Pln3 Week 3 Handouts
Pln3 Week 3 Handouts
Pln3 Week 3 Handouts
Outline
1. History of Cities
2. Theories of Urbanization
2. There was increase in tribe size to the point where huntingand gathering could no longer provide
adequate food, which
encouraged fixed settlements3. successful domestication of selected plants and animalsgenerated huge
food surplus that led to sedentary settlementsin alluvial plains (Nile, Tigris, Euphrates, Indus, Huang Ho,
Tiber rivers)
4. The resource base was the source of water rivers, lakes and
6. Rectilinear plotting with the use of plow made easy the divisionof land according to crop7. Use of
massive warehouses to store food in preparation for
drought or warfare
Theory
of Early
Urbanization
Wittfogel
1957)
urbanization
surplus
irrigation systems
denied water
Inca)
Ur, in Sumeria
1/29/2017
Theoryof EarlyUrbanization
Religious Model
(Paul Wheatley1973)
priestly class
social control; political leader had toclaim to be a high priest with specialand unique knowledge.
political system
rationing
kings to codify laws, and theirsupposed literacy led to claims ofunique divine wisdom inaccessible to
the masses.
Paul Wheatley Religion and the Rise of Urbanism, The Pivot of the
Worship of the
totalitarian god-
kings
Totalitarian god-
monuments and
EgyptEgyptXian,Shaanxi,China
Greek City-States
and the
birth
of Democracy
a,
to totalitarian empires.
Priene
Pergamon.
The Greeks also had the
fine arts.
of self-government, and
citizenship
not included)
ECOPOLIS2009PAGE7MycenaeSpartaMinoaTroyorIlionPergamon
TempleofZeusatOlympia
Lawyer-architect Hippodamus
Planning in Europe.
He emphasized geometric
theoretical framework in
planning.
from Macedonia
Alexander captured.
AlexandertheGreat
1/29/2017
Plato, 427-347 BC
height 450 BC
AthensandAcropolis
be found guilty of injuring the water bydeleterious substances, let him not onlypay damages, but purify
the stream or the
each case.
Aristotle,
384-322
B.C.
on
Inter-generational equity
whatever people's
preferences happen to be at
a particular time; it is also
constrained in their
preferences.
p10
Milo, 100BC
The godHermes
Zeus, god
of the
gods in
Greek
mythology
Discobolus,
500 BC
1/29/2017
Rome The Eternal City Rome straddles 7 hills originally inhabited by pastoral communities with
access
to Tiber River.
Rome was first a Republic run by democratic Senate until 27BC then it became
an Empire after the assassination of Julius Caesar who was succeeded bydynasties of
emperors/dictators
Imperial Rome did not excel in philosophy and science but excelled in
sewerage
Rome was the first ancient city to reach 1 million population in 03 AD about thetime Jesus Christ was
6 years old.
City was bisected by 2 main streets that met at the center called the Forum
Even with magnificent public buildings, Rome was overcrowded, susceptible toepidemics, plagues, and
large disastrous fires (e.g. Nero)
Ancient Rome
Romans were preoccupied with defense and built their city like a military camp called castra whole
Grid-iron design: Basic street pattern useful for military movement, or marching by rectangular
platoons
Romans chose locations with good access to major road, trade route, or sea egress
Londinium200ADquadrangles andpiazzas
Paris,ca.400AD The Roman militarycamp or castra was
perimeter blocks,
Roman Empire
AncientRomanEmpireatitsheight,
117AD
Arabia
AncientRomanEmpireatitsheight,
117AD
Arabia
by Emperor Caracalla
Apollodorus of Damascus was credited for manyimportant designs of Classical Rome under Emperor
design.
Fall of Roman
Empire,
476
AD
Moral Decay Emperors were too obsessed with power. In power struggles,
Emperors were killed by their own sons or wives. Brothers killed their own
brothers who were rival heirs to the throne, showing the breakdown of families.
Among the elite, incest, in-breeding, deceit, and treachery were common, as well
of treasury and loss of respect from the citizens. Military generals were rewarded
with multiple women and sex-orgies as prize for battle, which resulted in loss of
The States official persecution of early Christians and of diaspora Jews before
the reign of Constantine The Great led to sectoral strife; socio-religious divisions
among the citizenry prevented them from uniting during periods of crisis.
