as a Makeup Water backup in conjunction with use of
TSE, GSW, Grey Water, or other type of Recycled Water the Cooling Tower Makeup Water system
design shall include cross connection control and backflow prevention in accordance with the
following:
a. The backflow prevention device used shall be either an air gap or a reduced pressure principle
backflow assembly suitable for high hazard and potential backpressure applications;
c. All non-Potable Water system shall be prominently labelled as such in both Arabic and English.
Page 18 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
a. Water Quality
Blowdown Water
Polishing Plant reject water
Odor
Noise and vibration
Cooling Tower Drift
Refrigerant leak
Hazardous wastes
d. Dangerous goods
2.2.3 DC Plant
Unless otherwise specified, the following minimum requirements apply to all New Plants, excluding
Temporary Plants.
2.2.3.1 Redundancy
Redundancy is a key element that shall be considered in the design to minimize Interruption of
Services and maintain compliance with system reliability KPI requirements.
a. DC Plant shall be designed with redundancy (n+1) for electrical equipment and for all life
safety equipment.
b. DC Plant shall be served with redundant (n+1) power feeders, such that total DC Plant power
demand can be met with one feeder out of service.
c. DC Plant shall be designed with firestops and fire protection systems in accordance with Qatar
Civil Defence requirements and NFPA Standards.
Secondary distribution CHW pumps (for primary-secondary pumping schemes) or primary CHW
Page 19 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
pumps (for variable primary pumping schemes) shall incorporate variable flow pumping, and shall
be controlled to maintain the minimum required differential pressure at the most hydraulically
remote Customer in the DC Network.
DC Plant internal pipe sizing shall be performed in accordance with Up to Date ASHRAE Handbook,
Fundamentals, to minimize noise, erosion levels and pumping costs.
a. Refrigerant systems, including but not limited to refrigerant piping, refrigerant storage, safety
relief valves, alarm systems, emergency ventilation and refrigerant leak detection, shall be
designed and sized in accordance with Up to Date ASHRAE Standard 15, Safety Standard for
Refrigeration Systems.
b. Refrigerant type used in chillers shall comply with all relevant decisions, rules or procedures
mandated by local regulations and international protocols.
a. Cooling Towers shall be installed with VFD drives to reduce fan speed at part load
conditions to minimize annual energy consumption.
b. Cooling Towers shall be sized and field tested in accordance with codes published
by CTI or ASME. If the DC Provider wishes to use modifications to these codes or
specify another procedure, the DC Provider may apply for an Exemption, subject to the
Regulators approval.
c. Cooling Towers using unpolished TSE or seawater shall be equipped with cellular type
drift eliminators.
a. All New Plants with capacity equal to or greater than 10,000 TR shall include a TES system.
If the DC Plant is primarily serving cooling loads with a flat daily load profile, such as process
loads, the DC Provider may apply for an Exemption from the requirement to include a TES
system, subject to the Regulators approval.
b. For all New Plants with TES, the TES type shall be stratified CHW TES, except in cases where
space limitations or aesthetics do not allow for CHW TES; in these cases the DC Provider may
apply for an Exemption to use Ice TES or other TES technology. DC Providers must provide
justification for their choice of TES type in their application for Exemption to the Regulator.
c. TES tank(s) shall be sized, at a minimum, for complete load levelling (peak shaving) of the
projected peak day load profile for the DC Plant.
d. TES tank walls shall be provided with insulation on all sides, ends, bottom and top of tank.
Insulation shall be of adequate thickness to prevent condensation on tank walls and limit heat
gain to less than 1% of tank capacity across a twenty-four (24) hour period at 46C ambient
temperature. Tank exterior shall include a complete vapour barrier and protection of the insulation.
e. For CHW TES tanks, the diffuser shall be designed to resist damage from unanticipated water
hammer events that could be initiated elsewhere in the hydraulic system apart from the TES
tank.
