Research of Asphalt Layer Bonding in Lithuanian Pavement Structures
Research of Asphalt Layer Bonding in Lithuanian Pavement Structures
Research of Asphalt Layer Bonding in Lithuanian Pavement Structures
5 Građevinar 11/2012
Authors:
Preliminary note
Audrius Vaitkus, Donatas Čygas, Alfredas Laurinavičius, Viktoras Vorobjovas, Rita Kleizienė
Research of asphalt layer bonding in Lithuanian pavement structures
1
Asst.Prof. Audrius Vaitkus The strength and durability of road pavement structures are directly influenced by the way
audrius.vaitkus@vgtu.lt in which asphalt layers are bonded. An insufficient bond between pavement layers leads
to wearing, tearing, pavement deterioration, and cracking, and the pavement life span is
reduced. The quality of bond between pavement layers was determined by direct shear test,
using the so called Leutner method, without normal stress in specimen. Test samples were
taken at various locations along the Lithuanian road network, from pavements characterized
by standard asphalt structure, and reinforced asphalt structure in which geosynthetic
2
Prof.dr. Donatas Čygas materials are used in interlayers
donatas.cygas@vgtu.lt
Key words:
asphalt pavement, bond between pavement layers, Leutner method
Prethodno priopćenje
Audrius Vaitkus, Donatas Čygas, Alfredas Laurinavičius, Viktoras Vorobjovas, Rita Kleizienė
2
Prof. dr. Alfredas Laurinavičius Istraživanje veziva asfaltnih slojeva kolničkih konstrukcija u Litvi
alfredas.laurinavicius@vgtuu.lt
Način povezivanja slojeva asfaltne kolničke konstrukcije izravno utječe na čvrstoću i trajnost
kolnika. Ako veza nije pravilno izvedena, kolnik postaje sklizak, dolazi do habanja, pucanja,
propadanja kolnika i pojave pukotina te smanjenja vijeka trajanja. Kvaliteta veze između
slojeva kolnika određena je direktnim ispitivanjem na smicanje, takozvanom Leutnerovom
metodom bez pojave normalnog naprezanja u uzorku. Uzorci za ispitivanja uzeti su na
1
dr. Viktoras Vorobjovas različitim lokacijama cestovne mreže u Litvi, i to iz kolnika s klasičnom asfaltnom konstrukcijom
viktoras.vorobjovas@vgtu.lt te s pojačanom asfaltnom konstrukcijom primjenom geosintetika u međuslojevima.
Ključne riječi:
asfaltni kolnik, veza slojeva kolničke konstrukcije, Leutnerova metoda
Vorherige Mitteilung
1
Rita Kleizienė, PhD student Audrius Vaitkus, Donatas Čygas, Alfredas Laurinavičius, Viktoras Vorobjovas, Rita Kleizienė
rita.kleiziene@vgtu.lt Untersuchung des Verbunds von Asphaltschichten in litauischen Fahrbahnstrukturen
Der Verbund von Asphaltschichten der Fahrbahnstruktur hat einen direkten Einfluss auf die
1
Roads Research Institute Festigkeit und die Haltbarkeit der Fahrbahn. Unsachgemäß ausgeführte Schichtenverbunde
Vilnius Gediminas Technical University, können eine rutschige Oberfläche der Fahrbahn verursachen, während möglicherweise
Lithuania auftretende Verschleißung, Rissbildung und andere Beschädigungen zu einer Verringerung der
erwarteten Lebensdauer führen können. Die Qualität der Schichtenverbunde des Straßenbelags
2
Department of Roads ist durch Abscherversuche ermittelt, mit Hilfe der sogenannten Leutner-Methode, die ohne das
Vilnius Gediminas Technical University, Auftreten von Normalspannungen ausgeführt wird. Versuchsproben sind an verschiedenen
Lithuania Standorten des Straßennetzes in Litauen entnommen worden, und zwar sowohl für Fahrbahnen
mit klassischen Fahrbahnstrukturen, als auch für Asphaltbeläge, die durch die Anwendung von
geosynthetischen Materialen in den Zwischenschichten verstärkt wurden.
Schlüsselwörter:
Asphaltfahrbahn, Schichtenverbunde der Fahrbahnstruktur, Leutner-Methode
In 1979, R. Leutner described a direct shear test method for quantities of bitumen emulsion between the layers, and using
determining the asphalt layer bonding strength [14]. The different compaction levels for the asphalt wearing course.