Scandinavia) & Huns from Asia Minor who plundered wealth of Roman cities.
Vikings cut off Roman lifeline the Aqueduct. Without steady supply of water,
Empire was just too large to maintain for an overstretched army fightingin
multiple fronts.
1/29/2017
1/29/2017
Socio-Cultural
Theory
of
Urbanization
greater heterogeneity.
After the Fall of the Roman Empire in 476 AD, central concern of
communities during Dark Ages until 800-AD was survival and security.
Because of walls, cities could not grow more than one square mile.
Bran Castle,
Transylvania
Angers Castle,Angers
City, France
Fortress
Cities
monastery, or castle
Cathedral is a church
chair of a Bishop is
institutions
because of water
kms)
Heidelberg, Germany
Zurich, Switzerland
Zurich, Switzerland
Zurich, Switzerland
Zurich, Switzerland
1/29/2017
Munich,
Germany
Mannheim,Germany
rise to power of the Merchant Class whoshaped trading and treasury policies of theMonarchies.
trading companies.
Italy Urbino
Renaissance(1440-1769)
Florence,ItalyFlorencecathedralBrunelleschiDuomoPittiPalaceTowerbyGiottoFlorence,birthplaceofRenai
ssance
1/29/2017
shaped plans with streets radiating from acentral point, a church, palace or castle
topography
RadialUrbanModel(LeoneBattistaAlberti)
Renaissance(1440-1769 )
Venice,Italy
Venice, Genoa,
Amsterdam, Lisbon,
Hamburg, St. Petersburg
Venice,ItalyVenice,ItalyVenice,1454
Vienna,AustriaVienna,AustriaBelvederePalace,ViennaViennaasLandlockedRenaissanceCity
Moscow
CitieswhichflourishedduringRenaissance
1/29/2017
New Amsterdam
ManhattanwastheoriginalCountyofNewYork,
Dutch East India Company found triver and harbor of New York
he
PierreCharlesLEnfant(1784-1825)
French architect, engineer, cityplanner who prepared Plan forWashington D.C. (1791)
Britain
A plan to serve as the framework forthe capital city of the new nation
Movement later picked up byEbenezer Howard (UK) and DanielH. Burnham (US)
1/29/2017
Washington DC
BaronGeorgesEugeneHaussmann(1809-1891)
after Viennas
mob behavior;
Paris, Best
Planned City of
the World
Arc de Triomphe
Arc de Triomphe
Champs Elysees
River Seine
Invention
of steam
engine in
1769
ushered in
the
Industrial
Revolution
in the 1800s
Dickens
ECOPOLIS2009PAGE43
IndustrialCities orManufacturingCities(1769-1970s)
resources
Management
1/29/2017
Londons Covent Garden Square designed by Iigo Jones in 1630s featured the Royal Opera
House but eventually became a market for vegetables, fruits and flowers
Londonwasoriginallya Romancamp(castra)
andthen replannedbyInigoJones1630
Improved
Population of 10,000
St.PaulsCathedralBuckinghamPalaceTrafalgarSquare,
officialcenterofLondon
ECOPOLIS2009PAGE46
Planning Models
I.
Garden City Movement (Sir Ebenezer Howard and his disciples in UK)
II.
City Beautiful Movement a response to urban decay and urban blightduring the Industrial Revolution
Le Corbusier Radiant City led to Skyscraper Cities and the common form ortemplate of CBDs
reconceptualized the city in relation to its peripheries; tried to address economicpolarization, inter-area
imbalance, regional divergence
Parks Movement
asystem of Americanparks
Towns
and cultural.
Olmsteds Vision
Mixed use
&
John Muir
Frederick
Law
Olmsted
Sr.
attempted to rationalize urban planning in relation to economic production that had been
Transport Planning
planning
Urban Renewal and Gentrification addressed the hollowing out of historic city cores by
means of revitalization but also resulted in massive urban slum demolitions, giving rise to
combated indiscriminate, inhuman urban renewal and sought to revive the lost art of
Neo-Traditional Neighborhoods
Ecosystem-Based Planning
Ecological Footprinting
Sustainable Cities
Riverside, Illinois
Bostons
Emerald
Necklace
FrederickLawOlmstedSr.