Page 20 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
a. DC Plant monitoring and control system shall be an industrial grade SCADA system with
PLC controllers. The SCADA system shall provide complete process monitoring, control, and
troubleshooting capabilities.
b. DC Plant monitoring and control system shall be capable of monitoring and controlling all
process equipment (mechanical and electrical), including water treatment systems.
c. Electric meters shall be installed which shall be capable of measuring, displaying and storing
data on:
d. Thermal energy meters shall be installed which shall be capable of measuring, displaying and
storing data on:
f. The SCADA system shall be capable of measuring, displaying and storing hourly data on
Cooling Energy consumption by each individual DC Retailer and Customer served by the DC
System.
g. DC Plant monitoring and control system shall generate automated daily, monthly and yearly
reporting for all DC Plant major process variables and equipment operation.
h. DC Provider shall maintain computer logs of hourly data for key process variables, alarm
status, and power and water consumption for a rolling three (3) Year period, at minimum, and
shall make logs available to the Regulator upon request.
Page 21 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
a. DC Providers may implement, consistent with applicable laws and regulations, a range of
potential condenser cooling alternatives, including:
b. DC Providers shall undertake and submit to the Regulator a Condenser Cooling Plan which shall
DC DESIGN & WATER MANAGEMENT CODE
include Life-Cycle Cost Analysis of condenser cooling alternatives at the site or sites for the DC
Plant(s). The Condenser Cooling Plan shall consider, among other things, the following:
When TSE or other RW will be available at the DC Plant site(s) in sufficient quantities to
provide for condenser cooling for the DC Plant(s);
Expected quality of TSE or other RW according to Ashghal;
Capital and operating costs of using TSE or other RW either directly or with a Polishing
Plant;
Capital and operating costs of using seawater for condenser cooling, either in seawater
Cooling Towers or with direct cooling of condensers;
Assessment of the environmental and regulatory requirements for using seawater, and the
associated timelines for meeting regulatory requirements;
Regulatory requirements and associated costs for disposal of wastewater for each
condenser cooling alternative;
Comparison of Life-Cycle Costs of all condenser cooling alternatives, with comparison to
condensing cooling using Potable Water as a base case; and
Proposed plan for condenser cooling, including phasing as appropriate.
c. The Regulator will review and comment on the Condenser Cooling Plan, and either: approve
the Condenser Cooling Plan; or provide direction to the DC Provider regarding additional
information or analysis required for an approvable Condenser Cooling Plan.
d. DC Providers must receive approval from the Regulator of the Condenser Cooling Plan for a
DC System.
a. For New Plants, where TSE or other RW is available in sufficient quantities for the operation
of the DC Plant, and the TSE or other RW meets TSE/RW Quality Expectations, TSE or other
RW must be used for condenser cooling unless another non-Potable water condenser cooling
alternative is more cost effective.
Page 22 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
b. Where TSE or other RW is not available at the time when design of a New Plant is initiated, but
is expected to become available within ten (10) years in sufficient quantities for the operation
of the DC Plant, and of sufficient quality to meet TSE/RW Quality Expectations:
The DC Plant shall be designed with sufficient space and mechanical/electrical capacity to
incorporate a TSE polishing plant; and
Potable Water may be used for Cooling Tower Makeup until such time that TSE or other
RW becomes available.
c. In DC Plants using TSE or other RW as the normal source for condenser cooling, Potable
Water may be used for Cooling Tower Makeup as an Emergency source of water in the event
that TSE or other RW is not available in sufficient quantities or at acceptable quality for more
than forty-eight (48) hours.
d. For all DC Plants, Potable Water may be used for closed loop Chilled Water Makeup.
e. Existing DC Plants shall be converted to use TSE or other RW as soon as practicable under
the direction of the Regulator.
b. For all applications using seawater, the intake and discharge piping shall be capable of
withstanding the aggressive characteristics of seawater and, therefore, non-ferrous materials
such as glass-reinforced plastic (GRP) and/or high-density polyethylene (HDPE) are required.
c. For all applications using seawater, chiller condenser materials and seawater Cooling Tower
materials shall be capable of withstanding corrosion by seawater, and shall meet the following
requirements:
d. All water treatment control, monitoring and alarm functions shall be through the DC Plant
monitoring and control system.