Leutner test is one of the most commonly used direct shear The roller compactor was used to compact the samples. The
methods, and is widely used in many countries. In Switzerland, wearing course was made either of the asphalt concrete for
Austria, and Germany it has been accepted as the national wearing courses with maximum grain size of 11 mm, designed
standard for evaluating strength of asphalt layers. The bonding for normal loads (AC 11 VN), or the asphalt concrete for wearing
of layers is evaluated by measuring the maximum shear force course with maximum grain size of 11 mm, designed for heavy
(kN) and shear flow (mm). loads (AC 11 VS). The binder was made of the asphalt concrete
In Germany, the bonding strength of asphalt layers is determined for binders with a maximum grain size of 16 mm, designed for
by performing the Leutner test according to the document normal loads (AC 16 AN).
TP asphalt–StB Teil 80 (direct shear test). In this country, the The asphalt binder, 7 cm in thickness, was prepared during
minimum value of the asphalt layer bonding strength is regulated the first day of the testing. The asphalt wearing layer, 4 cm in
by the document ZTV Asphalt–StB 07 [15]: between the asphalt thickness, was prepared a day after. Thus two slabs 410 mm
wearing course and binder – no less than 15 kN; between all long, 210 mm wide, and 11 cm thick, were prepared. Different
other asphalt layers – no less than 12 kN. The recommended limit types and quantities of bitumen emulsion were sprayed
values between the wearing course and binder is 2,0–4,0 mm, and in between the asphalt layers. The emulsion‘s working
between the binder and base course 1,5–3,0 m Recommended temperature was 40°C. Asphalt layer slabs, without the
limit values for shear flow are given in ZTV M–V and Arbit Nr. 60. bitumen emulsion in between the layers, were also made for
comparison purposes. The compaction level of the asphalt
3. Experimental research wearing course was 97% or 100%, while the compaction level
for the asphalt binder layer was 97% for all samples. Three 150
The experimental research was conducted at the laboratory mm diameter asphalt cores were drilled from each asphalt
of the Road Research Institute of the Vilnius Gediminas slab. The interlayer bonding was measured in accordance with
Technical University in 2010 and 2011. Direct shear tests were the Asphalt technical testing guidelines, Part 80 (German-
performed on samples prepared in laboratory, and on samples Technische Prüfvorschriften für asphalt, TP Asphalt–StB
(cores) taken from Lithuanian roads and city streets. Teil 80). The tests were performed in the standard Marshall
compactor, with shearing mould. The constant static load
3.1. Test results for samples made in laboratory of 50 mm/min was applied. Before the test, asphalt cores
were stored at the temperature of 20°C for 24 hours. Sample
In the laboratory, the asphalt wearing course and binder combinations made in laboratory and test results are
samples were prepared by applying different types and presented in Table 1.
The test results (Figure 2) show that the shear force varies in emulsion C 60 BF 1–S the shear flow varied from 2,1 mm to
a wide interval, from 14,2 kN to 44,8 kN. The minimum shear 3,5 mm. The highest values were determined for samples
force was registered in combinations 3 and 4, i.e. in samples in containing the 90 g/m2 emulsion, tested after 10 days. In
which the asphalt wearing course was AC 11 VS with the 97 % samples with bitumen emulsion C 60 BP 1–S the shear
and 100 % compaction level, and no any bonding material was flow varied from 2,8 mm to 4,5 mm. The greatest value was
used in interlayer. The maximum shear force was registered determined for samples containing the 250 g/m2 emulsion,
in the combination 9 (38,17 kN after 2 days, and 43,83 kN after tested after 10 days.
10 days), i.e. in samples in which the asphalt wearing course The analysis of the asphalt layer bonding strength results
was AC 11 VN with the 97 % compaction level, and with the shows that after 10 days of asphalt compaction, the bonding
150 g/m2 bitumen emulsion in interlayer. Depending on the strength was in all cases greater than 25 kN, and the shear
testing time, a 13 % higher shear force was obtained after 10 flow was greater than 1.5 mm. It should be noted that the use
days. Shear force results for asphalt wearing course samples of bitumen emulsion leads to sufficient bonding of asphalt
subjected to 100 % compaction were 13 % (AC 11 VN) and 18 layers, but only the right amount of bitumen emulsion ensures
% (AC 11 VS) higher when compared to the 97 % compaction good bonding and an allowable shear flow. Results are much
level. The values of all asphalt wearing course samples made more promising for polymer modified emulsions C 60 BP 1–S,
of AC 11 VN were higher by av. 26 % (tested after 2 days) and when compared to bitumen emulsion C 60 BF 1–S.