ECOPOLIS2009PAGE51
In UK, Problems of
century
animal wastes
street cleaning
public transport
lack of cemeteries
Modern
Town
Planning
1. Main Goals
Solve acute public health crisis associated with overcrowding and lack of
2. Under Englands Public Health Act of 1875, counties were divided into
stated that land use has to be regulated, thus giving birth to town planning
access
to back alleys for waste disposal (garbage and waste water)
8.
Planning is as old as urban formation but the initial interest was social
Sir
Ebenezer
Howard
(1850-1928)
of Tomorrow (1902)
Concerned about abject living conditions and needto change the physical form of cities:
uncontrolled growth
Three magnets in his paradigm depicted thatboth the city and the countryside had
advantages and disadvantages. Creation ofjobs and urban services in the City resulted in
Garden
City
1. Population ~ 30,000
zerHowardandThenCityMovementAmong thedisciplesofEbenezerHowardwere
influentialinthedevelopmentof30"NewTowns"
afterWorldWar IIbytheBritishgovernment,
includingStevenage,Hertfordshireandthelast
(andlargest) beingMiltonKeynes,
Buckinghamshire.
GermanarchitectsHermannMuthesiusandBruno
TautcreatedGermany'sfirstgardencityofHellerauin1909,theonlyGermangardencitywhereHoward'sideasw
erethoroughlyadopted.
1934
Buckinghamshire.
EbenezerHowardandTheGardenCityMovement
Designed by Sir
Raymond Unwin
Welwyn
Garden City
by Louis de
Soissons
1/29/2017
Letchworth Garden
City
Welwyn Garden
Greenbelt
testament to
success of Sir
Ebenezer
Howard!
City Beautiful
Movement
1/29/2017
CityBeautifulMovement(1800-1950s)
design and planning --grandeur, monumentality(drama & tension), exuberance, cohesiveness, and
symmetry.
parks and promenades starting from a prominentwaterfront, clusters or blocks of focal civic buildings
Ithis movement embraced all public works designedwith classical facades and built as grand portals to
circulation/transport planning but generally criticizedas utopian --Beauty stood supreme, had
littleconcern for health and sanitation (hospitals,
sewerage, solid waste), mass housing, economicgrowth (factories), natural hazards, geology, zoning
described the
Chicago Expo as
"temporary
wonderland of grand
perspectives,
shimmering lagoons
and monumental
palaces an
enthralling amalgam
of Classical Greece,
Bourbon Paris"
Grand Basin
beautification
Sanitation
Aesthetics
Civic Improvements
Building Design
Civic Spirit
Islamabad,Pakistan (1959)
93 in Chicago with Olmsted which drew millions ofvisitors and stimulated concern for urban design
Also designed Baltimore, Buffalo, Cleveland, SanFrancisco (1905), Manila (1903-06) and Baguio
City(1911).
congestion Created a business core with no conscious provision forbusiness expansion in the rest of
the city
DanielHudsonBurnham(1846-1912)
never die, but long after we are gone will be a livingthing, asserting itself with ever-growing insistency.
a park.
Charles-Edouard
Jeanneret (1887-1965) Le
Corbusier
part of land.
would live in hygienic, regimented high-rise towers, set far apart in apark-like landscape. This rational
city would be separated intodiscrete zones for working, living and leisure. Above all, everything
should be done on a big scale big buildings, big open spaces, big
urban highways
we burn our bridges and break with the past. (no heritage
conservation)
space.
Le Corbusiers Radiant
objective was to decongest the entire city byincreasing density at the core; to concentratepopulation
without congestion.
technology could make the design possible. Itwould house 3 million people.
building shapes
Housing and office towers were grouped inabstract formal relationships that maximized
Le Corbusiers design influenced the design ofCBDs with High-rises/Skyscrapers in office parks
Radieuse)
Applied concepts to City of Chandigarh, newcapital of Punjab, India; and to Brasilia, Brazil;
found to be socially-destructive.
In the United States, took the form of vastregimented public housing projects (Tenements)
of Paris, 1955
Radiant
City
(Le
Ville
Radieuse)
Applied concepts to City of Chandigarh, new capitalof Punjab, India; and to Brasilia, Brazil; Boston and
Toronto.