DC Providers shall create and file with the Regulator a plan to maintain Cooling Tower
systems and equipment to comply with Section 7.2 of ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 188-2015,
Legionellosis: Risk Management for Building Water Systems.
Page 23 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
a. The CHW treatment program shall utilize environmentally-friendly approaches and treatment
chemicals to the greatest possible extent.
b. The CHW circuit is a low temperature, closed system and therefore protection against
corrosion shall be given primary consideration. Secondary consideration shall be given to
deposit control and microbiological activity.
c. An automatic dosing system shall be used for the dosing of corrosion inhibitor. The automatic
system shall consist of a water meter fitted in the CHW Makeup Water line, chemical dosing
pump and storage tank with low-level switch. DC Plant control system shall monitor the
quantity of CHW Makeup Water and control the corrosion inhibitor dosing pump based on the
Makeup Water rate.
d. The CHW circuit water treatment program shall be designed to control corrosion to less than
1 mpy maximum.
b. The condenser circuit water treatment program, and/or equipment material selection, shall be
designed to control or limit corrosion to less than 3 mpy maximum.
c. Dosing pumps and tanks for required chemicals shall be provided with low level alarm.
d. If the condenser cooling approach is use of unpolished TSE in Cooling Towers, then the water
treatment system shall be a fully automated system with active monitoring and capable of
adjusting water treatment in real time in response to changes in TSE Makeup Water quality.
a. The DC Provider shall engage an independent party for inspection and verification of proper
execution of the DC Providers water treatment equipment and program on a minimum
quarterly basis.
b. Quarterly water quality reports shall be prepared and conveyed to the Regulator and other
responsible authorities to ensure compliance with environmental and health requirements.
Minimum water parameters to be recorded, in addition to other parameters required by
jurisdictional authorities, are indicated in Table 1.
Page 24 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
Table 1
Cooling Circulating
Chilled Wastewater
Unit Tower Condenser
Water Discharge
Make-up Water
pH pH
Conductivity S/cm
Chloride mg/l
Iron mg/l
Colony
Heterotrophic Aerobic
Forming
Bacteria
Units (CFU)
Temperature degrees C
Legionella CFU/ml
Other as required by
discharge permitting
authority
Wastewater discharge quantities and water quality must meet all applicable laws, regulations and
permit conditions.
Page 25 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
The minimum requirements in this section apply to all New Distribution Pipelines and extensions
of Existing Distribution Pipelines, and apply to both DC Provider Facilities (DC Networks) and
Distribution Pipelines comprising part of DC Retailer Facilities.
b. Automatic control or isolation valves shall not be fast-closing valves, or fail closed, unless
specific provisions are put in place to mitigate water hammer under these conditions.
c. Distribution Pipeline designs shall incorporate, at strategic locations, sectioning valves (isolation
valves) to facilitate repair of Distribution Pipelines while minimizing Interruption of Services.
d. Stress analysis calculations shall be performed to confirm that thermal stresses produced in
the DC Network as a result of temperature difference from start-up to operation, pipe pressure,
and dead weight, comply with ANSI/ASME B31.1 Power Piping code.
DC DESIGN & WATER MANAGEMENT CODE
f. All underground Distribution Pipelines shall be thoroughly cleaned via flushing or mechanical
cleaning before they are put into service.
a. DC Network shall be designed with an annual heat gain less than 4% of annual Cooling Energy
for the DC System, at full projected build-out of system.
a. Minimum depth of burial for underground Distribution Pipelines shall be in accordance with
local regulations and in accordance with pipe manufacturers recommendations to maintain
pipeline integrity under required traffic load conditions.
b. In order to ensure DC System reliability and allow for potential repairs, no other utilities shall
be placed above or below Distribution Pipelines in the same Trench.
Hydraulic analysis shall be performed to ensure that required minimum differential pressure is
available under all operational conditions for connections to DC-Ready Buildings.