av. 54 % (tested after 10 days), when compared with values of
the asphalt wearing course made of AC 11 VS. In this case, the 3.2. Test results for samples taken from roads and
bitumen emulsion was not used in the interlayer. city streets
Table 2. Testing combinations and laboratory test results for samples taken from roads and city street
1 2010 Oslo Str., Vilnius Pozition A AC 16 AS SAMI (under binder layer) 24,40 5,90
Savanoriu Str.,
2 2005 Pozition A SMA 11 S SAMI (under wearing layer) 24,60 6,10
Vilnius
Pavegrid G100/100
3.1 Plytines Str., 16,40 2,20
2006 Pozition A AC 11 VS (under binder layer)
Vilnius
3.2 Without geogrid 30,30 3,40
Pavegrid G100/100
4.1 23,50 2,80
Kalvariju Str., (under wearing layer)
2007 Pozition A SMA 11 S
Vilnius
4.2 Without geogrid 32,40 3,50
Hatelit C 40/17
5.1 20,10 1,80
(under binder layer)
Eisikių Str.,
2007 Pozition A SMA 11 S Armatex RSM 50/50
5.2 Vilnius 9,60 1,70
(under binder layer)
5.3 Without geogrid 26,10 1,00
6.1 Pozition A 11,83 1,78
2008 Road Nr. 153 AC 11 VS Without geogrid
6.2 Pozition B 18,45 2,00
7.1 Pozition A 17,82 2,55
2010 Road Nr. 143 AC 11 VN Without geogrid
7.2 Pozition B 18,35 2,70
8.1 Pozition A 11,85 2,05
2010 Road Nr. 130 AC 11 VS Without geogrid
8.2 Pozition B 15,45 2,78
9.1 Pozition A 21,20 2,08
2010 Road Nr. 128 AC 11 VS Without geogrid
9.2 Pozition B 16,90 2,25
10.1 Pozition A 34,05 4,03
2010 Road Nr. 102 SMA 11 S Without geogrid
10.2 Pozition B 31,85 3,95
11.1 Pozition A 33,20 3,35
2010 Road Nr. 2828 AC 11 VN Without geogrid
11.2 Pozition B 25,35 4,05
12.1 Pozition A 19,45 3,95
2010 Road Nr. A4 AC 11 VS Without geogrid
12.2 Pozition B 16,35 2,70
13.1 Pozition A 25,69 5,53
2009 Road Nr. A14 SMA 11 S Without geogrid
13.2 Pozition B 24,23 3,43
combination 3.1). Testing of samples selected from the combination, but is however influenced by the material used
Eisiskiu Street has revealed that the shear force is by about in interlayers. In 72% of testing combinations (18 out of 25)
30% greater in samples without the geosynthetic interlayer the shear flow ranged from 2,0 mm to 4,0 mm. The analysis
(testing combination 5.1), when compared to samples with of samples taken at the Plytines Street has revealed that
the geogrid Hatelit C 40/17 (testing combination 5.3), while the shear flow is 35 % lower with geosynthetic interlayer,
this shear force is as many as 2.7 times greater (testing than without this interlayer. The testing of samples taken
combination 5.2) when compared to the sample with the at the Eisiskiu Street has shown that the shear force of
Armatex RSM 50/70 geogrid. An insufficient asphalt layer samples without geosynthetics is greater by about 40%
bonding strength has also been identified in samples taken when compared to the Hatelit C 40/17 geogrid (testing
at the roads No. 153, No. 130, and No. 143. It was determined combination 5.1), and the Armatex RSM 50/70 geogrid
that the shear flow changes independently from testing (testing combination 5.2).
4. Conclusion
The shear force results for samples with the 100 % compaction
of asphalt wearing course were 13% (AC 11 VN) and 18 %
(AC 11 VS) higher when compared to the 97 % compaction level.
The values of all samples made of the asphalt wearing course
type AC 11 VN were higher by av. 26 % (tested after 2 days) and
av. 54 % (tested after 10 days), when compared to the values of
the asphalt wearing course made of AC 11 VS. In this case, the
bitumen emulsion was not used in the interlayer.