In the United States, took the form of vast regimentedpublic housing projects (Tenements) that
damaged the
urban fabric beyond repair. Today these megaprojectsare being dismantled, as Tenement-blocks give
way torows of houses fronting streets and sidewalks.
Downtowns have discovered that combining, notseparating, different activities is the key to success. So
communities (1912-1960s):
of architectural inspiration
innovative way.
universal space
bearing cantilevers
use of concrete
Metropolitan Cathedral
National Congress
Palacio da Alvorada
Radiant Cityattempted in
Brasilia at
huge financial
costs and
environmental
costs(forests)
1/29/2017
New
Towns
Movement
(1920-1950s)
Pursued Garden City ideas of Ebenezer Howard which theybelieved could produce better communities
Considered endless grid-iron tracks as wasteful and unnecessaryand pursued other ways to address
community problems and
issues
Put factories and other industrial buildings where they can be usedwithout wasteful transportation of
people and goods
separation between
pedestrian traffic
Movement in
the US
FrankLloydWright(1867-1959)
Major US architect involved in site planning and communityplanning, had 41 commissions, 532
designs, 1000+ drawings
Under Broadacre City design, settlements would have size ofabout 10km2 (1000 has) with all services
and amenities of asmall city schools, museums, markets, offices, trains etc.
homes. Families would have one acre each (4,050m2)fromfederal land reserves, with sufficient space for
gardens and
fiction.
He also designed neighborhoods and subdivisions employingthe Quadruple Block Plan wherein
houses are set on smallsquare blocks of four equal sized lots surrounded on all sides
in the center. This also allowed for more interesting viewsfrom each house. This design would have
eliminated the
straight rows of houses on parallel streets with boring viewsof the front of each house.
FrankLloydWright(1867-1959)
Major US architect involved in site planning and communityplanning, had 41 commissions, 532
designs, 1000+ drawings
homes. Families would have one acre each (4,050m2)fromfederal land reserves, with sufficient space for
gardens and
fiction.
He also designed neighborhoods and subdivisions employingthe Quadruple Block Plan wherein
houses are set on smallsquare blocks of four equal sized lots surrounded on all sides
in the center. This also allowed for more interesting viewsfrom each house. This design would have
eliminated the
straight rows of houses on parallel streets with boring viewsof the front of each house.
Henry
Wright
(1878-1936)
development in the US
pathways.
explained how New York developed from a city ofsmall trade centers to an industrial belt, to a
low-density
car-oriented
freeways +
feeder roads
Multi-nucleated
Clarence
S.
Stein
(1882-1975)
Mumford
Reston, Virginia;
Columbia, Maryland
Greenbelt, Maryland;
Greendale, Wisconsin;
Greenhills, Ohio;
Greenbrook NJ
1/29/2017
1/29/2017
ClarencePerry(1872-1944)
Perry intended his neighborhood unit to satisfymost needs of residents and bring advantages
oftraditional small town living into the city.
support an elementary school, generally a halfmile in diameter at most, (2) boundaries on allsides by
arterial streets, (3) open spaces for small
parks and recreation of about 10% of the totalneighborhood area, (4) institutions such as
around the circumference at traffic junctions, and(6) internal street system with lots of cul-de-sacsand
street widths sized to facilitate internal traffic
Regional Planning
Movement
Scottish biologist, sociologist, and city planner responsible forintroducing the concept of "region" to
planning and city architecture;
Famous Books
Popularized the framework Folk Work Place and the planning method
synoptic planning
He made extensive use of survey method; Planning must start with asurvey of the resources of a region,
of human responses to it, and ofthe resulting complexities of the cultural landscape;
and conurbation
as the
large cities), Build-up (overcrowding), Backflow (slum formation, centralcity blight), and sprawling mass,
resulting in amorphic spread, waste
SirPatrickGeddes Geddes stressed the social basis of the city the relationshipbetween people and
cities and how they affect one another.
Sir
Leslie
Patrick
Abercrombie
(1879-1957)
best known for the re-planning of London thru the County of London
Plan (1943) and the extended Greater London Regional Plan (1944)
which are called the Abercrombie Plan, where 1.25 million people
which included the building of Harlow and Crawley and the largest
the City & County of Kingston upon Hull, with the assistance of Sir
Edwin Lutyens.
