GURU NANAK DEV ENGINEERING COLLEGE, LUDHIANA

MECHANICAL ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT

INTERNAL ASSESSMENT OF MAJOR PROJECT

Rubric#3: Midterm Evaluation (20 Marks)

Rubric Excellent Good Average Partially acceptable Unacceptable

% Weightage (81-100%) (61-80%) (41-60%) (21-40%) (0-20%)

Data collection/Design/ Chooses appropriate Chooses appropriate Chooses appropriate No proper selection No
Fabrication work etc. computational and computational and computational and of computational computational
(10 marks) information tools for information tools for information tools for tools for Data tools for Data
Data Data collection/design/ Data collection/design/ collection/design
collection/design/ fabrication work obtains collection/design/ fabrication work. / fabrication
fabrication work correct solution to fabrication work. Data was not work were used
obtains correct model developed for the Partially collection of collected properly. and Incomplete
solution to model project. data. work.
developed for the
project or uses tools
effectively.
Data analysis & Clear application of Clear application of Clear application of Research tools are No work has
Experimentation research tools. Results research tools. Results research tools. not specified. Results been done
(05 marks) are analyzed properly are analyzed to some Results were not were not analyzed related to
and discussed with extent and discussed analyzed and hardly and not discussed analyze /
guide. with guide. discussed with guide with guide. fabrication/
experimentation
of the project.
 Teamwork The team worked well The team worked well The team worked The team worked The team did not
(05 Marks) together to achieve together most of the together but with together very rarely collaborate or
objectives. Each time, with only a few many instances of but some members communicate
member contributed in occurrences occurrences work independently, well. Some
a valuable way to the of communication of communication without regard to members work
project. breakdown breakdown objectives or independently,
or failure to collaborate or failure to collabora priorities. without regard to
when necessary. te when necessary objectives or
priorities.

Rubric#4: Overall Evaluation- Internal (80 Marks)

Rubric Excellent Good Average Partially Acceptable Unacceptable

% Weightage 81-100% 61-80% 41-60% 21-40% 0-20%

Project Diary It includes all of the It includes most of the It includes some of It includes a very few It includes none
(15 Marks) following: following: the following: of the following: of the following:
1.Compilation of 1.Compilation of 1.Compilation of 1.Compilation of 1.Compilation of
literature. literature. literature. literature. literature.
2.Rough sketches, 2.Rough sketches, 2.Rough sketches, 2.Rough sketches, 2.Rough
calculations, calculations, calculations, calculations, sketches,
observations etc. observations etc. observations etc. observations etc. calculations,
3.Rough chapters of 3.Rough chapters of 3.Rough chapters of 3.Rough chapters of observations etc.
project report. project report. project report. project report. 3.Rough
chapters of
project report.
Attendance/Regularity 90-100% attendance in 80-90% attendance in all 70-80% attendance in 70-60% Below 60%
(15 Marks) all project classes project classes all project classes attendance in all attendance in all
project classes project classes
Demonstration of Full understanding and Full understanding and Partial understanding Demonstrates very No
Project demonstration of demonstration of project and demonstration of little and some demonstration of
(20 Marks) project with makes with makes links with project with makes understanding of project and no
links with complete partial fulfillment of links with very few of objectives. understanding of
fulfillment of objectives. objectives and does project
objectives and also not make connections objectives.
suggest new ideas. among ideas.
Project Report Information in project Information in project Information in project Less Information is There is no
(15 Marks) report is in logical report is in logical report is not in logical provided in the report Information
sequence with sequence with diagrams, sequence with about the project, about the project
diagrams, tables, tables, results and diagrams, tables, results and with no results
results and discussion. discussion. The report is results and discussion. The and discussion.
The report is complete partially complete and in discussion. The report is incomplete The report is
and in proper format. proper format. report is incomplete and not in proper incomplete and
but in proper format. format. not in proper
format.
Viva-voce Give complete and Give complete and Give incomplete and Give very few and Given no reply
(15 Marks) logical reply to the logical reply to the illogical reply to the illogical reply to the to the questions
questions asked by questions asked by questions asked by questions asked by asked by
examiner. examiner with few examiner. examiner. examiner.
errors.