Page 26 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
This section describes the minimum Building connection design particulars for an efficient and
reliable DC System. The requirements of this section apply to all New and Refurbished Buildings
unless otherwise noted.
a. For large-scale DC Systems with multiple DC Retailers and/or a DC System that includes high-
rise Buildings, the Building interconnection type shall be Indirect Connection.
b. For small-scale DC Systems, and/or sub-networks within a larger DC System (separated from
the main DC System by a HEX), a Direct Connection may be used for service to New Buildings
if Building Systems in such Buildings have an appropriate pressure rating.
For Indirect Connections, plate and frame HEX shall be certified in accordance with the AHRI
Liquid-to-Liquid Heat Exchanger Certification Program, provided that the capacity of the HEX is
encompassed by this certification program at the time of procurement.
a. DC Side modulating flow control valve(s) shall control the Building Side CHW Supply
temperature. Modulating the flow control valve(s) to control the Building Side or DC Side Return
temperature is not acceptable in order to implement the pump control strategy described
under Section 2.2.6.4.
b. In order to protect and ensure comfort conditions for all Buildings connected to the DC System,
DC Side flow control valves shall have the ability to restrict the flow down to the maximum
contracted CHW flow.
c. Two-way modulating flow control valves are mandatory for DC Side ETS Equipment.
a. Large direct bypasses used for flushing, or other similar start-up purpose, must be removed
once the ETS Equipment is in operation.
b. Direct bypass lines shall be avoided, but if a bypass is required it shall include redundant
isolation valves to mitigate the possibility of unintended bypass flow.
a. If a Temperature Different Event occurs, Building System CHW pumps shall be controlled by
the DC Provider or there must be a means for the DC Provider to override the pump control to
ensure the Building Side Supply temperature at all times.
Page 27 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
b. Overriding the pump control may limit Customer comfort and shall only be utilized by the DC
Provider on a temporary basis during critical low Delta-T situations while a permanent solution
to low Delta-T is being arranged.
The provisions of this section apply to DC Provider Facilities providing DC Service to any New
Customer. DC Service may be provided to a Customer directly from the DC Provider acting as DC
Retailer or indirectly from the DC Provider through a separate and unrelated DC Retailer to the
Customer.
a. The DC Provider shall procure, install, operate and maintain Bulk-Metering Equipment, which
shall remain the property of the DC Provider.
b. Where the DC Provider is also the DC Retailer for service to a Customer, the Bulk-Metering
Equipment shall be used for billing the Customer for DC Retailer Services.
c. Where the Customer contracts with a DC Retailer other than the DC Provider, the Bulk-Metering
Equipment shall be used for billing the DC Retailer for DC Provider Services.
d. Bulk-Metering Equipment shall consist of a CHW flow meter, two paired temperature sensors,
DC DESIGN & WATER MANAGEMENT CODE
and an energy calculator that integrates the CHW flow, temperature data, and correction
factors.
e. Bulk-Metering Equipment shall be supplied as a complete unit, factory calibrated with accuracy
performance ratings.
f. Flow meters shall be fast responding type in order to ensure adequate performance during
short peaks in consumption.
g. The DC Provider shall carry out Periodic Inspection and, as required, reconditioning,
of Bulk-Metering Equipment in accordance with KPI service interval requirements and
recommendations from the manufacturer of the Bulk-Metering Equipment. Periodic Inspection
and reconditioning shall be performed by personnel qualified to carry out such work.
h. Bulk-Metering Equipment must be capable of remote data access and must have data logging
capability.
j. Bulk-Metering Equipment shall at all times be accurate to a tolerance in accordance with Table
2 in section 2.2.6.7.
The provisions of this section apply to DC Retailer Facilities providing DC Retailer Services to any
New Customer.
a. The DC Retailer shall procure, install, operate and maintain Sub-Metering Equipment, which
shall remain the property of the DC Retailer and shall be used for billing the Customer for DC
Retailer Services.