Emperor Haile Selassie (Ras Tafari) to draw up plans for the capital
of Addis Ababa.
Lewis
Mumford
(1895-1990)
American thinker called the Last of the Great Humanists, Father of Historical-
The City in History was sweeping, masterful historical analysis of city development
all over the world, describes why cities came about and what their continuing
function is.
must return to a perspective that places emotions, sensitivity, and ethics at the
saw the city not only as a place with poor living conditions, but also as a threat to
democracy and the breeding place of fascism, as the masses of people in the big
fundamental basic needs of society be the bases for the judicious use of
technology;
advocated harmonious life among civilized groups in ecological balance with the
the modern city (New York 1960) is following the patterns of Imperial Roman city
(the sprawling megalopolis) which ended in collapse; if the modern city carries on
in the same vein, then it will meet the same fate as the Imperial Roman city.
Benton
MacKaye
(1879-1975)
from Maine to Georgia blazed through the efforts ofvolunteers. He advocated preserving cultural and
recreational
"townless highway."
Planning, 1928
City Functional
Movement
City
Functional
Movement
(1910-70)
Reacted to preoccupation with urban design of the City Beautiful Movement in US and
Greater concern for the functioning of cities rather than design aesthetics --function over form
Emphasized opportunity rather than focus on economic and social evils of city
2.
Focused on utility infrastructure and on land use zoning rather than master
planning
Ironically, Excessive zoning creates homogeneity which leads to sterility and inconvenience.
3.
Zoning originated in New York City in 1916 by Edward Bassett as the first
purpose at that time was to contain the invasion of factories into the FifthAvenue business district and
the shadowing of adjacent propertiesbyemerging skyscrapers.
4.
Constitutionality of zoning as part of police power of the State was upheld byUS Supreme Court in 1926,
as a result of Village of Euclid v. Ambler Realty
6.
Picked up in Germany --Grundriss-plan of 1910 was Master plan for GreaterBerlin ; Rudolf Hillebrecht In
Hamburg, Germany
7.
in Rotterdam, the Netherlands; Helsinki & Tapiola, Finland; and Melun Senart,
France.
houses and buildings could be set alongside linear utilitysystems supplying water, communications and
electricity. Heconsidered impact of technology on urban form.
parallel sectors.
a residential zone, including a band of social institutions, a band ofresidential buildings and a
"children's band",
As the city expanded, additional sectors would be added tothe end of each band, so that it would
become ever longer,
The city may run parallel to a river and be built so that the
industrial strip.
Don
Arturo
Soria y Mata
ECOPOLIS2009PAGE98
Linear
City
ECOPOLIS2009PAGE99
1/29/2017
1/29/2017
Tony
Garnier
(1869-1948)
Noted French architect and city planner, forerunner ofavant garde 20th century French architects
Cite Industrielle (1917-18) designed for about 35,000inhabitants living in lushly landscaped residential
areas.
France.
His basic idea included the separation of spaces byfunction through zoning into four categories including
Thomas
Adams
became
father
of
urban
planning
in Canada
117
government
land
ownership)
4. Adam saw fundamental conflict between right to lifeversus right to property. However, Adams
belonged tothe British liberal tradition, not socialism/communism.
Town plan should provide for the proper and efficientcarrying-on of business.
to adopt
hearing process
City Efficient
Movement
1/29/2017
C. Britton
Harris, ( 1895-
2005) University
of Pennsylvania
Dr.
Francis
Stuart
Chapin
Jr.
(1888-1974)
phenomena; Proposed to treat a town or region as anevolving system and simulate its growth as a
system in arecursive manner while studying directly the influence ofdifferent public policies on the
pattern of town evolution
behavioral process
conducted pioneering research on how residents use theircity in the course of daily life, social and
physical conceptsof neighborhood, and urban growth dynamics.
health
safety
convenience
economy
amenity
Primarily driven by the popularity of automobile as mode oftransport (General Motors, Ford, and
Chrysler in USA; before theylost to Toyota and Nissan in the late 1990s) the car is king
City cores lost out to suburbia and exurbia in terms of capitalimprovement and employment
Amorphic Sprawl refers to the low-density fragmented use ofland for consumptive urban purposes at
a scale expanded faster
(formless) manner.