Figure 3. Distribution of shear force between asphalt layers in cores
taken from roads and city streets The experimental research has shown that the bonding
strength between asphalt layers decreases from 20 % to 50
A relatively high shear flow range, exceeding the ZMT M-V % when the geogrid is laid between asphalt layers. The use of
recommendations, was identified in samples 1, 2 and 13.1. In geosynthetics also contributes to the reduction of shear flow.
samples 1 and 2, a special asphalt mix SAMI 0/5 was used for It was also established that the quantity of bonding emulsion
the interlayer, and the SMA 11 S mix was used for 13.1. It can be C 60 BF 1–S influences the shear force exerted on asphalt
noticed that in testing combinations with the asphalt wearing layers. Thus, shear force values ranged from 22,8 kN to 32,7 kN
course SMA 11 S (10.1, 10.2: road Nr. 102, and 13.1, 13.2: road (tested after 2 days), and from 32,7 kN to 44,8 kN (tested after
Nr. A14) the shear flow was not significantly higher compared 10 days). The bonding strength was by about 30 % greater
to other types of asphalt wearing courses. It was revealed that with bitumen emulsion present in asphalt interlayer, when
the shear flow changes independently from the sample taking compared to the situation without the emulsion (tested after
location (wheel-path or between the wheel paths). 2 days), while the difference was not significant after 10 days.
REFERENCES
[1] Raab, C., Partl, M. N., Halim, A. E.: Evaluation of interlayer shear [8] Dübner, R., Glet, W.: Unterhaltung von Asphaltstraßen
bond devices for asphalt pavements, The Baltic Journal of Road Arbeitsgemeinschaft der Bi-tumen-Industrie, e.V., Hamburg, 1993.
and Bridge Engineering, 4(4), p.p. 186-195, 2009. [9] Tashman, L., Nam, K., Papagiannakis, T.: Evaluation of the
[2] Raab, C., Partl, M. N.: Interlayer Bonding of Binder, Base and Influence of Tack Coat Construction Factors on the Bond
Subbase Layers of Asphalt Pavements: Long-term Performance, Strength Between Pavement Layers, Report# WCAT 06-002,
Journal Construction and Building Materials, 23, p.p. 2926-2931, Washington Center for Asphalt Technology, 2006.
2009. [10] Vaitkus, A., Žilionienė, D., Paulauskaitė, S., Tuminienė, F., Žiliūtė,
[3] Frohmut, W., Ascher, D.: Untersuchungen zur Wirksamkeit des L.: Research and Assessment of Asphalt Layers Bonding, The
Haftverbundes und dessen Auswirkungen auf die Lebensdauer Baltic Journal of Road and Bridge Engineering, 6(3), p.p. 210-
von Asphaltbefestigungen, Schlussbericht zum AiF-Projekt Nr. 218, 2011. ISSN 1822-427X (print), ISSN 1822-4288 (online).
13589 BR/1, Technische Universität Dresden, 2007.Schulze, K.: (Thomson ISI Web of Science).
Asphaltbeton mit erhöhtem Füller-Bitumen-Verhältnis und [11] Vaitkus, A., Puodžiukas, V., Motiejūnas, A., Vitkienė, J., Vorobjovas,
dichter Belagsstruktur, Straßen- und Tiefbau Heft 11, 1979. V., Paliukaitė, M.: Long Term Research of Experimental Asphalt
[4] Weber, R.: Rißbildungen in Asphaltstraßen als Folge Pavement Structures, in Transport Research Arena Europe
mangelhaften Schichtver-bundes, Dissertation TU München, 2010, Brussels: Selected papers (2010, Brussels, Belgium).
1991. [12] Čygas, D., Laurinavičius, A., Vaitkus, A., Perveneckas, Z.,
[5] Eisenmann, J., Neumann, U.: Auswirkungen von Verbundstörungen Motiejūnas, A.: Research of asphalt pavement structures on
auf die Spurrinnenbildung, Forschungsbericht Nr. 1444 (FE 07.151 Lithuanian roads (I), The Baltic Journal of Road and Bridge
G 91 K), Prüfamt für Bau von Landverkehrsflächen der TU München. Engineering, 3(2), p.p. 77-83, 2008. ISSN 1822-427X (print), ISSN
1993. 1822-4288 (online). (Thomson ISI Web of Science).
[6] King, G., May. R.: New Approaches to Tack Application, [13] Leutner, R.: Untersuchungen des Schichtenverbunds beim
presentation made to the 83rd Annual Meeting of the bituminösen Oberbau Investigation of the Adhesion of
Transportation Research Board, Washington, D. C., 2003. Bituminius Pavements], Bitumen 3, p.p. 84-91, 1979.
[7] Roffe, J. C., and Chaignon, F.: Chatacterisation Tests on Bond [14] Forschungsgesellschaft für Straßen- und Verkehrswesen,
Coats: Worldwide Study, Impact, Tests, and Recommendations, Zusätzliche Technische Vertragsbedingungen und Richtlinien
3rd International Conference Bituminius Mixtures and für den Bau von Verkehrsflächenbefestigungen aus Asphalt ZTV
Pavements, Thessaloniki, 2002. Asphalt–StB 07. 2007.