Page 28 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
b. Sub-Metering Equipment shall consist of a CHW flow meter at a minimum, and may consist of
a CHW flow meter, two paired temperature sensors, and an energy calculator that integrates
the CHW flow, temperature data and correction factors.
e. Sub-Metering Equipment that is based on CHW flow volumes alone shall be an acceptable
Sub-Metering solution provided that all Cooling Loads beyond the Bulk-Metering Equipment
have Sub-Metering and that Bulk-Metering Equipment is used to determine Cooling Energy
consumption based on the percentage contribution of individual Sub-Metering Equipment
CHW consumption relative to aggregate Sub-Metering Equipment CHW consumption.
f. The Sub-Metering and monitoring system shall be designed to accommodate billing allocation
for common areas and fresh air based upon Customer rental floor area.
g. Flow meters shall be fast responding type in order to ensure adequate performance during
short peaks in consumption.
i. The DC Retailer shall carry out Periodic Inspection and, as required, reconditioning, of Sub-
Metering Equipment in accordance with KPI service interval requirements and recommendations
from the manufacturer of the Sub-Metering Equipment. Periodic Inspection and reconditioning
shall be performed by personnel qualified to carry out such work.
The relative error of Bulk-Metering Equipment and Sub-Metering Equipment, positive or negative,
are expressed in percent and calculated from the CHW flow-rate in the case of the flow sensor and
CHW temperature difference in the case of the energy calculator and the temperature sensor pair.
Table 2 show the maximum permissible relative error of Bulk-Metering Equipment and Sub-
Metering Equipment used for the purposes of billing, where:
Page 29 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
1
Select content from OIML International Recommendation R 75-1 for Heat Meters.
a. The error, Ef, relates the indicated value to the conventional true value of the relationship
between flow sensor output signal and mass or volume.
b. The error, Et, relates the indicated value to the conventional true value of the relationship
between temperature sensor pair output and temperature difference.
c. The error Ec, relates the indicated value to the conventional true value of the Cooling Energy.
d. Qmax is the maximum permitted CHW flow, according to the manufacturer, where the flow
meter is able to function continuously without exceeding the maximum pressure drop, and Q
is the actual CHW flow during the test.
e. Tmin is the minimum permitted T, according to the manufacturer, under which the Metering
Equipment shall function properly, and T is the actual temperature difference between CHW
Return and CHW Supply during the test.
Table 2
DC DESIGN & WATER MANAGEMENT CODE
Flow meter (Qmax > 3 m3/h) Ef = (2 + 0,02 x Qmax/Q), with a maximum tolerance of 5 %
2.2.7 Commissioning
Page 30 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
The metric used to express performance and assess compliance on a given activity is called a Key
Performance Indicator (KPI). An overview of the KPIs and their applicability is provided in Table 0.
DC Providers/Operators and DC Retailers are required to meet minimum KPI performance levels
as provided in this document.
Table 0
Overview of Key Performance Indicators
Reliability
DCP & Metering Equipment Service Intervals New or Existing 9.1 - 9.4
DCR
Notes
DCP means DC Provider.
DCR means DC Retailer.
1.2.1 DC Providers
a. Each DC Provider must monitor its own performance levels for key activities against all KPIs
and must provide reporting to the Regulator (DC Provider Annual Information Returns Form).
Page 31 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
1.2.2 DC Retailers
a. Each DC Retailer must monitor its own performance levels for key activities against KPIs 1 and
9.1-9.4 and must provide reporting to the Regulator (DC Retailer Annual Information Returns,
Form CD-P6/F1).
a. The non-compliant entity must submit a letter, signed by a responsible officer of that entity,
with the following information--
b. The non-compliant entity must submit a quarterly update report on the items listed under a.
above until performance is brought into compliance; and
c. Information about the non-compliance shall be made publically available until such time that
performance is brought into compliance.
Page 32 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
Compliance with the KPIs does not absolve the DC Provider or DC Retailer from compliance with all
laws, standards, regulations, and codes applicable to their systems and business activities.
1.3 Reliability
DC Providers must operate their DC Provider Facilities, and DC Retailers must operate their DC
Retailer Facilities, to minimize Interruption of DC Service. A minimum of one week of notification
shall be given to Customers in writing, providing the date of any Planned Interruption of Services
and the expected duration of interruption. Planned Interruption of Services shall be scheduled
during low-load seasons and outside of Normal Usage Hours whenever possible.