Over time, this pattern means more and more houses are built
farther away from the urban core that require more energy use per
person and that need to be supported by piecemeal extensions ofurban infrastructure such as roads,
sewer, power and water.
Distances become too great for walking and this forces dependenceon the automobile; hard for old
people when they can no longerdrive; hard for young people who arent yet old enough to drive
Pioneers
of Transport
Planning
Rapkin (1954) -developed transport and landuse study. Traffic is a function of land use e.g.
Wesley Mitchell (1954) -advocated that plansshould be in dynamic not static terms. He was aleading
figure in setting up the Penn-Jersey
simulation model.
Urban
(1915-1983) UCLA
Planning relies
more
and
more
onpositivist
and
empirical
methods:
Comprehensive Planning
(1959)
centripetal forces
Spatial Modelling
ECOPOLIS2009PAGE109
America, 1950-70s:
Robert
Moses,
New Yo
rk
Ed Logue
Catherine
Bauer
Wurster
(1905-64)
NY and in Pennsylvania
Richard King
Mellon,
Pittsburg
Rexford GuyTugwell(1891-1979)
Urban
Renewal:
Robert
Moses
New York City, oversaw major publicworks projects and emerged as one of
trees.
Planner of New
York City
Urban
Renewal
and
Tax
Increment
Financing
Urban Renewal is a US Federal program under the
projects or public assets parks, streets and streetscapeimprovements, parks and plazas, greenways,
communitycenters, and facilities that would not happen on their own.
options.
revenues will pay for revitalization. The City Governmentdraws a line around an area (the urban renewal
boundary)
property tax revenues (called tax increment) is used topay off the urban renewal bonds. This financing
method is
area.
Gentrification
city
revitalization of blighted
urban poor
classes.
Montreal,Quebec
Social
Protest
Movements
and
the
Rise
of
Advocacy
or Activist
or
Equity
Planning
Gentrification and large-scale demolition of slums andblack neighborhoods in the 1960s gave rise to
the
Advocacy Planning school asserts that the planningprocess should take the side of the poor, the last,
theleast, and the lost.
Planners should work for the redistribution of power andresources to the powerless and the
disadvantaged; to
Goals are Social justice and Equity in Housing, provisionof services, environmental protection.
Advocacy planning has both reflected and contributed toa general trend in planning away from neutral
objectivityin definition of social problems, in favor of applying moreexplicit principles of social justice.
shifted formulation of social policy from backroomnegotiations (haggling among varied interest
groups) outinto the open as Government and Private Institutions
groups
Urban Renewal through Gentrification was initiallycalled racist and segregationist and contributedto
Civil Rights protest led by Dr. Martin Luther
King. James Baldwin called urban renewal as
Negro removal.
Single, dont have to raise a family, no need tomaintain community traditions, social life in night
occupations
focused on community
Advocacy Planning
Paul Davidoff (1965): father of advocacy planning, idol ofBarack Hussein Obama during Obamas
communitydevelopment work in Chicago. Called for development ofplural plans rather than a unitary
plan, claimed that public
mobilization that confronts the State and dares the State to live up to its
own principles but without Marxist/Maoist ideology of taking over the
State
Alan Altshuler
Allan
Planners
Heskin
Advocacy Planning
Norman Krumholtz
1/29/2017
1/29/2017
New Urbanism or
Neo-Traditionalism
Jane
Jacobs
(1916-2006)
Traditionalism
specialization, spurs urban growth. It is the diversity ofgeographically proximate industries that
promotes innovation
and growth. As measured by employment, industries growslower in cities where they are heavily over-
represented. But
industries.
common theme of Jacobs work has been to question whetherwe are building cities for people or cities
for cars
and therefore mixed land uses to ensure that people were there
Traditionalism
seeks to rebuild inner city neighborhoodsaround important traditions and core values;
employs multi-use development scheme onfocal points such as waterfronts, spectacularor distinctive
settings
(1907-1964)
United States
American biologist who wrote Silent Spring (1962); books title suggested a
time when bird populations are greatly reduced as a result of pesticides bioaccumulation
Ironically Carson died of cancer in 1964 before she saw the fruit of her
labor:
Silent Spring as one of the most influential books of the last century.