KPI 1 (Table 1) provides the required performance level with respect to DC Provider Service
reliability and DC Retailer Service reliability, with the KPI calculated for DC Providers and DC
Retailers as follows:
a. For DC Providers, the KPI for the Reporting Period is calculated as follows:
SHP = Number of hours during which DC Provider Services were available to meet the
Cooling Load requirements of all DC Retailers under contract at that time (up to maximum
Cooling Load requirements contracted).
THP = Total number of hours during the Reporting Period.
FMP = Number of hours during the Reporting Period during which service to any DC
Retailer by DC Provider was interrupted due to a Force Majeure Event or due to actions of
the Retailer or other entity.
b. For DC Retailers, the KPI for the Reporting Period is calculated as follows:
In which --
SHR = Number of hours during which DC Retailer Services were available to meet the
Cooling Load requirements of all Customers under contract at that time (up to maximum
Cooling Load requirements contracted).
THR = Total number of hours during the Reporting Period.
FMR = Number of hours during the Reporting Period during which service to any Customer
by DC Retailer was interrupted due to a Force Majeure Event or due to actions of the
Customer, DC Provider or other entity.
KPI 1 (Table 1) shall be in effect for New Plants after a period of one (1) Year or more from initial
start-up (at the Regulators discretion). During the first Year of operation (or more at the Regulators
discretion) a KPI Level of 95% is acceptable.
Page 33 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
Table 1
1 All 99.5%
1
Reporting Period is the calendar year for Annual Information Returns (8,760 hours) or the calendar
quarter for follow-up reporting in case of non-compliance as discussed in Section 1.2.3 (2,190 hours).
The following tables provide minimum required performance levels for New Plants, Existing Plants
and Temporary Plants with respect to electricity consumption. Energy efficiency KPI requirements
for DC Providers utilizing unconventional DC Plant designs (e.g. natural gas chillers) or that
otherwise do not fit into the categories listed shall be established by the Regulator based on the
design characteristics of the DC Plant(s).
DC DESIGN & WATER MANAGEMENT CODE
KPIs 2.1 2.9 (Table 2) shall be in effect for New Plants after a period of one (1) year (or
more, at the Regulators discretion) from initial start-up.
KPIs 3.1 3.2 (Table 3) shall be in effect for Existing Plants.
KPIs 4.1 4.2 (Table 4) shall be in effect for Temporary Plants.
a. KPI: Plant electricity consumption in kWh divided by Cooling Energy (TR-hrs) produced at the
DC Plant(s).
Table 2
KPI 2 -- Electricity Consumption in New Plants
Page 34 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
Table 3
Table 4
The KPIs in Table 5 provide required performance levels for all DC Plants, including New Plants,
Existing Plants and Temporary Plants, with respect to Cooling Tower Makeup Water consumption.
Performance requirements differ depending on the type of water used for Cooling Tower Makeup:
KPI 5.1 shall be in effect for DC Plants using Potable Water for Cooling Tower Makeup.
KPI 5.2 shall be in effect for DC Plants using TSE or other Recycled Water for Cooling
Tower Makeup without polishing of TSE or other Recycled Water.
KPI 5.3 shall be in effect for DC Plants using TSE or other Recycled Water with polishing
of TSE or other Recycled Water.
Page 35 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
a. KPI: Water consumption in liters divided by Cooling Energy (TR-hrs) produced at the Plant(s).
b. If a Polishing Plant is used, water consumption refers to water input to the Polishing Plant.
c. If there is no Polishing Plant, water consumption is equal to total Cooling Tower Makeup Water
(which is comprised as follows: Makeup Water = Blowdown Water + Drift loss + Evaporation
Loss).
Table 5
The KPIs in Table 6 provide required performance levels for all DC Plants, including New Plants,
Existing Plants and Temporary Plants, with respect to the quantity of wastewater discharged from
the DC Plant. Performance requirements differ depending on the type of water used for Cooling
Tower Makeup:
KPI 6.1 shall be in effect for DC Plants using Potable Water for Cooling Tower Makeup.