IanL.McHarg(1920-2001)
environmental information.
development constraints
statements (EIS)
of Arts 1990.
placed.
LandOwnership/ConservationLandsTransportationNetworkLandCoverAgriculturalSoilsSurfaceWaterTop
ographyOrthoimageryGeodeticControlIan L. McHarg built the foundations for
Six
Evils of
Industrial
Cities
1. Overcrowding and Traffic-Congestion
6. Economic Polarization resulting in Mass Poverty and Urban Blightin Primate Cities
Residents live in perceptually undifferentiated areas, many arecenterless and borderless, without a
soul.
but going to places which are not better. This is called the
Geography of Nowhere.
With the breakdown of human communities, people experienceurban anomie the person is so
overcome by feelings ofanonymity like a nameless, faceless statistic (Dr. Herbert Gans)
Gans criticized architectural determinism the fallacy thatarchitecture alone could solve the
problems of poverty and civicdis-engagement
Dr. Herbert J.
Gans, pioneer of
Policy Planning
and Blueprint
Planning
James Howard
Kunstler The
Geography of
Nowhere, The
Rise and
Decline of
Americas Man-
Made
Landscape.
1993
1/29/2017
1/29/2017
IndustrialCitiesarenotself-sustainingInputs Outputs
Energy
Food
Water
Raw
materials
Manufactured
goods
Money
Information
Solid wastes
Waste heat
Air pollutants
Water pollutants
Greenhouse gases
Manufactured goods
Noise
Wealth
Ideas
IndustrialCitiesas UrbanEcosystems
In contrast to natural
biological factors:
heterogeneous
boundaries
Resourceflowsinto urban
UrbanHeatIslandEffect92
85
33
29
residential
Downtown Urban
residential
Park Suburban
residential
Rural
farmland
Megalopolis term byJean Gottmann Sprawling Metropolis with more than 10million population
Hyper-Urbanization or Over-urbanization
polarization of a country.
1/29/2017
False Urbanization
refers to the unexpected large-scale migration ofrural people into urban areas even though
Hyper-Urbanization:Megacitiesof theWorld
ECOPOLIS2009PAGE130
or agurbs, which feed on the city and have multiple relations with it in
terms of education, cooperation and work places, but holds its village
Micropolis small city of less than 50,000 residents, built upon its
agrarian roots, values and sense of community, but embraces newtechnology, knowledge, and creativity
in modern life and in work. Theywould form creative or high-technological clusters of small
cities.Agropolis (John Friedmann) create connections and
Development
COMPLETE THE WASTE and WATER CYCLES: Treat 100% of water and waste (sewer, gray
water, storm water) on-site and at all scales. Viewing the cycle from pool to planet, these
DESIGN for EFFICIENT ENERGY: Utilize on-site renewable energy technologies in conjunction
with site orientation and planning to maximize benefits of passive and climatic power
conservation.
MAXIMIZE ON-SITE FOOD PRODUCTION: Increase self-reliance and local food production
ENHANCE MOBILITY & CIRCULATION: Use new modes of transportation that reduce energy
consumption from local to regional, from personal to shared. Reshape and organize the
RESTORE STREAMS & RIVERS: Enhance and rehabilitate existing waterways. Restore and
RE-ESTABLISHHABITAT&WILDLIFE:Retain,constructandrestoreecologicalmatricesto
support animal species, vegetation and topographical features. Conserve and protect existing
INCORPORATE INNOVATIVE MATERIALS: use building materials and site products (pavers,
walls, etc) that reduce energy consumption (local materials) and have the potential to adapt to
changes.
PRESERVE CULTURE & HERITAGE: Integrate local values through preservation, protection and
VALUE EQUITY, HEALTH & HAPPINESS: Improve living and working environments for all
Hierarchy
of World
Cities
Beijing, Moscow
Birmingham
Inward migration
Corporate headquarters
Legal services
Producer services
Sources
Routledge (Chapter 1)
What
makes
a city
different?
Spatial proximity
Infrastructure
Historical
association
Concentration
of
socio-economic
activity
Centres
of
creativity
Social
practices
and
the
built environment