KPI 6.2 shall be in effect for DC Plants using TSE or other Recycled Water for Cooling Tower
Makeup without polishing of TSE or other Recycled Water.
KPI 6.3 shall be in effect for DC Plants using TSE or other Recycled Water with polishing of
TSE or other Recycled Water.
a. KPI: Wastewater quantity in liters divided by total Cooling Energy (TR-hrs) produced at the
Plant(s).
b. Wastewater quantity refers to water discharged from a Polishing Plant (if any) plus Cooling
Tower Blowdown Water.
Page 36 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
Table 6
KPI 7 (Table 7) sets the minimum performance levels for all New and Existing DC Systems with
respect to Chilled Water Makeup Water consumption.
a. KPI: CHW Makeup Water consumption in liters divided by average DC System CHW total volume
in liters during the reporting period.
Table 7
KPI 7 -- Water Consumption for Chilled Water Makeup
7 All 2.0%
KPI 8 (Table 8) sets the required minimum performance level for the quality of water circulating in
Cooling Towers. This requirement is in addition to other requirements that may be set by permitting
authorities.
Table 8
8 All 200
Page 37 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
KPIs 9.1 9.4 (Table 9) establishes performance levels for Bulk-Metering Equipment and Sub-
Metering Equipment servicing.
b. KPI Maximum Service Interval is the longest time interval a component of Bulk-Metering
Equipment and Sub-Metering Equipment (free from known defects) is permitted to be in
service between Periodic Inspection.
Table 9
1
Qmax is the maximum permitted CHW flow, according to the manufacturer, where the flow meter is able
to work continuously without exceeding the maximum pressure drop.
Page 38 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
The following Information shall be submitted to the Regulator by the Licensed Entities by March
31 of each year covering performance for the prior calendar year. Data shall be provided in each
area indicated in grey. Supporting data shall be attached.
General Information
Input Value
Company Name
Respondent Name
Respondent Position
Respondent Email
Values to be inserted
System Reliability
1 All 99.5%
Performance Requirements Met?
Page 39 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
Electricity Consumption
KPI Level (kWh/TR-hr)
Water
Weighted Averages
Performance Requirement Met?
Maximum Performance
Condenser Cooling Water Polishing
KPI # DC Plant Type TES DC KPI Level Level Achieved
Type Source Plant?
Permitted by Plant Type
Weighted Averages
Performance Requirement Met?
Maximum Performance
Condenser Cooling Water Polishing
KPI # DC Plant Type TES DC KPI Level Level Achieved
Type Source Plant?
Permitted by Plant Type
Weighted Averages
Performance Requirement Met?
Page 40 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
Make-up Water
Total Water Volume in Maximum KPI Performance Level Achieved
KPI # DC Plant Type Added to DC
DC Network (liters) Level Permitted by Plant Type
Network (liters)
7 All 2.0%
Maximum KPI
KPI # Equipment Performance Level Achieved
Level Permitted
Licensed Capacity TR
Page 41 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
Licensed Capacity TR
Page 42 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
2. Preventive maintenance activities planned but not completed during the Reporting Period.
1. Statement of Compliance with occupational health and safety laws and regulations.
The following Information shall be submitted to the Regulator by the Licensed Entities by March
31 of each year covering performance for the prior calendar year. Data shall be provided in each
area indicated in grey. Supporting data shall be attached.
Input Value
Company Name
Respondent Name
Respondent Position
Respondent Email
Values to be inserted
Performance requirement met? (level achieved less than maximum permitted)? (Yes or No)
Page 43 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified
DC Design & Water Management Code CS-CSI-P1/C5
System Reliability
1 All 99%
Maximum KPI
KPI # Equipment Performance Level Achieved
Level Permitted
1. Statement of Compliance with occupational health and safety laws and regulations.
2. Statement of Compliance with environmental laws and regulations.
Page 44 of 44
Issue : 0 16-10-2016 Unclassified